What's unfair, unsustainable, and costs £15bn a year? | James O'Brien - The Whole Show
Sep 30, 2026
This is a catch-up version of James O'Brien's live, daily show on LBC Radio from the 29th of September 2026.
00:00 - How do you sell the end of the triple lock to the British people?
47:22 - How difficult would it be to take the phones off children?
01:34:23 - Martin Lewis sparks heated debate following clash with loud train passengers - How has this happened?
Listen to the full show on the all-new LBC App: https://app.af.lbc.co.uk/btnc/thenewlbcapp
#jamesobrien #politics #LBC
LBC is the home of live debate around news and current affairs in the UK.
Join in the conversation and listen at https://www.lbc.co.uk/
Sign up to LBC's weekly newsletter here: https://l-bc.co/signup
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
It's three minutes after ten and you are listening to James O'Brien on LBC
0:08
The front pages are not united in their predictions, but there is certainly a sense that the triple lock is in jeopardy
0:19
Right, how many people just switched off? Not literally, because if you just switched off literally, you won't be able to hear me asking how many people just switched off
0:26
The word's triple lock. It's a funny one, isn't it? because Andy Burnham is linking it inextricably to social care
0:32
Money saved by adjusting the triple lot would go towards the social care plans
0:36
that we were talking about yesterday. And yet, it's very much subject to the same malaise, isn't it
0:43
The same intellectual malaise, in that I say social care and you
0:47
depending upon where you are in life, where you are on life's journey at the moment
0:52
your ears either prick up or turn off. My ears turned off at the conversation
0:57
of social care until you actually taught me why it was so important
1:01
And the same with triple lock. You know, I say triple lock, you say, oh, whatever
1:06
Or you say, how dare you even mention the possibility of reducing something that I need or deserve or want or have
1:15
I don't know what to do about that. There's no way every single thing that we talk about every single day
1:20
can be of equal interest to everybody listening. But I want to reach today, if you're still here
1:28
the people who just go, oh no, triple lock. It doesn't have to be boring, all right
1:34
I appreciate the fact that I've never had a conversation about it with you before suggests that I have concluded somewhere subconsciously that it is always boring
1:41
But let's begin with me being a bit obnoxious, shall we? And suggesting that even people who are passionately opposed
1:48
to any scrapping of the state pension triple lock don't actually know what it is
1:52
or aren't entirely clear on what it does. What is the triple lock
1:57
How long has it been in place? What is it? How much would it cost to scrap it
2:02
How much does it cost to have it? All of these questions, I think, need to be answered
2:08
The first is pretty easy. It means, essentially, that the government is committed to raising the state pension
2:19
every single year by one of three rates, whichever is highest. Inflation, earnings, or 2.5%, a sort of flat rate of 2.5%
2:33
If I told you that over the past three years, if we'd had a double lock on the state pension
2:40
then you would not have suffered any material loss. That's because the average earnings increase outpaced inflation
2:48
So the simple fact of the matter is that for the last three years
2:54
it wouldn't have affected you if they'd already scrapped the triple lock three years ago
2:58
If Keir Starmer had scrapped the triple lock, it would not have affected anybody's pension
3:03
Hands up if you knew that. Go on, hands up, seriously. I'm talking to my colleagues, I can't see anyone else
3:08
Hands up if you knew that if Keir Starmer had scrapped the triple lock
3:12
nobody would have seen their pension go down. I work with children, so they're not really thinking about paychecks
3:18
You didn't know that. You didn't know that. Did you know that? You didn't know that
3:22
So that's point number one. It is not going to be, in the short term at least
3:28
a particular financial penalty for everybody. And for decades prior to 2010
3:35
the rise was pegged to only two of those metrics. It was not pegged to all three
3:42
and, you know, we can't afford it. Now, in almost any other context
3:50
when you say the country can't afford it, everyone either agrees or disagrees
3:56
according to how it affects them personally. The country can't afford it. The problem is it's often a very manufactured conversation
4:02
and it's often replete with an awful lot of lies. We can't afford it. Yes, we can
4:06
We're spending all that money on X, Y and Z. We should stop spending money on that instead. Do you know what would raise
4:11
Roughly two-thirds of the money needed for the social care plan. Rising immigration, which would wipe out the £6 billion deficit
4:17
that John Healey is looking at as a consequence of plummeting immigration. That's the Office of Budgetary Responsibility
4:23
Technically, an extrapolation of their figures. And an abolition of the triple lot on pensions
4:29
So here's one problem that we've got immediately that I've just spotted. How come it would save a lot of money
4:34
if it wasn't going to, in the short term, affect any pensioner's income
4:39
That's something to wrestle with. I don't know the answer to that. This is why I find the subject matter somewhat challenging at the best of times
4:47
So, it's only been in place for 16 years. It would not involve any reduction in any year
4:55
It would never see the pension going down on an annual basis. And it would save money, not quite to fill a big enough gap
5:05
but the policy is now costing, according to one estimate, more than 15 billion pounds a year
5:12
And it's not sustainable. It's not sustainable. That is the bottom line and the fact
5:23
It is not sustainable. And I'm going to tell you something else. It is not fair either
5:29
One of the biggest myths, and I find it extraordinary, but to be honest, after all these years, I'm used to it
5:34
I find it extraordinary that you can ring, for example, a radio station
5:37
and talk utter gibberish unchallenged. The money you paid into your pension
5:42
was spent on pensions for people who were pensioners when you were paying it into your pension
5:48
That's the nature of the relationship. That's the nature of the social contract
5:52
It hasn't been kept for you in a vault at Gringotts, accruing interest bestowed by the goblin bankers
6:00
that will then be given to you when you reach retirement age
6:04
It's a fundamental platform of the social contract. and the social contract involves everybody in society
6:11
So the money I am paying now is what pays your pension if you're not working
6:16
The taxes I am paying now, I am paying for your pension, you're not
6:20
The people whose pension you paid for when you were working are probably dead. Okay, so let's just very politely suggest
6:27
don't bother ringing me to make that argument, because although you've probably heard it on this radio station before
6:33
it's bogus, pointless and false I am currently paying for your pension
6:40
with my taxes if you're retired you paid for someone else's years ago
6:45
so the question of what's fair and what's not fair should probably be answered by me, not by you
6:49
because it's my money that is paying your pension and I think it would be perfectly fair to see it go up every year
6:55
according to a double lock, not a triple lock right? this isn't even opinion yet, this is just counting
7:01
the problem is it becomes immediately politically toxic i am never going to bore i'm never going to
7:09
tire this morning um or indeed in this career in this life i'm never going to tire of pointing out
7:16
to you how fundamentally dishonest much of our discourse is in this country i are fundamentally
7:21
dishonest most obviously with those two statistics that i have fallen in love with this week 53 of the population takes out more than it puts in And roughly billion in lost revenue
7:35
as a consequence of the plummeting migration that everybody thought that they wanted
7:39
and continues to insist will somehow make us richer. So we are not only making ourselves poorer
7:44
by pursuing populist political goals, we are also, at the same time
7:49
ignorant of the fact that most of us take more out than we put in
7:55
with pensioners being by far the most highly represented members of that category
8:00
But the older you get, the more likely you are to cross the threshold from putting in to taking out
8:08
And all of that is fact. All of those are matter of facts
8:13
But the reason I mention the disingenuous media is that immediately you will have
8:17
although to be fair to the Daily Telegraph today, They do a fairly measured job of running through the reasons why it should happen
8:24
but also why no politician or no leader is going to have..
8:29
Well, it's not even guts, is it? It's not the guts. It doesn't take guts to jump off a cliff, even if you've got a parachute
8:36
What is even the word? Enough optimism. Hearing Andy Burnham talk a lot about optimism
8:43
and the idea that you would be able to somehow overcome the corrupt discourse
8:51
I think is the heart of this conversation. So according to One Front Page, he is signalling the end of triple lock
8:58
He will announce a review of the policy as he seeks money for NHS style social care service
9:07
Fascinating listening to him talk to Sheila Fogarty about that yesterday. It was, as we suspected, confined to OAPs
9:14
It won't encompass people under the pensionable age who are in need of long-term, even permanent social care
9:20
That's another Rubicon to cross later in government, or possibly never, but this is specific to old-age pensioners
9:27
One way to raise the money is to abolish the triple lock, render it, rather, a double lock
9:33
That is estimated to save between £15 billion and £22 billion by 2030
9:39
depending on whether you are following wage growth or inflation. So you simply remove the 2.5%
9:44
It means that some years your pension can go up by less than 2.5%
9:48
but it will never go up by less than whatever is highest out of earnings or inflation
9:57
And that is just fair. I couldn't even tell you now why they introduced this in the first place in 2010
10:02
except to shore up the vote of old-age pensioners. your pension will never go down
10:08
unless I suppose inflation unless we're in deflation or earnings are going down
10:17
in which case you don't need to worry because your money is going to go further anyway you'll be in the same pot as people who are earning
10:21
whose money has gone down so you will never ever ever see your pension go down under a double lock
10:27
because it would be going up in line with wage growth or inflation
10:34
Right, who's turned off now? Who have I lost during my, I would say, 60% to 70% effective attempt
10:41
to explain exactly what is going on? Who have I lost? Because here's the political problem
10:46
People who aren't even close to the pensionable age don't care. People who are close to it or over it care too much
10:54
They care too much to avail themselves of the correct information. And the correct information would be, don't worry
11:00
All right? Yeah, you are not going to receive as much as you might have received otherwise
11:06
but that's entirely fair because you will still be receiving the same
11:10
as anybody who depends upon wage growth or wages for their income
11:14
Your increase in pension will be the same as someone who earns money
11:20
Your percentage increase in income will be the same as someone who works for a living
11:25
So what exactly is the problem here? Answer politics. Answer media. answer rhetoric answer we live in a country where people have been variously persuaded that brexit
11:37
would be a good idea that boris johnson would be a brilliant prime minister that liz trust was an
11:41
economic genius that donald trump would be a doughty and devoted ally to the united kingdom
11:46
that climate change wasn't real um that benjamin netanyahu was uh also likely to be a trusted ally
11:52
to the united kingdom or that he would um honor our our generosity towards him um all of these
12:00
things. The British media has successfully persuaded people to believe, despite the fact that
12:04
they are all dangerously and demonstrably untrue. Untrue. So, how's it going to go
12:15
How's it going to go? Can it be won politically? Can, and
12:22
the BBC this morning, and I didn't pick up on this myself because I wasn't
12:26
tuned in, but somebody that I trust very much has picked up on it. And the BBC this morning kind of effortlessly segued
12:32
from arguing that it would be electoral suicide to scrap the triple lock
12:38
to explaining that critics are wondering whether the Prime Minister has the nerve
12:43
to make the tough decisions. And it's easy to criticise them for that. But that is the siller and charybdis of this conversation
12:51
It would be political suicide to scrap the triple lock. Andy Burnham hasn't got the guts to scrap the triple lock
12:57
Andy Burnham hasn't got the guts to commit political suicide. That is on the same broadcaster on the same morning
13:04
in reference to the same story. Critics point out that it would be political suicide
13:08
to scrap the triple lock. Critics wonder whether Andy Burnham has the guts to scrap the triple lock
13:12
And although it sounds contradictory and counterintuitive, two things can be true at the same time
13:17
That's the fundamental problem here, which is why today's conversation is going to be about Andy Burnham
13:25
and perhaps John Healy who we know a lot more about today than we did yesterday as a consequence
13:30
of the decision to take his speech in full. Can anybody, because I don't think anyone else could
13:35
sell it to the British public, I'm not sure anybody else would try. People in opposition
13:40
don't have to deal in reality, something that Nigel Farage proves every day and which Cami
13:46
Bader not kind of almost proves every day, flirts with every day, with a side order of completely
13:53
ignoring what happened when her lot were in charge for 14 years. So do you think
13:59
do you think it's doable? 0345 6060 973. Do you think it's doable in Brexit Britain
14:11
I'm going to say it again because I really think it matters. In a country where the public have
14:15
been persuaded by bad actors, populist politicians, liars and plutocrats, been persuaded that Brexit
14:22
would make us richer, that Boris Johnson would look after us, that Liz Truss was an economic
14:27
genius, that Donald Trump would be a brilliant ally for this country, and that climate change
14:31
wasn't real. The public can be persuaded of that. But it depends what side of the bed I got out
14:39
I've got to be honest with you. I got out on the right side of the bed. I can turn up my optimism
14:44
in the morning and think, well, just because we have fallen down all of those holes doesn't mean
14:49
that we won't actually manage to get over that bridge. And then on other mornings, I think
14:53
how the hell is anybody ever going to persuade the people of the United Kingdom to vote in their own interests when all they ever do is vote in the interests of the liars and the racists and the plutocrats and the weirdos who dominate our public discourse
15:06
And the client journalists, of course, who dominate our public discourse. But I can never be that person
15:12
Even if some mornings I kind of find myself drawn to those people, I can never be that person
15:16
It's the way I'm made. It's in my DNA. Always going to have a little bit of optimism
15:21
Always going to think that we can be better than this. I'm always going to think that even people who might be hurling abuse at RNLI volunteers
15:28
if they were actually in a position to save a drowning child who happened to have come from Syria or Afghanistan
15:35
I'm always going to have to believe that even if they were hurling abuse at the RNLI volunteers yesterday
15:40
today, if it was down to them to save that child or let them drown, they would save that child
15:44
I have to believe it. Otherwise, we can all pack up and go home and hand over the keys on the way out to
15:50
I don't even know, Elon Musk, I suppose. So, can it work
15:55
Do you think it can work? How would you do it? There's the question. I got there in the end
16:00
How would you do it? How do we sell the end of the triple lock
16:06
to the British public, to enough of the British public to ensure that it wouldn't be electoral suicide
16:13
How do we do it? Can it be done? I want no's as well. I want you to ring in and say
16:17
no, it can't, James. But if it can, then how can it
16:22
0345 6060 973 is the number that you need. What do you think
16:28
I mean, listen, the recognition that you will never see a reduction in your pension
16:33
is probably the first thing that you need to be hit over the head with. But that's what I want
16:38
0345 6060 973 is the number that you need. It's 20 past 10
16:45
I'm James O'Brien. James O'Brien on LBC. Okay, I'm going to do some economics
16:52
I know I went to the famous London School of Economics, and I know that my degree technically has econ in it
17:01
I have a BSC bracket, econ, closed brackets. But if you've ever listened to this program for more than seven consecutive seconds
17:08
you will know that economics, sometimes I can't even say it, economics, economics, economics is not my strongest suit
17:16
suit. I don't know what is my strongest suit, but it's not
17:20
my strongest suit, but here we go. If, for example, average wages, including
17:26
bonuses, went up by 4%, right, and inflation stood at 2%, then under the triple lock
17:34
pensioners would get a 4% increase despite the fact that their outgoings had only
17:38
gone up by 2%. That can't be right. And that is the end of the economics
17:45
Roy's in Whitstable. Well, Roy, what would you like to say? It's Ray, by the way, not Roy
17:49
Sorry? Ray. Oh, I can't talk to you. I've done all my Rays for this week
17:54
Can we pretend you called Roy just to the end of this conference? Thank you, Ray, Roy, Roy, Ray
17:58
Carry on. What do you want to say? Please take it. As a pensioner, I want you to take the triple block
18:06
One thing I will say, Jones, if you didn't mention it, it's a benefit
18:10
Yes. Because they write to you and say, give us your details of your bank account
18:14
and we will pay your pension in. So it is a benefit. Benefits can be changed
18:19
The way to sell it specifically is this. At the moment, if you get Alzheimer's or dementia
18:27
and you go into a home, they take your life savings and they take your property
18:32
And that is the way to sell it. If it means you have a few quid less a week pension
18:36
and then you go in there and it's free, that's the way to sell it to the public, to the pensioners
18:42
He's done that quite well, hasn't he? He's ceded the ground with the social care conversation
18:46
before he's actually personally said anything at all about the triple lock
18:52
Indeed. That is the way it should go. Because a lot of, like myself, a lot of elderly people
18:57
that is your main concern. Well, is it your main concern? Because I tried to touch on this yesterday
19:02
and I'm not sure I was entirely successful. You know how it works, Ray. The conversation goes off in unexpected directions
19:07
But I'm fascinated by the relatively small percentage of people who will end up in the position that you describe
19:13
I'm not sure it's big enough for it to be the main concern of most pensioners
19:19
I think it is. But, I mean, obviously, and also one of the things is
19:24
why are you giving money to the richest by age group in society? We own 65% of the property in the country
19:31
There's more children in poverty than there are pensions in poverty. Yeah, but you very rarely, you are a glorious exception to this, Ray
19:37
and I salute you for it, but you very, very rarely meet people in your age demographic
19:42
demographic who think that they have actually enjoyed the boom years and have had
19:48
one of the best deals in the history of humanity in the Western world. They largely
19:52
and of course they're very easily persuaded that if it wasn't for those pesky small boats
19:56
they'd be living in a mansion by now. Well the main thing is James, I'm not a stupid racist
20:00
and not a stupid old racist either. Don't put words in my mouth
20:05
Ray, but unfortunately a lot of people are. Well they haven't got any brain cells
20:10
they've got about much teeth if they've got brain cells Let's put it that way. And to my view, you have to think about the young people
20:17
They are the ones who are paying for my pension. They're the ones who can't get a house. They're the ones who are not going to have final salary pensions
20:23
or defined benefit pensions. Those are the people I worry about more
20:27
young people in society, not pensioners. And with pension credits in place
20:31
the poorer end of the pension demographic would still be looked after. But you mentioned, what did you say, stupid old racists
20:38
Yeah. And I just run through the list of things that this country has done in recent years
20:42
It's done Brexit, it's put Boris Johnson in Downing Street, it treated Liz Truss like an economic sage
20:48
it believed that Donald Trump would be a doughty ally to this country, and I don't think this has got much to do with racism
20:53
but it's all about stupidity. It also persuaded itself that climate change wasn't real
20:58
So, I mean, where do you derive your optimism that having jumped off all five of those cliffs
21:03
thinking that they were going to fly off into the stratosphere with angel wings, on this occasion, reality will prevail
21:10
and the stupid old racists will not. Ray? Yes, I'm still here
21:17
Where do you get your optimism from? Well, I assume that there are some old people around
21:22
who actually have some brain cells left, like myself. Well, yeah, we need more Ray, actually
21:29
You were a Ray of Suns. Oh, stop it, honestly. That's such an open goal
21:33
Alex in Leicester. Alex, what do you reckon? I reckon I could solve this
21:38
and make young people buy into it. All right, he's got the headlines at half ten, so no pressure
21:43
I'm not in economics. Don't worry, I've got that covered. I've just proved that
21:48
I've got the economics covered. So I think what you should do is
21:54
once you get enough in your private pension part, you should be able to exchange your state pension
21:59
for a tax-free gift at the end of when you retire, because you're going to need that money when you retire
22:04
to pay off a mortgage or pay off a final lump sum or something
22:08
and that state pension then goes back into a care allowance. But that's not going to do anything in the short term, is it
22:16
It's not going to do anything in the short term, but in the long term... He's got an election to fight. He can't fight an election on something that kicks in in 15 years' time
22:23
But that how you get young people interested in it and going actually that works for me as a young person I don I need to dangle the tax allowance of a private pension No you don Young people are going to vote against the triple lock
22:36
No one's going to say, I want to keep the triple lock, because they're thinking about the now of it
22:40
So it's actually, I mean, listen, it's an intelligent thought, but I think it is a little bit niche
22:45
Most people are going to say, my taxes are currently paying that pension. So if you reduce the likelihood of a pensioner getting a bigger pay rise
22:54
a bigger percentage pay rise than a worker. I'm perfectly cool with that because I'm a worker
23:00
You don't need to bring private pension pots into it. But I'm 36 and I know that when I'm paying into a state pension
23:05
now that I'm not going to get at the end. Where does that pessimism come from
23:09
Talked about Ray's optimism. What about Alex's pessimism? That comes from just basic economics
23:14
that they can't keep up with the triple lock so you need to do something. Oh, sorry
23:18
So, yes, but the triple lock is unsustainable but you'd still get a pension. No, it's not going to be worth anything
23:24
I mean, that underpins... Well, that's a worldview that is unchallengeable, isn't it
23:30
It's a little bit kind of... I can't prove that it will
23:34
but I don't think any government is going to introduce legislation that renders the state pension worthless
23:39
It's already relatively low compared to other countries, but I can't see if it's going to be political suicide
23:45
to abolish the triple lock, to effectively abolish the pension is going to be whatever is even worse than that
23:51
But you brought it in on time, Alec. Lovely work. don't moan about not being able to get through
23:55
as I free up Alex's phone line it frees up a phone line for you the number is always the same 03456060973
24:02
how would you sell it? not actually quite as hard as I thought it would be
24:06
at 10 o'clock this morning how do you get it over the line? and I guess it's going to be like everything else isn't it
24:11
but unlike Brexit the facts don't need the future to prove themselves
24:17
with Brexit we could all sit here going no you don't understand this will happen and that will happen
24:22
and Jacob Rees-Mogg or Boris Johnson or Nigel Farage could pop up and go, oh, no, it won't
24:27
No, it won't. And then it did. And they all went quiet or disappeared entirely
24:31
in the case of the first two, but sadly not the third one. The point here is that the numbers are simply correct
24:38
If the cost of, if average wages go up by 5%, but inflation goes up by 2.5%
24:44
the pensioners get a 5% pay rise, even though the prices have only gone up by 2.5%
24:49
half percent i i think that's i'm sure there are flaws in that um in the politics and philosophy
24:55
of what i just said but i don't think there are any flaws in the mathematics half past 10 is the
24:59
time dominic ellis has your headline james o'brien on lbc it's 10 34 you are listening to james o'brien
25:07
on lbc where i'm i'm enjoying this i don't know whether you could detect in my tone at the outset
25:14
or indeed from the fact that we've never ever had a conversation about the triple lot before
25:18
I wasn't sure I would but I am, especially when I get messages
25:22
like this, morning James, thank you for your clear explanations of the triple lock
25:26
oh you're very welcome, I went to the London School of Economics you know unfortunately many people seem to
25:30
link removing the triple lock with removing the state pension completely or means testing it, some of us have
25:36
retirement plans that depend on the state pension but not necessarily on it going up
25:40
hugely in value, an average lock or a double lock, that would not present a
25:44
problem, but don't pivot the debate to removing the state pension completely
25:48
That was Alec in Leicester, David, in Halifax. Alec in Leicester pivoting pessimistically
25:53
The pessimistic pivot, I like to call it, to the observation popular among many young people
25:58
that by the time they get to your age, the pension won't be worth buttons. But I think that if abolishing the triple lock
26:04
is political suicide, as many people attest, then in any way whatsoever
26:09
abolishing the state pension or rendering the state pension utterly, utterly irrelevant
26:12
would be worse by a factor. Alan is in Wandsworth. Just for the benefit of the tape
26:20
former Labour Party Campaigns Director. So you've been in the room where it happens, Alan
26:24
Is this sellable? Is this doable? Yes, it is. Is that it? Do you want to add to that
26:30
or are we just going to leave... I'd change the name of it
26:34
I would change it away from the old age pension and call it the old age benefit
26:39
Yeah, it does. Words matter, don't they? Yes, they do. Words really do matter
26:43
It's your stock in trade. as you said at the start it is a benefit
26:49
so let's call it what it is it's the one seal of you know
26:53
people think they understand a pension scheme where you pay in and it matures and then you get
27:02
something out and they've been allowed over the years to understand the state pension
27:08
as being akin to that when it isn't so let's call it what it is
27:11
it's an old age benefit And make all the right noises about protecting it and ring-fencing it
27:17
and guaranteeing that it will always go up, except in extraordinary circumstances where everybody's income has gone down
27:24
But if it's going to go up by more than inflation, then it is going to be adding to the problems that the country faces
27:31
Do you think the average... I mean, so this is the problem now, in that if we could get that message out there, clear and undiluted
27:37
then an awful lot of the heaviest lifting would be done. but we live in a country where clear and undiluted messaging
27:43
has become close to impossible, even without the influence of social media
27:48
Well, it's harder, that's for sure. I'm not saying it's close to impossible. But it's not hard
27:54
So just paint with the whole might of the state. Suddenly, every letter that goes out says
28:00
hooray, you're now entitled to your old age benefit. Good luck. This is what it's going to be
28:04
Every single month, people get paid the old age benefit. It appears on their bank statements
28:10
So there's three prongs to this. Rename it, because words matter, and that percolates through consciousness
28:16
Society changes its view. Hitch it absolutely inextricably to the provision of free social care
28:22
NHS-style social care for old-age pensioners, and make it absolutely crystal clear that the pensions will still go up
28:31
Yes. You get all three of those messages, front and centre, and it's doable
28:35
I'd actually like to add a fourth one. Go on. where you make the tax-free allowance the same as the pension
28:44
Remind me what that means. Everybody is allowed to have a tax-free allowance
28:50
Oh, yes. A certain amount of money that you're paid. I just make it the same as the old age benefit
28:56
Just always and going forward. So you'd handcuff the tax-free allowance, so the amount that anyone can bring in before being required to pay tax
29:05
handcuff that to the state benefit, as we now call it, on this programme
29:09
but it will soon catch on. The state benefit, and therefore you will never pay any tax whatsoever
29:14
on your state benefit. Your old age benefit. That's right. OK, I think that's nice, actually
29:20
We haven't fixed it, have we? We've got another 20 minutes of the program. Well, of course, we talk about cars
29:25
Parking. Go away. 20 minutes. I nearly said four wheels, then. We've got four wheels on our triple lock abolition
29:33
the vehicle of triple lock abolition. So, listen, as I bid farewell to Alan
29:38
phone line free for you to tell me why everyone else is talking jibber-jabber and you've got this absolutely right
29:43
why any suggestion of tinkering with or abolishing the triple lock is absolutely unthinkable
29:50
I have to tell you that the thing in the Daily Telegraph... Daily Telegraph is such a weird newspaper
29:55
and I know you don't find any of this stuff as fascinating as I do, but it was my late father's..
30:00
at Parrish for many, many years. It's such a proud thing growing up to have a father on the Daily Telegraph
30:05
It's quite hard to believe now, of course, but it does still do some brilliant journalism
30:10
Just the opinion pages that are populated more or less entirely by freaks and Froot Loops
30:16
but it does still do some brilliant journalism. And there's a really good piece in there today
30:20
about how, I mean, in their words, even the right is turning against the triple lock
30:26
And, I mean, there is, I think, an inevitability to elements of it
30:30
if you have the conversation in the correct fashion. And here we are
30:34
And here's Barry. So, Barry, I'm not going to put you in idiot's corner, mate, unless you don't take your medicine
30:40
Barry's been in touch and said, how can the state pension be called a benefit when its recipients have paid into it all their working life
30:46
That's not how it works. I know this is quite hard to swallow
30:50
but I'm paying your pension, Barry. Your pension is not currently being paid
30:55
out of the money that you put into it 20 years ago
30:59
that money that you put into it 20 years ago was paying your grandparents pension or possibly your
31:04
parents pension this is the point that alan was making it's it's you know it's different if you
31:10
were made unemployed tomorrow then the people who were working would be paying your unemployment
31:15
benefit it wouldn't somehow come from a pot that has been kept carefully in the vaults of gringotts
31:20
bank in the event to be broken open in the event of you becoming unemployed or passing the old age
31:27
pension threshold. It's not the same money. It's different money. Alec in Leicester is paying your pension
31:33
Barry, and he doesn't think he's going to have a pension at all when he gets to your age. So that's why I think that Alan's ysis
31:39
is semantic. Evolution is attractive, but unlikely to happen. But also, he's describing a social
31:47
contract of which everybody is a signatory. Everybody in society. At the moment, it doesn't really feel
31:53
like that, does it? Steve's in Reading. Steve, what would you like to say? My simple answer to that is
31:59
pensioners can keep their assets, they don't have to sell them to pay for their care
32:04
and then the means that they've got something to pass down to their children. But that's true
32:08
This is the bit, and I haven't been able to find the full numbers here, mate
32:12
so I don't know whether they're unavailable or I'm just losing my touch on the old internet
32:16
but it's a very small percentage of people that lose their assets
32:21
But you can think about it, James. It's a very small percentage
32:25
but for the entirety of the conversation, it feels like it's the entirety of the pension population
32:31
Yeah, but people know it isn't them. So they might, you know, this is why Ray was such an interesting caller
32:36
Well, Ray aside, the first caller, if you're 75 now, you're going to take your chances
32:42
if you haven't got Alzheimer's. You're going to take your chances. I'd rather... Sure, sure
32:47
But it's like the Brexit vote, mate. So you have pensions saying, oh, I'm voting basically for my children
32:52
I'm voting for their future. But you're saying, like right now, is that, well, what we're going to do
32:57
is we're going to reform it, basically, so you can give British jobs to British people
33:03
And we're going to reform it in a way where you can keep your own assets, you can hand more down to your children
33:09
The only disadvantage is we're going to reform it to make sure that that money goes to pensioners
33:14
who are in poverty. Yeah, well, I mean, that is just tacking the tax credit system
33:19
the pension credit system, onto the back of what we've already discussed. But this is the philosophical and the social issue here, isn't it
33:27
It is the trade-off between the risk of losing your house to pay for your social care
33:33
versus the relatively minor reduction in your pension as a consequence of abolishing the triple lock
33:41
And the reason why those two things are on the opposite sides of scales is because a relatively minor reduction in the income of millions of people
33:50
versus an incredibly major revision of the outgoings of quite a small number of people
33:57
can be a similar sum, can't it? The calculation is, I hope I'm still making sense
34:02
the calculation is a personal one. Well, I don't think I'm going to get Alzheimer's
34:08
but I am going to suffer if they abolish the triple lock. Not enormously, but it's no suffering versus some suffering
34:16
Andy Burnham's challenge, and I think people like Angela Rayner will be great at helping him with this
34:20
Andy Burnham's challenge is simply to sell it as a social contract and to say everybody loses the relatively small amount
34:28
that the triple lot would have delivered, and therefore everybody can sleep secure in the knowledge
34:34
that if they get Alzheimer's or a similar condition, they're not going to lose their house
34:38
So it's selling a social contract that almost is a little bit socialist, isn't it
34:43
Because everybody contributes to something that helps not everybody. yeah i think that makes total logical sense oh thank god one of us did
34:53
but like but you but every time you have this conversation james where you've spoken to someone
34:59
over the age of 70 and they say that i just want to leave something to my children i just want to
35:04
leave something to my children and it is drummed into us basically a younger people or people in
35:08
our mid-ages that we want to work this towards something and leave something for our children
35:13
It answers it perfectly, knocks that on the head, quite simply. It's a blunt hammer, it's basically for a blunt nail, and it knocks it perfectly
35:24
Yeah, well, it's a very upbeat conversation, this, and I'm going to have to do that thing that I have to do sometimes
35:30
and urge people who disagree with what they've heard so far to ring in. Maybe you can't, maybe Steve is absolutely right
35:36
And it is like Brexit. And that you might think that you've got arguments against it
35:40
but as soon as you bring them into the light, they'll crumble. They'll fall apart
35:44
Like, I don't know, the Wicked Witch of the West when she's had a bucket of water thrown over her
35:48
And that, of course, is why I am generally so pessimistic about public discourse in this country
35:53
Just because it's true, just because it's demonstrable, just because it's evidence-based
35:57
and just because it's inarguable, doesn't mean that the British public will fall for it
36:03
Because they keep falling for things that are not true, that are not evidence-based, that are absolutely arguable, or not even arguable
36:09
they're inarguably wrong. and they're being punted by everybody from Nigel Farage
36:14
to Jacob Rees-Mogg and Liz Truss and the British public keep going for it
36:20
So I think the key thing here is going to be what we do, not on this little show
36:24
but what the conversation is like. Is it going to be in the interests of Russian disinformation agents
36:31
to start telling lies on your granddad's Facebook about this? Because it looks like the right-wing media is beginning to move
36:37
The Telegraph is. I doubt the mail will. but is your Aunty Doris going to be going on Facebook
36:43
and reading about how they're stealing her pension to feed immigrants probably she is, is she going to believe it
36:49
probably she is, is that going to be a big enough thing to scupper the whole project
36:53
I don't know it's 10.46 James O'Brien on LBC It is 10 minutes to
37:01
11 and you are listening to James O'Brien on LBC where the conversation continues
37:07
and in a direction I wasn't really expecting. So sometimes when I say to you, you know
37:11
come and rain on our parade, come and wee on our chips
37:15
then I do, well, I always mean it, but sometimes it sort of comes from a space of wondering
37:20
whether we've missed something rather than spoiling for a scrap. So all of the above Martin is in Lakenheath Martin before we get on to the conversation that we actually having what the mood like in Lakenheath at the moment Has it been affected at all by events in Fairford
37:36
Not really. I mean, we have lots of Americans that live around here. We see
37:40
them in the shops and places. I mean, you've got Lakenheath, Milton Hall and Feltwell
37:46
And talking to them, no, it hasn't changed at all, really. Everyone just sort of gets on with it. And you're not detecting
37:50
a heightened security presence or anything like that in the environs of the
37:54
airfields. No, not at all. I mean, I go past there every other day
37:59
Can I just take a moment to give you a round of applause? That was so... You had absolutely
38:04
no idea that I was going... I just... I know your neck of the woods quite well. I'm very fond of it
38:09
And I just saw Lakenheath on the screen. Eleanor and I were talking in the break about
38:14
Fairford and what we can do to discuss the latest crazy developments
38:18
And I just dropped that on you completely randomly and you hit it like a pro, mate
38:23
You sounded like Kate Adie coming in live from a war zone
38:27
or something like that. You've covered your miles. You've spoken to locals. It was just
38:31
magnificent. Anyway, what about the triple lock? On that basis, I'll give Blake and Heath Football Club a plug
38:37
They need all the publicity they get at the moment. Fantastic. Go on
38:42
Getting back to what we're supposed to be talking about, you mentioned Nigel Farage
38:46
and this is why I think the government would be best to leave it until their manifesto
38:51
for the next election. where they can lay out all the points that you have done very eloquently
38:56
saying you won't lose money overall. Because in the short term, by elections, council elections, or just campaigns
39:03
I think this would be a gift to reform. They said they've got all this money they're going to use for advertising
39:08
Now, I can envisage billboards with a sad old lady on one side
39:12
and small boat arrivals on the other, and a message such as, sorry, Mrs Jones, we can't pay you a decent pension
39:17
because we need to give all the money to act when it is made. And they say a picture is worth a thousand words
39:22
I don't know if you're old enough to remember the Labour isn't working before Thatcher's government
39:26
That was a very effective campaign. It was on posters, billboards, newspaper adverts, you know
39:32
and people wouldn't go down that deeply as you have. And the numbers wouldn't touch the sides
39:40
You know, to point out the absurdity of thinking that one would somehow wipe out the other
39:45
would be pointless because the emotions run so high. I mean, they've already said they'd cut the benefits bill by billions
39:51
without really specifying where they were going to get that money from, except by sort of typifying everybody unemployed or disabled
39:58
or out of work as being somehow faking it, and therefore, just with a loud enough bang
40:04
they could be chased back into the workplace. But yeah, you're probably right, aren't you
40:08
But they're going to do that anyway, whenever it is unveiled. But you're just sort of saying, give yourself a bit more space and time
40:16
Yeah, because if it's actually in the manifesto, set out clearly, calmly, balance sheets
40:22
all the rest of it, as you have done, then they can point to that. But if they try and do it beforehand
40:27
I just think it would be a gift to the right-wing parties. Yeah, I mean, you're really on the cusp
40:34
or on the absolute edge of that tension, I feel, between optimism and pessimism
40:40
You can't do everything based upon the fear of what the far-right liars will do
40:46
But, of course, you can't ignore what the far-right liars will do when you're working out what you should do
40:51
So that's the best... I mean, in a way, that's quite an upbeat ysis, isn't it? It's the best criticism we can think of
40:55
is that people will lie about it in order to persuade the gullible
40:59
to vote against their own interests again. Yeah, just, I think, keep their powder dry for now
41:04
They've got a very good majority, as it is. You know, why... Because of the win
41:10
The win would be the social care thing. It's a fascinating arithmetic that you bring to the table
41:14
Have you got a game tonight? No, not there. Because the local derby fund left against Melbourne Hall on Saturday
41:20
The El Bassico, as we call it, Battle of the Bases. What's Lekaneet's nickname
41:27
The Heath. The Heath. Oh, I didn't stay up late thinking of that one, did you
41:31
Well, anyway, come on. No, it's true. Up the Heath is the slogan. Come on
41:35
We're at Boreham Woods tonight. So up the Harriers. Come on the Reds while we're there
41:39
Good luck with that. Thank you very much indeed. You don't go to the top of the table. 10.54 is the time
41:44
Roger is in Cambridge. Roger, what do you reckon? I think we've been asking the wrong question, James, I'm afraid
41:49
That's all right, mate. Go on. Stepping back from this, it was brought in
41:53
because it was recognised that the state pension was too low. So we have this mechanism that makes it grow faster than the rest of things
42:02
faster than the rest of the economy. And incidentally, the same thing will happen on the double lock you were suggesting
42:08
because wages are a lagging indicator. But ignoring that, the way you get out of it is just by bribing people in the short term
42:16
It's currently about £12,500. It's going to go up by about £500 next time
42:22
If you say to people, we can't afford it, but what we think is that there ought to be a number that the state pension should be in today's money
42:32
And instead of £13,000, we'll make it £14,000 or £14,200. and we'll index link it from there, then..
42:42
You make it go away. It goes away as a hot potato. You also end up with a system that people understand
42:49
and the argument isn't about some abstract economic system that a lot of people, I'm afraid, don't understand
42:57
I know that's slightly patronising. No, that's all right. But it's about a number
43:02
and I suspect that the politicians haven't come out with a number at any point
43:06
because if Labour say 14, Conservatives will say 14.5 and Reform will say 15.20
43:13
It turns into policies under the hammer on Channel 5. To be honest, maybe that's how politics should work
43:21
When you say index link, do you mean inflation? I mean, yeah, I mean link it to the CPI or something
43:29
Okay, but then, I mean, so then it just becomes a single lock
43:34
Yes, but the difficulty with... And pensioners could get a bigger rise than workers year on year
43:38
That's true. But the situation with a triple lock is that the pension ends up rising faster than any other thing
43:49
Because the different aspects that it's linked to... Not every year, but it can do, and often will do
43:56
But it's not every year. I mean, if inflation is below 2.5% and wage growth is below 2.5%, then it goes up by 2.5%
44:04
And that is greater. That's greater. But I don't, I mean, I don't think that's hardly ever happened, has it
44:08
But they suspended it in 2021 because inflation was so high. Just talk me through briefly
44:16
the benefits of having a single lock instead of a double lock. Well, over time, it goes up less
44:23
Okay. And you deal with that. You soften, you sugar that pill by saying, here's a one-off increase
44:29
Yeah, and there's another thing, which is that people understand it. The double lock that you're proposing with wages
44:39
the reality is that wages are a lagging indicator. So what you'll have in an inflationary year
44:44
the next year, people get wage rises. In year two, the wage rises are bigger
44:50
So people get... So the pensioner wins twice. And the pension is still going up in a way that is unaffordable Yeah that a really good point You have to link it And I not saying don put it up And I not saying No it will go up every year unless inflation I not saying have it go up by
45:06
You can't have a mechanism that makes it go up faster than everything else forever
45:14
Or the whole economy will basically be the state pension. Yeah, which is the direction we're going in
45:19
Which is the direction we're going in. But also, if you just say to people
45:23
well, that's your lot. Thanks. It's not very attractive. It doesn't give people who are now receiving it
45:29
or who are about to receive it a reason to like the policy. But if you say to them, it should be 14 and a half
45:37
So either just we'll increase it to 14 and a half because eventually if you draw a shot
45:41
the lines are crossed and you'd be better off doing it that way. Or if you say to them, we'll keep the..
45:46
Our policy is to keep the triple lock until it is, in today's money, 14 and a half
45:52
and we will then make it index-linked. And it possibly spikes the guns that we were talking about in the last call
46:01
in the attempts to say, oh, look, they're taking your money and giving it to these people
46:06
which would be a lie, but they're very effective lies. That doesn't really work
46:09
if you've just had a bit of a measurable, invisible boost in your pension. Yeah
46:15
Expensive, though, in the short... Well, not really. Well, it is in the short term
46:20
Because the government finances are projected forwards, so they know how much they're going to be saving over 5, 10, 15 years
46:28
by just increasing it by, I don't know, 1,000, 1,200 now, something like that
46:34
It doesn't... At the same time, it would be enough to make people think
46:40
well, actually, yeah... But do you know how naive I am? I love this. Well played
46:44
It's a nice end to the conversation as well, sending things off in a slightly different conversation. But I'm such a little snowflake
46:49
snowflake, I really am. I'm sitting there thinking, wouldn't it be nice if some of these people, like
46:53
Christopher Hardborn, just sort of said, I'll cover that. I'll cover that
46:57
increase. I mean, that's what patriotism is. Nigel, mate, here's five million quid. So, people have got
47:03
billions and billions of pounds. Wouldn't it be nice if one of them just went, do you know what? I'll cover. I'll ring
47:07
around. I'm sure we can cover that. Patriotic billionaires. We'll take care of that
47:11
I don't know if we have enough of it. Do you want to sell me a bridge while I'm here, Roger
47:17
it's 11 o'clock James O'Brien on LBC it is four minutes after
47:24
11 and you're listening to James O'Brien on LBC a couple of things coming up later in
47:29
the programme or later on LBC today Andy Burnham speaking to Labour Conference
47:34
at approximately 2 o'clock this afternoon which is flippin inconsiderate of him because A
47:39
it means I can't put my feet up for 40 minutes while he struts his stuff
47:43
like I could yesterday when John Healy was behind the podium and B, I can't start writing my newspaper column
47:48
until he's finished. Some people are so inconsiderate. But we will be bringing you that live here on LBC
47:55
during Sheila Fogarty's programme. And I'm going to get Andy Hughes into the studio
47:59
LBC's crime editor, because this business in Fairford is just bonkers. You go from people, I mean, absolutely adamant
48:10
that there was some terrible terror threat being posed by people who'd arrived here yesterday on a dinghy
48:14
Sorry, the day before. Sorry, the day before Sunday on a dinghy
48:18
And then they got released yesterday on bail. The five British men known to have come to the authorities
48:26
I mean, what is going on? We get told, and I probably should have checked this with someone a bit more senior
48:31
before I said it out live on the radio, but I'm always really careful about speculating on
48:38
I probably go less far than I could. I tend not to talk about things at all
48:42
But the front page of The Sun today, it literally says plots going on so you go from being told not to speculate um which everybody
48:50
obeys except nigel farage who can never see a potential national tragedy go past without trying
48:55
to turn it into something that benefits him up to and including murders of course where the family
49:00
of the victim have asked people not to turn it into a conversation about immigration or ethnicity
49:05
and then up pops nigel farage in direct contravention of henry novak's family's express
49:09
wishes to try to turn it into a conversation about immigration or ethnicity so everybody
49:14
decent respects the authorities requirement that i mean everybody decent in public life
49:20
can't control what goes on in the sewers of socials um not to speculate and then they release
49:26
them on bail and and all bets are off everybody starts speculating i wanted to do a phone in today
49:31
about what you think is going on but i'm too scared because i think i might be breaching
49:36
guidelines or risking contempt. And then I turned to the Sun newspaper
49:41
which a million years ago was the best-selling newspaper in the country, and it's not just speculation
49:46
it's a flipping front-page story saying, plot's going on. The vans they seized did not contain any viable explosives
49:54
And I've got theories. I've got theories. I've got ideas. None of which are racist, obviously
50:02
so, you know, you wouldn't be able to stick me in the same boat as Old Farage. but I think as a couple of things
50:08
when you read, the more detail you read about it, the more possible it is to come up with theories
50:14
But I won't. It is six minutes after 11. They are on bail, James, says Ellie
50:22
They haven't been released. They have been released on bail. I think you'll find..
50:26
I don't think that's... Haven't they? I don't think that's particularly confusing
50:31
but I think probably a reason why I should... obey my instincts and not wade into this unaccompanied
50:39
So we'll get Andy Hughes in the studio at 11.45. Do you ever notice stories that..
50:47
I don't think you do, probably, but there are some stories that I just can't bring myself to talk about
50:54
It doesn't happen very often, because, of course, sometimes they are the stories
50:59
that you absolutely have to talk about. But you can't... you just can't do it
51:06
I'm a human being, right? And I'm a father and a husband and a son and a friend
51:13
and somebody who sometimes feels that the stories of tragedy are just too unbearable
51:19
I'm not that kind of journalist. I could never have been a war correspondent. I don't imagine that comes as a major surprise to anybody
51:25
not because I'm a better person than people who can be war correspondents, but because I'm a different person
51:31
I don't even like meeting politicians in case I have to be mean about them six months down the line
51:35
I'm just a bit of a, I suppose you'd say, a bit of a snowflake
51:39
I could be tough when I need to be tough, but my heart breaks when I read certain types of stories
51:47
And sometimes when that happens, and it happened last week, I don't talk about them to you
51:53
And when I'm in that zone, what you might call that hypersensitivity or excessive sensitivity
52:00
I don't know, or just normal empathy, when you're in that zone, you're not at your most reliable
52:06
So when I saw a story last week about a 12-year-old girl
52:10
who became so addicted to her mobile phone that she was, in the words of her father, almost nocturnal
52:18
my heart broke. The young lady concerned Angel Karanja died on March the 17th having become so withdrawn that her existence in the words of her grieving father became almost nocturnal And when I say I not at my most reliable I wouldn be
52:39
able to stay polite to people who were rude about the father. You get it when you are in the genre
52:49
of the phone-in, especially since we now take texts and emails. You don't even have to have the
52:54
courage to put your voice to your comments, but when a family is grieving like that, it seems to
52:58
me to be entirely unhelpful and unkind to think that it could have been easily avoided if only
53:05
the father was a bit more like you. If your little girl, I want to make this absolutely crystal clear
53:12
if the only apparent pleasure in life that your little girl can find is being on her phone
53:18
in the night, then you can't take it away from her. Because it's the only place
53:26
I mean, I know you can, and obviously you should. No evidence of cyberbullying
53:32
no internet searches relating to suicide. Just a tragedy and a mystery
53:41
but one which becomes perhaps a little bit easier to understand when you learn that she hated school
53:48
telling one friend shortly before she died that she would rather be in hell than at school
53:53
And the only distraction she could find from her mental torture was her phone, right
54:05
I just want to get that front and centre before we tentatively start looking at something
54:10
that is not part of these conversations enough. And I want to leave Angel's memory there
54:18
with you, with that simple observation that if you're watching your child feel tortured
54:23
and the only thing that soothes them is something that might be making things worse
54:30
you would have to look that parent in the eye and tell them that they should have made their tortured child's life worse
54:39
by tearing that phone out of her hand. So for Angel, it would appear that things have already gone
54:46
had already gone too far, right? And the way that we have to work these days
54:52
the hours that people have to work, not me, obviously, I'm very lucky
54:57
the independence that children have to develop very young, the trauma of changing school, the pressures
55:03
all of these things create scenarios in which you could find 10 children
55:08
going through exactly the same thing and they would respond in 10 entirely different ways
55:12
And the thing I just mentioned was the idea that the parents
55:18
that some people will automatically and immediately see this as an invitation to attack grieving parents
55:27
Here's one. David's been in touch. No, James, it's the parents' fault
55:31
Let's have a look at David's history, shall we? And just work out what kind of person it is
55:36
Go out and wash cars for a Saturday job. They are lazy and want to just earn money at home
55:41
Honestly, what does the system have to find them a job? Anybody who wants to work can
55:46
They don't. The entitlement of youth is insane. Ten years on and still banging on about Brexit, James
55:52
The benefit cap doesn't really exit. So why do we pay £3,000 to universal credit to some people
55:58
Why don't unemployed people do litter? So David is clearly a word I can't say on the radio
56:03
And just mention it to illustrate what I mean about how fundamentally broken some people's moral compass is
56:13
You hear a story about a dead 12-year-old and you think, I'm going to attack her dad. That's David
56:23
But there's a conversation that we need to have. And it's a conversation informed by a couple of things
56:28
I'm going to just change the tone quite profoundly, I think, by playing you a little clip of Alan Milburn
56:35
talking to Nick Ferrari this morning. And this is the lad I want you to think about
56:39
But I didn't want to have this conversation without properly honouring Angel's memory
56:43
This is the lad that this conversation will be about. It won't be about somebody in mental, in her own words, in mental hell
56:50
It will be about someone who's become a kind of hermit. Here's Alan Milburn, who chairs the Young People and Work Review
56:57
speaking to Nick Ferrari earlier this morning. I met a young guy in Bradford, Wayne, who's training at Bradford College
57:07
I was asking about his life. He's 19, I think. And I said, what have you been doing for the last three years
57:11
And his answer was, I've been in my bedroom. I said, what do you mean you've been in your bedroom? He said, I've been in my bedroom for three years
57:16
I said, what were you doing? He said, I was on my phone for three years, doing nothing. And I said, well, what, are you here
57:21
He said, my mum. My mum kept me out of the house, maybe go to college. And I said, what's it like
57:25
He said, well, I'm going to be an electrician. I'm going to be earning 50 grand a year. I said, good for you
57:29
and we gave him an opportunity. We gave him an opportunity and he seized it
57:35
Three years on it. And now, how do you respond to that right there? What are you doing
57:41
You're kind of going, well, that's a bit of a... Is that an extreme example? Is that an extreme example
57:48
Or is that actually a large part of the explanation of why
57:52
one million young people are currently not in education, employment or training
57:57
You remember how many times I've tried to have this conversation, and we've done well
58:01
We've had some brilliant conversations. I've met some lovely people. But I kind of wonder whether this is the biggest element of all
58:10
And it's not actually about the harm that social media can do
58:17
Do you know what I mean? It's not about the exposure to profoundly unhealthy sites
58:22
It's not about radicalization. It's not about bullying or cyberbullying. it's actually just the
58:31
utterly hollow fulfillment that it provides that actually because adults do it as well but we
58:40
don't generally have the option to spend three years in our bedroom we have to
58:46
go to work for example or go to the shops you know and I'm sure there's a bit of an
58:52
exaggeration there I'm sure he did leave his room occasion. I'm sure it wasn't like 24-7, 52 weeks a year, but adults can't do it. And you can see
59:04
some adults who are absolutely glued to their phones. They're always slightly struck by
59:09
couples out for dinner. And you think, I wonder how often you go out for dinner
59:14
And they're both just glued to their phones. They both seem perfectly happy. Occasionally, you see one partner sitting there sort of drumming their fingers and tapping their foot while the
59:23
other one and you sort of think yeah i'm not quite sure that one's going to go the distance but generally speaking adults are just as likely as teenagers to be glued to their phones and to be
59:30
endlessly scrolling but by dint of being adults by dint of being adults we kind of have to do
59:38
things like being a functioning addict you know you can just about handle your habit and keep the
59:46
wolf from the door. You can just about sustain your normal life and spend an unconscionable amount
59:53
of your downtime scrolling on your phone. More stories today. The effect of high screen time on
59:59
children is as significant as parental behavior and premature birth, if not greater
1:00:06
Just think about that. 2.8 million children across 64 countries, elevated screen exposure, affecting children
1:00:15
more than parental influence or premature birth, and obviously affecting everything from academic
1:00:22
achievement to emotional problems, in one of the largest studies on the subject, concluding
1:00:28
that the impacts of screen time, regardless of what's on the screen
1:00:33
are as big or larger than other factors linked to child development
1:00:38
and mental health outcomes, including family wealth, the behaviour of parents, and whether or not the children were born prematurely
1:00:45
So there is nothing, there is nothing as significant, potentially
1:00:55
in the development of our young people than the amount of time that they're spending on screens
1:00:59
And it's almost all negative. Don't at me to tell me about the positive stuff you can do
1:01:04
I know about that. So it's pretty obvious the conversation that we should have had
1:01:12
or should be having, isn't it? We talked a lot about banning the platforms of the government
1:01:19
It's in hand, but everybody else is talking about how unfeasible that is or how hard it will be
1:01:27
I mean, there are two questions here, because I've got a funny feeling that the first one might actually be rhetorical
1:01:36
It might not be. And I need to put my cards... Actually, I'll just take a quick junction now
1:01:40
and then I'll come back and tell you where I fit into this story, and then I'll take you a call. We may stay with this for longer than the 12 o'clock
1:01:46
because Andy's joining us at 11.45, and you know this happens to me sometimes, doesn't it
1:01:51
I start trying to explain something to you, and I realise that my interest in it is even deeper than what I thought
1:01:55
we're edging towards a question of whether or not we really just have to grasp the nettle and say
1:02:01
to young people you cannot have a phone in your room or six o'clock at night we're taking it off
1:02:07
you eight o'clock at night we're taking it off you i just can't see any way past all of the stories
1:02:13
that we hear and all of the conversations that we have but i'm allergic to simple answers to
1:02:18
complicated questions and then there's this little voice in the back of my head that says james what
1:02:22
if this isn't a complicated question? What if it's a really simple question? And therefore
1:02:28
the simple answer works. James O'Brien on LBC. It is 21 minutes after 11. So that's the
1:02:35
phone in. Is it actually where we are going to have to end up? We are going to have to
1:02:44
treat everybody as if they are addicts. And we are going to have to tear the phones out
1:02:49
of the hands of our young people or delay the moment when we give them one but that doesn't
1:02:56
help the kids who are currently in jeopardy i i can't put a number on how many of the million
1:03:02
are in the category that adlin milburn described to nick ferrari this morning a lad who simply
1:03:07
said i was in my room for three years and he was oddly occupied is a word i'd use he wasn't
1:03:14
fulfilled. He was simply occupied. I think the biggest difference between his generation and his
1:03:20
parents' generation is boredom. You're bored and not bored at the same time. And we can sit here
1:03:26
and talk about, oh, let's limit access to the platforms, or let's make sure they regulate
1:03:31
or let's do things to ensure that they don't get exposed to the most dangerous stuff
1:03:35
But I can't help thinking today, and I've never really thought this before, and it was partly the
1:03:41
story about that poor little girl. And something clicked when I heard that conversation with
1:03:46
Milburn on Nick's show. And I had that other tragedy in the back of my mind. And something
1:03:52
just clicked. And it was the, it was the difficulty. It was the, it was the, it was
1:03:59
it was the probability that the thing that needs to be done is the really difficult but easy
1:04:05
thing. And that's a contradiction in terms. It's really easy to say what needs to be done
1:04:09
But it's going to be really difficult to do it. And our society, as I mentioned the adults who are already addicted
1:04:17
our society is tuned in such a way that it feels absolutely impossible
1:04:24
And that's my question. Simply, is it? So oddly, it's the same question as selling the British public the triple lock
1:04:31
Is it actually doable? Because I don't think there's any other way to stop this from happening
1:04:36
I think it would take an enormous chunk out of the Neats issue overnight
1:04:40
and I also think it would save lives. Some of the messages I'm getting are unbearable
1:04:44
Truly, truly unbearable. I can't ring in because I will get too emotional
1:04:51
I'm thinking of suing TikTok and Meta because I've watched my teenage son turn into a phone addict
1:04:56
He has now cut contact with me and my entire side of the family and chosen to stay with his mum full-time
1:05:02
after an argument about his phone usage. He has no restrictions on screen time
1:05:06
his mother's and I was always dreading the date would come where he would leave it feels like I
1:05:11
am grieving the loss of a child says Mal and and that is what happens with addicts is that they
1:05:18
will prioritize access to their fix over pretty much everything else Ricky says my daughter went
1:05:23
through the same but her turn came on a waiting list of three years for send otherwise I'm not
1:05:29
sure that she'd be okay now it's heartbreaking James I could cry actually I am crying
1:05:36
Ricky Ricky I wasn't expecting that final line um listening to you James I'm in tears
1:05:41
my wife and I have been through similar luckily not to the point where our daughter died but her
1:05:47
words were you're forcing me to go to school and topping and stopping me from using my phone is like
1:05:53
sending me to hell her school only wanted to get an attendance mark they did nothing to help in fact
1:05:59
one teacher told her it's all in your head I wonder if David our texter earlier is a teacher
1:06:04
that's the kind of thing that he would have said it's all in her head
1:06:08
the only thing that soothed my daughter was her phone and so as a parent we'd be damned if we do
1:06:13
and damned if we don't just listen to that line there the only thing that soothed my daughter was her phone
1:06:18
happily school is over and my daughter is now working my heart goes out to the family
1:06:25
and of course those parents did everything they possibly could to help their daughter
1:06:29
but the only thing that soothed her in those moments was her phone
1:06:33
So is this what we need to do? We actually need to stop faffing about
1:06:37
and lock phones away at night. Listen, right, we've been very lucky
1:06:44
and I use that word advisedly, and Mrs O'Brien and I talk about it sometimes
1:06:48
My wife works as a child psychotherapist, so she knows quite a lot about some of the issues here
1:06:53
And we have been very lucky. We can't quite work out why we dodged these bullets, okay
1:06:59
But there was one point where one of ours was conscious that she was spending too much time online
1:07:05
I forget precisely what it was she was doing, but going back 10 years, and we bought a safe from Robert Dias
1:07:11
And every night, about 8 o'clock, we would put the phone in the safe
1:07:16
And even if she'd changed her mind and wanted to get it out, she couldn't. I can't remember whether I've told you that before
1:07:22
I think I have. It didn't last for very long. It only lasted for about three months, and then she didn need the safe anymore But the simple act of taking that phone out I wonder what impact that had in the long run Just breaking that moment of flirtation with some sort of addiction
1:07:35
Stick it in a safe, and you can't have it until morning. I don't care
1:07:40
You asked us to do that, though. Would we have had the wherewithal to do it
1:07:44
without being asked? I don't think we would. And that's why this is a tricky topic
1:07:48
Because you're going to essentially take something away from your child that when you gave it to them
1:07:54
you never told them there was any possibility whatsoever of taking it away. That's the thing I want you to answer, all right
1:08:00
0345 6060 973. Have you done it? Am I right? The more you think about it, the more you see
1:08:06
yeah, it's going to be hell, James, but we've got to do it. And do you think it's possible or impossible
1:08:13
0345 6060 973 is the number you need. Russ is in Bangor
1:08:17
Russ, what do you reckon? I was saying to your producer, hi, James
1:08:22
I'm quite fortunate because I've got grown-up kids. I've got kids from 32 to 11
1:08:27
Okay. So my older kids were a great source of help when we were considering what to do for our youngest
1:08:34
Yes. And I asked my older girls, when my daughter was pushing me for a phone
1:08:41
should I give her one? And they all said no. Yeah, they would do. And I asked them why
1:08:45
and they gave me reasons such as the pressures of TikTok and Instagram. and it was all about things like the pressure on them
1:08:52
to look beautiful and thin and all these kind of things and the bullying stuff that goes on
1:08:57
and these terrible role models that are on there. But the problem we have is what would you do
1:09:04
if you'd given it to her and she was now 15, 16 years old
1:09:08
Exactly. So we had this advice from our girls and so me and my wife did exactly what you said
1:09:13
Is it, can you do it and does it work? And the answer is yes. So these are the rules in our house
1:09:17
You never gave her one? No, we had to because she went to secondary school
1:09:21
Oh, I see what you mean. She's nearly 12 now, so she had to have a phone to go to secondary school
1:09:26
but we had to find a way of giving her a phone and protecting her at the same time
1:09:31
Because that's the big word that most parents forget about. We're here to protect our children
1:09:36
And that's not me being sort of pious. That's me just saying that's the gig
1:09:40
And I respect that, and I'm glad it's worked for you. But I think, and I'm very grateful for you bringing in
1:09:46
But I think the challenge is what do we do with the ones who are stuck already
1:09:52
The ones who are getting the paralysis brought on by severe dopamine addiction
1:09:57
The people who will tell you that, you know, what do you say to that dad whose tortured daughter is saying
1:10:05
and he is saying, the only thing that soothed her was her phone
1:10:09
And you're now going to tell, neither of us have faced this, so neither of us can really answer it
1:10:13
But that old adage about you have to be cruel to be kind
1:10:17
doesn't really cover it, does it? But we still have the toughness
1:10:21
We still have to deal with... We still have an 11-year-old, who's nearly 12
1:10:25
saying, all my friends have this. Why can't I have screens in my room
1:10:29
Why can't I have my phone in DNA? What do you say? What do you tell them? We tell them that
1:10:33
We say that the phone is a privilege, it's not a right. That was the thing we drilled into from day one
1:10:38
Do you ever say, because I say so? No, no, you can't say that. You actually have to model it
1:10:43
You can't be telling your kids not to have phones at dinner if you're sitting with your phone at dinner
1:10:47
No, you can't. Or in a restaurant. So you really have to model it. I heard this thing a few years ago
1:10:52
that kids don't catch what you say, they catch what you are. Yeah. And so I think there's a lot of truth in that
1:10:58
And so me and my wife, so at 6pm every night, everything's off
1:11:03
And then we sit down as a family and we have dinner and then we watch TV together or we do other things together
1:11:09
But the phones are gone. It's feasible, it's doable. I mean, some families won't have the luxury of all being at home, of course, at six o'clock in the evening
1:11:16
But the rule with the phone, change it to eight o'clock, make it nine o'clock, just make it bedtime
1:11:21
We take it off you. We take it off you. Three years that lad was in his room until finally his mum nudged him out
1:11:29
And he wasn't, I don't think, suffering in mental torture. So this is the distinction that needs to be drawn between the young people who are finding their only sucker and solace in their online activity
1:11:40
because the dopamine has become so intrinsic to their existence and the young people who are just stuck in a form of stasis or paralysis
1:11:48
And we sit here, how many phone-ins have we had about these two issues, safety on phones and NEATS
1:11:53
It's the first time I've probably fully recognised how it's in many ways the same conversation
1:11:58
Half past 11 is the time. Dominic Ellis has your headlines. James O'Brien on LBC
1:12:03
It is 11.34, and I think the two stories have to, in future
1:12:09
be viewed in tandem with each other. I want to play you that clip again of Alan Milburn
1:12:15
talking to Nick Ferrari earlier, because it's all very well talking about
1:12:19
what we would do with our 12-year-olds or our 13-year-olds. What do you do with an 18-year-old
1:12:24
I mean, what can you actually do? The only thing you can do to save this kid
1:12:31
from self-imposed hermithood is take his phone off him. Listen to this
1:12:36
I met a young guy in Bradford Wayne who's training at Bradford College
1:12:43
I was asking about his life he's 19 I think and I said what have you been doing for the last three years
1:12:47
and his answer was I've been in my bedroom I said what do you mean you've been in your bedroom he said I've been in my bedroom for three years
1:12:52
I said what were you doing he said I was on my phone for three years doing nothing and I said well what are you here
1:12:57
he said my mum my mum kept me out of the house made me go to college and I said what's it like
1:13:02
he said well I'm going to be an electrician I'm going to be earning 50 grand a year I said good for you
1:13:05
and we gave him an opportunity. We gave him an opportunity and he seized it
1:13:11
Hands up if you find that story entirely believable, right? Because if you don't
1:13:17
then I don't know what you've been doing for the last few years. And then hands up if you don't find that story believable
1:13:22
or you don't think it is, quotes, that simple, end quotes. But what on earth could that mum have done
1:13:27
Apart from chuck him out of the house, threatened to chuck him out of the house. You can't take a phone off an 18-year-old
1:13:33
I just, I, you can always tell when I'm sort of a little bit wary
1:13:37
of putting everything I own on a certain opinion, a certain conclusion. But the thing we need to do now is to take phones off young people
1:13:45
How can we do that if we're all addicted ourselves? So let me add another question to the mix
1:13:50
which is how do you persuade a skeptic that this is actually a full-on addiction
1:13:56
It's a full-on addiction. let me just read you briefly what one of my regular correspondents has to say
1:14:04
it's not false fulfillment it's paralysis brought on by severe dopamine addiction
1:14:10
they have been programmed to crave input in the way that I do
1:14:14
but they have no brain shields or mental training or experience related resilience
1:14:19
they're children this affects adults too this brain retraining but kids are so much more malleable
1:14:25
and they talk about an eight-year-old they know who has their own YouTube channel now
1:14:30
and that's just terrible. That's the thing. You're going to have to take it out of their hands
1:14:38
You're going to have to take it off them. Otherwise, we're going to be sitting here talking about neats for the rest of our lives
1:14:43
Sam's in Southampton. Sam, what do you reckon? Hi, James. Thanks for taking my call
1:14:47
I think you've... For a while, I've listened to the show and I've heard you have conversations about social media
1:14:53
and whether it should be banned etc And I always been sat listening thinking it the phones that the problem And I so glad you having this call here today I work in a school that obviously presents challenges
1:15:09
We've recently come up with a smartphone ban, where they're just not allowed to have smartphones
1:15:15
on them at all on school site. So they don't even leave it in reception? They just..
1:15:22
No, so in previous years we've had a policy whereby they're allowed to have smartphones
1:15:28
but it must never be out or heard or seen on school site
1:15:32
This year we've gone one step further and we've said they shouldn't have a smartphone at all on them on the school site
1:15:40
And I think it's a brilliant policy, but I think that the solution to these problems really
1:15:46
are simply to ban smartphones under, say, the age of 16. ban them entirely not not just not just ration them or or correct so it would be like buying
1:15:57
cigarettes or being being seen you know i mean it wouldn't be entirely imposable but you create it
1:16:02
enough stigma attached to it and it and it polices itself it's it's funny there that you've mentioned
1:16:08
cigarettes and alcohol would be another example both addictive substances are smartphones any
1:16:14
different they're equally as addictive there is anything designed to be addictive so you can almost
1:16:20
the argument that there's more of a case for doing so. How many kids in your school do you reckon have still got phones
1:16:25
albeit that they don't bring them to school? Because I'd say all of them. I'd say the majority
1:16:30
I'd say the Year 7s that have just come up and started in September. I think what the policy's done is it's given the parents a leg to stand on
1:16:38
where they say, no, you know what, you're not having a smartphone, you can have a brick phone
1:16:43
And so I think if there were to be a ban such as what I'm proposing brought in
1:16:47
you know, it would need to be drip-fed. in reality are we going to wrestle the phones out of 14 year olds but there are some 14 year olds
1:16:54
who and this is why i've used those two very different stories today to set this conversation
1:16:58
up there are some children who who you couldn't wrestle it would be i mean you know it is literally
1:17:03
the only thing that they can do to distract themselves you will have children with suicidal
1:17:08
ideation who find that their online activity is the only thing that stops the noise in their head
1:17:13
and things like that that that would be part of the challenge but i think a parent would know that
1:17:18
A parent knows the difference between a child who is in hell
1:17:22
and a child who is in, forgive the religious ogy going even further
1:17:27
a child who is in limbo. No, 100%. And I would suggest that this is something that should be brought in gradually
1:17:34
So let's say the current generation of primary school kids start in secondary school
1:17:40
you know, the law could apply to that generation where those of that age group are not allowed to have a smartphone
1:17:46
until they are age 16, as for those that are... But that does nothing to help the 18-year-olds
1:17:54
like the one Alan Milburn was talking about. I mean, I appreciate it, you know, it's generational
1:17:58
but listen to this, you could literally be talking about my 19-year-old son. It's completely believable
1:18:03
Thank goodness three months ago he finally found a job because I honestly believe that having the escape from reality
1:18:08
within the four walls of your bedrooms via your phones prevents them from moving forward with their lives
1:18:14
it's probably, there are lots and lots of other elements, but it's probably the biggest explainer for the neat phenomenon of all, isn't it
1:18:22
Is this false fulfillment or paralysis? And what you're doing is nipping it in the bud and stopping it from developing
1:18:31
And I agree with you for what it's worth. But how on earth do you address the people in whom it has already developed
1:18:39
I don't know how you do it. And also, we don't like being mean to our own children. So that mum, it took us three years to lay down the ultimatum that Alan Milburn was talking about
1:18:48
So what do you do? You spend the first six months thinking, well, they're doing their best
1:18:52
and the next six months thinking that the world is against them and the poor little treasure can't get anywhere
1:18:57
And then, what, the next 12 months sort of thinking, oh, well, maybe he just needs a nice rest
1:19:02
It's a tough time to be young. I'm sure he'll come out punching. And then suddenly it's year three of his self-imposed exile, his self-imposed hermithood
1:19:11
and you're beginning to contemplate the possibility he's never going to leave his bedroom again. And he doesn't need to because you're feeding him
1:19:17
And, you know, he's got a nice roof over his head and you're going to turn the heating on soon, but not yet
1:19:23
And then you've suddenly realised that something has to shift and I've got to get him out of the house
1:19:28
And getting him out of the house means getting him off his phone. You get him off his phone, you get him out of the house
1:19:32
And she found a way to do it. I would not deign to sit here for a nanosecond
1:19:37
and say that that would be an easy thing to do. And that's why I began the programme by pointing out that many people hear conversations like this
1:19:44
and think that it's an invitation to be both cruel and stupid
1:19:48
You say, oh, it's very, very easy to do this. You just need to spare the rod, spoil the child or something
1:19:54
Ross is in Mickleover in Derby. Ross, what made you pick up the phone? Hi, James. Big fun. Pretty nervous
1:19:59
Wasn't expecting to phone in today. It's only me. It's only me. Go on
1:20:03
But, yeah, so I'm 28. and recently in the last year I noticed that I was spending
1:20:09
upwards of 14 hours a day on my phone especially at weekends. 14? 14 yeah. Holy moly
1:20:15
In your screen time and your settings it tells you what you've been doing so
1:20:19
it was horrifying to see and you don't think gosh you didn't think it was anywhere near that much at the time
1:20:23
anyway. So I got a different kind of smartphone and it's called a
1:20:27
balance phone and it's got a modified version of Android in so it works like
1:20:31
a smartphone still so you've got Google Maps and you can download WhatsApp and
1:20:35
things like that, contactless payments, etc. It doesn't let you download social medias
1:20:40
or many games from the Play Store. So I got that phone, thinking, right, I need a hard limit
1:20:47
And then sort of after a couple of months, I was quite unpleasant after I first got
1:20:54
I'll be completely honest. Snappy, short-tempered, grotchy. Yeah, because I gave up vaping
1:20:59
and I felt very similar to when I gave up vaping as I did to giving up short-form content
1:21:05
Is that all you were watching? YouTube Shorts was my thing. So quite innocuous stuff, not like corrupt stuff or dangerous stuff
1:21:13
No, not really. Just completely addictive stuff. Yeah, I mean, the sort of right-wing rubbish tries to infiltrate its way in, you know
1:21:21
And if you weren't quite switched on to it, then, you know..
1:21:25
It would, but you can still be on there for 14 hours a day just watching nonsense
1:21:30
Yeah, because it's all AI and it's all designed in a way to... and it knows the clips that you're most likely to watch at the end
1:21:35
So whoops-a-daisy, here's another 400 of them. Exactly, yeah. 14 hours a day later, you're just going
1:21:41
what the fudge has happened to me? Yeah, so I started noticing that the other parts of my life
1:21:46
were sort of taking the hit for it. So I had the apprenticeship, I did plumbing and heating
1:21:50
I loved my job, I couldn't imagine doing anything else. Yeah. But if I was how I was now, back when I was sort of 16
1:21:57
just sort of around that apprenticeship sort of age, I don't know if I'd have the drive to do it
1:22:02
And it's just the phone. It is literally the phone. It is literally the phone, yeah
1:22:06
I completely believe you. I completely believe you. I feel a bit stupid for not having joined these dots
1:22:11
quite so completely a little bit sooner, but you just, because you know what it's like
1:22:15
Those shorts are like, they're like crack cocaine, aren't they? They just sort of get stuck on them and you can't get out again
1:22:21
Totally. So, obviously, I'm not a parent. I can't give any parenting advice at all. Sure
1:22:25
Well you kind of just have actually In a good way You know take the phone away from them Take the phone away from them Yeah I mean but No I wouldn take the phone away
1:22:36
You just program it, or lock it, or put hard limits in place
1:22:40
That's going to be slightly age-dependent. What about the 18-year-old, Ross? You were 18 a lot more recently than I was
1:22:46
What about the 18-year-old in his room? I always remember an old producer of mine when we were talking about Truant
1:22:51
And I went to boarding school. you can't really play truant at boarding school
1:22:55
although I did manage on a couple of occasions. And he just said, what are you talking about? I used to be quite sort of like a bit of a lazy radio presenter
1:23:02
Oh, it's just easy. You just tell them they won't be able to have any sweets. And he just said, what if you're a single mother
1:23:08
and your son is bigger than you? How are you going to get him to go to school? So here's an 18-year-old, locked in his room
1:23:14
not even locked in his room, never coming out. How do you get the phone? How do you break that bond
1:23:18
How do you break that relationship? You've just got to tip away so gently
1:23:23
and slowly, you can't go in organs blazing because then you're going to get a reaction
1:23:29
just as big as the one you're sort of giving off. It's got to be really gentle
1:23:35
It's got to be loving. I think it's all just about knowing what's out there and
1:23:40
sort of... I think everything's all about education. I think when you get to a point
1:23:47
where you've got to ban something, there's so much stuff you can do before that
1:23:51
Before you get to that point. I mean, you're more thoughtful than I am, actually. I am still putting most of my chips on the idea
1:23:58
that you've got to get the phone out of their hand, actually, in the first instance
1:24:02
and then the education can involve putting it back in their hand. But maybe you're right, and you need to be weaned off it
1:24:08
If someone's really vulnerable, sometimes you've got to be... I've made that clear
1:24:12
No, you're absolutely right. But I don't think most of the kids aren't necessarily vulnerable
1:24:17
I think they are addicted, and you're right to remind me, that involves a form of vulnerability
1:24:22
So what we need is a kind of telecoms methadone. I mean, something that can help you wean a child off an addiction
1:24:33
without actually endangering them or making them go off the deep end
1:24:38
Ross, lovely stuff, mate. Thank you. The time is 11.46. Let's get Andy Hughes in the studio
1:24:42
even though I don't think anybody has got anything to say about what's actually gone on at RAF Fairford
1:24:48
I think if you hear that from Andy Hughes rather than me, then you're much more likely to believe it
1:24:52
It's 11.47. James O'Brien on LBC. Ten minutes to twelve is the time
1:24:57
I suppose we need to get a handle on how many so-called NEATs
1:25:01
are spending their almost entire lives on their phones. You get a handle on that
1:25:07
I'm getting a surprising number of messages, you get a handle on that, you get a better answer to the question that I'm asking
1:25:13
We may return to that, it's up to you. Just think on that for me for a moment. Have you got one in your life
1:25:19
Were you one? How feasible is it to spend, let's say, a year on your phone
1:25:26
How feasible is it? Because you as an adult with a job can't. But if you didn't have a job, you'd be like the last lad
1:25:32
14 hours at the weekend? Every day? Got no job? Got no college
1:25:36
That's it. That's why they're neat. Anyway, I digress. Andy Hughes is here
1:25:40
LBC's crime correspondent. I think I promoted you earlier. And co-host, of course, of the Crime Agents podcast
1:25:45
And here to discuss one of... In your long and storied career
1:25:49
presumably one of the strangest stories that you've ever encountered. It is an odd one
1:25:54
It began in the early hours of Sunday morning where five men were arrested near RAF Fairford
1:26:00
on suspicion of terrorism offences. A major incident declared, dozens of homes evacuated
1:26:06
and after police were alerted to three suspicious vehicles near the airbase in Gloucestershire
1:26:13
Now these men, all British men in their 20s from London, they were initially detained on suspicion of committing offences
1:26:19
under the Explosives Act and on suspicion of preparation of a terrorist act
1:26:24
And yesterday, the suspects were released on police bail and would be subject to stringent conditions on their movement
1:26:32
and contact with others, and no explosives were found. Now, President Donald Trump and US Secretary of State Marco Rubio
1:26:40
have questioned that decision to release the suspects. Yeah, I mean, Trump's saying he knew who they were
1:26:46
and they've been watching them for ages, and Marco Rubio then coming out and saying that he knows
1:26:50
that a foreign agent, a foreign state is involved, it's foreign state sponsored
1:26:55
Biggest surprise was the bail, probably. The fact that they were suspected of the most serious potential crimes
1:27:04
and bailed in 24 hours, pretty much. Well, what this suggests is that counter-terrorism police
1:27:09
do not believe that these five suspects are an immediate threat to the state
1:27:14
And they didn't have any explosives. No, no, they didn't. If they believed they were an immediate threat, they would have simply been held in custody
1:27:24
How the process works is counter-terrorism investigations. Suspects can be questioned for up to 48 hours
1:27:31
They are then either released with no charge, released on police bail or charged
1:27:36
So where we are today is that the counter-terrorism detectives will be trying to establish
1:27:43
whether the suspects, knowingly or unknowingly, were up to no good on behalf of any foreign state or not
1:27:52
Or doing something completely different but nefarious. Exactly. Or doing something completely different and not even nefarious
1:27:59
albeit that they, I mean, some of the details suggest that they were trying to sort of go undercover, as it were
1:28:04
Well, we do know that, and I have spoken to sources in security services
1:28:09
they had intelligence that this air base was going to be attacked
1:28:15
Yes. And also the fact that counter-terrorism police are still leading this investigation
1:28:22
that gives you a few clues into the motives. Potentially, except, of course, that if they had had
1:28:28
and I mean, it's hardly surprising given that Fairford is a stopping-off point
1:28:31
for planes that are heading out towards Iran, But the fact that the culprits, suspects
1:28:40
were apprehended as a consequence of a member of the public phoning it suggests that they weren't exactly at action stations
1:28:47
No, no, but they were on high alert, I'm told, from Saturday evening
1:28:51
OK. So there seems to have been some intelligence. I mean, we're not really allowed to speculate, are we
1:28:57
No. Are you sure? What are the rules? I mean, I... I'll tell you what
1:29:02
There's no doubt that... How can you not speculate a bit now
1:29:06
There's no explosives. And they were in... I mean, a lot of people think that diesel might be involved in that
1:29:12
Yeah, well, it's certainly not my job to speculate. I can tell you for a fact that counter-terrorism police
1:29:18
would not have been happy when they heard Donald Trump and Marco Rubio
1:29:21
coming out, questioning their decision and effectively saying that this was linked to a foreign state
1:29:27
But they're unhitched, aren't they, from the parameters of honest discourse. So just because, I mean, it's an incredible thing
1:29:35
to have to remind people of, but just because the President of the United States has said something doesn't mean that there is necessarily
1:29:41
a scintilla of truth in it. And that's a mad thing. It never stops being mad, that
1:29:46
Even though it sometimes feels like we were the only people saying it for a long time. Everyone's caught up now
1:29:50
Just because Donald Trump says the President of the United States of America
1:29:54
says something about events at an airfield where his own... ...is stationed in the United Kingdom, and he says it, and I don't know what the odds are on it being true
1:30:06
or complete bunkum, but you absolutely no guarantee whatsoever that it would be true
1:30:11
Marco Rubio, a long time ago, fell into line behind Donald Trump
1:30:16
And so what might happen next? Presumably the police have got hold of devices
1:30:23
Yeah, home searched of the suspects, all devices seized, and that does take time to go through
1:30:30
The main object is to decipher the motive or the potential motive of the suspects
1:30:37
and if indeed this was linked to terrorism. I think a lot of people have jumped to conclusions immediately because it's an RAF base
1:30:44
and both the Iranian state and the Russian state have made no secret of their desire to target these bases
1:30:51
especially given that RAF Fairford is, well, that's where American bombers go from to the Iranian war
1:31:01
And as we saw with the arson attacks on Keir Starmer's property
1:31:06
there is a sort of newish trend of signing people up who don't really have any ideological skin in the game
1:31:14
to do things that are designed to disrupt democracy. And then it goes alongside online agitation
1:31:20
So in that case, it was people claiming that Kirstenmer hadn't paid some rent boys
1:31:24
And that was absolutely everywhere on social media. And it was sponsored, it appeared by somebody with pretty close links to high ups in Russia
1:31:34
And that is a new mode of hybrid warfare, just simply combining actions or plots in the real world with online speculation, provocation and incitement
1:31:47
Yeah, well, the head of MI6 came out last year and said that attacks or threats from foreign states is up 50%
1:31:56
And the use of proxies has also been rising. And we've seen several cases going through the courts in the last year
1:32:04
So the only thing anybody could say with any certainty about this is that Nigel Farage would absolutely turn it into a conversation about small boats
1:32:10
Even though we now know that the absolute absence of any link whatsoever to anything that has anything whatsoever to do with small boats
1:32:17
which is why he's now issued a public apology. Don't be ridiculous
1:32:22
Of course he hasn't issued a public apology. Why on earth would he issue a public apology, even though the revelation or the announcement
1:32:28
that it was five British nationals came pretty much while he was delivering a nonsense on social media
1:32:33
about how it proved everything that he'd said about the Iranian Revolutionary Guard and small boats crossing
1:32:40
So literally announced that it's got nothing to do with small boat crossings, it's British nationals
1:32:45
which also means it's got nothing to do with the Iranian Revolutionary Guard directly, in the middle of Farage recording himself
1:32:51
claiming the polar opposite. But anyway, I suppose in a world of confusion and flux and change
1:32:56
it's almost reassuring to know that some things remain relatively certain. Thank you, Andy
1:33:01
I mean, I can't do it, can I? Because, I mean, what you might call healthy speculation
1:33:09
in the spirit of Occam's razor or Sherlock Holmes, once the impossible has been eliminated
1:33:13
whatever you are left with, however improbable, must be the truth. We can't even really do that
1:33:19
Do you know what? I've noticed that the police are even giving up
1:33:23
on asking people not to speculate now because it is so rife
1:33:27
All that can be really done is have people like me who know about these issues
1:33:32
read in between the lines into what something like releasing them on police bail may mean
1:33:38
Yes, yes, yeah, good point. And I suppose just to make that transatlantic connection once again
1:33:43
that if Donald Trump and Marco Rubio were following them and knew exactly who they were
1:33:47
and were absolutely fully aware of what was going on, why the hell did it take a farmer to bring it in
1:33:51
on her way back from a dinner party in the middle of the Cotswolds in the early hours of Sunday morning
1:33:56
I think we may have been let down by five eyes on this one, or certainly by our supposed allies
1:34:01
That, of course, presupposes that Trump and Rubio are telling the truth, which, as I reminded you a moment ago, is sadly far from guaranteed
1:34:09
Andy Hughes, great stuff. More on this, no doubt, as the situation develops, or indeed doesn't, because it might not now
1:34:14
It might go nowhere for a week or two. Probably. Extraordinary scenes. It's 12 noon
1:34:20
James O'Brien on LBC. It's three minutes after 12. You are listening to James O'Brien
1:34:26
on LBC. You know there are very few people who I regard with almost
1:34:33
undiluted admiration. It is, I mean, sometimes I even forget who's on the list, it's so short
1:34:40
But Martin Lewis is always and eternally very near the top of it i i i love the guy i i know him off air i know him
1:34:49
outside of broadcasting work um and it is one of those rare examples where getting to know somebody
1:34:56
away from their public image makes you like them even more um but i'm not talking about liking
1:35:02
someone i'm talking about admiring someone martin's dedication to uh the work that he does
1:35:09
to make your money go further is extraordinary. It's motivated partly by a real deep disdain
1:35:17
for all of the effort that's put into parting you with your money, parting you from your money
1:35:22
in ways that should not be allowed or opaque or commonplace. And that's what he dedicates so much of his energy to
1:35:32
finding ways in order to save you money. That's why they call him the money-saving expert
1:35:37
I remember watching him in the early days when he was just doing little slots on telly
1:35:44
on daytime telly. And some of us, because we went to the same university
1:35:48
although we didn't really know each other then, other journalists, other people that had come out
1:35:54
of the same university at the same time, we all sort of watched each other quite closely
1:35:59
I was measuring inside legs in Aquascutum at the time, so nobody was really watching me
1:36:03
But, you know, you'd notice, you'd know who the other people trying to get into your industry
1:36:07
roughly were and and he started popping up on telly and i remember talking to somebody else who'd
1:36:14
gone down a more traditional route and they they thought he was bonkers they said he doesn't he
1:36:17
wants to do it all on his own website um and he's he's and he's going to do it in this entirely new
1:36:24
way in which no nobody has done it and i remember thinking he's either he's either absolutely
1:36:29
bonkers or he is a genius it's like that old line that teachers used to say about people say
1:36:34
He'd be a millionaire or in prison by the time he's 21. There was no prospect of Martin ending up in prison
1:36:39
but he could have ended up in relative penury and oblivion. Also, what they did with advertising on the website as well
1:36:48
or rather not having advertising on the website, he was sort of really ploughing his own furrow and doing his own thing
1:36:55
And I watched it from afar. I watched it from afar, and I wasn't really concentrating that hard
1:36:59
And then suddenly, he's one of the biggest dudes in town. and he sells the company for tens of millions of pounds
1:37:06
and puts an awful lot of the money that he's made, as he continues to do
1:37:09
into charities that are dedicated to exactly the same principle that motivated him in the first place
1:37:16
I can't think of another journalist whose motivation was as pure, is as pure as Martyr
1:37:22
It embarrasses the hell out of him when I do this. Do not whatever you do send him a clip We haven told him that we talking about this and we haven asked him to come on because we talking about something completely different I just want to establish beyond any reasonable doubt that the guy is an absolute mensch
1:37:37
He is the mensch of mensches. He is just a legend. I can't think of another journalist
1:37:44
that has not only managed to stay so true to their founding principles
1:37:50
but also enjoy such extraordinary success and share it around, you know
1:37:56
and use some of the money that he's made to help people who would not get help from anywhere else
1:38:02
More relevantly to the conversation that we're about to have, I've been on a train with him
1:38:07
I've been on a quite long train journey with Martin Lewis. When we were going up to Manchester
1:38:11
to do Celebrity Mastermind together, we were on the same team. Do not watch the clip
1:38:15
We'll both fall, in your estimation, although quite possibly me further than him
1:38:20
And the first thing that surprised me most about the story that has gone a little bit viral
1:38:25
gone very viral in the last couple of days, was that the people involved didn't recognise him
1:38:30
Because it's another thing you do when you've sort of gone down the path I've gone down
1:38:36
career-wise, is that you can sometimes, particularly in the earlier days, when it starts happening for the first time
1:38:41
you sort of compare who's getting asked for selfies or who's getting asked for autographs
1:38:46
or who's getting clocked. So sometimes I've been out socialising with some extremely famous people
1:38:52
and they get bothered a little bit less than you would imagine, actually
1:38:57
The people who get bothered the most are the people when they need to double-check it's you
1:39:03
So, excuse me, but are you... And then you go, yes, yes, I am. So it's when there's a bit of..
1:39:07
It sounds weird, this, but, you know, a Lineker can walk down the road
1:39:12
probably less bothered than somebody less famous because you know it's him
1:39:18
You don't need to check. You just check. Martin is probably the famous person I've been out with the most
1:39:25
Sorry, the famous person I've been out with who gets stopped the most
1:39:33
Everybody wants to talk to him. And all they really want to do is say, Oh, you're amazing, thanks. Can I have a selfie
1:39:38
And they might tell him a story about something they've done as a consequence of following his work
1:39:42
and saving some money. And he loves it. He's got very strict rules about when he's with his family
1:39:50
and when he's on his own, and he manages to keep... Another thing I really admire about him
1:39:55
he keeps the parameters in place, and he is not public property
1:39:59
but, you know, the guy's a legend, right? And by rights, I should be jealous of him
1:40:04
because we went to the same university, and he's as rich as Croesus. So by rights, the old envy thing should be kicking in
1:40:10
the old Truman Capote. A small bit of me dies, said Truman Capote
1:40:13
every time a friend succeeds. I love that line. And I don't know how Lewis has managed to swerve that response from me
1:40:22
but my goodness me, he has. And I can almost picture the scene
1:40:28
that I'm about to describe to you, travelling with his family on a busy train on Sunday
1:40:37
when a couple across the aisle started playing music loudly from their phone
1:40:42
He says he initially bit his tongue, and it would be social media videos
1:40:47
that were playing on their speakers at full volume and then they started watching a documentary
1:40:53
about serial killers at full blast. Busy train, he's taken to social media to explain what happened
1:41:03
he leant over the aisle and this is the moment where everybody reacts differently, right
1:41:07
So that was what was going on. They're obnoxious and we have had conversations in the past
1:41:13
and this might turn into one of them. This might be part of the conversation we're about to have
1:41:17
They possibly don't realise how obnoxious they are because it's become curiously commonplace
1:41:22
to eschew headphones or earphones and listen instead at full volume to something that nobody else in the carriage
1:41:29
or the bus is remotely interested in being able to hear. But it was Gore Vidal, not Truman Capote
1:41:34
God, I've got such erudite listeners, haven't I? Gore Vidal, everybody, not Truman Capote
1:41:39
Schoolboy error from me. But I think, you know, both of their work. not an unforgivable one
1:41:46
Gore Vidal, a small piece of me dies every time a friend succeeds. And he did that thing
1:41:53
He did that thing where he said, excuse me, could you turn that down? Excuse me, could you turn that down
1:41:58
I don't think I've ever done that. I've wanted to. I don't think it's ever happened to me
1:42:04
on a long journey. It's only really happened to me on the bus
1:42:11
It's not a rush hour thing. But here's the point. He did it
1:42:15
He leant across and did it, pointing out that he was with his daughter
1:42:19
and that he didn't particularly want her to be listening to a documentary about serial killers
1:42:24
The woman in the couple responded by saying, I'm sure she's heard worse at school
1:42:29
I can see him now. I could see, I'd be like thinking, okay, I'm in now
1:42:34
I've done it now. I can't back down. And so he would say calmly, that's not your decision to make
1:42:40
and I would really appreciate it if you would turn the volume down
1:42:46
And as he said himself, for me, that's exactly why it is antisocial. I'm wondering which one of us is out of kilter on this
1:42:53
Which one of us is out of kilter on this? And people queued up to tell him that she was
1:43:00
That he hadn't actually done anything wrong. It's just incredible, isn't it, one response said
1:43:04
I've come to the conclusion that some people just must have their brains wired differently
1:43:08
as to think that playing loud music or videos, and particularly, you know, non-child-friendly material in a public space is acceptable
1:43:15
I don't think he'll mind me saying that that will be entirely authentic. He will have been tying himself in knots
1:43:21
worrying about whether or not he had done the right thing or whether or not he, you know, had..
1:43:29
He was the one that was out of kilter with modern mores or modern behaviours
1:43:34
And he's not, is he? So, two questions, really. And your answer to the first one, obviously
1:43:44
the funnier or the more unexpected or the more shocking it is, the better
1:43:48
And that is, have you done this? Have you taken it upon yourself to do this
1:43:53
But the second is why that line there about, am I the one that's out of kilter
1:43:58
How has this happened? How has this happened? Look, there are a couple of people, like I get in Idiot's Corner
1:44:07
so he got on social media. She's in the right here. she should have just played a more offensive video even louder
1:44:14
Why post it on here, said someone else. I'd have said, mind your own business, and I wouldn't have recognised you either
1:44:19
So there's a couple of people taking a day off from Idiot's Corner
1:44:24
to start trolling Martin Lewis on social media instead. But there are two elements to this conversation
1:44:29
that I want you to help me with. The first is, what's going on in the minds of those people
1:44:37
Because it's far from rare now. sheila got onto this um horse long before i did it bugging she because i often have my headphones
1:44:45
on when i'm on public transport you see i'm often listening to improving music um i'm definitely
1:44:51
not listening to my own podcasts but uh i i think that might be part of the reason why it took me a while to wake up to how commonplace this is I there in my bozes jiving away And yet it is really common
1:45:06
I would say, what, three or four times a week, if you travel quite a lot by public transport like I do
1:45:10
So I get the tube and a bus every day. And I would say three or four times a week, particularly on the bus
1:45:17
I don't always have my headphones on on the way home. You find yourself thinking, what are you doing
1:45:22
What are you actually doing? How have you ended up in a space where you are not..
1:45:28
You're not... You're kind of... What are you? You're almost detached from polite society
1:45:34
It's a crowded train. And at no point in this process, in a couple
1:45:40
have either of you gone, maybe we should turn it down or maybe we should..
1:45:45
Even if it's not unpleasant content, I don't... People don't want to hear... I just..
1:45:49
I'm not a prude and I'm no Mary Whitehouse. and I often find that I can find some elements of social conformity
1:45:58
even vaguely fascistic. You know, when David Cameron tells Jeremy Corbyn to put a tie on and stuff like that
1:46:04
I just think, oh, jog on, you plum. But there is some behaviour, because it doesn't affect anybody else if I'm not wearing a tie
1:46:10
It doesn't affect anybody else if Jeremy Corbyn hasn't polished his shoes or whatever it is
1:46:14
So I get that side of it and I dismiss that out of hand
1:46:18
This is entirely different. This is inflicting something on other people who obviously don't want to have it inflicted on them
1:46:28
And just... I suppose I'm asking, do they think to themselves this is going to annoy other people and I don't care
1:46:36
Or do they not even think to themselves this is going to..
1:46:41
I mean, I don't know what's worse. This is going to annoy other people and I don't care
1:46:46
or it somehow doesn't even occur to them that they're doing something obnoxious
1:46:54
that they're doing something intrusive and that they're doing something that's wrong. And that's what I want you to tell me
1:46:59
What is going on in the minds of these people? 03456060973 and what happened to you
1:47:07
when you did what Martin Lewis did and you thought, you know what
1:47:12
I'm actually, I'm not, because it's an hour until the next stop. I'm not sitting here for another hour listening to somebody else's serial killer documentary
1:47:20
And I don't think it needs to involve material that is unpleasant or inappropriate
1:47:27
It's the obnoxiousness of the imposition that I find absolutely fascinating. What's happened
1:47:34
How do you explain this? And what happened when you sought, in your own way, to address it
1:47:41
And I'll tell you what as well. I'm not in the mood for a scrap at the moment
1:47:45
I don't know why. Hopefully I'll grow out of it, but I'm feeling so mellow about it
1:47:49
It's probably all the yoga that I'm doing and my incredibly wholesome algorithm, which I must tell you more about my incredibly wholesome algorithm in a minute
1:47:56
because it's a great corrective to some of the stuff we were just hearing about phones and social media
1:48:02
But the simple idea, really, that you are going to sit there and impose it on somebody else
1:48:11
is just beyond my ken, utterly beyond my ken. Is it beyond yours
1:48:16
The reason I mention that I don't want a scrap is because maybe you think this is fine
1:48:20
like genuinely, and you don't think you are obnoxious, and you certainly don't think you belong in Idiot's Corner
1:48:24
but you just think that I'm sounding out of touch, old. Because I'll tell you for a fact
1:48:29
that Martin will have meant that when he wrote it. Am I out of kilter here? Is it, am I, are we the baddies
1:48:35
Am I? He will have genuinely felt that. And I don't think he is
1:48:40
but if you do, if you think it's none of my business, how dare you tell me what I can and can't listen to
1:48:45
at full volume on public transport then I just want to have a chat
1:48:49
with you, I don't want to have a scrap and you have to be telling the truth it has to be in absolutely good faith
1:48:54
what on earth are you thinking when you conclude that you can do this, that you should do this
1:49:01
and that anybody who's objecting to you doing this is actually the problem phone lines are open, 03456060973
1:49:08
is the number you need James O'Brien on LBC Two more elements to this, all right
1:49:13
Number one, what if my switchboard and inbox now are humming at such a rate
1:49:20
that you begin to think, well, maybe we are the baddies. Maybe, I mean, not, so everyone getting in touch to say how obnoxious they find it
1:49:26
but so many people experiencing it that at some point the balance shifts
1:49:31
Does it or not? It doesn't, does it? It never shifts. Even if I'm the only person, even if there are 99 people on this train
1:49:38
listening to their devices at full volume and I'm sitting there getting cross. I'm still in the right
1:49:43
It's just obnoxious behaviour. That's question number two. Sorry, that's point number one
1:49:50
Point number two, who does it remind you of, like in other areas
1:49:54
Because I love this. Option three is that they know that it annoys people
1:49:58
and that's why they do it. I often think about this with people... You know when you split the bill at the end of a meal
1:50:04
and some people come out at an enormous profit and it's really unfair
1:50:13
So normally, if everyone's had more or less the same, then you would split the bill and everyone would be happy
1:50:19
No one ever really objects to that. But I remember, not long after leaving college
1:50:25
we went out for a shared meal and there was a young woman there
1:50:30
who literally only had a starter and drank water. And this bloke was saying, we must all share the bill
1:50:36
And I did actually speak up on that occasion. I said, well, you can't expect her to pay the same as what you've paid
1:50:41
You've had about a bottle and a half of wine, mate. And there's another occasion that happened
1:50:46
I can't remember once when I was with my wife. And we said on the way home, do they go home now and sort of high-five each other
1:50:54
This is a great mystery to me. This is why I love the suggestion that they know they're being obnoxious
1:50:58
And that's part of the pleasure for them. So if you go out and you're too polite
1:51:02
say, well, I don't think we should split the bill. You had the oysters, Nigel. I just had a starter and a glass of fizzy waters
1:51:10
We're splitting the bill. It's not one. Do they then go home and go
1:51:15
we are 73 pounds up on that. We ate and drank 73 pounds more food and drink
1:51:24
than we actually paid for. Or do they just not know? I find it hard to believe that they don't know
1:51:30
that they're being obnoxious, but that's partly down to my nature, in that I kind of always want to believe the best of people
1:51:38
They're sitting there with their phone on full, with a screen on full, watching something, whether it's inappropriate or not
1:51:44
and they have absolutely no idea that they're doing something wrong, feasible or not
1:51:49
I don't know. 22 after 12. Matt's in Orpington. Matt, what do you reckon? Hi, James. How are you doing
1:51:54
Very well indeed. What made you pick up the phone? So I was telling your producer just now that I do challenge it almost every time
1:52:02
Crikey. I know. But in a very, very low-key, very non-defensive, calm way
1:52:10
And I travel a lot internationally, so I collect the really low-budget headphones you get in economy
1:52:15
I have lots of them. I've actually thought about doing this. Yeah
1:52:19
Because it's my way of saying, look, you can do what you want, and I can do what I want
1:52:24
and he can do what she We can all do what we want but at the same time really respect each other in a public place And what kind of reactions do you get So you do it a lot a lot a lot I mean to a point
1:52:35
of it being a bit weird, if we're honest. Yeah, my boyfriend, if he
1:52:39
hears somebody doing it, he's like, oh God, here we go. I've got sympathy for both
1:52:45
of you. I kind of, part of me thinks, yes, finally, we've got a crusader
1:52:49
And then I'm thinking, no, actually, I'm glad he's not my boyfriend
1:52:52
we were in montenegro a couple of weeks ago we went out for dinner um and a young boy about nine
1:53:01
or ten came and sat two tables next to us the restaurant was empty and he sat there he put his
1:53:06
phone in front of him and i thought oh please there we go yeah and he played a tv show at full volume
1:53:12
so i very politely went over and said here's some headphones and his english was amazing and i said
1:53:18
to him wow your english is incredible and he was like oh thank you i get that a lot and i said you
1:53:22
Just please be respectful, pop the headphones in, and then you're in a restaurant, like you're in a public place
1:53:27
and people are coming to eat. And he said, they don't fit, it's a USB-C
1:53:31
and you've got a headphone jack, but I'll turn it down. So he took the message
1:53:35
He got a letter? No, no, no, no, no, no, no. He turned it down, and then very slowly, incrementally
1:53:40
and I could see my boyfriend getting more and more frustrated. And I said to the waiter, please can you ask him to switch it off
1:53:45
Not down, but off. Yes. And eventually we moved and we left
1:53:50
Really? Yeah. And what about your answer to the question? Because that's quite an interesting example
1:53:56
He's lost to us, that one. That's a new generation. I don't know if we can ever tempt them back to the light
1:54:03
But do you find or do you think, given what you do on a regular basis
1:54:08
that people are surprised to realise that they're getting on people's nerves
1:54:12
I don't know if this is the right question, but it's the one that intrigues me the most, the distinction between being deliberately
1:54:18
and accidentally obnoxious. I'm going to go on a little tangent here
1:54:22
but bear with me I'm sure you watched Boris Johnson in the committee
1:54:26
where he was hauled over the coals and there were moments when he
1:54:31
and some of it I thought oh maybe he's actually been telling the truth here
1:54:35
but there were moments when he had that wry smile of oh god I've been busted
1:54:39
there's a name for it I think it's called the something smirk
1:54:43
or the liar's smirk or something like that Liz Truss has got it as well yeah yeah absolutely
1:54:48
So some people know, some people don't. Some people know and don't care
1:54:53
Some people know, and when you call them out on it, some adults I say to them, I teach children
1:54:58
and I ask my children not to do this, and I explain why. Like, in your bedroom, fill your boots
1:55:03
But when you're in a public space, it is public. Respect everybody
1:55:07
And children always say the same thing to me. Adults do it
1:55:11
And when I tell adults this, sometimes they go, oh, yeah, oh, dear
1:55:16
We'll stop it as well. Have you had any unpleasant encounters? No, not really
1:55:20
I'm way too polite. I'm never going to... I would never engage anybody in a really aggressive way
1:55:25
because I don't know them. They don't know me. I don't know their story. They could be having a terrible day
1:55:30
Of course, but have you ever been told to do one? Oh, yeah. But you just crack on anyway
1:55:35
You've just taken it upon yourself to make this small difference. It's the..
1:55:39
Listen, it's the slippery moral slide. Is it? Nobody says anything. Everybody knows they shouldn't
1:55:46
Nobody says anything. that everybody knows they shouldn't, but people are just too frightened to say
1:55:52
And you can speak up. I often think, what would I do if I was on a busy tube or a busy train
1:55:57
and somebody was getting racially or sexually harassed? What would I do
1:56:01
And what I might do is go over to that person. In fact, I did it once in Orpington High Street
1:56:06
There was a woman walking down the street and there was this guy talking to her and clearly she did not know him
1:56:11
And he kept asking her questions and she was very politely batting him off
1:56:15
And then he said to her, sister are you married? She was like
1:56:19
what? And I went over and I was like hey Doreen, how you doing? That's the advice, that's what you're supposed to do
1:56:24
isn't it? That's what you're supposed to do And sorry, excuse me, it's interesting that you
1:56:30
put them in the same category in that one, again you know, if you asked him or if you got him on a
1:56:37
psychiatrist's couch, you'd probably argue that he wasn't being obnoxious or that he wasn't doing anything that invited
1:56:43
your intervention, but I see them as being similar i think they i think there was something there that invited your intervention
1:56:48
it's called duper's delight mark that's the thing apparently the phrase that i was i was looking for
1:56:53
duper's delight and he's right you did see it all the time with boris johnson in that
1:56:57
you think back to the things that his there you think back to that letter that his teacher wrote
1:57:03
to his dad back in the day and it talks about how he seems to believe that the network of
1:57:07
obligations he is he is separate from or immune to the network of obligations that bind us all
1:57:13
and that's why I find this subject so fascinating because when you are essentially
1:57:19
imposing your behaviour upon everybody in a closed space you are actually behaving in a way that suggests
1:57:27
you don't think the network of obligations that binds everybody else should apply to you
1:57:31
and that's the thing that interests me most the question of whether or not they know that they're doing it
1:57:36
or whether or not they are utterly surprised to discover that it has got on somebody's nerves
1:57:42
because there are so few Matts in the world. So few people are actually going to step up
1:57:46
and do anything about it. So I want more examples of both. Actually, Matt, are you still there
1:57:51
Why do you think it's exploded? I think it's exploded. I think it's exploded for a really simple reason
1:58:00
Number one, we literally have speakers on our phones now. We all have
1:58:04
Yeah, so it would have happened at any point in the past if the proliferation of the speakers had been
1:58:10
Absolutely. I listen to you every day, by the way. I think you're amazing, and thank you for your voice
1:58:15
That's very kind. Thank you. Thank you so much. You keep my sanity
1:58:19
Well, your boyfriend probably disagrees with that conclusion. It's coming up. He loves you too
1:58:27
If we're both home between 10 and 1, it's James O'Brien. Oh, that's lovely to hear. Thank you
1:58:31
Thank you very much. You're welcome. Thank you. And keep it up. It's half past 12
1:58:37
That's the thing, isn't it? The social change. It can't just be the speakers, because most of us know that that's not acceptable behaviour
1:58:47
And yet a significant number of people, an ever-growing number of people, either don't care about it being unacceptable, or don't actually realise that it's unacceptable
1:58:56
It's coming up to half past twelve. Matt Hewitt has your headlines. James O'Brien on LBC
1:59:01
I suppose the best people, the most qualified people to comment on whether we're looking at some sort of significant social decline here
1:59:09
are in fact the people who make a point of challenging it. So I don't know what to make of a 10-year-old boy in Montenegro
1:59:16
who is asked to turn down the volume on the thing that he's watching in a public carriage and agrees
1:59:21
and then slowly turns it up again. It feels like that battle might be lost
1:59:27
It was a restaurant. Was it a restaurant or a restaurant car on a train? I think it was a restaurant car on a train
1:59:33
But either way, it's a public space and other people are there to enjoy themselves
1:59:38
and they would not expect to be listening to whatever nonsense you're watching on your screen in doing so
1:59:44
The psychological, what has happened here? And it's funny that the last caller mentioned Boris Johnson
1:59:50
and that I observed when Andy Hughes was in the studio how mad it is that we live in a world where the President of the United States
1:59:57
can say something about us. And the chances are it's not true
2:00:03
The chances are it's simply not true. And it's mad on a whole heap of levels
2:00:07
because, number one, he didn't have to say anything. Number two, he doesn't really gain much by saying it
2:00:14
The people that were arrested at RAF Fairford at the weekend were apparently known to him
2:00:18
and he knew exactly what was going on, but presumably didn't know
2:00:22
that they were going to be bailed 24 hours later because there was absolutely no evidence
2:00:26
to link them in the first instance to any of the crimes that he somehow knew were likely to be committed
2:00:31
So you see what I mean. Is that like, I mean, am I reading too much into it
2:00:37
Are we just seeing the street-level equivalent of delinquency at the highest levels of politics
2:00:44
Prime Ministers and Presidents behaving with complete contempt for rules? And you're not even consciously going, well, why should I obey them anyway
2:00:52
You're just not aware that rules matter anymore because the people at the very top of societies
2:00:56
treat them with utter contempt. I like that, but I'd rather hear your answer to the question
2:01:01
of what you think has changed. It's not just the technology. Something else has changed as well
2:01:06
We had transistor radios. You would never get on a bus or a tube train
2:01:11
or a ghetto blaster. I mean, if you did it with a ghetto blaster, you knew you were being obnoxious
2:01:16
You know, if you were Breakdance 2 electric boogaloo, you knew that other people didn't want to hear that
2:01:24
and you were young and dangerous so you didn't care but a middle-aged couple watching films on a train
2:01:30
and then asked to turn the noise down they think that they're somehow being victimised
2:01:33
something's changed there I want you to tell me what it is Leroy's in Ryslip
2:01:37
Leroy, what would you like to say? Hi there, it's funny what you just said
2:01:41
I've been saying that for a long time that kids, I work with kids which bit? about politicians, their level
2:01:47
oh really? And it filters down to the kids, whether they read the newspapers or whatever
2:01:53
It filters down. And they hear that Boris Johnson got away with this, that, and the other said, don't do this with COVID
2:01:57
but yet he's done it. It all filters down. I've seen that happen over the years that I've been doing this
2:02:03
Fascinating. And it's subconscious, really, because it just essentially chips away at the rules
2:02:08
I'll find, while you tell me why you rang in, I'll find that quote from the teacher to his dad
2:02:13
about what his attitude was, and I think it will resonate with you. But go on, Leroy
2:02:16
Yeah, I've done it more times than I can count, to be honest with you
2:02:24
I'm 57 years of age. I ask exceptionally politely. I make sure that my eyebrows are raised
2:02:31
I say it in a very nice tone. I've never had a bad response
2:02:35
It's always been taken well. What I will add to that is that I am an ex-boxer
2:02:40
and I do still try and look after myself. But that, I mean, that shouldn't
2:02:45
I mean, I suppose that means that if someone was minded to be really obnoxious
2:02:49
they're going to have a second thought because if they kick off, you look like you can look after yourself
2:02:54
But I think your politeness is probably more relevant than your physique in these moments
2:02:58
I agree and I make sure I overcompensate for that reason because I don't want anyone to say
2:03:02
oh, I was intimidated. I'm not, I'm not intimidating you at all
2:03:06
I'm not asking you what I was saying if I was a different shape. And what do you think is going on
2:03:11
I think that people are being left to not... No one's questioning anyone anymore
2:03:18
People are scared. So no one's going to pull anyone up. And the more you get away with something
2:03:22
the more you think it's normal and you'll do it. And so they are conscious on some level
2:03:26
that what they're doing is wrong. I believe so, yeah. You can't..
2:03:29
I mean, you'd have to be off the scale, wouldn't you really? I don't know
2:03:33
That's why this is the bit of the conversation that intrigues me the most, is that you must notice that not everybody else is doing it, right
2:03:40
And that's the point at which you go, well, I probably shouldn't be either. Not if no-one's complaining, though
2:03:46
Not if no-one's complaining. You say, well, most of us aren't like that, are we? Most of us are..
2:03:51
We're herd animals, Leroy. We're going to sort of not follow the herd off a cliff necessarily
2:03:56
but if, you know, you find... I was sort of... You know, when Del Boy and Rodney turned up at that party in fancy dress
2:04:02
and nobody else was in fancy dress, they noticed, right? They noticed that nobody else was in fancy dress
2:04:07
How can the people with the film at full volume not notice that nobody else has got the film at full volume
2:04:14
They do notice, but they're just not bothered, because unless someone's going to pull them on it
2:04:18
then why should I bother? I'm going to live in my world. This is my bubble
2:04:23
This is my day. And they turn it down when you ask them to? I've never had anyone not do it
2:04:28
With an acknowledgement that what they would do, it's like an apology. Oh, sorry, mate
2:04:32
Yeah, I didn't... Varying. Some people have just done it. Other people have said
2:04:38
Oh, sorry, I didn't realise. I didn't realise. It is just weird. But I think you're probably right. Here you go
2:04:43
This is what Johnson's teacher wrote to his dad. I love this line, because it
2:04:49
sums up what you described at the bit, what you chimed in with at the beginning. I think he honestly
2:04:53
believes that it is churlish of us not to regard him as an exception
2:04:58
One who should be free of the network of obligation that binds everyone else
2:05:03
And you're here to uphold that network of obligation. Absolutely. Absolutely. Well that says bundles, doesn't it? And that's going back some
2:05:11
Yeah, no, that's going right back. Yeah, this isn't just down to technology changing, but technology changing has exacerbated that
2:05:17
without a doubt. People are all over it now. They've just got their, you know, all over
2:05:20
it. Just get a pair of headphones, man. I know, I know. It should be fairly straightforward. And if people are, I mean that whole thing
2:05:26
there unless you got someone like Leroy on the case the network of obligations ceases to bind everyone else because some ponds breached it And I don know whether this is contagious behaviour or not
2:05:37
It seems unlikely, but other behaviours are. There's a little bit. I wonder, is there a little bit of the zero tolerance theory here
2:05:44
The broken window theory. I think it's actually been challenged subsequently as not being quite the panacea that everybody thought it was
2:05:52
But the idea that if there's a broken window in your environs, then there is more likely to be some graffiti there tomorrow
2:06:01
And if there's a broken window and some graffiti in your environs, then there's more likely to be some street crime there next week
2:06:07
And if there is a broken window and some graffiti and a risk of street crime in your area, then somehow everything is moving in the wrong direction
2:06:16
Everything is declining. I think this is a broken window, this kind of behaviour
2:06:20
and I think more of us should do something about it. But I can't because I'm really famous
2:06:25
So I get a massive... Obviously, I'm not. If there's mine, Lewis wasn't recognised on the train
2:06:31
and there's absolutely no danger of me being clocked. Stuart's in Milton Keynes
2:06:35
Stuart, what would you like to say? Yeah, hi, James. Hello, mate. Great show
2:06:39
I listen to you a lot. Good morning. I got it. Someone on the train said to me yesterday, Stuart
2:06:44
as soon as you've raised that side, you're very kind. And I had my headphones on and she tapped me on the shoulder
2:06:48
so I took my headphones off and I said, Yes, hello. And she said, can I just say that I listen to your radio show sometimes
2:06:55
and I quite enjoy it. And I thought that's a very odd thing to interrupt my morning for
2:07:01
I listen to your radio show sometimes and I quite enjoy it. It's not the nature of these interactions normally
2:07:07
It's a little bit more excitable. But anyway, here we are. Go on, what made you pick up the phone
2:07:12
Yeah, so I was in a restaurant with a friend a few years ago
2:07:16
And the restaurant was empty, really. It was just me and my friend, and there was a table a bit further away with maybe five people
2:07:24
and they were having a birthday celebration. Well, it was so loud, the way they were shouting and screaming
2:07:32
This would have driven Eleanor absolutely bonkers, the producer of this programme
2:07:37
Well, we couldn't talk, literally. We had to wait to die down a bit before we could say what everyone wanted to say
2:07:42
Absolutely ruined our evening. I asked the waiter a few times to go and ask them to quieten down
2:07:49
or could you move them or move, whatever, and it just never happened
2:07:53
When we finished our meal, I went over there very nicely. I said, you know, I think you have really ruined our evening
2:08:01
because the noise was just too much. And the girl or the woman whose party it was said
2:08:08
that is my birthday. And I said, yeah. That's entitlement, entitlement. Entitlement, exactly, entitlement
2:08:15
But I believe somebody like that would do that most of the time
2:08:19
not just on her birthday. And we argued for a long time in a very nice way
2:08:23
So you ruined her birthday. Well, yes, it's like the old idea, you know
2:08:30
when somebody used to smoke in a restaurant and you said, please stop because you're affecting my enjoyment
2:08:35
They would say, you're affecting my enjoyment by telling me to stop. Yeah, that's a really good point
2:08:40
And it is, isn't it? It's a personality type, but it is a lot more prevalent now than it was five years ago, right
2:08:45
Yeah, but I mean, there used to be headphones. What happened to earbuds and headphones? I don't know
2:08:49
You had a caller who said he hands them out, which I think is a really good idea. You've got really cheap ones
2:08:55
But I do think that... They're not going to work. I mean, most people, some things these days
2:09:01
they don't even have jacks for them. But it creates the conversation, doesn't it? It starts the conversation
2:09:05
and it pushes the onus of responsibility onto the person doing it
2:09:09
But I mean, yeah, I don't know that we can nail this down
2:09:13
I like that story. And the whole business of intervening is so fraught
2:09:17
Some people find it incredibly easy, which is why everyone we've spoken to does it regularly
2:09:23
And some people find it almost impossible. I'm in the second category. I'm quite introverted when I'm out and about
2:09:29
It's fine when I've got a sort of light shining on me or a camera pointing at me
2:09:33
But when I'm out and about, or if I'm on a stage or something, but if I'm out and about, I'm quite a head-down kind of character
2:09:38
and I sort of wait for... There's been a couple of occasions where you've sort of thought..
2:09:44
I hate it when young people, or children as we sometimes call them
2:09:48
are being rude to bus drivers. I don't know why, I've got a real issue with that
2:09:53
So on a couple of occasions I've just sort of stood up
2:09:56
and gone to sort of loom in the vicinity of the bus driver. What are you waiting for the next stop to come
2:10:03
and them to get off or something like that? I don't know what I'm achieving in those moments. I'm not achieving anything
2:10:08
I don't think I said anything, didn't say anything last time. I just don't, I hate that
2:10:12
I'll tell you what I was doing. I was just trying to reassure the bus driver
2:10:17
I'm not going to intervene with the young person. I don't know why. Maybe I should
2:10:22
But I just didn't want the bus driver to think that everybody on the bus was completely ignoring
2:10:25
what a terrible time he was having. So I just wanted him to know that I knew he was having a terrible time
2:10:30
But I wasn't prepared or built in a way that meant I was going to do anything
2:10:33
to stop him from having a terrible time. I suppose partly because you don't want to become the focus of the negativity yourself
2:10:39
But that's much more obnoxious behaviour than just shouting your head off in a restaurant
2:10:45
or indeed having a device at volume 11, volume 12. 12.46 is the time
2:10:51
James O'Brien on LBC. It's 49 minutes after 12, or 10 to 1 in old money
2:10:57
And I promised I do this yesterday and I completely forgot I know what you thinking that not like you James it doesn matter how much you do because really what these algorithms do is um respond to what
2:11:09
you like I've told you a few times and and he's not with us anymore so he hasn't been around to
2:11:14
witness how right he was but but a pal of mine who worked in marketing very high up in marketing
2:11:21
and our daughters were but the same age that's how we became friends and he was obviously very
2:11:28
very aware of all the emerging platforms and going back quite a few years now he phoned me up he didn't
2:11:34
phone me very often you know sort of look forward to seeing each other at events and things like that
2:11:38
but it was quite a bit you know it'd be a bit look at my phone and go crikey why is he ringing me
2:11:42
so i answered it and he just said i'd need to tell you about tiktok i said pardon he said i need to
2:11:50
tell you about tiktok i said i don't really like i've got busy enough on twitter mate i can't be
2:11:55
doing with the new... No, he goes, not that. He says, it's just unbelievable. He said, I just had a look
2:12:00
at it, and two hours have gone. I said, what do you mean you just had a... I just had a look at it
2:12:07
I started watching things, and by the end of two hours, which I thought was two minutes
2:12:12
it's sending me stuff I really like. It has somehow read my mind. And remember, he was a
2:12:18
very high-up marketing dude, and he could not believe... And this is probably 10 years ago
2:12:23
this technology? And he just couldn't believe, and I didn't really understand what he was telling me
2:12:28
I think of him often when these conversations come around because he just could tell right then
2:12:35
because of what he knew about psychology and marketing and branding, all of those things
2:12:41
Lad was a genius. And he just knew, he said, this is absolutely crackers. And here we are
2:12:49
So I'm going to give you some advice on a wholesome algorithm, but it doesn't really
2:12:52
matter because if you're watching filth it's going to send you more and more filth so my algorithm
2:12:57
i've told you the stages of my algorithm over the last few years while everybody else has been
2:13:01
falling down fascist rabbit holes or um uh watching hideous ai created pornography or whatever it
2:13:09
might be it my my algorithm this is so lovely because it means this is actually the stuff that
2:13:14
i like has involved ping pong as in literally table tennis and particularly a shot called the
2:13:22
snake it has involved american military personnel it's always the same song playing in the background
2:13:29
coming back unexpectedly to surprise their families some of which i think have been faked
2:13:34
for clicks and i went through a long phase of really enjoying people trying to catch thieves
2:13:39
by leaving parcels on their doorsteps with a camera running so that when the thief came up
2:13:44
and then the parcel would explode and cover them in purple powder or something like that
2:13:48
I went off those because I think they were faked as well. So that kind of thing
2:13:52
But now on my Facebook, I've chosen to follow things. So here's some advice on how to cleanse your timeline
2:14:00
If you can't get off it entirely, and you find things that I find interesting
2:14:05
even vaguely interesting, here's how you cleanse your timeline. I was making a donation to the RNLI the other day
2:14:13
and therefore my Facebook started sending me RNLI-related content. one of which was just an account
2:14:21
that just literally posts pictures of RNLI stations up and down the country
2:14:26
Oh, man, I could lose an afternoon enjoying that. And probably because I enjoyed that so much
2:14:32
I then got sent an invitation to join a group dedicated to disused railways
2:14:37
Don't Alan Partridge me. This is how you cleanse your timeline, all right
2:14:41
Disused railway stations. So some people are watching violence and fascism. I'm watching pictures of disused railway stations
2:14:49
and RNLI stations. There's a theme there. I think that's probably why the second one got suggested
2:14:53
after the first one had happened. And it does, it does cleanse your timeline
2:14:58
The other thing I discovered that was... Have you ever heard of the three bridges in Hanwell
2:15:03
So Isambard Kingdom Brunel, of whom I'm an enormous fan, I also am a member of an Isambard Kingdom Brunel Appreciation Society
2:15:10
If you join things like this, I reckon you can get all the fascists off your Facebook
2:15:14
look, go and fiddle with your granddad's laptop and sign him up for stuff that he'd like
2:15:21
and start pressing close on all of the stuff about migrants and small boats
2:15:26
So three bridges in Hamwell, incredible. Technically, there's not three bridges. Did I tell you about this the other day
2:15:31
I didn't get around to it, did I? So there's this thing, it stuck the road from me near Ealing
2:15:37
It's a railway that Brunel built that went all the way to Brentford Docks
2:15:42
It's disused now, So that could come up on two of my feeds, bridges and disused railways
2:15:46
So it's disused now. I'm living the dream. But there was a c
2:15:52
So there's a railway line, right? And there's a c going over it in a mini aqueduct
2:15:58
like a metal trough that Brunel designed. And then there's a road bridge that goes over the top
2:16:04
If you position yourself correctly, you can see the railway line, the c and the road all in one frame
2:16:10
Three bridges, one junction. tell me that's not magic, that's the kind of thing you want on your Facebook, that's the kind of thing you want in your algorithm
2:16:17
not all the nastiness so that's the end of my TED talk, disused railways and stations
2:16:23
triple bridges and sundry other architectural feats or engineering feats to be precise Thomas Telford vs Isambard Kingdom Brunel should we do that one day as a phone Who was the greatest Telford or Brunel No all right So I need to look at me like that
2:16:42
And, and of course, very topical, the lifeboat stuff. So there it is. Back to the phone-in about
2:16:47
what's changed in society, which means that people will now do things that we would never
2:16:52
have considered doing. Chris is in Blackpool. Chris, what would you like to say? Good day, sir
2:16:57
So firstly, I've travelled a lot on the trains and I always used to book the quiet carriage
2:17:03
because I wanted to work or read. I stopped doing that because I got so fed up
2:17:09
of having arguments with people who would bring children in there or play music
2:17:15
or just sit there talking on the phone. They don't know what it means, I don't think, quiet carriage
2:17:22
I don't think they know what it means. No, and even when you point to the signs
2:17:26
or you ask them politely or you suggest, they have no interest
2:17:32
They absolutely have no interest. Was that not always true? Were you not a little bit feisty when you were a kid
2:17:39
An adult tells you, if you're being naughty and an adult tells you what to do, you would never..
2:17:44
I mean, children are a bit different from adults, I think, in these conversations
2:17:49
So it leads me on to my most recent experience, whereby I was walking through Blackpool Town Centre
2:17:56
I'd just been to the opticians and there was, it was a lot of people and there was two children running around a bench and they were trying to kick pigeons and seagulls
2:18:06
They were trying their best to kick them. And as I was walking up to them, I was watching them and they got very, very close
2:18:13
And I kind of stopped and just said, excuse me. One was about five, one was about nine
2:18:18
And I said, excuse me. I said, it's not good to kick animals. You know, be kind to animals
2:18:24
They carried on doing it. they paid no attention whatsoever. So I kind of said, whose children are these
2:18:28
Does anybody own these children? And this guy was sat feeding a baby on the bench
2:18:32
and he said, they're my children. What the F do you want to know about it
2:18:35
And I said, well, you know, maybe teach them not to kick animals
2:18:40
because, you know, we all know that children that bully animals grow up to be a bit weird
2:18:45
He was absolutely just aggressive. He threatened to break my leg. Yeah
2:18:51
I mean, I... I mean, you're in the right, obviously, but you kind of told him his kids were going to grow up to be serial killers
2:19:00
Well, and the point was... I wouldn't open with it. He absolutely just didn't see an issue in rowing with me
2:19:08
rather than telling them. No. So they were doing that in front of him
2:19:12
Now, my point is, he was probably 35. He was a big fella, I'm not
2:19:17
My point is that the generation is growing up younger and younger children
2:19:22
where it's just acceptable. Pass it on so it gets worse. So what happens next
2:19:26
What do the children of the people on the screens with the volume on full
2:19:31
what do they do on public transport? Well, exactly. They'll go even further
2:19:36
And eventually, they'll be in the majority, and you, me, and Sheila will be in the minority
2:19:40
So we will become the baddies. And if you dare to say, please turn that down
2:19:45
they'll be like the whole carriage will go, get lost, Sheila Fogarty. We like our volumes high
2:19:49
I think it's already happened. Do you really think? So does Eleanor. The pendulum has swung
2:19:53
It's already swung. The tipping point has been passed. The battle has been lost. I'm not going to stop
2:19:58
No, nor are some of my callers today. Although I would draw the line
2:20:02
at accusing people's children of being potential serial killers. I suppose it's true of all children
2:20:07
I involuntarily shamed someone off a train the other day. Well, they got off
2:20:11
They got off with shame. How did you know they weren't going to get off? Oh, they weren't going to get off. Go on, tell me what happened
2:20:15
This guy, tall, young, sort of 28, 30, suited and booted quite posh
2:20:23
very deep sort of baritone very loud voice on the phone I think he was a civil servant
2:20:28
and his bosses need to have a look at him because I think they signed the official secrets act he was saying things out loud
2:20:32
he definitely should have been and he got louder and louder and louder he was standing right near me
2:20:37
and I just on a relatively empty train and I actually involuntarily almost
2:20:42
in fact it was involuntary I just said I won't say it
2:20:46
because it's blaspheming but I did say to his face, as if to say, what the jiggery
2:20:53
And he looked horrified and got off. Because he clocked the fact that he'd been not only obnoxious
2:20:57
but also indiscreet, and possibly in breach of the official secret. Possibly, yeah. Possibly
2:21:02
Can you still get hanged for that? I don't think that's a wooden cow. What, for bullying people on trains
2:21:06
For treachery. For treachery. High treason, I'm sure. Julie's been in touch after my very, I found, powerful conversation
2:21:14
about disused railways. Sue, I beg your pardon, not jury. Julie. Sue's been in touch
2:21:20
Just suggesting I might want to follow a group dedicated to old garage
2:21:24
forecourts. That's just weird. Anyway, that's it from me for today. If you missed any of the show, you can listen
2:21:30
back on Catch Up on our free Global Player app or the LBC app, where you can also stay up to date
2:21:34
with all the latest news, videos and opinions. You can listen to a range of podcasts, including
2:21:38
James O'Brien Daily, best bits from my LBC show every day. There's a YouTube channel now as well for full
2:21:44
disclosure. I've been meaning to tell you about it. It's just hit a million views. It's only been up for 80 days
2:21:49
That's extraordinary. Thank you very much. So do download the official LBC app for free from your app store now
2:21:54
Coming up at four on LBC, it's Tom Swarbrick. But now it's time for Sheila Fogarty. I give you a round of applause
2:21:59
It's not even Thursday. That's very kind of you, too. It's not even Thursday. Thanks, James. Have a lovely afternoon
2:22:03
You too. James O'Brien on LBC
news


