The RPGBOT.podcast team takes a look at the classes in Pathfinder 2e's Player Core 1 and discusses which classes are and aren't good choices for new players. Will Fighter fit? Cleric is certainly correct. But is Bard better? Can we come up with other alliteration for the classes? Apparently not!
This episode originally aired on April 23rd, 2025, and we're currently working to upload our episode backlog. For the latest from the RPGBOT.Podcast, find us in your favorite podcatcher.
Full show notes for this episode are available on RPGBOT.net: https://rpgbot.net/pf2e-class-selection-its-actually-quite-simple-rpgbot-podcast-s5e49/
Find us on socials and stuff:
🦋 https://bsky.app/profile/rpgbot.bsky.social
⏰ https://www.tiktok.com/@rpgbotdotnet
🔍 https://RPGBOT.net/
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
It is weird to me that alchemist is not
0:02
in player core one cuz it's always been
0:04
kind of a base class for Pathfinder.
0:06
>> Yeah, I mean it's more complicated than
0:08
a lot of the stuff in player one.
0:10
>> That's fair. That's fair. Did Dan have a
0:12
bread spaceship as his background before
0:14
he hung up?
0:15
>> It was a doll.
0:16
>> Oh, it was
0:18
>> Yeah, he switched out the picture of my
0:20
daughter for the bread doll.
0:22
>> Yeah, it's a bread doll.
0:24
>> Okay.
0:24
>> Why is it a bread doll? Who can say?
0:26
Yeah, it's cuz I said I said the picture
0:29
of your daughter was creeping me out
0:31
because it was it was just a massive
0:33
picture of of Tyler's daughter's head in
0:37
the back of Dan's camera and it was just
0:39
I don't know. It was just weird to me.
0:41
But the dollic is also creepy. So, I
0:44
stand corrected.
0:46
>> Oh god. What What is this now? Is that
0:49
blood? Oh, it's a dragon.
0:50
>> Oh, is it?
0:51
>> Okay. I thought it was just a bunch of
0:53
blood.
0:54
And there's a snowman in the background.
0:56
What is happening?
0:57
>> Yeah. What is What is this, Dan? What?
1:00
>> Feel like there's a lot of questions
1:01
being asked.
1:04
>> No answers. There's no answers here.
1:06
>> Oh, okay. To be very clear for everyone,
1:10
Levvenworth, the vacation destination in
1:13
Washington State. Not Levvenworth the
1:15
prison. He wasn't in a gift store in the
1:18
prison.
1:20
>> Yeah. How do you know Dan's never been
1:21
to prison?
1:23
I didn't say that and I wouldn't assert
1:26
that.
1:29
>> I'm sure you raised what you could make
1:31
with misprinted license plates.
1:34
>> Apparently dragons. I
1:35
>> apparently Hey, should we do a podcast?
1:39
>> Yeah,
1:39
>> whatever.
1:40
>> Fine.
1:42
>> We'll see you. See you, producer Dan.
1:44
Bye, Dan. All right.
1:56
Welcome to the RPG about the podcast.
1:57
I'm Erna James and with me is Tyler
1:59
Camstra. Oh god. Oh god. Hi everybody.
2:02
And Ashi.
2:03
>> Hey everybody. We're talking about new
2:04
new player characters. Not necessarily
2:06
your first player character, but
2:07
definitely your first for Path Fighter
2:08
2. There's a lot of different
2:09
complicated things that go in. And just
2:11
to clear it out of the air, we're
2:12
talking about player core one, not
2:13
player core 2. Okay. So, are we all
2:15
focused? Ready, prepared? Let's go.
2:17
>> Oh god. Is that the energy we're
2:18
bringing tonight? Cuz this is the second
2:20
episode and I'm sleepy.
2:24
>> All right, that's fine. We could we
2:25
could bring it down a notch. Okay, so we
2:28
we recently did a D and D 2024 5e,
2:33
better known as 5.5 episode where we
2:36
were looking at the 5.5 uh character
2:38
classes and basically saying like, "No
2:40
kidding. Which of these would be good as
2:42
your first character if this was your
2:43
first game of 5.5?" We're going to do
2:46
the same thing in two parts for
2:47
Pathfinder 2, looking at the remastered
2:49
content. And we thought what would make
2:50
sense to do is we're going to break this
2:52
up into player core one and player core
2:54
2. If you're buying one book, you're
2:55
probably buying player core one.
2:57
Granted, you could get access to this
2:58
through Archives of Nethus. If you're
3:00
buying two books, then maybe player core
3:02
2 is the second book you're buying.
3:03
Before we get started with this, I'm
3:05
going to say something that might be
3:07
considered a hot take and maybe
3:09
sacrilegious. I don't think Pathfinder 2
3:11
is a good game for a brand new player to
3:15
TTRPGs.
3:16
>> I agree with you 100%. That's exactly
3:18
the disclaimer I was about to give.
3:19
>> Yeah. Yeah. Uh so if you have a
3:22
significant other or someone else who is
3:24
interested in playing TTRPGs, you should
3:26
absolutely introduce them to fifth
3:28
edition, especially if it's like Dungeon
3:29
World. Honestly, I don't think even
3:31
fifth edition is maybe the best to
3:32
introduce people to TTRPGs, but for
3:34
dungeon world, I mean dungeon fantasy,
3:36
yes, it is. And then once they've played
3:39
with it for a while and you want to and
3:43
they're interested in more crunch and
3:44
stuff like that, then you can move to
3:45
Pathfinder 2. Pathfinder 2 is for
3:47
players who are already familiar with
3:49
how TTRPGs work. It is not good for
3:51
brand new players.
3:52
>> Yeah, it's like you got to get them
3:53
acclimated. And if at the end of like
3:55
many many sessions they're like, I
3:56
really wish that we spent more time role
3:58
playing and like less time worried about
4:00
these weird like feat like class feats,
4:02
Pathfinder is probably not the game for
4:04
them. And if they're like I, you know,
4:06
if if you walk in and they've converted
4:08
the office into that scene from It's
4:10
Always Sunny in Philadelphia where
4:12
they're optimizing characters on a
4:14
whiteboard, drawing strings from place
4:15
to place, Pathfinder 2, like bring it
4:17
along. I I actually want to make a
4:19
proposal. The way that I would suggest
4:20
we do this, I I think folks who play
4:22
Pathfinder 2 are familiar with these
4:24
classes already, and I hope they enjoy
4:26
this episode. I hope it gives them
4:28
thoughts about how they might bring
4:30
their friends along for the game. For
4:31
folks who haven't played Pathfinder 2, I
4:33
think it's a reasonable assumption to
4:34
think that this person has probably
4:35
played, if not fifth edition, at least D
4:37
and D, in the past. I think it would
4:39
make a lot of sense for us to talk about
4:40
the bridge between like, hey, it's a lot
4:42
like the fifth edition bard in these
4:45
ways and then it's not like the fifth
4:46
edition bard in these other ways.
4:48
>> Yeah, I was actually going to say that.
4:50
So unlike with fifth edition where we
4:52
were approaching it from a sort of brand
4:53
new player perspective like what's the
4:55
best way to just easily put people in
4:58
that we can't really do that with
4:59
Pathfinder 2 because if we did we would
5:01
just be like no no no these are none of
5:04
these none of these are good for a brand
5:06
new player it's going to be too
5:07
overwhelming. So I think I agree with
5:09
you Randall. I think we should come at
5:11
it from a perspective that this is the
5:13
second system that you're learning. like
5:15
especially if we're going under the
5:17
assumption that you're coming from fifth
5:18
edition cuz let's be honest if you're
5:20
moving to Pathfinder 2 you're probably
5:21
coming from something like fifth edition
5:23
rather than like Call of Cthulhu
5:25
although maybe you did that transition I
5:27
don't know I know at least Quasit did
5:30
well I think Quasit went from call of
5:32
Cthulhu to fifth edition but you know
5:34
you know what I mean
5:35
>> it also it could be really natural that
5:37
you're coming from D and D like 3 3.5 or
5:40
Pathfinder 1 and moving straight into
5:42
Pathfinder 2 in that case I think we'll
5:43
try to lay down something that makes
5:45
sense there as well.
5:46
>> Yeah, actually. So, yeah, Josh says in
5:49
the chat, "I haven't gotten a chance to
5:50
play it yet." I know that you're
5:51
relatively new to fifth edition as well,
5:53
like you joined like two years ago, so
5:54
this is going to be a great episode for
5:56
you if you if you are considering
5:58
checking out a new system. Maybe you'll
5:59
get a lot of value out of this.
6:01
>> Uh Joshua might be talking about Shadow
6:04
Dark based on the comments a couple
6:06
posts, but uh yeah, regardless,
6:08
>> both are true. There you go.
6:10
>> Yes, I I do like all of these
6:13
assumptions. So yes, I I agree with all
6:16
of the advice. Pathfinder second edition
6:19
probably not a fantastic first RPG
6:22
unless you're a very very particular
6:24
kind of person. I am that very
6:26
particular kind of person, but I am not
6:29
everybody.
6:30
>> Okay. And just personal like my my story
6:32
with Pathfinder too. The very first time
6:34
that we were going to play it, I sat
6:37
down to create a character and at that
6:39
point I had created a handful of fifth
6:41
edition characters. I understood fifth
6:43
edition. Okay, not great. Honestly, this
6:45
entire podcast has been a learning
6:46
experience for me over the past 20 years
6:48
that we've been doing it. I sat down to
6:50
create my first Pathfinder 2 character
6:52
and I I got lost very quickly and I
6:55
called Tyler Pancake saying, "Help me."
6:58
>> Yeah, it's it's overwhelming. Even if
7:00
you're really intimately familiar with
7:02
how RP TDRPGs work, especially coming
7:05
from like fifth edition, you're going to
7:07
come into Pathfinder 2 and it's really
7:08
easy to be like, "Oh, I don't know Jack
7:10
Squat.
7:13
Fortunately for me, I had a bit of a
7:16
less of a rough experience than than
7:18
Randall did because yeah, I did come
7:19
from a fifth edition, but my my roommate
7:23
had introduced me to Pathfinder 1
7:26
because he it's his it was the system he
7:28
was introduced to D and D with and he
7:30
thinks it's the best system. Hard
7:32
disagree with him, but that's just my
7:34
opinion. I actually had a player join
7:36
one of my games who said who was making
7:38
an argument for Pathfinder 1 being the
7:39
best system. if that if you think
7:40
Pathfinder 1 is the best system. Again,
7:42
I'm not here to yuck anybody's young.
7:44
It's just personally not my favorite. I
7:45
I have a lot of problems with it. But
7:47
going from that, which if you think
7:49
Pathfinder 2 is a nightmare and is
7:51
overwhelming, boy, you haven't seen
7:53
anything yet. Pathfinder 1 is
7:54
ridiculously obtuse.
7:56
>> So coming from that to coming to
7:58
Pathfinder 2, I was like, "Oh, this is
7:59
just way more simplified Pathfinder 1
8:02
with some vague elements of 5e thrown
8:04
in. I can get behind this."
8:07
So, I was coming from a hardcore
8:09
experience, too. Somewhat of a It was
8:12
like someone put me into a video game
8:14
where I played easy mode first and then
8:16
they were like, "Hey, you want to play
8:17
super to duper hard mode?" I'm like, "I
8:20
don't know. I don't really want to."
8:21
Like, you're going to play it anyway.
8:22
And then I played that and I was like,
8:24
"Can I just Is there a normal mode? Can
8:26
I go to normal?" Yeah. This is what I
8:28
want. This is good. I like this. This is
8:29
my happy place.
8:31
>> All right. All right. So, let's let's
8:34
hit the classes that are in player core
8:36
one. I'm going to list them real quick.
8:38
So, there are only eight. So, bard,
8:40
cleric, druid, fighter, ranger, rogue,
8:45
witch, wizard. So, we've got eight
8:47
classes in player core one.
8:50
>> Yeah. So, just in case anybody's
8:52
wondering who's not familiar with
8:53
Pathfinder one, if you're like, they
8:54
only have eight classes.
8:56
5 has 12. No, core one. There are
9:00
multiple there are multiple books. I
9:02
don't know how many they have right now.
9:04
I think it's like how many? Like 16,
9:06
something like that.
9:07
>> Oh, it's got to be more than that. I was
9:09
going to guess 30 plus
9:11
>> classes. Classes.
9:13
>> Yeah, classes.
9:14
>> Okay. So, all right. So, we've got 16
9:16
between the two player cores, two from
9:19
Secrets of Magic, two from Guns and
9:21
Gears, two from Dark Archives, so that's
9:24
22. Two from God's Reign. Oh god, the
9:29
>> I have the number. Do you want me to
9:30
tell you? Yeah.
9:32
>> 25.
9:33
>> Oh, I was at 24. What's the 25th one?
9:36
What did I forget?
9:37
>> There are 25 classes.
9:39
>> So, yeah. Why? I'll just have
9:41
>> to bring them all in the darkness. Bind
9:43
them. Is that,
9:44
>> you know? Well, I'm I'm just going to
9:45
list out all the classes. Obviously,
9:47
we're only talking about player car one
9:48
cuz if we don't limit it somehow, we're
9:51
going to be here forever. And you're
9:53
like, there's no way it's going to be
9:54
eight classes is going to be as long as
9:56
12 classes. Oh, boy. You haven't you
9:57
haven't played Battlefire 2. Anyway, so
9:59
the classes are alchemist, animus,
10:01
barbarian, bard, champion, cleric,
10:04
druid, fighter, investigator,
10:06
kineticist, magus, monk, oracle,
10:09
psychic, ranger, rogue, sorcerer,
10:12
summoner, swashbuckler, thurge, witch,
10:15
wizard, gunslinger, inventor, and
10:17
exemplar.
10:18
>> Okay, kineticist is the one I forgot.
10:20
Josh has it right. I I thought of every
10:22
book that has two classes in it, Rage of
10:25
Elements only has one class. Yeah,
10:27
>> that's how we got to 25. All right.
10:29
Dang.
10:29
>> Cuz kineticis is a big special baby.
10:32
>> Yeah, it's so many classes in one. An
10:35
entire party.
10:36
>> Kinesis is probably just the most
10:37
overpowered class in Pathfinder 2 right
10:39
now. It's so good.
10:41
>> A little bit. All right. Okay. So, we're
10:44
looking at player cord. Player core one,
10:47
the eight classes in it. So, these were
10:50
deemed the most essential, the most
10:53
iconic classes for Pathfinders Dungeon
10:56
Fantasy. And also, these are kind of the
11:00
baseline level of complexity. So, these
11:02
classes will generally be less
11:04
complicated to play than any of the
11:06
classes in the other books.
11:08
>> Yeah. And it's worth pointing out like
11:10
we'll talk about it as player core one,
11:11
player core 2. We're going to do another
11:12
episode on player core 2. Going back in
11:14
time, pre-reaster, we had the players
11:17
handbook and
11:19
>> was it rule book and then the advanced
11:22
players guide,
11:23
>> right?
11:24
>> That's what I was going to call it. It
11:25
was literally the advanced players
11:26
guide. Like, hey, you want something
11:28
more complicated, we have these other
11:29
classes for you. Was it actually called
11:31
core rule book?
11:32
>> Yeah. Yeah.
11:32
>> Okay, good. There we go. Okay.
11:33
>> Yeah, cuz the player content and the
11:35
game master content were all in one
11:37
book. They did eventually do a game
11:39
mastery guide as well, but it was super
11:41
optional.
11:42
>> Yeah. I like how the I like the new
11:44
naming scheme for remaster. It's super
11:46
to the point and makes sense. So yeah,
11:49
if people are curious how the there's
11:51
going to be several of these episodes as
11:53
opposed to 5, which only had one. So
11:55
it's going to be player core one, then
11:56
player core 2, and then we'll probably
11:58
do the peripheral ones like everything
12:01
else.
12:01
>> Yeah. Everything else is their own
12:02
episode.
12:04
>> And and we may just, you know, we
12:05
haven't decided yet. We may wait to do
12:06
that everything else to give them a
12:08
little bit more time to remaster more of
12:10
the content. Yeah, we can at least touch
12:12
on the ones that feel like they're
12:14
already remastered. Like Kineticist, I
12:16
know released, right? It was like the
12:18
first thing they released under the
12:19
remaster license. And then Gunslinger
12:21
and Ventor have been remastered. Animist
12:23
and Exemplar are in the remaster. So
12:26
those ones we can touch on. Maybe we
12:28
should keep Summoner and Magus for last.
12:30
>> Yeah,
12:31
>> those are the only two I think they
12:32
haven't remastered yet. So,
12:34
>> all right. So, let's let's go ahead and
12:35
jump in the bard alphabetically, the
12:39
first one. So like in 5e the bard can be
12:43
a lot of things but it is primarily a
12:46
spellcaster. Kind of the unique
12:49
signature mechanic of the bard is the
12:51
composition cantrip. So it's a it's a
12:54
special kind of like focus spell but it
12:56
doesn't use focus points. So you don't
12:58
have to deal with that except when it
13:00
does. But composition canrips are a
13:02
oneaction spell that you use to perform
13:05
in some way to provide a buff for your
13:08
party. The default one is courageous
13:10
anthem. Everybody gets a bonus to
13:13
attacks, damage, and saves against fear.
13:16
So like that is the iconic bard ability
13:19
dating back as long as bards have
13:21
existed in D&D, but instead of bic
13:24
inspiration, it's now courageous anthem.
13:26
>> Or as my bard in my West Marches game
13:28
calls it, murderous anthem
13:31
>> a little bit. Yeah.
13:32
>> Yeah. You're good better at murder.
13:34
>> Yeah.
13:35
>> Okay. So, if we're talking about which I
13:37
think is the best one, easy to get into,
13:40
I'd probably put bard to kind of middle
13:42
of the road, I don't think it's super
13:44
complicated. If you're coming from 5e
13:46
and you're used to playing bards, it's
13:48
going to feel really similar. Obviously,
13:50
there's more emphasis placed on, you
13:52
know, performance stuff like
13:55
composition, lingering composition, all
13:56
that stuff. You mean I actually get to
13:58
use my performance for something? Yes.
14:00
>> It's kind of a crucial skill. If you
14:02
don't have performance as a bard, you're
14:05
going to have a rough time. Um, so so
14:08
and the spells are all a cult is a good
14:11
spell list. I think there's a lot of
14:13
good versatility on there. There's not
14:15
many spells that I feel are traps. It is
14:18
it does lean into that support cer type
14:21
of role, but you can do just as much
14:23
damage as any as some other casters, and
14:26
you also have some healing capability.
14:27
It's a pretty versatile class.
14:29
>> Yeah. So, what I like about the bard is
14:32
that the the gameplay loop in combat can
14:35
be very simple. You'll use courageous
14:37
anthem that's going to use one of your
14:39
three actions. You might use lingering
14:41
composition. And Tyler, remind me, is
14:43
lingering composition a free action? Is
14:45
it triggered by using
14:47
>> It's a free action. Yeah,
14:48
>> but it's also it's also limited to one
14:51
of the subasses. So, that's not
14:53
available to everybody.
14:54
>> I thought it was a feat. Is it not a
14:55
feat? It is, but it is limited to one of
14:58
the subasses you can use.
15:00
>> Exactly. So, so the bard subass is
15:02
called their muse, which is like what
15:05
variety of thing inspires you. So,
15:07
there's like the the fighty one that's
15:09
kind of about weapons. The maestro one,
15:11
warrior muse, thank you. The maestro,
15:13
which is just I'm really good at being a
15:15
bard. There's the enigma muse, which is
15:18
more about spellcasting. And you get to
15:21
you get to play a little bit like a
15:22
wizard, just a little bit, and you know
15:24
a lot of things. So that's fine.
15:26
>> Oh, you're right. It is limited to one
15:28
subass. So yeah, if you want your
15:30
compositions to last more than a turn,
15:32
>> Mhm.
15:33
>> Lingering composition is the way to go.
15:35
>> Yeah.
15:36
>> And so my call out here is like you can
15:38
use courageous anthem as one of your
15:39
actions every every turn. If you happen
15:42
to have subclass muse, you could do
15:43
linger composition, in which case it's
15:45
going to free you up for future turns.
15:47
Most spells of consequence in combat are
15:49
going to be two action spells. So you're
15:52
going to pick a handful of spells.
15:53
you're going to have them available and
15:54
and that's probably what most of your
15:56
turns are going to look like. The other
15:58
thing that you get to do if you're a
15:59
bard is you you're probably going to be
16:01
the face of your party. You're going to
16:02
have very high charisma and so a lot of
16:04
your social interactions are going to
16:05
fall to you. If you as a player are
16:07
ready to take on driving that, you're
16:10
probably going to have a lot of fun
16:11
playing this class. I think and this is
16:14
towards the point everybody was getting
16:15
at. You can do a lot of things as a
16:16
bard. So driving your bard in combat
16:19
could become quite complicated if you
16:21
want to allow it. But but my my call it
16:23
is it doesn't really have to be and you
16:25
combine that with fun of being the face.
16:27
This I think it is a good first class.
16:30
>> I will say the let's see so kind of the
16:32
core design thing of how Piso builds
16:35
classes for PF2 is they look at the
16:37
three action economy and you're going to
16:40
do something that usually takes two
16:41
actions and then something that takes
16:43
one action on most of your turns. four
16:45
bards. That one action is your
16:48
composition cantrips and the two actions
16:50
is usually casting a spell. So there
16:53
will be turns where like you use a
16:55
composition cantrip, you cast a spell,
16:57
but you have no movement. So if you need
17:00
to move, you need to choose between
17:02
using a composition cantrip or casting
17:05
one of your bigger spells. And that can
17:07
cause some kind of analysis paralysis
17:09
which can be frustrating. But at the
17:12
same time, because your composition
17:14
cantrips are only one action, even if
17:16
you have to like stride twice or like
17:18
stride and raise a shield, you always do
17:21
something that's beneficial for your
17:23
entire party. So like your baseline
17:26
level of effectiveness even when you're
17:27
struggling is still pretty good.
17:29
>> Yeah. I mean, the other thing that's
17:31
great about Bards, like yeah, there is
17:32
that analysis process, but there are a
17:34
bunch of different compositions that all
17:36
do different things. And so regardless
17:39
of what you want to do, you'll be able
17:40
to find something that is useful for you
17:42
and the party. So there's there's no
17:44
real bad compositions. I would say
17:46
there's just niche compositions that
17:49
really depend on the situation that
17:51
you're doing. So you need it's about
17:53
knowing what composition is good for the
17:55
specific situation you're in. It's
17:58
usually going to be Courageous Anthem,
17:59
but there are other times where it might
18:01
be something else.
18:02
>> Yeah. Like one of the one of the
18:04
composition cantrips gives all of your
18:06
allies a small amount of resistance to
18:09
bludgeoning, piercing, and slashing
18:11
damage. It's like one point by default
18:13
and it increases by a couple of points
18:15
to a maximum of like four or five. And
18:18
that doesn't feel like a lot, but if you
18:21
have an entire party who are using
18:23
firearms that have that like splash
18:25
damage thing, you can just have
18:27
everybody in the party do a ton of
18:28
splash damage to everything in the
18:30
encounter. your entire party just
18:32
resists all of the damage. So suddenly
18:34
everyone's just throwing grenades and
18:36
blowing stuff up, not hurting
18:38
themselves. So like you can build an
18:40
entire party around that that strategy
18:42
and it could work great.
18:44
>> Go ahead.
18:44
>> No, the the last thing I want to
18:45
highlight here is that how impactful it
18:47
can be to be giving your party these
18:50
buffs and as a player that's really
18:52
rewarding especially if folks are
18:53
acknowledging the fact that like yes,
18:55
what you were doing is making the
18:57
difference between being effective and
18:58
ineffective. And again calling out in
18:59
Pathfinder 2, not only do we have
19:01
success, we also have critical success.
19:03
And so there's a a 5% chance when you
19:06
give somebody plus one to something that
19:07
you're going to move something from a
19:08
failure to a success. There's also a 5%
19:11
chance you're going to move them from a
19:12
success to a critical success. And so
19:14
all of that feels really good.
19:15
>> Yeah, Steph in the chat pointed out that
19:17
yeah, if you're worried that in order to
19:19
get lingering composition I have to be
19:21
maestro, no, there's a feat that she
19:24
pointed out is multifarious muse which
19:26
allows you to take feats of other muses.
19:28
So yeah, if you want if you don't want
19:30
to be a maestro muse, you just take that
19:33
and you can get lingering composition.
19:34
It's worth it. Lingering composition is
19:36
great.
19:36
>> It really is. I have it on my current
19:38
bard. It is so nice.
19:41
>> Yeah. No, it makes it makes your action
19:43
economy as a bard so much better.
19:45
>> Yeah.
19:46
>> She's going to roll good.
19:47
>> All right. So So bard, we're saying good
19:50
starting class, bad starting class,
19:52
somewhere in the middle. I think it's
19:54
somewhere in the middle.
19:55
>> I'd give it a B. Yeah. If we're putting
19:57
on a tier list, I'd say it's a B for a
19:58
starting class. It's right in the
19:59
middle. I think it's got enough
20:01
complexity that you'll you can really
20:05
invest time into it and get some really
20:07
cool unique builds, but it's not so
20:10
overwhelming that it's going to be it's
20:12
going to lose players in the sauce. I
20:15
think it's a fine class to start with.
20:17
It's not my my number one pick if I'm
20:20
being honest. So, I'm willing to accept
20:22
to be and and I want to echo what I said
20:25
a little bit ago. You can be a very
20:27
effective bard keeping your combat loop
20:30
very simple and then you can learn the
20:32
complexity along the way. You can kind
20:33
of grow into this character. Yeah. Which
20:35
I think is really great,
20:36
>> which is why I'm giving it B. I don't
20:38
think it's the most complex class, but I
20:40
also think there's a lot of ways that
20:42
you can get a little bit confused or
20:44
like Tyler said, get analysis paralysis.
20:46
But hey, if you get analysis paralysis,
20:48
you can always go to rpgbod.net.
20:49
>> Yeah. Oh, I should call out the bard is
20:53
the only spontaneous caster in player
20:55
core one.
20:55
>> Oh, yeah. That's true. Now, that's the
20:57
other thing. Spontaneous casters, if
20:59
you're especially if you're coming from
21:00
5e, it's going to take a bit for you to
21:03
wrap your head around. Yeah.
21:04
>> So, that's the other major pitfall of
21:06
the bard. So, the the thing you have to
21:08
keep in mind with spontaneous casters is
21:11
you get to you it's like 5e and that you
21:14
get to use your spell slots for whatever
21:15
spells you know, but you don't know your
21:18
spells. You can't immediately upcast all
21:20
of your spells.
21:21
>> If you want to upcast a fireball to like
21:24
level four, then you need to learn you
21:26
need to dedicate one of your learned
21:27
spells to that fourth level's fireball.
21:30
And that that can irritate some people
21:32
coming from fifth edition.
21:34
>> Yeah, but you make it your signature
21:36
spell.
21:36
>> Yeah, complication of
21:38
>> Yeah, I was just about to get to that.
21:40
Uh, all spell repertoires come with
21:43
spell signature spells. So those are
21:45
spells that you use a lot of that you
21:47
and you immediately learn that spell at
21:50
every single rank. So you can just if
21:52
you cast fireball a lot, I want to make
21:54
this my signature spell. Now you can
21:56
cast it from level three to level 10.
21:58
>> Yes.
21:58
>> So does RPGbot have just an explainer
22:01
for spell casting at Pathfinder 2?
22:03
>> I think we have a how to play Oh,
22:07
>> I don't remember if I uh
22:08
>> if we don't have that article, I will
22:10
write that article.
22:12
I can't remember if I finished the how
22:14
to play PF2 articles series. I did. I
22:18
didn't. So, I haven't covered
22:21
spellcasting. I got through like all of
22:22
the core mechanics.
22:24
>> I will write it for you, Tyler.
22:26
>> Cool. Good.
22:27
>> Yeah, cuz it's confusing. It was
22:29
confusing for me cuz it's similar in
22:31
Pathfinder 1 as well. So, that's why
22:34
people might like fifth edition really
22:36
changed how spells work and people don't
22:38
realize that. Uh, the fifth edition is
22:40
really generous with how spells work.
22:43
So, if you're coming from fifth edition
22:45
and you're used to how spells work, and
22:47
I see this all the time from people who
22:48
are trying to get into Pathfinder 2,
22:50
it's the immediate turnoff for them.
22:52
They're just like, I hate how spells
22:54
work and it's not a system for me. But
22:56
it's like, yeah, okay, I get it, but
22:58
just give it a chance. Trust me, it
23:00
makes sense once you get into it and it
23:02
still feels really good because you're
23:04
now having to think strategically about
23:06
what spells you're are important to you
23:08
rather than just taking it for granted.
23:10
>> It it also does a really really good job
23:13
balancing spellcasters versus marshals.
23:16
So like wizards no longer run away with
23:18
the game. I still think they're the best
23:20
class, but they don't run away with
23:21
game.
23:22
>> Yeah. They're not they're not just
23:23
making fighters look like worthless just
23:26
meat shields.
23:28
>> Yeah. So I that's what I appreciate
23:30
about it. Everybody's kind of on the
23:31
same level. It kind of irritates me,
23:33
especially in higher levels where if
23:34
you're not playing a caster, you're just
23:36
not having a good time
23:37
>> in 5.
23:38
>> In 5e. That's what I mean.
23:40
>> Yeah. Cool. Ready to talk about cleric?
23:42
>> Yeah.
23:42
>> Yeah. I think this is a great first
23:44
class. I think it's easy to learn. The
23:48
spell casting is also really forgiving
23:50
because you know all of your spells.
23:52
It's similar to how it works in in 5e.
23:55
You know all of your spells. You don't
23:56
have to write them down in a book and
23:58
you can change them out whenever you
23:59
want to. The they are still a prepared
24:02
class. So it works differently from
24:04
fifth edition, but it's not as much of a
24:05
mindbender as spontaneous. So to explain
24:09
briefly how repaired casters work, you
24:11
can up your spells to whatever as long
24:13
as you know the spell, you can upcast it
24:15
to any any spell slot that you have
24:18
available similar to 5. But your spell
24:21
slots are dedicated to that spell. So,
24:25
if I wanted to cast two heals in a day,
24:28
I don't just prepare heal and then I use
24:30
the two spell slots that I have to cast
24:33
heal twice. I have to specifically
24:36
prepare two spell slots to cast heal and
24:39
nothing else from those two spell slots.
24:41
I can't use those spell slots for
24:43
anything else. Yeah.
24:44
>> Although, is that actually a bad example
24:46
for cleric? Because don't they get don't
24:48
they always have a certain number of
24:49
heals?
24:50
>> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Sure. I'm just I'm
24:53
just trying to get it's a general
24:55
prepared prepared rule. Clerics are
24:57
their own bag of worms, but it's and
25:00
again that can be kind of a turnoff for
25:02
people. It was for me when I first
25:03
started playing Pathfinder one, but it
25:05
it gets to a point where you know what
25:08
specific spells are good to prepare for
25:10
a specific day. Are you consider are you
25:12
probably not going to get into a lot of
25:13
combat? Then maybe you should pick like
25:15
some social utility buffing sort of
25:18
spells. If you're if you're considering
25:19
getting into combat, then you should
25:21
pick buffing and healing spells. And
25:23
what's also great about this sort of
25:25
spell casting is unlike 5ev, there's no
25:28
concentration. So if you want to buff
25:30
your barbarian to high heaven, you can
25:33
do that. I want to enlarge him. I want
25:35
to give him some extra attack. I want to
25:37
make him holy and I want to I want to
25:40
transfer some of the portion of my life
25:42
that gets hit into him. You can do all
25:44
of that before you go into the boss room
25:46
and just make a huge tank, which is
25:49
awesome and it feels great,
25:52
>> but it does wind up being difficult to
25:54
balance. You know, again, being being
25:56
more generic, like think about yourself
25:58
as a 5v wizard, and if you are the type
26:01
of 5v wizard that walks into every
26:02
situation and fireballs it to do the
26:05
same thing in Pathfinder 2, you're
26:07
literally going to fill your spell slots
26:08
top to bottom with fireball, which means
26:10
that you're not going to have the other
26:12
options available to you. And then
26:13
you're going to wish that you had them
26:15
and you're going to hope that you have
26:16
something that lets you make a quick
26:17
stop depending on the situation that you
26:19
find yourself in.
26:20
>> Yeah, related to that stuff point out it
26:22
also makes it more effort to be a
26:23
blaster cer that 5v8 players may
26:25
dislike. Absolutely. I don't think being
26:28
a blaster caster in Pathfinder 2 is the
26:30
play. I think if you want to play that
26:32
way, you're going to have a rough time
26:34
because it's just going to be well all
26:37
of my spell slots are just fireball and
26:40
when you're not casting when they're not
26:42
in a situation where you can cast
26:43
fireball, you're not doing anything. So,
26:47
so that can be a trap for a lot of
26:50
players. So, my recommendation is if
26:52
you're if you know there's a damage
26:54
spell that you're going to cast multiple
26:55
times, prep two of those, maybe a third
26:59
at a higher level. That's it. You don't
27:01
need more than that. Trust me, you
27:03
won't. Especially at like some of the
27:06
lower levels, any more than that is kind
27:07
of overkill. and then prep other utility
27:11
spells or buffing spells because again
27:13
since there's no concentration, you can
27:15
just cast buffing spells on your turn
27:17
and not overwrite anything and it's
27:19
still going to feel just as awesome as
27:21
casting fireball. So, it's a different
27:23
way of approaching spell casting that
27:26
might take an adjustment for people, but
27:27
once you get a hang on it's like, oh, I
27:29
don't have to just cast fireball and not
27:32
feel like I'm not contributing to the
27:34
fight in any way, shape, or form. This
27:36
feels awesome.
27:38
And don't forget, you're always going to
27:39
have your cantrips available to you.
27:41
>> Yeah. Yeah. 100%. And the cantrips are
27:43
actually pretty good. There's some
27:45
really useful cantrips.
27:46
>> All right. So, talking about the
27:48
cleric's actual features that might
27:50
appeal to new players. So, they have the
27:51
divine spell list. Like the cleric is
27:54
the only divine spellcaster in player
27:57
core one. And the divine spell list has
28:00
the it has the best healing options of
28:03
the four spell lists. In addition to
28:06
that, clerics get a feature called
28:08
divine font. And depending on your
28:10
deity, if your deity is goodle leaning,
28:13
you can have the healing font. If your
28:15
deity is evil leaning, you'll have the
28:17
harming font. So, you will get free
28:19
castings per day of either heal or harm
28:23
depending on your deity. If you get
28:25
harm, it's a whole bunch of damage. If
28:27
you get heal, it's a whole bunch of
28:29
healing. And healing in combat in PF2 is
28:33
really really good and effective. So
28:36
getting free castings of heal is really
28:38
impactful and it feels very satisfying.
28:40
>> Yeah, heals in PF2 are crazy. Although
28:44
the 2024 rules buffed healing quite
28:46
substantially, so that's good.
28:48
>> Yeah.
28:49
>> Clerics also get to choose between being
28:51
a war priest or a cloistered cleric.
28:53
Cloistered clerics are basically divine
28:55
wizards. Like you're you're built for
28:57
the backline. Your armor is terrible.
29:00
You're kind of frail, but you're really
29:01
good at spell casting. War priest,
29:03
you're wearing armor. You're using your
29:06
deity's favorite weapon. You're getting
29:07
in melee and you're mixing it up a bit.
29:09
>> Yeah, Steph is a is a war priest in our
29:12
in our West Marshes game. And her
29:14
signature move is tossing people
29:16
unconscious away from the danger.
29:20
>> It's a good trick.
29:22
>> Just triaging heat.
29:24
>> Yeah. No, I mean, hey, it's it's work.
29:26
It saved multiple people's lives at this
29:28
point. The lawyer in one of Yeah. One of
29:30
the sessions they were in two sessions
29:32
now that she's been in there were these
29:34
big huge monsters that were chasing
29:36
them. In one the lawyer went down, she
29:37
tossed him out of the way. And then the
29:39
recent one our gunslinger went down. She
29:41
tossed him into a cave was like, "You're
29:43
fine." But then she forgot that he was
29:45
down and they were like having this
29:47
conversation.
29:47
>> Oh no.
29:48
>> And and Quasa was just like, "Um, is
29:51
somebody going to heal me?
29:58
H clerics are great. You also get Yeah.
30:01
And your choice of deity matters. It's
30:03
not just flavor. Like each deity has
30:06
their like Tyler said, they have a
30:08
divine font. They have favored spell
30:10
list. They have a favored weapon as
30:12
well. And when you use like spirit
30:15
spiritual weapon, that weapon forms into
30:18
into the deity's favored weapon and
30:20
stuff like that. And there's also, you
30:22
know, the edicts and anathemas that you
30:25
really have to pay attention to. So your
30:28
deity will reward things that you follow
30:31
your edicts and will severely punish you
30:33
if you do an anathema.
30:35
You don't want to do an anathema cuz you
30:37
might lose some of your power. I believe
30:40
it requires you to do a flat check
30:41
anytime you use a spell that if your
30:44
deity is angry at you, otherwise it
30:46
fails. So you need to go on a mission to
30:48
redeem yourself. There's actually a
30:49
whole ritual, I think, called
30:50
redemption. So,
30:51
>> sounds right.
30:52
>> Yeah.
30:53
>> All right. So, what do we think? Good
30:54
starting class, bad starting class.
30:56
>> I think it's a pretty good starting
30:57
class. I think if you're coming from
30:59
fifth edition, it's going to feel very
31:01
familiar. Other than the prepared
31:02
casting things, and you're going to feel
31:04
more connected with your deity than you
31:06
were in 5e. Like we talked Randall, your
31:08
cleric in your in your Dragon Lance game
31:11
didn't even remember who their deity
31:12
was.
31:14
That's not that's going to be less of an
31:15
issue in Pathfinder 2 because your deity
31:17
gives you features that you need to
31:19
engage with as well as edicts and
31:21
anathemas that will come to bite you in
31:23
the butt if you're not paying attention
31:25
to them. So I think roleplaywise really
31:29
easy to understand mechanics-wise it's
31:31
pretty forgiving and clerics are just
31:34
great. The the divine spell list has a
31:36
great number of spells that are all
31:38
useful. Yeah, I think this is probably
31:40
an A or S tier start start starting
31:42
class in my book.
31:44
>> Yeah, I think coming from 5e, I think
31:45
you do need that explainer of how
31:47
prepared casters work and understanding
31:49
that you have to fill spell slots. I
31:51
think the good news is that if you're
31:53
using a system like Foundry, it's going
31:54
to kind of squeeze you into that, but I
31:55
don't want to assume that every player
31:57
is there.
31:57
>> Yeah, it does. Yeah. I I think if you
32:00
can get if you can wrap your head around
32:02
how casting works at that point, I'm
32:05
excited for you to play either the
32:07
closter cleric or the war priest because
32:09
again, I think the the combat loop will
32:12
make sense. And when you know, oh,
32:14
you're extremely injured. It is my time
32:16
to shine. And if I'm a war priest, I'm
32:18
just going to stab this guy until
32:20
somebody says I'm hurt.
32:22
Pretty much that's that's been Steph's
32:24
go-to move.
32:27
But um what was I going to say? Yeah.
32:29
And you know, coming back to the
32:30
prepared caster thing, I think the
32:33
reason why I think it's it's it's a good
32:35
class to start with, especially with the
32:37
prepared stuff is unlike with wizard
32:38
where the tendency might be to go
32:40
blaster caster. I feel like people if
32:42
you're coming to cleric, that's not the
32:44
first thing on your mind. You're
32:45
probably coming at it from a support
32:47
mindset, which is the correct way to go
32:49
about it when you're talking about
32:50
prepared spells. I mean, not that you
32:52
can't play some builds that do a lot of
32:55
damage. You certainly can, but it really
32:58
Pathfinder 2 really encourages you to to
33:01
make cast a wide net when it comes to
33:03
your spells. And I think clerics in 5e
33:06
are encouraged to be kind of like a
33:07
support Swiss knife type of caster. So
33:11
it the transition I think won't be as
33:13
harsh for clerics as it will be for
33:15
something like a wizard.
33:16
>> I could see that.
33:17
>> Tyler, where's your head at?
33:18
>> Oh. Oh yeah, good call. Um I think it's
33:20
a Yeah, definitely better than the bard.
33:24
It probably wouldn't be my first choice
33:26
for a new player unless they
33:28
specifically wanted to try a
33:29
spellcaster, in which case pretty good
33:31
choice. I would push people more towards
33:34
cloistered cleric for their first
33:36
character, but I do like the durability
33:38
of the war priest. So, I'm kind of on
33:40
the fence there. Like cloistered cleric
33:43
with a dedication feat to get heavy
33:45
armor is probably like that perfect
33:47
sweet spot where you're durable, but you
33:49
only have to worry about spellcasting.
33:51
You don't also have to deal with being
33:53
good at weapons.
33:54
>> Yeah, 100%. I think I think you're right
33:57
about that. I think cloistered is
33:58
probably the better choice.
34:00
>> Yeah,
34:00
>> Druid. All right, I'm going to say what
34:02
I said in 5e. Don't start with Druid.
34:05
>> Uh I think Druid is a bit complicated.
34:08
There's a lot of traps when it comes to
34:09
druid. There's the whole animal
34:11
companion thing
34:12
>> that you're pretty pushed into as a
34:14
druid. and animal companions, especially
34:16
if you're coming from fifth edition,
34:18
like any sort of minion or summon is a
34:21
nightmare. Um, and it's going to
34:23
disappoint you hard because minions are
34:26
minions are good. Don't get me wrong.
34:28
Minions are great.
34:29
>> Yeah.
34:29
>> But they are not as godly,
34:31
game-breaking, action economy destroying
34:33
as fifth edition. So, if you're coming
34:36
at it from that standpoint, you're going
34:37
to be massively let down. I'm just
34:40
telling you what I can only ever have
34:42
like two minions and I wanted to play a
34:45
necromancer. This is bull crap. Well,
34:47
wait. My response to that is wait for
34:50
the necromancer that's coming out soon
34:51
because I've seen it firsthand and it is
34:54
rad. It's very fun. But yeah, I think
34:58
druid it's a it's it's a good class. I
35:01
it has it has similar pitfalls to fifth
35:03
edition in that I think it is a very
35:05
complex class that requires a lot of
35:07
understanding of how the game works, how
35:11
works, and how the action economy
35:13
functions for you to get a lot out of
35:15
it. It might be me squeaking. So yeah,
35:19
Ash is absolutely right. The druid does
35:21
require some understanding of the system
35:24
that you might not need for other
35:26
classes. So there's there's basically
35:27
three varieties of druids. There's wild
35:30
shaped druids, there's animal companion
35:32
druids, and then there's just straight
35:34
up casting focus druids. Animal
35:36
companions will get you into the minion
35:38
rules. And your animal companion can be
35:40
fantastic, but it is complicated.
35:43
>> The the wild shaped druid, you basically
35:46
turn yourself into a fighter for one
35:48
minute at a time. And the uh like the
35:50
polymorph spells, that will be your
35:52
character. Like you will build for
35:54
polymorphing, you will build your stats
35:56
for polymorphing, you will build your
35:58
items for polymorphing, and that is all
36:00
that you will do because it monopolizes
36:03
your build to do it right. And it's a
36:06
pretty complicated mechanic. So I like
36:08
not your first character, please. Not a
36:11
wild shape druid for your first.
36:13
>> No. No. Wild shape is even worse than
36:16
than animal companion. Like animal
36:18
companion once you understand it, it's
36:19
not too bad.
36:20
>> Yeah. I still don't fully understand how
36:23
how wild shaped druids work. It's weird,
36:25
y'all. It's very odd,
36:28
>> let alone like how to actually do it.
36:29
Well,
36:30
>> yeah, it's it's it's so complicated.
36:34
>> We do have a PF2 Wild Shape article,
36:36
which I'm pretty happy with. I haven't
36:38
updated it for the remaster, but not
36:40
that much change, so it should still be
36:42
good. M
36:43
>> now if you go for a straight casting
36:45
focused druid it's it's not
36:48
significantly more complicated than
36:50
playing a cloistered cleric. You have
36:52
the primal spell list instead of the
36:53
divine spell list. So like that's going
36:55
to be the big distinguisher. And then
36:57
like whatever subclass you pick is going
36:59
to add some complicated things like the
37:01
uh I believe it's the tempest subclass
37:04
if I remember right. You're really good
37:06
at fighting in nasty weather. So, you're
37:08
encouraged to use spells that create
37:11
nasty weather for you to fight in
37:12
because you are at an advantage compared
37:14
to everybody else on the battlefield.
37:16
But that alone can be very complicated.
37:18
>> I also think talking about the primal
37:20
spell list, I I don't think the primal
37:22
spellist is the weakest spell list, but
37:24
I think it has the most traps and the
37:26
most niche situational abilities. So, it
37:31
it it primal can be very good, but you
37:33
need to know how to use it effectively.
37:35
It has a lot of summoning spells. It has
37:37
a lot of like area control stuff and
37:39
weather stuff as Tyler said. So, some
37:41
things that sound good on paper are
37:44
you're going to cast them and realize
37:45
they don't do what you thought they did.
37:47
So, read up on your spells if you're
37:49
doing druid or any sort of primal
37:50
caster. Otherwise, you're in for a rude
37:52
awakening.
37:53
>> Yeah, I could see that.
37:54
>> All right. Ready to move on to fighter?
37:56
>> Yeah, I think so.
37:56
>> Yeah. I mean,
37:57
>> all right. So, yes.
37:59
>> Yeah. I mean, it's just everything we
38:02
said about 5e applies here as well.
38:04
Fighter is the most basic class. It is
38:06
really easy to get into, especially if
38:08
you're coming from 5e and you're like,
38:10
"Martials are boring." Oh, man. Are you
38:12
in for some a treat, my friend. Fighters
38:15
are great in Path Fighter 2. I mean,
38:17
they're great in 5e as well, but it's
38:20
it's not even a comparison. Like,
38:21
fighters in in PF2 are so customizable.
38:24
They're so versatile. They have so many
38:27
buttons that they can push. You can do
38:29
all these different things. You can make
38:30
literally any sort of Marshall character
38:33
that you could dream of. Do you want to
38:35
play a per a a a character that fights
38:37
people with a false leg? Specialize into
38:40
dynamo. Get the dynamo archetype. It's
38:42
fantastic.
38:43
>> Wait, do you mean like I have a false
38:45
leg and also I fight people or do you
38:46
mean I literally take off my false leg
38:48
and I beat people with it?
38:50
>> Either and or both.
38:52
>> Either and or both options.
38:54
>> Yeah, those are both options. You can do
38:56
literally anything with fighter and
38:58
archetype. Like you can even do some
39:00
casting if you want to. Very
39:03
customizable, really versatile. They're
39:06
super beginner friendly. S tier.
39:08
Absolute S tier. This is the f like if
39:11
nobody want if if a new player coming
39:13
from fifth edition or even a new player
39:15
to teach RPGs in general has no idea
39:17
want to play what they want to play.
39:18
Fighter.
39:19
>> Yeah.
39:19
>> Hands down.
39:20
>> Yeah. So this is a small thing, but it
39:22
excites me a lot. Longtime listeners of
39:23
the podcast or people familiar with
39:25
Pathfinder 2 will know you do not always
39:27
get attacks of opportunity in Pathfinder
39:29
2. Beginning the game with reactive
39:31
strike is awesome because everybody else
39:34
who's played 5D is like, "Oh, he's
39:35
leaving my square. I want to stab him."
39:37
And you're like, "Nuh-uh, you can't."
39:38
And the fighter is like, "Yeah, I
39:39
can't."
39:41
>> Yes,
39:41
>> he stabs him.
39:42
>> Yeah, Steph makes a good point. You can
39:45
make literally any character from media,
39:48
any fighter character from media that
39:49
you can think of. You want to play
39:51
Batman, easy enough to do. You want to
39:54
Steph gives the example of Jet from Atla
39:56
because hook swords, those are a thing
39:58
in Pathfinder 2 and they have their own
40:00
mechanics. It's super cool. So yeah, you
40:03
can do you that's fighters are
40:05
infinitely customizable.
40:07
>> Okay, so there's three things that I
40:09
that I think are going to be fantastic
40:10
for new players on the fighter. First,
40:13
their attack bonus with weapons is plus
40:16
two better than anybody else. Like no
40:20
one except arguably the gunslinger, no
40:23
one is as good with weapons as the
40:25
fighter. So you're going to hit more
40:28
often than anybody else. You're going to
40:30
crit more often than anybody else. And
40:32
just the reliable success of hitting
40:35
frequently and critting frequently is
40:38
going to feel very satisfying for new
40:40
players. Like you're coming into a new
40:41
system, maybe you've never seen degrees
40:44
of success. So knowing that you're going
40:46
to do well whenever you do like your
40:48
most important job, which is going over
40:50
there and hitting that guy. Anytime you
40:52
do that, you've got really good odds of
40:54
success there. That's going to feel
40:56
great.
40:56
>> You also have critical specializations
40:58
as a fighter, which are super fun to get
41:00
into. Each weapon type and c certain
41:04
special weapons have their own critical
41:06
specialization. And so when you crit,
41:07
certain cool effects happen, but you
41:09
need to they're kind of like weapon
41:11
masteries in a way, but you need to be
41:13
able to you need to spec into them. And
41:15
so with a fighter, you can really dig
41:17
into that system and get a bunch of
41:18
different specializations for whatever
41:20
situation you're in. And they're super
41:22
satisfying and fun to use. I love them.
41:25
If nothing else, having like you the
41:27
deadly dice that increases the size of
41:28
dice on a crit. So that hey, like this
41:30
was a d6 weapon or it was a d8 weapon
41:32
and now because I've critted, which I'm
41:34
going to do at least 10% more often than
41:36
anyone else. Now all of a sudden that
41:38
six turns into a d8, a d8 turns into a
41:40
d10. I'm dealing not just double damage,
41:43
but a lot more damage per die.
41:45
>> Yeah. All right. Second thing I'm I'm
41:47
excited about for fighters, for new
41:48
players, it doesn't have subasses.
41:50
Basically, every class in the game has a
41:53
subclass or subclass like mechanic where
41:56
you have to make some important build
41:58
decision when you're building the
42:00
character that locks you into what that
42:02
character is going to be for the rest of
42:03
your career. And changing subasses is
42:06
basically only available as an option if
42:08
your GM lets you do it. The fighter
42:10
doesn't have subasses. The only
42:12
customization is feats and equipment.
42:16
So, like you might retrain your first
42:18
level feat if you don't like whatever
42:20
you picked, but after that it's like you
42:22
pick what you want. You pick what makes
42:24
sense for your character. You're largely
42:26
not locked into whatever whatever your
42:28
build decisions are. So, very little
42:30
analysis paralysis. Very forgiving.
42:33
>> Yeah. And that what's great about
42:35
Pathfinder 2 is you can retrain feats
42:37
whenever you want as long as you have
42:39
downtime and money to do so. So, if you
42:41
don't like a build, how a build is
42:42
going, visit a trainer in town and
42:44
retrain it. Mhm. All right. And then
42:46
third thing I want to hit, they get the
42:48
shield block feet for free.
42:51
>> Now, shield block. If you raise a
42:53
shield, which does take an action in
42:55
PF2, if you have the shield block feet
42:57
as a reaction, you can put your and you
42:59
can put your shield in place and reduce
43:02
the incoming damage when you're hit by
43:04
an attack. Uh, I'm not going to go into
43:06
the full details of the mechanic, but
43:08
having that available at level one means
43:11
that you have a way to keep yourself
43:14
alive through level one, which is very,
43:17
very helpful.
43:18
>> Yeah. It's the best way to get to level
43:19
two is what I found.
43:20
>> Yeah. Living.
43:21
>> Yeah. Yeah. And so, keep in mind like
43:24
you've you positioned yourself in
43:25
battle. You are standing next to the
43:27
people that you would like to be
43:28
stabbling stabbling. Perfect as a level
43:31
one character, right? because of the
43:32
multi-attack penalty. Like maybe you hit
43:34
the first time, maybe you hit the second
43:35
time. Are you going to gamble on the
43:36
third, or are you simply going to use an
43:38
action to raise a shield? Now, doing
43:40
that, you've raised your shield. If
43:41
anyone leaves the region around you, you
43:43
get reactive strike, so you get to hit
43:45
them again anyway, but because it's no
43:48
longer your turn, you don't have to
43:49
worry about the multi-attack penalty.
43:50
And if anybody tries to stab you, you
43:52
get to use shield block.
43:53
>> Yeah. So, I think we're all in
43:54
agreement. Fighter, perfect choice for a
43:57
new player.
43:57
>> 100%. And I'll say the same thing that
43:59
we said last time about the barbarian.
44:02
And at the table, if you're playing with
44:03
experienced players, you will still get
44:05
to absorb how spell casting works, how
44:08
face skills work, how lore works in
44:10
Pathfinder 2. You'll still get to learn
44:12
all about the game, but feeling like you
44:14
are a meaningful contributor to the
44:16
campaign that you're playing as a
44:17
fighter. Yeah. All right, let's keep it
44:21
going. Let's talk about the Ranger. I'm
44:23
going to be honest, I've never seen a
44:25
PF2 Ranger at a table.
44:26
>> They're good. They're they're very very
44:28
very good.
44:30
>> Yeah. Especially if you're coming in
44:31
from 5e and you're not expecting it,
44:34
it's going to be a shock to the system.
44:35
You're like, "Rangers good?" Yes,
44:37
rangers are really good.
44:40
>> Um, yeah. I think I don't know if
44:43
they're the best starter class cuz they
44:46
do require you to engage with a lot of
44:48
their systems. It's kind of like druid
44:50
in that way. You can also get an animal
44:53
companion.
44:54
I don't think it's the I think it's
44:56
better an easier start than a druid, but
44:59
I still think it's not the best one to
45:01
start with. But that being said, I just
45:02
want to make it out put it out here.
45:04
Rangers are good in Pathfinder 2. I
45:06
promise.
45:07
>> Also, they're not spellcasters.
45:09
>> Yes, cuz why why would they be?
45:13
>> Cuz they always have been.
45:14
>> I know. Literally, that's the only
45:16
answer. Yeah, I agree with you, Ash.
45:18
like they're they share a few things
45:20
with druids, which again, like that is
45:23
D&D history. They're more complicated
45:25
than fighters. They're definitely less
45:28
complicated than a full spellcaster.
45:31
There are a few different ways you can
45:32
build them. Like I really like the uh
45:34
the monster warden build essentially
45:37
where like you take a bunch of feats
45:38
that rely on recall knowledge. So you
45:41
can recall knowledge about monsters and
45:43
then depending on how well you do, you
45:45
can share a buff with your allies. And
45:47
like that feels really good for me. I
45:49
get to ask the the GM for trivia and
45:51
then I get to give everybody in the
45:53
party a plus one and that's fun for me.
45:57
>> It's admittedly like the least exciting
45:59
of the ranger build options, but it
46:01
appeals to me personally.
46:03
>> I mean, it's it's fun. If you want to do
46:05
big damage numbers, especially to like
46:08
monsters and stuff like that.
46:09
>> Yeah, great. If you want to join my West
46:11
Marges game, rangers are going to be so
46:13
good at this game. You could be really
46:15
really excellent.
46:18
I I I'm surprised that I think only one
46:21
person right now in my west marches I
46:22
have 20 people in that server and one
46:24
person is playing a ranger. I thought
46:26
when I when I created this game and that
46:28
it was going to be just rangers.
46:31
>> What? Not a single exemplar?
46:34
>> Oh, I've banned exemplar.
46:36
>> Oh, okay.
46:37
>> Examplar is not available in West in the
46:39
West Merches game because they are
46:40
ridiculous.
46:42
Yeah. Oh god. Flurry rangers are are
46:44
ridiculous. Flurry rangers are so good.
46:47
>> Okay, Randall, do you know how flurry
46:49
ranger works?
46:50
>> I do not.
46:51
>> Okay, you know how the multiple attack
46:53
penalty works?
46:54
>> Yes. What if No.
46:57
>> What if we just made the multiple attack
46:59
penalty way smaller?
47:02
>> Way smaller. Like it maxed out at minus
47:04
four.
47:05
>> Yeah,
47:05
>> that sounds great. Super rangers are
47:07
insane.
47:08
>> Super effective.
47:09
>> Yeah. And also, I'm pretty sure rangers
47:12
can get a feat that lets you make two
47:13
strikes as part of one action. So, like
47:15
four strikes in one turn maximum map
47:18
like Yeah.
47:19
>> I can't remember if this is a monk feed
47:20
or a ranger feat, but there is a feat
47:22
called flurry of maneuvers as well,
47:24
which is which is very good.
47:27
>> Yeah.
47:28
>> You know how rules, what if no rules?
47:30
Yes, Josh. Exactly.
47:33
>> Exactly.
47:34
>> Rules exist so that we can make fun
47:35
exceptions as player character options.
47:39
>> Mhm. Mhm. That does sound nice.
47:41
>> All right. So, what do we think as a
47:43
starting class for the ranger?
47:45
>> I would put it Okay, I would put it
47:47
between fighter if if if we're putting
47:50
Okay, if we're putting bard at B and
47:52
we're putting druid at D, I would put
47:55
them on the same level of bard maybe a
47:57
little bit lower on the tier list in
48:00
terms of start. I think bard is a little
48:02
bit easier to get into than ranger, but
48:04
that's just my opinion. I was going to
48:06
say like bard and ranger I'd probably
48:08
rate around the same like
48:10
>> fair enough. I could I could see
48:12
arguments for both.
48:13
>> Yeah.
48:14
>> So like if we're going with the the four
48:15
tier RPG bot like fighter is top tier,
48:19
four stars blue. I'd say cleric green,
48:23
bonan ranger orange. I don't want to put
48:26
druid at red cuz that feels mean. But of
48:28
the of the classes we've looked at so
48:30
far, I would be the most nervous to
48:32
recommend it to a new player. Like
48:34
>> if if there was going to be a red, it
48:36
would be druid.
48:36
>> Yeah, I I'd say uh orange for most
48:39
druids, red for wild shaped druid.
48:42
>> That's fair. And and I guess it it feels
48:44
like the ranger has similar opt-in
48:46
complexity except for you kind of got to
48:49
make a choice. Are you going to do the
48:50
build that has the complexity at the
48:52
very beginning?
48:53
>> Yeah. Yeah.
48:54
>> Yeah. I think Yeah. Steph makes a makes
48:56
a valid argument. B minus. If barter B,
48:59
then then then a Ranger is a B minus. I
49:02
see no issue with that.
49:03
>> Yeah.
49:04
>> All right. Well, there you go. All
49:05
right. Let's move on to the next one.
49:07
Rouge
49:09
>> I think these are these are these are
49:11
pretty great starting class. Not a super
49:13
lot of complexity. I will say if you're
49:14
coming for 5e and expecting to do a ton
49:17
of damage numbers on your sneak attack,
49:18
you're going to be pretty disappointed.
49:20
Sneak attack, while I think it does
49:22
scale, it scales a lot slower than in 5.
49:24
And what's going to annoy some people is
49:27
there are some creatures like oozes that
49:29
are immune to precision damage and your
49:31
sneak attack is considered precision
49:33
damage. So that's going to irritate you.
49:35
>> But 5 is not super complicated. I mean
49:37
5y rogue is not super rogue is not super
49:40
5y isn't super complicated either. But
49:41
rogue isn't super complicated. Yeah. If
49:44
you liked it in fifth edition, you'll
49:46
probably like it just as much in
49:48
Pathfinder 2 despite some of the things
49:50
that are going to frustrate and maybe
49:51
disappoint you. So you you called out
49:53
that like your sneak attack damage isn't
49:54
going to like be as wacky as it gets in
49:56
5e. Tell me if I'm remembering wrong
49:59
though. So in 5e you can only apply your
50:01
sneak attack damage once per once per
50:03
round
50:04
>> once per turn. But yeah.
50:05
>> Yeah. In in PF2, as long as you qualify
50:08
for sneak attack damage, you get to
50:10
apply your sneak attack damage on every
50:12
that feels or excuse me on every attack.
50:13
And that feels really good. But at most
50:15
you're going to get it three times a
50:18
turn if that but realistically maybe two
50:21
because the minus 10 or if you're using
50:25
agile weapons which you really should as
50:26
a rogue than minus 8 it has less of a
50:29
chance to a very small chance to hit but
50:31
it it happens. But if you're expecting
50:33
to sneak attack off your turn you
50:34
shouldn't because reactive strike is not
50:36
ubiquitous to everybody. So you have to
50:38
spec into it and it's probably not worth
50:40
your time as a rogue. There are better
50:41
feats. Uh yeah, I think one of the
50:45
things that's really exciting about the
50:46
Rogue and PF2 is they get twice as many
50:49
skill increases as any other class. They
50:52
also start with just an absurdly large
50:54
number of trade skills. Like if you
50:57
really want to lean into skills, the
50:59
rogue is the best. No contest. Like a
51:02
high a decently high intelligence rogue
51:06
can start at level one trained in every
51:09
skill and it's not even hard.
51:11
>> Yeah. Yeah. And and then you also get
51:12
skill feats at every single level. So
51:14
it's like
51:15
>> rogues rogues are the skill monkeys in
51:17
Pathfinder 2. I mean they were kind of
51:19
in 5v but that was more bred.
51:21
>> Rogues are the true skill monkeys in
51:23
Pathfinder 2. So if you want a lot of
51:25
skills and a lot of skill feats, Rogue
51:27
is your boy.
51:28
>> Yeah. I will say like the the need to
51:31
make enemies offguard to trigger sneak
51:34
attack like that's going to force folks
51:36
to learn a couple of things very
51:38
quickly. You're going to have to learn
51:40
how flanking works. You're going to have
51:41
to learn how hiding works in combat.
51:44
Those things.
51:44
>> And hiding is super complicated.
51:47
It it makes sense once you understand it
51:50
and how the different conditions and and
51:52
levels of visibility work, but it might
51:54
break your brain a little when someone
51:56
first tries to explain it to you. Wait,
51:59
so what's the difference between
52:00
concealed and undetected? Like what?
52:03
>> Yeah.
52:03
>> Go listen to our stealth episode. Yeah,
52:05
it's I think it's a good system and
52:09
better than 5 is just you're invisible.
52:11
I don't like that. That's stupid.
52:15
Uh so I can appreciate what they're
52:17
going for here, but it is going to be
52:19
more complicated for people.
52:20
>> So what do we think? Good starting
52:22
class,
52:22
>> B+. A maybe a minus the I think
52:26
>> I think this is pretty high up there. I
52:28
think the Heidi mechanics are what
52:29
brings it down a bit because the hiding
52:31
mechanics are pretty complicated.
52:33
>> Yeah. But if you can get past that, it's
52:35
not too bad.
52:36
>> I Yeah. Look, just to talk about that
52:38
for a second, like if you're in a party
52:39
with a lot of Marshall characters that
52:41
are all going to be like in creatures
52:43
faces, I think it's going to be easier
52:45
because it's going to be easier to put
52:47
other it's it to put enemies off guard.
52:49
>> Yeah.
52:49
>> If you have maybe one other marshall in
52:52
the party and you're counting on them
52:54
partnering with you to flank, I think
52:56
then it could be frustrating. You're
52:58
going to have to engage in all of these
52:59
other mechanisms for putting things off
53:01
guard. And at that point, you're
53:02
probably gonna have a you're not gonna
53:03
have as good of a time with this class.
53:05
>> Yeah,
53:05
>> I agree.
53:06
>> The witch.
53:07
>> All right. Yeah, we're getting into the
53:09
W classes. Warlock. No,
53:12
>> which is PF2's version of Warlock
53:15
>> in a lot of ways.
53:16
>> Wait, which one?
53:20
>> I'm biased. I Which is probably my
53:24
favorite class.
53:25
>> Okay.
53:25
>> I really like witches. I think I like
53:27
them a little bit more in PF1 if I'm
53:29
being honest, but PF2 they're still
53:31
pretty fun. That being said, I think
53:34
they're not the greatest starting class.
53:37
I think they they're not super
53:40
complicated. The the familiar stuff, I
53:42
think, is probably going to be what
53:44
trips people up the most. The familiars
53:46
and the hex. The hex's, you really have
53:48
to lean into the hex's. And the hex's
53:50
are going to be the main gimmick of
53:52
witch. And if you're not using your
53:53
hex's, you're what are you even playing
53:55
a witch for? It's kind of
53:58
>> Yeah, it would be be like playing a
54:00
sorcerer without engaging with metamagic
54:02
at all. Like, why are you doing this?
54:04
Why do you hate my soul?
54:06
>> But witches are so fun. So, I'm just so
54:09
biased. It's like I think if you want to
54:12
have a good time, especially if you're
54:14
coming from 5e and the spellcasting
54:16
classes confuse and annoy you, play
54:18
witch and you'll see why people think
54:20
Pathfinder 2 is so cool and interesting
54:23
with its magic. because there's nothing
54:26
like witch in fifth edition which is
54:29
yeah we say it's the warlock of
54:31
Pathfinder 2 but that does it a supreme
54:33
disservice the patron really matters in
54:35
this your patron gives you different
54:38
spell list like it's not just default to
54:40
a cult like you could be a primal witch
54:43
you could be a divine witch you could be
54:44
an arcane witch and the the hex's are so
54:49
so much fun to engage with your familiar
54:51
is cool you get a lot of ways to make
54:53
your familiar really awesome. The one
54:56
thing that I think holds it back for me
54:57
is yeah, the familiar is going to be
54:59
where you probably get lost in the sauce
55:00
because there's a lot you're kind of
55:03
pushed towards advancing and customizing
55:05
your familiar. There's a lot of feats
55:06
dedicated to making your familiar
55:08
better. And like we said, minions are
55:11
rough.
55:12
>> Minions are a rough thing to get
55:14
involved in. So, as much as it pains me
55:17
to say this, I'm going to have to put it
55:19
maybe just above druid in terms of
55:22
complexity. It's It's pretty
55:24
complicated, but it's if you can get
55:25
past it, it's a really good introduction
55:28
to casting. You do like you can make
55:30
whatever caster you want and you'll see
55:33
what makes Pathfinder 2 stand apart from
55:36
fifth edition.
55:37
>> Yeah. I think the thing that I want to
55:39
add to that, like you said, there really
55:41
isn't anything like this in 5D, which
55:44
unfortunately means you're not coming in
55:45
with a basis to do the comparison. You
55:48
know, it is really like needing to
55:51
understand whole cloth what they've
55:52
created. And I think understanding how a
55:54
lot of these systems work in Pathfinder
55:56
is going to help you do that. But I
55:58
think that again in my mind makes this
56:00
not a great first class.
56:02
>> Yeah, it's not.
56:04
>> So, all right. So, let's talk about the
56:05
action economy of the he the witch a
56:07
little bit cuz it it's very similar to
56:09
the bard where you have a oneaction
56:12
focus spell and that's your hex's and
56:14
then also you have your regular
56:17
spellcasting and they're a they're a
56:19
prepared spellcaster. Most frequently
56:22
they are oult but there are subasses
56:25
patrons that let you be primal or
56:27
arcane. I don't think there are any
56:29
divine witches but
56:31
>> I think there are let me let me let me
56:33
double check while you talk. I think
56:34
there's at least one if I call it
56:37
>> prepared spellcaster. So in a lot of
56:39
ways it's like a wizard but you add the
56:42
hex's and the additional emphasis on the
56:45
familiar and yeah Ash you covered it
56:47
really well. The familiar adds some
56:49
complexity that you might not be ready
56:51
for.
56:52
>> Uh choir politic is the one is the
56:54
patron that gives you divine.
56:55
>> Okay.
56:56
>> And then there's also faith's flame
56:58
maker gives you divine.
56:59
>> Okay. There's more than one. Neat. Uh,
57:01
Paradox of Opposites also gives you
57:03
divine.
57:05
>> There's so many that give you divine.
57:07
>> Yeah. All right.
57:07
>> God, there's so many themes. I didn't
57:09
even realize how many patron themes
57:10
there are. There's so many.
57:12
>> There's so many.
57:14
>> Are these all PF2?
57:15
>> Yeah.
57:16
>> Yeah, these are PF2.
57:17
>> Okay. I was just double checking that we
57:18
didn't I made the mistake of
57:19
accidentally getting into path.
57:21
>> No, no, these are on these are on
57:23
archives. So, the So, Faith Flame Keeper
57:25
is from Player Core. That's just from
57:28
player core one. Yeah. Yeah.
57:29
>> Choir politic is from Divine Mysteries.
57:32
Paradox of opposites is also from Divine
57:34
Mysteries. Yeah. But yeah, there there's
57:37
there's literally a there's literally a
57:39
witch for every spell list. Oult arcane
57:42
and primal and divine. So yeah, if you
57:44
that's that's what's that's one of the
57:46
positives I think that bumps them up for
57:48
me from druid is that you can make
57:51
whatever you can do whatever caster you
57:53
want as a witch and you'll have a good
57:56
>> Yeah. Yeah. And in terms of like how
57:59
good these are for a new player, Ash, I
58:01
think you're right. They're a bit above
58:03
druid. I would probably put them right
58:04
next to the bard. The there are ways you
58:07
could build a witch to reduce the
58:10
complexity quite a bit. But when you
58:13
take out the complexity of hex's and
58:16
you're familiar at that point, just play
58:18
a wizard cuz all that's left is
58:20
spellcasting.
58:21
>> Exactly. So yeah, if you were going to
58:22
play a witch, you should lean into the
58:24
hex's and the familiar. While you can
58:27
play like like Tyler said, well, there
58:29
are builds that cut out the familiar or
58:31
the hex's entirely. Those are for more
58:34
advanced players who know what they're
58:35
doing and it's more about like a
58:37
specific way that they're approaching it
58:38
and it's not something I would recommend
58:40
for new players because Yeah. Again, at
58:42
that point, you're just playing a
58:43
wizard.
58:44
>> Yeah.
58:44
>> So, cool. Well, in that case, let's go
58:47
ahead and talk about wizards.
58:49
>> Yeah.
58:49
>> Tyler, you go first. I was gonna say,
58:53
>> um, I saw somebody do the math on Reddit
58:56
and just with what was available in
58:59
player core one, not considering
59:01
ancestry, not considering spell list,
59:04
there's over 100 unique ways to build a
59:08
level one wizard. So that's just like
59:10
feat, subclass, and then Oh god, what?
59:14
So
59:15
>> Tyler, does that make it good for a
59:17
first character in Pathfinder 2 or does
59:19
that make it bad for a first character
59:21
in Pathfinder 2? Yes or no?
59:23
>> Admittedly, that does make it difficult
59:25
for a new player. Once you have
59:27
>> Yay, we got him to admit it. We got him
59:29
to
59:30
>> Once you have built the wizard though,
59:33
it's actually pretty simple. Like all of
59:36
their feats are basically all around
59:39
their spell casting. So, all you really
59:41
have to worry about is your spell
59:44
casting. They don't really have a go-to
59:47
like third action use. So, like what do
59:50
you do in combat? You cast a spell. It's
59:53
very simple.
59:54
>> Yeah. Unlike with fifth edition wizards,
59:57
especially if we're coming at this from
59:58
you already have some familiarity with
1:00:00
how 5ev plays. I think wizard is not as
1:00:04
bad of a first start class as 5D wizard
1:00:07
cuz the spell like I can't in good
1:00:09
conscience rate it below the witch
1:00:12
because the witch has the same more
1:00:14
complexity than the wizard.
1:00:16
>> Yeah.
1:00:16
>> So I I would actually put wizard maybe
1:00:19
in like an AA minus as Tyler said like
1:00:22
once you once you figure out how you
1:00:24
want to build your wizard they're pretty
1:00:26
simple. They're they're you cast a
1:00:28
spell. The one pit trap that I would say
1:00:32
is with like when we were talking about
1:00:33
cleric, I meant I foreshadowed this. I
1:00:36
if you're coming from fifth edition, the
1:00:38
prepared way of casting is going to hit
1:00:42
you more in the face than clerics are
1:00:44
because with wizards, if all you played
1:00:47
with wizards was as a blaster caster,
1:00:49
you're going to have a buff time in
1:00:50
Pathfinder 2.
1:00:52
>> Don't build your wizards like that. It's
1:00:54
okay to build some damage spells, but
1:00:55
you should really prepare some
1:00:58
situational or utility spells. And
1:01:00
unlike with cleric, you can't just
1:01:03
switch out your spells whenever you want
1:01:04
to because you have the spell book. You
1:01:06
need to find new spells. You need to put
1:01:08
them into your spell book, similar to
1:01:10
how you do it in fifth edition.
1:01:11
>> Yeah.
1:01:11
>> And it's it works the same for witch 2,
1:01:13
by the way. You also have a pseudo spell
1:01:15
book, but it's your it's your familiar.
1:01:17
Your familiar holds your spells for you.
1:01:19
And people are like, "How does that
1:01:20
work?" I don't know. It just does.
1:01:22
You tell you tell your you're familiar
1:01:24
your spells. You tell your cat your
1:01:25
spells and your cat just shouts out the
1:01:27
spell components to you.
1:01:29
>> Yeah. Look, you're familiar as a dog and
1:01:32
your dog eats your homework and that is
1:01:34
how witches learn spells.
1:01:36
>> Yeah. It's really intuitive. I don't
1:01:38
know what you guys are talking about.
1:01:39
>> People can't people can't act like
1:01:41
they're not familiar with this, right?
1:01:42
It's like, you know, you know, where you
1:01:44
know where where where do we leave my
1:01:45
keys? Where do my keys go? You know, you
1:01:47
ask your dog that all the time. Does
1:01:49
your dog find the keys? No. You
1:01:50
eventually find your keys and you get in
1:01:52
your car and you drive away. It's like
1:01:53
that, but it's a fireball.
1:01:54
>> Oh, and there's al Yeah, and there's
1:01:56
also there's also a familiar feat you
1:01:58
can take that gets your familiar to
1:01:59
talk, which is awesome and I love it.
1:02:01
But anyway, you can also get a familiar,
1:02:03
too, as wizard and you can choose to go
1:02:05
into it as much as you want to, but at
1:02:07
that point, why aren't you just playing
1:02:08
a witch? So, but wizards, yeah, I think
1:02:12
wizards are super intuitive to play.
1:02:14
They don't require a lot of thinking
1:02:17
about other things besides spell casting
1:02:19
like druids tend to do. And but my one
1:02:23
caveat to newer players, especially if
1:02:24
you're coming from fifth edition, please
1:02:26
prepare some utility spells and buffing
1:02:27
spells. Don't make it all damage or
1:02:29
you're going to have a really bad time.
1:02:31
>> Yeah.
1:02:31
>> Yeah.
1:02:32
>> Yeah.
1:02:32
>> Wizards are also locked into the arcane
1:02:34
spell list, which is the largest spell
1:02:37
list by like a margin.
1:02:38
>> A lot. Yeah. A lot. I don't know if it's
1:02:42
quite double, but it's close.
1:02:44
>> It's pretty big.
1:02:46
>> Yeah.
1:02:46
>> Which is why going back to witch, if
1:02:48
you're going to play a witch, stick with
1:02:49
a cult. You don't need to do arcane.
1:02:51
Arcane is way too much.
1:02:54
>> So, so really, it sounds like in PF2,
1:02:56
the wizard is the fighter of
1:02:58
spellcasting.
1:02:58
>> 100%.
1:02:59
>> Yeah, absolutely.
1:03:00
>> Yeah. I would say, you can do a lot.
1:03:03
>> I would put cleric and wizard at about
1:03:05
the same level. Maybe I would put cleric
1:03:08
a little bit higher than wizard because
1:03:10
like I said, it doesn't have that sort
1:03:12
of like trap of wanting to lean into the
1:03:16
damage spells for especially if you're
1:03:18
coming from fifth edition. But if you
1:03:19
eliminate that part of it, then yeah,
1:03:21
they're exact they're on exactly equal
1:03:23
footing in my eyes.
1:03:24
>> Yeah.
1:03:24
>> When and you do have to engage with your
1:03:27
divinity or or lack thereof, right? Like
1:03:29
you have to engage with the gods and
1:03:31
that has to be part of the character
1:03:32
versus like with wizard, you don't even
1:03:34
have that complexity. It's just like I
1:03:36
don't know, man. Pick some spells.
1:03:38
>> Yeah, I guess that kind of cancel that
1:03:40
that then cancels it out again. So,
1:03:42
yeah, I I think you're right. I think
1:03:43
wizard and cleric would be on pretty
1:03:45
much the same level for me. Like,
1:03:47
they're in a tier, 100%.
1:03:48
>> All right, we have a question of the
1:03:50
week this week. This week, our question
1:03:51
of the week comes to us from Joshua CC
1:03:52
on Discord. How the heck do you balance
1:03:54
the desires of the players in the DM
1:03:56
when you've got very different play
1:03:58
styles involved? For example, a DM
1:04:00
interested in crafting an epic story
1:04:01
line versus a group of players who enjoy
1:04:03
goofing off and fighting monsters, but
1:04:04
can't remember events from more than one
1:04:06
session ago.
1:04:07
>> Good question, Josh. This is a
1:04:09
conversation that you have at session
1:04:10
zero. If you have a particular game you
1:04:14
want to run, you need to be upfront with
1:04:16
the players at the beginning of that
1:04:18
campaign what kind of campaign you're
1:04:20
looking to run. And if the players don't
1:04:22
want to play in that game, then either
1:04:25
you need to figure out a way to make it
1:04:28
work for them or find a different group
1:04:30
or or simply abandon your idea and run
1:04:33
the game that they want to play because
1:04:35
at the end of the day, it it is your
1:04:37
game, yes, but it is also your players
1:04:40
game. So, this is this requires
1:04:42
compromise. Uh yeah, stuff basically.
1:04:45
Don't Yeah, that's the easy answer. I
1:04:47
think there's a way to make it work.
1:04:48
It's going to require a compromise and
1:04:51
but I would say don't force your players
1:04:53
to do things that they're not having fun
1:04:56
doing. Find a way to make it fun for
1:04:58
them. So if you're doing crafting for
1:05:01
instance, like take my West Marches game
1:05:03
for example. I really wanted to do like
1:05:05
a sort of crafting thing, but there
1:05:07
might be players who don't want to
1:05:08
engage with that. And so I have sort of
1:05:10
a middle ground where it's not all
1:05:12
crafting all the time. Instead, it's
1:05:15
focused on you going out, you exploring,
1:05:17
you fighting monsters, getting materials
1:05:20
from them, and then crafting that into
1:05:22
weapons. So, the crafting is still
1:05:23
there, and it's a big part of it, but
1:05:25
it's not it's like maybe 1/4 or one/ird
1:05:28
of the whole game. So, I can still
1:05:30
scratch that itch for myself without my
1:05:31
players feeling like this is the whole
1:05:33
game and they're not having fun with it.
1:05:35
They're you try to interconnect these
1:05:38
systems so that they play off one
1:05:40
another. If you want to do a political
1:05:41
thriller, but your players want to just
1:05:43
do some dungeon crawls, maybe you have a
1:05:46
session or two where you are in this
1:05:49
political ball, but you treat the ball
1:05:51
like a dungeon, but it's a social
1:05:53
dungeon. So, there are ways that you can
1:05:56
do it. Yeah, it it takes creative energy
1:06:00
to figure out how to how to interweave
1:06:04
these things. So, for newer DMs, I would
1:06:07
just say Steph's advice is great. Just
1:06:09
don't. If you if your players are not
1:06:11
interested in that, then find something
1:06:13
else that they are interested in or find
1:06:14
a different group. But once you get more
1:06:16
advanced and you get more comfortable
1:06:18
with how to run games, trying to find
1:06:20
ways to insert stuff that you enjoy and
1:06:23
making it so that your players don't
1:06:25
even realize that that it is that thing
1:06:27
and it's feeds into what they enjoy it.
1:06:30
There's no more satisfying feeling in
1:06:31
the world. People are like, "Oh, I
1:06:32
didn't even realize I was going to like
1:06:34
this, but you made it so fun and cool. I
1:06:37
made a whole like so I made several
1:06:39
sessions in my Ravenloft game where it
1:06:41
was just players at this perilous
1:06:43
cutthroat ball in Borca where people
1:06:46
were just talking to each other and
1:06:48
trying to sus out each other before they
1:06:50
were backstabbing each other. My players
1:06:52
who basically were only at that point
1:06:55
interested in dungeon calls and stuff
1:06:56
had a great time cuz it felt
1:06:58
threatening, it felt exciting. So yeah,
1:07:00
just be creative. Okay, I want to speak
1:07:02
to the like a DM interested in crafting
1:07:04
an epic story line versus a group of
1:07:05
players who enjoy gooping off and
1:07:07
fighting monsters first. And then I want
1:07:08
to come back to like the more general
1:07:10
how do you handle different play styles.
1:07:12
I think specifically for this like I
1:07:14
think you can still run the epic story
1:07:15
line you can give the narrative but you
1:07:17
don't have to push the characters
1:07:21
experiencing this world to recognize the
1:07:24
vastness and the epicness of what
1:07:26
they're living through. like they're
1:07:28
just a group of folks going along and
1:07:30
the fact that the world is being shaped
1:07:31
around them, it's okay if they're
1:07:32
oblivious to it. And if your players
1:07:34
can't be bothered to exactly like
1:07:36
memorize or recognize the magnitude of
1:07:37
what you're presenting to them, I I
1:07:39
think just lean into it. Then they don't
1:07:41
understand what a big part of the world
1:07:42
they're playing into, then how do you
1:07:44
scratch that itch? How do you
1:07:45
occasionally make it clear to them? I
1:07:46
think you could do different things. You
1:07:48
could have either like imagine a
1:07:50
traveling bard that shows up and is
1:07:51
like, you know, every other session or
1:07:53
so, you open up with a recounting of how
1:07:57
awesome and epic the things that they're
1:07:59
doing are, maybe even overexaggerating
1:08:01
it to the point of like, you know, they
1:08:03
thought they got in a drunken brawl and
1:08:05
then they fled town and actually they
1:08:07
burned the entire city to the ground and
1:08:09
the nobility is in shambles, for
1:08:11
instance.
1:08:11
>> Yeah. No, that's a that's a great point.
1:08:13
Like I think there's ways to make
1:08:15
players who want to goof off take things
1:08:17
seriously. So I'll give an example.
1:08:20
Private game that I'm running right now
1:08:22
is a group of players that have that are
1:08:24
all friends with each other. They've
1:08:25
known each other. At least one of them
1:08:26
are brother and I mean two of them are
1:08:28
brother and sister and they're
1:08:29
constantly goofing up. They're they're
1:08:31
goofing off. Shut up.
1:08:35
At least one of them is brother and
1:08:36
sister with himself anyway. No. So yeah,
1:08:39
they're constantly goofing up. So in a
1:08:41
we're playing strength the thousands and
1:08:42
in one of the recent sessions they
1:08:44
fought like this main bad guy stone
1:08:46
ghost who's just like this kind of angry
1:08:49
self-s serious kind of person and there
1:08:51
through a series of events he embedded
1:08:53
one of the players halfway into the into
1:08:55
the floor and so the player was like I
1:08:57
want to what I'm going to punch him in
1:08:59
the dick because I'm at dick level and
1:09:02
so and then it became a running joke
1:09:04
where everybody was just specifically
1:09:06
targeting this guy's dick and it was
1:09:08
hilarious and I had a great time with
1:09:10
it. But the next session, the the
1:09:13
players were tasked with protecting
1:09:15
these students that were coming in and
1:09:17
one of them ended up dying and that hit
1:09:19
my players, one of my some of my players
1:09:21
really hard. So, they had this
1:09:23
heartto-he heart with this teacher where
1:09:24
the teacher was like apologizing to
1:09:26
them. He's like, "Hey, I'm sorry that
1:09:27
I've I've sent you guys on these life or
1:09:29
death missions when I didn't really want
1:09:30
to. You guys are just students." And one
1:09:32
of my players just blew up at him. He's
1:09:34
like, "You you you have been treating us
1:09:36
like we're just servants at this point.
1:09:38
So I want some above board sort of
1:09:40
situation and now someone has died and
1:09:44
that's not okay. You guys failed as
1:09:46
faculty to protect your students and you
1:09:48
failed to protect us. So just
1:09:49
apologizing is not going to cut it and
1:09:51
actually got into a really emotional
1:09:52
sort of thing. I didn't even prompt it.
1:09:54
I just had the conversation be put your
1:09:57
players into that situation. Treat it
1:09:58
seriously and a lot of times your
1:10:01
players will surprise you. And yeah,
1:10:03
there's always going to be players that
1:10:04
treat as a joke but it's okay to lean
1:10:06
into that. Not everything needs to be
1:10:07
serious. Like if you watch Critical Role
1:10:09
or Adventure Time, there is so much
1:10:12
ridiculous, stupid nonsense that goes
1:10:14
into those campaigns, but there's a lot
1:10:16
of stuff that makes you want to cry. And
1:10:18
I think that's important. You can still
1:10:20
have an epic tale filled with adventure
1:10:22
and heroes and emotional connect and
1:10:24
emotional stakes, but it doesn't have to
1:10:26
be serious all the time. Moments of
1:10:28
levity are necessary in my opinion.
1:10:31
Yeah, I agree with all that. So coming
1:10:33
back to maybe the more general like, you
1:10:35
know, how do how do we get through
1:10:37
having different play style expectations
1:10:39
between the GM and the players, maybe
1:10:41
another example of this could be like
1:10:43
you really want them to engage with the
1:10:44
technical mechanics of the game. So for
1:10:46
instance, like I want you to engage with
1:10:48
the hide action. I want to push you to
1:10:51
main, you know, to to constrain your use
1:10:54
of resources because you're going to run
1:10:56
out of resources. Like there there's all
1:10:57
these different things that you might
1:10:58
do. We talked about in the past. I I
1:11:00
love the idea basically telling the
1:11:02
players up front like, "Hey, for this
1:11:04
session or for this arc, we're going to
1:11:06
lean heavily into these mechanics or
1:11:09
we're going to try these mechanics." And
1:11:11
what you could do with that is like now
1:11:13
you're not committing to them to like
1:11:14
hiding is always going to be important
1:11:15
for, you know, from here to eternity in
1:11:17
the game that we're playing, but it can
1:11:19
be a way of like try these mechanics on
1:11:20
for size. If you find that your players
1:11:22
continue to engage with it, then
1:11:24
continue to give them the opportunity to
1:11:26
engage with it and do the meta
1:11:28
afterwards, like checking in. Hey, what
1:11:30
do you folks think of this? And they're
1:11:31
all like, honestly, I hate it. I feel
1:11:33
like it's slowing down the game. I'm not
1:11:34
enjoying it. I don't get it. Then you
1:11:36
can drop that thing. But there might be
1:11:38
other things you bring in that they do
1:11:39
enjoy. My last little tip, I know I'm
1:11:42
talking a lot. Um, is a thing that my DM
1:11:45
I might I play in a Wednesday game uses
1:11:48
and I think it's a really great system.
1:11:49
It's called Stars and Wishes, which is
1:11:51
at the end of every session, especially
1:11:52
this is really good with a group that
1:11:53
you don't know very well. Ask them what
1:11:55
their favorite moment from today's
1:11:57
session was and what they're looking
1:11:59
forward to. And that will give you a
1:12:01
sense of what you put in front of
1:12:02
players they connected with and what
1:12:04
maybe didn't connect with. So, if like
1:12:06
nobody mentions the cool dramatic death
1:12:09
scene for an NPC, if no one really cared
1:12:11
about that, then you know, okay, my
1:12:13
players just aren't interested in that
1:12:14
kind of storytelling. Uh, and then you
1:12:16
ask them what they're looking forward
1:12:17
to. And if like they're saying, I'm
1:12:19
looking forward to just more mindless
1:12:21
combat, then hey, you have your answer.
1:12:23
And it's a good way to check in with
1:12:25
players and adjust your expectations and
1:12:28
their expectations.
1:12:29
>> Okay. So, I I want to encourage I want
1:12:33
to encourage DMs, DMs, GMs finding
1:12:35
themselves in this situation to engage
1:12:38
in a bit of lampshade hanging. So you
1:12:40
are going to in some ways acknowledge
1:12:44
that this is the situation you find
1:12:46
yourself in and say like yes this is the
1:12:48
situation but then largely otherwise
1:12:51
ignore it. You can keep your entire
1:12:53
world your entire plot serious epic all
1:12:58
of those things like you can tell your
1:12:59
Lord of the Rings story. The players can
1:13:02
be out to save the world and face the
1:13:04
big bad and kill God at the end of Final
1:13:07
Fantasy. all of those things and the
1:13:09
world itself and all of the characters
1:13:12
in the world are in that story, but your
1:13:15
party is a wandering troop of clowns,
1:13:18
but everyone in the world is perpetually
1:13:21
surprised by that. When you do your
1:13:23
session recaps, it's being told by the
1:13:26
most serious historian, like, "Ah, yes,
1:13:30
the mighty heroes slew the dragon and
1:13:33
claimed yada yada yada all of all of
1:13:36
that." But then the first time people
1:13:39
encounter the party, they're realizing
1:13:42
that they have gotten the craziest party
1:13:45
of clownish juvenile murder hobos and
1:13:49
are disappointed, but realize that they
1:13:52
are still in the epic story and have to
1:13:55
make do with these idiots. So it's like
1:13:58
you're telling Lord of the Rings and you
1:14:01
expect Aragorn, Gimy, and Legalist to
1:14:03
walk through the door, but you get Mary
1:14:06
and Pippen and Mary and Pippen.
1:14:08
>> You just get the Blues Brothers.
1:14:10
>> Yeah. Like
1:14:13
they're here. They're in the epic story.
1:14:15
They're going to do the thing. They're
1:14:17
going to hit all of those important
1:14:19
things, but they're very much not the
1:14:21
right people for this situation, but
1:14:23
they're all that the world has. So
1:14:25
sometimes you save the world with
1:14:28
clowns.
1:14:29
>> Hey, Bill and Ted did it. If it's good
1:14:31
enough for Bill and Ted, then it's good
1:14:32
enough for your campaign.
1:14:34
>> Perfect. Yes.
1:14:37
>> Excellent. Righteous.
1:14:41
All hail leisure Illuminati. H.
1:14:47
>> I'm Reynold James. You'll find me at
1:14:49
danger.com
1:14:51
and on Blue Sky RPG. I wrote a book. I
1:14:55
wrote a novela. It's called Malong.
1:14:57
There's a link in the show notes.
1:14:59
>> I'm Tyler Camster. You'll find me on
1:15:01
rpgbot.net teaching people how to play
1:15:04
Pathfinder second edition. Maybe even
1:15:06
including you listening to this podcast.
1:15:08
We can hope. You'll find me on Tik Tok
1:15:11
RPG doot ne and blue sky rpgbot.net.
1:15:16
>> I'm Ashi. You can follow me on Blue Sky
1:15:18
at graven ashes. If you want to hire me
1:15:20
to run one of your games, you can find
1:15:22
me on startplay.games. games link in the
1:15:24
show notes. If you want to put what you
1:15:27
learned from Tyler into practice and
1:15:29
maybe learn the the system a bit more
1:15:31
hands-on, come join us for our West
1:15:34
Marches game. It's Monster Hunter
1:15:36
themed. Literally any skill, any
1:15:38
experience level is welcome. We're super
1:15:41
good at helping people learn the game
1:15:43
and it's super casual.
1:15:44
>> Steph, thank you. Thank you, Steph.
1:15:49
All
1:15:51
right, this is the part of the podcast
1:15:53
where we tell you that if you want to
1:15:55
help the creators that you like the
1:15:56
most, the thing that you could do is
1:15:58
rate and review their content. The
1:16:00
second best thing that you could do is
1:16:02
share their content with like-minded
1:16:03
individuals that you think might enjoy
1:16:05
it. This is all huge activity. It helps
1:16:07
us reach new listeners. It helps us
1:16:09
reach new people. Rating and reviewing
1:16:11
Ash's online games helps him to find new
1:16:14
folks to run games for. Rating and
1:16:15
reviewing my novela helps people find
1:16:17
it. writing interview Tyler's tiny
1:16:19
videos.
1:16:24
>> It's so tiny. I posted a 7-second video
1:16:27
today.
1:16:28
>> It will never not be funny. Tiny videos
1:16:30
is inspired.
1:16:31
>> Yes.
1:16:35
>> I need a minute. I need a minute.
1:16:41
>> God, we are the clowns in the epic story
1:16:43
that that is this podcast.
1:16:45
You think we take this this stuff
1:16:47
seriously? No. No, we don't take it
1:16:49
seriously at all.
1:16:51
>> It's all too late. That makes me sleepy.
1:16:53
>> Yeah.
1:16:55
>> Uh you'll find affiliate links for
1:16:57
source books and other materials linked
1:16:58
in the show notes. Support your friendly
1:17:00
local game store. But if they don't have
1:17:01
the content that you're looking for
1:17:02
using these affiliate links helps us to
1:17:04
uh continue doing this podcast, so we do
1:17:06
appreciate it.
1:17:07
>> Don't know what you mean. Josh, what?
1:17:09
>> Just I'm gonna keep moving on.
1:17:11
>> I'll explain later.
1:17:13
>> Okay. Uh, we like questions of the week.
1:17:16
If your question should be the question
1:17:17
of the week next week, please email
1:17:18
podcast rbgbot.net or message us on blue
1:17:21
1:17:22
Please also consider supporting us on
1:17:24
Patreon where you can find all kinds of
1:17:25
great rewards. At any tier, you'll get
1:17:27
early access to rbgbot.com and full
1:17:29
future content. At our $3 tiers, you'll
1:17:31
enjoy your choice of adree access to
1:17:33
rpgbot.net or ad free podcast episodes
1:17:35
and access to live stream podcast
1:17:36
recordings. At our $5 tiers and above,
1:17:38
you'll get all of that plus access to
1:17:40
the rbqbot. Discord. You'll find us at
1:17:42
patreon.com/rpgbot.
1:17:44
If you like shirts,
1:17:45
>> a cool shirt, want a cool shirt, maybe a
1:17:47
sticker, visit rpgbot.store,
1:17:50
you want RPGbot email in your inbox.
1:17:52
Sign up for the rpgbot.newsletter
1:17:54
at rpgbot.net/newsletter.
1:17:59
>> We got to put some ease in that.
1:18:03
>> There's a double use honestly unclear.
1:18:06
Maybe.
1:18:06
>> I don't know why I was possessed by that
1:18:08
voice and it just inspired me. Was that
1:18:11
Kermit or was it Bobcat?
1:18:13
>> Wait. Let's go with probably Bobcat. I
1:18:15
don't think that's Kermit.
1:18:17
>> Bobcat doing impression.
1:18:19
>> By the way, I don't know if you've
1:18:19
watched this, if you've seen this
1:18:21
YouTube channel called There I Ruined
1:18:23
It.
1:18:25
There's a video of Kermit the Frog
1:18:28
singing a Snoop Dog song. It's so great
1:18:33
and it's everything I wanted. Yeah,
1:18:36
>> look up Kermit the Frog Snoop Dog and
1:18:37
you'll find it is fantastic.
1:18:40
>> Okay,
1:18:41
>> but I want to address what Josh said.
1:18:43
All I've got to say is they're turning
1:18:45
the frogs gay frogs gray gray. I think
1:18:49
that is a play on Alex Jones, but I
1:18:52
>> it is pretty made this joke on our Slad
1:18:55
episode as well, but I posted a very
1:18:57
short episode about Slud and 2024 rules
1:19:00
where they explained that Slad can
1:19:02
advance from red, blue, and green to the
1:19:05
higher tiers by either one of the Slud
1:19:08
lords or the spawning stone. So, I read
1:19:10
all of that very like soberly, straight
1:19:14
to the point, and then looked into the
1:19:16
camera and gradually zoomed in. And so
1:19:18
I'm just going to lean in slowly as I do
1:19:20
this. They're putting chemicals in the
1:19:22
water. They're turning the frogs gray.
1:19:25
>> Excellent. Fantastic.
1:19:28
>> It worked.
1:19:29
>> Like I said, tiny videos.
1:19:31
>> I was about to say, ladies and
1:19:32
gentlemen, tiny videos.
1:19:34
>> Tiny videos. If you want to see that
1:19:36
video, uh, and instead of having it
1:19:39
described to you, go watch it. Go follow
1:19:41
Tyler on Tik Tok or Tiny Videos,
1:19:43
whatever it is.
1:19:45
>> All right. Go join Skylight. Find me
1:19:48
there.
1:19:48
>> Skylight. Who uses Skylight?
1:19:51
>> Everyone, honestly, by the time this
1:19:52
podcast comes out,
1:19:53
>> as as of yesterday, it's the number one
1:19:55
entertainment app on the iOS app store.
1:19:58
So,
1:19:58
>> fair enough. I I guess everybody's
1:20:00
fleeing Tik Tok. Yeah.
Games

