In Episode 3 of Other Worlds, the RPGBOT.Podcast team serves up a delightfully chaotic mix of culinary hot takes and deep tabletop RPG insights. Randall makes a chicken Caesar abomination. Tyler admits that he enjoys pineapple on pizza. The pizza talk eventually turns toward more tabletop territory, but not before a quick anecdote about a friend with a professional pizza oven makes everyone jealous.
This episode originally aired on May 21st, 2025, and we're currently working to upload our episode backlog. For the latest from the RPGBOT.Podcast, find us in your favorite podcatcher.
Full show notes for this episode are available on RPGBOT.net: https://rpgbot.net/other-worlds-3-recap-the-great-pizza-debate-rpgbot-podcast-s5e61/
Find us on socials and stuff:
🦋 https://bsky.app/profile/rpgbot.bsky.social
⏰ https://www.tiktok.com/@rpgbotdotnet
🔍 https://RPGBOT.net/
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
And as soon as we go live, all of our
0:02
charisma just falls to the ground.
0:04
>> A
0:05
>> no, no, no. Okay, look, let me tell you.
0:06
I had this thing for dinner tonight. I
0:08
got a message from Danielle earlier that
0:09
said something along the lines of, "I'm
0:11
going to make a pizza crust out of
0:14
chicken and we're going to have a
0:16
chicken Caesar pizza." And I I know I
0:18
say that. I see the face here looking at
0:19
me.
0:20
>> It was delicious. You know how people do
0:21
like the like smashed chicken and do
0:23
like a chicken parmesan? Imagine that
0:25
with like a tossed Caesar salad and like
0:28
some roasted chicken on top of it. these
0:29
like cheesy crisp potato things. It was
0:31
really good.
0:31
>> Huh?
0:32
>> I just want to tell you about dinner.
0:33
>> How large was this? What? Tell me the
0:36
dimensions of this chicken pizza crust.
0:38
>> It was made with ground chicken,
0:40
parmesan, and oil. And it was like
0:42
probably 14 in.
0:43
>> Okay.
0:44
>> Yeah,
0:44
>> it makes more sense. made it with ground
0:46
chicken in my heading from like a full
0:49
chicken breast and just hammering that
0:50
thing until it got
0:52
>> one of the crazy carving things where
0:53
it's like, you know, it's one solid
0:55
piece of chicken, but I'm completely
0:56
devoid and then I'm [laughter] sitting
0:57
there like Gallagher with a hammer JUST
1:03
the kids are 12 feet away covered with
1:04
chicken wearing safety glasses,
1:06
[laughter]
1:07
>> you know, something like that. It's a I
1:10
I getting more of the disconnect between
1:13
being a dad and not being a dad because
1:15
I just see Tyler like, "Please describe
1:17
the crust. What was it like?" And like
1:20
getting all into it and I'm just like,
1:21
"I so bored right now. You're talking
1:25
about cooking and I don't care."
1:27
>> He described to me a culinary
1:29
abomination and I had to know.
1:32
>> So good. I'm just teasing you. It does
1:34
sound very interesting. It is. That is
1:37
wild that you did that. [laughter]
1:40
>> I like you leaned in just like it does
1:41
sound very interesting. [laughter]
1:44
>> Yeah. No, that's the best way I can
1:46
describe it. Like I definitely I
1:48
wouldn't eat it. Doesn't sound
1:50
appealing.
1:51
>> Uh you would had to have seen it. It It
1:53
looked delicious. It tasted delicious.
1:54
>> Oh, well I'm glad.
1:55
>> We have a Joe's pizza and the last I
1:58
last I knew it's the only Joe's pizza
2:00
not in New York.
2:01
>> Is Is pizza hard to find in Michigan?
2:04
>> Good.
2:06
Yeah. So,
2:06
>> yeah, I figured you could get really
2:08
good pizza anywhere. It's like the one
2:10
staple of American cuisine. [laughter]
2:13
>> Well, okay. No, I think we're like
2:14
holding a higher bar like
2:16
>> Okay, if you're comparing your if you're
2:18
if you're comparing it to New York
2:20
pizza, yeah, everybody's going to fall
2:21
short of that.
2:23
>> No, you're wrong.
2:25
>> Stop it. [laughter] Get out of here.
2:27
>> Do you know Okay. Okay. Neither Tyler
2:29
nor I are native Detroititers or
2:31
Michiganders. Do you know what Detroit
2:33
style pizza is?
2:34
>> Yeah. Detroit style pizza is great. I
2:36
Yeah, I prefer it to Chicago style
2:38
pizza.
2:39
>> It's It's not a lasagna.
2:41
>> Yeah, [laughter]
2:42
exactly. Yeah. No, so Detroit style
2:45
pizza is basically like a like a square
2:48
type type of pizza that is a thick
2:50
crust,
2:50
>> which is what I thought deep dish pizza
2:52
was. I was like, I love deep dish pizza.
2:55
And then I went to Chicago and I was
2:56
like, deep dish pizza, please. And they
2:58
brought out this casserole and I'm like,
2:59
what the hell is this? [laughter]
3:02
To be clear though, I think like most of
3:03
the country when they hear deep dish,
3:05
they're thinking Detroit style but round
3:07
and then the square pizza confuses them
3:09
a little bit. And then Chicago has their
3:11
own thing going and it's like, okay, no.
3:12
So, we've got a place around here that
3:14
can do a reasonable like Neapolitino.
3:16
But Tyler and I have a hack. We're
3:18
really good friends with an Italian
3:20
couple who have like a real pizza oven.
3:22
So, when we want Neapolitino pizza,
3:24
we're just like, "Hey, we should do
3:26
that." And they're like, "You're right.
3:27
The oven's on. Let's go."
3:28
>> Yeah.
3:29
>> We got jokes for New York style. And
3:31
then we've got a couple chains that do
3:33
reasonable Detroit style and that meets
3:35
my needs and like I've got a little
3:37
oonie. So like
3:38
>> I mean you guys are right in the area
3:39
for Detroit style pizza. Like you should
3:41
be good.
3:43
>> We we got it covered. Give us a
3:45
>> Joshua in the chat says out to offend
3:47
all of America again. I say yeah that's
3:49
why I'm here. Josh [laughter] broaden
3:51
your horizons. Offend Italy instead. I
3:53
would but I've never been to Italy so I
3:56
don't really have any hot takes about
3:58
Italy. I have been through Europe, but
4:00
Italy was not on my stops, which is very
4:02
disappointing. I would have loved to
4:03
have gone to Italy. [laughter]
4:05
>> For those at home, there's a hot take.
4:08
There's the hot take.
4:09
>> I'm going to repeat what Dan said for
4:10
folks at home. His favorite Italian
4:12
style pizza is from a place in Germany.
4:15
>> Yeah. And Josh. Yeah, that is true.
4:17
Italian style pizza isn't real pizza. I
4:19
have heard that as a criticism for a lot
4:22
of people. Yeah.
4:22
>> What are you talking about?
4:24
>> It's it's it's very different from
4:26
American style pizza. I'm required to do
4:29
this at you. I don't know what it means,
4:31
but I'm required to do this at you.
4:32
Okay? You see this?
4:34
>> For those listening at home, Randall
4:36
just did a what are you talking about
4:39
sort of move, you know, where you put
4:40
your fingers together, the finger
4:42
together. It's very New York.
4:44
>> I'm going to go tell this little Italian
4:46
lady that I know that you said that. And
4:48
you know what she's going to do? She's
4:49
going to do exactly that at me. And
4:50
she's going to say, "Come on. [laughter]
4:53
>> I I can't I can't have it say that.
4:57
Quaset's response that take is
5:00
psychotic.
5:01
>> It is an American take 100%. But
5:05
>> no, no, no, no. What I'm saying is
5:06
Americans, some Americans have that
5:08
take. I'm not saying all Americans do,
5:10
but it is a it is a common criticism
5:12
that I've heard from people who have
5:14
been to Italy is that the pizza is not
5:16
real pizza because it's a different kind
5:18
of pizza. Like if you think you're
5:19
thinking like it's a American pizza,
5:21
it's not. It's more the people have
5:23
described it as like it's like bread
5:24
with stuff on it. [laughter]
5:26
flatbread. Okay.
5:27
>> Yeah, it's a flatbread. It's not really
5:29
pizza,
5:30
>> but not like an or not Olive Garden, but
5:32
you know, there's like a million
5:33
flatbreads. It's like, oh, let me serve
5:34
you sauce on a cracker. It's not that
5:36
either.
5:37
>> Yeah. I would argue that pizza, quote
5:40
unquote, pizza is fully an American
5:42
thing now. Like it's like what what
5:44
Italy is doing is its own thing. It's
5:46
not pizza. It's it's
5:49
>> it's whatever you want to call it. I
5:50
don't know what what.
5:53
So, like I would just argue like it's
5:55
not yours anymore. Sorry, Italy. It's
5:57
ours now. [laughter]
5:59
We did that with orange chicken. Just
6:01
saying. Like orange actually orange
6:03
chicken was never a Chinese thing. It
6:05
was always an Americanmade thing. But
6:07
you know,
6:07
>> Brit Britain did it to half the curries.
6:10
>> Yeah, exactly. [laughter]
6:12
What is this discussion?
6:15
I don't know. We're not to offend half.
6:17
And meanwhile, Dan is just like rubbing
6:19
his head like, "Oh god, I'm going to
6:21
have to cut so much out."
6:24
Do I leave it in? Do I take it out? Do I
6:25
leave it or do I take it out?
6:26
>> Look, it's like a knife, but it's pizza
6:28
discussion.
6:29
>> Look, it's very easy. I just have to say
6:31
one thing that he has to cut. I like
6:33
pineapple on pizza.
6:35
>> You're a monster.
6:36
>> I know.
6:37
>> Everybody What's your blue sky?
6:39
[laughter]
6:40
>> RPGbot.net.
6:41
>> What is What is wrong with you? Are you
6:44
a human?
6:45
>> The the the savory and the sweet, they
6:47
go really really well together.
6:49
>> No. Okay. You have plenty of opportunity
6:50
in your life to combine savory and
6:52
sweet. Pizza is not one of those times.
6:53
Do you understand? Why not?
6:55
>> I can't be friends with you anymore.
6:57
>> I can't be friends with you anymore.
6:58
>> I will I'll even allow like a dessert
7:00
pizza. I'll let you sneak one to two
7:02
over the line. You could do barbecue
7:03
sauce on a pizza. That has molasses.
7:05
That's sweet. We're drawing the line at
7:07
pineapple.
7:08
>> But why that?
7:09
>> Go back to Hawaii.
7:11
>> But it's Canadian.
7:12
>> I thought it was Hawaiian.
7:14
>> Hawaiian pizza is Canadian.
7:15
>> Honestly, the the the pineapple and
7:17
Canadian bacon on a pizza.
7:19
>> What is words anymore?
7:21
>> It's it's the pineapple and the Canadian
7:23
bacon thing going on. Here's what I
7:24
don't like about that. The Canadian
7:25
bacon is so salty. I want like the umami
7:28
and the sweetness from the pineapple and
7:29
I want the pineapple to caramelize.
7:31
Instead, what I get is halfcooked pine,
7:33
half-cooked pineapple and salt and none
7:36
of the umami. If you could just roast,
7:38
if you could caramelize the pineapple,
7:39
we could have a conversation. Pizza
7:41
people,
7:41
>> Josh, I'm going to go ahead and agree
7:43
with Quaset. I think he might be vaguely
7:45
psychotic. What? Peach pie pizza? What
7:48
in God's green earth is that? [laughter]
7:51
>> Oh, no. This is like the Chicago sin for
7:54
dessert.
7:55
>> Okay.
7:55
>> You You made a peach casserole and
7:58
you're serving it as a pizza. Is that
7:59
what's happening?
8:00
>> Oh my god.
8:00
>> Isn't Isn't a peach pie pizza just peach
8:04
pie?
8:05
>> I think that's a cowzone is what you
8:07
would call it.
8:08
>> If you put a if you put a lid on it, I
8:10
>> What?
8:11
>> I I don't know what that is. Don't want
8:13
it.
8:13
>> You know what, Tyler? Look me in the
8:15
eye. Look me in the eye.
8:29
>> [music]
8:39
>> Welcome to the RPGbot dot podcast. I'm
8:41
Randall James and with me is Tyler
8:43
Camra.
8:43
>> Hi everybody. I'm an abomination.
8:46
>> Yes, you are.
8:46
>> Correct. Also, Ash Eli.
8:48
>> Yeah, you all are wrong. The best the
8:50
best topping on pizza is is uh
8:52
anchovies.
8:53
>> I you know, I've never had I've never
8:55
had anchovies on pizza. I can't say that
8:57
you're definitively wrong.
8:59
>> It's not the best. I just wanted to do
9:00
another hot tag, but it is good. Uh if
9:02
you haven't tried [laughter] it, I
9:03
highly recommend it. Also, articho carts
9:06
surprisingly good on pizza.
9:07
>> Oh, absolutely. Wonderful.
9:09
>> My one of my favorite pizza places in
9:11
New Mexico uh called Village Pizza put
9:15
chili on pizza. Oh, so good.
9:17
>> I mean, I bet that's great. Have you had
9:19
Have you had Anduja or Anduya? No.
9:21
>> You know what I'm talking about. It's
9:22
It's like a It's a spicy spreadable
9:24
salami. You put that on a pizza.
9:27
>> Maybe a little chili oil. It's amazing.
9:29
So good. It's It's like super pepperoni.
9:31
Like what a pepperoni. Well, it's the
9:33
sauce.
9:34
>> Wait. Quaset says, "Auent Italian pizza
9:36
is glorious. The rest of you are
9:37
heathens." No, this podcast doesn't get
9:39
to happen.
9:40
>> No. No. Closet. Closet. I'm aligned with
9:42
you. I will send you pizza pictures
9:44
[laughter]
9:46
like active. We We get the Italian guy
9:49
in the oven. Not [laughter] the Italian
9:50
guy working the oven doing doing the
9:53
pizzas. So good. Okay. Tonight, tonight
9:57
we are here to do the recap of session
10:00
three of Other Worlds.
10:03
>> Yes.
10:03
>> And also talk about pizza. But we'll,
10:05
you know, we'll work it out. [laughter]
10:07
>> Folks, where do you want to get started?
10:08
>> Uh, should we follow the same format as
10:10
the previous recap episodes?
10:12
>> Sure.
10:13
>> All right.
10:14
>> Yeah. What was that like? I [laughter]
10:15
don't remember.
10:16
>> I went back and I checked. I made sure
10:18
we hit all the same things. Right. So,
10:21
first we talked about our characters and
10:22
their various builds and what we wanted
10:24
to do with them. And then we talked
10:25
about what happened in the session. And
10:27
then we talked about what we learned
10:28
from the session, both like mechanically
10:31
and story-wise and stuff.
10:33
>> That's a great idea. Let's do that.
10:35
>> Yeah.
10:35
>> Yeah. Okay.
10:36
>> Um, so I'll start. Wizards are awesome.
10:39
[laughter]
10:40
>> Yeah, agreed.
10:41
>> I will I will give Tyler that win.
10:45
Especially in Pathfinder 2. It's It's
10:47
fun. I was watching XP to level three. I
10:49
don't know if you guys have watched him
10:50
at all. He's one of the bigger D and D
10:52
creators. He's recently gotten into
10:54
Pathfinder 2 and it's great to see
10:56
because he was going through the
10:57
different spells in Pathfinder 2 and how
11:00
much cooler they are than in fifth
11:02
edition. Yes, they are. They are way
11:04
cooler than in fifth edition. So, it was
11:07
fun. I mean, I've played a caster in
11:08
Pathfinder 2 before. Like my my other
11:11
campaign that I was in where resulted in
11:13
a TPK. Very sad. first ever TPK for that
11:16
DM in his 25 years of running tabletops
11:19
games.
11:20
>> Wow.
11:21
>> Yeah. Wait, but what what was the game?
11:23
>> Pathfinder 2. It was King King maker.
11:25
>> Perfect. Okay, that makes perfect sense.
11:27
Be because the beginning of that is
11:28
brutal.
11:29
>> No, no, no, no. We were we were past the
11:30
beginning. It was we were I think level
11:33
three and we got killed by a plant in a
11:36
random encounter. Super
11:38
>> just a random plant.
11:40
>> Yeah, we were doing a quest. So, we were
11:41
trying to find like I think we were
11:43
trying to get some ingredients for the
11:44
witch or whatever and the plant killed
11:47
us.
11:47
>> The the tree blight.
11:49
>> I don't know if it was a tree blight,
11:50
but it was like some sort of flower type
11:52
thing with vines.
11:54
>> Okay.
11:55
>> He might he might have brought it in
11:57
himself, but anyway, in that game I was
11:59
playing Animist and that was fun. I
12:01
think Wizard was a bit more fun. I've
12:03
always So, we've talked about this
12:05
before in the podcast. The most fun I
12:06
ever had playing a caster in Dn D was
12:10
when I played an illusionist wizard. And
12:12
I love illusions. They're so much fun,
12:15
especially when you have a great GM like
12:17
Randle who's willing to let you get away
12:18
with a lot of stuff. And what's great
12:20
about it in Pathfinder 2 is it's a lot
12:21
less up to DM fiat because the rules are
12:24
a lot more clear.
12:25
>> Yeah. [laughter]
12:26
>> Which is nice. And so like the highlight
12:30
for me was, you know, casting
12:31
invisibility, doing all this
12:32
misdirection. And my favorite moment was
12:35
when I when I brought in an elucory bug
12:38
with because I knew [laughter] exactly
12:40
how to get under Book's skin cuz Book
12:42
hates the bugs so much. [laughter]
12:44
>> That's both a Tyler and a Book thing.
12:46
How he just really hates bugs.
12:48
[laughter]
12:49
>> So So it was it was great. I Yeah. No,
12:53
wizards feel feel great in Pathfinder 2,
12:56
especially at level five and higher.
12:58
>> And and I'll say like that was super
12:59
mechanically impactful without making it
13:02
rely on GMBB fiat.
13:04
>> Yeah, which is exactly the point you
13:05
were making like that, you know, it's oh
13:07
illusion it's soft and like oh you know
13:09
depends on how it gets ruled like no
13:11
that kind of half wrecked the encounter.
13:12
Great job.
13:13
>> Yeah, exactly. And you know the the
13:15
great thing about wizards is like
13:16
they're so much more customizable in
13:18
Pathfinder 2. Like you can do a lot of
13:19
feats. I took so I was playing a
13:22
mentalism wizard which is essentially
13:24
the illusion wizard changed they changed
13:26
the name because you know remaster
13:28
shenanigans
13:29
>> but they also specialize in enchantment
13:31
as well but so yeah you get all these
13:34
free different like canrips and spells
13:36
based on like my background and my race
13:38
and my my chosen thesis or chosen school
13:42
I should say and then you know I got
13:44
access to the metamagic stuff that you
13:46
would get in 5e so I was concealing my
13:48
spells why I my spells. I was, you know,
13:51
all that turning my shields into
13:53
barriers. It was great. The only
13:55
downside I had was it wasn't long
13:57
enough. I wanted to play with the wizard
13:58
more.
13:59
>> Yeah. [laughter]
14:00
>> I mean, we we could decide, you know, we
14:04
we can kick the tires on these guys one
14:06
more time, but we'll save that maybe
14:07
towards the end.
14:08
>> Yeah,
14:08
>> maybe we can come back to them at some
14:10
point. Who knows?
14:11
>> Oh, that makes sense, too. You you made
14:13
the point early on when we first started
14:15
planning the session and I agree with
14:17
you, but I want to tell the folks at
14:18
home, we're going to come back and we're
14:19
going to do an illusion magic and PF2
14:22
episode dedicated to dive deep on it
14:24
because it is interesting. There's a lot
14:25
more detail. There's a lot of great
14:27
things on the PF2 side. I I think we've
14:29
probably talked about this on the 5D
14:31
side in the past, but honestly, there
14:32
there's more material here. I
14:34
>> did we talk about the illusion illusions
14:36
in just in specifics in 5e? I I don't
14:39
remember.
14:40
>> It's been so long. I think we spent more
14:42
time focusing on 5De than PF2 because at
14:45
time we didn't understand the rules as
14:47
well as we do now.
14:48
>> Fair enough. I mean, yeah, I think
14:49
Randall has a point. I think it would be
14:51
worth our time to go back to illusions
14:54
specifically from a Pathfinder 2 mindset
14:55
and maybe, you know, compare and
14:56
contrast that with fifth edition cuz
14:58
Yeah. No, I think that I would I when
15:01
Brandle pitched us doing the heist, I
15:05
pitched doing Illusion Wizard because I
15:06
was like, this would be a good
15:07
opportunity for us to compare and
15:09
contrast how illusions work in
15:11
Pathfinder 2 because I was curious, too.
15:13
I I have yet to see illusions pop up in
15:17
my Pathfinder 2 games. So, I wanted to
15:19
see how it works. And surprisingly, I
15:21
think it works pretty well. I think
15:23
there's still ways that it could improve
15:26
for sure, but thanks to the very
15:29
specific and well-written rules that
15:31
Piso puts out for literally everything,
15:34
it was no surprise that the illusions
15:36
feel very straightforward. There's not a
15:38
lot of room for interpretation when it
15:40
comes to how illusions work. There's
15:42
some because there always is with
15:44
illusions,
15:45
>> but it felt more mechanically tight than
15:48
within fifth edition. And I wasn't at
15:50
the mercy of my GM to know if my
15:52
illusions would even do anything.
15:53
>> Oh, perfect.
15:54
>> Yeah. Were there any buttons that you
15:56
didn't get to push on your character,
15:57
Ash? Spells you wanted to try, abilities
16:00
you wanted to play around with?
16:01
>> You know, let me let me bring up my
16:03
character sheet here real quick. And
16:05
>> I have one. [clears throat] We talked
16:06
about it towards the end of the session.
16:07
>> Okay. So, what what was your spell that
16:09
allowed you to read surface thoughts?
16:11
>> Oh, yeah. The mind readading. Yeah. I I
16:14
wish I had gotten to use that, but it it
16:17
it was fine. it that that would have
16:19
been fun to use. Like that could have
16:21
done some some interesting stuff. The
16:23
other the other spell that I was looking
16:25
forward to doing that I didn't get a
16:26
chance to was dja vu which is just a
16:29
very cool spell.
16:30
>> Yeah,
16:31
>> in my opinion. So basically the way dja
16:34
vu works is you loop a thought process
16:36
in a target's mind forcing it to repeat
16:38
a moment's worth of actions. The target
16:40
must attempt a will save. If the target
16:42
fails, whatever actions the target uses
16:43
on its next turn must repeat on its
16:45
following turn, which is so cool. like
16:48
it doesn't have to do the exact same
16:49
thing, but it has to do similar things.
16:51
So, it has to keep moving in if it moved
16:52
on its last turn, it has to keep moving
16:54
in that same direction. If it attacked
16:56
something, it has to attack that same
16:58
target if it's within reach, otherwise
16:59
attack the air. It's it's it's just a
17:02
really cool ability that I wish I had
17:03
gotten the chance to use.
17:05
>> Yeah.
17:05
>> Other than that, I I took alchemical
17:08
crafting even though I didn't think it
17:10
would come up, but, you know, it could
17:12
have been fun. I I could have let you
17:14
rule the al alchemy instead of alcohol
17:17
lore when you were mixing drinks.
17:19
>> That's true. That's true. Same thing.
17:20
>> Yeah. I didn't get to use my curriculum
17:23
spell or what was it? A curriculum
17:26
spell. There was a focus. Yeah. Charming
17:27
push. That's what it was. I didn't get
17:29
to use that. But again, these are just
17:31
like small things that I just didn't get
17:32
to use or engage with the free feat that
17:35
I got for my background of noble. Like I
17:37
didn't get to engage with my noble
17:38
background at all, like the courtly
17:40
graces. But again, not Randall's fault.
17:43
These are short one session session
17:45
things. So, it's understandable that we
17:47
weren't going to push buttons all the
17:48
time.
17:48
>> Yeah. When realistically, you're
17:50
bringing a wizard to a table like you
17:51
can't use everything available to the
17:53
wizard in a session cuz there's so much
17:54
freaking available.
17:55
>> Yeah. No, it was good. I didn't feel the
17:58
the big problem when it comes to wizards
18:00
is that you feel like you burn through
18:01
your resources too fast. But here, I
18:03
still had lots left because, you know,
18:05
it was one encounter, but it worked
18:07
pretty well.
18:07
>> Yeah. One combat encounter. True.
18:10
>> Yeah. one combat encounter.
18:11
>> Well, let's see. So, I played an Eldrich
18:13
Trickster rogue, and I I I built this
18:17
character probably three times. I was
18:18
originally just going to do a thief, but
18:20
I really wanted to bring in spellcasting
18:22
somehow, and Eldrich Trickster is the
18:24
option for that, but it confirmed a lot
18:27
of my doubts about the subclass. So,
18:30
rogues to deliver sneak attack damage
18:33
need the target to be offguard. So, you
18:36
can do that by hiding, you can do it by
18:38
flanking, you could do it by fainting,
18:40
and there are a few other like grabbag
18:42
options that you might not be able to do
18:44
yourself as a rogue. If you're if you're
18:46
fighting at range as a rogue, most
18:48
likely you are hiding between attacks to
18:52
make your targets off guard. If you're
18:53
fighting in melee, you're probably
18:55
either flanking or using faint. But the
18:58
problem with that is if I need to move
19:00
at all, I can't use my spells cuz all of
19:04
all of the attack spells are two
19:05
actions. So the the action economy is
19:08
just very difficult because you can't
19:10
both position yourself and make your
19:12
target offguard and use your spells at
19:14
the same time. So the action economy
19:16
really just does not work for the
19:18
subclass. And I built myself to be
19:20
really really good at fainting. So, like
19:23
if I could faint once, I would have a
19:24
pretty good chance to get a critical
19:26
success and then I have an entire round
19:28
to play around where I wouldn't have to
19:30
worry about it. So, that would have made
19:31
things better for me, but comet
19:34
encounter ended before that mattered.
19:36
>> Yeah. Oh, that was the thing. The other
19:38
thing I forgot to mention. So, my subass
19:40
for those who are curious was I was
19:42
playing a spell trickster, not an
19:43
Eldrich Trickster. They're different.
19:45
>> Yeah. [laughter]
19:45
>> Um, so spell trickster is kind of like
19:47
what Arcane Trickster wishes it was. Um
19:51
there there's so you get basically
19:54
they're free metamagic feats and that
19:57
was how I was able to do you know the
19:59
the barrier for the shield thing or the
20:02
conceal spell. And then the other one
20:04
that I took that didn't come up because
20:05
I realized Tyler I think also took it
20:08
was the ability to turn my telekinetic
20:10
hand invisible and use it to you know
20:12
pick locks and stuff like that.
20:14
>> I can't remember if I took that. I don't
20:15
know if you did, but I know you used
20:17
telekinetic hand. And I was like, "Oh, I
20:19
think we doubled up somewhere."
20:20
>> Um, oh, I I I got charlatan's gloves.
20:23
Wonderful item for rogues. Plus one to
20:26
thievery checks and you can cast
20:28
telekinetic hand. It's great.
20:29
>> Well, there you go. Yeah,
20:30
>> basically the same thing. But yeah, uh,
20:32
spell trickster. It's fun. I wouldn't
20:34
say it's the strongest class sub or
20:36
strongest archetype, but it's fun,
20:38
especially for a game like this. Did I
20:40
What did I say, Quaza? I meant free
20:42
archetype. Did I say something
20:43
different?
20:44
>> Oh. I meant free. Were
20:46
>> we using free archetype?
20:47
>> Yeah, I thought we were. Were we not?
20:48
>> Were we supposed to? I may have forgot.
20:50
>> I didn't say one way or the other for
20:51
this one. [laughter]
20:52
>> Oh, then that's my bad.
20:54
>> I don't think it changed anything.
20:56
>> I thought we agreed for your archetype.
20:58
>> I think we might have on one of the
20:59
earlier sessions and then we just
21:00
haven't talked about it since then.
21:01
>> Yeah. I mean, it's kind of become it's
21:03
kind of become the default for a lot of
21:05
Pathfinder 2 games. If you don't have
21:07
free archetype, like what are you doing?
21:09
>> [laughter]
21:09
>> Well, it's like if it were your first
21:11
session, I understand not wanting to or
21:13
first like campaign, I understand not
21:14
wanting to take the complexity in, but
21:16
as soon as you've climbed the PF2
21:17
complexity hill, like more fun. Like,
21:20
we're running Kingmaker and I gave our
21:22
gigantic freaking party free archetype
21:24
with the thought being like, we're only
21:26
going 1 to 20 in Pathfinder 2 once in
21:27
our lives. We're going to be 80 by the
21:29
time we finish this thing. [laughter]
21:30
>> Like, make it good.
21:32
>> Yeah.
21:32
>> Yeah. Yeah. No, I mean free archetype is
21:34
just like, don't get me wrong, without
21:36
free archetype, Pathfinder 2 is still
21:38
fun, but I think it's eminently more fun
21:39
with free archetype because it it allows
21:41
you to create really unique classes and
21:44
builds. So, um I've just always been a
21:46
fan of it. I know people are just like,
21:48
but the power scaling, it's like it
21:50
really doesn't make that much of a
21:52
difference in at least in my my
21:54
perspective. It's it's been fine. Like,
21:57
I haven't really noticed difficulty
21:59
difference between non-free archetype
22:01
and free archetype. Yeah, I for our
22:03
party because our party is sometimes
22:05
large, sometimes not, I tend to balance
22:07
by just throwing in additional creatures
22:09
or using the elite stat block, which
22:11
Foundry makes super easy to do. What I
22:13
find is I'm a lot more likely in that
22:15
scenario to knock people down, but the
22:17
party is large enough to typically
22:19
absorb it, survive it, and I think it
22:21
makes the combat a lot more dynamic and
22:22
more fun. I can understand if I was
22:24
running three to four people and I was
22:25
doing that to them, like, you know, two
22:28
down, two up is nerve-wracking.
22:30
>> Yes. But yeah, two down, three up still
22:32
feels pretty good, especially if you've
22:34
got one of the creatures down.
22:35
>> Yeah, dual class is a different story
22:37
closet. Dual class is definitely really
22:39
powerful. [laughter]
22:41
Changes the game quite substantially,
22:43
which is why I don't usually use dual
22:45
class.
22:46
>> Wait, are there rules in PF2 for dual
22:48
class proper? Yes, in GM4, I think.
22:50
>> Yeah.
22:51
>> Okay.
22:51
>> It's You think free archetype is
22:53
complicated. Oh boy, is dual class
22:55
complicated. [laughter]
22:58
And it's not worth it in my opinion.
23:00
>> [laughter]
23:01
>> Maybe that's it own episode.
23:03
>> Yeah.
23:03
>> Yeah. Well, Gaza was pitching that for
23:05
one of these we do a dual class, which
23:07
>> Yeah, maybe for one shot.
23:09
>> That's why that's why we're here. That's
23:10
literally why we're doing this.
23:12
>> No, I get it. And you know Yeah, we
23:14
should do that. I I just don't really
23:16
like dual class as a concept personally,
23:18
but that's my own opinion.
23:19
>> Reason.
23:19
>> Cool. So, Tyler, you're woke. Yeah. Did
23:21
you get to push all the buttons you were
23:23
hoping to push?
23:24
>> I think so. I I would have loved to have
23:28
done something goofy with my familiar,
23:30
but I think I got to I got to use almost
23:33
everything. So, the Eldrich Trickster
23:35
subclass, you get two wizard cantrips
23:39
from one of the feats that you're
23:40
expected to take. And I took attacks for
23:42
both of them, one for melee, one for
23:44
ranged. And the the ranged one would
23:47
have let me attack two creatures at the
23:49
same time. So, I could have sneak
23:50
attacked twice with two actions, which
23:52
would have been super cool as kind of an
23:54
opening move in combat, but we only had
23:56
one combat encounter against one
23:58
creature. So,
23:59
>> yeah. [laughter] No, that's fair. Yeah,
24:01
I think that's actually interesting and
24:03
good feedback for when we do these and
24:06
the goal is to really show off the
24:07
combat having Yeah. more than one
24:09
encounter, I guess, goes without saying,
24:10
but actually having them structured in a
24:12
way it's like, well, here's one very
24:13
large baddie. Here's a handful of
24:16
>> I mean, the problem with with with
24:18
sessions like this is that it's hard to
24:20
do more than one encounter over the
24:22
course of a 2hour recording session. I
24:25
mean, I I I've been able to do it.
24:28
[laughter]
24:29
Um, but that's just barely. I would say
24:31
like I can do maybe two with my West
24:34
Marches game cuz those tend to go like 2
24:36
and 1/2 hours. It It's pushing it
24:39
though. So, yeah. Now, I don't blame you
24:41
for only having the one encounter,
24:43
especially because the focus wasn't on
24:44
combat. The focus was on the stealth.
24:47
Okay, this is the one thing I will say
24:49
as a criticism, [laughter] which is
24:52
wasn't a lot of stealth. There was a lot
24:54
of puzzles, though.
24:56
>> We're I want to talk about this.
24:58
>> Yeah. Yeah,
24:59
>> sure.
24:59
>> Okay. You feel good about your rogue?
25:00
Have we Have we buried the rogue?
25:02
>> Yeah, I think so.
25:03
>> Okay, let's let's get into the session.
25:05
So hopefully you've already listened to
25:06
it because you're here. But just to do a
25:08
quick recap, the premise of this episode
25:10
was Tyler's previous character book
25:13
survived 60 years after the end of the
25:15
previous session. And in that built a
25:17
cult around the shard trying to study
25:20
the magical properties of the shard,
25:22
went a little crazy towards the end of
25:23
their life. And so Ash and Tyler woke up
25:27
at the, you know, at the bottom of
25:29
book's layer with Tyler's character
25:31
Cambendium knowing they were at the
25:33
bottom of the layer and knowing exactly
25:35
more or less how to get to the shard.
25:37
So, first off, the thing I want to say
25:40
about about the premise of this is first
25:42
off, I like it, but also I think stealth
25:45
and heist sessions are inherently
25:48
difficult to run in tabletop games
25:50
because it's it's just like the the
25:53
thing that makes them work in like say a
25:54
video game is you have different
25:55
enemies, you know, trolling in real time
25:57
and you're avoiding notice. You can't
25:59
really do that in TTRPGs. You can, but
26:01
it slows down the the session
26:03
substantially. But yeah, so I understand
26:06
the difficulty there. I am wondering.
26:08
So, I've I actually ran a heist mission
26:12
or a heist multi-shot for a
26:15
fatherdaughter duo. Shout out to you two
26:18
um if you're listening. And that went
26:20
that went really well. And I So, one of
26:22
the things that I found that worked for
26:24
that was I don't know if you took a look
26:26
at the infiltration variant rules for
26:28
Pathfinder 2.
26:29
>> Not. You should have because they're
26:32
very good. So, for future DMs that are
26:35
out there wanting to run a heist game,
26:37
look at the infiltration system for
26:39
Pathfinder 2. I think it's pretty
26:40
elegantly designed. It does require your
26:43
players to set up beforehand, but that
26:46
kind of feeds into the whole heist
26:47
aesthetic. Like, you're plotting, you're
26:49
scouting, you're trying to make these
26:50
connections. You're bribing people.
26:52
You're forging disguises and fake fake
26:54
fake uh identification. All this
26:57
different stuff that give you what are
26:58
called edges that you then spend to get
27:02
out of sticky situations. So like if a
27:04
guard spots you, your players can spend
27:06
one of their edges to be like, "Oh, this
27:08
is one of the guards that you bribed."
27:10
So he lets you he lets you through.
27:12
>> So and it also takes advantage of like
27:15
kind of a clock-like system similar to
27:17
Blaze in the Dark. That's the other one
27:18
that I would recommend for player people
27:20
who want to run heist missions. Look at
27:22
Blaze in the dark because nobody does
27:24
heist and stealth missions better than
27:26
Blaze in the dark. Bar none. The clock
27:28
mechanic inspired decision. So yeah,
27:32
that that's that's the one thing I would
27:34
say was my criticism of the session was
27:37
that it felt it felt more like a puzzly
27:40
sort of like trying to use our brains to
27:42
figure things out, which wasn't bad.
27:43
Like I did enjoy that, but it was it
27:46
wasn't what I was expecting.
27:48
>> Makes sense. I hear that.
27:49
>> Yeah.
27:50
>> Yeah. So, let's maybe talk about this in
27:52
three phases. Let's talk about the
27:54
Adrielma Memorial Bar. [laughter]
27:57
>> Sound like a great call back.
27:59
>> Yeah.
28:00
>> Let's let's talk through the music lab
28:03
and then we'll talk through the the
28:05
final lab. Elma memorial bar,
28:09
>> which for folks at home, Adriel Elma
28:11
survived about a decade, so 50 years
28:14
less than book did. And to quote Ash,
28:16
Adrielma drank themselves into a stuper
28:19
trying to make their their rig as
28:21
awesome as possible and accidentally
28:23
blew themselves up.
28:24
>> Yeah. So
28:26
would be rolling in their grave if they
28:28
knew that their old friend had made a
28:31
bar that enslaved people.
28:33
>> [laughter]
28:34
>> In fact, Major Soma didn't have to roll
28:35
over in their grave because he was right
28:37
there. [laughter]
28:38
He was one of the slaves,
28:41
was not happy about it. Yeah. So, the
28:43
the premise of this tower was that
28:46
people were committed, but once you
28:48
worked there, you were not allowed to
28:49
leave. And so, a lot of folks that you
28:51
the the characters were talking to were
28:54
happy to be there, but at the same time,
28:55
it's like I mean, working here is no
28:57
longer optional. You're here, you work
28:58
here, you're dead. only highlevel folks
29:00
ever got the right to actually leave the
29:02
leave the space. So, I wanted to do a
29:05
couple things here. I wanted you I
29:07
wanted to make that story like I wanted
29:09
to get that lore across so you
29:11
understood like what are people doing
29:12
here? Uh cuz I wasn't necessarily going
29:14
to railroad you through dealing with
29:16
security, dealing with Havari, dealing
29:18
with book at the end. You know, there
29:20
was opportunity if you wanted to to go a
29:22
couple different paths. You went exactly
29:24
where I was hoping you would go. So, it
29:25
made the content I had prepared work
29:27
really well.
29:27
>> Nice. So, what do you think of the bar
29:30
experience? And so, Ash, you got to use
29:31
your new lore skill in alcohol. You got
29:33
to make a couple checks. You got to, you
29:35
know, interact with some characters.
29:36
>> I enjoyed that part. It felt like, you
29:39
know, honestly, the best comparison I
29:41
could make for it is it felt like the
29:43
opening stages at a hitman level where
29:46
you're just you're blending in, you're
29:48
trying to you're you're fulfilling
29:50
orders and looking for your moment to
29:52
break away and assassinate the target.
29:54
Very bad. Even though we weren't there
29:56
to assassinate anybody, at least we
29:58
didn't think so.
29:59
>> But it turned out we were, [laughter]
30:01
>> we wanted to kill Book, although Book
30:04
technically killed himself.
30:06
>> Yeah. [laughter] And And you guys, you
30:07
you tried talking Book out of it. So, at
30:10
the very beginning of that, I I opened
30:12
with telling you what your work day was
30:14
going to be like. You're going to go
30:15
serve the bar when everybody's got their
30:16
food, everybody's got got their drinks.
30:18
I'll give you the whole pass to go
30:20
restock, and then you'll come and clean
30:22
up. And then, great news, you get to do
30:23
the exact same thing again tomorrow. So,
30:25
I wasn't trying to bang you on the head
30:27
with it, but I was trying to offer the
30:28
like the way you leave this room is with
30:30
the hall pass.
30:31
>> Yeah.
30:32
>> Yeah.
30:32
>> Considering there were only two doors
30:34
out of the bar, it seemed like a pretty
30:36
good option.
30:36
>> Okay. Um, [laughter] now I'd say like
30:39
you you got to that point pretty
30:41
quickly. You talked to one of the
30:42
characters. Character wanted a drink
30:44
that wasn't available.
30:45
>> Yeah. And then I mean I think the way
30:47
that you you pointed us in the direction
30:49
that we needed to go without like
30:50
forcing us that way was pretty elegant
30:53
and smooth if I'm not if I'm not lying
30:56
cuz basically you presented us with the
30:58
opportunity to go off the beaten path
31:00
and we're just like ah let's take it
31:02
[laughter]
31:04
like we didn't have to but you put it
31:06
you sort of dangled the thread out there
31:07
and we're just like yes.
31:09
>> Yeah. [laughter]
31:10
>> I do love a twist of plot hook.
31:12
>> I do.
31:14
It's going to be great. So, first guard
31:16
we had to get by.
31:18
>> Yeah,
31:18
>> you guys handled it great. If I remember
31:19
correctly, there might have been a
31:20
deception check and then invisibility. I
31:22
can't argue with that.
31:23
>> Uh, we Yeah, I think there No, there was
31:26
a I think it was a persuasion rule cuz
31:28
we were being honest. We're like, we're
31:29
here to get some wine or whatever.
31:31
>> Mhm.
31:31
>> And then, yeah, using share
31:34
invisibility. So awesome. Such a great
31:36
spell. Immediately ruined by Tyler.
31:39
>> I know. I'm sorry.
31:40
>> I love how [laughter]
31:42
his his answer to that. He's like, "I'm
31:43
invisible, right?" He's like, "Yes." And
31:45
he's like, "I'm going to go slap Ash."
31:47
You can walk 30 ft away from me and it
31:50
will go off of you. Why are you ruining
31:51
this for both of us?
31:53
>> Cuz I needed you to be visible.
31:55
>> Why? Why did you need me to be visible?
31:57
>> Because you were the one replacing the
31:59
guy.
32:00
>> Why couldn't you do it? Cuz I had to be
32:02
Havari.
32:03
>> No, because you didn't LOOK LIKE HAVARI.
32:06
YOUR LOGIC is flawed. Your logic is
32:08
flawed.
32:08
>> My logic is a flaw. In my defense, I
32:10
have a cold. Okay, so we we so you drank
32:14
a bottle of cough medicine, you maniac.
32:16
[laughter] Okay. No, so we they they
32:18
used shared invisibility to get by the
32:20
first guard. Now, here's what I'll say.
32:21
Like that that just works. Like you
32:23
invested in the spell. I I looked at
32:25
your spell list. I knew what you had
32:26
down. We ran through the rules just to
32:28
make sure everything made sense, but
32:29
like no, we're not going to do checks.
32:31
I'm not going to do it's like, oh, but
32:32
the guard sees like a footprint. No,
32:34
that's lame. It works. You get by them.
32:36
We're good.
32:37
>> Yeah. Yeah. Also, I mean, invisibility
32:39
in Pathfinder 2 is just a better spell
32:41
than it is in 5B. Cuz in 5B, thanks to,
32:44
you know, strict daddy
32:45
>> Jeremy Crawford, you still have when you
32:48
when you in when you He's not dead.
32:51
[laughter]
32:52
>> He's dead to us.
32:54
>> When When you cast invisibility on
32:56
yourself, you are not automatically
32:57
hidden from things. You have to then
32:59
make a stealth check
33:00
>> to hide.
33:01
>> Boom. [laughter]
33:03
Point. So yeah, invisibility is just
33:05
like yeah, you're undetected until you
33:08
do something that makes you not
33:10
undetected, which you know makes sense.
33:13
[laughter]
33:13
So yeah, like maybe if you're if you if
33:16
you're trying to like steal something
33:18
that's in plain view, I would probably
33:19
call for a check because, you know,
33:22
something is floating in midair. People
33:24
are going to have questions about that.
33:25
>> Yeah. Things are disappearing into your
33:27
possession, whatever the case may be.
33:28
Like something wonky is happening here.
33:30
>> Yeah. But I'm not going to make you make
33:31
a check for just walking around. It's so
33:34
stupid. So that's what I did appreciate
33:36
that about invisibility. It just didn't
33:39
get to use it for very long.
33:41
>> Okay, so let's let's rewind. So the
33:43
folks like Tyler's character compendium
33:45
remembered that there was a secret way
33:47
to get to the shard lab through the the
33:50
the brewing room. And so you know, they
33:53
went west to pretend like they were
33:54
going to the seller to get wine
33:56
invisibility and then cut back east to
33:57
go up through the brewing room. They got
33:59
into a lab that Compendium didn't
34:02
remember. Like this room made sense, but
34:04
everything that was in it made no sense.
34:06
And as soon as they're in there, like
34:07
they started talking to each other and
34:08
you know, hello, do I hear voices? Like,
34:10
you know, it's like, okay, well, there's
34:11
somebody in the room. And Tyler's
34:13
immediate thought was like, first, I'm
34:14
immediately going to scream back at this
34:16
guy.
34:17
>> Like, I was so mad at you. [laughter]
34:18
>> I know. So,
34:20
>> but he critted on the Okay, this was the
34:23
deception check. He critted on the
34:24
deception check and convinced the guy
34:26
that he was Havari. So Tyler does his
34:28
best. Sean Connory nails it.
34:30
>> He did nail it. That was very
34:32
impressive. [laughter]
34:34
>> Yeah. Okay. I I know I said this. Like
34:37
let's spoil this now. The password was
34:40
Havari with red wine. That was the
34:42
passphrase to swap out guards.
34:44
>> Yeah.
34:44
>> Yeah.
34:44
>> Okay. You pretended to be Havari.
34:47
>> Yeah. My anticipated solution for this
34:49
was that because I had already looked at
34:51
Ash's character sheet was that Ash was
34:53
going to use the read surface thought
34:56
spell. Yeah,
34:57
>> I for that was
35:00
a
35:00
>> I forgot I had it. So that was the
35:02
problem. [laughter]
35:03
>> Classic wizard.
35:04
>> I But I I did. So let's talk about how I
35:07
GM this. I you know I don't know if you
35:08
remember I did one like does anybody
35:10
have a skill or spell that would help us
35:11
get past this. You both looked at your
35:13
character sheets. You said nope. I said
35:14
cool. We're going to figure it out
35:15
together. [laughter]
35:18
>> We did it.
35:19
>> So I had you make one more. I think in
35:22
in cases like that, especially with with
35:24
a player such as myself or someone new
35:27
who maybe doesn't have a grip on all of
35:29
their spells or stuff like that, you can
35:31
you can I think it's perfectly
35:32
acceptable as a GM to be like, "Hey,
35:34
Ash, don't you have that mind readading
35:36
spell might come in handy and that way I
35:39
don't think that takes away player
35:41
agency? Players are just like, "Oh my
35:42
god, I forgot I had that. That's a great
35:44
suggestion." But I think the way that
35:46
you handed it is perfectly fair and
35:48
valid. And it was totally my fault that
35:51
I just forgot that I had that spell cuz
35:54
if I had used it, yeah, that could have
35:56
saved us a lot of grief. But we figured
35:58
out I think the way that you handled it
35:59
was pretty elegant. Like we found a way
36:01
to not soft lock the whole game because
36:05
we didn't remember our spells.
36:07
>> Well, and and peeking behind the GM
36:09
curtain, right? Like I was duty bound if
36:11
nothing else than like just lie. Let's
36:14
make something up and let's let it go
36:16
through. Like I I couldn't be like,
36:18
"Well, you just can't do this." I could
36:19
maybe make you murder the guard is the
36:21
other option here.
36:22
>> That was on the That was also on the
36:23
table, I suppose,
36:25
>> but that would have not been the most
36:27
elegant solution.
36:29
>> Okay. But the passphrase I had written
36:32
down was Havari with red wine,
36:34
[laughter]
36:34
which is a perfectly fine passphrase.
36:37
>> And you came upstairs and said like, you
36:39
know,
36:41
that's how sounded like Havari.
36:44
>> Havari. up here looking for some port,
36:47
you know, like you you you said this,
36:48
you talked about whine about their best.
36:51
[laughter]
36:52
>> Yeah,
36:54
>> Marlo was the prom queen. Anyway, um uh
36:58
so you did it like you did it in a
37:00
roundabout way, but honestly, the fact
37:01
that your improv plus your crit
37:03
deception was so freaking close to what
37:06
you needed to say to the guy to get him
37:08
to buzz off anyway, it was like, you
37:09
know what, you got it's yours.
37:10
>> [laughter]
37:11
>> Okay, now let's talk about the only
37:14
puzzle in the session. Yeah.
37:16
>> Okay. No, [laughter] there were two.
37:20
There were two.
37:21
>> I may not Okay. You may not have
37:23
intended it for to be a puzzle, but it
37:25
was.
37:26
>> The mirror room absolutely qualifies as
37:28
a puzzle, sir.
37:29
>> Yeah.
37:29
>> Okay. Let's Okay, we'll talk. We'll get
37:31
there when we get there. Let's
37:33
>> Okay. [laughter] I know from having run
37:35
mini games with Tyler and from
37:37
discussions with Ash that these folks
37:39
don't love puzzles.
37:40
>> Nah, not a huge fan.
37:42
>> I'm okay with them from time to time.
37:44
>> I freaking love puzzles. [laughter]
37:46
>> I know.
37:47
>> I love mysteries.
37:48
>> Look, here here's what I'll say. I
37:50
appreciate puzzles in dungeons. Like, I
37:52
feel like dungeon kind of needs a puzzle
37:54
or so or or some. I just if it's a
37:57
puzzle, [snorts]
37:58
it either needs to be something that is
38:00
relatively obvious or easy to understand
38:03
from like context clues or spatial
38:05
awareness or it needs to be something
38:08
that I can solve with a check. And this
38:10
isn't this isn't really you Randall, but
38:13
as soon as I saw the the image that you
38:16
popped up on the screen with the musical
38:18
notes, my brain shut off. I [laughter]
38:20
was like, this is too this is too
38:22
complicated for me. I'm not following
38:24
this at all. And so yeah, the the
38:27
problem I have with puzzles is not in
38:29
concept. The problem I have with puzzles
38:30
is they are extremely hard to execute
38:32
well because it it it's it's just diffic
38:36
it's a difficult skill to learn in game
38:39
design. You have to find that sweet spot
38:41
sweet spot between something that feels
38:43
satisfying to figure out and something
38:46
that just feels frustrating and bogs
38:48
down the experience. That being said, I
38:50
think that your puzzle was ultimately
38:52
pretty simple. we just overthought it.
38:54
But a large part of that was because of
38:56
the big complicated image that you
38:59
popped in front of our head that
39:00
[laughter] caused us to overthink it. So
39:02
that's an example of taking a a simple
39:04
puzzle and making it more convoluted to
39:07
the point where people start to
39:08
overthink it. It would have been better
39:10
if you had had like just a more obvious
39:14
point pointer rather than all of this
39:16
other information that ultimately had
39:18
nothing to do with the puzzle. But
39:20
that's just my opinion.
39:22
>> Okay. Well, let's talk through it. So,
39:23
the puzzle was, you know, the circle of
39:25
fits. Folks at home, there's a link in
39:26
the show notes, but you could Google
39:28
what the circle of fits is. If you know
39:30
music theory, you already know what it
39:31
is. But here was the thing. I I did want
39:33
to present something that looked
39:35
complicated and and my hope is like you
39:38
see this thing, it looks complicated.
39:40
When you figure out the trick, because
39:41
the actual puzzle was pretty simple,
39:43
we'll talk about the shape of it in a
39:44
second.
39:44
>> Yeah.
39:45
>> That then you feel really good because
39:46
you you you do use a lot of the
39:48
information that's on the sheet. You're
39:49
able to ignore the irrelevant things.
39:51
You're ready to go. So, here here's what
39:52
you got. You got the circle fits. You
39:53
got a clue saying that perhaps a minor
39:56
key because these creatures in the room
39:57
are sad. And then I called for a check.
40:00
I let Tyler use his alchemy lab or his
40:05
laboratory lore skill. And Ash, I I
40:07
forget what what you used, but you used
40:08
irrelevant like maybe. Perfect.
40:10
>> That sounds right.
40:11
>> There were 12 creatures in the room. You
40:15
looked at a clipboard. You found that it
40:16
was annotated with a sharp sign. You
40:19
started looking at other clipboards. You
40:20
found that some weren't, some were. You
40:22
counted up the number of sharps. So, at
40:23
that point, you had a major key and a
40:25
minor key. And and Tyler, you even said
40:26
like you were like, well, Gar, do I push
40:28
it? Do I not? Do I push it? Do I not?
40:29
And then we kind of got in. It's like,
40:30
well, what if I make the creatures
40:32
angry, make them sing? If you had pushed
40:34
the wrong button on the wheel, I was
40:38
going to let some insects out. They were
40:39
level one. You would have finished them
40:40
off really quickly, but I would have
40:42
opened some doors, let you do some
40:43
fighting. The route you went of instead
40:45
kicking them and making them sing, I
40:48
went with it.
40:49
I Does it count as animal abuse if
40:52
they're insects?
40:53
>> Yes.
40:53
>> Okay, [laughter]
40:56
>> that's fair. Okay,
40:57
>> but what if I hate them?
40:59
>> Yes,
40:59
>> that that's [laughter] I mean honestly
41:01
at that point that's even worse. You're
41:02
trying to justify violence with hatred.
41:04
>> Insects are pe insects are animals too,
41:07
man. I don't know what to tell you. Jan
41:09
I think it's Janice. Janice
41:12
pohour death in all of its forms.
41:14
Murder. So if there's an ant in their
41:15
path, they will pick it up and move it.
41:17
So, you are not allowed to kill any
41:19
living creature. Plants are the
41:21
exception cuz you got to eat.
41:23
>> Okay. I I thought you were going for the
41:25
lobsters or people too quote from the
41:27
kid from Terminator 2.
41:29
>> Okay.
41:29
>> Lobsters are people.
41:30
>> I don't remember that one.
41:31
>> Okay. This could be like this is the
41:33
same era of like the Marilyn Manson
41:35
stories, if you know what I mean. I
41:36
think you do. So, this could have been
41:37
like an urban legend of Wives Tale, but
41:39
the story was that he got arrested for
41:41
setting lobster free at a Walmart. And
41:43
when he was arrested, he was quoted as
41:45
saying, "Lob lobsters are people, too,
41:46
man.
41:47
Yeah. So, getting back to the puzzle,
41:49
uh, okay, so the thing that tripped me
41:52
up was the fact that, you know, I
41:54
figured out that each of the the symbols
41:58
lined up to, uh, the different cages. I
42:00
was and I felt really good about that.
42:02
But then I all of my victory immediately
42:04
drained away when we went to go check
42:06
the clipboard and the thing that it said
42:08
didn't match anything that was on the
42:11
sheet. And I'm just like, what? So, so
42:14
that was that that was the thing where
42:16
it's like simple is better in when
42:19
you're doing puzzle design. So, if
42:20
you're like if you had just put like,
42:23
you know, 12 different symbols and just
42:25
let us figure out that oh, these
42:27
different symbols apply to the diff the
42:29
12 different rooms. That's that's an
42:32
elegant puzzle and it works really well.
42:34
And then people just have to figure out
42:35
the order. Like maybe you're trying to
42:37
recreate a piece of music. Maybe you
42:39
have the bard do a performance check to
42:42
read the music to get a hint. That kind
42:43
of stuff. And but the the problem with
42:46
using the what what is the circle
42:48
called? I forget.
42:49
>> Circle of fifths.
42:50
>> Circle of fifths is that there's it's
42:52
not just 12 symbols. It's like 32
42:55
different symbols.
42:55
>> So many symbols.
42:56
>> Yeah. So it's just like which symbol
42:58
matters here and which doesn't. So it
43:00
over complicated the puzzle. Just have
43:02
12 symbols. Work with 12. 12 is a nice
43:05
even number. Players can work with that.
43:07
they can wrap their heads around it and
43:08
they you can you can work from that
43:11
point. But it turned out we just needed
43:13
a specific note that wasn't even
43:15
represented on the circle. I don't think
43:17
G# wasn't even on the circle.
43:19
>> It was a minor key on the circle.
43:21
>> Okay. It was again I'm still not fully
43:24
sure how we solved the puzzle.
43:26
[laughter]
43:26
>> There was some guessing some lucky
43:28
guessing and no I mean you counted up
43:30
the number of sharps. You looked at the
43:32
the the you know the minor and the major
43:34
key that had that number of sharps and
43:37
then one of the clues was it's a minor
43:39
key.
43:39
>> Oh, okay. I didn't find.
43:40
>> So you you guessed it immediately. As
43:42
soon as you knew there was five sharps,
43:43
you were like it's this. Let me ask you
43:44
this. So when I was initially thinking
43:46
about doing the puzzle, I was thinking
43:47
about instead having the clipboard have
43:50
a note like the this animal plays this
43:52
note. And then that note would have
43:55
defined a scale
43:57
>> which [clears throat] was the key. What
43:58
key is the scale in is the key. I
44:01
worried making you write the notes down
44:04
and then figure out what scale that
44:06
corresponds to would have been torture.
44:09
>> Yes, it would have been.
44:10
>> Yeah.
44:11
>> I don't even know where to start with
44:13
that. I [laughter]
44:14
>> It would have literally been dragging
44:16
you through the mud and I was like,
44:17
"Okay, that would have been worse." So,
44:20
glad you didn't do that. I'm glad you
44:22
>> So, here's here's my go-to philosophy
44:25
when it comes to puzzle design in Dn D.
44:28
have in your mind that your players are
44:30
dumber than you think they are
44:31
[laughter]
44:32
>> because it's probably true.
44:36
>> Uh, and yeah, I think we talked about
44:38
this when we talked about puzzles. I
44:39
don't know. I don't know if we ever did
44:41
like an actual puzzle design.
44:43
We did. Okay.
44:44
>> Two and a half, three years ago.
44:45
>> Yeah. So when we t I think it was in
44:47
this episode we talked about how puzzles
44:50
are are hard because they kind of bring
44:54
the the gameplay to a screeching halt
44:57
because now it's not about the dice
45:00
rolls anymore. It's not about the
45:01
character statistics anymore. It's about
45:03
the players and how they can it's like
45:06
it it's one of those things in in
45:08
addition to like social encounters where
45:09
it's a disconnect between what the
45:11
players capability is and what their
45:14
character's capability is. So I mean if
45:16
you wanted to do a less metagamey puzzle
45:19
that worked for your players anytime you
45:21
had a puzzle you'd have players make an
45:23
intelligence check and if they succeeded
45:25
they would solve the puzzle. But that is
45:28
boring and I get why we don't do that.
45:30
But but I mean at least with charisma
45:33
you can base your role play off of what
45:36
you roll. You can't really do that with
45:38
puzzle puzzles. Although I guess the
45:40
best you could do is like if someone
45:41
rolls high enough, you give them a hint.
45:43
So yeah, it's it's a difficult skill to
45:46
master and it's it's one I still
45:49
struggle with. So mine my puzzles tend
45:52
to kind of default to riddles. Um which
45:55
honestly idea.
45:56
>> Yeah, it works. Like I think the most
45:58
complicated puzzle I had was I so I had
46:02
two puzzles recently that I mentioned on
46:04
blue sky for the same dungeon that I
46:06
think were probably my most complicated.
46:08
One was like there was a mural with the
46:10
different seasons and there were four
46:11
different orbs that were of different
46:13
energies. And basically the players had
46:15
to associate each element with a
46:17
different season that I felt made sense
46:19
and that gave them the order that they
46:21
had to do it in. And then they had to
46:22
infuse each of those orbs with different
46:24
elements and I had an inscription kind
46:25
of hinting towards that. And then the
46:27
other one was a cauldron where I gave
46:28
them a sort of an esoteric hint and they
46:30
had a bunch of ingredients that they had
46:31
to put in. But again, all the
46:33
information was there. They did they
46:35
just it was just pattern recognition. It
46:37
was understanding this pattern goes
46:39
here, this reliance to that rather than
46:41
trying to I don't know do complicated
46:45
associations or math in their head or
46:47
something like that. It's look I'm not
46:49
saying I'm great at this cuz I
46:50
definitely am not.
46:52
>> [laughter]
46:53
>> So, so one other piece of advice we gave
46:55
in the puzzles episode, but I'll repeat
46:57
here is that one of the keys for
46:58
designing puzzles for the TTRPG is to,
47:01
you know, what are the key pieces of
47:03
information necessary to solve the
47:05
puzzle or the riddle? As a GM, you have
47:07
to have that mental model. You have to
47:08
have it written down. Every single one
47:10
of those things needs to be discoverable
47:12
by the player being clever or by the
47:14
character making a role. And so, give
47:16
yourself for each piece of information
47:18
one or two different checks or sources
47:20
that that person might check. And so in
47:22
this case, I had you folks roll
47:25
essentially to investigate and find the
47:27
clue of the sharps. That was your
47:28
character's acting. You rolled dice, you
47:30
got a good score, you got that answer,
47:32
and that helped you put everything
47:34
together. I I think you also did a
47:36
perception check to search for the clue
47:38
to find the minor key thing. And so that
47:40
was again something that you did in
47:42
character, but then at the end, yeah,
47:43
you were able to put it together as a
47:45
player. Tyler did. Yeah, it it's Oh,
47:48
it's one of those things that like you
47:50
just need to be open to the idea that
47:53
your players can come up with a solution
47:54
that you didn't think of and if it makes
47:57
sense, be okay with that being the
48:00
answer. Because that's a that's and we
48:03
talked about this in the puzzle episode
48:04
is that if if you get into your head
48:06
that there is a specific way that you
48:09
want the puzzle to be solved, we're
48:10
going to be here all night. Because
48:13
again, especially considering if the
48:15
puzzle is esoteric enough, players need
48:18
to be able to solve it and people can't
48:21
read your mind. So like an example that
48:23
happened on Blue Sky, I actually had my
48:25
followers try to guess what ingredients
48:27
went into the cauldron and some people
48:28
suggested alternatives to what I had in
48:30
mind. I was like, you know what, if
48:32
players had used those, I probably would
48:34
have accepted it cuz like one of them
48:36
was like make something harder than skin
48:38
and the ingredient I had was liquid
48:40
steel or liquid iron, I think it was.
48:42
And one of my followers said, "What
48:44
about dragon? You had dragon blood on
48:46
there. What about dragon blood?" Cuz you
48:48
know, harder than skin. I'm like, "Yeah,
48:49
you know what? I would have I would have
48:50
accepted that. That would have been
48:52
fine." As long as your players are
48:53
making an effort and they can logic out
48:55
why it makes sense, I see no problem in
48:58
it working.
48:58
>> Yeah. Makes sense to me.
48:59
>> But we talked enough about the puzzle.
49:01
We still have other things to talk
49:02
about.
49:03
>> Puzzle wasn't my favorite part. That's
49:04
all I'm saying. [laughter]
49:06
>> But I I can appreciate what you were
49:07
trying to do. I will I will refrain from
49:11
puzzles once every three once every
49:13
three sessions.
49:14
>> I'm not I'm not asking you to stop doing
49:15
puzzles. I'm just asking them to I'm
49:17
asking I'm asking
49:18
>> You're going to get them once every
49:20
>> I'm just asking you I'm pleading with
49:21
you to treat me as dumber than you think
49:23
I am. [laughter]
49:27
I'm actually
49:29
well the the next puzzle I'm actually
49:31
just going to roll like put a bunch of
49:33
dice out and say like what is the
49:35
expectation value of rolling this thing?
49:38
[laughter]
49:39
>> Oh no.
49:40
>> So you're telling me the mirror room was
49:42
not a not supposed to be a puzzle? Is
49:45
that what you're telling me?
49:46
>> I wanted to use it as a bit of lore and
49:49
help you understand what Book was doing
49:51
up here and why nobody was seeing him.
49:52
He had created this pocket dimension
49:54
where the inanimate objects were
49:56
inorganic inanimate objects were
49:58
reflected but then there were key items
50:00
in the room plus the organics and the
50:02
the primary inorganic object that was
50:05
not properly reflected was the lever.
50:07
>> Yeah. So that's what was tripping me up.
50:09
So, the fact that you had this mirror,
50:12
you had two identical rooms that were
50:15
reflected that had very seemingly random
50:18
objects in them and this lever was like,
50:21
"Oh, this is another puzzle room." I
50:23
realize now that it was the easiest
50:25
thing. You just needed us to touch the
50:26
mirror to go through to the other side.
50:28
That's all you needed us to do. Which I
50:30
I'm sure that you were like, "Oh, God."
50:32
When when I went to go investigate the
50:34
mirror and you're like, "Is part of
50:36
this, do you touch the mirror?" And I
50:37
was like, "No." You're like, "Oh,
50:39
>> he's just touching."
50:40
>> We're We're going to come back to that
50:41
later. [laughter]
50:42
>> Uh the What did the lever actually do?
50:45
>> Yeah. What did it do?
50:47
>> When you when you flipped both levers,
50:50
>> right,
50:50
>> the contraption at the center of the
50:52
room opened up and revealed the shot.
50:55
>> Moment came out, you know, ready to
50:57
shave like, "Oh, what's what's going on
50:59
in here?" [laughter]
51:00
>> That makes sense.
51:01
>> Save is a clip.
51:02
>> You can see why we why we thought it
51:04
would be another puzzle. We just came
51:06
from puzzle room and we were presented
51:08
with this other area that seemingly
51:10
didn't really have any hazards. It
51:11
didn't have any sort of monsters. It
51:13
just had this mirror and some objects in
51:16
the room. So immediately for a player,
51:18
this is just how dungeon design kind of
51:21
works. When a player enters a room in a
51:23
dungeon and it doesn't h have any
51:25
obvious hazards or traps or monsters and
51:28
it's not like a pretty simple bare bones
51:30
room, they're immediately going to go to
51:32
puzzle because it has to have something.
51:35
It can't just be a room. [laughter]
51:37
>> Okay, here's what I'll say.
51:39
>> When I initially laid out that room, I
51:41
was totally going to do a puzzle in
51:43
there.
51:44
>> I knew it. I knew it. I knew it.
51:47
>> Once [laughter] once I built the circle
51:49
of fits puzzle, I thought that's all the
51:52
puzzles these guys can stay. That's
51:53
enough. [laughter]
51:54
That's that's that's enough puzzles.
51:56
>> Also, for time was probably
51:59
>> fair, too. But but I did I did want to
52:01
have that bit of lore of like somehow he
52:03
found a way of building an alternate
52:05
reality. He built an other world using
52:08
the shard and I wanted that to be had a
52:11
portal. [laughter]
52:13
>> That's fair.
52:14
>> It was a mirror,
52:16
>> right? But the mirror reflected the
52:18
Never mind. We we've talked about this.
52:21
Look, I'm not I'm not
52:22
>> You're right. No, you're 100% right.
52:24
When you walked in, it's like this looks
52:25
like a puzzle room. It was going to be
52:27
and then I backed off.
52:28
>> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, it well, surprise
52:31
surprise. When you set something up to
52:32
be a puzzle room, but then don't
52:34
actually pull the pull the trigger on
52:35
it, it's going to come across as a
52:37
puzzle room.
52:38
>> I [laughter] tell you,
52:40
>> I left a lot of the pieces out.
52:43
>> Okay.
52:44
>> What you could have done, got rid of all
52:46
of the rest of those items. Just had the
52:48
two levers. That's all you needed to do.
52:51
>> I feel like the flowers like they were
52:53
dead on one side and alive on the other.
52:55
That was a really exciting clue. So,
52:58
which is why I spent so much time mcking
53:00
about with them.
53:01
>> I I realized like, okay, everybody So,
53:04
you know, of course, folks are in the
53:05
chat live when we're when we're playing
53:07
the session. Everybody's kind of like
53:10
looking at the circle of fits puzzle and
53:12
then in this room, everybody's so
53:13
excited about the mirror and there's all
53:15
these things that are happening. It's
53:16
like,
53:16
>> I should have just invested here.
53:18
>> Invested in the wrong place. Going to
53:20
Josh Josh Josh Josh Josh Josh Josh Josh
53:20
Josh Josh Josh Josh Josh Josh Josh's
53:21
point I think I was more excited more
53:24
interested in doing the mirror puzzle
53:25
than I was the circle of fists because
53:27
that was all about spatial awareness
53:29
which is the kind of puzzles that I
53:30
like. I'm not big on the sort of like I
53:33
have to use my thinky brain in order to
53:35
[laughter]
53:36
in order to sort of understand this like
53:38
written puzzle. No, I like spatial
53:41
awareness puzzles. They're fun. They're
53:43
interesting. Okay, but
53:44
>> wait I just say next time and and it
53:46
won't be next session. It might not be
53:48
the session after that, but the next
53:49
time I do a puzzle, it's going to be
53:51
spatial awareness shaped.
53:52
>> I feel bad that I feel like I'm just
53:55
ragging on you. I think
53:57
>> I had a great time in the session.
53:59
>> No, but but this is actually and and I'm
54:01
glad we're doing this like for folks at
54:03
home. Hearing criticism is difficult.
54:06
Receiving criticism is difficult.
54:07
Sometimes giving criticism is difficult.
54:09
Honestly, the only way that your table
54:11
is going to get better is if you talk
54:13
about the things that you like and don't
54:14
like. So, like nobody in this
54:16
conversation is upset. I'm happy to hear
54:18
all this stuff. And like me saying it's
54:19
like the next time I run a puzzle for
54:20
you, it's gonna be a spatial awareness
54:22
puzzle. That's not me like being like,
54:24
I'll show you since, oh, that's what you
54:26
like. I like building puzzles. I'll
54:28
build you a puzzle like that. And guess
54:29
what? It's not going to be like make the
54:32
plant alive again to solve the thing or
54:34
move the cage around, but it'll I can
54:36
take what you're telling me and create
54:38
something that you enjoy now.
54:39
>> Yeah. No, I w I'm with Josh. I wish my
54:41
players would give me this kind of
54:42
feedback, too. But that's why I think
54:44
stars and wishes can be a really useful
54:47
tool for DMs. I used to think it was
54:49
kind of a waste of time. But lately,
54:50
I've appreciated it more because if you
54:53
do stars and wishes, it keeps things a
54:54
little bit more positive, but you can
54:56
still tell what clicked for players,
54:58
like what connected with them, what they
55:00
what didn't click with them, and what
55:02
they're what they want their focus to be
55:04
on. So, if you're ever curious, but you
55:06
don't want people to just feel awkward
55:08
about like, you know, doing what we're
55:10
doing with Randall right now, it's just
55:11
like, you did this wrong. stop doing
55:13
this. Do stars and wishes it because it
55:15
keeps it keeps the conversation positive
55:18
without it being just like, you know, a
55:20
wave of criticism. And when people don't
55:22
mention things, you can keep in your
55:24
brain, they didn't mention this, nobody
55:26
mentioned this, so it must not have
55:27
connected or landed with my players. So,
55:29
I will tweak that in the future. Like
55:31
for me, my star would have been me
55:33
summoning that elucory bug. That was
55:36
super cool and I enjoyed it.
55:37
>> It was. Yeah.
55:39
>> Yeah.
55:40
>> Though you made me look at a bug. How
55:41
dare you? [laughter]
55:43
>> I mean, you only killed that bug once.
55:45
>> I mean, both of you look at a bug, but
55:47
both of yourselves. [laughter]
55:49
>> Let me I I want to ask a couple
55:51
questions here. I want to get your take
55:52
on it. One, Tyler. Yes.
55:54
>> I took one of your player characters.
55:56
>> Yeah.
55:57
>> You You told me generally what happened,
56:00
the Descent of Madness, and so I said,
56:02
"Okay, cool. Descent into madness. Then
56:04
you're I'm I'm going to take him and
56:05
he's mine now."
56:06
>> Yeah.
56:06
>> All right. Ash, you say you loved it,
56:07
Tyler.
56:08
>> Oh, yeah. I thought it was fun. I I'm a
56:11
little disappointed we didn't get to
56:12
fight the giant fighting robot, though.
56:14
>> Yeah.
56:15
>> Yeah. I'm also just It leaves me with
56:17
questions about how that even is
56:20
possible, how that works. Like how is it
56:22
that he can exist in two bodies
56:24
simultaneously? Like I just have
56:26
questions.
56:27
>> Um but is this like a time travel
56:30
situation? Like what is this? Yeah, it
56:33
Well,
56:34
>> these are all great questions that will
56:36
be answered next time
56:38
>> or they will never be
56:39
>> or not.
56:41
>> No, I I have I have a view more of these
56:45
like slightly mind screwy like
56:48
>> Yeah, I love mind screw. I love mind
56:51
screws, man. They're great.
56:52
>> Yeah, but I think the the next time we
56:54
do something, we're going to go to
56:56
another world. I think we're going to go
56:57
to another system before we hang up
56:58
today, so to speak. We should actually
57:00
talk about maybe what system we want to
57:02
go to next. But pause that for a second.
57:03
One other thing I want to take feedback
57:05
on. The combat to me felt like it had
57:07
gotten a little bit to the shin kicky
57:09
point. I thought we had hit the punch of
57:11
the story and so he didn't have a ton of
57:14
health left. He was dazzled. He was
57:17
losing. He was going crazy. Yeah.
57:20
>> I had him run away and trip and fall in
57:22
the incinerator.
57:23
>> I think I think I didn't and Tyler can
57:26
disagree with me. I didn't feel it
57:28
reached the shin kicky part for me yet.
57:30
I felt like we were still we were still
57:32
doing stuff and yeah, maybe we were
57:34
clowning on him a little bit, but that
57:35
was fun, too. I didn't mind that he fell
57:37
into the into the pit. I was I was like,
57:39
"Ah, I didn't get to use dja vu cuz I
57:42
was planning on using that next." But
57:44
but no, I I didn't feel like it the
57:46
combat didn't feel boring to me at all.
57:48
It felt fun. It felt exciting. Yeah. But
57:51
I'm just a person who my tolerance level
57:53
for combat is maybe higher than most
57:55
people except in Pathfinder 1 where I'm
57:57
just like can this combat be over
57:59
please? I'm so done.
58:00
>> Four hours later.
58:02
>> Try 5 hours. It's just like freak.
58:05
Jesus, man. I'm so done.
58:07
>> Weekend is gone and at the end the guy
58:09
ran away. Are you kidding me?
58:11
>> This guy has so much health. Why does he
58:13
have so much health, Matt? Why? He's
58:16
dead. I I used I used an Uno reverse on
58:18
him. How is he still alive? Just let me
58:20
kill him with the Uno reverse.
58:22
[laughter]
58:23
>> I'm alive. Uno reverso. I'm dead. I I
58:27
thought I thought Book got an absolutely
58:30
flawless cartoon villain death where
58:33
like
58:34
>> Great. It was hilarious.
58:35
>> We We smacked him around a whole bunch
58:37
and then [laughter] he did something
58:39
silly that finished him off and I was
58:41
just like, "Yes, cartoon."
58:43
>> You know what? It was kind of poetic
58:44
because it matched your descriptions of
58:47
how he died, how he remembers dying.
58:49
like fire and yeah, so it worked out
58:51
really beautifully. So I didn't really
58:52
have any complaint. I didn't think the
58:54
combat was too short. I didn't think it
58:55
was too long. I felt it felt it felt
58:57
about the right length
58:58
>> because I was I was nervous in the
59:00
moment. Go ahead. I
59:00
>> I will say I never felt threatened like
59:03
he threw the one blight bomb at the
59:05
beginning of the fight and I think
59:06
that's the only thing he really did.
59:07
>> No, but I didn't mind that. I felt it it
59:10
felt nice to just be in control of the
59:12
situation, especially against a guy who
59:14
felt like he was in control and then
59:15
doing like actually you've activated my
59:18
trap card. There's there can be fun
59:20
stuff in there when you're fighting
59:21
against a person who's obviously
59:23
outclassed by you. It's it can it can be
59:25
fun. Not every combat encounter has to
59:28
be a life or death situation.
59:29
>> True.
59:30
>> Yeah. I I should have spent more time
59:34
preparing, you know, something that
59:37
feels like layer action, something that
59:39
would have made that feel more
59:41
interesting, I guess.
59:42
>> Yeah,
59:43
>> that's the problem is running solo
59:45
monster encounters in Pathfinder 2 is
59:47
really hard because the math just is not
59:50
in their favor. It's something that I
59:52
have tried to I I I've and I've talked
59:55
about this before. That's something I
59:56
had to struggle come to terms with when
59:58
I was writing the West Marches game cuz
1:00:00
the majority of my fights are a party
1:00:02
versus a solo monster. But the way you
1:00:04
do that is you up their level, but even
1:00:07
that's not enough. You you need to up
1:00:09
their level and you need to either give
1:00:11
them like hazards like consistent
1:00:14
hazards that I I've found is like
1:00:16
equivalent to their actions or do what I
1:00:19
did. after they get to 50 50% health,
1:00:22
they enrage and get another turn, which
1:00:24
is essentially like legendary actions.
1:00:26
Um, but yeah, running solo boss
1:00:29
encounters in Pathfinder 2 is not
1:00:31
something that it's built for. In fact,
1:00:33
the highest challenge example that they
1:00:36
offer is a boss and a lack and a
1:00:37
lieutenant. There's no solo threat boss.
1:00:40
The only example they have a solo solo
1:00:42
threat boss is a plus five party level
1:00:45
solo threat encounter. It's meant to be
1:00:47
for the end of the campaign. And if you
1:00:48
don't know what [laughter] that is, a
1:00:50
five an a monster that's five levels
1:00:52
higher than your party is super deadly.
1:00:55
>> It's going to all the time.
1:00:57
>> It's also just not fun. It's not a fun
1:00:59
fight because your party will never hit.
1:01:02
>> They will almost rarely get their spells
1:01:04
to even affect the creature. So, it's
1:01:07
just like I've ran one of those before
1:01:09
and it was a miserable experience. My
1:01:11
players My players were sweet. I was
1:01:13
just like this just feels bad. So during
1:01:16
the combat, I had to like go in and
1:01:18
adjust their AC and their their safety
1:01:20
because I was just like, they're not
1:01:21
hitting. Like you're gonna you're gonna
1:01:23
miss like 75% of the time. It feels
1:01:26
awful.
1:01:27
>> Oh no, that blow knocked off a piece of
1:01:28
his armor. Keep hitting them, folks.
1:01:31
>> Yeah, [laughter] it's it's just Yeah. So
1:01:35
>> seems to have lowered his willpower.
1:01:38
>> Yeah. So solo boss encounters in PF2
1:01:41
aren't really a thing. You have to be
1:01:42
creative about it.
1:01:43
>> Yeah. Cool. I think I I I'm going to
1:01:45
offer this. I think the next time we do
1:01:48
something, I want to I want to do
1:01:50
something pretty combat heavy.
1:01:52
>> Okay.
1:01:53
>> What about we could do Tales of the
1:01:55
Valiant.
1:01:56
>> Yeah.
1:01:56
>> Yeah.
1:01:57
>> Yeah.
1:01:57
>> Yeah. That'd be great. And how would you
1:02:00
feel about doing and and Tyler, I don't
1:02:02
want to take your Doom style combat and
1:02:04
like bring it in here like wholesale,
1:02:06
but how would you feel about doing
1:02:08
something almost like, you know, the end
1:02:10
of Halo Reach style, 300 style, like
1:02:14
your goal as two characters is to
1:02:17
>> I've run sessions like that before and
1:02:19
they're very fun. I had so an evil game
1:02:22
that I was coddming with. We made a a
1:02:25
prologue where the players were a group
1:02:27
of heroes who had to protect this
1:02:29
orphanage from the these evil villains
1:02:32
who were coming in to like capture the
1:02:34
kids and recruit them to their evil
1:02:36
army. And it was a glorious last stand.
1:02:38
They managed to rescue some of the
1:02:40
orphans, but everybody pretty much
1:02:42
everybody died except for like maybe one
1:02:44
or two players. And then the we pitched
1:02:47
to the players, hey, we're going to do a
1:02:48
time skip for the actual campaign. Do
1:02:51
you want to play any of these orphans
1:02:53
that were recruited into the evil army?
1:02:55
And some of them
1:02:56
>> it was great. It was awesome. It was a
1:02:58
great start to the campaign.
1:03:00
>> Yeah, that's actually really awesome.
1:03:02
>> So my my one worry for doing just like
1:03:04
an all combat episode is it might not
1:03:06
make for great podcasting. Like
1:03:08
>> Yeah, that's true. Yeah, like long
1:03:10
grinding combat can be really fun at the
1:03:13
table, but it's just not super fun to
1:03:15
listen to. Like we we'll have that
1:03:17
discussion offline, but I am excited for
1:03:18
Tales of
1:03:19
>> Yeah, we we can we can pitch ideas
1:03:21
offline. Let's not do it here. Okay,
1:03:23
that's fine.
1:03:24
>> I I hear it. I think I think I've got an
1:03:26
idea. All right. Is there anything else
1:03:28
we want to hit in this episode?
1:03:31
>> I think I think we talked about
1:03:32
everything I wanted to touch on.
1:03:33
>> Yeah, same.
1:03:34
>> Okay, cool. In that case,
1:03:37
>> we have a question of the week. This
1:03:38
week, our question of the week comes to
1:03:40
us from Han from the RPGbot. Discord. In
1:03:43
the 2014 rules for the Rogue, the
1:03:44
cunning action class feature states,
1:03:46
"You can take a bonus action on each of
1:03:48
your turns in combat. This action can be
1:03:51
used only to take the dash, disengage,
1:03:54
or hide action." Couldn't this text mean
1:03:56
that in addition to their usual bonus
1:03:57
action, the rogue gets an additional
1:03:59
bonus action that may be used only to
1:04:01
take the dash, disengage, or hide
1:04:03
action? If not, why would the rogu's
1:04:05
bonus action be restricted to only these
1:04:07
three actions? Would giving the rogue
1:04:09
this special extra bonus action ruin the
1:04:11
action economy?
1:04:12
>> I think this just comes to a fundamental
1:04:15
m misunderstanding of the text. So, it's
1:04:18
not saying that your bonus action all
1:04:21
the time is restricted to these actions.
1:04:24
It just means that you can use a bonus
1:04:27
action to dash, disengage, or hide. It's
1:04:30
because those usually take an action.
1:04:32
That's all it's qualified. I agree that
1:04:34
it wasn't exactly stated very well. Like
1:04:36
it seems like you can only use your
1:04:38
bonus action on these things, but what
1:04:40
it's trying to say is like you're taking
1:04:42
these things that are an action that it
1:04:45
can now be treated as a bonus action as
1:04:46
a rogue. I think they could have stated
1:04:48
it a little bit better. It doesn't mean
1:04:49
you get an extra bonus action and it
1:04:51
doesn't mean your bonus action is
1:04:53
limited to these three things. Does that
1:04:56
make sense?
1:04:57
>> Yeah, I I'm going to agree with you.
1:04:58
Like I'll give my take right quick. I
1:05:00
think if if I was sitting at a table
1:05:01
rules lawyering, I might try to rules
1:05:03
lawyer exactly the way that Han is
1:05:05
describing this of like there's two
1:05:07
interpretations. Either I get two and
1:05:08
one of them can be used to do only these
1:05:10
three things. Or the other
1:05:12
interpretation that I think is valid is
1:05:13
is what he offered of like my bonus
1:05:15
action is now somehow limited to these
1:05:17
three things and neither of those is
1:05:19
actually what they meant to say. They
1:05:21
meant to say is exactly what you said.
1:05:23
>> Yeah.
1:05:23
>> So let me let me read from the rules
1:05:25
glossery. So, the the entry for bonus
1:05:28
action. A bonus action is a special
1:05:30
action that you can take on the same
1:05:32
turn that you take an action. You can't
1:05:34
take more than one bonus action on a
1:05:36
turn. And you have a bonus action to
1:05:38
take only if a rule explicitly says so.
1:05:42
So, by default, a character does not
1:05:45
have the ability to take a bonus action,
1:05:47
but specific rules give you the ability
1:05:49
to take a bonus action, such as cunning
1:05:51
action, using two light weapons, things
1:05:54
like that. So cutting action is a way
1:05:58
that you gain the ability to take a
1:06:00
bonus action, but you still only ever
1:06:02
get one bonus action per turn.
1:06:04
>> I see. So what they're trying to I I get
1:06:06
what they're saying now. So usually the
1:06:09
qualifier is in order to take a bonus
1:06:10
action, you have to use an action, which
1:06:12
everybody is everybody does. Everybody
1:06:14
nobody if you're spending your turn
1:06:16
doing no action, it's either for like a
1:06:18
roleplay moment or you're asleep at the
1:06:21
table. I don't I don't know why you
1:06:22
wouldn't use your action,
1:06:24
>> but this way it explicitly says that
1:06:26
even if you don't take an action, you
1:06:28
still get to use this this particular
1:06:31
bonus action. I think that's stupid.
1:06:33
Honestly, [laughter]
1:06:34
>> it is weird that it says you have to
1:06:36
take an action.
1:06:37
>> Yeah, they convoluted it in a way that's
1:06:39
causing this confusion. Just say bonus
1:06:41
actions are always available unless
1:06:43
stated otherwise because yeah, there are
1:06:45
some conditions I know that allow you to
1:06:46
take either a bonus action or an action
1:06:48
but not both. Um, but having a bonus
1:06:52
action should just be the default. It
1:06:53
shouldn't have the qualifier of you need
1:06:55
to take an action because then we get
1:06:56
into this situation and we don't have
1:06:58
the context for that. And people are
1:07:00
confused. They're like, why am I getting
1:07:01
this extra bonus action? Yeah. I I think
1:07:04
what you just read made it clear to me
1:07:05
like my mental model for 5e has always
1:07:07
been like under bonus actions I add all
1:07:10
the possible things that I could do and
1:07:11
so oh I've got a list of seven things I
1:07:13
can do for a bonus action. What you just
1:07:15
clarified is like well that's probably
1:07:16
not exactly the right mental model. like
1:07:18
I have a cunning action bonus action. I
1:07:21
have this bonus action. I can cast a
1:07:23
spell as a bonus action. And so when I
1:07:25
choose, I'm actually choosing to engage
1:07:26
with the cunning action bonus action of
1:07:28
which I can only use these three
1:07:30
actions. Or I'm choosing to use the
1:07:32
spellcasting bonus action to cast a
1:07:34
spell as a bonus action.
1:07:36
>> I'm struggling.
1:07:36
>> It's like a hierarchy instead of a list.
1:07:38
>> Yeah, I'm just I'm struggling to find a
1:07:40
situation where I would not use an
1:07:42
action and only use a bonus action.
1:07:44
>> It would only be if you were denied the
1:07:46
ability to do so. Like if you got hit
1:07:48
with Josh's mind whipped or something,
1:07:50
>> but I'm saying like willingly forgoing
1:07:52
your action.
1:07:53
>> Josh in the chat said he's seen some
1:07:55
situations where no action really made
1:07:57
sense, but a bonus action did. I'd love
1:07:58
to hear some examples, Josh, cuz I'm
1:08:00
struggling to find any examples in my
1:08:03
head.
1:08:03
>> Yeah.
1:08:04
>> And I'm not, this isn't any judgment on
1:08:06
anybody who's done that. I'm just like
1:08:07
I'm I'm I can't figure out a way of when
1:08:11
it makes sense to use an action but not
1:08:13
a bonus action. Uh Josh in a labyrinth
1:08:16
in a labyrinth in combat away from the
1:08:18
monsters.
1:08:20
>> Not sure.
1:08:20
>> You might need to elaborate for us.
1:08:21
>> Yeah, you might need to elaborate on
1:08:23
that for us, [laughter] Josh. But
1:08:24
>> so to go back to the rules text, so I I
1:08:27
think the way that they've worded this
1:08:28
is super weird, saying that you take a
1:08:31
bonus action on the same turn that you
1:08:33
take an action. I think that I think
1:08:35
what they're trying to say is you can
1:08:37
only take a bonus action on your turn. I
1:08:40
don't know why they didn't just say
1:08:42
that. But your turn's when you take an
1:08:43
action and so it's when you take a bonus
1:08:45
action, Tyler. It's pretty obvious.
1:08:47
>> Yeah, obviously. Butviously, but but
1:08:48
they've accidentally introduced this
1:08:51
thing where if you can't take an action
1:08:53
for some reason, like Tasha's mind whiff
1:08:55
or whatever, you also can't take a bonus
1:08:58
action, which is going to create some
1:08:59
like really weird fiddly rules
1:09:02
interactions that aren't good. But the
1:09:04
important part here is you can only take
1:09:06
a bonus action if you have something
1:09:08
that lets you take a bonus action. And
1:09:11
you can only take one bonus action per
1:09:13
turn. So cunning action does not give
1:09:15
you an additional separate bonus action
1:09:18
that you can take. It gives you the
1:09:20
ability to take an your bonus action
1:09:22
using cunning action instead of whatever
1:09:25
else might be available to you.
1:09:27
>> Cool. All right. Feel good.
1:09:28
>> Okay. So Josh clarified wanting to keep
1:09:30
distance and not attack, but do want to
1:09:32
down a potion. And I said, "What about
1:09:34
an an action to dash?" And he said,
1:09:36
"Nohere to dash without engaging the
1:09:37
monsters." Okay. It's a very specific
1:09:40
situation where it's like I don't have
1:09:42
anywhere to run.
1:09:43
>> That's all we asked for.
1:09:44
>> Yeah.
1:09:45
>> Yeah. That's true. [laughter]
1:09:46
>> Yeah. So, again, I guess it exists, but
1:09:49
it's such a niche. It's such a niche
1:09:51
situation. I've never seen that before.
1:09:54
It's wild to me that you have, Josh. But
1:09:56
hey, running I guess you run unique
1:09:59
encounters. So, kudos to you. [laughter]
1:10:02
>> Yeah. I Yeah, I didn't think of that. So
1:10:04
yeah, I guess there's a situation where
1:10:06
you wouldn't use an action, but you'd
1:10:08
use a bonus action. But again, I just
1:10:10
even if that was the case, I still think
1:10:12
it's bogus that if you don't take an
1:10:13
action, you don't get a bonus action.
1:10:15
That seems stupid to me. You should just
1:10:17
get it by default.
1:10:18
>> Yeah, I I don't think anyone's going to
1:10:20
enforce that rule.
1:10:21
>> No, I don't think most people even
1:10:22
realize that rule is a thing.
1:10:24
>> I mean, I didn't until I read it just
1:10:26
now. So like, [laughter]
1:10:28
>> yeah,
1:10:30
>> more sage advice, I hope. Jeez. I mean,
1:10:33
Jeremy Crawford's not anymore.
1:10:36
>> They just started publishing Sage Advice
1:10:37
on D and D Beyond again just in the past
1:10:39
like week or two.
1:10:40
>> Who is doing it? I think
1:10:41
>> they're not saying, which is probably
1:10:43
for the best, honestly.
1:10:44
>> Yeah, that's probably smart.
1:10:46
>> Yeah, it's it's I think it's probably
1:10:48
somebody named Claude.
1:10:50
>> It's probably an intern somewhere.
1:10:52
[laughter] Just like
1:10:53
>> that was Mine was a generative error
1:10:55
joke.
1:10:55
>> Yeah.
1:10:56
>> Oh, Claude. It's Chad. There you go,
1:11:00
>> Josh. Josh in the chat, Mistl is writing
1:11:03
the sage advice. [laughter]
1:11:05
>> It's like kill Mistl two or three times.
1:11:07
I don't remember.
1:11:08
>> Who can say?
1:11:10
>> Ed Greenwood.
1:11:11
>> That's fair. Actually, he can. We should
1:11:13
get him to come tell us.
1:11:14
>> Hill the leisure Illuminati.
1:11:16
>> Hail.
1:11:16
>> Hail.
1:11:17
>> Mistral is an AI. Oh,
1:11:19
>> Mistl with an I, not Mistl with a Y. Got
1:11:21
it. Okay.
1:11:22
>> Yeah.
1:11:23
>> Hail.
1:11:23
>> Hail.
1:11:24
>> I am Randall James. You will find me on
1:11:27
amateurjack.com and on blue sky
1:11:29
grimmoire rpg. I wrote a novela. It's
1:11:32
called Malas. If you're listening to
1:11:33
this, I appreciate that. If you're
1:11:35
listening this is far enough in the
1:11:36
future, there will be an audio book out.
1:11:37
Ash is reading it.
1:11:38
>> Yeah, I should be done I think by the
1:11:41
end of the week. I'm on I've just
1:11:43
recorded chapter 11. So
1:11:45
>> nice. I need to I need I got to figure
1:11:47
out how to publish it.
1:11:49
>> Just go to go to ACX. Um there's there's
1:11:52
a way to do it. It's not super
1:11:54
difficult. Yeah, I believe you can solve
1:11:55
that. Yeah, Audible ACX. But yeah, as
1:11:57
soon as that releases, we'll let
1:11:59
everybody know.
1:12:00
>> Y and then I've got I've got the ISBN.
1:12:02
It's like I've solved that problem. I
1:12:03
bought a pack because I'm an optimist.
1:12:06
[laughter]
1:12:07
>> You're ambitious. You've got goals.
1:12:10
>> Yeah, it's a good book. You should check
1:12:12
it out.
1:12:13
>> Thanks, buddy. [laughter]
1:12:15
>> Uh, I'm Tyler Camper. You'll find me on
1:12:17
rpgbot.net. Uh, blue sky rpgbot.net and
1:12:21
Tik Tok, RPG, B, DOT, NE, and you know,
1:12:26
various other socials, all the big ones,
1:12:28
the slightly smaller ones, the mediumist
1:12:31
ones, all in there. Uh, just search for
1:12:33
RPGbot. Look for the logo.
1:12:35
>> I'm Ashi. You can follow me on Blue Sky,
1:12:38
Graven Ashes. If you want to hire me to
1:12:41
run one of your games, I'm on StartPlay.
1:12:43
I currently am running just announced a
1:12:45
new Vecna Eve of Ruin game on Saturdays.
1:12:48
So, if you ever want to do epic level
1:12:50
5e, come join that. It should be fun.
1:12:52
Still recruiting for Isisles of Zantara
1:12:54
or Isisle of Zantara, my West Marches
1:12:56
PF2 game. Uh, and Dan may or may not
1:12:58
have played or will play an
1:13:00
advertisement during this episode for
1:13:02
it. So, enjoy that. Oh, yes. The aisle
1:13:05
of Xandar, a savage little island
1:13:07
brimming with monsters the size of
1:13:09
taverns and teeth like blessed sabers. I
1:13:12
I once wrestled a jungle wyvern with not
1:13:15
but a dagger and a bad attitude. Join
1:13:18
this glorious expedition. Slay beasts,
1:13:20
unear ancient relics, and try not to be
1:13:23
eaten or worse, be nourished, the aisle
1:13:25
of Zantara. Bring your blade, your
1:13:28
brains, and a clean pair of trousers.
1:13:30
Hey adventurers, Ash here. If you've
1:13:32
been enjoying this episode, please join
1:13:34
my West Marches style Pathfinder 2e game
1:13:37
over on Blue Sky, graven ashes.
1:13:42
You'll find the link to the Discord
1:13:44
pinned in my profile. join now and come
1:13:47
and hang out with us. [laughter]
1:13:49
>> Hope you did.
1:13:50
>> Yeah,
1:13:50
>> I hope you did.
1:13:52
>> All right, this is the part of the
1:13:53
episode where I encourage you to rate
1:13:55
and review content creators that you
1:13:56
enjoy. This is a podcast. We do this a
1:13:59
couple times a week. We enjoy hanging
1:14:00
out with you. We hope you enjoy
1:14:02
listening to us. If you were to rate and
1:14:03
review us, then we would know that you
1:14:05
enjoyed listening to us. And that feels
1:14:06
well, way better than guessing. You know
1:14:08
what I mean? The other thing you could
1:14:09
do,
1:14:12
the [laughter] other thing you could do
1:14:12
is you can you can subscribe. You can
1:14:15
steal your loved ones devices and you
1:14:17
can subscribe on their devices too.
1:14:19
They'll appreciate it or they won't. I
1:14:21
don't really care. Just do it. There are
1:14:23
affiliate links for source books and
1:14:24
other materials linked in the show notes
1:14:25
as well as on rbgbot.net. Following
1:14:27
these links helps us to make this show
1:14:29
happen every week. If your question
1:14:30
should be the question of the week next
1:14:32
week, please email podcast rbgbot.net or
1:14:34
message us on blue sky at rbgbot.net.
1:14:36
Please also consider supporting us on
1:14:38
Patreon, where you'll find all kinds of
1:14:39
great [music] rewards. Any at any tier,
1:14:41
you'll get early access to rpgbot.com
1:14:42
and polls for future content. At our $3
1:14:44
tiers, you'll enjoy [music] your choice
1:14:45
of adree access to rpgbot.net or add
1:14:48
free podcast episodes and access to live
1:14:50
stream podcast recordings. At our $5
1:14:52
tiers and above, you'll get all of that
1:14:53
plus access to the rpgbot. [music]
1:14:55
You'll find us at patreon.com/rpgbot.
1:14:58
Want a cool shirt, maybe a cool sticker?
1:14:59
Visit the RPGbot.store. Do you want
1:15:02
RPGbot in your email inbox often? May I
1:15:04
suggest to you the RPGbot.nnewsletter?
1:15:06
newsletter at rpgbot.net/newsletter.
1:15:10
>> I'm sorry. I need to stop everything.
1:15:12
You own dicegoblin.net
1:15:14
and you have no idea what to do with it.
1:15:17
Are you stupid?
1:15:19
>> He had a really good idea.
1:15:20
>> Make rpgbot branded dice or something.
1:15:24
>> No. No. What was the original idea?
1:15:27
>> Just It was probably just going to be
1:15:28
like a dice review site or something,
1:15:30
but I don't have time for that.
1:15:32
>> Baked dice. Just
1:15:35
>> No.
1:15:36
Do you know how
1:15:37
>> you don't need to have time? You hire a
1:15:39
company to make dice for you, man. It
1:15:41
doesn't take that much.
1:15:44
>> You could make a bank. Dice goblin is
1:15:46
great. It's premium real estate and
1:15:48
you're not using it. I know. I've sat on
1:15:51
the domain. Look, look, if if somebody
1:15:54
has big dreams of like doing something
1:15:59
cool with DICE, like as a blog or
1:16:01
whatever, I don't know, message me
1:16:03
rpgbot at rpgbot.net. Like, I'm willing
1:16:06
to let the domain go to someone who's
1:16:08
going to do something with it. I just
1:16:10
don't want to become freaking parking
1:16:12
lot, man. I hate when that happens. It's
1:16:14
depressing.
1:16:15
>> The fact that you own Dice Goblin, just
1:16:18
don't do anything with it. Let me tell
1:16:20
you the Let me tell you the story of how
1:16:22
I ended up with this domain name because
1:16:24
even stupid.
1:16:24
>> Please, please tell us the story.
1:16:26
>> So, we're driving back from Gen Con.
1:16:29
Randall, me, Amy, Danielle. So, Randall
1:16:32
and I, and our wives, we're driving back
1:16:33
from Gen Con. I can't even remember the
1:16:35
context of the conversation, but it it
1:16:38
was something like,
1:16:39
>> "No, why does he always froze?
1:16:42
>> Why does he Why do you always freeze
1:16:44
when your story is getting
1:16:45
>> climax?" The climax. All right. So,
1:16:48
we're talking about how nice dice are.
1:16:50
We're talking about how like we could
1:16:51
say nice things about dice on the
1:16:52
internet to people. And like that could
1:16:54
be a whole thing. And I explained the
1:16:56
concept of dice goblins. And I'm sure
1:16:59
someone made a joke about like that's
1:17:01
Tyler's next big thing, dicegoblin.net.
1:17:04
And Amy said, "Don't tempt him. He'll
1:17:05
have a whole business running by the
1:17:07
time we get home." And I took that as a
1:17:09
challenge.
1:17:10
>> You bought it as a meme on the way.
1:17:12
>> Yes.
1:17:13
>> Get in here. Tell him he's stupid for
1:17:15
not using this. [laughter]
1:17:17
>> Okay. I I think it was the second Gen
1:17:19
Con in a row and probably like the
1:17:20
fourth or fifth convention in a row
1:17:22
where like Amy had bought a brand new
1:17:24
dice set and they were beautiful and
1:17:26
gorgeous and we were joking about it's
1:17:27
like let's just empty the china cabinet
1:17:29
and let's just have the dice on display
1:17:32
and then I think that's where Tyler went
1:17:33
dice goblin.
1:17:34
>> Wait, wait, wait.
1:17:35
>> Yeah.
1:17:36
>> See, Dan Dan knows how to monetize it.
1:17:38
Dan is like your your goat, man.
1:17:41
>> I do know how to do that. We do actually
1:17:44
have I have someone who has offered to
1:17:46
do RPGbot branded dice for us before and
1:17:50
like it it hasn't happened like
1:17:52
>> see that's what I'm saying. You don't
1:17:53
need to do it yourself. Just just
1:17:55
outsource it to someone. [laughter]
1:17:58
>> Have them put on RPG RPG branded dice.
1:18:02
You get a cut. You literally have to do
1:18:04
nothing. You own premium real estate.
1:18:06
They're doing nothing with it.
1:18:07
[laughter]
1:18:08
>> Folks folks can't hear Dan. So Dan just
1:18:10
said I could be the Tiffany's of dice.
1:18:12
I'm like, I [laughter]
1:18:14
my wife is going to hear that, Dan. My
1:18:16
wife is going to hear that. She's going
1:18:18
to get thoughts.
1:18:19
>> Yes. My wife, your daughter.
1:18:21
>> Yeah.
1:18:22
>> You two are related.
1:18:23
>> What? We've said this on the podcast.
1:18:25
Dan is my father-in-law, folks.
1:18:27
>> If you're listening, if you're listening
1:18:28
to this, please yell him yell at him
1:18:30
about this cuz he can be making Do you
1:18:33
realize how lucrative Do you realize how
1:18:35
lucrative dice are? It's like the one
1:18:37
It's like the one thing in in the
1:18:39
tabletop hobby that makes bang. Like
1:18:42
people always want dice.
1:18:44
>> Tyler, is any hearing this right now and
1:18:46
saying, "Oh, we could do something
1:18:48
lucrative or Tyler doesn't need another
1:18:50
hobby." That one.
1:18:51
>> Okay. [laughter]
1:18:52
>> Again, outsourcing. You don't have to do
1:18:55
any work. You just have to put your
1:18:57
brand on it. That's it. It's all you
1:18:58
need to do. Literally, there's no
1:19:00
effort.
1:19:01
>> I'm at this special point in life where
1:19:02
like I'm like, "Danielle, I have a
1:19:04
really great idea." And she's like, I
1:19:05
don't have to say what it is. I don't
1:19:06
have to like call it out. The first
1:19:08
words it'll be, it's like, okay, you
1:19:09
have an idea. When do you have time for
1:19:10
this idea? [laughter]
1:19:13
>> All right. When Dan's wait, do you want
1:19:17
me to say that? Yes. You want us to say
1:19:18
that?
1:19:19
>> Yeah, we'll say that.
1:19:20
>> So, if anybody out there in
1:19:21
manufacturing would like to discuss
1:19:23
this, message Dan RPGbot.net. That's D-
1:19:28
Dan. You can spell Dan at rpgbot.net.
1:19:31
>> [laughter]
1:19:32
>> God, what have I done this?
1:19:34
>> I'm so disappointed in you right now. I
1:19:36
can't even look at you.
1:19:39
>> Jesus Christ.
1:19:40
>> Just I've known I've known that this was
1:19:42
available for years. If you want to, you
1:19:44
[laughter] can aim some of that at me,
1:19:46
too.
1:19:47
>> All right.
1:19:48
I'm speechless. I'm I'm speechless.
1:19:51
That's just what I am.
1:19:52
>> H All right, folks. Let's call it there
1:19:55
before I commit to anything else time
1:19:57
consuming. [laughter]
1:19:59
Oh,
1:19:59
>> hi. Have a good night, everybody.
Games

