MANAGING MAGIC ITEMS (Remastered) - Bag of Holding, Brain of Forgetting - RPGBOT.Podcast S5E41
Aug 10, 2026
In this episode of the RPGBOT.Podcast, the crew delves into one of the most beloved aspects of tabletop roleplaying games—magic items. From balancing their distribution to enhancing narrative flavor, the team explores how to manage magical items effectively, whether you're a Dungeon Master trying to maintain game balance or a player eager to wield arcane power responsibly.
This episode originally aired on April 4th, 2025, and we're currently working to upload our episode backlog. For the latest from the RPGBOT.Podcast, find us in your favorite podcatcher.
Full show notes for this episode are available on RPGBOT.net: https://rpgbot.net/managing-magic-items-remastered-bag-of-holding-brain-of-forgetting-rpgbot-podcast-s5e41/
Find us on socials and stuff:
🦋 https://bsky.app/profile/rpgbot.bsky.social
⏰ https://www.tiktok.com/@rpgbotdotnet
🔍 https://RPGBOT.net/
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
An auction hall for magical artifacts.
0:03
The rock's crowd is rowdy, shouting
0:05
intelligible bids over the den. Myriad
0:07
creatures make up the audience, and the
0:09
auctioneer strikes a strange and
0:11
alluring image. A humanoid of unknown
0:13
origin with unfamiliar features. Leaning
0:15
over their podium, they rattle off
0:17
prices and items, a rush of syllables in
0:19
a dozen languages. First off, a sword
0:21
dripping with acid goes for the half
0:23
hort with the eye patch. Second item up
0:24
for an ancient sphere of unknown
0:25
purpose. Sold the amorphous being from
0:27
an unknown time and place. And this
0:29
still living branch of the tree that
0:30
holds up the celestial heavens a loft
0:32
sunk the princess who arrives here in an
0:34
astral strip.
0:35
>> Just as soon as each bid begins, it ends
0:37
and the items are carried backstate.
0:40
This scene from describe.com describe
0:43
describe your world. Go to
0:45
describe.com/rpgbot
0:47
to get $5 off your first subscription
0:48
payment with code RPGbot 5 at checkout.
0:55
[laughter]
1:20
Welcome to the RPGbot dot podcast. I'm
1:21
Randall James and with me is Tyler
1:23
Camstra. Hi everybody. And Ashi,
1:26
>> you've come for magic items? Yes. Yes.
1:28
Come in. Come in. I've got bits and
1:29
bobs, enchanted brooms, and cursed. I
1:31
mean, come in. [laughter]
1:37
I've been to that, Steuart. [laughter]
1:42
All right, Tyler. What's happening?
1:44
>> Well, tonight we're going to discuss
1:46
managing magic items in 5. specifically
1:48
as a dungeon master, how do you award
1:51
magic items to your players in a way
1:54
that's fun for them, but also won't just
1:57
wreck your game. So, we're going to look
1:58
at some options for how to do various
2:00
things like allowing players to buy and
2:03
sell magic items, how you can pick magic
2:05
items for the party that won't cause you
2:07
trouble. We're going to try and give you
2:08
some advice on how to make this work. I
2:10
feel like I already know this, right? We
2:11
give everyone plus one magic weapon at
2:14
level two.
2:15
>> And then when sorcerer complains because
2:18
they don't get to use magic weapons, you
2:19
know, we give them uh oh, what's the the
2:21
vial that gives you extra sorcerer
2:23
points? Blood well vial. Yeah,
2:24
absolutely. Give them that at like level
2:26
three
2:26
>> and then give them staff of the magi at
2:28
level five, right?
2:32
[laughter]
2:32
>> And then at level six, the wizard rushes
2:35
your big bad and performs a retributive
2:37
strike with that staff of the magi. the
2:40
big bad and the wizard go on a fun trip
2:41
to the astral plane and now you've got a
2:43
buddy cop movie instead of your your D
2:45
and D campaign.
2:46
>> Well, that's really why we came here to
2:47
begin with, right?
2:48
>> Yeah. [laughter]
2:49
Yeah. So, I mean, that's that's a pretty
2:52
normal way for a lot of DMs to handle
2:54
things. Like, you're you're running one
2:56
of your first couple long form games and
2:59
you want to hand out presents to your
3:01
players cuz you love them and you want
3:02
them to be happy. So, you just rain
3:04
magic items on them. And then eventually
3:06
you get to this situation where like
3:08
your players are so far beyond what the
3:12
CR scale expects that it's really hard
3:14
to challenge them. Like everyone's got
3:15
plus a million to to attack and damage
3:18
and it becames it becomes a game of
3:20
rocket tag because the players are like
3:22
so skewed compared to what the game
3:24
expects.
3:25
>> Yeah, I I think it's worth highlighting
3:26
there, right? Like they can deal a lot
3:28
of damage, but unless they're picking up
3:30
the right magic items, they are still
3:32
squishy. So rocket tag indeed that it's
3:34
like okay whoever lands the first strike
3:36
is going down but like if I come in with
3:38
a appropriately level defensive CR set
3:41
of monsters just as likely like with a
3:44
few bad die rolls we've got a TPK on our
3:46
hands.
3:47
>> Yeah.
3:48
>> Yep. Yep. Yep.
3:50
>> So the the game is wellbalanced and you
3:54
know we'll talk a little bit about other
3:55
games. We'll talk about PF2. You know
3:56
I'll say these games are wellbalanced.
3:59
Not U3. These games are well balanced,
4:02
but when you skew the magic item
4:05
economy, things can get out of whack
4:07
really quickly.
4:08
>> Mhm.
4:09
>> Yeah, absolutely. Third edition, fourth
4:11
edition, PF2, like these are games where
4:14
there's a very fixed wealth by level
4:16
curve and players will be within like
4:19
some standard deviation of what the game
4:21
expects and you'll be fine. But if you
4:22
go beyond that, then you're going to
4:24
have trouble balancing the game. Like if
4:26
the players are too rich, they're too
4:29
strong. If they don't have enough money,
4:30
then they're too weak. So, like, if the
4:32
players are burning all of their money
4:34
on disposable items, they're going to
4:36
hurt themselves. But, you know, 5e
4:38
doesn't have that problem really because
4:41
magic items work so differently compared
4:43
to those games without and and because
4:46
gold is worthless.
4:47
>> Yeah.
4:47
>> Yeah.
4:48
>> Without an intentionally builtin wealth
4:50
by level curve and without like an open
4:53
market for buying magic items. Magic
4:56
items are intentionally special, but
4:59
they also go outside of the balance
5:01
expectations of the game. Like they are
5:03
very much an optional rule in 5e, even
5:06
though nobody really plays with them
5:08
that way. So these games where magic
5:10
items are available, like that is baked
5:12
into how the games are balanced. You're
5:14
expected to get X at level Y, like your
5:16
stats go up at some speed. And like PF2
5:19
has the automatic bonus progression
5:21
variant which we've talked about
5:22
previously on the show which says like
5:24
this is where we the designers expect
5:27
you to get these bonuses. So if you stay
5:29
roughly close to this your character is
5:31
going to be okay from a balanced sense.
5:33
We don't have that in 5e. So if all of
5:37
your players suddenly have like plus
5:39
three weapons that's going to that's
5:41
going to do stuff to your game and
5:43
you've got to be ready to handle it.
5:44
Also keep in mind the biggest difference
5:46
there with like Pathfind when you're
5:48
talking about Pathfinder and fifth
5:50
edition is you know the bounded accuracy
5:53
and plus one plus two plus three items
5:57
break bounded accuracy. So when you're
5:59
giving those magic items to players like
6:02
a plus one plus two sword in Pathfinder
6:05
3.5 is not going to do a lot for you.
6:07
It's going to be cool but it's not going
6:09
to break the game. If you give it to
6:10
someone who is early, they're going to
6:12
be they're they're going to be punching
6:14
way above their weight class, and you
6:16
have to be prepared for them to break a
6:18
lot of things.
6:19
>> So, we're also going to talk about a
6:21
thing that I'll frequently refer to as
6:23
the Christmas tree problem, which is not
6:24
a term that I came up with, and
6:26
definitely stole that from a forum
6:27
somewhere. Basically, the concept is
6:30
your characters may end up with so many
6:32
magic items on them that they're dressed
6:34
head to toe in ornaments like a
6:36
Christmas tree. And essentially each
6:39
individual magic item stops feeling cool
6:41
because you have so many of them that
6:43
they just kind of all blend together.
6:45
>> Mhm.
6:46
>> It It's like that scene in Thor Ragnarok
6:48
where like the guy brings you and it's
6:49
like behold my stuff. [laughter]
6:53
>> Yeah. Exactly.
6:54
>> Yeah. It's like Or or another example is
6:57
when you have you come across this
6:59
magical talking sword of legendary
7:01
imports like, "Oh, cool. I already have
7:03
one of those." [laughter]
7:05
>> But this one speaks in a British accent.
7:07
Yeah.
7:07
>> Oh,
7:10
[laughter]
7:10
Carl Urban. Great guy.
7:13
>> All right. So, let's talk about how
7:15
magic items work in 5D because we we
7:18
want to kind of set that basic
7:20
understanding before we get into like
7:22
where are the problems and how do we fix
7:24
them? So, like we we said this earlier,
7:26
magic items are technically an optional
7:28
rule in 5e. Now, basically, everybody
7:31
uses them, and to some degree, it feels
7:34
like the game actually expects you to
7:35
have magic items because resistance to
7:38
non-magical weapon attacks is so common.
7:41
Like, gargoyless, they're like a CR2 or
7:44
three monster, and they have resistance
7:46
to bludgeoning, piercing, and slashing
7:48
damage from non-magic, non-adamine
7:50
attacks. Like, how do you get th those
7:52
things? You got to have magic weapons or
7:55
you have to have somebody in the party
7:56
generous enough to cast their highest
7:58
level spell as magic weapon. Nobody's
8:01
gonna do that.
8:01
>> Well, I will say if anybody has ever
8:04
considered running a low magic setting,
8:06
like let's say you're doing a sort of
8:08
the Witcher type of monster hunting
8:10
thing, just don't use magic weapons and
8:12
they have to figure out the how to
8:15
overcome the resistances without using
8:17
magic. I guess here, right? Resistance
8:19
means taking half damage or resistance
8:22
means Yeah. So, we're talking about half
8:23
damage. We're not talking about
8:24
invulnerability. So, yeah, you know, if
8:27
you don't have magic weapons and you're
8:28
not using magical damage, it's like,
8:31
hey, let's let the casters do most of
8:33
the work and we're going to be more
8:35
useless than we normally are, [laughter]
8:38
>> which in a game where caster supremacy
8:40
is already a huge problem.
8:42
>> Yeah. And I would also argue that
8:44
>> it's a problem for the non-casters.
8:45
[laughter]
8:47
Now you now you get it.
8:49
>> I would argue that the damage resistance
8:51
to mag non-magic damage is actually an
8:54
argument against the game expecting you
8:56
to have an abundance of magical items
8:58
because in my experience I've had to
9:00
ignore those [laughter] because
9:02
essentially it doesn't do anything cuz
9:05
all my players will have some form of
9:07
magical magical weapon damage that they
9:09
can do within the first like five
9:12
levels. So it becomes a non-issue. So,
9:15
if you want to engage with the damage
9:17
resistance, non-magical weapon damage,
9:19
don't give your players magic weapons.
9:22
>> Yeah. Hey, so uh so here's some some
9:25
deep knowledge from building the
9:27
monsterizer. That resistance to
9:29
non-magical bludgeoning, piercing,
9:31
slashing does not factor into CR.
9:33
>> Crazy. Yeah, at least as far as I can
9:35
tell from the monsters I looked at in
9:37
the SRD, like yeah, no effect on
9:40
>> double the hit points. That's crazy.
9:42
Wait, so
9:43
>> let me ask to make sure that I
9:44
understand you correctly. So, you used a
9:45
quick monster table and you got to the
9:47
same CR as what it actually is in the
9:49
text.
9:50
>> It It's always a little bit off, but the
9:54
like looking at the numbers that the
9:56
calculator spits out compared to what's
9:58
actually written as the CR in the book,
10:00
it looks like the resistances to
10:03
non-magical attacks just do not factor
10:05
in. Like the CR written into the Monster
10:08
Manual just assumes that the players
10:10
will always be able to bypass that.
10:12
>> That's interesting. Okay.
10:13
>> Yeah. So, so back to magic items. So,
10:15
here's some more deep knowledge. So,
10:17
this is actually buried in Xanithars.
10:19
There are also minor and major items.
10:22
So, like we've talked about consumable
10:24
items before, and then there's permanent
10:26
items. There are also, you know, just a
10:28
minor versus major split. So, major
10:30
items are your cool items, your plus one
10:33
swords, your flame tongues, your like
10:34
wand of missiles, those cool things.
10:36
Your minor items are mostly consumables,
10:39
but also just like random bubbles like
10:41
bags of holding, myithal armor, stuff
10:43
that's not going to matter constantly,
10:46
especially in combat, but it's still
10:48
magical and still neat. You still like
10:49
to get it. And understanding that
10:51
distinction usually doesn't matter, but
10:53
it is actually very helpful when
10:55
awarding treasure. And I'm sure
10:56
everybody listening knows the rarity
10:58
scale. Common, uncommon, rare, very
11:00
rare, legendary. We could consider
11:03
artifacts and stick those at the end,
11:05
but I don't think we're going to talk
11:06
about those today because artifacts are
11:08
a plot point, not a reward.
11:10
>> I think it's worth our time to talk
11:11
about it at some point in the future.
11:13
>> Yeah. Let's see. So, things that are
11:16
used to balance magic items to try and
11:19
combat the Christmas tree problem. Like,
11:21
the only thing in 5e is attunement. And
11:24
in a lot of games, attunement will
11:26
generally just never be a problem for
11:28
you. You won't get enough items for it
11:30
to matter. But in some games, if you're
11:31
getting a lot of treasure and a lot of
11:33
magic items, you might be like, "Oh,
11:34
I've got I've got all these rings of
11:36
protection, suddenly I can't attune all
11:39
of my toys." That makes me sad.
11:41
>> I will say after having played
11:43
Pathfinder 1, three atunement slops is
11:46
really stingy. [laughter] It's really
11:49
stingy. Like I go through those pretty
11:52
regularly, but I guess it kind of makes
11:55
sense for fifth edition because fifth
11:56
edition again is like you're not
11:57
expected to be buried under a bunch of
11:59
magic items.
12:00
>> And and just remind folks at home, so
12:02
how long does it take to attune to a new
12:04
magic item?
12:04
>> 1 hour.
12:05
>> Yeah.
12:06
>> Okay. And how long is a short rest?
12:08
>> An hour. And you can attune to items
12:10
during a short rest. So they want you to
12:12
be like, "Oh, we found a cool magic
12:13
item. Somebody wants to attune to it.
12:15
Let's take a short rest while that
12:16
happens." Well, and the point I was
12:18
going to get at is like if you know what
12:20
you're walking into next and you have,
12:22
let's say, six magic items, you could
12:24
make that decision during a short rest.
12:25
Okay, I'm going to unattune from these
12:27
items. I'm going to attune from these
12:29
items. So, so in a way you could you
12:31
could play the game of like what do I
12:32
need today? Similar to a prepared
12:34
caster.
12:34
>> Yeah, that is a way you could play it.
12:37
He does. Nobody does that. [laughter]
12:39
And the thing about attunement also to
12:42
keep in mind is that when you attune to
12:44
an item, you learn all of its magical
12:45
properties, which essentially makes
12:46
identify useless unless you are trying
12:49
to find cursed items. Like if you're
12:51
trying to figure out if an item is
12:52
cursed, that's the only time identify is
12:54
actually useful for anything in fifth
12:56
edition. [laughter]
12:57
>> No, in in its defense, that's a great
12:59
reason.
13:00
>> And identify doesn't even reliably find
13:03
cursed items. Like the item itself has
13:05
to specify identify will tell you that
13:08
this item is cursed. They don't all say
13:10
that.
13:10
>> That is true.
13:11
>> Yep. That's terrifying.
13:13
>> Mhm.
13:13
>> Yeah. Let's see. So, so attunement. If
13:16
you've looked at magic items and you've
13:18
looked at the items which require
13:19
attunement, you'll notice like there are
13:21
a lot that don't. So, stuff like plus
13:23
one weapons, plus one armor, those
13:25
things don't require attunement because
13:27
you can factor that math into your
13:29
character sheet just like, "Oh, look, my
13:30
attack is one higher now. I never need
13:32
to think about this sword again." Most
13:34
of the things requiring attunement are
13:36
complicated items that have active
13:38
properties or have something that you
13:40
have to track. So like a staff of power,
13:43
like it's got charges you have to
13:44
manage. It's got a bunch of different
13:45
spells you can cast from it. That's
13:47
complicated. It adds complexity to your
13:49
character. So it requires attunement.
13:51
>> That would make sense. But then you
13:52
factor in the rod of packed magic and
13:56
that's another one that's kind of just
13:57
like a forget item and still requires
13:59
attunement.
14:00
>> Yeah. The the other kind of item that
14:03
requires attunement is items that might
14:05
break the math.
14:06
>> There you go.
14:07
>> Notably, plus one weapons, plus one
14:09
armor of or sorry, plus X weapons and
14:12
armor aren't they don't require
14:14
attunement, which is weird cuz they do
14:16
break bounded accuracy like Ash called
14:18
out earlier. Ring of protection, cloak
14:21
of protection, those require atunement.
14:23
Like that's plus one AC and plus one to
14:25
all your saves. So, like they don't want
14:27
you to stack a million of those cuz how
14:30
many fingers do you have? That's how
14:31
many rings you can wear. So, you could
14:33
get 10 rings of protection be a huge
14:35
problem. You can't take three plus one
14:38
swords, strap them together, and have a
14:40
plus three sword and break the gain.
14:42
>> Not with that attitude. [laughter]
14:44
>> Yeah. But at the same time, you also
14:46
have gauntlets or different sort of
14:49
items that increase your strength to
14:51
like 20 or 19, which you could achieve
14:54
normally. Those also require atunement.
14:56
>> So it kind of seems like magic items
14:58
that require atunement are just
14:59
arbitrary
15:01
>> a little bit. Yeah. Like there are some
15:03
items which really really should require
15:05
attunement but don't and then there are
15:07
some that do require attunement. It's
15:09
like this doesn't do much. Why?
15:11
>> Yeah. There's some that are like really
15:13
pathetic that require atunement. It's
15:15
like [laughter] why though is are the
15:17
developers just trolling me here?
15:20
Yeah, the the decision there does seem
15:22
to be a little bit odd as a DM. If you
15:24
look at something like this doesn't make
15:26
any sense, change it.
15:27
>> Yeah.
15:30
>> All right. So So I've done a bunch of
15:32
math on this on like I I built as far as
15:35
I know the only existent accurate wealth
15:38
by level table for 5e that includes like
15:42
the expected magic item progression. So
15:44
like that tells us some things.
15:46
>> Oh boy, more math. I I will say actually
15:48
I really really love this table when I
15:51
run games for people and I'm I I always
15:54
start my players above level one. I
15:56
typically go to three or five if it's
15:57
players I've played with a lot. I'll use
15:59
it as an opportunity like hey we're
16:00
going to do something level 15. Let's go
16:01
play a oneshot in order to explore cuz
16:03
most campaigns don't go that far. Every
16:06
time I start players above level above
16:09
level one I send them to to this table
16:11
and I say do whatever it says. And it it
16:14
has worked out fine mostly. Like aside
16:17
from the issues we're talking about in
16:19
this episode where you can get a bunch
16:20
of magic items and break the math, like
16:22
it it's good to have like here's a
16:25
progression that makes sense based on
16:27
what's in the actual random treasure
16:29
tables. Like if you follow the random
16:31
treasure tables, you have a a very
16:34
reasonable chance of ending up very
16:36
close to what is recommended in this
16:38
table. like no one ever lands perfectly
16:40
on the average, but you know, we use the
16:43
law of averages and do our best. So, so
16:45
one of the things in this table, by
16:47
level 20, your character is expected to
16:50
have around eight major magic items of
16:53
various rarities. Notably, you'll get
16:55
one legendary item. I hope you love it.
16:57
So, like when you when we talk about the
16:59
Christmas tree problem, when we talk
17:00
about the limitation on atunement slots,
17:03
eight magic items, three attunement
17:05
slots, like some of those items are
17:07
going to have to not require attunement
17:09
or you're going to have to switch
17:10
through items or you're going to get rid
17:12
of some or something like that. But just
17:14
having that baseline number of
17:16
eventually you will have eight permanent
17:18
magic items, like that does give us some
17:21
guidance. But within that number,
17:24
there's still more we can do to prevent
17:25
things from becoming a problem. 56
17:28
different combinations of magic items
17:29
you could have there.
17:30
>> So, you're telling me the system I've
17:32
been using where I give magic items when
17:34
my players complain a lot is not the
17:37
best way to do that. [laughter]
17:39
>> No, probably not, man.
17:42
>> Well, now you tell me. [laughter]
17:45
>> Well, we can only put out these episodes
17:47
so quickly.
17:50
>> Let's see. So, so by the time this is
17:52
out, our review for Keys to the Golden
17:55
Vault will also be out. Keys to the
17:57
Golden Vault, notably very, very
17:59
generous with magic items. After every
18:02
single quest, the players get to choose
18:05
a magic item for themselves as a reward.
18:08
And on top of that, a couple of the
18:10
quests the players will receive like
18:12
here's four or five magic items for you,
18:14
you as a group. We hope you enjoy them
18:16
and learn to share. But that means that
18:18
by the end of the ad by the end of the
18:20
campaign, you have something like 11
18:23
magic items that you have handchosen.
18:26
>> Yeah. And I think that actually makes
18:28
sense for that game if especially if
18:30
you're running as a campaign or actually
18:33
especially if you're running them as
18:34
individual one shots. It makes sense
18:35
either way because why do a heist if
18:38
you're not going to get rid? [laughter]
18:40
>> Fair.
18:42
>> You don't want to you don't want to just
18:43
do it for the golden vault, man. Yeah,
18:46
>> this mysterious maybe dragon sending you
18:48
uh dead drops.
18:49
>> Who's this golden vault person? I don't
18:52
care. Like if if they if they were
18:55
offering to pay me an experience or you
18:57
know the moral goodness of my heart, I'd
19:00
be like, "Go take a hike, buddy. Give
19:02
I'm breaking the law for you. Give me
19:05
something that makes it worth my while.
19:08
>> Pay me an experience. What What is this?
19:09
An adventuring internship?" [laughter]
19:14
All right, so let's talk about actually
19:16
giving out magic items because this is
19:18
where the uh this is where, you know,
19:20
the advice really applies, where it
19:22
matters. So, I as a DM have historically
19:27
relied very heavily on randomly
19:30
generated treasure. In a lot of ways,
19:32
it's really fun to be like, "Okay, you
19:35
players find a treasure horde." And they
19:37
get all excited and they say, "Ooh,
19:39
what's in the treasure horde, Tyler?"
19:40
And I say, "What a great question." And
19:42
I hand them the dungeon master's guide
19:44
and flip to the table for generating a
19:46
horde of appropriate level. And I hand
19:47
them a 2d10 and I say, "Go nuts. I'll
19:50
see you in half an hour." And naturally
19:52
like that that gives them like some
19:54
items, some gems, some art pieces, and
19:57
occasionally a couple of magic items.
19:59
The problem with generating stuff that
20:00
way is you'll get completely random
20:03
magic items that may be absolutely
20:05
useless to your party. Like if you have
20:08
a fighter in the party who's using the
20:10
slasher feet and they're like they're
20:11
all about slashing weapons and they're
20:13
very very happy. If you hand them a plus
20:15
one Warhammer, you've essentially handed
20:17
them a plus one piece of useless garbage
20:20
and also it's heavy and they have to
20:21
carry it. [laughter]
20:23
>> Yep.
20:23
>> Yeah. So, as much fun as it may be to
20:26
roll randomly generated treasure, use it
20:29
as a starting point, but handle the
20:31
magic items yourself. It's It's going to
20:33
make the results more satisfying for
20:35
everybody, and it prevents situations
20:37
where you accidentally give the entire
20:39
party brooms of flying.
20:40
>> But But Tyler, the the young wormling
20:43
that gathered all this treasure didn't
20:44
know that this particular party was
20:46
going to be the party that actually
20:47
slayed it and took all the treasure. So
20:49
why does it make sense they have these
20:50
perfectly fit items that go exactly with
20:52
what the characters need right now?
20:54
Well, you know, you're right, and I get
20:57
that. Sometimes you just wave your hands
21:01
and say, "Look, don't question it."
21:02
We'll talk about trading magic items in
21:04
a few minutes.
21:05
>> I will say if you The best way I think
21:07
to give directed magic items, like items
21:11
that you you handpick yourself that you
21:14
think will benefit the players in a
21:15
certain situation is as a reward for a
21:19
backstory sort of thing. Like maybe your
21:22
character finds out their long- lost
21:25
parents were part of a necromancy cult
21:27
and they left them a book, you know,
21:30
some sort of book that allows them to
21:32
speak with dead people or speak with
21:33
undead people, which would be [laughter]
21:37
but
21:39
right here to talk.
21:41
>> I can talk to you right now. No, but
21:43
talking to a zombie who's it's probably
21:45
going to be a scintillating
21:45
conversation. It's just going to be
21:46
brains brains. [laughter] Um but uh but
21:51
yeah like
21:52
>> Arby's
21:53
>> that's something [laughter]
21:55
Arby's.
21:57
You've been watching The Last of Us,
21:58
haven't you? [laughter]
22:01
>> No. Okay, I'm going to I'm going to I'm
22:02
going to poke fun of my own poking fun
22:04
though, right? Like that's lame. We're
22:05
playing a power fantasy. We want to have
22:07
fun. Like this is the place where you're
22:09
going to complain about realism, you
22:11
know? Not when like you jumped the 20
22:13
foot chasm to bury your axe into the
22:15
skull of a dragon, which probably should
22:17
have melted you with its acid, but you
22:19
know, that's neither here nor there. But
22:20
now it's like, you know, it's like, oh,
22:21
that's a perfect thing for me. How did
22:23
it get here? That's where you're going
22:24
to draw a line. Fine. You don't get the
22:26
item. The other three people in the
22:27
party get the items.
22:28
>> I don't know a single player who's
22:30
complained about that. It's like, oh,
22:32
this thing that's been irritating me is
22:34
now solved. Hm. Seems unrealistic. I'm
22:36
sorry. Would you prefer I not give it to
22:38
you that would solve all your whining?
22:40
No. No. I'll take it. I'll take it.
22:42
>> Yeah. [laughter]
22:45
>> Well, let's talk about that. Using magic
22:47
items to solve problems. So, this is a
22:49
piece of advice we've given on the
22:50
podcast many times before, and I still
22:52
think it's one of the best reasons to
22:54
use magic items in 5e. There will be
22:57
times your players have a character that
23:00
has some really annoying thing about
23:04
them. Like like I my beast barbarian who
23:08
who died somewhat recently, Scog, he was
23:11
also the stealthiest person in the
23:13
party, which was a problem cuz I planned
23:15
for him to be in medium armor. And most
23:19
medium armor gives you disadvantage on
23:20
stealth. And when you're trying to sneak
23:22
around and your armor's going clang
23:23
clang clang clang, doesn't go great. So,
23:26
Myithil Armor very neatly solved that
23:28
problem for Scog and then I could go
23:30
back to being a stealthy scary bug bear
23:32
ambush predator. And I was very, very
23:34
happy with that answer.
23:35
>> Yeah, speaking of annoyances, it's just
23:37
important to keep in mind when you're
23:39
awarding magic items, award magic items
23:41
to fix the players's annoyances, not
23:43
yours. They exist to empower players,
23:46
not nerf them. Don't nerf your players.
23:49
So, what I thought you were, the reason
23:50
I bring that up is because what I
23:52
thought you were going to with that sto
23:53
story was, you know, he was too
23:55
stealthy, so we got to make him less
23:56
stealthy, which don't do that. Don't
23:59
don't nerf your players. That doesn't
24:00
feel good.
24:01
>> Is that is that the cursed item podcast?
24:03
[laughter]
24:04
>> Sure. If you want to do it with a cursed
24:05
item, that's fine cuz that's a problem
24:07
that can be solved. But don't just like,
24:10
oh, this is a really powerful item that
24:12
does all the things you want, but it
24:14
also makes you less stealthy. Enjoy.
24:16
[laughter]
24:19
Dear RPGbot, the Gloomstalker keeps
24:21
melting my encounters. What do I do?
24:23
Give them a minus two crossbow.
24:25
[laughter]
24:28
>> A minus two crossbow that they can't
24:30
unattune to from even if they cast
24:33
remove curse. They're stuck with it.
24:34
It's just a constant minus two cuz screw
24:37
you player.
24:37
>> Oh, see that [laughter] that's the fun
24:39
part of minus X weapons. They're
24:40
explicitly intended for you to give them
24:42
to your player and say this is a plus X
24:45
weapon. They write that on your
24:47
character sheet and then the DM is
24:48
expected to just subtract that from
24:51
their attacks.
24:52
>> Oh, I hate that. Oh, I hate that. That
24:55
is that is
24:56
>> And then eventually eventually they'll
24:58
realize like why am I attacking a
25:00
different AC from all of the other
25:02
characters.
25:04
>> Oh, okay. The uh the AC is definitely
25:09
greater than 14, but also less than 12.
25:11
And I can't figure out what's happened
25:13
here. [laughter]
25:18
Anyway,
25:19
>> it's an imaginary creature.
25:21
>> Oh, [laughter] no. So, solving problems
25:24
for your party using magic items. Like,
25:25
there are a couple of easy go-to
25:27
examples that I like to use. Fighters
25:30
very frequently feel underwhelming,
25:31
especially once magic items come into
25:33
play cuz a lot of the other classes can
25:35
just run away with things. Every fighter
25:37
with a flame sword or flame sword a
25:39
flame tongue sword. Very very happy when
25:41
you've got like three or four attacks
25:43
and you get to add 2d6 to each of them
25:45
with your sword feels real good. Monks
25:48
need so many so many magic items. Please
25:52
help your monks. Bracers of defense just
25:54
plus two AC solves a lot of problems.
25:56
Dragon hide belt adds to the DC of their
25:59
special abilities. Like makes stunning
26:01
fist actually work for once.
26:03
>> Give them double the key points.
26:05
Yeah. [laughter] Uh I I think there are
26:08
magic items that give you extra key. I'm
26:10
struggling to remember any names though.
26:11
>> Uh taking taking levels in other
26:13
classes. [laughter]
26:15
>> Only levels and other classes.
26:16
>> I will die on this hill. Monks are cool.
26:19
Dang it.
26:20
>> They are cool. They just need a little
26:22
help.
26:23
>> Warlocks. Like when when you've got a
26:25
player who's like, I I don't know how to
26:26
manage my resources, so I'm going to
26:28
spend all of my resources on like a
26:30
scorching ray and be out of spell slots
26:32
in the first encounter. Give them a
26:34
pearl of power. Wizards.
26:36
>> Just everything. Just everything. Like
26:38
all of the magic items for wizards are
26:41
so ridiculous.
26:42
>> It's just
26:43
>> just give them scrolls. They'll be
26:44
happy.
26:46
>> Yeah. But if you if you really wanted to
26:48
spoil them, you know, you could give
26:49
them a staff of the Magi or the or the
26:52
robe of the Magi. Like, let's get crazy
26:55
with it. Let's make wizards even more
26:57
overpowered.
26:59
[laughter]
26:59
>> Look, one of those is very rare. One of
27:02
those is legendary. And those will be
27:04
their two best magic items.
27:06
>> Mhm.
27:06
>> Yeah. Like like wizards, if you want to
27:08
give them magic items, scrolls are easy.
27:10
Wand of the war mage is fine cuz it'll
27:12
give them a bonus to spell attacks,
27:14
which basically only matters for
27:16
cantrips, so it won't make their big
27:19
spells matter, but it'll make their
27:20
cantrips feel a little better.
27:21
>> Also, don't give magic items to your
27:23
artificer. They don't need any help
27:24
getting more powerful. They can make
27:26
their own. [laughter]
27:28
>> I mean, you got to give them something
27:30
so they don't feel left out. They also
27:31
get more attunement slots, so keep that
27:34
in mind. [laughter]
27:35
>> Yeah, just uh just get to high levels.
27:38
The artificer's got three of those uh
27:41
clockwork amulets that are a common item
27:43
that requires a tune. It's like, here we
27:45
go. [laughter]
27:47
All right. So, so we we alluded to this
27:50
a little bit about players picking magic
27:52
items or just finding the perfect item.
27:55
So, guys, I'm going to ask your
27:56
opinions. Should we just let players
27:59
work this out themselves and pick their
28:00
own magic items?
28:02
>> Well, I don't know what Randall's going
28:03
to argue, but I'm going to take the
28:05
stance that yes, I don't think it
28:07
should, but it's sort of like a middle
28:09
ground kind of yes. I think surprising
28:12
players is fun, and players like
28:14
surprises. So, if we just let them pick
28:17
what their magic items are going to be
28:18
all the time, then there's no surprises
28:20
and they're just like, "Cool, I just got
28:22
the thing that I wanted." But what I
28:24
would say is that the way that you
28:26
should approach it is recognize what the
28:29
players are wanting, what they what
28:31
their expressed desires are, and then
28:33
either make a magic item or find a magic
28:36
item that you think fits their
28:38
capabilities and what they are wanting.
28:40
Don't give don't give the don't give the
28:42
[laughter] barbarian like a book that
28:45
gives them a bunch of spells. They're
28:46
not going to like that. Give them a
28:48
thing like give them a give them a
28:50
javelin of lightning or something like a
28:52
returning weapon. Something that allows
28:54
them to throw it and come back. As a
28:56
barbarian player, I will kiss your feet
28:58
if you do that. [laughter]
29:00
Um because that's the major drawback and
29:03
the major complaint of barbarians is
29:05
like, "Oh, there's a creature that's
29:06
flying. Cool. I'm just going to sit
29:07
here." Or if you don't want to make it
29:10
that easy for them, give them a a like
29:12
spring-loaded boots that they can jump
29:14
high and then have their gauntlets
29:16
attach like chains onto a creature that
29:18
pulls them down onto the ground. Like
29:19
there's a lot of fun ways that you can
29:21
do it that that help your players
29:23
achieve the cool things that they want
29:25
to do without just being like, "Okay,
29:27
why don't you just go pick some magic
29:28
items?" So like I kind of landed the
29:30
middle. Sometimes yes, sometimes no.
29:32
>> What do you think? I I think I'm going
29:34
to agree with you and I'm going to maybe
29:35
add a little bit something different to
29:37
to what you've said. I think a great way
29:39
to handle this is call out to the
29:41
players like, "Hey, by the way, you
29:43
know, we we've taken a few levels. If
29:45
there's a particular magic item you're
29:46
looking for, let me know."
29:47
>> Yeah,
29:48
>> some players know exactly what they
29:49
want. They've been doing research.
29:51
They've been reading about this very
29:52
special item they're hoping to find, and
29:54
they're going to let you know that,
29:55
yeah, at level three, they want this
29:56
legendary item. You're going to be like,
29:57
"No." [laughter]
29:59
Um, but solicit a list. Try to get that
30:01
list put together. you know, a couple
30:03
items. And so now, what do you have? You
30:04
have a couple players at your table who
30:06
have said, "Hey, I'm looking for
30:07
something like this, or I'm looking for
30:09
one of these three items, and you can
30:11
find a reason for them to find that item
30:13
to give them that item to reward it to
30:15
them as part of a quest line where maybe
30:16
they have to pull the party with them to
30:18
to execute on it. For your other players
30:21
who, let's face it, might be too busy to
30:23
go do that research, might be too
30:24
unfamiliar with the game to like know
30:26
what even an option is." I think that's
30:28
where you as an experienced GM, somebody
30:29
who knows the game and knows the content
30:31
that's out there, can do exactly what
30:32
Ash said and look for the things that
30:35
are going to complete the way that
30:36
they're trying to play, enhance the
30:38
parts of the game that they seem to be
30:39
enjoying. And then when you give it to
30:40
them, you can mention it's like, yeah,
30:41
there's these other cool things, too,
30:43
but I think you're really going to enjoy
30:44
what this is. I I think that probably
30:46
strikes balance at the table where
30:47
you're you're bringing the players along
30:49
who don't know the game as much, but
30:51
still giving the other players an
30:52
opportunity to be excited about
30:54
particular things they think they'd
30:56
enjoy.
30:56
>> Yeah. And just to add on to that, like I
30:59
think if you're if you're going to ask
31:00
your players if players have a specific
31:02
item that they want, I think giving it
31:04
to them in random loot feels
31:06
underwhelming. So if they want a
31:08
specific type of a specific item, like
31:11
even one, let's just say a legendary
31:13
item, you can say no. Or you can make it
31:16
part of a quest, like a long quest
31:18
that's going to take them a time to
31:20
achieve, or maybe give them the
31:21
opportunity to craft it, or maybe buy
31:24
it. Don't do that. [laughter] But uh but
31:27
you know, you can make an entire quest
31:29
line of this player trying to find this
31:32
powerful magic item, which is what the
31:34
third arc of campaign one of Critical
31:37
Role was, was basically the players
31:39
trying to find these powerful weapons
31:40
called the vestages of divergence. And
31:42
it created like a really satisfying arc
31:44
with each of these players tracking down
31:46
each of these powerful artifacts. So
31:48
yeah, make a campaign out of it.
31:51
So, so my opinion bl so fourth edition
31:54
very like very explicitly in the dungeon
31:57
masters guide talking about magic items
31:59
just said yeah ask your players when you
32:01
start the game what magic items do they
32:02
want at each level cuz they understand
32:04
how this game works and they will need
32:06
these items to satisfy their builds for
32:08
their characters to work for the game to
32:10
be playable for them so just ask them
32:12
give it to them as loot when it makes
32:14
sense it's fine and for like all the
32:16
items had levels and stuff so you so
32:18
like PF2 you could say okay you for this
32:20
level, it is now safe for you to own
32:22
this item. Here you go. And that that
32:24
works in PF2. That works in 4 in 5e. I
32:28
agree with you guys. It does kind of
32:29
take away some of the specialness for
32:31
every item that they ask for to just
32:32
show up. So my thinking is don't
32:35
necessarily give them exactly what
32:37
they're asking for. Like give them the
32:39
thing that that satisfies the fantasy
32:41
that they want. Give them the thing that
32:43
does the thing that they need done, not
32:46
necessarily the item that they're asking
32:48
for. Like Henry Ford's line is if I'd
32:50
asked people what they wanted, they
32:52
would have set a faster horse. So like
32:54
your players might not know to ask for a
32:57
solution to problems that you as the DM
32:59
are seeing. So it's kind of on you to
33:01
try and, you know, balance that. Do do I
33:04
give them exactly what they want? Do I
33:05
give them something that solves this
33:07
problem for them that like they're
33:08
clearly struggling with but might not
33:10
know how to fix on their own? It's
33:12
interesting that one of the first
33:14
podcasts we ever recorded was you asking
33:16
for a better horse mechanic. [laughter]
33:23
[laughter]
33:25
All right. So, let's uh let's talk a
33:28
little about trading magic items. If
33:31
you're in if you're in 3x 4, PF2, like
33:35
you were used to being able to just go
33:37
into a store, buy items off the shelf.
33:39
In 5e that's kind of not a thing. Like
33:43
you can go and buy potions of healing.
33:45
If you're in strict haven, there's a
33:47
little table of like here's how you buy
33:48
like first level spell scrolls and plus
33:50
one weapons and they just cost X. So
33:52
those are just available there. Most of
33:54
the rest of the time it's just not an
33:56
option. Do we want it to be an option? I
33:59
think that depends on a few factors.
34:02
First, how high fantasy is your game? If
34:04
it's extremely high fantasy, then yes.
34:07
We talked a bit about like making magic
34:10
seem more powerful and I think scarcity
34:15
of magic items feeds into that fantasy.
34:17
If it's hard to find magic items and no
34:20
one's selling them. When you do find
34:21
something, it's a feat and it it
34:24
separates your player characters even
34:26
more from the average person because
34:28
you're finding these magic items that no
34:30
one else has. So, think about that.
34:33
Also, uh, don't break your game.
34:35
[laughter]
34:36
If you if you buy if you put if you put
34:39
a bunch of magic items for sale, you're
34:41
going to run into the Christmas tree
34:43
problem real quick and you're going to
34:45
run into situations where you're just
34:48
going to break your game because
34:50
depending on how how liberal you are
34:52
with your magic items, your players are
34:53
going to have a magic item for literally
34:55
any scenario that you could come up
34:56
with.
34:57
>> Yeah. I feel like the thing that you
34:58
can't do is you can't have ye old
35:02
general store [laughter]
35:04
where, you know, on the top shelf behind
35:06
the register is, you know, 12 cases of
35:08
dapper Dan [laughter] and a plus two
35:11
sword, right? We we can't think of these
35:13
magic items, especially magic items that
35:15
have significant mechanical impact as
35:17
things that the general store is going
35:19
to stock. And when I buy one and I I
35:21
throw it into the the chasm at the
35:23
dragon, I can just go back to the
35:24
general store the next day and buy the
35:26
other one that they pulled out of the
35:27
back. So I I I think that model doesn't
35:29
work. You know, we did this read at the
35:31
beginning with the the auction from
35:33
Describe. I can imagine having an
35:35
auction house in a big city where
35:37
interesting magic items occasionally
35:39
appear and you could even go up and you
35:41
could throw up a couple offers. You
35:42
could do some bids. You could probably
35:44
even build a random mechanic to see like
35:45
do do people drive up the bid or do you
35:47
get a good deal? So kind of do a mean
35:49
price and then use dice to decide
35:50
whether you go above or below that. In
35:52
that way you could kind of entice the
35:54
players like yeah here's a couple
35:55
different things that you might be
35:56
looking at what catches your eye. Let's
35:58
go model the bidding for that. So I I
36:00
think that mechanical work. The other
36:01
way that I think this could be
36:02
interesting because we do know we can
36:03
create magical items. So maybe you have
36:04
an artisan where you can go in and you
36:06
could talk to them about what you are
36:07
looking for. They could tell you what
36:09
they think they might be able to make
36:10
and maybe they do this for you for
36:12
money. Maybe they do this for you for a
36:14
favor. So like Ash said, you could
36:15
create a plot point out of it. I think
36:17
it in that way you can have that
36:20
experience of going into a venue where
36:23
you're going to trade goods or services
36:25
or just straight cash to acquire the
36:28
magic items, but it can't be the the the
36:31
market idea. It can't be the general
36:33
store.
36:34
>> Yeah.
36:34
>> Yeah, I agree with you. So, Zanithars
36:36
has some rules on this and I think that
36:38
auction house suggestion like that's a
36:41
great comparison. There's a downtime
36:44
activity detailed in Xanthars, which is
36:45
just find magic items for purchase and
36:48
you get a D4 items that are available
36:50
for you to purchase and the price is
36:53
like semi-randomized and the items are
36:55
randomly generated from those tables in
36:57
the DMG. So like you could spend several
36:59
days and find a trader who has like a a
37:03
plus one spear and a bag of holding and
37:08
a suit of plus one splint mail. And like
37:12
you as the the fighter are like, I want
37:14
none of those things.
37:15
>> Yeah. If you're going to do something
37:17
like this, like if you're going to make
37:19
items for sale, I think a good rule of
37:20
thumb if you don't want to go overboard,
37:22
don't sell anything that's higher than
37:24
rare value. Like I would say common and
37:26
uncommon are where I would limit it
37:28
because if you're selling things that
37:30
are rare, then it's not rare. [laughter]
37:34
>> That's fair.
37:35
>> That's how that works.
37:37
>> Yeah, actually that might be a good
37:38
dividing line. like limiting tradable
37:41
items to common and uncommon. That kind
37:43
of makes sense. In a lot of adventures,
37:46
nobility will have like plus one weapon.
37:48
So that means there's enough of them
37:51
that it's a status symbol, but getting a
37:54
plus two weapon, like that's a serious
37:56
big deal that that people generally
37:58
can't do, even if you're crazy rare.
38:00
>> Yeah. If you have something that's rare,
38:02
people are going to be talking about it.
38:04
like you you'll know where the rare
38:07
items are or they'll be a lost time.
38:10
They're not going to be for sale. That's
38:12
just not how that works. [snorts]
38:15
>> So, let's say let's say I've made a huge
38:17
mistake. I have allowed my players to
38:20
purchase rare items on the open market.
38:22
I have now fallen into the Christmas
38:24
tree problem. So, let's talk about that
38:26
disaster scenario where I have given my
38:29
players way too much stuff. We've fallen
38:32
into the Christmas tree problem. bobbles
38:34
hanging off of them. Their pockets full
38:36
of potions are incredibly incredibly
38:38
deep and numerous. They've had to find a
38:40
magical trench coat with extra pockets
38:43
for their healing potions.
38:44
>> They sewed together a bunch of bag of
38:45
holdings. Like we're one folding
38:47
accident away from accidentally putting
38:49
a bag of holding and a bag of holding
38:50
and killing us all. [laughter]
38:53
>> Just the worst laundry situation. First
38:56
of all, if you get into the situation,
38:58
sorry, you're you're kind of this is
39:01
kind of your fault and you're out of
39:03
luck. Now, there are ways that you can
39:06
fix it. None of them are good because
39:09
you're going to get players mad at you.
39:11
That's just that's just going to that's
39:13
people don't like having their toys
39:15
stolen. They don't like having their
39:16
toys taken away from them. They don't
39:18
like having their toys nerfed. And they
39:19
don't like having their toys destroyed.
39:21
So there are ways to deal with this, but
39:24
they are not good options. So don't get
39:26
in this situation.
39:28
>> Yeah, that's super fair. Ounce of cure,
39:32
pound of prevention or backwards,
39:35
>> [laughter]
39:35
>> ounce of prevention, pound of cure. I am
39:37
not a doctor.
39:38
>> Yeah. Yeah. Nor do you cure meats.
39:40
Anyway, [laughter]
39:42
I Yeah. Like what what can you do in
39:44
that situation if the goal is literally
39:45
just to strip items off of them? So, one
39:47
thing that you could do is like a
39:49
classic prison situation, like drug them
39:52
at the tavern and take against their
39:54
will with no saving throws or maybe with
39:56
saving throws, but cram them into prison
39:59
without their stuff just in their
40:01
leathers. And then when they find their
40:03
things, a bunch of stuff is missing.
40:04
They're going to hate you. Like, that's
40:06
terrible. This is bad. We're going to
40:08
Right. We all agree this is bad.
40:09
>> Yeah. No. N
40:11
>> now [laughter]
40:12
you could leave the clues about where
40:13
their stuff went and then like 10 levels
40:16
later when they're finally like at an
40:18
appropriate level for all the stuff that
40:20
they've accumulated like oh you found
40:21
your stuff and then they realize that
40:23
you know the real friends was the new
40:24
stuff they found along the way.
40:26
[laughter]
40:27
>> Yeah. I think so I don't want to
40:28
discount that having rivals or the bad
40:32
guy like steal a magic item or destroy a
40:34
magic item from your players can be a
40:37
good plot device. But I think that you
40:39
should limit it to items that are
40:42
essentially like mcguffins, like things
40:44
that are plot that are plot driven that
40:47
uh your players have and they realize is
40:49
important that everybody wants. Don't be
40:51
like that decanter of endless water is
40:54
really causing problems for my fireplane
40:57
setting. So, I'm going to target that
40:59
specifically even though it's not a
41:02
thing that everybody wants. It's just a
41:03
thing that I hate cuz your players will
41:05
see through that.
41:07
>> Yeah. So, if you're going to do the
41:08
stealing thing, like the only way that I
41:10
can really see it working without your
41:11
players getting instantly mad at you is
41:13
if you've already established how
41:15
important this item is and how much the
41:18
bad guys want it. So that when it's
41:20
stolen, they'll be upset, but they won't
41:22
be upset at you. They'll be upset at the
41:24
bad guys, but they will be like, "That's
41:25
fair. You set up this as like a thing
41:27
that people want, and it's only natural
41:29
that they would try to steal it. But if
41:30
it's just a thing that's irritating you,
41:32
just you're going to have to deal with
41:33
it, buddy. I'm sorry. [laughter]
41:37
So, something you can do to hopefully
41:40
avoid this situation. PF2 sets a cap on
41:43
how many items you can invest. Not every
41:45
item requires investment. It's kind of
41:47
like a tunement in 5e. Adventurers
41:49
League very specifically has like
41:51
depending on what tier of play you're
41:52
at, you can have x number of magic items
41:55
on your character when you go into a
41:57
session. You could just stick to those
42:00
guidelines. say like, "Look, I am aware
42:02
of my flaws as a DM, and I'm going to
42:04
rain treasure upon you, but I also need
42:07
the game to continue functioning, so
42:09
please just adhere to these numbers." It
42:11
It's still a pretty generous cap. Like,
42:14
the players will do just fine. A lot of
42:16
campaigns, you won't hit that magic item
42:18
number cap, but having it there as a
42:20
guard rail really helps cuz yeah, taking
42:23
items from your players is hard. Yeah,
42:25
if you're going to do that, I think
42:26
that's a good idea. But establish that
42:28
before you award any magic items. Have
42:31
that set up from the beginning because
42:32
it's like, okay, look, I am bad at this.
42:35
I'm And in case anybody's thinking I'm
42:38
just shaming people, I am bad at this.
42:40
[laughter] I give I am sometimes either
42:43
way too stingy or way too generous with
42:44
my magic items. So, trust me, I feel
42:46
your pain. So, just if it's something
42:49
that causes you a lot of anxiety, which
42:50
I know it does for me, just tell people,
42:52
"Hey, look, I'm don't know the proper
42:55
way to award a good amount of magic
42:57
items, so we're going to do this." Don't
42:59
do it in the middle of the campaign
43:00
after the damage is already done.
43:02
[laughter]
43:05
>> And [clears throat] if you do need to
43:07
take things away from your players,
43:08
sometimes the social fix is what you
43:10
should go to. Just say like, "Look, I
43:12
messed this up. Let's work this out. Can
43:14
we consolidate these items down to
43:16
something that you're happy with? Or
43:18
maybe you just solve the problem in
43:19
world, like an NPC comes to the players
43:21
and is like, "Hey, I hear you have a
43:24
plus two great axe, and I, this lower
43:27
level barbarian with pockets overflowing
43:29
with gold, would very much like that
43:31
plus two great axe. Can we work
43:33
something out?" Literally, just have the
43:35
players sell the magic items to NPCs in
43:39
the game for things that you want the
43:41
players to have. Maybe it's more gold.
43:43
Maybe it's a haunted house on a hill
43:44
that the next adventure takes place in.
43:46
Like,
43:47
>> yeah, that's not a bad idea.
43:48
>> You can make this work if you're clever.
43:49
>> Yeah.
43:50
>> Although, knowing my players, they would
43:51
sell it to the guy and then steal it
43:53
back from him. [laughter]
43:57
>> The uh the GTA solution, it's like,
43:59
okay, I've gotten what I wanted from
44:00
this NPC. I'm going to run them over now
44:02
and get my money back.
44:03
>> Mhm. But yeah, I think the ultimate
44:05
solution, just talk with your players,
44:08
see if you can find a compromise or a
44:09
solution. I think the best one that a
44:11
suggestion that we came up with is
44:13
Tyler's suggestion, which is, you know,
44:15
if players really want a thing like a a
44:18
fortress or something, have it require
44:19
them to give a magic item, maybe
44:21
something that they're not as attached
44:22
to. Like, you know, we especially if
44:24
you're giving a lot of magic items and
44:25
you run into the Christmas tree effect,
44:26
there are going to be some magic items
44:27
that your players are more attached to
44:29
than others. So, target the ones they're
44:31
not attached to. Don't target the ones
44:33
they are attached to. They won't be as
44:35
mad at you.
44:36
>> All right, this week we have a question
44:38
of the week. Our question of the week
44:39
comes to us from ppb on Discord. What is
44:42
your go-to snack and drink when you are
44:44
DMing?
44:45
>> I always try and avoid things that are
44:48
going to make me cough or get stuck in
44:50
my teeth. So, no nuts, no popcorn. I
44:53
really like pretzels. Like I I joke
44:55
about running beer and pretzels style
44:57
game, but I like to drink a beer and eat
45:00
some pretzels while I play games. Like,
45:02
they're a good go-to snack. It works.
45:04
They don't make a huge mess. I don't
45:06
spend half the session coughing. you you
45:08
belong in the Midwest. [laughter]
45:10
>> Here I am.
45:11
>> If you're hoping PBB for a a friendly
45:15
mulligan style rant about almonds,
45:17
you're going to be disappointed.
45:18
[laughter]
45:19
I typically will snack on cheese or
45:24
Cheetos is another staple for me. Pizza
45:27
cuz I'm the classic nerd. So [laughter]
45:30
yeah.
45:31
>> So when I'm DMing, I typically have
45:34
computer out, keyboard out, using the
45:35
mouse, all this. And so I don't like to
45:37
get my hands like sticky or dirty, this
45:39
sort of thing. So I actually do have
45:40
like I have a couple like, you know,
45:42
Costco sized things of nuts that I eat
45:44
because that isn't something that gets
45:45
me super messy. But yeah, like I'm I'm
45:47
not going to get chicken wings, right?
45:48
Cuz at that point it's like I need to
45:49
flip to this other monster and see what
45:51
the tab is. But I can't. So I'm just
45:52
going to have to estimate like Yeah, it
45:53
doesn't work. I Yeah, I like beer. I
45:56
like a good cocktail. The problem is if
45:59
you're running a session and everybody
46:01
is laughing and having a great time,
46:02
like let's say you've got like a
46:03
three-hour session that you're going if
46:05
you keep drinking cocktails the entire
46:07
time, you get to the last 30 minutes of
46:09
the session and like [laughter] who
46:12
knows what's going on. I think so, so
46:14
Tyler and I participated in a TPK
46:16
playing Rhyme of the Frostmaidaiden and
46:18
I'm fairly certain that's partially what
46:20
happened to us. We had a new friend who
46:22
joined. The DM was rolling. There was
46:24
great. There were like three different
46:25
kinds of bourbon on the virtual screen
46:27
and then the next day I woke up and we
46:28
had all died. [laughter]
46:29
>> Hey, there's something to be said about
46:31
drunkards and dungeons, okay? Uh
46:35
drinking drunk Dungeons and Dragons
46:36
could be fun, but
46:38
>> it could it could be a ton of fun. Just
46:40
it has its consequences.
46:41
>> DM DM responsibly. DM responsibly.
46:45
>> Yeah. [laughter]
46:46
And and so sincerely, I think that that
46:48
is the one piece that I'll say to is
46:49
like I Yeah. I love to have a drink. I
46:51
that is a great way if it's something
46:53
that you enjoy doing. It's a great way
46:54
to play any tabletop game. But being
46:56
metered and kind of recognizing it's
46:58
like okay is it getting to the point
46:59
where I can't help advance the story
47:00
because you as the DM you have a little
47:03
bit more responsibility to make sure
47:04
that the story continues beyond what the
47:06
players have. So kind of I think they're
47:08
putting your trust they're putting their
47:10
trust in you to tell a good story that's
47:12
going to continue on next week. And so I
47:14
think this is a place where you have to
47:15
really be measured. I will say my
47:18
roommate Matt when he's running his
47:19
games, whenever we're in a bar and he
47:22
comes up with a drink, he will pour
47:24
drinks into our big tinkerers that we
47:25
have [laughter]
47:27
>> cuz he's kind of a mixologist. So that
47:29
is a way you can play the game and it's
47:31
quite an enjoyable way to play the game.
47:33
[laughter]
47:35
I should also say like I as we've
47:37
started going to conventions more, I've
47:39
gotten to actually play convention games
47:41
a few times and I'm finding if I'm at a
47:43
convention table, just water. Like as
47:45
much as I enjoy having a beer, like if I
47:47
have a beer or two during the game and
47:48
it's like a 3 4 hour game, I'm going to
47:51
get sleepy cuz apparently that's what
47:53
happens to me now.
47:54
>> What about coffee or soda?
47:56
>> Uh yeah, I could do coffee martini.
47:59
>> I martini. Yeah, I don't think they
48:01
usually serve those at conventions,
48:03
unfortunately. We really need like a Red
48:05
Bull in vodka. Imagine going to a
48:06
fourloo convention.
48:08
>> Oh god.
48:08
>> Oh god. [laughter]
48:11
>> Everybody's going to die. That's what's
48:13
going to happen.
48:13
>> Yeah. Okay. Do Do we all agree that
48:15
nobody has Has anybody ever drank a
48:16
fourloo and play tabletop?
48:18
>> No. Not play table I have done a forloo
48:20
is No.
48:21
>> Okay. PPV. We do not endorse for Loco
48:24
and tabletop.
48:25
>> No. I just don't endorse for Loco in
48:28
general. Don't do Loco. [laughter]
48:32
Okay. I'm going to I'm going to give one
48:33
more. So, all all of our answers I think
48:35
were were fine and they were honest. One
48:37
more thing I'll add to this and I I
48:39
think I think Stubbins does Discord does
48:41
a good job of this. I feel like there's
48:42
a few other folks like maybe Wing Lady
48:44
and Gle Rock do this as well. Like doing
48:47
basically I don't want to say medieval
48:49
food cuz it was still food then. What's
48:50
what's the phrase I'm looking for?
48:52
Right. Like roast some turkey legs, make
48:55
a spread, have a long session, and then
48:58
pull the spread out part of the way
48:59
through the session. So like we're going
49:00
to go to the banquet. And by that I mean
49:02
we're gonna go to the banquet, right?
49:04
You can't do that for every session, but
49:05
I feel like especially if you hit a
49:06
milestone session or a session near the
49:08
holidays, that's a great way to have a
49:10
holiday party with your party is to have
49:13
them over, play a little bit, have a
49:15
feast, and then use the feast to
49:16
actually advance the RP. I feel like
49:18
I've done that with chicken wings after
49:19
all of my ranting against chicken wings.
49:21
[laughter]
49:22
They're like turkey legs. I fed Matt and
49:25
them a hearty stew once.
49:27
>> It was good. It was a beer stew. It was
49:28
delicious. [laughter] All hail the
49:30
leisure Illuminati. I'm Rand James.
49:32
You'll find me at amateurjack.com and on
49:34
Twitter and Instagram, jackamate.
49:36
>> I'm Tyler Campra. You'll find me at
49:37
rpgbot.net, Facebook and Twitter, RPG,
49:40
B, DOT, NE, and most other socials as
49:43
RPGbot.
49:44
>> And I'm Ashi. You can follow me on
49:46
Twitter, Graven Ashes, where I announce
49:48
all the things that I'm doing.
49:50
>> If you've enjoyed the show, please rate
49:51
and review us on Apple Podcast and read
49:53
us on Spotify or your favorite podcast
49:54
app. It's a quick free way to support
49:56
the podcast and helps us to reach new
49:58
listeners. You'll find links in the show
49:59
notes. You'll find affiliate links for
50:01
source books and other materials linked
50:02
in the show notes as well as on
50:03
rpgbot.net. [music]
50:05
Following these links helps us to make
50:06
this show happen every week. If your
50:08
question should be the question of the
50:09
week next week, please email podcast at
50:11
rpgbot.net or message us on Twitter at
50:13
rpgbot dot n. Please also consider
50:17
supporting us [music] on Patreon where
50:18
you'll find ad free podcast episodes,
50:20
early access to rpgbot.content, polls
50:23
for future content, and access to the
50:24
rpgbot. [music]
50:25
Discord. You'll find us at
50:26
patreon.comrpgbot.
50:29
>> I don't think I can blame this one on
50:31
beer.
50:31
>> Nope.
50:32
>> Or tequila. [laughter]
Games

