NAVAL COMBAT (Remastered) – High Seas, Low Rolls, and Kraken Problems – RPGBOT.Podcast S5E14
Jun 25, 2026
Set sail with this remastered episode of the RPGBOT.Podcast as we navigate the stormy seas of naval combat rules, patch the holes in D&D and Pathfinder mechanics, and pray the kraken doesn’t TPK the party!
This episode originally aired on January 31st, 2025, and we're currently working to upload our episode backlog. For the latest from the RPGBOT.Podcast, find us in your favorite podcatcher.
Full show notes for this episode are available on RPGBOT.net: https://rpgbot.net/naval-combat-remastered-high-seas-low-rolls-and-kraken-problems-rpgbot-podcast-s5e14/
Find us on socials and stuff:
🦋 https://bsky.app/profile/rpgbot.bsky.social
⏰ https://www.tiktok.com/@rpgbotdotnet
🔍 https://RPGBOT.net/
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:23
Welcome to the RPGbot dot podcast. I'm
0:25
Randall James, your carnivorous cockway
0:26
and with me is Tyler Camstra.
0:28
>> Hi everybody. and Ashi.
0:31
>> Yeah. Hail and well met, babies.
0:34
>> All right. All right, Tyler. What What
0:36
is happening?
0:37
>> Tonight, we are going to talk about
0:40
naval combat. Uh, specifically shipto-
0:42
ship combat, not like two dudes swimming
0:45
in the ocean fighting each other. Pretty
0:47
sure there'd be Marines, right? I don't
0:48
know. I have no idea. They didn't cut
0:50
that.
0:50
>> Me neither.
0:52
Well, so let's talk about some things
0:53
that I that I do know about since I
0:56
spent a bunch of time researching them.
0:57
Not Marines. have not researched that.
0:59
Let's talk about naval combat. Uh so,
1:02
you know, two floating boats in the
1:05
water getting into a fight. It's going
1:06
to be great.
1:08
>> Perfect. And and all right, let's we'll
1:10
get it out right up front. Some of the
1:12
naval combat isn't going to happen in
1:14
the water. You're going to have a good
1:15
time with it. Just bear with us.
1:18
>> Wait until we talk about land ships.
1:19
It's going to be amazing.
1:21
>> Oh, yes. So many ships.
1:23
>> All right. So, uh, so before we, uh,
1:25
start looking at what's out there
1:26
already. So, let's talk about like
1:28
basically what we expect from naval
1:31
combat in our tabletop RPGs, very basic
1:35
table stakes. We would like to be on a
1:37
ship and we would like to be fighting
1:40
another ship. What are some things that
1:41
you guys want to see in naval combat? I
1:44
want I want mechanics for piracy.
1:46
>> Okay. Right. Like as a as a DM or GM, I
1:49
want a table where like, you know, I can
1:51
roll to find out what kind of booty I'm
1:52
going to get if I'm able to take over
1:54
the ship and like when have I come and
1:56
dear a ship versus I'm just intruding
1:58
and they would like me to leave kindly.
2:03
>> When is your ship my ship? That's what I
2:06
want the answer to.
2:07
>> I say you villain, get off my ship. You
2:10
are trespassing and I don't appreciate
2:13
it.
2:14
>> This is my ship, good sir.
2:16
I don't know what voice this was. That's
2:18
my iron voice, actually.
2:20
>> All right. So, piracy. So, we want to
2:22
have some ship to- ship violence with
2:24
the potential promise of, you know,
2:26
booty, hostages, salvage, potentially
2:30
just taking the other person's ship.
2:32
Okay.
2:32
>> Privateeers, you know.
2:33
>> Yeah. How about you, Ash? What do you
2:35
want to see in naval combat? I think I
2:37
want to see sort of roles for the ship
2:39
in terms of like, you know, not roles as
2:41
in rolling a D20 or whatever, but roles
2:44
as in like jobs for each of the players
2:46
to sort of take sort of like not just
2:50
one person is the person who's doing the
2:52
actions for the boat, but everybody has
2:53
to contribute to the boat and
2:55
interactions with the crew.
2:57
>> Okay. All right. So, roles for the
2:58
party, crew needs to matter. That's
3:01
cool.
3:01
>> And then I guess I I want to add to
3:02
this, right? Like the crew should matter
3:05
and the boat should also matter.
3:07
>> Yes.
3:07
>> Like if we get into combat or we get
3:09
into a role play, like I I want to make
3:11
meaningful rules to make the boat
3:13
matter. Whether it's getting it in the
3:15
right place to do what I want to do,
3:16
whether it's dealing damage, like we we
3:19
ultimately don't want behold my
3:21
fireballing wizard riding up on the
3:24
front of the ship. You know, the the the
3:26
bow. Is this the bow?
3:27
>> I think I think so.
3:28
>> We're gonna go with yes. So, like, you
3:30
know, it's like the Titanic, he's
3:31
sitting up there, except we're like, you
3:33
know, Jack's not hugging him. He's just
3:34
throwing fireballs at things. That's not
3:36
what I want. I want cannons and I want
3:38
them to blow things up.
3:39
>> Yeah. And in that same vein of ships
3:41
mattering, like different ships should
3:43
do different things, like different
3:44
types of ships. A gallon along should be
3:46
different. And also upgrades to ships,
3:49
like give players ownership over that
3:51
ship and allow them to add features, add
3:54
upgrades. Maybe you add a motor to an
3:56
arcane motor to it and it goes faster.
3:58
Or maybe you add a antimatter laser gun
4:02
to your spell jammer, which would be
4:05
fantastic. I
4:06
>> I love that we've somehow taken like
4:08
what if I took my strongholds and I
4:10
turned it into a mobile home?
4:11
>> That's the dream. I mean, come on. Like
4:13
kind of most of my players in all of the
4:17
games that I've run, their ultimate goal
4:18
is to make an airship because it's just
4:21
a mobile base. I feel like Final Fantasy
4:24
trained us for that though as kids.
4:26
>> Yeah, that's true.
4:27
>> You know how you made it in the world.
4:29
Literally airship.
4:30
>> Yeah, you got an airship.
4:32
>> I know. I have something to aspire to.
4:34
>> Exactly. All right. All right. So, we've
4:36
covered a bunch of cool stuff. We So, we
4:38
don't want wizards to dominate things,
4:41
which Okay, fine. We want the ship to
4:44
matter. We want distinctions between
4:46
different kinds of ships. Yeah, makes
4:47
sense. Personally, I'd like I'd like the
4:50
ships to be a little more simulation-y
4:53
than just here is my ship. It has 400
4:55
hit points. Go. Like, I want to be able
4:58
to board the other guy's ship and like
5:01
rip off the uh the steering wheel, the
5:03
helm. Boy, it's confusing in a game
5:05
where helmets are a thing. Yeah. I want
5:08
to be go over there. I want to rip the
5:09
helm off, throw it over the side, and
5:12
then teleport back to my ship and be
5:14
like, "Cool, mission accomplished." You
5:16
can't do that if it's just a bag of hit
5:17
ones.
5:18
>> Yeah.
5:18
>> No. Or some weird roll of Yeah. Because
5:20
it it makes sense that you have you want
5:22
to damage it, but I can imagine it's
5:24
like, oh, let's just disable it like
5:25
it's a trap. I don't know. Like, no.
5:28
Yeah. I can make a rule and I could
5:29
disable the mechanism. I guess this
5:31
makes sense, but how do you structure
5:32
that? What's fair?
5:33
>> Yeah. And of course, I imagine we all
5:35
want to fight some sea monsters, right?
5:38
>> It's like you do, but you don't.
5:40
>> I I had not considered this. I will
5:43
bring up the last phobia, right? Like if
5:45
if the Kraken actually comes out and the
5:47
Kraken wants to pull the ship down, I
5:49
right. I'm looking for the escape hatch.
5:52
>> Yeah. All right.
5:53
>> As far as that is concerned, I also want
5:56
to see more emphasis on underwater naval
5:59
combat. Like let's let's see more sub
6:03
stuff. I know Eberon exists. I know it's
6:05
possible. I know you can do it.
6:08
>> You know, I don't know if there are
6:10
submarines on Eberon. I don't think so,
6:12
but it would make sense if there were.
6:14
Magitech has reached such a level that
6:16
there's like walking castles. You're
6:19
telling me they don't have submarines?
6:21
Yeah. Moving moving castles. Like it's
6:24
like I believe there's a whole fortress
6:26
that's on like a moving tank. It's
6:27
insane. Magic is out of control in
6:29
Eberon. Give me submarines. There's
6:31
absolutely no. You're telling me there's
6:33
a moving castle built on a tank and
6:35
there's no submarines. I call bull.
6:38
>> Okay. What is a spell jammer but a air
6:41
and vacuum submarine?
6:43
>> No, that's terrible cuz spell jammers
6:45
are are made for the vacuum of space.
6:47
They are literally we talked about this
6:49
in different episode. They are not made
6:52
for high pressure environments. They are
6:54
made for the opposite of high pressure
6:56
environments.
6:56
>> Look, there's a very simple way to
6:58
answer this. Keith Baker is very active
7:00
on social media. We'll just we'll just
7:02
send a message like, "Hey, does everyone
7:04
have subs?" Yes.
7:05
>> And if you say no, you're a coward.
7:08
If he comes back and asks like the
7:10
sandwich or the ship, I'll be happy with
7:12
that answer.
7:12
>> No, that's actually exactly what I was
7:14
saying. Like he's sitting at his table
7:15
slathering mustard. You're like, "Why
7:16
wouldn't they have subs? They're
7:17
delicious."
7:19
>> I mean, ideally, they would have both.
7:23
>> That's fair.
7:24
>> All right. Well, why don't we talk some
7:26
mechanics?
7:27
>> Which one was named after which? All
7:28
right, fine. Mechanics.
7:29
>> That's That's a That's a good question.
7:34
>> All right. So, we usually we usually
7:36
start with 5e and then branch out from
7:38
there. Today, we're going to mix it up a
7:40
little bit. I want to hit Pathfinder
7:42
second edition first. This will be
7:44
surprisingly fast because this is one of
7:47
those parts where PF2 doesn't really dig
7:50
into the mechanics a whole lot. Like,
7:52
there's just not a lot of support here.
7:53
So, we've talked about PF2's vehicle
7:56
rules on, I believe, the flight episode
7:58
when we talked about airships. And, you
8:00
know, like all vehicles basically work
8:02
the same way. There's a handful of
8:03
actions you can take like make it go,
8:06
get on, get off, take control, make it
8:09
stop, run people over. That's pretty
8:11
much all you can do with vehicles. I
8:13
believe there are three types of ship
8:16
with stats in the game mastery guide.
8:18
It's like robo, long ship, gallion, and
8:21
it's like, wow, really, really just
8:23
flung to those extremes. But yeah,
8:25
they're they're kind of shallow. There's
8:27
not a lot to them. They don't even list
8:29
weapons or anything. Yeah, the there's a
8:31
few other weird quirks with it, like
8:34
since they're made of wood and they have
8:35
sails and stuff, they're vulnerable to
8:37
fire, which makes sense. But it also
8:39
means that if you take a torch, you can
8:41
just whack the deck of a ship until it
8:43
dies or or again just a fireball and
8:46
we're done.
8:46
>> Yeah, exactly. Yeah. So, I guess another
8:49
thing here is like we talked about
8:50
wanting to have meaningful roles and
8:53
yeah, PF2 like there is no idea or you
8:57
have and I love that in the notes it's
8:59
put in as quote driver quote. So like a
9:02
coxin or a helmsman who's controlling
9:04
the ship that that is the only named
9:06
role that has meaning and if you've ever
9:08
been in a rowboat with somebody there is
9:10
no helmsman, right? All you're doing is
9:12
fighting and disagreeing and spinning in
9:13
circles.
9:14
>> Yeah, that that's pretty much it. like
9:16
the the driver drives the vehicle
9:19
regardless of what the vehicle is.
9:21
Everyone else just kind of mills about
9:22
on the deck.
9:23
>> Yeah. So, it's not super satisfying.
9:25
Like there's not good integration with a
9:27
lot of what we already have with our
9:29
characters in in general. It almost
9:32
feels like at some point there's going
9:33
to be a supplement.
9:34
>> That wouldn't surprise me. Skulls and
9:36
Shackles was very popular for PF1. So,
9:39
if it got reprinted for PF2, reprinted
9:42
isn't the right word, but you know what
9:44
I mean. If they brought it back for PF2,
9:46
I think that would probably expand the
9:48
ship rules. They'd have to just cover
9:50
all the content that was in the existing
9:52
AP. And yeah, I would look forward to
9:55
that. I'd enjoy playing that in PF2.
9:57
>> Yeah, I could see them doing that at
9:59
some point. They've been they've been on
10:00
a track to redo some of the more popular
10:04
supplements and adventures. So, I think
10:06
could see them doing something with
10:08
naval combat in the near future.
10:09
>> Yeah. So, like I said, pretty brief. not
10:12
a lot to the support for naval combat in
10:14
PF2. The siege weapons didn't even
10:17
appear until Guns and Gears. So like if
10:19
you said, "Oh yeah, I'm going to take
10:21
this gallion and I'm just going to say,
10:22
yeah, it's got a ballista, a catapult,
10:24
or a cannon on board." Didn't have stats
10:26
for those for a while.
10:28
>> Yeah. Mechanically, how is this going to
10:30
work? I don't know.
10:32
>> So let's jump over to 5e because we've
10:34
got a a bunch more support there. Now,
10:37
the vast majority of this is going to
10:39
come from Ghosts of Salt Marsh, which a
10:41
lot of people looked over, which I think
10:43
is unfortunate. It's a really cool
10:44
adventure. We don't really see a lot of
10:46
nautical content in D&D in general. It's
10:50
also the only thing in 5D, which is
10:53
explicitly set in the world of Greyhawk,
10:55
which is interesting.
10:56
>> And hey, our friends from Cobalt Press
10:58
worked on it, which is really cool. I
10:59
like I've started looking for people in
11:01
the credits. I'm like, we know those
11:02
people. Neat.
11:04
>> That is cool. So, it's got some more
11:06
extensive naval rules. There's rules
11:08
like how ships move, what ships do, how
11:10
you use them, and it's got a lot of the
11:13
things that we touched on earlier in the
11:15
episode that we wanted supported by any
11:18
given rule system. So, let let's yeah,
11:21
just quick peek at the stats for ships.
11:23
So, it's going to have a stat block like
11:25
a creature. Weirdly, they have ability
11:28
scores, which feels odd. Like they list
11:30
out that the boat has they list out that
11:33
it has zero intelligence, wisdom,
11:35
charisma. It's like
11:36
>> no really
11:37
>> do they need that?
11:38
>> Yeah. Like why? Uh in theory it is
11:42
possible to make a boat make a wisdom
11:44
saving throw. I haven't figured out how
11:46
but it's theoretically possible.
11:48
>> I mean it's it's immune to blinded,
11:50
charmed, deafened, exhaustion,
11:52
frightened, incapacitated, paralyzed,
11:54
petrified, poisoned, grown, stunned, and
11:57
unconscious. So, I'm not sure what else
11:59
there is to say. I guess you could try
12:02
to banish it. Is that possible? Can you
12:04
banish a boat?
12:05
>> I think it has to target a creature.
12:07
>> Oh, no. Hear me out, though. If you
12:09
animate it, then you can banish it.
12:11
>> Oh god, please don't animate your
12:14
warship.
12:16
>> I I feel like you and I have different
12:18
ideas of fun.
12:23
>> What's What's What's it doing? It's
12:24
sinking itself. It's done with this. I I
12:28
do think that giving it the typical stat
12:30
blocks is maybe dumb, but it was made as
12:34
a way of like communicating something
12:36
communicating stuff to to people in a
12:38
way that they understand. I think
12:39
because strength, decks, and con are the
12:41
only things that really matter for a
12:42
boat. They could have just changed it to
12:44
I think strength is about as good as I
12:46
can think of for strength, but for
12:48
dexterity, maybe maneuverability, and
12:50
then con is like sturdiness, something
12:53
like that.
12:53
>> Okay. But if they if they had done that,
12:55
then all they would do it's like anytime
12:56
something tells you to make a saving
12:58
throw for dexterity, use the maneuver
12:59
score instead. I feel like they just
13:00
they cut one out and they said, "Look,
13:02
if if you want to try to dodge a
13:04
fireball with your boat, this is how
13:06
dextrous it is and we're good."
13:08
>> That's fair. That's valid.
13:10
>> Yeah. On the on the other hand, it's a
13:12
boat. I feel like it shouldn't be that
13:13
hard to hit.
13:14
>> You would certainly hope not.
13:15
>> Yeah. If I remember right, there like
13:18
the AC on all the boats is actually
13:20
pretty low. So hitting them with an
13:21
attack is pretty simple, but they do all
13:24
have a damage threshold. So any try to
13:26
any time you try to damage them, you
13:29
have to do more damage than that damage
13:31
threshold to do a significant amount of
13:33
damage. So like if you're taking a bow
13:35
and trying to shoot a galley, you're not
13:37
going to get through its like 20, 30,
13:39
whatever damage threshold. You're going
13:41
to need something a little bigger or I
13:43
don't know, pylon divine smite or
13:44
something. Yeah, I mean that's a huge
13:46
penalty for builds that require or that
13:48
depend on multiattack, right? Like
13:50
imagine I mean Okay, okay, now that I
13:52
say this, this makes perfect sense.
13:53
Imagine a monk going for a flurry of
13:56
blows. It's just not going to work out.
13:58
>> No, you cannot slap a boat to death.
14:00
Typically,
14:01
>> as far as armored class for ships goes,
14:04
ships are really unique in that way in
14:06
that each part of the ship has its own
14:09
AC and its own health, which is odd, but
14:12
kind of makes sense. So like hitting the
14:14
hole really easy but has a damage
14:16
threshold. Hitting the helm a lot harder
14:18
but obviously more advantageous if you
14:21
hit the helm and and the weapons
14:24
themselves don't have a damage threshold
14:27
either. So
14:28
>> yeah, hitting that hidden exhaust port
14:30
that you know that million to one shot
14:33
>> incredibly difficult.
14:34
>> Do it. Yeah, I would say that the Death
14:36
Star exhaust port would have an AC of
14:38
25, but it only has like maybe five
14:42
health.
14:45
>> Exactly.
14:48
>> So, so it sounds like if the the
14:50
individual parts of the ship like they
14:52
have their own hit points and stuff, I
14:54
can live out my fantasy of teleporting
14:56
onto the ship, ripping off the helm,
14:58
throwing it overboard, and then
15:00
teleporting back to my ship. And that
15:02
makes me happy. I love that. If you can
15:04
do 50 damage in a round, for sure.
15:07
>> Okay. Disintegrate.
15:09
>> Okay. Or
15:10
>> I'll figure it out. Whatever.
15:11
>> If you're a barbarian, I believe you
15:13
could probably do 50 damage in a round
15:14
pretty easily.
15:17
>> Yeah.
15:18
So, there there are some other like
15:20
another point of weirdness I noticed
15:22
about ship stats in 5e. They're not
15:25
squares. So like I I'm a native of third
15:27
edition where things could be like size
15:31
size tall and then size long. So like a
15:34
horse was 1 by two in in 3 0. So like it
15:38
was 10 ft long, 5 ft wide. And the fact
15:41
that it was a rectangle caused all sorts
15:43
of heartburn. So 5e they're just like
15:45
nope everything's a square. Ships not
15:47
square. So you can have a ship that's
15:49
like 80 ft long, 20 ft wide. And that
15:52
raises some interesting questions about
15:53
how it turns. Let's say our boat is
15:56
going to move 100 ft. Halfway through
15:58
it's going to make a 90° turn. Where's
16:01
the pivot point?
16:02
>> It Well, it you can't do that in 5D cuz
16:04
there's no acceleration in 5D.
16:06
>> Yes. All boats are fixed in place. Yes.
16:09
>> Yeah. Well, well, no, just like there's
16:11
no acceleration. You just
16:12
instantaneously have velocity all of a
16:13
sudden, right? Like when you fall from
16:15
the sky, it's just Yeah. And and here
16:17
here again, like the reason we don't
16:19
have facing is because you can't turn
16:20
because turning is still, you know,
16:22
potentially acceleration.
16:25
>> Well, maybe that's maybe that's why
16:27
we've never needed facing because
16:28
there's no acceleration, right?
16:32
>> But yeah, like how how would this work?
16:34
And I I guess what's interesting, do we
16:36
have like what would make turning
16:39
matter?
16:40
>> Well, let's see. So So you need to go
16:42
around obstacles
16:44
>> so much. Yeah.
16:47
Yeah. Like you need to get around
16:48
obstacles. You need to change direction.
16:51
Like I I think they wanted it so that
16:53
your your like your massive gallion
16:56
couldn't just turn on a dime and like
16:58
I'm going to go forward this turn and
16:59
exactly backwards on the next turn cuz
17:01
that does that feels a little silly. But
17:05
like they just left some unanswered
17:06
questions cuz like I have this great big
17:08
rectangle. I'm going to go almost to the
17:11
end of my movement and then turn. And
17:13
it's like, do do I follow rules like the
17:15
game Snake where you like you go and
17:17
your tail just falls along behind you or
17:20
do you get to the end and then your like
17:23
you turn from the front so the butt just
17:24
whips around or do you like whip from
17:27
the back so you're just like the front
17:29
of your ship just flips? Like the
17:31
question is not answered in the rules.
17:33
Yeah, this is reminding me of the
17:35
conversation overflight. I think it was
17:36
in third edition you were talking about
17:38
the idea that like in flight you
17:39
actually had momentum and so like young
17:42
dragons would actually have a problem of
17:44
like I'm trying to fly towards something
17:45
and I'm going to get you but actually
17:47
the best thing they could do is like hop
17:49
from place to place because otherwise
17:50
they were way too likely to overshoot.
17:52
It it almost feels like that rule set
17:54
would be useful for managing the boats
17:56
as they're described in 5D. Well, I
17:58
mean, I agree with what you guys are
18:00
saying, but at a certain point,
18:02
suspension of disbelief is a thing, and
18:04
we got to do what people don't want to
18:05
do geometry and math when they're trying
18:08
to rule on how a boat would work. I
18:10
think the the way that they've described
18:13
how boats turn is kind of a good
18:15
compromise, which is basically you can
18:17
only turn once when you move in a turn,
18:20
and it can only be in a single 90° turn.
18:23
So, you can't just completely rotate
18:25
around and you can't just go turn turn
18:28
and then I'm ending up here. So, it
18:31
still takes during your entire movement.
18:34
You can only turn once.
18:35
>> Is there a limit on how much you can
18:37
turn?
18:37
>> 90°.
18:38
>> 90°.
18:39
>> Does it say up to 90°?
18:41
>> It says you can move up to the speed of
18:44
one of the ship's movement components
18:46
with one 90° turn.
18:48
>> Oh, I may have overlooked that bit of
18:50
text. So, it's it's one 90° turn, not
18:54
one turn of up to 90°, which means we're
18:58
we're in like a chessboard situation
18:59
where you're either a rook or a bishop.
19:01
>> Yeah. Essentially,
19:05
>> you can't make partial turns.
19:06
Interesting.
19:07
>> Yeah. So, you have to go in a straight
19:09
line. If you want to turn, it has to be
19:11
in 90° angles. But it So, it is it is
19:14
there. Is it perfect? No, absolutely
19:17
not. I've actually run this system and I
19:21
think it was overall pretty decent. I
19:24
would have to say I didn't have a lot of
19:26
complaints with it. I would say tracking
19:28
the the health and stuff of all of the
19:31
different components was kind of a
19:33
nightmare, but but if you can do it,
19:36
it's it can be kind of exhilarating,
19:38
especially since maneuvering the boats
19:41
into position. The one thing that I
19:42
think that this thing lacks is the thing
19:45
that is a problem in all 5e is dealing
19:47
with distance, especially in something
19:50
as big as this and chases is kind of a
19:54
problem. So you're dealing with like
19:56
you're not dealing with small
19:57
measurements here. You're dealing with
19:58
like 60 ft 120 ft. It's a lot. And so
20:03
unless you're dealing with like ship
20:05
combat that's like both ships have kind
20:07
of lined up to each other and are just
20:10
going to attack each other, it becomes a
20:12
little bit unwieldy. And I think the
20:14
turns are a big part of that.
20:15
>> Yeah, I can see that making a lot of
20:18
sense. Like the the longest range
20:20
weapons we have are like long bows,
20:22
which top out at I want to say 500 ft.
20:25
I'm not remembering. So, like if you
20:26
have ships that are like a thousand feet
20:29
apart, then it's a whole lot of just
20:30
chasing each other and waiting, which
20:32
seems like it might not be a ton of fun.
20:34
>> Yeah, in those situations, I would just
20:36
have you I would just probably narrate
20:39
the thing and maybe have a few checks or
20:42
something. I wouldn't pull a map out and
20:44
be like, "Okay, so he's here and you're
20:46
all the way back here. First turn, you
20:48
get a little bit closer. He gets a
20:50
little bit further away. Next turn, you
20:52
get a little bit closer. You get a
20:53
little bit further away. That's a
20:55
nightmare. No, don't do that.
20:57
>> And and it feels like this is where you
20:58
might want to bring in something like
20:59
chase rules or something like like a
21:02
skill challenge to determine whether or
21:04
not you're able to close or whether
21:05
you're escape escaping. You can add
21:07
randomness due to weather events or like
21:09
it's like, oh, I didn't expect the
21:10
Kraken to pop out right now, but here we
21:12
are. Nobody expects the Kraken. And
21:15
yeah, we we've talked about some of
21:16
these things, so we'll put links in the
21:17
show notes if folks, you know, are
21:18
familiar, they can go take a look. I I
21:19
guess something we haven't talked about
21:20
yet for 5e is the roles. So, are the
21:24
roles expanded beyond what we got in
21:25
PF2?
21:26
>> Yeah, there are uh let's see, one, two,
21:29
three. There are six different roles
21:31
that players can take. And it says that
21:35
these are optional roles. Not everybody
21:37
has to have a role, but the ones that
21:40
are this role, it can only be one person
21:42
per role. So there's the captain which
21:45
issues orders and you basically you
21:48
basically want to have to have someone
21:49
with high intelligence and high charisma
21:51
as well as proficiency with water
21:52
vehicles and
21:54
>> all good feats to have in a captain.
21:55
>> Yeah, all good feat and definitely
21:57
either some good intimidation or
21:59
persuasion. One of the two. First mate
22:01
is the one that keeps the crew's morale
22:03
high. morale is a whole other thing that
22:06
the system also like this system is very
22:08
in-depth about like how the player's
22:10
relationship with the crew is and how
22:12
the crew factors into their performance
22:13
like how their morale factors in. So the
22:15
first mate is the person who's going to
22:16
boost the morale of the crew. They they
22:19
need to have high charisma as well.
22:21
There's a lot of high charisma. Well,
22:22
shocker running a ship requires you to
22:25
be a pretty charming person. Then
22:27
there's the bosen, which is the person
22:29
that gives technical advice to the
22:31
captain and crew, does maintenance and
22:33
repair. You want to have like
22:35
proficiency in carpenters tools, maybe
22:38
good strength and athletics. Then
22:40
there's the quartermaster who plays
22:42
>> Okay, wait. We can't leave the bosen
22:44
yet. We We can't leave the bos yet. I I
22:46
love the idea of like it's your job to
22:48
give strategy. Here's what I think we
22:50
should do. Let's get out there about 50
22:51
ft. Let's turn straight left.
22:55
>> There you go. Perfect. Uh,
22:56
>> that's what my 20 years on Zoolander
22:58
strategy.
22:59
>> I mean, it is it is funny that it
23:01
doesn't really elaborate on it provides
23:03
that they provide technical advice. Hey,
23:05
Captain, for this next battle, I
23:07
recommend we don't get hit.
23:13
>> Because then I don't have to repair
23:14
anything. That would be great.
23:16
>> Everybody hated it.
23:19
>> So, the next one is quartermaster, which
23:21
is the navigator. They're the person who
23:23
plots the course needs to know like
23:26
nautical charts and weather and sea.
23:28
Druid would be ideal for this this this
23:31
role because you need to have be have a
23:34
high wisdom score. You need to be able
23:35
to navigate well. Nature doesn't hurt
23:38
and survival is definitely very
23:40
important. And there's the surgeon. This
23:42
would be something that a cleric could
23:43
really do really well, which is the
23:45
person that, you know, keeps injuries
23:47
down, keeps inuh illnesses from
23:50
spreading. You need to be able to use
23:53
herbalism kits, medicine, and the cook,
23:56
which you don't get to see a lot of in
23:58
in the at least in the games I run. No
24:00
one wanted to be the cook. And I was
24:02
very disappointed because you get to
24:04
make you get to make meals and you can
24:06
keep the morale up. You don't need to be
24:08
charming in order to keep the morale up.
24:10
You just need to be a good cook. And you
24:12
just This is the one that requires a
24:14
high constitution score, which I think
24:16
is interesting. and brew proficiency
24:19
with brewer supplies and cooks utensil.
24:21
Obviously, the cook I think could use a
24:23
little bit more. The fact that you
24:26
basically keep the morale up, but the
24:28
it's redundant with the first mate. I
24:30
mean,
24:31
>> I feel like maybe there there's more you
24:34
could do with the cook, like giving
24:36
people extra hit die on a short short
24:38
rest or something like that. I don't
24:40
know. But
24:41
>> something like the chef feet.
24:42
>> Yeah, something like the chef feet. The
24:44
cook just doesn't That's the reason why
24:45
the cook isn't chosen a lot because
24:47
their role is redundant.
24:51
>> Now, how many of those get to do things
24:53
in combat? I can't imagine the cook is
24:56
out there. Like, yeah, snacks, guys.
24:58
Chucking fish heads.
25:00
>> Realistically, the ones that will be
25:01
doing the most are the first four. The
25:04
captain, the first mate, the bosen, and
25:06
the quartermaster. The quartermaster
25:08
maybe less so, but the captain will be
25:10
the one, you know, who's steering the
25:12
ship and giving orders to the crew. The
25:14
first mate is the one who's trying to,
25:16
you know, keep the morale of the people
25:19
up during the battle if there are
25:20
casualties. The bosen is going to be,
25:23
you know, doing repairs and stuff like
25:24
that where they can, keeping damage to a
25:26
minimum. And if you're trying to hunt
25:29
another another ship or trying to keep
25:31
keep an eye on the weather and stuff
25:32
like that so that things don't mess with
25:34
you during combat, the quartermaster is
25:35
there to do that. But the surgeon and
25:37
the cook are probably not going to do
25:39
much during the battle.
25:41
>> Okay. Well, cool. So, let's let's talk
25:43
about the actual fighty parts, I guess.
25:45
So, ships have weapons in their stat
25:48
blocks. I've noticed like each each ship
25:51
has pre-written weapons, and they're
25:54
generally ballistas. And Randall, we
25:57
looked up pronunciation on this.
25:58
Mangonal.
25:59
>> Manganel.
26:00
>> The internet said mangonal.
26:02
>> Did it?
26:02
>> Yeah.
26:03
>> Always manganel.
26:05
>> That's what we said.
26:06
Also, the internet could have lied to
26:08
me. Sometimes it does that.
26:09
>> True.
26:09
>> It has a habit of doing that.
26:11
>> It's one of those two things. Mangonal
26:13
manganel. I've only ever seen it
26:15
written. It's It's never mattered until
26:18
now.
26:18
>> Yeah.
26:19
>> It's basically a catapult. It's a tiny
26:21
catapult. And then Yeah. ballistas. And
26:23
those are your two weapons generally.
26:26
And they're just kind of like they're
26:28
pre-written into all of the different
26:31
ship stat blocks. And they have listed
26:33
like takes x number of actions to fire.
26:36
Actually, no, sorry, I'm getting that
26:37
mixed up. Like the the ship gets x
26:40
number of actions to take on a turn. The
26:42
captain decides which ones and it's like
26:44
move, shoot my two ballista, and that's
26:47
the boat's actions. I mean, they're kind
26:49
of neat. It's It's cool to be able to
26:51
use a ballista and like I I want to
26:53
shoot the troll sitting on the deck of
26:55
the other the other ship or like I want
26:57
to try and snipe the helm and break it
26:59
or something like that. It's kind of
27:01
neat. Yeah,
27:02
>> I do wish you'd be able to change them,
27:04
though.
27:04
>> Yeah, Watsy, what about cannons? Give us
27:07
cannons.
27:08
>> Even in your Spell Jammer book, you
27:10
didn't have cannons except for the one
27:12
the one ship that had a huge cannon.
27:16
>> All the rest of them have manganels and
27:18
ballista.
27:19
>> It in its defense, it's a really cool
27:21
cannon.
27:21
>> It is a very cool cannon, but I want
27:23
more of it. It's like, come on. More
27:26
more weapon options than just catapult
27:28
and ballistic. We can be a little bit
27:30
more creative.
27:31
>> Wait, you have fireballs. It's
27:33
>> true.
27:34
>> And and if you can't reach with a
27:35
fireball, you have a meteor swarm.
27:38
>> Fair enough. Fair enough. I guess in a
27:40
in a world where magic is a thing,
27:42
weapons on ships don't really need to
27:45
have as much emphasis. Just put the mage
27:47
there.
27:48
>> Yeah. Yeah. Just I've got three wizards.
27:51
I own this ocean now.
27:53
>> Yeah, pretty much.
27:55
>> So, I'm noticing that there's a few gaps
27:57
in here. So, from looking at the rules,
28:00
like the first thing that jumped out at
28:01
me is there's there's a rule for how to
28:04
handle area effects from spells, and
28:07
it's just like D6 crew members die per
28:10
spell level.
28:11
>> It's like that is
28:13
>> profoundly unsatisfying. Like, if I walk
28:16
over and use Burning Hands on the ship,
28:18
I just kill 1d6 people like that.
28:20
>> Yeah. Especially if you're if this is a
28:23
ship that your players are invested in
28:25
and you're killing their crew members
28:27
that easily. That's that's rough. Like
28:30
1d6, no save. You're just dead. Hope you
28:33
weren't attached to Tiny Timmy, you
28:35
know, the little gunner. He's dead now.
28:37
He's a mangled mess over in the corner.
28:39
>> We We just canonically agree like there
28:41
are 10 named NPCs on this ship and
28:43
everyone else is literally cannon
28:45
fodder.
28:46
>> Yeah.
28:46
>> Like that. That's what that's asking
28:47
for, right?
28:48
>> Pretty much
28:49
>> kind of. Yeah. But it becomes more of a
28:51
problem with like smaller ships where
28:53
realistically you would know all of the
28:55
crew like on on some Yeah. a rowboat or
28:59
I believe long ships have smaller uh
29:01
crews but you know you would maybe name
29:04
all of those and if they die it's really
29:07
rough because it doesn't change. It
29:09
doesn't matter how much crew you have.
29:11
But still, while D6 is going to die, and
29:13
if you have a smaller ship, that could
29:15
be like almost half your crew in one
29:19
shot, which is brutal.
29:21
>> Yeah, that's not really satisfying from
29:22
a role playing standpoint, cuz it's
29:23
going to go one of two ways. Either, you
29:26
know, you're going to Okay, Dave fell
29:28
over, but don't worry, we have his
29:30
brother Crave, and then when when Crave
29:33
dives, we have his brother Mave, right?
29:35
And and like that's the joke and
29:37
everybody keeps doing it and like okay
29:38
we can't really take this seriously or
29:40
every time there's a naval battle you
29:42
then need to spend like the next session
29:43
mourning
29:44
>> or you need to spend the next session
29:47
finding a new crew.
29:52
>> You long lost brother.
29:56
>> So there is also there's already a
29:58
solution to this problem. It's in the
30:00
dungeon master's guide. There's a table
30:02
called adjudicating area effects. We
30:04
mentioned it on the theater of the mind
30:06
episode because it's a great way of like
30:08
I don't know where people are in this
30:10
room. So just here's an AoE, here's the
30:13
size, and then the DM says, "Okay, look
30:15
at this table. You get this number of
30:17
targets." Just do that. Like most of
30:19
your crew is going to be commoners, have
30:22
like singledigit or low double- digit
30:24
hit points. So if you're fireballing the
30:26
enemy ship, then yeah, people are
30:29
basically going to be dead if they're
30:30
affected. But it it feels like a better
30:33
solution to figuring out how many things
30:36
you hit. And yeah, it's already in the
30:38
dungeon master's guide. So I I don't
30:40
know why they didn't just use that.
30:42
>> No, it makes sense.
30:42
>> I I also noticed there's no rules for
30:44
ramming things. Like there's rules for
30:47
>> collisions. There is.
30:48
>> Is there?
30:49
>> Yeah. I mean,
30:51
>> like I found rules for like I hit a
30:54
wall, I hit an object. There's no rules
30:56
for like I deliberately ram my ship into
30:59
somebody else's ship. I found I found an
31:02
entry for a ram that you can put on your
31:04
ship, but no rules for using it.
31:07
>> Yeah, that action doesn't go into the
31:09
legendary actions of the captain.
31:12
>> Okay, so the on the warship there is
31:16
baseline a naval ramp and it says the
31:18
warship has advantage on all saving
31:19
throws relating to crashing. when it
31:21
crashes into a creature or object. Any
31:23
damage it takes from the crash is
31:25
applied to the naval ram rather than the
31:27
ship. These benefits don't apply if
31:29
another vessel crashes into our ship. So
31:30
essentially, it is like crashing with
31:32
style
31:33
>> cuz there are there are there are rules
31:35
for crashing into. So I assume it's just
31:38
you move your ship into the other ship.
31:42
>> Yeah, pretty much. Okay. So it sounds
31:44
like it sounds like it's specific to
31:46
that ship.
31:47
>> Yeah. or any ship that I would assume
31:49
that any ship that you add a ram to is
31:51
going to work the same way.
31:52
>> Yeah, that makes sense. So, I I just
31:54
want to hit one more goofy thing before
31:56
we move on. The rules for crew morale
31:58
and mutinying don't change regardless of
32:01
the size of your ship. So, if you have a
32:03
rowboat and you have two crew and one of
32:06
them is you, it is possible for your
32:08
other crew member to mutiny.
32:09
>> I can see my players taking advantage of
32:11
that.
32:13
>> Yeah, mutiny. Mutiny. Mutiny. Mutiny. I
32:17
at that point, isn't it just like
32:19
attempted murder?
32:20
>> Yeah, pretty much.
32:21
>> Maybe boat theft, like Yeah. Okay.
32:25
>> All right. So, we're going to we're
32:27
going to jump in the wayback machine.
32:29
Not go super far back. We're only going
32:31
to go back to a first edition
32:32
Pathfinder, not all the way back to 300.
32:35
My my wayback machine only goes back
32:36
that far. The rules for shipto- ship
32:39
combat in PF1 are an absolute nightmare
32:42
to read on Archives of Nethis. D20 PFSRD
32:45
has done a much better job of linking
32:47
those articles. So, we'll have a link to
32:48
that in the show notes. The parts that
32:51
you care about come from the PF1 game
32:53
mastery guide and the Skulls and
32:55
Shackles adventure path, which we
32:56
mentioned earlier. And if you're not
32:58
familiar with Skulls and Shackles, it's
33:00
the one about pirates. Makes sense.
33:02
Ships have stats. It's a thing. They're
33:04
they're objects. They're not stated out
33:07
in a stat block similar to a creature,
33:09
but they have things like AC and a
33:11
saving throw modifier and a size. And
33:13
they have slots for weapons that you can
33:15
put weapons in like catapults. They are
33:18
square, which is weird cuz like 3X had
33:21
the concept of creatures who were
33:23
rectangular. So, it's weird that they
33:25
made boats square, but they did keep
33:27
facing like it it very explicitly says
33:29
your ship is going a direction. you need
33:32
to track your facing because you have to
33:33
turn. And basically everything in this
33:35
entire system is dominated by two
33:38
things. One, your uh profession sailor
33:41
skill, which is how you do all of the
33:43
boat things. And then if you want to use
33:45
the siege weapons, you have to have
33:47
exotic weapon proficiency, which is just
33:49
I want to be proficient in things cooler
33:51
than swords. So I guess that includes
33:54
like repeating crossbows, double axes,
33:58
catapults, ray guns. It's a very strange
34:00
feat. The game master's guide has a
34:03
table of just like here's ships at
34:05
different sizes. Here are the generic
34:07
stats. And it specifically says like we
34:09
can't represent every possible ship
34:11
under the sun in this. So just here's
34:13
examples. Call them whatever. And then
34:15
Skulls and Shackles comes along as like
34:17
well what if I tried to name all of the
34:19
ship? Yeah.
34:22
Um if you want to see the stat the text
34:25
on this stuff, grab the Skulls and
34:27
Shackles players guide PDF. It's free
34:30
and it has the expanded naval combat
34:33
rules and the additional ship stat
34:35
blocks and all of the upgrade for your
34:37
ships, all those cool things. I'm gonna
34:39
say the the rules here are a little
34:41
weird. Like acceleration and
34:43
deceleration matters. The like the
34:46
captain spends actions to drive the ship
34:49
and can do things like I spend my move
34:51
action to make the ship move. I convert
34:52
my standard action to a move action,
34:54
make the ship move again. It's like did
34:56
you just move double the ship's maximum
34:58
speed in a turn? Yes, he did. Which all
35:00
feels very silly. Players can man man
35:03
siege weapons because they're just
35:04
weapons that happen to be on a ship.
35:06
There's rules for like a million
35:08
different things. Uh ramming, grappling
35:10
hooks thrown onto other ships so you can
35:12
like grapple the ships together and
35:14
board and do all that. There's like four
35:17
pages of just here's a bunch of named
35:19
spells that we think are going to come
35:20
up and like here's how we interpret
35:23
them. like fog cloud. If you cast fog
35:25
cloud, it floats off and doesn't stay
35:27
with the ship or things like that. What
35:29
happens if you can't cast animate object
35:31
on your ship? Your ship can move
35:33
sideways. Have fun. Like it's very
35:36
detailed. There's a lot of stuff in it.
35:38
You can get really really nitty-gritty
35:40
with customizing your ship. Like I would
35:41
like my ship to be extremely wide and
35:43
also extremely long, but somehow not a
35:45
large larger size category. Like all
35:47
these things. My biggest gripe with it
35:49
is it's just so much text. It's uh like
35:53
Ash, you've played PF1 a bunch and like
35:55
you you know this problem.
35:57
>> Yep. It's like
35:58
>> they do not know what editing is.
36:03
>> They did not. They've gotten better.
36:04
>> They have gotten better for sure.
36:06
Pathfinder 2 is a vast improvement.
36:08
Speaking from personal experience in the
36:10
Pathfinder game that I'm currently a
36:12
player in, my DM just gave us a landbo.
36:15
>> Land boat. Nice.
36:16
>> A boat. Yeah. It's a boat that has
36:18
wheels that can also go in the water and
36:20
is pulled by two flail snails. Haven't
36:22
seen what it's capable of in combat yet,
36:24
but I will report back when I do.
36:28
>> Yeah. Growing up, we call those gators.
36:30
>> Yeah, that's what it is. It's a gator.
36:32
>> I'm curious to see what those flail
36:34
snails do in the water. I can't remember
36:35
if those can swim.
36:36
>> We just put them on the ship.
36:37
>> Oh, okay.
36:39
>> If there's time. If there's time.
36:42
>> So, yeah. Aside from being incredibly
36:45
verbose, the rules in PF1 for shipto-
36:47
ship combat are actually really, really
36:49
good. There's a lot of cool ideas here.
36:51
It covers a lot of the edge cases. There
36:53
are some weird things where like your
36:55
ship adds your profession sailor
36:58
modifier to its AC. And this is a game
37:01
where the expectation was your your
37:04
modifier and a skill you're you care
37:05
about goes up by at least one every
37:07
level. So like I'm a level 10 character.
37:10
I'm proficient in this skill. I've got a
37:11
decent wisdom modifier and a hook took
37:13
skill focus. My bonus is like plus 20.
37:15
My boat gets a plus 20 to its AC and to
37:18
all of its saving throws. It's nuts. It
37:23
anyway PF1.
37:25
Good times. So, hey, tell me about
37:27
space.
37:28
>> Yeah. So, I think it's important that we
37:30
talk about Spell Jammer cuz I feel like
37:31
Spell Jammer, you know, took what you
37:34
got from Ghost of Salt Marsh and
37:36
expanded it and now I actually think we
37:38
have a pretty decent system sitting
37:40
here. So, some of the highlights beyond
37:41
what we got out of 5 that we were just
37:43
talking about a moment ago. Talk about
37:44
roles. In this case, you really only
37:46
have two roles that matter. You have the
37:48
captain and the captain it says
37:50
basically they give orders with no
37:52
explicit effect. What I wonder though is
37:54
effectively does that mean it's a free
37:56
action. You get to hauler out things to
37:57
the crew like we're going to do a
37:58
broadside and then the crew manning
38:00
everything gets to take you know if if I
38:02
have two blisters I get to fire them
38:04
that round. Now the caveat is
38:05
>> um I think you're reading from my notes
38:07
a little. the uh so the captain like it
38:10
it says in the spell jammer text like
38:13
they give orders does not say what the
38:15
result of that is. So yeah I guess it's
38:17
just like narratively you can shout at
38:19
people on your turn and hope that they
38:21
do things. Yeah, it my my my is issue
38:24
with Spell Jammer and I haven't actually
38:26
run it, so Randall will have more
38:27
experience on this with me, is that
38:29
unlike with Ghost of Salt Marsh where it
38:31
really felt like they dealt in dug into
38:33
the meat of like this is how a ship
38:35
works. This is what the crew does. This
38:37
is what the roles are. Spell Jammer was
38:39
basically just it it presented different
38:41
ships, which was great. Like I liked all
38:43
the different ships. I thought the
38:44
different ships were very cool, but they
38:47
they didn't go into explicit zip. like
38:49
this is what the role of the captain is.
38:51
The first m or didn't even really list
38:53
any of the roles. It just listed captain
38:55
and helm the the the person who runs the
38:58
helm. That was kind of it and feels like
39:01
a missed opportunity. I also do think as
39:03
cool as the ships are, aside from
39:05
aesthetics, a lot of them don't have a
39:08
lot that distinguishes them. There are
39:10
exceptions like the Nautiloid is awesome
39:12
and I love it and mwah. The living ship
39:15
is also very cool and the the the GIF
39:19
cannon is awesome and I want one. But
39:23
other than that, it's it's I there there
39:26
were complaints about how spell how
39:28
loose the rules were for Spell Jammer's
39:31
ship combat. But I am curious as to how
39:33
Randall feels after having run it.
39:35
>> Yeah, I think I mean there's a a couple
39:37
things to take away from this. So what I
39:38
was getting at a second ago is the idea
39:40
that like okay, you get to give orders.
39:41
you probably have NPCs running your
39:43
ballistas or or your manganels or or
39:45
your bombard super cannon if you're on
39:48
one of the gif ships. So the caveat here
39:51
and I think it's worth calling out if
39:52
you read the text they basically say all
39:55
of these things are only useful at long
39:59
range and that once you're within range
40:02
of your spells you should stop trying to
40:04
use the ballistas. You should stop
40:05
trying to use the bombard and you should
40:07
flip over and just use the spells and
40:08
abilities of the party.
40:10
>> Disappointing. So rather than saying,
40:12
"Let's have really awesome naval combat
40:15
with all of these cool weapons we have
40:16
mounted on the ship," it's basically get
40:19
within a range where it makes sense to
40:20
start talking about the weapons that are
40:22
available to each ship. Talk about that
40:24
until you're in range to treat this as
40:26
like a boarding party situation or
40:28
broadsides with spells and then pivot to
40:30
that. And so because of that reason,
40:33
like like you say, they bypass. But but
40:34
we can also talk about like what were
40:36
some of those things? We talked about
40:36
the cook, right? You know what you don't
40:39
have to do in in the astral in the
40:41
astral sea?
40:42
>> Eat.
40:42
>> Don't have to eat. Yeah. Yeah.
40:45
>> Poor guy. Just in the back. I brought
40:47
all these delicious ingredients from all
40:49
the worlds that we came we came from.
40:51
And I was going to make you guys this
40:53
incredible feast that no one has ever
40:55
had before. Yeah. We don't need it.
40:56
We're not hungry.
40:57
>> Yeah. As soon as soon the bright side,
40:59
nothing ages, so nothing spoils.
41:01
>> Fair.
41:02
>> You're flying around in the world's the
41:05
multiverse's largest refrigerator.
41:07
>> Yeah. No freezer burn though ever. So
41:08
that's also a nice feature. And and so
41:10
yeah, like in in the sense that it is
41:12
cool and you can have the the idea of
41:14
having like a spell jammer battle where
41:17
somebody, you know, literally they bring
41:18
their lawn chair onto your ship, they
41:20
drop their lawn chair, they sit and they
41:22
say, "We're going to have brain fights."
41:24
Like that's a lot of fun, but it just
41:27
isn't this naval experience that we're
41:28
talking about. So I don't want to take
41:29
anything away from it. I think you can
41:31
have a ton of fun doing this boarding
41:33
party situation, thinking about the
41:35
wacky things that happen with gravity of
41:36
like you're the larger ship or you have
41:38
more health, therefore your gravity
41:40
dominates my gravity and everybody just
41:42
falls off my boat, which again in the
41:44
Astral Sea, falling off the boat, not a
41:46
great time cuz you're you're never going
41:48
to die. You're just going to float at
41:50
the speed of your brain. But but there
41:52
are some things worth calling out. So
41:54
cool combat tip tidbits here. It's
41:56
explicitly called out that side
41:57
initiative is actually a great way to
41:59
manage this and I imagine that makes
42:00
sense maybe until you actually get
42:02
everybody onto the same boat and then at
42:04
that point you say okay let's roll and
42:06
let's run like a standard initiative
42:07
unless everybody loves it. Talking about
42:09
doing this boarding party setup you can
42:11
tactically execute the boarding party
42:13
maneuver as long as everybody else
42:15
readies the action to board the other
42:17
ship. So there has to be a concentrated
42:18
effort if you use your action to do
42:20
something else next round and then you
42:21
play the game of like, okay, I'm going
42:23
to fly up to it. I'm gonna let everybody
42:24
hop off and I'm gonna fly back to
42:25
safety. If somebody burned their action,
42:27
they're actually still stuck on the
42:28
ship. They're not able to do the
42:29
boarding party. So, strategically, you
42:31
might be wasting around to ready until
42:34
your spell jammer can execute the
42:36
maneuver. And you have to think about
42:37
that trade-off.
42:38
>> Now, I I came up with a I'm going to
42:40
generously call this a dumb idea. So,
42:42
you mentioned how like the gravity
42:44
planes from the ships interact based on
42:47
like who has the most health. So when
42:50
two spell jammers touch, when they love
42:52
each other very much, which whichever
42:55
one has the most hit points has the
42:57
dominant gravity plane. So you can do
43:00
crazy things where like I have a very
43:02
very small ship with not a ton of hit
43:04
points. Someone help me. What is the
43:06
long pointy part that sticks out of the
43:08
front of a ship?
43:09
>> A prow.
43:10
>> That sounds right. So you get a prow on
43:12
your ship, right? You're in space. Space
43:15
in three dimensions. So you come down at
43:18
the enemy ship like it imagine the shape
43:21
of a tea and you're coming down from the
43:23
top and your prow touches the other
43:26
ship. All of the gravity on your ship
43:28
goes away and is taken over by the other
43:30
ship. All of your crew on the deck very
43:33
quickly on the other ship boarding
43:35
party.
43:35
>> That is pretty brilliant.
43:36
>> Yeah.
43:37
>> And then when you want to get off, you
43:39
just hit their ship until it has less
43:40
hit points than yours and then you're
43:42
right back on your ship.
43:43
>> Yeah.
43:43
>> Like I said,
43:44
>> no, it makes perfect sense. You could
43:45
split their party, like have everybody
43:47
on your deck and just trap two people on
43:50
your side, so they have to make their
43:51
way around your ship. Yeah. The problem
43:53
is, of course, right, damaging your ship
43:54
is always fun and it's expensive to
43:56
repair. So, you do have to be thoughtful
43:57
of these things. Yeah. Yeah. I One other
44:01
thing I want to bring up is the variety
44:04
in the ships I do think is pretty
44:05
interesting. You talked about like the
44:06
Nautil's interesting. What makes it most
44:08
interesting is that it can teleport. It
44:10
can also grapple. So literally a
44:12
nautaloid might reach out and say my
44:14
ship to another ship in a fleet of ships
44:16
and then teleport away and that's it.
44:19
>> Yeah,
44:19
>> there are other terrifying. Yeah, there
44:21
there are other Well, especially because
44:23
who's who's typically piloting the
44:25
Nautaloid? The mind flarers. Yeah, there
44:28
are other ships that have grappling
44:30
abilities. There ships that have
44:31
different ramming ram capabilities. The
44:34
most novel weapon is the giant
44:36
cannonball, which is on the bombard. The
44:39
bombard being the GIF ship. And that has
44:41
a range of 600 to 2400 feet,
44:44
>> which is nuts in 58.
44:46
>> Yeah. Dealing 16d10 damage.
44:49
>> Geez.
44:50
>> But outside of that,
44:51
>> remind me how much those cannonballs
44:53
cost.
44:54
>> Yeah, they weigh 10 tons and they cost
44:56
a,000 GP. Thousand gold.
44:58
>> Jeez.
45:00
>> Wow.
45:01
>> But the if they hit, bye-bye ship.
45:04
>> Yeah. Here's what I'll say though. It I
45:07
can't imagine the cannon cannonballs
45:08
completely destroyed, right? Like, can't
45:10
I destroy the ship and then just catch
45:12
up to my cannonball?
45:13
>> Perpetual motion?
45:14
>> No, that's a really good question.
45:16
>> I don't know. This is not the point
45:18
where I'm going to I'm going to suspend
45:19
disbelief. I'm going to say this is
45:20
fine. We have perpetual motion with my
45:23
brain.
45:24
>> That's the whole point of being a spell
45:25
jammer, right?
45:26
>> But but outside of that, right,
45:27
>> how do you how do you slow down a 10 ton
45:30
cannonball even if you catch it?
45:31
>> Well, there's no acceleration. So, maybe
45:33
no. True. You go around it and you shoot
45:36
another cannonball at it
45:37
>> and then they each take 6010 damage. O.
45:41
Okay. All right. This This probably
45:42
isn't going to work.
45:43
>> My brain hurts.
45:44
>> We'll figure something out, I'm sure.
45:45
Telekinesis or something.
45:46
>> Yeah. Perfect. Outside of this, so what
45:49
do you get? Right. You have the
45:50
ballista, you have the Mangonal, and
45:52
then you have a couple like flavored
45:54
things for ramming implements and
45:55
grappling implements. Yeah, I like I
45:58
feel like there are definitely some
46:00
improvements here over the ship
46:02
mechanics in Ghost of Salt Marsh. Like
46:05
parts were simplified, parts were made
46:07
more complicated. Ramming was definitely
46:09
given more attention than in Salt Marsh.
46:13
I like that they went with side
46:14
initiative until until you close to like
46:17
personal combat distance. That probably
46:20
does make things a lot simpler to run.
46:22
Yeah, I'm with you on like the
46:24
challenges with the boarding thing
46:26
though cuz it's so easy to just mess up
46:28
the timing and not get to board the
46:29
other ship, which that really sucks if
46:31
you're built for melee cuz like using
46:34
the longrange weapons isn't super
46:36
effective at like as a player character.
46:38
It's great for your NPCs who are like
46:40
I'm a commoner. I have plus two to hit
46:42
with a club. But for the players, it's
46:45
like I would like to go over them and
46:46
hit with my nine live steeler great axe,
46:49
please. But uh they're hundreds of feet
46:52
that way. So I guess I'll just hang out
46:54
or I'll brainfly over there cuz that's
46:56
an option, too. But then like that's
46:58
almost worse, right? Because you get
46:59
about halfway there and then the ship
47:01
actually flies past you. It's like if I
47:02
had known
47:03
>> Yeah. Spell jammers which can move like
47:06
hundreds of thousands of miles an hour.
47:08
It's like,
47:09
>> well, we have naval combat rules in 5e
47:13
and we have space rules in 5e. Now give
47:17
us airships, airship rules, and give us
47:20
undersea rules, Watsi, you cowards.
47:25
That's all I have to say.
47:27
>> We want We want large races to cram into
47:30
our submarines and have submarine fights
47:32
with centaur.
47:33
>> Yes.
47:34
>> Yes. That's exactly what I want. Thank
47:36
you. You're on the same page.
47:38
I also I also want to have a huge blimp,
47:41
a huge airship, and I want it to get in
47:44
dog fights with biplanes. I think that's
47:47
cool.
47:51
All right. Well, we'll put it on the
47:52
next one D and D survey.
47:56
All right. So, we've looked at we've
47:58
looked at our various games. Um, we
48:00
haven't talked about fighting monsters
48:02
because honestly, it's not all that
48:04
different from fighting other ships.
48:05
Just the ship is a monster. Yeah.
48:08
>> Kaiju here.
48:09
>> Yeah.
48:10
>> So, between the systems we've looked at,
48:12
like guys, where where do you see the
48:14
pros, cons of each, which one's your
48:17
favorite? Like, what would you steal
48:18
from each and put in the others?
48:20
>> I think in terms of just robust and
48:23
coherence, I would say fifth edition
48:26
probably is the winner here. I think it
48:28
concisely creates the the rules for ship
48:32
combat that are pretty easy to follow.
48:34
They're not overwhelming like Pathfinder
48:36
1's and they're not almost non-existence
48:38
like Pathfinder 2. I feel like right now
48:42
fifth edition is the winner. Maybe in a
48:44
few months time or a year Pathfinder 2
48:47
will come out with something even
48:48
better.
48:49
>> How about you Randall? What do you
48:50
think?
48:50
>> Yeah, I guess I'm really tempted to say
48:51
I would love to stick with Spell Jammer
48:54
navigation and motion rules. I don't
48:56
want to think about only doing left
48:57
turns. I like let's continue to ignore
49:00
facing and ignore turning and just party
49:02
on. Let's have a good time. only because
49:03
I don't know I don't know that that's
49:04
the most interesting part of this right
49:06
really what we want to say is sure if
49:08
I've got ballistas I can aim them
49:09
forever and it's fine I I wish there was
49:12
a larger variety of weapons and you
49:15
could tie that to like the status of the
49:17
ship if it's an ongoing like you know
49:19
I'm going to be an admiral of the fleet
49:21
and I'm going to have all these cannons
49:22
and I'm going to buy super gunpowder I
49:24
feel like that would be a lot more fun
49:25
the good news is that actually feels
49:26
pretty easy to homebrew I don't want to
49:28
say just 5ev I actually want to say I
49:30
really like the spell jammer rules Okay.
49:33
Yeah, I think I'm I I think I agree with
49:36
you guys. Like the 5D definitely feels
49:38
like the winner here. I Yeah, Randall, I
49:42
I think I agree with you. I would
49:43
definitely take Spell Jammer's motion
49:45
rules just for the simplicity. Like I
49:48
either the Ghost of Salt Marsh movement
49:51
rules need to be explained a little
49:52
better or just go with the Spell Jammer
49:54
rules for simplicity. Like where it sits
49:57
is kind of frustrating. I think I prefer
50:00
Spell Jammer's rules for how like siege
50:03
weapons on the ship work as well, but I
50:05
do prefer the Ghost of Salt Marsh. Like
50:08
I want to be able to break individual
50:10
parts of the ship and I want the rules
50:12
to matter a little bit more beyond just
50:14
like whoever has the Spell Jammer helm
50:16
gets to drive the ship.
50:18
>> I think if you like both of those, just
50:20
take elements from both and maybe
50:22
that'll meet in the middle and you can
50:23
make rules for the airship. Just a
50:25
thought.
50:28
Come on, Watsy.
50:29
>> I want my airship supper.
50:31
>> Give it to me.
50:34
>> All right, I think we did it. So, we
50:36
have a question of the week this week.
50:37
And our question of the week this week
50:38
comes to us from RPGbot.net on Twitter.
50:44
So, I snuck this one in here. I wanted
50:46
to have a a rules discussion in here and
50:48
couldn't figure out where to fit it into
50:50
the like the body of the episode.
50:52
>> You know, you could just ask us, right?
50:54
Yeah, but I you know it fits the format
50:57
anyway.
50:57
>> That's fair. Okay. Well, here I'll
50:59
handle it for you. So, our peg dudet
51:02
says, "If I can cast a spell with an
51:04
ongoing area of effect, hunger of hadar,
51:06
wall of fire, fog cloud, etc. while on a
51:09
moving ship, what happens? Does it float
51:11
in space or stay in place relative to
51:13
the ship?"
51:13
>> This has actually come up for me as a
51:16
both as a DM and as a player because we
51:18
had we were on a ship in one of my games
51:21
that I was a player as. And I think that
51:23
we but we just all came to the consensus
51:26
that anything that you place is going to
51:28
sort of lock to the surface it's on. So
51:31
if the if the ship moves, it moves with
51:34
it. Just for simplicity sake. I realize
51:36
that that can be abused pretty easily.
51:38
But don't go overboard with it. Just
51:41
it's like I'm going to cast firewall on
51:43
tensor floating disc and float it in.
51:47
Don't do that. Don't be a jerk cuz
51:50
that's how nice things are taken away
51:51
from you. But I I could see it going
51:53
both ways. Like I think it kind of just
51:55
depends on where you stand as to if it's
51:57
connected to if the ground counts as
52:01
whatever the the whatever is there at
52:04
the moment or if it's just locked in
52:06
space, which I also think is kind of
52:08
abusable. Like if you put tensors
52:10
floating disc, if you cast a fire hunger
52:13
vitar on tensor floating disc and then
52:15
take tensors away and it's still
52:16
floating in the air. I could see ways
52:18
that you could abuse that. So, just kind
52:21
of depends.
52:22
>> All right. I have an answer, so come
52:24
with me.
52:25
>> Okay.
52:25
>> All right. If the caster is on a huge
52:28
object or larger, and that object is
52:31
moving at some velocity in a straight
52:33
direction, we're going to call this an
52:35
inertial frame of reference, including
52:36
if it's stationary to the world. As soon
52:38
as that object turns in any direction,
52:42
the spell effect, the the wall of fire,
52:43
the fog cloud continues going forward as
52:46
it was.
52:48
>> Okay. So what you're saying is I can get
52:50
on a ship. I can cast wall of fire on
52:52
the front of the ship. I can run the
52:54
ship toward a city and turn and then
52:57
cast wall of fire rolling.
52:59
>> No matter how you rule it, there are
53:01
ways to cheese it to where it's like
53:03
this is the most powerful thing that I
53:05
can ever do. And if you just if you hate
53:07
your players like and you hate the fact
53:10
that if they're constantly trying to
53:12
cheese rulings that you make, just say,
53:14
"Yeah, locked in spells don't work on
53:17
ships."
53:19
>> Okay. Wait, does does does wall of fire
53:21
does wall of fire Wow, I can't say the
53:23
word. Does the wall of fire require
53:27
concentration?
53:28
>> It does.
53:28
>> Okay. What if as soon as it leaves your
53:31
inertial frame reference, you have to
53:32
start making concentration checks?
53:33
>> I could see that working. That would
53:35
work like that. That would at least
53:36
limit it a little bit.
53:37
>> Well, it makes it to where it's not
53:39
likely to go for the full time or or to
53:41
infinity.
53:42
>> Yeah, that's fair.
53:43
>> Maybe maybe with disadvantage if you
53:44
know if it's getting too wild
53:46
>> if it's okay.
53:48
>> Maybe if it's out of your cast range.
53:50
>> I love that. Yeah, that makes really
53:52
good sense.
53:52
>> If it's out of your cast range, it just
53:54
like dissipates maybe or you get
53:55
disadvantage on the concentration check.
53:57
>> Yeah. Yeah. Honestly, that's probably
53:59
just a like a good rule in general. like
54:02
caster gets out of range of the spell,
54:04
make them start making concentration
54:06
checks. So, it's like, okay, the caster
54:09
has found a 10-minute duration wall
54:12
spell and they throw it up behind
54:13
themselves and flee. And it's like,
54:15
okay, great. This entire adventure is no
54:17
longer a challenge. Congratulations.
54:20
>> Y it would kind of address that issue.
54:22
It I feel like it could get kind of
54:24
complicated, but it would be a cool fix.
54:25
>> I think we started complicated, so
54:27
>> fair.
54:28
>> And then we went into math nerd real
54:30
quick. Okay. Sure did. So Tyler, do you
54:34
want to answer our pigbadonet question?
54:37
>> I don't know who this Yahoo is. So my
54:40
opinion is if the when the spell is cast
54:44
by the caster, they can choose. They can
54:46
either fix it to the surface of the
54:49
vessel that they are on or they can fix
54:52
it in space. So like if I cast if I cast
54:54
hunger for Dar I can say I want it to be
54:57
on I want the origin point to be this
54:59
point on the deck of the ship in which
55:02
case it stays there on the ship or I can
55:04
say I want it to be this spot floating
55:06
in midair ahead of the ship and then the
55:08
ship can drive through hunger of Hadar
55:10
and have a good time. And I mean that
55:12
arguably gives casters like way too much
55:15
flexibility and power in this situation.
55:17
like I'm going to make my enemies drive
55:19
their ship through a blade barrier cuz
55:21
that sounds like fun to me. But I it
55:23
does solve a lot of other problems.
55:25
>> Yeah. Towards your point, you ultimately
55:26
don't wind up with a projectile
55:29
stationary spell.
55:30
>> Yeah, exactly.
55:32
>> Uh just
55:34
>> flaming flaming orb. Isn't that a
55:36
projectile stationary?
55:38
>> Flaming sphere.
55:38
>> Flaming sphere. Yeah.
55:39
>> I mean, you roll it. You intentionally
55:41
roll it around. It's like It's like an
55:43
RC car but fire,
55:46
>> which is bad for ships, it turns out.
55:48
>> Yeah.
55:49
>> All hell the Leisure Illuminati. I'm
55:50
Randall James. You'll find me at
55:51
amateurjack.com and on Twitter at
55:53
Instagram, Jackamate.
55:55
>> I'm Tyler Campa. You'll find me at
55:56
rpgbot.net.
55:58
Or piggbot.net on Facebook and Twitter.
56:01
Uh, and patreon.com/rpgbot.
56:04
>> I'm Ashi. You can find me follow me on
56:06
Twitter, graven ashes for now. And
56:11
>> yeah, o also on starplay.game where I'm
56:14
going to be running a oneshot for a call
56:17
of Cthulhu Regency.
56:19
>> All right. And yeah, we'll have links in
56:20
the show notes. If you've enjoyed the
56:22
show, please rate and review us on Apple
56:23
Podcast and rate us on Spotify or your
56:25
favorite podcast app. It's a quick free
56:27
way to support the podcast and helps us
56:28
to reach new listeners. You'll find
56:30
links in the show notes. You'll find
56:31
affiliate links for source books and
56:33
other materials linked in the show notes
56:34
as well as on rpgbot.net. Following
56:36
these links helps us to make this show
56:38
happen every year. If your question
56:39
should be the question of the week next
56:40
week, please email podcastrpgbot.net
56:43
or message us on Twitter at rpgbot dete.
56:47
Please also consider supporting us on
56:48
Patreon where you'll find adfree podcast
56:50
episodes, early access to
56:52
rpgbot.content, polls for future
56:54
content, and access to the rpgbot.isord.
56:57
You can find us at patreon.com/rpgbot.
57:00
>> Oh no.
57:03
Sorry about that.
57:04
>> Yeah. Yeah, my bad.
Games

