ABBERATIONS: Nothing says 'Fun Game Night' like Psychic Trauma! - RPGBOT.Podcast S5E65
Sep 21, 2026
In this episode, the RPGBOT.Podcast team delves into the weird, the squishy, and the utterly incomprehensible world of Aberrations—those delightful horrors that break the rules of reality and challenge players’ expectations. From Mind Flayers to Gibbering Mouthers, the hosts explore how these creatures can be used to discomfort, disorient, and delight your game table. Whether you’re looking to run a horror campaign, design a disturbing encounter, or just want to terrify your players with something that doesn’t have a front or back, this episode will help you lean into the madness.
This episode originally aired on May 30th, 2025, and we're currently working to upload our episode backlog. For the latest from the RPGBOT.Podcast, find us in your favorite podcatcher.
Full show notes for this episode are available on RPGBOT.net: https://rpgbot.net/abberations-nothing-says-fun-game-night-like-psychic-trauma-rpgbot-podcast-s5e65/
Find us on socials and stuff:
🦋 https://bsky.app/profile/rpgbot.bsky.social
⏰ https://www.tiktok.com/@rpgbotdotnet
🔍 https://RPGBOT.net/
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
A massive shape rises slowly from the
0:02
water's surface, larger than any
0:04
creature you had thought possible. The
0:06
leechlike face has three inky black eyes
0:10
stacked above a jawless mouth filled
0:12
with serrated teeth. Long tentacles
0:15
lined with barbs detach and uncoil from
0:17
its body. One longer than the rest ends
0:20
in a fish tail. It navigates through the
0:22
waters effortlessly [clears throat]
0:24
and lowers its gaze to look directly
0:26
into your eyes, overwhelming you with
0:29
its ancient presence. This description
0:32
called Meeting an Ancient Abalith is
0:34
from Describe. Ready roleplay. Go to
0:36
describe.com/rpgbot
0:38
and use code RPGbot 5 to get $5 off your
0:42
first subscription [music] purchase.
0:45
Welcome to the RPGbot. Podcast. I'm
0:47
Randall James, your jippering mouth
0:49
breather, and with me is Tyler Camstra.
0:51
Hi everybody. And Ashili.
0:57
Oh no.
0:59
>> How many times have you rehearsed that?
1:02
>> Absolutely none.
1:03
>> It just rolls off the tongue.
1:04
>> Good. [laughter]
1:05
>> It's gibberish. It's gibberish. Don't
1:07
come at me.
1:08
>> It's speech.
1:09
>> It's all gibberish.
1:10
>> It's It's fine. Yeah.
1:11
>> Yeah. The only difference between
1:13
gibberish and fine literature is what's
1:15
published on the page.
1:16
>> Yep. Pretty much.
1:18
>> All right, Tyler. What is happening?
1:19
Well, tonight we're going to talk about
1:21
aberrations. So, we had a lot of fun
1:23
with our two-part series on undead. So,
1:25
we wanted to do kind of the same thing
1:27
for some other creature types. So, we're
1:29
starting with aberrations next. Now,
1:31
aberrations are maybe a little harder to
1:34
explain than undead. Like, undead are
1:36
things that were dead but now aren't.
1:37
Again, aberrations are a little more
1:40
far-fetched, a little crazy.
1:42
>> They're weird. You You could just say
1:43
that like they're they're freaking
1:45
weird.
1:46
>> That That feels like a great way to
1:47
describe them. uh like a creature type
1:49
freaking weird.
1:50
>> Yeah, you run into something and it's
1:51
not like a larger version of something
1:53
or an angrier version of something. It's
1:55
not something it's not something you've
1:57
ever seen. [laughter]
2:00
>> I believe Randall, you have a definition
2:01
of what aberrations.
2:03
>> I [laughter] I I sure do. I was trying
2:05
to figure out what this had to do with
2:06
optics and so I figured, okay, let's go
2:08
to the internet and figure out what
2:09
actually happened. So, an aberration, a
2:11
departure from what is normal, usual, or
2:13
expected. Typically, one that is
2:15
unwelcome. And I would say, yeah,
2:17
typically aberrations in Dn D extremely
2:21
unwelcome.
2:21
>> Yeah.
2:22
>> Since aberration is such like a a broad
2:25
term, if you're ever confused as to
2:27
whether a creature should be classified
2:29
as an aberration or not, if it has
2:31
tentacles, there's a good to fair chance
2:33
it's an aberration.
2:34
>> Yeah, I'm racking my brain trying to
2:36
think of a like nonan animal thing with
2:40
tentacles that's not an aberration. It's
2:42
like chew, which are like the crab dudes
2:45
with tentacle mouths, but no, those are
2:46
an aberration.
2:47
>> Those are an aberration. Yep.
2:49
>> Yeah. Dang. Tentacles are just
2:50
>> Not all aberrations have tentacles, but
2:52
all creatures that have tentacles are
2:53
aberrations. Unless they're an octopus.
2:56
>> No, actually,
2:57
>> even octopus. Those things are like
2:59
wildly brilliant. Extremely creepy.
3:02
>> Yeah, but not according to Dn D is what
3:04
I mean. [laughter]
3:04
>> Fair.
3:05
>> Okay.
3:07
>> Actually, that's a great question. I
3:08
guess a giant octopus is in the Monster
3:10
Manual, isn't it?
3:11
>> It is. Yes. Okay.
3:12
>> Yes. But when they say giant octopus,
3:14
they mean like giant giant, not like
3:16
weighs 100 lb and lives in the Puget
3:19
Sound. Like not that kind of giant.
3:21
>> Those are also terrifying. Beautiful.
3:22
Wonderful. Terrifying.
3:24
>> Cuttlefish. Cuttlefish are weird. They
3:26
aberate.
3:27
>> Or if you really want to look give
3:28
yourself some nightmares, look up
3:30
Colossal Squid. Size comparisons. Have a
3:33
pleasant dream.
3:34
>> Yeah, there's a reason people believe in
3:36
Kraken. Uh,
3:38
>> all right. So, so I have here written in
3:40
the show notes. Nothing specifically
3:42
about tentacles, but yeah, that's pretty
3:44
good. My favorite thing about
3:45
aberrations is they very frequently have
3:47
a super weird diet. So, like undead will
3:50
do things like eat your body, eat your
3:52
brains, eat your soul, things like that.
3:54
Aberrations will feed on frequently more
3:57
abstract things like they can be fed by
3:59
fear or they can feed on psychic energy
4:01
or things like that. Mind flares
4:03
famously eat brains, which doesn't feel
4:05
like enough to sustain a creature of
4:07
their size, but it seems to work for
4:08
them. So, what do I know?
4:09
>> It's also creepier for some reason than
4:12
you know the the classic zombie thing is
4:14
they want brains, but for some reason
4:16
it's creepier with the mind flares
4:19
because they're an intelligent species
4:20
that craves brains.
4:22
>> Yeah. [laughter]
4:23
>> So, they have a better ch they have an
4:24
actual chance of getting out your brain.
4:26
>> Yeah. I think the fact that it's not
4:28
like an instinct thing that I must have
4:30
brains, but it's like I think I'm going
4:32
to gorge on your brains today like that.
4:34
Yeah. That's terrifying.
4:35
>> Yeah. Hannibal Lectar. Fantastic
4:37
example. Extremely intelligent. Very
4:39
creepy when he wanted to eat my skull.
4:41
>> Mhm.
4:41
>> Yeah. A little bit. [laughter]
4:43
>> This entire race of Hannibal Lectctors.
4:45
>> Yeah.
4:45
>> Oh,
4:46
>> with cooler facial hair.
4:48
>> Um, [laughter]
4:49
what you call tentacles facial hair?
4:52
>> I Well, do you trim them? If not, I
4:54
guess not.
4:54
>> No, I don't think so. [laughter]
4:57
>> What a beard.
4:58
>> I want to see a handlebar tentacle.
5:01
>> You know what? just for that. Someday
5:03
I'm going to pay someone to draw me a
5:05
mind flare with like waxed handlebar
5:08
tentacle situation.
5:09
>> You know, this is a little bit off
5:11
topic, but there is a creature in the
5:13
extended universe of Star Wars called
5:15
the true Sith who have these
5:17
tendril-like things that form facial
5:20
hair. It's very weird.
5:21
>> The like weird fleshy mustache thing.
5:23
>> Yep. Mhm.
5:24
>> Yeah. They're like catfish whiskers.
5:26
>> Yeah.
5:26
>> Very strange.
5:28
>> I don't like that. [laughter]
5:32
Just ju a content warning for people.
5:36
Theophobia is probably going to be a big
5:39
trigger in this episode because a lot of
5:41
aberrations come from HP Lovecraft who
5:45
was famously very scared of fishy things
5:48
and that kind of translates into how
5:51
aberrations are depicted into Dn D. I
5:54
don't know why so many pe whyophobia is
5:56
such a common fear that we ascribe it to
5:59
something that's alien or weird or
6:01
terrifying, but it is. Also, body horror
6:04
is going to be another big thing. So,
6:06
>> yeah.
6:07
>> Yeah, it this may not be the most
6:10
comfortable episode for you if you
6:12
suffer from either of these.
6:13
>> Fair. [laughter]
6:15
>> Hey, Randall, I'm going to give you a
6:16
new fear real quick. Hey, look over your
6:18
shoulder. Do you see all those angles
6:19
right there? like the the right angle of
6:21
your wall and that shelf and the
6:23
ceiling, all those angles.
6:25
>> I sure do, buddy. My house is not made
6:27
of circles.
6:28
>> Okay, so I'm gonna read you one
6:29
sentence. Those pursued can escape only
6:32
by avoiding all angles as hounds of
6:35
Tindelos could step through them from
6:37
nothingness at any time.
6:38
>> I mean, I I think you're just you're
6:40
you're you're out of luck.
6:42
>> Yeah, like [laughter]
6:43
angles just exist in the world.
6:46
>> Yeah. Yeah. I'm Reynold James. You'll
6:47
find me in a dribble ball fleeing down
6:49
the hill. [laughter]
6:51
>> I guess you Yeah, I guess you have to
6:52
exist in a circular room. A completely
6:54
circular room.
6:55
>> Yeah. So, aberrations will also
6:57
frequently say like, "Hey,
6:58
[clears throat] you know how physics
6:59
works?" Nah.
7:01
>> Yeah.
7:01
>> Uh like the hounds of Tindalos are from
7:04
kind of the extended Cthulhu mythos. I
7:07
guess Ash, you had an answer for this
7:08
one on me like before the episode. So,
7:10
so the thing that you have to understand
7:12
about the L Cthulu mythos and this is
7:15
just in general about the Kala Cthulhu
7:18
monster manual. HP Lovecraft wasn't that
7:20
creative. Like he didn't like he was a
7:22
creative guy, but he you're going to go
7:24
through the monster manual and be like,
7:26
"Did he come up with all of this?" No,
7:28
he did not. He came up with like maybe a
7:30
handful of that stuff, but because his
7:33
work was so unpopular during his time,
7:35
one of his friends approached him and
7:36
asked if he could contribute to the lore
7:38
or mythos. And HP Lovecraft was like,
7:40
"Yeah, I don't care about it anyway."
7:42
And he basically opened up the rights to
7:43
his universe when he before he died. And
7:46
so after he died, his mythos exploded in
7:49
popularity because anybody who had a pen
7:53
could basically contribute to this
7:55
mythos. So that's why you get some
7:57
really weird creative stuff from all
8:00
different disperate authors that
8:02
Chaosium just sort of gathered up into
8:04
one monster manual. So if you're if
8:07
you've if you're pretty familiar with HP
8:09
Lovecraft and you go into Call of
8:10
Cthulhu expecting to know exactly what
8:12
you're facing, you're going to be
8:13
unpleasantly surprised. [laughter]
8:17
>> I feel like open sourcing your content
8:18
and letting people extend it for the
8:20
greater good of a community is a lesson
8:22
that I have never heard.
8:23
>> Mhm. [laughter]
8:25
>> Although caveat there, he did die
8:27
penniless, unknown, and miserable. So
8:30
[laughter]
8:31
>> I guess there's another lesson to take
8:33
from there as well. But the community is
8:35
doing great.
8:36
>> Yes. Look,
8:37
>> it's thriving.
8:38
>> If only there was some some sort of
8:40
license, perhaps one that was open and
8:42
specifically supported gaming. I wonder
8:45
if that would ever work.
8:46
>> I feel like it could.
8:48
>> We might be on to something. We should
8:49
find lawyers.
8:50
>> We can We can dream our pipe dream.
8:52
>> Yeah. [laughter] All right. Moving on
8:54
from the five-part episode series on the
8:56
open gaming license [laughter] again.
8:58
>> Oh jeez. [snorts]
9:01
>> Yeah, that that's an aberration. Okay.
9:03
>> Yeah. All right. Hey,
9:05
>> unusual. Unwelcome.
9:06
>> So, here's a trivia question. What is
9:07
the difference between monstrosities and
9:09
aberrations?
9:10
>> Okay. I'm going to go with my prayer
9:12
definition. If it's a large or angrier
9:14
version of a thing that seems like a
9:15
normal thing, monstrosity. If it is
9:17
unlike anything you've ever seen before
9:19
and can barely be described or
9:20
comprehended, aberration.
9:22
>> I mean, yeah, that seems to work pretty
9:24
well. What if I What if I took three
9:26
different animals and like glued bits of
9:28
them together? Monstrosity or
9:30
aberration?
9:31
>> Absolutely. Monstrosity. Yeah. What do
9:32
we We got our manacor. We got our sphinx
9:35
chimera.
9:35
>> Turduck. [laughter]
9:39
>> It's a monstrosity. People love it. It's
9:41
delicious. [laughter]
9:42
>> I think the difference is monstrosity is
9:44
and when we do our episode on
9:46
monstrosity, it's going to be a
9:47
nightmare because monstrosity feels like
9:50
the catchall term that Wizards of Coast
9:52
came up with that. What is this? I don't
9:54
know. Let's put it as a monstrosity.
9:56
[laughter] It's not a beast. It's not an
9:58
aberration. It's not fay. Let's just put
10:01
it into monstrosity. Yeah, like it's
10:03
it's native to the material plane. It's
10:05
clearly not natural monstrosity.
10:07
>> Yeah, it totally makes sense and is not
10:09
at all weird that mimics are in the same
10:12
category as chimeas and yuanti. That
10:15
makes total sense.
10:16
>> Yeah, [laughter] especially since their
10:18
natural form is literally a pile of
10:20
ooze.
10:21
>> Mhm.
10:22
>> Yeah.
10:23
>> Yeah. Yeah. They are not naturally
10:24
shaped like treasure chests.
10:26
>> No. I mean, I guess that makes sense.
10:28
>> Yeah. What?
10:29
>> All right. So, so we've hit on a few
10:31
easy examples, but like if you're
10:33
racking your brain and thinking like I
10:35
have opened a monster manual, but you
10:37
can't remember any aberrations. Anything
10:39
from Cthulhu, anything Cthulhu adjacent,
10:41
definitely an aberration. Gibbering
10:43
mouththers are one of the like lower
10:45
level iconic aberrations. Like take a
10:48
think like a pile of hamburger with
10:49
teeth and eyeballs.
10:51
>> Yeah. I mean, they're basically Yagso is
10:53
what they are. If anybody is familiar
10:55
with Kulu, [laughter]
10:56
>> God bless you.
10:59
>> Yeah. So
11:00
>> I mean like every every aberration that
11:02
we're going to talk about has like a
11:04
Cthulhu equivalent. So Jerry Mother's
11:06
Yagso and Kuatoas deep ones and Deon
11:11
minders mind flares are probably pretty
11:15
unique to to Dn D. Okay.
11:17
>> Um but it's mostly it's I would say
11:19
actually no. You know what? I take it
11:21
back. It's Cthulhu. It's 100% Cthulu.
11:23
>> Oh yeah. Okay. Are aren't mind players
11:25
and beholders the two aberrations that
11:28
Dn D swears up and down. Absolutely.
11:30
These are ours and if anybody else
11:32
touches I'll kill you.
11:34
>> Yeah, they can say that. All they did
11:36
was they shrunk down Cthulhu and took
11:38
away his wings. That's it.
11:39
>> Okay. [laughter]
11:41
>> Yeah. Beholders. Sure. I'll give them
11:44
beholders. I From what I understand,
11:47
Gary Kyak I don't know if this is true
11:49
or not. Gary Gyax got it from like
11:51
looking at his son's soccer ball or
11:52
something.
11:53
>> [laughter]
11:56
>> What if those were eyeballs?
11:57
>> Yeah.
11:58
>> I mean, he he came up with a lot of
11:59
iconic monsters from like dollar store
12:02
plastic toys. Like, you'd go in and you
12:05
buy like a dollar store bag of monsters.
12:07
Like, what is this? And you have no
12:09
idea. And it's just some like plastic
12:10
reject toy, turned it into a D and D
12:12
monster, and that's how we got Rust
12:14
monsters.
12:14
>> Yep. Yep. Next up, [laughter]
12:16
>> another cool set of operations. The
12:19
slotty. Is that
12:20
>> Yeah.
12:20
>> So, that's the plural. There's
12:22
>> that is the plural. Yeah.
12:24
>> Okay. So, a single slud, a group of
12:26
slotty.
12:27
>> There's a cool what's the word I'm
12:29
looking for? Like, you know, how do they
12:30
reproduce? How do they live in society?
12:32
Uh, ecology.
12:33
>> Perfect. Yeah. There's an awesome like
12:35
ecology description. So, if you wanted
12:37
to, you could have like either a short
12:39
like oneshot all about SLO. You could
12:42
have an entire campaign engrossed in the
12:44
culture of the slottie. Evil frog people
12:47
who come in multiple colors from limbo
12:50
reproduced by Lego is in you.
12:53
>> Yeah.
12:54
>> Remember what I said about body horror
12:56
being a thing? Yeah, that's what I was
12:58
thinking about the slide.
13:00
>> What's also interesting about about
13:02
aberrations, another distinguishing
13:04
feature that distinguishes them from
13:06
monstrosities is most if not all of them
13:09
are evil aligned. There's one exception
13:11
which I believe is the flumps. Flumps
13:13
are not evil.
13:15
>> Those are the only ones that are not
13:16
evil aligned. And I love flumps.
13:17
[laughter] Uh but what's also great
13:19
about aberrations is that you know we
13:21
talked about undead last last time and
13:25
we set out a challenge to be like how
13:27
can you make a game around this type of
13:29
undead? You can do that really easily
13:32
with every single aberration. You could
13:34
make an entire game just focused on that
13:36
kind of aberration. Like you could make
13:38
an entire game focused around kuatoas,
13:40
beholders, mind flares. Really fun.
13:44
Slade, abalis. Absolutely. You could
13:47
even make one focused around flumps cuz
13:50
why not?
13:52
>> I'd say you could probably do that for
13:53
like the bigger, more iconic
13:55
aberrations. There are some smaller
13:57
aberrations that are kind of dumb. Like
14:00
there's one from Spell Jammer that's
14:01
literally like it it is a beach ball
14:03
with bird feet. [laughter]
14:06
Uh, it is it is called, I kid you not, a
14:09
goon ball.
14:11
>> Okay. They're not all of them. They're
14:12
[laughter] not all winners. A vast
14:15
majority of them you could use for
14:17
something as like [laughter] a main
14:18
>> Okay, I have a I have another challenge
14:20
for you. So, I was looking ahead of
14:22
time. Every aberration that I looked at
14:24
had relatively high intelligence and
14:27
wisdom. Are there any that are actually
14:29
dumb?
14:30
>> I think givering mouththers are pretty
14:32
dumb. Caring crawlers are basically
14:34
bugs. So, I misspoke. I was thinking
14:37
this whole time that kuatoa were
14:38
aberrations, but they're not.
14:40
>> Oh, yeah. We're going to They should be
14:42
fish.
14:43
>> They absolutely should be. I thought
14:45
they were.
14:46
>> Mhm. For folks at home, remind them what
14:48
a kuatoa is.
14:49
>> A kuoa is a fish person. And the reason
14:52
why I would argue that they should be an
14:54
aberration is because they are very
14:56
clearly modeled after the iconic HP
14:59
Lovecraft monster called Deep Ones,
15:01
which if you've ever heard of or read
15:03
the book Shadow of Insouth, that's where
15:06
the Deep Ones come from. And like even
15:08
their ability to create gods through
15:11
group think, that is a thing deep ones
15:13
can do as well.
15:14
>> So yeah, it's very surprising that
15:16
they're not classified as aberations.
15:18
>> Wait, what are they then? deepest. Oh.
15:21
Oh, they're Coto, I think, are
15:22
humanoids, right?
15:23
>> They are.
15:23
>> Yeah.
15:24
>> Okay. All right. I get that makes sense
15:26
in the sense that they are humanoid fish
15:27
monsters, right?
15:28
>> Yeah. Like if you if you look at the 5e
15:30
monster manual art, take like a humanoid
15:33
in like commoner's rags, but like you
15:37
transformed them halfway into a sardine
15:40
and they were excited about it. Like cuz
15:42
the pose is just like they look ready to
15:44
go. They're like I'm excited for what's
15:46
about to happen in the picture. Like
15:49
they're not
15:49
>> That's just how fish look.
15:51
>> That is just how fish look. Yeah.
15:54
[snorts and laughter]
15:54
>> Um Yeah. No, that they would absolutely
15:56
terrify HP Lovecraft.
15:58
>> Yeah.
15:58
>> But [laughter]
16:00
yeah, I mean I get it on the one hand
16:02
because I guess you know give these
16:04
people like actual agency and you know
16:07
not say these things are aberrant just
16:10
because they're different from us which
16:11
I get. don't want to lean into those
16:13
problematic stuff. But I mean, and also
16:16
you have to go back getting into the
16:18
weeds here, but like the deep ones were
16:21
really just HP Love's Crafts being like,
16:23
"White trash people are dirty."
16:27
>> Yeah, we're white people are dirty.
16:30
>> Yeah,
16:31
>> cuz Lovecraft had some problematic
16:33
thoughts of his own.
16:34
>> He did indeed. I have some problematic
16:35
thoughts.
16:36
>> We're going to sidestep those. Okay. I
16:38
guess one distinguishing feature. So,
16:39
Kuatoa, they live in a society, right?
16:41
little little fish person societies.
16:43
>> They sure do. It's it's mostly
16:46
theoccratic and it's got some weird
16:48
rules. They're led by arch priests and
16:51
uh so you remember me saying how
16:53
aberrations frequently disagree with
16:55
physics. So Kuotoa get to disagree with
16:57
how religion works and how divine magic
16:59
works because Kuotoa arch priests can
17:01
grant cleric powers to other Quotoa.
17:04
>> Well, if they can use belief to create
17:06
gods, then why not, right?
17:07
>> Yeah, that's fair. [laughter]
17:08
>> The Kua are just so cool. And I think
17:11
they would be a great race for a player
17:14
to play.
17:15
>> Mhm.
17:16
Yeah. The next campaign.
17:18
>> They do have some kind of a weird taste
17:20
in dies though. Like their most famous
17:22
one is Glibdul Pulp, who is literally
17:24
just a statue of a naked woman with
17:26
lobster claws.
17:27
>> Yeah. And
17:29
>> her name is essentially, if you're
17:32
wondering why her name is so weird, it's
17:34
supposed to be the sound of water
17:36
dripping.
17:36
>> That sounds right.
17:37
>> Yeah. [laughter]
17:39
off the giant lobster claws into the
17:40
water.
17:41
>> Mhm.
17:43
[laughter]
17:44
>> All right. So, so let's talk about using
17:46
aberrations from a DMG GM perspective
17:49
cuz you know that chances are if you're
17:52
bringing an aberration into the game,
17:54
you are most likely the person running
17:56
the game because players don't really
17:58
have a ton of options for just like I
18:00
would like an aberration to be here now,
18:02
please. Can I have an abalith as a
18:04
familiar? What kind of game are you
18:05
running?
18:06
>> [laughter]
18:07
>> Yeah, if if you are able to just summon
18:10
an aberration, you're not running
18:12
aberrations, right?
18:13
>> I [laughter] I mean, there is literally
18:15
a spell in five
18:16
>> and I don't I don't like it. I don't
18:18
like it. I think that spell should not
18:20
exist.
18:21
>> What I look I want my pet slod that I
18:24
can summon and walk around with and it's
18:27
got regeneration so I can throw it into
18:29
traps. It's like ah I am injured and
18:30
like you're fine. I've got an hour of
18:32
you.
18:33
>> Yeah. Yeah, we're replacing the log
18:34
rogue with the slotty slot. [laughter]
18:36
>> I think if you if if you want to use
18:38
summon aberration, it can only summon
18:40
flumps and that's it. [laughter]
18:44
>> I don't think that's even one of the
18:45
options.
18:47
Why is it not? I don't know. [laughter]
18:50
All right. So, so we talked a bit about
18:52
this already, but aberrations are super
18:54
weird. So, I mean, that alone is
18:56
frequently enough to justify using
18:58
aberrations because they're so weird. So
19:01
you can take what is a fairly normal
19:03
like peaceful pastoral situation. You're
19:05
like, "Ah, yes, you've lived here in
19:07
peace for 10, 20, 30 years in this
19:10
quaint village and all of a sudden one
19:12
day physics stops working the way you
19:14
think it should and you should probably
19:16
figure out why that has happened to
19:18
you." It also is just really useful for
19:22
turning a game into more of like a
19:24
darker horror sort of vibe because I
19:28
mean a lot of times aberrations are
19:31
classified as evil which is maybe an
19:33
oversimplification. They just have
19:35
they're operating on a different level
19:37
of intelligence than we are and their
19:40
their intentions to us feel like evil
19:43
because they could care about us less.
19:45
they couldn't care about us less and
19:47
we're just like sort of scraps off their
19:49
plate sort of thing. So, it's a way to
19:51
turn sort of take that cosmic core
19:54
deeper darker conspiracy running the
19:57
world creepiness to the next level.
19:59
>> Yeah, aberrations are also really really
20:02
easy to introduce to a lot of games.
20:04
Like, yeah, you can definitely take that
20:06
pivot to horror, to cosmic horror by
20:09
adding aberrations. They frequently come
20:11
from other planes of existence, other
20:14
dimensions, places that are very
20:16
difficult for humanoids to get to most
20:18
of the time, which makes it really easy
20:21
for them to just pop into existence when
20:23
it's plot convenient. And the players
20:24
can be like, "Where did they come from?"
20:26
And the GM can say, "Who knows? These
20:29
dogs suddenly popped out of the corners
20:32
cuz they have right angles." Yeah. So,
20:34
like you can come up with weird other
20:35
dimensions. Ebron has the realm of
20:38
dreams and these aberrations. I think
20:40
they're called the quarry. Check our
20:42
Keith Baker episode. I'm pretty sure he
20:44
used that word properly somewhere in
20:45
there. So yeah, aberrations frequently
20:48
come from outside the material plane or
20:51
like if they do come from material plane
20:52
is from a very weird part of it. And you
20:55
can have these things just pop up or
20:57
like land there unexpectedly. You could
20:59
literally just crash a spell jammer
21:01
right into the middle of your town and
21:03
have mind flares pop out of it. There
21:05
you go. You got your plot. I mean,
21:06
nothing's
21:07
>> and that it, you know, spoiler, a Watsi
21:10
published adventure has done that in the
21:12
past two years.
21:13
>> Yep.
21:13
>> You [laughter] could get space lasers.
21:16
>> Yeah. Or just play Balders's Gate 3.
21:18
That's kind of the whole premise is a
21:20
Nautiloid comes and attacks Balders's
21:22
Gate. So, man, poor Balders's Gate. It
21:25
cannot catch a break. [laughter]
21:27
First, it was dragged into hell and now
21:29
it's being attacked by mind flares.
21:32
>> [laughter]
21:33
>> Look, Never Winter has the recurring
21:35
undead problem. Water Deep is just crime
21:38
the city. And Boulders's Gate gets
21:41
everything else, [laughter] which
21:42
>> is a lot. It gets a lot. [clears throat]
21:45
>> All the other planes of existence.
21:47
>> Yeah. It's the uh London, New York, and
21:49
Los Angeles of fantasy land. So, it's
21:52
like that's where all the superhero
21:53
fights happen.
21:54
>> Yeah. Yeah, pretty much.
21:54
>> Has there ever been an elemental crisis
21:56
at Balders's Gate?
21:57
>> I'm pretty sure that was Princes of the
21:59
Apocalypse.
22:00
>> Perfect.
22:01
>> I think so. Someone will have to correct
22:02
[laughter] me on that one.
22:03
>> So, one of the reasons I like to throw
22:06
aberrations in as antagonists is their
22:08
motivists are also confusing for players
22:11
frequently like so mind flarers like
22:14
they they want to grow in power and take
22:16
over the multiverse. Like that one's
22:17
fairly straightforward. Beholders are
22:19
frequently just driven by paranoia and
22:22
it's like what are they paranoid about?
22:24
Everything. Other aberrations like
22:26
sometimes their motives are very simple
22:28
like we need to make more of us or we
22:30
need to eat stuff. But a lot of times it
22:32
can just be something like weird, vague,
22:35
out of the ordinary that doesn't make
22:37
sense to the players. Like maybe there's
22:38
an abalith trying to take over a city
22:40
and kill everyone named Steuart. Why?
22:43
Personal grudge maybe. Maybe there's
22:46
some like weird ritual that involves
22:48
people named Stewart. Who knows? But
22:50
hey, if you're out there listening this
22:51
and your name is Steuart, I'm very
22:53
sorry. The abaliths are coming for you.
22:55
Another cool thing about operations is,
22:58
you know, we talked about they come from
22:59
different planes of existence. They
23:01
mostly come from one plane of existence
23:03
and that's the far realm, which is one
23:05
of the least explored and talked about
23:08
realms of existence because it exists
23:10
outside the cosmology of the great
23:12
wheel. It's like we have the great wheel
23:15
here and then there's everything else
23:17
outside [laughter] of it. And it's
23:19
anybody's guess how big the far realm is
23:21
or if we're just a tiny beacon of like
23:25
oasis of normaly in an entire forest of
23:28
just utter incomprehensibility
23:31
which can be kind of terrifying. I've
23:33
never seen someone try to tackle a
23:35
journey to the far realm but I am
23:36
curious how you guys would run a far
23:39
realm adventure. Okay, so I've got a
23:41
couple of I've got a couple things for
23:42
this. So we reviewed journeys through
23:44
the radiant city citadel a while ago.
23:46
The very last adventure actually takes
23:49
you to the far realm super briefly and
23:51
you get to walk through the dead body of
23:53
a giant space bug called the drought
23:56
elder which if I remember right it's a
23:58
giant space bug that lights things dry
24:01
and that is its whole deal.
24:02
>> That is very interesting.
24:04
>> It had interesting features such as the
24:06
fact that it was dead and still hated
24:08
you. It had gibbering mouths for doors
24:11
inside of its own bodies which raises
24:12
some weird questions. Let's see. Looking
24:14
a little further back, there was a D and
24:16
D35 supplement called Lords of Madness.
24:19
I think I've referenced it previously. I
24:21
think I called it out on our villains
24:23
episode. It's literally just a book
24:25
about like here are the motivations,
24:27
ecology, and fun facts and ways to use
24:30
aberrations. So, in a lot of ways, it's
24:33
very very similar to this podcast
24:35
episode, but you know, it was a product
24:37
of its time. It's, you know, all of the
24:39
content warnings, all of them.
24:41
>> Just every last one.
24:42
>> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. what Tyler's saying,
24:44
he's not recommending the book. He's
24:46
acknowledging it exists and covers all
24:48
of these things. Yes. [laughter]
24:50
>> Including the content warnings.
24:51
>> Yeah. Let's see. So, yeah, it covers a
24:54
lot of those those big aberrations.
24:56
Avaliths, beholders, mind flares. Prior
24:58
to 5e, like I don't know if it was ever
25:01
covered in 4, but prior to 5e, this was
25:03
the first time we learned about the
25:04
ecology of beholders. So, if you know
25:06
beholders in 5De, you know that they
25:08
reproduced by dreaming. In 35, they
25:11
reproduced asexually by having a several
25:14
monthsl long period where they went
25:16
extra paranoid and eventually spat out a
25:19
bunch of tiny beholders, ate half of
25:21
them, and then chased off the rest to go
25:23
about their devices. And it also
25:25
introduced the possibility of fat
25:27
beholders.
25:28
>> Why were they fat?
25:29
>> Aren't they already fat?
25:31
>> They're spherical. How do you know if
25:32
they're fat? I don't know. Radius,
25:35
[laughter]
25:36
>> I guess
25:37
>> this one has reached huge size. Yeah. Or
25:40
maybe like if the body gets so big that
25:42
the eye stalks aren't stalks so much as
25:44
just like eyeballs pinned to the
25:45
surface. [laughter]
25:47
>> Yeah, that's that's strange to think
25:49
about.
25:50
>> I mean, that kind of defines
25:51
aberrations, doesn't it?
25:52
>> Fair. I I think another another good
25:55
source for inspiration like cuz there's
25:57
not that many in Dn D. Unfortunately,
26:00
aberrations are kind of the most off
26:03
neglected of the things in Dn D. like
26:06
they they are occasional one-off
26:08
monsters and that's about it. Check out
26:10
Call of Cthulhu. Anything Call of
26:12
Cthulhu is going to give you a good idea
26:14
of how to use aberrations. Well, I think
26:16
often times aberrations are used
26:19
ineffectively in games and people just
26:22
don't use them because they they seem
26:24
less interesting and it's because
26:26
they're just a thing that you can easily
26:29
beat and move on. They're just another
26:30
monster. [laughter] I think that if
26:32
you're playing aberrations well, your
26:34
party shouldn't really be able to beat
26:36
them. I mean, they can they can, but it
26:39
will be very hard. Like, there's a joke
26:40
that people say that it's impossible to
26:42
run a beholder the way it should be run
26:44
because if you play a beholder, well,
26:47
your party isn't going to make it
26:48
because it will have prepared for every
26:50
possible minutely constructed
26:53
contingency plan
26:55
>> because beholders are extremely paranoid
26:57
and they have a lot of time. [laughter]
26:59
So, so yeah, playing I think the problem
27:02
is playing aberrations is hard because
27:04
it requires you to think on a level that
27:06
is impossible for humans to do.
27:08
>> Yeah, we talked about this on a previous
27:10
episode. I think it might have been the
27:11
villains episode. Generally, the hard
27:13
part of playing these very intelligent
27:16
villains is that we're dumb.
27:18
>> Yep. [laughter] I can attest to that. As
27:21
someone who is very dumb, playing really
27:23
intelligent characters is hard.
27:25
>> Then aberrations kick it up like another
27:27
level, right? cuz it's like, okay, not
27:28
only are they smart, they're also alien
27:31
and like I've barely got this world's
27:33
things under lock and now all of a
27:35
sudden I've got to imagine a whole
27:37
universe of things I've never imagined
27:39
and how to be brilliant in that way of
27:41
thinking. And yeah, I think the what
27:43
most of us come up with is like let's
27:45
just do something random. You know, you
27:47
talked about the whole thing with like
27:48
the the stewards and like I'm you know,
27:50
I'm an abalith and I'm possessing people
27:52
and taking over their minds. I can
27:54
communicate with them as long as they're
27:56
on my plane of existence. And what I'm
27:58
doing is I'm sending them into town to
27:59
kill the stewards. It's random. And it's
28:01
like, okay, yeah, sure. That's that
28:03
doesn't make any sense to me, so it must
28:04
make sense to them. So, how do you do
28:06
this without also stepping into that
28:09
cartoonish line of like, ah, this is
28:11
silly. Like, if your goal is really to
28:12
instill fear, to bring that cosmic
28:14
horror aspect to this, how are we going
28:17
to do this? What's a formula that works
28:19
that doesn't involve killing 12
28:20
stewarts? [laughter]
28:22
I think the answer to this, and it's
28:24
going to be a controversial thing to
28:25
say, but bear with me. If you want to
28:28
play aberrations, well, well, you you
28:30
can't play by the rules. You have to
28:32
cheat. I think a player does a really
28:35
powerful spell that they've like set up
28:37
that they that makes sense and it's
28:39
like, oh, your spell fails. Why? Because
28:40
he planned for it. Obviously, not just
28:43
like that sort of thing, but like, you
28:44
know, it has to it you can get kind of
28:47
creative with it. Like maybe a beholder
28:49
went out of its way and the party is
28:51
like trying to like fight with it all
28:53
the way only to prevent it from gaining
28:55
its goal and you don't know what its
28:56
goal is and it turns out its goal is
28:58
this vase that it really wants. Why does
28:59
it want that vase? Because it predicted
29:02
in 2 years time your party members are
29:04
going to be walking down a hall and it
29:06
needs that vase to drop on their head
29:08
and knock someone out. [laughter]
29:11
>> Hopefully that vase has the right
29:12
aerodynamics to like get there right at
29:14
the right time.
29:15
>> Exactly. like they're gonna they're
29:17
gonna knock the vase over and that'll
29:19
trigger the their their trap card
29:21
essentially. Like it has to be something
29:23
ridiculous like that. Like obviously
29:25
don't just pull it out of your ass.
29:26
Don't just say your spell fails because
29:28
it does. Obviously have like some sort
29:30
of contingency plan in place and know
29:33
ahead of time what your party's plan is
29:35
and make sure that your your uh creature
29:39
knows what your party's plan is. You're
29:41
a creature should be able to metag game
29:43
because that's how aberrations do.
29:46
>> Wait, that's not how you run all your
29:47
villains? [laughter]
29:49
>> No, that's a terrible way to run most
29:51
villains.
29:53
>> All of my villains are very very good at
29:55
divination magic and my players never
29:57
think to block scrying. So,
29:59
>> that is true. But [laughter] even still,
30:02
like I I encourage people to just cheat
30:05
when they're playing aberrations. It may
30:07
be frustrating, but that's how
30:09
aberrations are.
30:11
>> Okay, so separate from that advice,
30:12
which I just want to say the RPG about
30:14
podcast is not endorse cheating. And I
30:16
think no one here is actually saying
30:17
this is a good idea. [laughter]
30:19
>> I am I endorse it.
30:22
>> I do not endorse I do not
30:25
>> That wasn't very clear.
30:26
>> No, it really wasn't. [laughter]
30:28
>> Let me be clear. I do not endorse
30:31
players cheating. It's not cheating if
30:33
you're the GM. You can't break the law.
30:35
You are the law. Exactly. It's not
30:37
cheating if I say it isn't cheating.
30:39
[laughter]
30:41
All right, moving on.
30:46
Another piece of this that I think is
30:47
important is some of our cooler
30:50
aberrations are very complicated to run
30:53
and even more complicated to run
30:55
successfully.
30:56
>> Yeah. [laughter] Have you guys ever
30:57
fought a gibbering mouth?
30:59
>> Yes.
30:59
>> Do not remember.
31:00
>> Okay. So, so Randall, since you haven't,
31:03
it it's a pool of flesh and teeth. It
31:05
will roll over you and chomp on you. And
31:07
if I remember right, it's got an aura
31:09
that makes you frightened.
31:10
>> Terrible.
31:10
>> It's pretty much it. Like they're
31:12
they're unpleasant to fight. Like
31:13
they've got a lot of hit points and all
31:14
that, but they're like CR1 or two, so
31:17
you know, not terrifying.
31:18
>> So just like throw an acid flask or
31:20
throw like lit oil into it and then
31:23
wave. Is that
31:24
>> Yeah, I'm actually wrong. I mean, yes,
31:26
they are based off of Yagsoth, but
31:28
they're based off of a very specific
31:30
servant of Yagsoth, a Shagath, which was
31:32
from the mountains of madness. And if
31:34
you want to use a shagath, which are way
31:36
better than gibbrey mouththers. Gibbre
31:38
mouths are kind of laughable,
31:40
>> check out to of beasts because to be has
31:42
a shagoth in it.
31:44
>> There you go. Yeah, they are horrifying.
31:47
[laughter]
31:48
>> Yeah, cobalt presses to of beasts and
31:50
then Pathfinder both editions have stats
31:53
for a lot of Kufu mythos creatures. So
31:56
yeah, great place to find those.
31:57
>> I think 5 really neglects its
32:00
aberrations a lot. It doesn't. It's like
32:02
probably one of the most least
32:04
represented monsters in the Monster
32:06
Manual, but Pathfinder I I mean Cobalt
32:09
Press loves themselves some aberrations.
32:12
[laughter]
32:12
>> Yep.
32:13
>> And Fay Folk.
32:14
>> I don't Other than Raven Loft, I don't
32:17
think we've gotten anything even horror
32:19
adjacent in 5e
32:21
>> Out of the Abyss.
32:22
>> Would you call that horror?
32:23
>> I would. Yeah.
32:24
>> Yeah. All right. Also, the uh the D in
32:28
Eberon rising from the last war.
32:31
>> The creature or is that an
32:32
>> It's a It's a dude.
32:34
>> Okay. [laughter] He's an aberration.
32:36
It's a CR24 aberration.
32:39
>> Jeez, that's Wow. That's
32:40
>> Yeah. Okay.
32:40
>> Yeah. Which speaking of creatures that
32:43
are extremely complicated to run, so
32:45
many options. [laughter]
32:47
>> Anything above CR20 except the
32:48
terrasque.
32:49
>> Yeah.
32:50
>> Yeah. Yeah. I mean, there are a ton of
32:53
aberrations that are really complicated
32:55
to run across the full level scale like
32:57
in intellect of hours. Hey, if you saw
32:59
the D and D movie, you got to see them.
33:01
They're great. I I'm going to ask both
33:03
of you your current characters that
33:05
you're playing. Well, Randall, you're
33:07
DMing right now, but so last character
33:08
you played, how much intelligence did
33:10
they have? My witch has I want to say so
33:14
people are going to call shenanigans on
33:17
me because witches are usually
33:19
intelligence-based casters, but my DM
33:20
let me do a charisma based W. So her
33:23
intelligence was a 17 if I recall
33:25
correctly.
33:26
>> Dang, that's still really high for not
33:28
being intelligence-based.
33:29
>> I mean, that's Pathfinder.
33:31
>> Fair. [laughter]
33:32
>> And uh and my DM also, he has a very
33:35
interesting way of making us roll stats.
33:37
He has us roll d20s for stats. Y
33:39
>> Mhm. Oh,
33:42
[laughter]
33:42
>> I have feelings about that.
33:43
>> Yeah, that gives me really strong
33:44
feelings. Uh,
33:46
>> it's very interesting. I'll say that.
33:48
>> Has your GM ever listened to the Dice
33:49
Math episode? [laughter]
33:51
>> Cuz it would help in this situation.
33:52
>> Yeah. Mhm. Mhm.
33:54
>> Okay.
33:55
>> So, I I was a sorcerer, so charisma
33:57
based. I want to say my intelligence
34:00
might have been like 11. You may have,
34:03
if I remember right, our bard was the
34:05
smartest person in the party at like 12.
34:07
>> That feels right. Yeah. So, an
34:08
intellecter will force you to make an
34:10
intelligence save. If you fail, it rolls
34:13
3d6. If the 3d6 roll is higher than your
34:18
intelligence, and this is the 5e stats,
34:19
if the 3d6 roll is higher than your
34:21
intelligence, your intelligence is
34:23
reduced to zero.
34:24
>> Cool. Uh-huh. So, that is an existential
34:28
threat to any player except wizards and
34:31
artificers basically across the entire
34:34
level spectrum. So if you see an
34:36
intellect devour and you're not a
34:37
wizard, just leave. Just leave. There is
34:40
no way that is going to go well for you.
34:42
How how do we fix this wish?
34:44
>> No, you can you can fix it with greater
34:46
restoration. Okay.
34:47
>> Um so this actually happened to one of
34:50
the player characters in the early c the
34:52
first campaign of Critical Role. Grog
34:55
the barbarian famously has real bad
34:57
intelligence. got knocked to zero by an
35:00
intellect devour and almost got almost
35:02
got his brain devoured, but they killed
35:04
the intellect devour and then the druid
35:06
cast greater restoration on him. It uh I
35:09
think Matt ruled that it took a day for
35:11
him to recover fully. There are ways to
35:13
[laughter] fix it.
35:13
>> Yeah. I wonder [clears throat] if that's
35:14
rules is written or if that was like,
35:16
well, we can't just we're not going to
35:17
let this character go like this.
35:19
>> I don't know. [laughter] I'd have to
35:20
look into it more. Someone who knows the
35:22
rules better than me can tell me that if
35:24
that was a bad Matt Mercer ruling or a
35:26
good Matt Mercer ruling. Look, you know,
35:28
Rule of Cool, that's great.
35:30
>> Yeah, Rule of Cool. He decided that was
35:32
a more interesting story. Uh, and I
35:33
haven't watched enough Critical Role to
35:35
know what the answer is there, but uh,
35:37
>> I mean, without having seen the arc,
35:39
that's a more interesting story than
35:40
like, hey, cool show we're doing here.
35:42
You're going to roll a new character and
35:43
everybody, let's [laughter]
35:44
>> It was It was also in the first like
35:46
seven episodes of the entire Critical
35:49
Role thing. So, it they were still
35:52
learning the system and they made a m
35:54
made a lot of wrong calls. So it very
35:57
well could have been an erroneous call.
35:58
>> Were they still Were they in for at that
36:00
point?
36:00
>> No, they were in fifth edition. They
36:02
started in fifth. Oh, so the thing was
36:04
they started it was they started
36:06
streaming halfway through the campaign
36:08
that they had been doing offstream and
36:10
that game was a home game that they were
36:12
running in Pathfinder. So they figured
36:15
that it would be easier for the to
36:16
relate to the audience better if they
36:18
used fifth edition. So there was some
36:20
growing pains when it came to fifth
36:21
edition. Some people got a lot stronger,
36:24
some people got a lot weaker.
36:26
>> So Randall, I have all these
36:28
aberrations. When do I get to use them?
36:30
>> Yeah, I I guess one thing that's worth
36:31
saying first, the very first episode we
36:34
had Ash on the podcast was an episode
36:36
called Horror.
36:38
>> Is that how you pronounce that word?
36:39
Horror.
36:40
>> Horror.
36:41
>> If you remember from the horror episode,
36:42
we had to work on that.
36:44
>> Yeah.
36:44
>> You sound like a dog.
36:47
[laughter]
36:49
Well, cuz on the week leading up to
36:51
that, I kept saying we were doing the
36:52
horror episode and everybody was staring
36:54
at me funny. Okay.
36:55
>> Yeah. [laughter]
36:57
>> Horror.
36:58
>> Horror.
36:59
>> I don't understand why this is hard.
37:01
>> You've got to pronounce it.
37:03
>> You've really got to pronounce that
37:04
second O. God, kill me.
37:08
>> Okay, so uh we did the horror episode.
37:10
We talked about the sanity rules in 5e.
37:12
They are not wonderful, but if you
37:13
really are trying to do this cosmic
37:15
horror thing, it's a great step in the
37:16
way. And if everybody at the table loves
37:18
it, hey, go check out Cthulhu.
37:20
>> Yeah. [laughter]
37:22
>> Yeah. It's probably a better game for
37:23
this.
37:24
>> But if your table is just looking to
37:26
experiment, I think aberrations are a
37:29
great way to do a small arc where you
37:31
play with the sanity rules and you
37:33
really try to bring that cosmic horror
37:35
to the game. So if you were going to try
37:37
to do something like this, there are
37:39
story lines that you can tie to, you
37:41
know, most aberrations that are in the
37:42
book. You know, an evil wizard has
37:44
invited something into the chapel, and
37:47
the local villagers are asking to go to
37:48
look. What is it? I don't know. I don't
37:50
care. Whatever is a level appropriate.
37:51
Go have fun with it. [laughter]
37:53
Fishermen are returning from the lake,
37:54
hellbent on destroying the dam that
37:56
holds the river at bay, keeping the
37:58
city, you know, not underwater. There
38:00
are rumors of a cave just beneath the
38:02
water surface near the center of the
38:03
lake. It's an abalith. It's an abalith.
38:05
is, you know, taking over the fisherman
38:07
and then saying, "Hey, I would like to
38:09
expand my domain and that dam is getting
38:11
in my way. Can you please go just get
38:13
rid of it so I can keep doing my sight
38:15
unseen thing?" The small keep has
38:17
recently discovered a decaying arcane
38:19
library below the dungeon. The local
38:21
lord will pay a pittance for some
38:23
adventures to verify it is safe prior to
38:25
sending people she cares about into the
38:27
library. Okay, so back when I first
38:29
published Monstrous Races, Random and I
38:32
were discussing starting up an actual
38:34
play podcast. Never got off the ground,
38:36
never happened. Like we discussed
38:38
characters, never went anywhere. one of
38:40
the guys who was going to be in the
38:42
group who's going to play with us wanted
38:44
to play a nthic and like I came up with
38:46
this whole plot where let's see so nics
38:48
form from like someone who learned or
38:53
has some relation to an arcane secret
38:55
and like goes insane and athic spawns
38:57
and they maybe die. So like his whole
39:00
personal arc was going to be like in in
39:02
his previous life he was this great
39:04
wizard who discovered some crazy secret
39:07
of the multiverse and then plot happened
39:10
in the world emerges is introduced to
39:13
the party and they're basically using
39:15
the Nthic to hunt out magical artifacts
39:17
and the Nic is like yeah fine I'll find
39:19
these mag magical artifacts so that
39:21
these random NPCs don't kill me but I'm
39:23
specifically looking for my nonsense and
39:25
like I was planning to just never reveal
39:28
what the secret was cuz that's the thing
39:29
with Nthics is like they want the
39:31
secret, they can never find it. And the
39:33
secret was eventually going to be his
39:35
old wizard self. Like it was this whole
39:37
plot arc I had planned out that I never
39:39
got to use. So like, hey, if anybody in
39:41
your group is like, I would like to play
39:43
an aberration. There you go. Steal that
39:45
plot hook. Nice. And so yeah, if you go
39:47
and read about the aberitions in the
39:50
monster manual or you pull some out of
39:51
Toma of Beast, there's enough of the
39:53
ecology of the the wise and who's and
39:54
whats of these creatures that you should
39:57
be able to piece together at least
39:59
enough story to get you through that one
40:01
shot, that short arc, which would allow
40:03
you to experiment a little bit with the
40:04
sanity rules. Similarly, what I like to
40:07
do if I'm running like a longer,
40:08
especially a published adventure, let's
40:09
say a couple people can't be there,
40:11
people really want to play the game,
40:12
something like this is just a great
40:14
aside. You can do one session on it. At
40:16
the end, uh, you fight the aberration.
40:18
I'm sorry, Ash. We're gonna let them
40:19
kill it. Or maybe the aberration runs
40:21
away and just that that's the that's the
40:23
timeout monster. Like, if somebody can't
40:25
be here, it's like, we're back to
40:26
fighting the the the Nok. Here we go.
40:29
[laughter]
40:30
But apparitions can also be great for
40:31
building a longer quest or even a
40:34
campaign around. So, I'll pose to you
40:35
folks. You have to build a longunning
40:38
campaign. Let's say up to a year. I
40:40
guess that's not really longunning by
40:41
some people's standards, but you're
40:42
going to play game for at least a year.
40:44
What aberation do you want to build your
40:45
campaign around?
40:46
>> You can pick, like I said before,
40:48
beholder, mind flares are always good
40:51
for a campaign. I mean, that's the
40:53
entire premise of Balders's Gate 3 is
40:55
the ilithids are the main bad guys in
40:57
that game. Abaliths use those quite a
41:00
bit. And slots, slots are the other one
41:02
that you that are come to mind as
41:04
something you could use pretty well and
41:07
have a lot of really creepy awful gross
41:10
things happen. If if you're doing
41:12
Eberon, the Corey are pretty easy cuz
41:14
they're all aberrations and they're
41:16
literally from the realm of dreams. So
41:17
like you can have space invasions from
41:20
the realm of nightmares which, you know,
41:22
feels like a plot.
41:23
>> Feels like a World of Warcraft
41:25
[laughter] game.
41:27
>> The Emerald Nightmare.
41:30
>> Um, abaliths and mind flares also
41:32
historically hate each other. So you
41:34
could literally have that be the plot.
41:36
Like the abaliths and the mind flares
41:38
have made whatever world the players
41:40
live on the battlefield for that their
41:42
next war against each other and the
41:44
players get stuck in the middle and have
41:46
to you know do something so that
41:49
humanity survives.
41:50
>> Yeah. In in the beginning and I believe
41:52
took over one of the characters brothers
41:54
and sent them off on some journey and so
41:56
the party just went to find the brother
41:58
and then hilarity ensued. [laughter]
42:01
>> Perfect. You could also aberrations are
42:04
uh good for the uh greater scope
42:07
villain. Like the like there's a lot of
42:10
problems and like fighting that's
42:12
happening, but where did all of this
42:14
conflict really start? Who's driving
42:16
this conflict? It's actually this creepy
42:18
Eldrich being that's been like using
42:20
people as pawns for its own ends.
42:22
Basically, a lot of Final Fantasy
42:24
stories are like this, too. [laughter]
42:27
The main big bad is like a nebulous god
42:30
who has aberrations at their command. So
42:33
>> uh Gova in Final Fantasy 7.
42:35
>> Mhm.
42:36
>> A bit aberrational.
42:37
>> The end singer in Final Fantasy 14.
42:40
There's so many examples.
42:42
[clears throat]
42:42
>> Well, so there isn't a ton of material
42:45
for this, but let's quickly hit on the
42:47
player's perspective. In 35, Lords of
42:49
Madness did have like two or three pages
42:51
of feats for players that were
42:53
aberration adjacent, but that was really
42:56
it. In in 5e, there are no official
43:00
options to play in aberration. I don't
43:02
think there are in 2 either. Like, there
43:04
are some that feel like maybe they
43:06
should be, but they aren't aberrations.
43:08
Cobalt Press in Tome of Heroes has I
43:12
honestly have no idea how to pronounce
43:13
it. S A T A R R E Sar.
43:17
>> Satire. One of the two.
43:19
>> Okay. So, so, so there's a D and D
43:21
creature I'm just now forgetting the
43:23
name of. It's like a spider body with an
43:25
eel head. Starts with an N something.
43:28
Anyway, they they keep the eel head, but
43:30
it's a humanoid body. Uh, so it's like
43:32
eel humanoids who are connected to the
43:34
great old ones. So, they're like very
43:36
aberration adjacent. They're pretty cool
43:38
race. Like they've got some cool traits.
43:40
Not super strong, but pretty neat. So,
43:42
yeah. Grab to of heroes. Other than
43:44
that, like great old one warlocks are
43:46
basically the closest you're going to
43:47
get in 5e. Something similar from PF2,
43:51
you know.
43:51
>> And it is worth saying, of course, you
43:53
always have the option of picking up
43:54
monstrous races.
43:55
>> Yeah.
43:56
>> Yeah. I ran a game where one of my
43:59
players played a mind flare, and that
44:01
was fun.
44:02
>> Oh, cool.
44:02
>> Basically, every time they would, it was
44:05
a heist, and every time there was a
44:07
guard, he's like, "Wait, I'm going to
44:08
eat this dude's brain." And I had a
44:10
mechanic in place where when he ate a
44:12
guy's brain, he would get memories, like
44:14
traces of memories from that person's
44:16
brain, so it was useful for him. The
44:17
party was fine with it because they're
44:19
all evil. [laughter] But yeah, I do
44:23
think that there are ways you can lean
44:24
into it in 5 if you're creative. Like
44:27
the great old one is a good one. Also,
44:29
the aberant mind sorcerer is one that I
44:32
think a lot of people don't really play
44:34
with a lot. Like there's a there's some
44:36
cool backstory things that they pitch to
44:38
you. One of the ones that I was going to
44:39
play with before the ca the campaign
44:41
that I was going to be in was canceled
44:42
and I was very disappointed was a person
44:44
who survived getting a tadpole in their
44:46
brain. Yeah, sort of similar to how the
44:49
plot of Balders's Gate 3 is. So that is
44:51
a way that you can play that like that.
44:53
That can be fun. There's also the dark
44:56
bargains thing. You could play with
44:58
that. Maybe make a dark bargain with an
45:00
Eldrich entity or maybe your god as a
45:04
cleric is an Eldrich entity. You could
45:06
play with that. Maybe the god of the the
45:08
the storms and tempest is just an
45:11
Aldrich entity that exists outside of
45:13
time and is unknowable. Like I think
45:15
playing gods as kind of Aldrich beings
45:18
is more interesting than just playing
45:19
them as like benevolent beings with a
45:21
clear intention. I think that there's a
45:24
there's a god in a sea of Theos that
45:26
does that really well. The god of the
45:27
unknown is basically like an Eldrich and
45:30
the representation is just a humanoid
45:32
shape filled with like space, outer
45:35
space. It's [laughter] crazy. Yeah.
45:38
>> Mhm.
45:39
>> So, not not that this is going to add
45:40
much to the pod, but I have to call it
45:41
out. I looked up the Satari, not in Tome
45:44
of Heroes, but in Toma of Beast 2. They
45:46
look like the elites from Halo.
45:48
[laughter]
45:49
>> Interesting.
45:49
>> Oh my gosh, they do. So, if you ever
45:51
wanted to play that of Heroes,
45:54
[laughter]
45:56
>> they do kind Oh my god, that's funny.
45:59
>> Oh my gosh, I can't get that out of my
46:01
head now.
46:02
>> I want to I want to play one now. They
46:04
look so good. They look so they sound
46:06
like James Earl Jones. [laughter]
46:10
>> All right, so very quickly because we
46:12
did cover this in the Undead episodes.
46:14
Advice on killing aberrations. Protect
46:16
your brains. That's literally all we can
46:18
tell you. That's the only thing I have
46:20
in common.
46:21
>> I have to read what Tyler put in the
46:23
show notes. Listen to Wuang Clan.
46:25
Protect your neck. Okay, technically
46:27
your brain.
46:27
>> Or you could go the Cthulhu method and
46:29
be like, you can't run away or submit.
46:32
It's your choice.
46:33
I mean, it's D and D. It's it's cosmic
46:36
horror light. You're expected to fight
46:38
back.
46:38
>> I know. I know.
46:40
>> It's it's pulp pulp cthulu.
46:42
>> Yeah. No, 100%.
46:43
>> Yeah. [laughter] This wasn't Brennan
46:45
Frasier's The Mummy 2 enough. Let's make
46:47
it Brennan's Frasier. It's the Mummy
46:49
one.
46:49
>> Was the Mummy one lighter [laughter]
46:51
than the Mummy 2?
46:53
>> I don't know. I can't remember. It's
46:54
been years. Was wait, was the Mummy 2,
46:56
the one with the train or was that the
46:57
Mummy 3?
46:58
>> I think that was Mummy 2.
47:00
>> Okay. Yeah. No, that was lighter. So,
47:01
reverse it. people at home. It's fine.
47:03
>> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
47:04
>> This week we have a question of the
47:05
week. Our question of the week comes to
47:06
us from Steph on Discord. I'm curious
47:08
how y'all would run a heist in 5e rules
47:11
versus maybe other systems.
47:13
>> So, I actually do have experience with
47:14
this. I coincidentally was talking about
47:16
it. That mind flare player. It was a
47:18
heist mission to sort of steal a magical
47:22
artifact from a holder wizard. So, two
47:25
for one. [laughter] Um, uh, heists are
47:28
hard to do in fifth edition, especially
47:31
since the emphasis is mostly on just
47:33
killing everything. Your players aren't
47:35
really sort of motivated to be quiet. If
47:38
they can if they're like, we can take
47:40
things, we can just kill all the guards,
47:43
it's like not a problem. So, I think
47:46
that 5 is hard to do heists well in. I
47:49
think that keys to the Golden Vault did
47:51
it pretty well. So that if you want
47:54
ideas for how to run it, I would say
47:55
just look at that book. There's also a
47:57
an article that they released to
47:59
coincide with that called like making
48:01
your heist better. I'd have to look it
48:03
up. I check the show notes and the heist
48:05
the golden vault episode. I think we
48:06
linked it there. Very good advice for
48:08
running heist in 5B. I wish I had read
48:10
it when I'd run my heist. I think a big
48:12
thing is adding complications, adding
48:16
timers, and adding really bad
48:18
consequences for making a scene. Not
48:21
just like, oh, more low-level guards
48:23
come in. No, no, all the guards come in
48:26
[laughter]
48:27
and then your players will never break
48:30
stealth again because they will get
48:32
TPKed. Like even if you throw like
48:34
people like, well, I mean, my party
48:36
level is eight and you know, if I throw
48:39
guards at them, no matter how many I
48:40
throw at them, they'll they'll they'll
48:42
take them out. No, no, no. I in my evil
48:44
game that I ran with B, we managed to
48:46
TPK the almost the entire party with
48:49
just low-level commoners. Commoners. We
48:52
threw 50 of them at the players and that
48:56
brought them to brought obviously it
48:58
didn't kill them all. We just they
49:00
knocked them out and took them
49:01
elsewhere. But yeah, so if you throw
49:04
enough things at your players, the
49:06
action economy is going to going to
49:08
screw them over. That's just how that
49:10
works in fifth edition.
49:11
>> Yep. Mhm.
49:12
>> I would also say that I think puzzles
49:13
could be a lot of fun if you were trying
49:14
to do a heist in 5e. And this is where
49:17
you could actually have those puzzles
49:18
be, you know, player only puzzles or at
49:20
the very least, you know, metagaming
49:22
player using character skills to get
49:24
certain clues. That could be a lot of
49:26
fun as part of like, well, no kidding.
49:27
How are we going to get into this room
49:29
or how are we going to get this item
49:30
out? For folks who have seen the D and D
49:32
movie, they did a lot of really cool
49:34
things with the the mirror that they
49:36
could uh I don't know, teleport through.
49:38
What do we name this mirror?
49:40
>> It wasn't a mirror. It was they used a
49:42
portal gun.
49:42
>> Yeah, the hither run.
49:44
>> No, that's Yeah, it basically was a
49:46
portal gun, wasn't it? Yeah. Great. No,
49:47
that that worked wonderfully, right?
49:49
>> So, putting tools like that in front of
49:51
them, letting them solve it. Granted,
49:52
they're like, you know, it's a spatial
49:53
puzzle. Let's just go here, beat Portal
49:55
2, and if you do, I'll let you in the
49:56
cave. I don't know. [laughter]
49:59
>> Yeah.
49:59
>> So, I I recently played a new game and
50:03
now I want to hit everything with that
50:04
hammer. I'm going to make the
50:06
suggestion. Call of Cthulhu is the best
50:08
system for running a heist ever and
50:09
there isn't a better game.
50:10
>> Well, that's an interesting thought. Was
50:11
this rules the game I ran for you or did
50:14
you play a different game?
50:15
>> No. Okay. I I played Call of Cthulhu
50:17
with you, but reading the rules,
50:19
understanding how the professions work,
50:22
yada yada yada. The idea like chase
50:24
mechanics are built in. You are
50:26
encouraged to not get into combat even
50:28
with human beings because you'll die.
50:30
you have relevant skills that are likely
50:32
to come up in a chase such as
50:35
proficiency with weapons, proficiency
50:37
with different types of vehicles,
50:39
lockpicking, can you read different
50:41
languages like all of these things are
50:43
things that depending on the heist could
50:44
come up. So I think you could actually
50:46
run like a non-Cthulu heist in Cthulhu
50:49
doesn't have to be any cosmic horror
50:50
about it. one better. Let's say what you
50:53
are stealing like it's supposed to be
50:55
this mundane thing and then it turns
50:56
actually it turns out actually to be
50:58
influenced by the the happenings of a
51:01
typical Cthulhu game which then brings
51:03
you into the cosmic horror where like
51:05
yeah I'm trying to get away from the
51:06
guards I'm also trying to get away from
51:08
the old one.
51:09
>> Yeah. No, I think that's exactly like
51:11
Call of Cthulhu can be useful for that.
51:13
I think a game like if you really wanted
51:15
to just do a heist focused campaign with
51:18
jobs and stuff like that, the system I
51:20
would actually recommend you check out
51:21
is Blades in the Dark. Blades in the
51:23
Dark is built for that. That's its
51:25
entire system is based around heists.
51:28
And if I'm running heist in games, I'm
51:30
stealing stuff from that. Like
51:32
especially the clock mechanic. The clock
51:34
mechanic is genius. And I highly
51:36
recommend anybody who wants to run a
51:37
heist, you need to check out Blades in
51:39
the Dark and at least steal that clock
51:40
mechanic or your D&D heist game because
51:43
it's great.
51:43
>> Yeah, that was absolutely going to be my
51:45
piece of advice. The clock mechanic is
51:48
so easy to adapt to any RPG. Give us the
51:51
one minute version of the clock
51:52
mechanic. Okay, so you take a circle and
51:54
you divide it into sections. And I I
51:57
don't understand this mechanic super
51:58
well. Like I need to study up on it and
52:00
then there will be an episode about
52:01
clocks at some point in the future. But
52:03
you take a circle, you divide it into
52:04
sections. Like maybe you do 12 sections.
52:06
And then every time the players do
52:08
something related to that clock, you
52:11
fill in one section. When the clock is
52:14
completely filled in, something bad
52:16
happens. So it may be like the guards
52:18
are alerted. They fill in like you do
52:20
three sections. Like they fail to pick a
52:22
lock, it makes a loud noise. They get
52:25
spotted and just barely get away. And
52:27
then like they drop something and break
52:30
it. You filled in the clock. The guards
52:32
are alerted. Now everything is harder.
52:34
>> Yeah, it's also important to to mention
52:37
that this should be visible to players.
52:40
>> That's what makes it stressful is your
52:42
players can see the clock slowly filling
52:44
in cuz if you don't tell them, they
52:46
won't it won't click for them like, oh,
52:48
we don't have a lot of time. But if they
52:50
can just look and see that the clock is
52:52
working against them, it puts the fear
52:54
of God into them.
52:55
>> Okay. So, I recognize that that would be
52:56
hugely powerful. I'll ask the question.
52:58
That feels kind of similar to in a chase
53:00
just saying I need four successes before
53:02
you have two failures
53:03
>> kind of. Yeah.
53:04
>> And then counting as you go. But
53:05
[laughter] that sounds a lot more
53:06
powerful to me. Like I really like this
53:08
idea. I'm not dismissing it. But it it
53:10
does it feels like we're accomplishing
53:11
the same way. But people are used to
53:13
time. People are used to thinking about
53:14
running out of time which is only going
53:16
to make them feel stressed.
53:18
>> Yeah, that one
53:19
>> in a way.
53:20
>> I I have one more system I want to toss
53:22
out there talking about games that are
53:23
meant to run a heist. Shadow Run.
53:25
>> Yep. [laughter]
53:27
>> Yeah. You know, I don't know that
53:29
Shadowrun, like it is very much a game
53:31
about like heists, crime, breaking in
53:34
and out of places, things like that. I
53:35
don't know that there's any super easy
53:37
mechanics from Shadow Run to adapt
53:39
specifically for heists. Like that's
53:42
it's more like the trappings and genre
53:45
of the system really. But yeah, I mean
53:48
certainly there's plenty of equipment.
53:49
>> Are are you saying that we can't bring
53:51
Shadowrun into 5e? I I'm I'm saying it
53:54
would be difficult to bring Shadow Run
53:56
mechanics into other games. Like Steph
53:58
did specifically ask also about 5e. So
54:01
it would be hard to adapt Shadow Run to
54:03
5e. Like you're not going to bring your
54:05
Smart Link pistol into 5e,
54:07
unfortunately.
54:08
>> I got you. Yeah. Okay.
54:09
>> Yeah. [laughter]
54:11
>> Yeah. I mean, Shadow Run is definitely a
54:13
game where heists feature prominently,
54:15
so it's a it's a good game to do heist
54:17
in. And if you want to do heists using
54:19
Call of Cthulhu or Call of Cthulhu
54:21
adjacent rules, Chaosium just published
54:24
an update to their basic role playing
54:26
system, we'll have links in the show
54:28
notes. And that's like the generic
54:30
version of the Cthulhu rules
54:31
essentially.
54:31
>> Yeah.
54:32
>> Oh, Halo the Leisure Illuminati. I'm
54:33
Randall James. You'll find me on
54:34
amateurjack.com and on Twitter and
54:36
Instagram, Jackamate. I'm Tyler Campa.
54:39
You'll find me on RPGbot.net. Facebook
54:41
and Twitter, RPG Boot, DOT, NE, and most
54:45
other social media as RPGot.
54:47
>> My name is Ash Eli. You'll find me on
54:50
Twitter, Graven Ashes, and on YouTube,
54:53
Ashraven Media or Graven Ashes. Again,
54:56
>> if you've enjoyed the show, please rate
54:58
and review us on Apple Podcast and rate
55:00
us on Spotify or your favorite podcast
55:02
app. It's a quick free way to support
55:03
the podcast and helps us to reach new
55:05
listeners. You'll find links in the show
55:07
notes. You will find affiliate links for
55:09
source books and other materials linked
55:10
in the show notes as well as on
55:12
rpgbot.net. Following these links helps
55:14
us [music] to make this show happen
55:15
every week. If your question should be
55:17
the question of the week next week,
55:19
please email podcastrpgbot.net
55:21
or message us on Twitter at rpgbot
55:23
[music]
55:24
doot ne. Please also consider supporting
55:27
us on Patreon [music] where you'll find
55:28
ad free podcast episodes, early access
55:31
to rpgbot.content, polls for future
55:33
content, [music] and access to the
55:34
rpgbot. Discord. You'll find us at
55:36
patreon.com/rpgbot.
55:40
>> So, fun dumb Halo fact since we were
55:42
talking about the elites. The the famous
55:45
wart wart wart line. Sergeant Johnson
55:47
says go. And the wart wart wart line is
55:50
that played reverse with the pitch
55:52
adjusted.
55:53
>> Interesting. Okay, I buy that.
55:55
>> [laughter]
Games

