2024 DMG: BASTIONS – Fortress-Building for the Adventurer – RPGBOT.Podcast S4E134
Apr 30, 2026
Ever wanted to own real estate… in D&D? The latest RPGBOT.Podcast episode breaks down the 2024 Dungeon Master’s Guide’s new Bastion system, aka “castle maintenance but with monsters.”
This episode originally aired on November 17th, 2024, and we're currently working to upload our episode backlog. For the latest from the RPGBOT.Podcast, find us in your favorite podcatcher.
Full show notes for this episode are available on RPGBOT.net: https://rpgbot.net/2024-dmg-bastions-fortress-building-for-the-adventurer-with-too-much-downtime-rpgbot-podcast-s4e134/
Find us on socials and stuff:
🦋 https://bsky.app/profile/rpgbot.bsky.social
⏰ https://www.tiktok.com/@rpgbotdotnet
🔍 https://RPGBOT.net/
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
from Italian plumber to Jamaican.
0:03
>> I mean, it was it was pretty good.
0:05
Honestly, it was just the man at the
0:06
end. Like, if you didn't do that, I
0:07
think everything else would have flowed.
0:09
>> Get your house in order.
0:11
>> No, still Jamaican.
0:12
>> No, no, no. I It worked. It was smooth.
0:14
I liked it.
0:15
>> Um, okay. I hope Dan goes back to that
0:18
one minute clip and pulls the jokes from
0:20
it.
0:20
>> Probably. Same.
0:21
>> That's fair. I think Ash wins. Ash is
0:23
probably right. But Dan, if you're
0:24
listening to this right now, if there's
0:26
a one minute recording sitting there,
0:27
like three minutes, whatever it was, I I
0:28
can't tell time. What do I look like? A
0:30
clock. Yes.
0:31
>> You might want some of that content.
0:33
Okay. Okay.
0:33
>> Yeah. We're going to talk about
0:34
Bastion's. But before we do that, I'll
0:36
do the intro to the podcast, Tyler,
0:38
>> that checks out.
0:39
>> Did you put your cat in a straight
0:40
jacket yet?
0:40
>> I did.
0:41
>> Brilliant. Okay. Why is my upload speed?
0:44
Give me just before we actually get
0:45
going.
0:46
>> It's too upload speed's a little slow
0:48
tonight, too.
0:48
>> It's too bad I didn't get to see Tyler
0:51
running away with his cat. That's always
0:52
entertaining. Like you'll just see him
0:54
in the background. He's just holding it
0:56
like it's like it's some sort of toxic
0:58
waste and just like running in the
1:00
background while the catch
1:03
>> has anyone seen the Adam West Batman
1:06
episode where he carries a giant bomb
1:09
and spends the entire episode trying to
1:11
figure out what to do with it. It is
1:13
exactly that. It except it is my cat and
1:15
she is screaming.
1:16
>> Yep. That's an accurate depiction.
1:20
>> Okay.
1:44
Welcome to the RPGBOT podcast. I'm
1:46
Reynold James and with me is Tyler
1:48
Camstra.
1:49
>> Hi everybody. and Ashy lie.
1:51
>> So, welcome to my apartment. This would
1:53
be my bastion. It's not what I would
1:55
call defensible, but it's mine.
1:58
>> I wish I got benefits from it, but you
2:01
know what I do get from it is a lifetime
2:03
of pain and financial struggle.
2:05
>> A
2:07
do you have defenders in it at least,
2:09
right?
2:10
>> No,
2:10
>> there's two dogs that they count. Yeah.
2:12
Either either they're defenders or you
2:14
have
2:14
>> more as a doorbell than a defense
2:16
system. Like no, it's it's hilarious
2:19
because our doorbell is actually broken.
2:21
So it doesn't it makes a sound, but it's
2:24
it's not a sound that humans can hear.
2:27
It's only a sound that dogs can hear. So
2:29
like someone will push it and
2:31
immediately the dogs go
2:35
like, "Oh, someone's here. Someone's
2:37
here."
2:39
>> So it's it's a roundabout doorbell.
2:41
>> Yes. Exactly. Yeah.
2:42
>> And then immediately what will happen is
2:44
they'll run down they'll run out from
2:46
wherever they are to whoever is the
2:48
offender that comes in and just looks at
2:50
them and they're like, "Okay, you're
2:51
fine." And then they'll leave the room
2:53
to like go to the bathroom or something
2:55
for like maybe 30 seconds and they COME
2:57
BACK AND LIKE A NEW PERSON, NEW PERSON.
2:59
WHO ARE YOU? OH, OKAY. YOU'RE FINE.
3:02
GUYS, literally just here.
3:04
>> I just expected to be this dude again.
3:07
That's wild. Especially because I didn't
3:10
hear the doorbell.
3:14
>> Bastions.
3:15
>> Bastions.
3:16
>> All right, folks. This is the second
3:17
episode we're doing the 2024 Dungeon
3:20
Masters Guide. And when I say that, what
3:22
I really mean is the DMG for 5.5.
3:24
>> Yeah. Has been made available to us. Our
3:27
previous episode, we did a quick rundown
3:29
of what we thought about the book. A lot
3:31
of the content that we found
3:32
interesting, some of the content we
3:33
didn't find interesting, a few things
3:35
that made us angry, and the one thing
3:36
that we didn't really dive into was the
3:39
entire chapter committed to Bastions.
3:41
And the reason is because we're talking
3:43
about it tonight in its own episode.
3:46
>> This has be this has been the beginning
3:48
of that episode, and from here we're
3:50
going to continue it.
3:51
>> For some reason, when I was reading
3:53
through bastions, I just kept thinking,
3:55
what would the what if you were trying
3:57
to claim a bastion? and the Frenchmen
4:00
from Montipython the Holy Grail were
4:02
just already taking it.
4:05
>> GO INSIDE YOUR MOTHERS, YOU LITTLE PIG
4:08
DOGS. I'm fart in your general
4:10
direction.
4:14
>> I I'm pretty sure I'm pretty sure that's
4:16
just the attack event.
4:20
>> You come back, you come back and it's
4:22
just a bunch of salty freshman
4:25
Frenchmen.
4:27
Maybe some freshman. That would be
4:28
funny.
4:29
>> No, that's that's my lieutenant. It's a
4:30
French word, obviously.
4:34
>> All right. So, before we jump into the
4:37
mechanics, I want to call back to the
4:39
unearthed arcana that gave us the first
4:41
peak at bastions for the the one D and D
4:45
play test leading into the 2024 rules.
4:48
We got an unearthed arcana, the primary
4:50
content of which was the new bastion
4:53
system. We also got cantrips, which I'm
4:55
pretty sure sure were just thrown in
4:57
there in case everyone hated bastions.
5:01
The bastion system was generally praised
5:03
as like this is a great idea. We love
5:05
that they're including this. The
5:07
mechanics need a little bit of work. If
5:09
you have read those things, the only
5:12
things, not the only things like most of
5:14
the change has been pretty minor. You'll
5:16
notice that the bastion points system
5:18
completely gone. It was overly
5:20
complicated and annoying. Gone. But in
5:23
removing that, they basically took all
5:25
the safeguards off of using bastions.
5:28
That's definitely a problem. We'll get
5:30
to that.
5:31
>> They they locked it. They locked some of
5:32
the more powerful stuff behind levels. I
5:34
will say I was looking at it and and you
5:36
know, you have a better eye for this
5:38
when you first read it than I do, Tyler.
5:40
I don't really see how this is super
5:42
abuse.
5:44
Like the stuff that you get, especially
5:45
at low levels, is incredibly
5:46
underwhelming.
5:47
>> Oh, yeah. Low levels. I agree.
5:49
>> Oh, okay. And and Tyler, yeah, you're
5:51
going to surprise me as well. When when
5:52
I read it and I look at it, it's like at
5:54
every level, the things that I can get
5:56
from this feel underwhelming. When I
5:58
look at my level 17 character and I'm
6:00
like, "Oh, look, all these things that
6:01
are unlocked to me, I I'm fine."
6:03
>> Also, also, I will say if this scares
6:06
you, I'm just going to say this. If this
6:08
scares you, Tyler, or anybody else like
6:10
looking at this like, "Oh, this is this
6:12
is a lot." I encourage you to read
6:14
Strongholds and followers because the
6:17
power curve there is way bigger. You can
6:20
craft custom spells in your own wizard
6:23
tower in that one.
6:24
>> Oh yeah,
6:24
>> that's cool.
6:25
>> Mhm.
6:26
>> I mean, incredibly powerful, but also
6:28
>> Oh, yeah.
6:29
>> Very cool.
6:29
>> Yeah, very cool.
6:30
>> Okay, but but you do that by rolling on
6:32
a table and strongholds and followers,
6:34
right?
6:34
>> You can you can also just work with the
6:36
DM and say Okay, I got you. I got you.
6:39
like the Okay, so the mechanics that are
6:41
provided I think have reasonable guard
6:43
rails and strongholds and followers,
6:45
which is not the point of this episode,
6:46
but it's worth talking about cuz it's
6:47
really comparable material.
6:49
>> We might we might talk about strongholds
6:51
and followers later on in the episode
6:53
because it's inevitable that it's
6:55
inevitable that they're going to get
6:56
compared. So yeah,
6:58
>> and that's why we started there. But so
7:00
like the mechanics of it pretty
7:01
reasonable, pretty well bounded. And
7:03
then obviously Yeah. If you say we're
7:04
going to leave the mechanics that are
7:06
provided and just say you can create a
7:07
spell. Yeah. No, you could. Things are
7:09
gonna get broken. It's gonna be great.
7:11
>> Yeah. No, I'm excited to see I'm excited
7:13
to see how Tyler breaks everything
7:15
because I I mean, I can see some obvious
7:17
ways, but I'm curious to see if there's
7:19
stuff I miss.
7:20
>> So, before we do that, Tyler, I have to
7:22
ask you a question. Okay. What is a
7:24
Bastion? That is a great question,
7:27
Randall. At its at its most basic, it's
7:31
just where your adventurer lives. Like
7:34
there are some specific there are some
7:36
specific mechanics. Obviously
7:38
>> this healthy is my bastion.
7:39
>> It could be honestly the strangest
7:42
things like you get to you get to add
7:45
certain features to your bastion
7:46
completely for free. Hallways, windows,
7:49
doors completely free. So if you just
7:52
want your bastion to be an insane maze
7:54
of hallways and doors that's infinitely
7:56
large, that is technically within the
7:59
rules.
8:00
>> Okay, I just got to find the real estate
8:01
for it.
8:02
>> Is it?
8:02
You I thought you had to pay money to
8:04
get certain rooms. I'm pretty sure
8:06
>> most rooms. Yes. Saying like those
8:09
aren't rooms. They're free.
8:10
>> Yeah. Hallways, windows, doors, and
8:12
washrooms are all Oh, closets, too.
8:14
Those are all free. Those five things.
8:16
You could have as many bathrooms in your
8:18
in your bastion as you want completely
8:20
for free.
8:21
>> Okay. But facility space,
8:24
>> they're not facilities. That's the
8:25
trick.
8:26
>> Okay. But they do count bedroom, dining
8:28
room, parlor, courtyard, kitchen, and
8:30
storage as facilities. Yes.
8:32
>> So you couldn't put ba bathrooms don't
8:34
exist. They're not an option.
8:37
>> Search for washroom. They use the word
8:38
washroom. I don't know why. Look, they
8:41
probably ran it by some consultant. Like
8:43
what is the politest term we can use for
8:46
bathroom here?
8:46
>> So the Canadian
8:47
>> I like that you're factchecking this.
8:48
This is the explicit thing that Tyler
8:50
wanted to come in with first is that you
8:52
could have an infinite maze of hallways.
8:54
I don't know why you would do that, but
8:56
sure. Me neither.
8:57
>> But but but just first way first way to
8:59
break it though is like I'm going to
9:00
have a bastion in a city and
9:02
mechanically I'm allowed to occupy more
9:05
than the volume of the city.
9:06
>> I will say I think that as with all
9:09
things, the caveat there is with DM
9:12
permission.
9:13
>> If you're like, I'm going to find a way
9:14
to make this an infinitely large
9:16
bastion, the DM's like, no, you're not.
9:19
>> All right, we're not doing bastions.
9:20
We're done away. No.
9:23
All right. So, more seriously, the
9:26
basics of bastions. At level five, if
9:28
you are using the bastion rules at level
9:30
five, each character in the party
9:32
receives a bastion. It is left up to the
9:36
table to decide how they acquire their
9:38
bastions. There are some suggestions
9:40
like they might receive a bastion as a
9:42
quest reward. They might build one on
9:44
some land that they acquired somehow.
9:47
And you're encouraged to find something
9:48
that fits with the story of your
9:50
campaign. So, like that all feels great.
9:52
>> Yeah. The Yarl of White Run now really
9:54
likes you and wants to give you the
9:55
opportunity to buy property.
9:57
>> Speak to prevents.
9:59
>> All right. So, you you now own Breeze
10:01
Home. Uh, as part of acquiring Breeze
10:04
Home, you get two basic facilities of
10:06
your choice. One is cramped, one is
10:08
roomy. The cramped bedroom is the loft
10:11
upstairs, which contains a bed and
10:13
exactly nothing. And then the roomy den
10:15
is downstairs, which has a nice
10:17
fireplace and a couple of basic pieces
10:18
of furniture. That's right. I made
10:22
Yeah. What's funny is bastions do come
10:25
with hierlings who you don't have to
10:28
pay.
10:29
>> So it's Lydia. It's Lydia 100%.
10:31
>> 100%.
10:33
Okay. Uh on the subject of hierlings
10:35
that you don't have to pay, they're not
10:36
slaves. Your your bastion
10:39
>> technically you're not paying them. So
10:42
technically they're slaves.
10:44
>> Your B explicitly your bastion generates
10:47
enough revenue to pay their salaries.
10:50
Like there is a specific line like your
10:52
bastion is selfunding.
10:54
>> Are people visiting your bastion and
10:56
just be like no that's a thing that
10:58
happens.
10:58
>> Yeah. This is show up. Yeah.
11:00
>> Sure. But I'm just like is your house a
11:02
museum like like some sort of celebrity
11:04
museum where people are just like and
11:06
over here we have G we have the the the
11:10
big axe that Girthy got. I don't know.
11:13
Girthy the goblin. Girthy the go.
11:15
>> Just just alas. I am the high king of
11:18
Skyrim and everyone must pay me taxes
11:20
with which to pay my bastion people.
11:22
>> Exactly.
11:23
>> I mean, technically you don't pay Lydia
11:24
either.
11:27
She's just sworn to carry your burdens.
11:29
>> Yeah. Who pays Lydia? Where does she
11:31
live?
11:32
>> I believe my dragon.
11:33
>> I believe the Yarao plate pays Lily.
11:35
>> Okay, I'm going to go with that. That's
11:37
great. Okay.
11:37
>> Yeah, sure.
11:38
>> Um I'm I'm going to bring us back. Okay.
11:40
So, like like you said, uh at level
11:43
five, anybody in the party who wants a
11:46
bastion can have a bastion if your DM is
11:49
letting the party have bastions. I I
11:51
think it's worth talking through now
11:52
like the the structure of this. So, you
11:54
know, oh, let's get together and let's
11:56
build like one big mansion cuz we like
11:58
hanging out together anyway. Sort of
12:00
doable. We'll get into the the mechanics
12:02
of a single bastion, but essentially you
12:04
can't mix and mingle and share
12:06
facilities. Your bastion is your
12:07
bastion. Your rooms are your rooms. But
12:10
you could have them be part of like the
12:12
same outpost or the same structure.
12:15
There's a couple specific things where
12:16
you actually can mingle and we'll get to
12:18
that in a little bit. Yes. On facilities
12:21
specifically, you can't share special
12:24
facilities. You can share basic
12:26
facilities. So basic facilities are like
12:29
bedrooms, kitchens, stuff that you would
12:31
have in a completely normal, mundane,
12:34
not full of magical murder tourists
12:37
house. Yeah. the the stuff that's not
12:39
super mechanically impactful.
12:40
>> Yeah. Explicitly zero mechanical impact.
12:43
No basic facilities specifically have no
12:46
mechanical effect on the game. They're
12:48
purely story devices.
12:51
All right. So, we talked about getting
12:52
Bastion. We talked about the basic
12:54
facilities. We will get to spe to
12:56
special facilities in a little bit. I
12:59
mentioned how you can get a bunch of
13:00
stuff for free in your Bastion.
13:03
hallways, closets, washrooms,
13:05
staircases, doors, windows, and if you
13:07
have defensive walls, port colises, so
13:09
like ways in and out, ways between
13:12
rooms, all of those things completely
13:14
for free. And you are encouraged to draw
13:16
your bastion basically however you want.
13:18
>> Can I put a port colis as an entrance to
13:20
my washroom so that people can only use
13:23
it if I have express permission?
13:26
>> I'm pretty sure I'm pretty sure you can
13:28
only put port colises in defensive
13:31
walls, unfortunately. You said I could
13:33
do infinite of those
13:36
>> techies on the placement. Yeah,
13:38
>> there's nothing stopping you from
13:39
putting the bathroom attached to the
13:41
defensive wall and then having a port
13:43
colis into it. That's what I'm saying.
13:45
See what I'm saying? The only downside
13:47
to it is that you're kind of exposed to
13:49
everybody.
13:50
>> Well, imagine having a murder hole
13:53
>> like
13:55
I'm going to stop you right there. This
13:58
is a joke that I made that went way too
14:00
far. This is going to get bad.
14:03
>> Yeah, let's move on.
14:06
>> Their second best joke of the night.
14:08
Number two.
14:09
>> It was a good joke, buddy. It was a good
14:11
joke, but it was
14:12
>> number two.
14:13
>> Familyfriendly podcast.
14:15
>> In addition to the basic facilities, in
14:18
addition to those freebies that you can
14:20
use to decorate and interconnect your
14:22
bastion, you can also buy defensive
14:25
walls to encircle your bastion. We'll
14:27
talk about defending your bastion later.
14:29
They're stupid expensive. 250 gold
14:32
pieces per five foot square. Now,
14:34
they're 20 feet they're 20 feet tall and
14:36
have a walkway on top. So, like that's a
14:38
ton of masonry. I get it. But still,
14:40
like that's a lot to ask, man. And in a
14:44
game where wizards can just cast wall of
14:46
stone and do it themselves. Like, what
14:48
are we doing? Why bother?
14:50
>> Well, you asked for a gold task tax and
14:52
you asked for gold to actually matter.
14:55
Well, there you go.
14:56
>> We've got it.
14:57
>> Gold tax.
14:58
>> I want to call this out while we're
14:59
here, Tyler. So, you're talking about
15:00
the cost of building defensive walls. I
15:02
also want to call out it takes 10 days
15:04
to build a 5ft section of defensive
15:07
wall. Yeah. Now, there's nothing that
15:09
says you couldn't parallelize that,
15:10
assuming there's just infinite
15:11
stonemasons running around. And I think
15:13
as a DM, allow that. But 10 days, I want
15:16
a wall put up. It's going to take 10
15:17
days. Think about your adventures and
15:19
think about how many things happen in 10
15:21
days time. This is going to be a
15:22
recurring theme as we talk about some of
15:24
the other things that we could build.
15:25
We've already talked about the basic
15:27
facilities, so maybe it's worth talking
15:28
about that right quick. uh you know
15:30
cramped, roomy, vast. A cramped space
15:33
takes 20 days to build. A roomy space
15:35
takes 45 days to build. A vast space
15:38
takes 125 days to build. Imagine saying
15:41
like I want to add a vast living area
15:44
for everybody to come together and like
15:46
join. I want to have feasts in this room
15:47
and it's going to be awesome. I have to
15:49
wait a third of a year. The campaign's
15:51
going to be over. I'm going to be level
15:52
20 and retired. It the room better be
15:55
done by then because I'm going to spend
15:56
the rest of my life here. 120 days.
15:58
>> Yeah.
16:00
125 days. Yeah. Yeah.
16:02
>> It's good. It's probably good to point
16:04
out that again, this is just a caveat
16:07
that's on all of this podcast and this
16:09
section. This is an optional system. You
16:12
have to use this. I feel like bastions
16:14
are a very specific type of game.
16:17
They're a type of game kind of like King
16:19
Maker where you're dealing with large
16:21
amounts of downtime and large amounts of
16:24
uh flash forward and that kind of stuff.
16:26
So if you're not doing that, don't do
16:28
bastions.
16:29
>> Yeah, don't do bastions. If you're
16:31
running like Tomb of Anni Island, why
16:32
why would you do that?
16:34
>> At the end of this episode, I want to
16:36
talk exactly about that of like the
16:38
kinds of things that would make sense. I
16:39
will say just I want to harp on time a
16:42
little bit as a DM. This is probably the
16:45
part of the system I most likely throw
16:47
out.
16:47
>> The time requirements.
16:49
>> Yeah. Not to say that I'm going to make
16:50
it zero time, but I'm probably going to
16:53
have a bastion wizard just run around
16:54
like, "Oh, you got gold. Poof, there's
16:56
your room.
16:57
>> Yeah. Just just go go Animal Crossing.
16:59
It's like, "Oh, you want you want your
17:01
house expanded? Sure. Pay me in the
17:03
morning. It'll be done."
17:04
>> I don't I don't agree. I I I get that
17:08
temptation, but I think it's a good
17:10
balance balancing factor and it feels
17:13
more right for it to take time. I agree
17:15
that maybe the time is a little
17:17
excessive, but in some places, but I
17:19
will say I don't think Strongholds and
17:21
followers changed much in that respect.
17:24
stuff.
17:24
>> It also took time to
17:25
>> You're not You are absolutely not
17:27
getting a bastion in in Plscape closet.
17:30
No way. You guys already have a
17:32
technical bastion. It's your walking
17:34
castle. Do you need more than that? No,
17:36
I don't think you do.
17:38
>> Yeah. Uh, for listeners at home, Curious
17:40
Quaset in the chat says, "Ash, when are
17:42
we getting individual bastions in
17:44
Plscape? I want to make a house in
17:46
AOSAR's head." Ash,
17:47
>> that's not going to happen.
17:48
>> Apparently not. Sorry, buddy.
17:50
>> Oh, yeah. Yeah, they're going to
17:51
Aoscar's head. That's happening.
17:53
landscapes are wild.
17:55
>> Yeah. Okay. So, on on the subject of how
17:58
annoyingly long it takes to build
18:00
facilities, build and expand them, the
18:03
wording of how you do it specifically
18:05
says it costs X gold and Y time. Like
18:09
you must you must spend X gold and Y
18:12
time, which means however long it takes
18:14
to build that facility, you are there
18:17
building it. So, it's not 120 days and
18:20
like you go on vacation and come back to
18:22
like, "Oh, my house has been renovated.
18:23
Great. Good job, general contractor."
18:26
No, it's you.
18:27
>> I have a problem with that then. Yeah.
18:28
No. Okay. If you have to be there for
18:30
the entire time, then yes, Randle's
18:32
point makes sense to me. If it's just
18:33
something that can be done in the
18:34
background while you go adventuring, I
18:36
feel that's fair. That's fine. And to
18:39
make
18:40
>> You're not a You're an adventurer.
18:41
You're not a contractor. Are you kidding
18:43
me?
18:44
>> Yeah.
18:45
>> The work's going to be so much better if
18:46
I don't do it. But if I don't even see
18:48
it done, that's the best way to
18:49
guarantee it's going to be good work.
18:50
But again, I can imagine DM DMP at like
18:53
I left for 30 days. I came back. I've
18:55
got good people working to hire the
18:57
right people and I pay them well and
18:58
they got the work done. Great.
19:00
>> Yeah. If you're going to if you're
19:01
asking one of some of my characters to
19:05
build like a fortification or an actual
19:08
room, that room is not going to be up to
19:10
code and it is going to fall over in a
19:12
stiff wind cuz my character does not
19:14
know how to build things. Are you
19:16
kidding me? That is the dumbest thing
19:17
I've ever heard. Yeah. No, ignore that
19:20
rule. That's stupid. I didn't see that.
19:22
>> I will say, Tyler, I I didn't read it
19:24
the same way that you did that like you
19:27
absolutely had to be there for the time.
19:29
I
19:30
>> feel that I am being too pedantic.
19:31
>> I Yeah, I I would hope most people will
19:34
not interpret it that way. I'll read
19:37
I'll read the line. A character can
19:39
spend money and time to increase the
19:41
space of a basic facility. Now, the fact
19:43
that they said you can spend money and
19:44
time, I do understand Tyler's point of
19:46
like, what does it mean to say they're
19:47
spending time unless they're spending
19:49
time there? I think it would have been
19:50
better to say something like can spend
19:52
the money and let time pass.
19:54
>> Mhm.
19:55
>> Yeah, they phrased it badly. I think
19:57
that is a very specific way you're
19:59
reading it, Tyler. I don't think that's
20:01
the way they intended it. I would be
20:03
shock I would be shocked if that's the
20:05
way they intended it cuz that's dumb and
20:06
I hate it. But, you know, Dn D surprised
20:08
me before, but I feel like that's a
20:10
generous reading of that. Ash, I I'm
20:13
gonna tell you right now, the more time
20:15
we spend with this, the more times you
20:17
are going to say that exact sentence.
20:19
>> Okay,
20:21
but I mean, here's the thing. Usually
20:23
the usually when you point out things
20:25
are bad, it's because you have a very
20:27
hyperfixated specific reading of a thing
20:29
that I just think is true.
20:30
>> Okay, that's what the words say. I don't
20:33
think you're factoring in that a lot of
20:36
the way that and I'm not disagreeing
20:38
with you that and this is this is just
20:41
uh how Tyler approaches things is like
20:42
but it's that's what the text says and
20:44
we have to go by literally the letter of
20:46
the text when that's all they give us
20:48
>> right but then the developers have made
20:50
it abundantly clear these past like 10
20:53
years that they leave a lot to
20:55
interpretation and the spirit of the
20:56
rules almost never matches the letter of
21:00
the rules. So
21:01
>> yeah,
21:02
>> I know that's frustrating. I know what I
21:05
wrote,
21:05
>> but it's the it's the company we're
21:07
working with.
21:08
>> That that gets into kind of a spicy
21:10
discussion around like rules as written,
21:13
rules as intended. Sometimes you can
21:14
read the rules as written and say like,
21:16
okay, the intent here was clear even if
21:19
the rules as written aren't. But then
21:21
there's times where the rules as written
21:23
and the rules as intended directly
21:26
disagree with each other. And then it's
21:27
like unless you give us the sage advice
21:29
saying specifically where you got things
21:31
wrong here as players were left in the
21:33
wind.
21:34
>> No, I don't disagree with you. That's a
21:35
big problem with 5v.
21:37
>> What was what was Trin Monk's line on
21:38
this? Cuz we we brought up rules as
21:40
written with him and he like immediately
21:42
jumped on it. He hated that. What
21:44
>> he hates rules is written. He he doesn't
21:46
like how a lot of people use the phrase
21:48
rules is written because there are
21:50
people who use the phrase rules is
21:52
written specifically when there is no
21:55
rules text on a subject. They say the
21:58
rules don't say that I can't do this so
22:01
I can't do this. Like that's not rules
22:03
as written. That is assuming rules by
22:06
omission. That is a very different
22:07
>> rules is omitted. Yeah, but no, I I also
22:10
think it's just because when people
22:12
bring up rules is written uh and rules
22:14
lawyers, I forget what YouTuber said
22:16
this, but rules rules negot rules
22:19
lawyers are different from rules
22:21
negotiators. Like rules rules lawyers
22:24
just very much like want to make sure
22:26
that everybody's just following the the
22:28
spirit of the rules and make sure that
22:29
everything is going well. Rules
22:31
negotiators only seem to care about
22:33
rules when it allows them to exploit the
22:35
rules. It's like but that's what the
22:37
rules is written say but then they won't
22:39
bring it up when the rules is written go
22:41
against their so that's why there's a
22:44
lot of and I've met people like that and
22:46
it drives me up the wall which is why
22:49
I'm kind of with tree monk on this where
22:51
I'm like I don't care what the rules say
22:53
I know what the intention is here and
22:55
the way that you're in you're reading it
22:57
is stupid
23:00
>> yeah I all right I hope they do a better
23:02
job in the 2024 explaining what their
23:05
intent is
23:06
>> I agree with you. I hate that we have to
23:09
I hate that we have to have this
23:10
discussion especially, you know, cuz
23:12
there are other systems that very
23:14
explicitly say that there's a what
23:16
they're trying to say.
23:17
>> All right, so let's talk about basic
23:19
facilities in my bastions.
23:21
>> Yeah.
23:21
>> So, I think we already did that.
23:23
Bedroom, dining room, parlor, courtyard,
23:25
kitchen, storage done.
23:27
>> Yeah, that's really it. What's funny is
23:29
like there are no special facilities
23:30
that compete with most of these. It's
23:32
like there's no special kitchen or
23:34
special courtyard really. There is a
23:37
store room which is different from a
23:40
storage. Don't question it. Shut up.
23:43
>> Wait, honestly, isn't a tavern just an
23:45
improved improved dining room? It's a
23:47
dining room, but it has friends in it
23:48
and they're drinking.
23:49
>> Okay. All right. You've got me there.
23:50
And I guess you could say a garden is
23:52
just a better courtyard.
23:53
>> Yeah. Yeah. And a gambling hall.
23:56
>> Actually, no. Garden is not a basic
23:59
facility. It's an actual special
24:00
facility.
24:01
>> Yeah. No, that's what we're saying. We
24:02
have special facilities for
24:04
>> a basic facility, but good.
24:05
>> Yeah.
24:06
>> Yeah. Okay. All right. I'm wrong.
24:08
>> There are special facilities.
24:09
>> Is there a brothel as a special
24:10
facility?
24:11
>> No, I don't think uh I don't think we
24:13
will ever get an official brothel in
24:15
fifth edition. They have tried such
24:17
things in a place called third edition,
24:19
and we're never going back there.
24:21
Honestly, it's probably for the better.
24:22
>> Oh, you mean uh what is that?
24:25
>> Book of Wild Darkness.
24:26
>> No, not that.
24:27
>> Oh, I know the one you're talking about.
24:29
The one that killed the OGL. Yeah, the
24:31
sex supplement. I can't remember what
24:32
it's called. It was bad. Don't use it.
24:34
>> Yeah,
24:35
>> don't use it.
24:36
>> Look at the Wikipedia the Wikipedia page
24:38
for the history of the OGL. Basically,
24:41
the heyday of OGL 1.0A back in third
24:44
edition ended with a third party
24:46
supplement. And then it's like, okay,
24:48
everything is radioactive now. Great.
24:50
>> Yeah, thanks for burning down our game,
24:52
jerk. Okay, so we've talked through the
24:54
basic facilities. Like we said, these
24:55
are not mechanically impactful. You are
24:57
book of erotic fantasy. Thank you, CLA.
24:59
That's the one.
25:00
>> All right. You are encouraged to lay out
25:02
your bastion with these basic facilities
25:05
as you want. Of course, you get two of
25:07
them when you first get your facility at
25:08
level five. And as you grow, you can
25:10
invest. You can continue to grow it.
25:12
Now, let's get to the mechanically
25:14
impactful rooms in our bastions, the
25:16
specialty facilities. Yeah.
25:19
>> Yeah.
25:20
>> All right. So, specialty facilities are
25:21
why you should actually care about your
25:23
bastion beyond just as a storytelling
25:26
device. Like if you just want a home as
25:28
a storytelling device, you do not need
25:30
the bastion rules and they're going to
25:32
over complicate things. Yep.
25:33
>> If you're going to use the bastion
25:34
rules, it's for the special facilities
25:36
and what they can do for you cuz some of
25:38
the things they can do are actually
25:39
pretty cool. You will start with two
25:42
specialty facilities starting at level
25:44
five when you first get your bastion.
25:46
You will get one more at levels 9, 13,
25:50
17.
25:51
>> You get two at nine.
25:52
>> Thank you. Appreciate being corrected.
25:53
two at nine, one at 13, and one at 17.
25:56
You also get access to new facility
25:59
options at each of those levels. And at
26:01
level 9, a bunch of the level five
26:03
facilities upgrade and can do things
26:05
like crafting magic items for you, which
26:07
we'll revisit that later. So, you will
26:09
get a maximum of six over the course of
26:12
your career. By level 17, you'll have a
26:14
maximum of six. You generally cannot
26:17
have duplicates of the same facility.
26:19
There are a handful of exceptions. Most
26:21
of them are useless. They, as as I
26:23
mentioned before, they'll come with
26:25
hierlings. They are self-funding. So,
26:27
like, if you get a garden, it's assumed
26:29
that your hireling is like selling
26:31
produce from the garden to pay their own
26:32
salary in addition to whatever they're
26:35
doing for you. I don't know, maybe they
26:37
lease the space from you or something. I
26:38
don't know how it works. Don't question
26:40
it too much.
26:41
>> Yeah, I I'm actually pretty impressed by
26:43
how many options for special facilities
26:45
we got. There are 29 in the Dungeon
26:48
Masters Guide. Very frequently when we
26:50
get new systems like this, they'll give
26:53
us like a handful of options, which is
26:55
enough to say like, "Wow, this is really
26:57
cool. I wish there was enough to play
26:59
with this." But no, like there's a lot.
27:02
And since you're only going to get six
27:03
per player, there are enough options
27:06
that most parties will not need to have
27:09
duplicates. And that feels pretty good,
27:10
honestly.
27:11
>> Should we talk about each of the
27:13
facilities briefly? Maybe
27:16
>> we could we could run through the list
27:18
rapid fire. That feels like maybe. Okay.
27:21
>> So, we're going to do this and we'll
27:23
just call out the level of what we're
27:24
working with. So, at level five, arcane
27:26
study, armory, bareric, garden, library,
27:30
sanctuary, smithy, storehouse, workshop.
27:33
At level 9, gaming hall, greenhouse,
27:36
laboratory, sacry, scriptorum, stable,
27:39
teleportation circle, theater, training
27:41
area, trophy room. At level 13, archive,
27:45
meditation chamber, menagerie,
27:47
observatory, pub, relic. At level 17,
27:50
demiplane, guild hall, sanctum, and war
27:53
room.
27:54
>> Now, it's important to also note that
27:56
each each facility that you have has a
27:59
specific order that you can give. So
28:01
like they're tied to specific orders. So
28:03
like for instance, something like arcane
28:05
study or workshop or scriptorum have
28:09
craft orders. And then something like
28:12
armory or gaming hall has trade. Barrack
28:16
and war room have recruit. Garden and
28:19
greenhouse have harvest. And then
28:21
library and archive have research. And
28:25
the last one is empower which is where
28:27
the broken stuff comes.
28:30
So I think it's probably worth let's go
28:32
through and let's talk about the orders
28:33
you can give because I think it's a
28:35
pretty short list and I think it paints
28:37
a picture of what's going to happen in
28:38
the rooms that allow you to give those
28:40
orders. Sounds good.
28:41
>> Sure. Just to briefly go over it. So,
28:43
craft exactly what it sounds like.
28:45
Allows you to craft things. Some of the
28:46
stuff that you can craft is just
28:48
severely underwhelming. Like, uh, the
28:50
arch like I for I forget which one it
28:52
is. I think it's the arcane study. It's
28:53
like it lets you make a blank book.
28:55
Cool.
28:56
>> That's awesome.
28:57
>> Don't know what I'm do.
28:59
>> I I I did look. So, I guess the way that
29:01
you would use it is there's a there's a
29:03
later facility. I think is the
29:05
scriptorum or something that allows you
29:06
to craft a certain item like magic item,
29:10
but you need a blank book. And I'm like,
29:11
"Oh, hey,
29:12
>> you can duplicate a published book."
29:15
>> Yeah.
29:17
Yeah. You have to bring your own book.
29:18
It's so stupid.
29:20
>> You got to invest.
29:21
>> So, that's on one end. On the other end,
29:23
you can craft like full-on magic items,
29:26
which very good.
29:27
>> Or spell scrolls and stuff like that.
29:29
Empower. Oh, boy.
29:31
power is very broad and it can range
29:35
from a lot of different things. Like the
29:36
training yard allows you to
29:39
>> do a bunch of different effects like one
29:40
of them is like do extra D4 on your
29:43
unarmed strikes which is nice or the
29:46
meditation chamber which allows you to
29:48
give yourself advantage on a single save
29:50
for seven days.
29:51
>> Oh dang.
29:52
>> Okay.
29:54
>> All right. So in in addition to issuing
29:56
orders to your facilities and we'll go
29:58
into Bastion turns in a minute. In
30:00
addition to issuing orders to your
30:02
facilities, you can also just do stuff
30:04
in your special facilities. That will
30:07
take some amount of time and do some
30:09
specific effect. Varies between
30:11
facilities. So the training room, if you
30:13
spend 8 hours a day for 7 days straight
30:16
training in the training room, you will
30:18
get a specific buff that then lasts for
30:21
a week. And it can be things like a
30:23
skill proficiency, plus 1d4 damage to
30:26
all of your unarmed strikes, weapon
30:28
mastery in in a single weapon,
30:30
proficiency in one tool. There's one
30:32
other thing that I'm forgetting. Uh
30:34
>> yeah, there's a lot of cool stuff. The
30:36
arcane study, I think if you if you
30:38
spend a long rest in your arcane study,
30:41
you get a little charm that allows you
30:43
to identify for seven days. That's cool.
30:45
I like to see them using charms more.
30:47
Charms are actually big thing in here.
30:49
And then there's stuff like some of the
30:50
terms are like you could cast heal once.
30:53
>> Yeah.
30:55
>> No, no, no. Heal. Not not cure wounds.
30:58
Heal.
30:59
>> Okay. All right. Fine.
31:00
>> Yeah.
31:01
>> But that is a higher level one. And then
31:03
recruit is allows you to recruit some
31:05
like guards or other people that are
31:08
protecting your bastion, which comes up
31:09
when your bastion's under attack.
31:11
Research allows you to learn a thing or
31:13
in one case cast legend lore.
31:16
>> Yeah,
31:16
>> love to see that. my favorite spell.
31:21
>> Yeah, there's there's ways to cast
31:23
legendal lore, contact other plane,
31:26
divination. You can recruit an NPC
31:29
wizard who can cast any spell of up to
31:31
level four if you're level 17. It's any
31:34
spell of up to level eight. They'll just
31:36
cast them for you. It's great.
31:38
>> It's level seven.
31:39
>> That has no prerequisites. So, if you
31:40
are not a caster, that's actually kind
31:42
of nice. It's like, I would just like
31:43
this spell. My wizard is useless.
31:46
So, it's also just a useful facility in
31:48
general because it's a it's a
31:50
teleportation circle. So, it just allows
31:51
you to teleport back to your bastion.
31:53
So, that's cool.
31:54
>> I I do love the gimmick, though, is you
31:56
basically it's like you just summon some
31:58
dude in and be like, "Oh, hey, thanks
32:00
for visiting. I need
32:02
>> And they may not come. That's the thing
32:04
is they may not come."
32:05
>> Yeah.
32:06
>> Yeah. It's a 50-50 shot. They come or
32:07
not. Trade is the final Well, the second
32:10
to final one. We'll talk about the other
32:11
one in a second. trade is allows you to
32:14
stock your bastion with stuff you need
32:17
or make money. That's it. That's it.
32:19
Money actually now has a use if you use
32:22
bastions because bastions are the long
32:24
sought after money sync in Dn D. So,
32:27
hey, if you I know what you're thinking.
32:30
It's like, oh, cool. I can make a
32:32
facility that makes me more of this
32:33
useless gold that I'm after. No, no, no.
32:35
That's actually a good facility to use
32:36
in this. You need money because a lot of
32:38
the stuff in this bastion to upgrade it
32:40
is very expensive. Oh yeah, owning
32:43
houses is expensive. Who knew?
32:44
>> Yeah, the final order is just a general
32:46
order you can give to your entire
32:48
bastion and it's usually the default one
32:50
if you're not there, which is maintain.
32:52
And that's just basically your NPCs
32:55
become NPCs and they're just standing
32:57
there like, is he back yet?
32:59
>> Yeah.
33:00
>> I only exist in the warmth of your gaze.
33:04
>> Yeah. Quaset likes legend lore because I
33:06
I they have Mamir the It's not my choice
33:10
to give it to them. The campaign just
33:11
gives them a mamir which allows them to
33:13
cast legend lore once per day.
33:15
>> Y pretty good. Okay, so the the maintain
33:19
order. I want to look at that for like
33:21
two seconds. When you take the maintain
33:24
order, which is technically you can just
33:27
issue the maintain order to your whole
33:28
bastion. Don't. That's stupid. If you've
33:30
done that, it's because your bastion is
33:32
bad and you've made poor choices.
33:35
If you are if you are not physically in
33:38
your bastion to give orders, by default,
33:41
your bastion will use the maintain
33:43
order, which is just like just keep the
33:45
lights on, don't break anything. If you
33:46
do that, however, the the DM rolls for a
33:49
random bastion event. It's a d00 table.
33:52
There are exactly 11 options on it. 50%
33:56
of the time, nothing happens. The other
33:58
50% of the time, stuff happens. 5% of
34:02
the time. So essentially like one on
34:04
AD20, you will get the attack event. And
34:07
that is an event where something which
34:10
it lets you and the DM define attacks
34:13
your Bastion. We'll get to that in a
34:14
little bit. So like it is possible to
34:16
have your bastion intact in your
34:17
absence.
34:18
>> The other thing is I hope you're not
34:19
attached to your higher lanes because
34:22
there's there's several options in the
34:24
other 50% where you just lose a higher
34:26
lane.
34:26
>> Here's the trick. Do not name them. Not
34:29
an attack like sometimes they just leave
34:31
or disappear or something. They
34:33
arrested.
34:34
>> Yeah, they Yeah, it's great.
34:37
>> Okay, now to avoid that maintain order
34:40
because sincerely the maintain order is
34:42
annoying and sucks. It's a It is a waste
34:45
of your time and resources. Avoid it at
34:47
all costs. To avoid hitting the maintain
34:50
status, we'll call it, you need to issue
34:52
orders during bastion turns. And now the
34:55
bastion turn is how you will actually
34:57
benefit from your bastion primarily.
35:00
They're supposed to occur roughly every
35:01
seven days, but you have to be in your
35:03
bastion most of the time. You have to be
35:05
in your bastion to issue orders. Now,
35:08
the text of the rules very specifically
35:10
says, hang on, I'm going to read a
35:12
quote. If a character isn't in their
35:14
bastion on a given Bastion turn, the
35:16
bastion acts as though it were issued
35:18
the maintain order on that turn unless
35:20
the owner can communicate with the
35:22
bastion hierlings using the sending
35:24
spell or similar magic. So explicitly
35:27
you have to use magic, which is stupid.
35:31
Like I'm all for wizard supremacy, but
35:33
why can't I just leave them a to-do
35:35
list?
35:36
>> Exactly.
35:37
>> I mean, exactly. I think I think I I
35:40
would interpret it as like if if your
35:43
bastion is is current if you give your
35:46
Bastion order to do a thing that's going
35:49
to take you know a while because some of
35:51
the actions that they the orders you can
35:53
give them are like project based and can
35:55
take a while and then you leave
35:57
immediately. When it comes to the
35:58
bastion turn order I would just say
36:00
they're continuing to do that. That I
36:02
that's not technically rules as written
36:04
but that's a way you could do it.
36:05
>> Yeah. But uh I think by trying to do
36:08
everything you can to power a game and
36:10
not maintain, not not avoid giving the
36:13
maintain order, you're kind of
36:16
exploiting the system in a way it's not
36:18
intended to be exploited and you're just
36:20
fundamentally ignoring half the system,
36:23
which why are you using the Bastion
36:24
system? Part of the part of the fun is
36:27
stuff happens that you can't control or
36:30
expect when you're away. That's just
36:32
kind of the fantasy of a Bastion. If
36:34
everything was running smoothly and
36:36
optimally 100% of the time, that's
36:38
boring.
36:40
>> That's true.
36:41
>> I I can see a world where the table and
36:44
the DM just agree. We are literally not
36:47
messing with the maintain table.
36:48
Everything is of order. Your bastion is
36:50
either like well isolated or it's in the
36:53
middle of a city. And either way,
36:54
nobody's going to attack you. We're not
36:56
going to have any visitors. Nobody's
36:57
putting eggs in people's boots. By the
36:59
way, that's a thing that can happen.
37:00
It's on the table. Like, none of these
37:02
things are happening. I can also imagine
37:05
and I almost wonder if they toyed with
37:06
this idea. Imagine if you separated the
37:08
maintain order from the orders that you
37:10
get for the bastion. So you could leave
37:12
the automation rule of like I want each
37:14
of my special facilities to do this and
37:16
if I'm gone for 30 days then I want this
37:18
then this then this then this. I can
37:20
leave that automation. Maybe the
37:22
agreement is I have to make those
37:24
decisions and hand in that automation
37:27
before we lead to go adventuring. Maybe
37:29
that's the rule that you agree with your
37:30
DM. Now, imagine if separately from
37:33
that, every week that you were gone, we
37:36
had to roll on the maintain table. And
37:38
so, I still get the benefits of my
37:39
automation, I still get the benefits of
37:40
my special facilities, but what we're
37:42
saying is that the orders you left
37:44
behind have nothing to do with the
37:45
random events that are going to happen.
37:47
And while you're gone, we're going to
37:49
roll through those things. I think Ash,
37:50
towards your point, if you really wanted
37:52
to engage with the things happen when
37:54
you run, you know, a small villa B&B, I
37:57
would almost rather do it that way where
37:59
I get all my automation. I don't lose
38:01
the benefit through maintain, but I
38:03
still have to deal with the consequences
38:04
of these random events.
38:05
>> I mean, the another compromise that you
38:07
could do and it's one I used in my game
38:10
where I'm using a base like rules the
38:12
strongholds and followers is yeah, for
38:14
the most part there your base is
38:16
probably pretty secure, but I will bring
38:19
in story moments that threaten your keep
38:22
on occasion. So, just like rather than
38:24
rolling on random tables, it's kind of
38:25
like with random encounters. there.
38:27
Random encounters aren't really fun and
38:30
they don't really add much to the story.
38:32
So, if you're So, if you're going to use
38:34
an encounter and you're going to use a
38:36
bastion event, use it purposefully.
38:38
Like, you know, the bad guy finds your
38:41
your little hideout and decides, "Hey,
38:43
I'm going to murder all of your guards
38:44
just to send you a message to stop
38:46
messing with my plans." And you come
38:48
back and you find all of your all of
38:50
your people like dead or at least some
38:52
of them like the faceless NPCs you
38:53
didn't care about. And like the one guy
38:55
who you really care about is he he held
38:58
out valiantly and was able to save some
38:59
people. Have to have to find a healer
39:02
for him and stuff like that kind of
39:04
stuff is great. A random attack that
39:06
your guards just drive off. Did that
39:08
need to happen? Do we need to talk about
39:09
that?
39:11
>> Yeah. I mean luckily it resolves quickly
39:14
cuz it just like roll 66. How many ones
39:16
did you roll? Cool. They're dead.
39:18
>> Yeah.
39:20
>> No save.
39:21
>> No saving them. No raising them. Did you
39:23
know their names? Who cares? Get a new
39:25
one next turn.
39:26
>> Yeah.
39:26
>> Yeah. That's the problem that I have
39:28
with the system is that like you're
39:29
you're told to like increase or give
39:32
your hierlelings like backstories and
39:34
names. It's just like but it's so easy
39:36
to lose them. So, how can I get attached
39:38
to them? And it's like you're oh
39:41
faceless NPC. And then what's hilarious
39:43
to me is that like if you lose a
39:44
hierling, they're replaced the next time
39:46
you have a bastion event at no cost to
39:48
you. So, it's just like so what was the
39:49
point then?
39:51
>> Yeah. Well, I've got a bunch of them
39:52
running around in red shirts and I just
39:54
don't name those. Those are Okay, so
39:57
>> no, go ahead.
39:58
>> Okay, so we talked about you have a
40:00
bastion event every week. Now, one of
40:02
the things that it calls out on the
40:03
rules, let's say the party is going to
40:05
be at their bastions for like half a
40:07
year. You know, we're we're doing one
40:09
ring rules and we're going to go and
40:11
we're just going to hang out for a
40:12
couple seasons before we go back out
40:13
adventuring. And I'm going to quote from
40:15
the text, you can slow the frequency of
40:17
bastion turns to better serve the needs
40:19
of your players in your campaign. For
40:20
example, if the characters have months
40:22
between adventures, you can call for a
40:24
bastion turn every month instead of
40:25
every 7 days. So the characters aren't
40:27
issuing so many orders or reaping too
40:29
many benefits at once. So So basically
40:31
by DM Fiat, I can just be like, "Oh, you
40:34
want to take 6 months off cuz you really
40:36
want to get you you're going to do a
40:37
bunch of theater performances. That's
40:38
your dream." Nah, you get one show a
40:41
month instead of one show a week. You're
40:43
out of here. Well, I think the what
40:45
they're implying with that is this is a
40:47
thing you decide for the game and you're
40:49
consistent with it. What what they're
40:52
Okay. No, but what I'm saying is is that
40:54
like if you're running a game where
40:56
there's a lot of downtime like
40:57
Kingmaker, then have it have it be set
41:00
to once a month. If if the if that's if
41:03
if they're actually advocating I again I
41:07
have to think that you guys are reading
41:08
this genu generously. If they're
41:10
actually advocating you switching the
41:11
system in the middle of the game, that's
41:12
bad and needs to be re rewritten.
41:14
>> Where does it say that? Let me see.
41:16
>> In the book.
41:17
>> No, no, no, no, no. I I think I think
41:20
you could be right that so you can slow
41:22
the frequency. The the fact that they're
41:24
saying slow as in like you can
41:26
decelerate the frequency makes me think
41:27
of changing the frequency mid campaign.
41:29
I would have rather they use language
41:30
like you can use a different frequency.
41:33
But I can see a reading of it.
41:35
>> I see what you're saying. Yeah. Again,
41:37
it comes back to them phrasing [ __ ]
41:39
badly.
41:40
>> Yeah.
41:40
>> Yeah. Fair enough. Maybe they did intend
41:42
it the way that you're saying, in which
41:44
case, bad. Bad. Watsy, don't do that.
41:47
>> Okay. You know, so so the idea of a
41:49
bastion turn, you are going to once a
41:52
week. So when 7 days passing game time,
41:55
you're going to have a bastion term. At
41:57
that point, you can issue an order to
42:00
each of your specialty facilities,
42:02
assuming you have living hierlings
42:04
capable of running that facility. And
42:06
so, you imagine like you get to level
42:08
17, you've got six different facilities.
42:10
You kicked open a teleportation circle
42:12
because you're going to recruit a mage
42:14
to come and cast a spell that you've
42:15
been looking forward to. You're going to
42:17
open up the gambling den. You're going
42:18
to make a bunch of money. You're going
42:19
to roll some dice to see how much money
42:20
you make. You're going to open up the
42:22
tavern. You're going to have people
42:23
coming in. There's going to be a great
42:24
party. That's going to be a great time.
42:26
You're gonna have a guild hall. It's
42:27
going to be the brewer's guild hall.
42:29
They're gonna come in. They're gonna
42:30
make a ton of beer. And when they make
42:32
that beer, you're gonna sell it. You're
42:34
gonna make a lot of money from the beer.
42:35
Like, and that's that's that week. And
42:37
then next week, you get to do the whole
42:39
thing all over again.
42:41
>> And only the exact same thing everywhere
42:43
>> over and over and over again.
42:44
>> Yeah. Cuz most facilities only have one
42:47
order.
42:47
>> Yeah. And so that that that's where it
42:49
is exciting that you can do things like,
42:52
okay, take the teleportation circle
42:54
where I can recruit a mage. that mage is
42:56
going to come in and cast a spell. At
42:58
high levels, there's a ton of awesome
43:00
spells that I may want to take advantage
43:02
of. For the things that just make you
43:04
money, you know, take the the gambling
43:06
hall for instance, or gaming hall, I
43:07
think is what they call it. I get to
43:09
roll a dieice and I'm going to make some
43:10
amount of money and that's really the
43:12
only thing I ever get to do with this
43:13
thing. Now, it's exciting cuz there's a
43:14
little bit of variability, but
43:16
>> yeah. All right. So, we talked a bit
43:18
about bastion turns and how to use your
43:21
facilities. I want to talk about
43:24
defending your bastion kind kind of
43:27
briefly cuz it's so boring.
43:29
>> It's so boring. Okay, so when you get a
43:31
bastion event, you roll on that D100
43:33
table. You have a 1 in20 chance of
43:35
getting the attack event. If you get the
43:37
attack event, you roll six d6 and for
43:40
every one that you roll, one of your
43:42
defenders dies. If you have zero
43:45
defenders, if you have zero defenders
43:48
after this roll, then one of your
43:51
special facilities shuts down until your
43:54
next bastion turn. So like, you lose it
43:56
for one bastion turn. Fine, whatever.
43:59
The wording there is unclear, though. If
44:01
you have zero defenders and you don't
44:04
roll any ones, does a facility still
44:08
shut down? I I sincerely don't know what
44:11
the intent is here.
44:12
>> Wait, wait. You have defenders and you
44:14
don't roll any ones.
44:15
>> No. If you have zero defenders, it just
44:17
says
44:18
>> if you have zero defenders, a facility
44:21
shuts down.
44:22
>> I think that's implied then is that if
44:23
you don't have any defenders, then a
44:25
facility just shuts down. So
44:27
>> even if you don't roll any ones, though,
44:28
>> correct? I think so.
44:29
>> Well, you're not rolling because there's
44:31
no defenders.
44:32
>> Well, no, you do roll. You roll the 66.
44:34
Period. I think
44:36
>> Tyler, I'll tell you how I interpret
44:37
this. Right. You You have had the attack
44:39
action. You are being raided. Period.
44:41
>> Yes. Okay. You roll the 66 to see if you
44:44
lose any defenders. And if you roll
44:45
ones, you lose the defenders. If you go
44:48
to zero defenders, then because you've
44:50
had the attack action, one of your
44:51
special facilities, you know, gets
44:52
burned down. They go into your tele
44:53
teleportation circle, graffiti all over
44:56
the glyphs. It doesn't work anymore,
44:57
right? If you have the attack action and
44:59
there are no defenders, instead they
45:01
kind of just like throw open the door
45:02
and they're like, "We're here to kill
45:03
the people." And everybody's like,
45:04
"There's no one to kill. We're just the
45:06
hierlings. We're going to be over here."
45:07
And then they still walk into your
45:09
teleportation circle and make graffiti
45:10
all over it. That's how I interpret
45:12
this. Honestly, I I find that
45:14
interpretation to be much more
45:16
plausible. Like I I think that is
45:18
probably what they intended.
45:20
>> Yeah, probably.
45:21
>> Yeah, the the math on how this works is
45:25
annoying. Randall, you and I have played
45:28
a few Year Zero engine games. We have
45:31
attempted to roll sixes on a pool of d6s
45:34
and seen what a struggle that is. I did
45:36
the math. On a on 66, you have a nearly
45:40
40% chance to roll zero ones. You have
45:44
something like a 90% chance to roll
45:47
either zero or one ones. And then like
45:52
all the other possibilities are in that
45:54
like tiny 10% remaining. The odds of
45:56
losing more than one defender per attack
45:58
and per attack are so exceptionally
46:02
small that if you if you got a bareric,
46:06
filled it with 12 defenders, left your
46:08
bastion, you even at level 20, you could
46:11
leave your bastion for so long that your
46:15
hierlings are all like, "Well, he's
46:17
never coming back. We're leaving." That
46:19
would happen before all of your
46:22
defenders were killed by attacks. And
46:24
it's it's not like, oh, it's pretty
46:26
close. No, it's like four of them would
46:28
die in the 20 bastion turns it takes for
46:32
your bastion to be abandoned. Okay. So,
46:34
so Tyler's calling out the ways that you
46:35
can lose your bastion. Let's go and jump
46:37
to that and explain it just to give
46:38
folks the context for what you're
46:39
describing.
46:40
>> So difficult. Very difficult.
46:42
>> One of the ways you can lose your
46:44
bastion. I'm unable to give commands for
46:47
my character level weeks.
46:48
>> Mhm.
46:49
>> I have a question for you because the
46:50
language for this actually I I thought
46:52
it was a little bit confusing.
46:52
Essentially, if you fail to issue orders
46:55
when I am gone and the maintain order is
46:58
being issued, am I failing to give
47:01
orders in that case? Would that be your
47:02
interpretation?
47:03
>> Yes,
47:03
>> I think. Yes, that is that is how they
47:06
intended that.
47:07
>> Okay. And and so what that says is at
47:08
level five, I have to be able to revisit
47:11
my bastion every 5 weeks.
47:13
>> Yeah. Or cast sending, which is a level
47:16
two spell.
47:16
>> I mean, okay. E I don't love this.
47:20
>> Yeah. Me neither. only because
47:21
mechanically like I don't know where to
47:22
take this. Either I can't go adventuring
47:24
for 40 days, which is a thing I'm
47:26
absolutely going to go do.
47:28
>> Yeah.
47:28
>> Or the maintain order is senseless and
47:30
useless because I'm just going to have
47:32
the wizard cast sending once a week.
47:34
>> Yep.
47:34
>> Yeah. It's a tax. And
47:36
>> curiously, it's a level three spell.
47:37
>> Level three. Thank you for correcting
47:39
me, Quazette. To make that even better,
47:42
there are two facilities which can let
47:44
you craft sending stones. You can use
47:47
sending stones, leave one at home, and
47:49
use them to contact your bastion.
47:51
>> Do that.
47:52
>> Yeah. So, so starting at level 9, you
47:55
can 100% of the time from anywhere in
47:58
the multiverse reliably communicate with
48:00
your bastion to issue orders.
48:02
>> So, I'm I'm going to go back to what we
48:03
were saying earlier. If as a DM you're
48:05
excited about the maintain table because
48:08
you you think and your table is going to
48:10
enjoy that that dynamism
48:13
>> sure interaction something that level of
48:15
fun.
48:16
>> Yeah.
48:16
>> Then
48:18
>> yeah Steph that's the problem I had.
48:19
Okay.
48:21
>> Um if you think that you're going to
48:23
enjoy this then I would say without the
48:26
maintain just every week that you're
48:28
gone roll and have the random event
48:30
happen. If you want to make it extra
48:31
spicy, roll it in the background and
48:33
when they come back to visit, tell them
48:35
the whole story of everything happened
48:37
for the 40 days they were gone. Okay, I
48:39
like that so much better than what they
48:42
actually gave us. Like, sincerely, if
48:45
somebody said like, "We're going to play
48:46
with the Bastion rules, but we're going
48:48
to do this." I'd be like, "I am in. I am
48:50
excited. This is going to be
48:52
>> I don't know what happened until they
48:54
come back essentially."
48:55
>> Yeah. Or like the 25 words sending you
48:58
get back is, "Okay, boss, you need to
49:00
come home. All of the defenders are
49:02
dead. I am scared. Send help."
49:05
>> What happened? I was gone for a week.
49:09
>> I think that I think that would be that
49:11
would be great, actually. Yeah, that
49:13
sounds fun.
49:15
>> All right. I I want to beat up on on the
49:17
attack event just a tiny bit more cuz
49:19
No, get after it. I've already
49:21
highlighted how stupid it is, and I want
49:23
to highlight it gets stupider. If you
49:26
spend all of that stupid amount of gold
49:28
to build defensive walls around your
49:30
bastion, the only thing it changes is
49:32
when you roll that 66, it goes from 66
49:36
to 68. So, it's slightly less likely
49:39
that you're going to roll once.
49:40
>> Nope, it goes to 46. You're wrong.
49:42
>> What? Oh, am I Sorry, I'm mixing up.
49:45
>> Armory. Yeah, you're thinking.
49:47
>> Okay. Yeah. So, defensive walls drop the
49:49
dice by two. Like, that's significant.
49:52
It's basically impossible to roll more
49:54
than one one at that point.
49:55
>> If you if you get all of the upgrades to
49:58
do that. So, what you would need to do
49:59
is wall
50:01
>> armory and then a lieutenant from the
50:03
war room.
50:04
>> War room. So,
50:06
>> each lieutenant knocks off one dice. So,
50:09
if you get four lieutenants and
50:10
defensive walls, you're good.
50:12
>> Yeah. You don't need to roll. You don't
50:13
need to roll ever.
50:15
>> Wait, wait. Okay, real quick. I
50:16
apologize. How much defensive wall do I
50:18
need? Like if I build one foot section,
50:21
>> it has to completely encircle your
50:22
bastion.
50:23
>> Okay.
50:23
>> Yeah. And and your bastion can be buil
50:27
built vertically, which means the
50:29
optimal defensive structure is in fact a
50:31
wizard's tower.
50:32
>> Oh, get out of here.
50:34
>> I'm I'm going to build an inverted
50:36
wizard pyramid. Right. I want a 5ft
50:38
section on the bottom that I have to put
50:40
eight 5ft sections of wall around and
50:42
then we're just going up.
50:44
>> Yeah. Or you can go underground. I
50:46
suppose there's nothing saying that you
50:48
can't. There's also nothing saying that
50:49
you can. So like what you're ruling.
50:52
>> Can my bastion just be a dungeon,
50:54
please? That's a lot of gold. Then
50:56
you're playing Tor fortress.
50:58
>> Yeah, I want to I I want to I want to
51:00
play dungeon defender and just create
51:03
craft my own dungeon. I'm going to be a
51:05
lich. I'm going to create my own tomb of
51:07
horrors and lure adventurers into her
51:09
into it so I can steal their souls.
51:11
>> Okay. I think we're playing very
51:13
different game of attack and defense.
51:16
>> Le let's just Oh, okay. There is a
51:18
facility called an armory. The sole
51:19
function of the armory is you can stock
51:21
it with equipment for your defenders. It
51:23
costs 100 gold pieces per defender. Keep
51:26
in mind that you can have 12 defenders
51:29
in a barrack and if you upgrade it, 25.
51:31
And you can have multiple barracks if
51:33
you're stupid. Don't. So, you can spend
51:35
like 1,200 gold equipping your defenders
51:38
and be like, "Great, I'm going to roll
51:40
D8s instead of D6s, which is not worth
51:42
100 gold." It's not. And then when you
51:45
do that, it is single use. If you roll
51:48
the attack event, all of the equipment
51:50
in the armory is gone for good.
51:53
>> The armor is a trap. Don't do it.
51:55
>> Yeah.
51:56
>> Just
51:57
war room. Get a war room.
51:59
>> Yeah.
51:59
>> Four lieutenants. You don't ever have to
52:01
roll.
52:02
>> Yeah. or or again it 66 you're never
52:07
going to roll more than one most likely
52:09
like
52:10
>> Yeah. And if you have like 20 foot Yeah.
52:11
If you have 12 or 24 guardsman, you're
52:14
never going to run out. You're never
52:15
going to run out.
52:16
>> Okay. And and if you do get attacked,
52:19
which again is a one in 20 chance. If
52:22
you do get attacked, the consequence is
52:25
one of your special facilities is shut
52:27
down for one bastion turn. So you you
52:31
know what you could do instead of having
52:32
a bareric? You could just have another
52:34
special facility cuz if you have a
52:36
bareric, you're effectively shutting
52:38
down one of your special facility slots
52:40
every bastion
52:41
>> permanently. I didn't think about that.
52:43
Okay, who gets to pick the special
52:45
facility?
52:45
>> It doesn't say.
52:46
>> Okay, so if I'm a DM, I'm going to roll
52:49
on a random table.
52:50
>> Yeah, that's how I'd handle it.
52:51
>> Or if it's like a villain attacking,
52:52
they might do the thing that they know
52:54
hurts you most.
52:55
>> Oh, yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
52:56
>> Yeah. This is this goes back to my
52:57
argument like I feel like the attacks
52:59
are kind of worthless and you should
53:01
just if something happens to the the
53:04
bastion you should just have it be a
53:06
story based thing. Yeah.
53:07
>> So I agree.
53:08
>> Okay. I want to talk about that Ash cuz
53:09
I'm actually really excited about it.
53:11
Before we go there cuz I think that's a
53:13
great place to go soon. Is it worth
53:15
talking through the other ways you can
53:17
lose your Bastion?
53:18
>> You can willingly give it up and you can
53:20
lose it to the ruin card. That's it.
53:22
>> The ruin card in the deck of many
53:24
things. Yeah. I keep forgetting that's a
53:26
choice.
53:27
>> That's it. Those are the only three ways
53:28
that you can lose your
53:29
>> And then the one we mentioned earlier,
53:31
which is not calling home in in
53:33
character level weeks, which we've
53:34
already discussed how we're going to get
53:36
by. We all agree. Fantastic. I do love
53:38
the like I can just It's like I can
53:40
declare bankruptcy. I can't declare
53:42
bankruptcy, but I can basically say like
53:44
go on, get get
53:46
>> Yeah. And and then just nature takes it
53:48
back over. It's It's great. Okay. I Ash,
53:50
I I like what you're saying about I
53:53
would rather have it be a story event
53:55
and I think I like that. What I'm
53:56
looking at and I I just I feel like it's
53:59
missing. I I wanted them to give us
54:00
something for it because it's so
54:01
tempting. Fair mechanics for story
54:04
interactions with the Bastion for the
54:07
DM. You know, we've been running around.
54:09
We're not hiding our identity. People
54:11
know who we are. We're building renown.
54:13
What does the villain do to my bastion?
54:15
I very publicly stole some artifact. I I
54:18
pissed off some noble like at their big
54:20
party. What will the government or or
54:22
the guard or or that noble in his family
54:25
do to my bastion?
54:27
>> Yeah, there's a lot of ways you could do
54:29
it. I wish they could give you some
54:30
scenarios that would be helpful, but
54:32
here's some for you if you're stumped on
54:34
ideas. So, building off what Randall
54:36
said, let's say you stole a the mcuffin,
54:38
the powerful mcguffin that the that the
54:40
villain needs, a sorcerer. He sends his
54:42
he finds out where it is. He sends his
54:43
lackey to raid your bastion. you come
54:47
back, everybody's dead except for maybe
54:49
a few people that you you feel like your
54:52
your party would be very pissed at you
54:53
for killing off screen.
54:58
>> You know, you could you could also just
54:59
make some roles. You could make some
55:00
roles, but you know, give I think
55:03
bringing in Tyler's idea of hey boss,
55:06
get back here. Something bad is going
55:08
down and so you know stuff is going down
55:10
so the players feel like they have some
55:11
agency and it's not just like
55:13
something's happened without their
55:14
control. The other thing is like going
55:16
to Randall's example, let's say you piss
55:18
off a noble. Well, guess who has the
55:20
power to seize your property or
55:23
foreclose on it. Maybe you pissed off
55:25
the wrong guy. And they they they get
55:27
the government to declare that you are
55:30
in violation of some sort of building
55:31
code. And you come back and there's like
55:33
there's tape over your door that says do
55:36
not enter. And you're just like, what
55:37
the hell happened?
55:39
>> Randall built an inverted pyramid. Now
55:42
his house is looming over every other
55:44
house in the city.
55:46
>> It's structurally unsound. Randall.
55:48
>> Yeah.
55:48
>> Yeah. Or you can face.
55:51
>> I think it would be very funny is if if
55:53
you come come to your bastion and you're
55:55
just you've got that one neighbor who's
55:56
like trim your hedges. Dang it. God.
56:01
So Ash, I do like what you brought up
56:04
front and I I kind of want to riff on it
56:05
a little bit using the mechanics that
56:07
we've been given. Imagine you do go
56:09
adventuring for 40 days and then you
56:11
come back and you find out the entire 40
56:13
days you've been gone, your bastion has
56:15
been under siege by the villain.
56:18
>> I thought you were going to say by by
56:19
the IRS or something.
56:20
>> You know what? You know what? This this
56:22
transitions too nicely.
56:24
>> Strongholds and followers.
56:28
>> Are have you ever seen a reference or a
56:30
splatbook that has really good guidance
56:32
on siege engines?
56:34
>> I do. It's right here. In fact, it's
56:36
called Strongholds and Followers. And
56:38
they have actual like, you know,
56:40
mechanics for sieges, like if if the
56:42
army figures out where your bastion or
56:44
your stronghold is located and they want
56:46
to siege it. They have like troop how
56:48
how to run like actual wars and stuff
56:51
like that. Very cool. I do want to
56:52
briefly talk about what Strongholds and
56:55
followers do does, my experience with
56:57
it, and why I think it's superior to
56:58
bastions in a pretty much every way.
57:01
Okay, before you go there, I do want to
57:03
toss out actually the 2024 Dungeon
57:05
Masters Guide does actually have a list
57:07
of siege equipment. We were excited to
57:09
note it last time and it's worth saying
57:10
it is in there. So, if you're debating
57:12
about picking it up, it's there.
57:13
Strongholds and Followers has a whole
57:15
system about sieges.
57:16
>> Mhm.
57:17
>> Ash, go.
57:18
>> Well, I don't know too much about the
57:20
sieges cuz I never got a chance to use
57:21
them, but in my Raven Loft game, my
57:25
party members are trying to reestablish
57:27
a dead order called the Keepers at the
57:29
Feather. And there's this tower called
57:31
the eb and hold. And I thought it would
57:33
be very cool for that to be kind of like
57:35
their stronghold and for them to add on
57:37
to it. And I use strongholds and
57:39
followers. And man, am I glad I did
57:41
because there's some cool stuff. So kind
57:43
of like it's a little bit more involved.
57:46
I mean, it's way more involved than
57:48
bastions in that like you have
57:50
buildings. It's not just like
57:51
facilities. It's like whole buildings.
57:53
And they require a commitment cuz a lot
57:55
of them are expensive to upgrade. But
57:57
they give some amazing benefits. Like
57:59
there's tower, the library, the
58:02
blacksmith, the establishment, and they
58:04
give you some great bonuses. Like the
58:05
blacksmith can take uh creature parts
58:08
that you harvest and turn them into
58:10
interesting armor that gives you bon
58:12
bonuses or benefits against that
58:14
creature. The alchemist can brew you
58:16
specific specific potions based on
58:18
material you get from monsters as well.
58:20
And it has like a suggested list of like
58:22
the things that you can craft into
58:24
various potions. It's not as intricate
58:27
as I would like, but it's it's good.
58:28
It's a good foundation to build off of.
58:30
My favorite feature and the one that my
58:32
players built, so I gave them a choice
58:34
basically once they got the bastion was
58:36
you can you have enough money that Van
58:39
Richton's giving you to refurbish one
58:42
building in the stronghold. And I gave
58:44
them a choice of like you guys can
58:46
create like a little way station in to
58:49
gather information from people or
58:51
recruit interesting adventurers to go
58:53
and do tasks for you. You can expand the
58:55
library so you can get more information
58:58
about the things that you're trying to
58:59
fight. Or you can refurbish the wizards
59:02
tower. My players chose the wizard's
59:03
tower.
59:04
>> Good.
59:05
>> Yes.
59:05
>> As well they should. Ash.
59:06
>> And the wizard's tower is awesome. It
59:09
allows you to craft custom spells kind
59:12
of. So
59:13
>> kind of
59:14
>> kind of. It's not like you can't just
59:16
full cloth make like a completely new
59:18
spell. I mean you can, but they don't
59:20
really have guidance for that. It's more
59:22
like you're modifying spells in really
59:25
cool ways. So, hold on. I need to I was
59:29
actually looking at these rules earlier.
59:31
>> So, so yeah, you pick basically a player
59:33
picks what spell they want to modify.
59:35
And then it has different tables based
59:37
on what type of spell that is. So,
59:39
there's a spell that targets you or one
59:41
ally, spell that targets several allies,
59:43
spell that targets one enemy, and a
59:45
spell that targets several enemies. And
59:47
then there's there's a separate one for
59:49
ones that do damage. And it has like
59:51
different thing different things for
59:53
like different damage types. And then
59:55
basically the player rolls to, you know,
59:58
study and craft. And if they're
59:59
successful, you either roll randomly,
1:00:02
have the player roll randomly, or you
1:00:04
and the player decide what happens. So
1:00:06
one of my players was a warlock. He
1:00:09
decided to take advantage of it. and he
1:00:10
crafted an upgrade to his hex spell that
1:00:14
basically every time he cast hex, it
1:00:17
would strip the AC bonus from that
1:00:20
person for one round. It basically like
1:00:23
if they were wearing armor, they don't
1:00:24
get to benefit from that armor for one
1:00:26
round. Very cool. There's some really
1:00:28
cool effects in there. Let me bring up
1:00:30
some of the other ones cuz there's
1:00:31
there's some fun ones here.
1:00:33
>> We probably shouldn't go into too much
1:00:34
detail for time sake, but
1:00:36
>> that's fair. But yeah, but yeah, there's
1:00:38
some cool stuff in strongholds and
1:00:40
followers. If you want your players to
1:00:42
feel invested in their stronghold, I
1:00:44
would say this is a better system.
1:00:45
>> Yeah, it maybe a reasonable way to
1:00:47
approach this is get the players going
1:00:49
at level five in Bastions as it is in
1:00:51
the 2024 DMG. And if folks are loving
1:00:54
it, they're leaning in, they're having a
1:00:55
great time with it. Um, at that point,
1:00:57
grab MCD MCDM's strongholds and
1:01:00
followers. There's a link in the show
1:01:02
notes.
1:01:02
>> Yeah. Yeah. I recommend you use that
1:01:04
more than the bastion system in 58. The
1:01:06
bastion system is just kind of bare
1:01:08
bones and as we have said it's kind of
1:01:10
underwhelming.
1:01:11
>> Yeah. Yeah. I mean I think for some
1:01:13
tables it's going to be enough because
1:01:14
it isn't going to be the focus of the
1:01:16
game. It's a thing that like you might
1:01:18
be resolving in Discord between sessions
1:01:21
even like it could have essentially and
1:01:23
and we we observed this last time we
1:01:25
were talking. There's no more section in
1:01:26
the DMG in 2024 for downtime activities.
1:01:29
Effectively these are your downtime
1:01:31
activities now. And so this is something
1:01:33
that you know if you if you listen to a
1:01:34
previous episode we gave the advice
1:01:36
where this is absolutely something that
1:01:37
you can take care of outside the session
1:01:39
away from the table. I would still say
1:01:41
that's half true here unless you run
1:01:44
long enough sessions that that amount of
1:01:46
time is actually passing in in a single
1:01:48
session.
1:01:49
>> Yeah, I I I agree with that. I think if
1:01:51
you just want to take like the bare
1:01:52
bones of the thing, instead of giving
1:01:54
everyone their bastion, just have one
1:01:55
play the players have a single bastion
1:01:57
that they can maybe add on to if they
1:01:59
want to. And then just when they when
1:02:02
they have that downtime, they can use
1:02:03
their facilities and don't worry about
1:02:05
like the defense and maintaining and all
1:02:07
of that other stuff because it's not
1:02:09
going to factor in that much. It's just
1:02:10
a thing that they can do in downtime and
1:02:12
get some cool bonuses.
1:02:13
>> Yeah, I do agree and that kind of goes
1:02:15
back to what we were talking about at
1:02:16
the beginning of episode. I really do
1:02:17
think it'd be perfectly acceptable for a
1:02:18
table to basically say we're not rolling
1:02:20
on the maintain order. We're not dealing
1:02:22
with it at all. I I think the way the
1:02:23
book is presented, that's actually in my
1:02:25
mind the worst case. I would either not
1:02:27
have the maintain table or I would let
1:02:30
you leave orders for what to do, but
1:02:31
then these these things which could be
1:02:33
bad are going to happen every week while
1:02:35
you're gone. Uh there's one other thing
1:02:36
that I wish was here and and I'm asking
1:02:39
for too much. I recognize I'm asking for
1:02:41
too much. It was hard enough to come up
1:02:42
with the 29 different options they gave
1:02:44
us and Tyler, you highlighted this
1:02:45
earlier. It's actually a lot of options
1:02:46
for a new rule system. They gave us a
1:02:49
lot of content. I'm hoping they continue
1:02:51
to expand it as we continue to get
1:02:52
additional additional books for 2024
1:02:54
rules. I do kind of wish there was some
1:02:56
guidance for creating your own custom
1:02:57
rooms.
1:02:58
>> Yeah.
1:02:59
>> Yeah.
1:02:59
>> The there's not a ton of consistency in
1:03:02
how they're designed, so it would
1:03:03
probably be pretty hard. Like the you
1:03:06
could probably do some things like you
1:03:08
can't craft magic items for a level 9,
1:03:10
you can't cast spells before yada yada.
1:03:12
Other than that, like it's kind of
1:03:13
loosey goosey. Honestly, that the power
1:03:16
fluctuates wildly between the rooms.
1:03:19
>> Yeah, I kind of I want like a wild magic
1:03:21
room that I get earlier where like
1:03:23
occasionally something awesome happens,
1:03:25
but then occasionally like you literally
1:03:27
summon a Banshee into the room. Yeah, I
1:03:29
mean it would be nice because I like
1:03:31
having bases for my my players. I've
1:03:34
I've I've used I home brerewed a similar
1:03:36
system when I was running one of my
1:03:38
games where basically my players treated
1:03:40
the game like Pokémon because they were
1:03:42
going out and getting all of these cool
1:03:44
NPCs that they were meeting and they're
1:03:46
just like I want to hire them to work at
1:03:47
our bastion. Can we do that?
1:03:50
And then that was basically their
1:03:52
motivation for going out to do quests.
1:03:54
And that was fun. I enjoyed that. And
1:03:55
you know there's not a lot of stuff out
1:03:58
there that's like this. So it the fact
1:04:00
that they're attempting is good. I would
1:04:02
just like to have more guys because like
1:04:04
I'm considering giving one of my my
1:04:06
groups I'm running right now a zeppelin
1:04:07
base and I want to know how I could make
1:04:10
custom custom rooms based off of that.
1:04:12
So yeah,
1:04:14
>> you can get a one of the guild hall
1:04:16
options is you can get a ship rights
1:04:18
guild and they can make airships for
1:04:21
you.
1:04:21
>> I know. But their base is going to be on
1:04:24
the airship. That's
1:04:25
>> put the air It's a smaller airship
1:04:28
docked to a bigger airship. It's like an
1:04:30
aircraft carrier where they're doing
1:04:32
airplane maintenance.
1:04:33
>> Also, I want to point out it takes 40
1:04:34
days to build an airship. It takes 120
1:04:38
days to build you a large living room.
1:04:40
Don't ask question.
1:04:41
>> Say that again. It takes how long to
1:04:43
build an airship?
1:04:44
>> 40 days. And you don't have to be
1:04:47
involved.
1:04:48
>> Y
1:04:49
>> I don't understand your logic, Watsi.
1:04:52
>> Don't understand your Do you not
1:04:54
understand how long it takes to build a
1:04:56
ship? But you No, of course not. Because
1:04:59
the developers probably have been
1:05:00
through house remodeling and know that
1:05:02
it takes forever, but they never built a
1:05:04
ship before.
1:05:06
>> Have you ever pulled permits in Skyrim?
1:05:09
>> It's the worst.
1:05:11
Okay, we we talked about some rooms here
1:05:13
and there. I I want to hit maybe one
1:05:16
room that we didn't talk about enough.
1:05:18
So, the theater, it's one of the ones
1:05:20
that uses the empower order,
1:05:23
>> and you can help contribute to like the
1:05:26
composition of the music. You can help
1:05:27
contribute to the success of the show.
1:05:30
You can act in the show. And then if you
1:05:33
do this and it's successful, you
1:05:36
effectively get BIC inspiration. It's
1:05:37
called a theater die. The die gets
1:05:39
larger as you hit higher levels. And
1:05:41
then you can roll it on any d20 test.
1:05:44
>> Oh, and the it never goes away. It
1:05:46
doesn't have a timeline.
1:05:48
>> It just doesn't go away until you use
1:05:50
it, which is
1:05:50
>> or until you get another theater die.
1:05:52
>> Okay. Yeah, sure. So you can't stack
1:05:54
them is the only but like the whole
1:05:56
party can contribute like oh hey
1:05:58
everybody I did a great acting. Do you
1:06:00
remember how awesome I was in that show
1:06:02
last week? Anyway, I just stabbed this
1:06:05
guy.
1:06:05
>> Suggestion. Bring this in. Bring this
1:06:07
in. Modify it for Pathfinder 2. Then use
1:06:10
that theater ritual that we were talking
1:06:11
about that allows you to put on a play.
1:06:13
Woo.
1:06:13
>> Yeah. Yeah.
1:06:16
>> Best of both worlds, baby.
1:06:18
>> I Okay. I don't know if so I ran I ran a
1:06:21
oneshot called headshot the rot which
1:06:23
was like a zombie survival oneshot where
1:06:27
that ritual was used to summon the
1:06:29
undead and start a zombie curse. Like
1:06:31
that's that's the story. That's the
1:06:33
backtory of the oneshot. It was really
1:06:34
cool.
1:06:34
>> The zombie curse started because the
1:06:36
play was going on.
1:06:37
>> Yeah, literally they
1:06:39
>> I'll hand it to you. That's a creative
1:06:41
premise. That's a very creative premise.
1:06:43
>> Yeah. The Oh, what's what's the the
1:06:45
goddess of death?
1:06:47
I almost said Sarin Ray, but no,
1:06:49
>> Fiasma. I'm I'm saying it incorrectly.
1:06:51
>> Fasma.
1:06:52
>> Fasma. Thank you. So, a follower of
1:06:54
Farasma like created this corrupted
1:06:56
ritual and tricked two actors into
1:06:59
acting out the ritual and everybody
1:07:01
thought they were showing up to see a
1:07:03
play and then the people on stage became
1:07:05
zombies and then the people in the
1:07:06
audience became zombies and then
1:07:08
hilarious.
1:07:08
>> That's horrifying. It's horrifying.
1:07:10
>> Yeah. Okay, on that note, we have a
1:07:13
question of the week. This week, our
1:07:14
question of the week comes to us from
1:07:15
Steph. Do you think Watsi will ever
1:07:17
release a downtime heavy adventure?
1:07:20
>> Boy, I hope so. I mean, they add the
1:07:23
Bastion rules. You'd hope that they
1:07:25
would, but I think Tyler's right. I
1:07:27
don't think they will. They used to do
1:07:29
stuff like that like in third edition. A
1:07:31
lot of there were a lot of downtime
1:07:33
heavy stuff. I want the 5e equivalent of
1:07:36
Kingmaker. Like cuz Kingmaker is such a
1:07:39
popular game in Pathfinder 2 for good
1:07:41
reason because it's basically like it's
1:07:44
one part life simulator, Kingdom Maker,
1:07:47
and the other part just a fun D and D
1:07:49
adventure. And I think that if they
1:07:52
really wanted to lean into that and give
1:07:54
excuses to use this new Bastion system,
1:07:57
it could be really cool. And but the
1:08:00
problem is is that most of their
1:08:01
adventures tend to be mostly either
1:08:03
dungeon crawls or pretty linear and
1:08:05
happen over a very short time frame. So
1:08:07
>> true.
1:08:08
>> Okay, I'm going to be contradictory. I
1:08:09
absolutely think within the first three
1:08:12
adventures we get from now, we're going
1:08:14
to get an adventure that is very heavy.
1:08:17
I'm going to make one more call on top
1:08:19
of this. What I'm asking for like give
1:08:21
me examples of how my villain interacts
1:08:23
with the Bastion. the Bastion will be
1:08:25
critical to the story and absolutely
1:08:28
there going to be story beats where they
1:08:29
narrate the villain doing awful things
1:08:31
to your bastion.
1:08:32
>> That being said, if you wanted to you
1:08:35
that I hope you're right about that. I
1:08:37
think if you wanted to use an existing
1:08:38
campaign and bring in the concept of
1:08:41
bastions and make them more of a focal
1:08:43
point. I would say maybe the best one to
1:08:46
do that is either Icewindale
1:08:49
or Storm King's Thunder because those
1:08:52
tend to be more wide open sandbox that
1:08:54
have a very open time frame. So you
1:08:57
could do that.
1:08:58
>> Yeah, I I I was actually trying to think
1:09:00
through like what are the published
1:09:01
adventures I played where the Bastion
1:09:03
rules would work. 100% 10 towns makes
1:09:05
perfect sense. Just pick your favorite
1:09:06
town and build there. Maybe even having
1:09:08
something dynamic where you get an
1:09:10
additional benefit depending on what
1:09:11
town you decide to found in would make a
1:09:13
lot of sense. I feel like we deacto did
1:09:15
that anyway. We got one of one of our
1:09:17
player characters. Yeah. Yeah. Exactly.
1:09:20
Am I Am I crazy? Didn't Piso put out a
1:09:23
5D adaptation or like a conversion guide
1:09:26
for
1:09:28
if you love fifth edition and you want
1:09:30
to play King Maker, you can just do it.
1:09:32
That being said, one thing I've heard
1:09:34
online, I don't know if this is true for
1:09:35
the 5e edition, the Pathfinder 2
1:09:37
construction mechanics are really obtuse
1:09:40
and complicated, and you're better off
1:09:42
just ignoring them. Just like like
1:09:44
still, you can still make the the
1:09:46
buildings and stuff like that, but just
1:09:48
the construction itself is really
1:09:50
involved. Like you have to get the right
1:09:52
resources and all this other stuff, and
1:09:55
it's a pain.
1:09:56
>> Simulationy.
1:09:56
>> Yeah, it's very simulation-y. And people
1:09:59
don't like it. So, yeah. Apparently,
1:10:01
it's it's trimmed down quite a bit from
1:10:03
what it was in PF1. In PF1, people
1:10:06
figured out that the uh the way to
1:10:09
optimize your kingdom was to only build
1:10:11
graveyards, apparently
1:10:15
I
1:10:17
>> I don't I haven't read the rules.
1:10:19
>> Video game logic if I've ever headed
1:10:22
anyway.
1:10:22
>> Yeah. I mean, Pathfinder was like that.
1:10:24
Pathfinder one was always like that
1:10:26
where everything was so involved.
1:10:28
>> Yeah. Still a great game from what I've
1:10:30
heard. I've never played it myself. I've
1:10:31
never ran it. Although I did just join
1:10:34
as a seat filler for a fellow DM for
1:10:36
King Maker, so that could be fun.
1:10:38
>> Yeah, I hope it's great.
1:10:39
>> Yeah, our our table is about to close on
1:10:43
like the first arc of the game. So, get
1:10:46
to it. Yeah, it's going to be fun.
1:10:47
>> I really want to play my Animus
1:10:49
Wandering Chef. So, I was like, I need
1:10:51
to find a game that lets me play this.
1:10:53
>> Okay. But also, you still have to plan
1:10:55
that session because we're going to do
1:10:56
it and we're going to live stream it.
1:10:57
Obviously. Obviously.
1:10:59
>> And on that note, all hail the leisure
1:11:01
Illuminati.
1:11:02
>> Hail.
1:11:02
>> H.
1:11:04
>> Your mother was a hamster and your
1:11:06
father smoked of elderberry.
1:11:08
>> I am Randall James.
1:11:12
>> You'll find me at amateurjack.com on
1:11:14
Twitter and Instagram, Jackamate. I'm
1:11:16
Tyler Camshire. You'll find me in my
1:11:18
bastion rpgbot.net.
1:11:20
Sometimes I venture out into Facebook
1:11:22
and Twitter, RPG, Boot, DOT, NE, and
1:11:26
you'll find me issuing bastion turn
1:11:28
orders on other social media platforms,
1:11:30
usually as RPG pot.
1:11:33
>> You silly English pig dogs, you'll find
1:11:35
me over on Twitter at Graven Ashes.
1:11:39
If you want me to run a game for you
1:11:41
where I can be persuaded to run maybe
1:11:44
even these Bastion roles or at least
1:11:47
have I I always like strongholds focused
1:11:49
games. I think they're very fun. Find me
1:11:51
on Star Play link in the description.
1:11:52
>> If you've enjoyed the show, please rate
1:11:54
or review us on Apple Podcast and rate
1:11:55
us on Spotify or your favorite podcast
1:11:57
app. It's a quick free way to support
1:11:59
the podcast and helps us to reach new
1:12:00
listeners. You'll find links in the show
1:12:02
notes. You'll find affiliate links for
1:12:03
source books and other materials linked
1:12:05
in the show notes as well as on
1:12:06
rbbot.net. Following these links helps
1:12:08
us to make the show happen every week.
1:12:10
If your question should be the question
1:12:11
of the week next week, please email
1:12:12
podcastbot.net
1:12:14
or message us on Twitter at rpgbot d ne.
1:12:18
Please also consider supporting us on
1:12:19
Patreon, where you can find all kinds of
1:12:20
great rewards. At any tier, you'll get
1:12:22
early access to arbgotent and polls for
1:12:24
future content. At our three tiers, you
1:12:26
will enjoy your choice of adfree access
1:12:28
to rbgbot.net or add free podcast
1:12:30
episodes and access to live stream
1:12:32
podcast recordings at our $5 tiers and
1:12:34
above. You'll get all of that, plus
1:12:35
access to the rpgbot. Discord. You'll
1:12:37
find us at patreon.com/rpgbot.
1:12:39
Want a cool shirt, maybe a sticker?
1:12:41
Visit the rpgbot.store. Want RPGbot in
1:12:43
your email inbox? Sign up for the
1:12:45
RPGbot. RPGbot. blah blah blah at
1:12:48
rbgbot.net/newsletter.
1:12:52
>> Okay, hang on. I forgot. I forgot to
1:12:55
talk about the stupid broken thing that
1:12:56
you can do with your bastions.
1:12:58
>> Oh, yes. Please tell me tell me tell me
1:12:59
tell me tell me.
1:13:00
>> You can print money. Obviously, you can
1:13:02
get charms. Great. You can make
1:13:04
defending your bastion laughable. Fine.
1:13:07
More importantly, there are four
1:13:09
facilities that starting at level 9
1:13:11
allow you to craft common or uncommon
1:13:13
magic items. And yes, one character can
1:13:17
have all four of them by level 9. You
1:13:20
can then craft permanent common or
1:13:23
uncommon magic items for a week, every
1:13:26
week, forever. And just just some stupid
1:13:29
examples of things you can do. Alchemist
1:13:32
jugs just flood the world with
1:13:34
mayonnaise.
1:13:36
Decanters of endless water. Same but
1:13:39
water. Plus one weapons, plus one
1:13:41
shields, wands of the warm mage. They
1:13:44
made a mistake by not having this thing
1:13:45
cost more money cuz
1:13:47
>> it doesn't cost money to get
1:13:49
>> Yeah. You just get facilities
1:13:52
>> in Strongholds Thunder if you I mean
1:13:53
Strongholds Thunder.
1:13:55
>> King Thunder. I know what you mean.
1:13:57
>> No, I was strongholds and followers. I
1:13:59
don't know.
1:13:59
>> Okay.
1:14:00
>> My brain just decided Nope. In
1:14:02
Strongholds and Followers to create
1:14:05
those custom spells costs you an arm and
1:14:07
leg every time.
1:14:08
>> Yeah, it should.
1:14:09
>> Yeah. you have to spend like I think
1:14:10
it's like a 100red or or maybe like 500
1:14:14
per spell level of whatever spell you're
1:14:16
trying to modify. So yeah. Yeah, that's
1:14:19
it's a bit broken.
1:14:20
>> It's a bit broken.
1:14:21
>> I I'm finishing up a a written article
1:14:25
about bastions, which will go into this
1:14:27
in a little bit more detail on like
1:14:29
here's the items you need to break your
1:14:31
game.
1:14:32
>> Not very many and you can get them for
1:14:33
free.
1:14:34
>> Yay.
1:14:36
>> That'll be out sometime after this
1:14:37
episode. Not too long. And here we are.
1:14:40
>> Hi chat.
1:14:41
>> We are here.
1:14:41
>> Hi chat.
1:14:42
>> I spent like 20 minutes today trying to
1:14:44
think of like a little Sebastian joke to
1:14:46
lead in with, but I
1:14:49
little Sebastian.
1:14:51
>> I couldn't.
1:14:52
>> Missed you in the satisfaction.
1:15:00
>> God, what a great show.
1:15:02
>> It's the only It's the only word that
1:15:04
rhymes with Bastion.
1:15:06
>> Bastion. Sebastian. surprised how good
1:15:08
of a song that is considering it's Andy
1:15:10
who wrote it.
1:15:13
>> Yeah,
1:15:13
>> I don't watch TV. I don't know what
1:15:15
we're talking about.
1:15:16
>> I'm not here for the memes. No, I I'm
1:15:18
here just the memes. Everything about
1:15:20
>> You're referencing little Sebastian. You
1:15:22
haven't watched Parks and Wreck.
1:15:24
>> No, I've seen I've seen the internet.
1:15:26
I'm from the internet.
1:15:26
>> Dude, it is exactly your [ __ ] You would
1:15:29
love it.
1:15:30
>> Yeah, sincerely. You would love it.
1:15:32
>> It's a good show.
1:15:34
>> It's a really feelood show. Like if
1:15:36
you're ever frustrated by politics, like
1:15:38
especially in the world we live in now,
1:15:40
it's like I wish politics was had good
1:15:44
people in it, watch that show.
1:15:47
>> Yeah. I
1:15:48
>> It just makes you feel warm and fuzzy
1:15:50
inside.
1:15:51
>> Like I hear you and I'm there, but like
1:15:53
when
1:15:55
>> Yeah.
1:15:56
>> Hey, you know what also might have good
1:15:58
people inside it that make you feel warm
1:16:00
and fuzzy?
1:16:00
>> Bastions.
1:16:01
>> No.
1:16:02
>> Oh, okay.
1:16:02
>> Okay. Yes, actually.
1:16:04
>> Yes. What? What were you going to say?
1:16:06
>> What were you going to say?
1:16:08
>> I was going to say bastions, but I knew
1:16:09
you were going to say bastions, too. So,
1:16:11
I just had to be I had to be
1:16:13
>> You were trying to be smooth and it
1:16:14
failed.
1:16:14
>> No, not smooth. Contradictory. It's a
1:16:17
It's a good word. It's
1:16:18
>> so Oh, so you're a child. Got it.
1:16:23
>> Okay, hang on.
1:16:24
>> We good.
1:16:25
>> He has to fix things, but we're going to
1:16:26
give him a second to do it. Being bad.
1:16:28
>> Oh, yes, it is. Steph Bastion's is
1:16:30
already sounding weird to me.
1:16:32
>> Okay. All right. Here's what's going to
1:16:33
happen. I'm going to fix my inputs. I'm
1:16:35
going to fix my outputs. And then we're
1:16:37
going to restart the recording session
1:16:38
just to be sure.
1:16:39
>> That makes sense.
1:16:40
>> Don't
1:16:42
chat. Stick around. I have to kill the
1:16:43
recording session so I can fix my inputs
1:16:46
to not be bad. We will be back in just a
1:16:48
moment. Don't go anywhere.
Games

