TWO-WEAPON FIGHTING: Swords, Spells, and Audiobook Shenanigans - RPGBOT.Podcast S5E7
Jun 10, 2026
Ever wonder why two-weapon fighting feels like juggling flaming swords while blindfolded? We dove deep into Pathfinder, D&D, and the eternal question: "Is the Dual Wielder feat secretly trolling us?" Along the way, we debated the cultural legacy of Drizz't, praised doubling rings like they’re the new sliced bread, and agreed that critical hit confirmations are basically your dice laughing at you. Tune in to hear us talk combat mechanics, convention chaos, and why humor might just be the ultimate life-saving spell.
This episode originally aired on January 15th, 2025, and we're currently working to upload our episode backlog. For the latest from the RPGBOT.Podcast, find us in your favorite podcatcher.
Full show notes for this episode are available on RPGBOT.net: https://rpgbot.net/two-weapon-fighting-swords-spells-and-audiobook-shenanigans-rpgbot-podcast-s5e7/
Find us on socials and stuff:
🦋 https://bsky.app/profile/rpgbot.bsky.social
⏰ https://www.tiktok.com/@rpgbotdotnet
🔍 https://RPGBOT.net/
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
You need to read it eventually. The
0:02
intent is still to have you do the audio
0:04
book.
0:05
>> Oh, really? Oh, I just I thought I
0:06
thought that had fallen through. Yeah,
0:08
I'd be happy to. [laughter]
0:10
>> I'm just saying now.
0:11
>> Oh, okay.
0:12
>> Yeah. Sorry.
0:14
>> No, you're [laughter] fine. You're fine.
0:15
I figured.
0:17
>> Yeah. No, actually. Okay. So,
0:20
>> two autistic. I have a hard time
0:23
recognizing sarcasm. [laughter]
0:25
>> No, it's okay. No, no, no. No sarcasm. I
0:27
am excited. We'll talk about it offline.
0:29
It's gonna be great.
0:30
>> Yeah. Okay. Wait, so I'm confused. Do
0:32
you want me to do it or are you Do you
0:34
not Okay.
0:34
>> Yes. I thought you were I thought you
0:36
were just joking.
0:37
>> No, 100%. Like he has told me this plan
0:41
several times. Like he's very excited to
0:43
have you record the audio for the audio
0:45
book.
0:46
>> Okay.
0:46
>> Yeah. Like the the plan on this has
0:48
never shifted. This has always been
0:50
Randall's plan as long as there has been
0:52
one.
0:52
>> Again, I I have a hard time recognizing
0:56
>> when people are being genuine or when
0:57
it's sarcasm. So, [laughter] uh, now I
1:00
am embarrassed.
1:01
>> No, I feel I feel like that's honestly a
1:03
common experience for a lot of people.
1:04
Like, if somebody approaches you about
1:06
something that you enjoy and you're
1:07
passionate about and they're like, I
1:08
know you enjoy this and you're
1:09
passionate about it. I want to pay you
1:11
to do it. The immediate reaction is
1:12
like, you don't mean that. I'm not a
1:15
professional professional.
1:17
>> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
1:19
>> It's like I when people are like, hey,
1:21
can you do this thing do this thing that
1:23
you're good at for me? I'm just like,
1:25
yeah, you're full of [ __ ] Oh,
1:27
[laughter] nice joke. Nice joke. You
1:30
don't Nobody pays me to do the thing
1:32
that I like doing and I'm good at.
1:33
People pay me for grunt work. That's
1:35
what they pay me.
1:36
>> Way to Lucy and the football on me on my
1:38
dreams again.
1:39
>> Oh, yeah. Oh, that feels mean.
1:40
>> Well, that's that's the discussion we're
1:43
having. No, I Hey, [laughter] I'm I'm
1:45
not going to lift the football. And the
1:47
fact that I'm saying I'm not going to
1:48
lift the football actually feels all for
1:50
it. Just the football's good. You know
1:51
what? Let's not even play football.
1:52
Let's just read the audio book. It's
1:54
worth so folks at home. So, it's been
1:56
two episodes since we announced Malaw.
1:58
Don't worry about it. There's a link in
2:00
the show notes, so you can just go click
2:01
it. Yeah, the response has been Yeah.
2:04
Well, the response has been really
2:05
tremendous. I really appreciate it. What
2:06
I'll say now, for folks who have read
2:08
it, if you wouldn't mind leaving a
2:10
rating and review wherever you purchased
2:12
it. That would help other folks find it,
2:14
and that would also be tremendous. And
2:15
hey,
2:16
>> let's get it to the New York Times
2:17
bestseller list. Come on, baby.
2:19
>> Yeah, let's do that.
2:22
[laughter]
2:23
To
2:23
>> together we can. and and yeah, again, I
2:26
really appreciate it, folks.
2:41
[music]
2:50
Welcome to the RPGbot podcast. I'm
2:52
Reynold James and with me is Tyler
2:54
Camstra. Hi everybody. And Ashili.
2:56
>> Right now I am dual wielding the twin
2:59
emotions of excitement to be here but
3:02
anticipation that I might have to
3:04
abandon all I know and love. So hey, two
3:09
two conflicting emotions there. Hit you
3:11
with the one two whiplash.
3:13
>> Yeah. For a brief moment, I was trying
3:15
to figure out like why you were going to
3:16
abandon things for two weapon fighting
3:18
and then I remember you you literally
3:20
live in the middle of a disaster zone.
3:21
>> My city's on fire. Yes.
3:23
>> Yeah. [laughter]
3:24
For for folks listening to this in the
3:26
future, hopefully we're getting to the
3:28
tail end of the LA fires, but I guess we
3:30
don't know that yet. It has it's already
3:32
been devastating. I think the last thing
3:34
that I saw is, you know, well over 20
3:37
folks have died in these fires. A lot of
3:38
folks have lost lost their homes, lost
3:41
their businesses. And so this is
3:43
>> Yeah. And I don't I don't mean to laugh
3:45
or m make light jokes, but at the end of
3:48
the day, humor humor is a coping
3:50
mechanism. And I think people grieve in
3:52
different ways. And some people are
3:54
going to want to laugh, some people are
3:55
going to want to cry, and that's okay.
3:56
Whatever helps you get through it. And
3:58
that's kind of what's helping me is a
4:00
good dose of denial and humor. So for
4:03
anybody who's listening, I am safe. I am
4:07
about 11 miles from the closest fire, so
4:10
I think I'm gonna be okay. But my heart
4:13
goes out to everybody who's been
4:14
affected by this fire. It's been
4:16
freaking awful and a logistical
4:18
nightmare, too. Just like so
4:20
disorganized, you know, all the hydrants
4:22
were running out of water and stuff like
4:24
that. And I don't blame the fire
4:25
department. I do not blame I think
4:26
they're they're doing great work and
4:28
they're doing the best they can with
4:29
what they got. But yeah, just stay safe.
4:33
And I think we might be doing a charity
4:34
stream for Recovery of the Wildfire. I
4:37
hope it's looking like things are
4:39
starting to turn in our favor.
4:41
Hopefully, if the winds can freaking die
4:44
down for just a goddamn second, just
4:46
chill, please. But yeah, we'll get
4:49
through it.
4:49
>> Yeah. So,
4:50
>> it's been the worst disaster LA's ever
4:52
seen. I think it's been awful.
4:53
>> Yeah. So, there's not a lot that we can
4:55
do from here on the RPGbot podcast, but
4:58
yeah, you know, keep your ear out and I
5:00
think we're going to do something soon.
5:01
All right, Tyler, we're doing a podcast.
5:03
What is happening?
5:04
>> All right,
5:04
>> that was that was very serious and I
5:06
didn't intend it to. [laughter]
5:08
>> These are these are serious times.
5:11
>> I know.
5:12
>> Hey, we're starting off 2025 with a No.
5:17
[laughter]
5:18
>> No. No.
5:19
>> It's fine.
5:21
>> I'm going to I'm going to stop talking.
5:23
>> Yeah.
5:24
>> Hey, let's talk about some mechanics.
5:26
Some nice safe mechanics about stabbing
5:29
people. Yeah, that [laughter] sounds
5:31
that sounds great. Let's do that.
5:33
>> All right.
5:34
>> Tonight we are talking about two weapon
5:37
fighting. And this is one of those
5:39
>> That's not the card. That's not the
5:40
card.
5:40
>> That's not the card. I plan three cards.
5:43
>> No, no, but we're No, we've we've done
5:45
two weapon fighting before.
5:46
>> Oh, no. Surprisingly, no. We've done
5:49
>> We've been doing this podcast for 4
5:50
years. You can't tell me we haven't done
5:52
two weapon fighting.
5:52
>> We haven't done two weapon fighting. I
5:54
checked.
5:55
>> Apparently not. [laughter] Apparently
5:57
not. We've done we've done fighting
5:58
styles which touches on two weapon
6:00
fighting. We've done weapon masteries
6:03
which touches on two weapon fighting.
6:05
We've done Pathfinder. We've done Dn D.
6:08
We've done Star Wars. We haven't gone
6:10
Actually, we haven't done Star Wars. We
6:11
haven't done Imperial Maladeectum. Shut
6:12
up. You get my point.
6:14
>> Yeah,
6:14
>> we haven't done two weapon fighting
6:16
somehow. So, we're doing it now.
6:18
>> Okay. Oh, look. There's a card on two
6:20
weapon fighting. Let's do that.
6:22
>> Yeah, it it's wild. I gaslit myself into
6:26
thinking that we had done two weapon
6:27
fighting as well, but nope.
6:29
>> Yeah, somehow I had a whole plan to like
6:33
have two beverages when we started this,
6:36
but then I realized I wasn't going to be
6:38
that thirsty, so I just didn't. So, just
6:40
just There you go. Randle's got it. Way
6:42
to go, Randall. Prepared.
6:43
>> Yeah, I've got uh let's call this spicy
6:47
coffee and some water. [laughter]
6:50
>> All right, Curious Quazet is in the
6:52
chat. All I can say is this. If you can
6:54
give me a way to dual wield laser
6:56
pistols, Tyler, I will be very, very
6:57
happy. Quaset, which rule set?
7:00
>> No. No. Don't encourage them.
7:04
>> Oh,
7:04
>> yeah. Um, cuz I made the mistake of
7:08
giving No. Giving one of my mind flares
7:12
that attacked them a laser pistol,
7:15
similar to the ones that the gnome
7:17
camorphs have. And now Quaset has made
7:20
it his mission to find another one so he
7:22
can do a wheel.
7:23
>> Okay. All right. Hang on. I am.
7:26
>> So I need you to give me reasons not to
7:28
do that. [laughter]
7:30
>> Oh, but that's the opposite of what I
7:32
was going to do. Ash. [laughter]
7:35
>> All right.
7:35
>> It's funny to see Tyler in this moment
7:36
with Quaset sitting on one shoulder and
7:38
Ash sitting on the other.
7:39
[clears throat]
7:40
>> Don't do it. Don't do it. You're a good
7:42
person. You know,
7:44
>> would it be fun though? Would it be
7:45
amazing person? Look, I I am compelled
7:48
to do this. I can't find laser pistols
7:50
on D and D Beyond. Okay, I will tell you
7:52
this. We'll get there. But in the 2024
7:56
rules, the two weapon fighting
7:58
requirements no longer require you to
8:00
use melee weapons. So, you can now dual
8:04
wield pistols and crossbows.
8:06
>> Why do you hate me?
8:07
>> Look, we'll get there. Not to the part
8:09
why I hate you. I don't. But we'll get
8:11
to the pistols. All right.
8:12
>> Okay. But what was the joke about the
8:14
two drinks? I want to roll it back to
8:15
the top. Oh, just I was going to have
8:17
two pinina coladas, one for each hand.
8:19
That's that is the joke. That's all I
8:21
had.
8:21
>> Okay. Okay. Cuz the card says, you know,
8:23
I got to have two plus three faucadas.
8:26
>> Yeah, that I that was more clever, but
8:28
the moment is lost.
8:30
>> Okay.
8:30
>> So, when you say sp when you say spicy
8:32
coffee, do you mean like coffee that has
8:34
a little bit of heavy spice to Oh, so
8:37
it's Irish. That's what I thought.
8:38
>> No, no, I I actually just mean straight
8:41
whiskey.
8:42
>> Oh, just whiskey in a coffee cup. There
8:44
you go. Yes. Okay.
8:46
>> All right. So, I'm going to ask a
8:49
fundamental question, gentlemen. Why
8:52
does anyone ever want to engage in two
8:55
weapon fighting?
8:56
>> Because it's cool, man.
8:57
>> It fulfills my fantasy. Somebody at once
9:00
with two weapons.
9:02
>> I mean, have you have you seen people
9:04
fight with two weapons in in movies?
9:06
It's freaking rad, man.
9:08
>> Does seem pretty cool.
9:10
>> The best is the two weapon lightsaber
9:13
dueling. Oh yeah.
9:14
>> Did Obi-Wan do that against Darth Maul?
9:16
I feel like he did
9:16
>> in in the Clone Wars animated series.
9:19
Yes.
9:20
>> Right. Yeah. Yeah. And it was a popular
9:22
stance in the in the Old Republic video
9:24
games, which
9:25
>> Oh, yeah.
9:25
>> Always fun. [laughter]
9:27
Yeah. No, dual weapon fighting is
9:28
awesome. And two guns even more awesome.
9:32
>> Very. Have you ever jumped through the
9:34
air while holding two guns?
9:36
>> Yeah. By the way, for those who
9:38
>> your weapon into the air going,
9:40
>> for those who don't For those who don't
9:41
know, dual wielding guns is a terrible
9:43
idea. [laughter]
9:44
>> Yeah.
9:45
>> Don't do it.
9:47
>> Just got to get real tiny guns.
9:49
>> No, it's just not you. My my my buddy
9:53
who used to be military told me how the
9:55
logistics of it is stupid because a
9:57
normal gun requires both hands to aim
9:59
effectively. Mhm.
10:00
>> And so if you have two guns, you're
10:02
sacrificing accuracy and like heavily
10:05
accuracy to have more bullet spray and
10:07
prey, which isn't an effective way to do
10:10
anything.
10:12
>> Think of it this way. I wasn't going to
10:13
aim well enough to hit anything anyway.
10:15
So now I'm just rolling dice.
10:17
>> Then you shouldn't have a [laughter]
10:20
>> Yes. Now, now I'm just imagining Creger
10:23
sitting behind Fort Kickass go
10:25
suppressing fire.
10:26
>> [laughter]
10:26
>> Oh god, I love that crashing fire. Sir,
10:31
why do you suck at everything?
10:33
[laughter]
10:36
>> Okay, so in all sincerity, like for for
10:38
two weapon fighting, the way that I feel
10:39
about it is like it's hard to
10:41
mechanically add to this to a game
10:43
because if I just get to attack twice
10:45
with my two weapons, then everybody
10:47
should do that because you'd be dumb if
10:49
you didn't do that. And if I only get to
10:52
choose which weapon to attack with, then
10:54
that sucks. So realistically like I need
10:56
to give something up like there has to
10:58
be an opportunity cost for letting me do
11:00
anything awesome or else it becomes
11:02
broken and by default a thing that I
11:03
should do if I'm a Marshall character.
11:05
>> You have exactly hit the mechanical
11:07
design problem for two weapon fighting.
11:09
>> Yeah.
11:10
>> Yeah. Yeah. That's exactly it. Like if
11:12
you just make it free damage it's way
11:14
too good. If you just make it as good as
11:16
just using the same weapon twice, why
11:18
bother? So where do you find that line
11:20
in the middle?
11:21
>> It's tough, man. Yeah. Yeah. I don't
11:23
know.
11:24
And how do how do I opportunity cost you
11:27
into saying I want this instead of that?
11:30
>> Yeah. All right. Well, why don't we
11:31
start in the wayback machine? And now we
11:33
have got
11:36
>> There you go. How well does everyone
11:38
know the Doctor Who theme?
11:42
[laughter]
11:42
>> No, we're doing the we're doing the
11:43
Wayne's World one.
11:44
>> Oh, that's good.
11:45
>> Yeah. They back up.
11:48
[laughter]
11:50
>> Okay. Pick your favorite one. That's a
11:51
gift to you.
11:52
>> Yeah. or all all of them are great.
11:55
>> He's going to leave them all in.
11:56
>> Yeah, but there's like
11:58
>> How many times back have they gone? Oh,
12:01
>> all the way back to third edition. Not
12:04
even 35. Not even Pathfinder first
12:07
edition. All the way to year 2000 and
12:12
30. Third edition.
12:14
>> I think the three third edition is in
12:16
the 90s, which shows how much I know
12:18
about D&D.
12:19
>> It released in 2000.
12:21
>> Crazy.
12:22
>> Yeah. the uh
12:23
>> so fourth edition was extraordinarily
12:26
shortlived.
12:27
>> Yeah. Yeah, it was. All right. So, third
12:29
edition players handbook. In the third
12:32
edition players handbook, we saw for the
12:35
first time the future of what two weapon
12:37
fighting would look like in the RPG
12:38
space. So, I I'm going to say some
12:41
numbers at you that are going to make
12:43
you sad. I'm just going to read the text
12:44
directly cuz that is there's really no
12:47
way to summarize this without making it
12:48
worse. If you wield a second weapon in
12:51
your off hand, you can get one extra
12:54
attack per round with that weapon. Now,
12:56
I'm going to pause there cuz this is
12:57
very much the like, wait, I get to hit
13:00
twice. That feels great. So, let's talk
13:02
about the action economy very quickly.
13:04
In third edition, you had a standard
13:06
action, a move action, and later on they
13:09
would introduce the swift action. The
13:13
typically when you made one attack, you
13:14
would use your standard action. Casting
13:16
a spell was typically a standard action.
13:19
If you needed to do something more
13:20
involved, sometimes you would combine
13:22
your standard action and your move
13:24
action into a full round action. Now, if
13:27
you were going to make multiple weapon
13:29
attacks, nearly always it was as a full
13:32
round action called full attack. Makes
13:35
sense. So, if you wanted to engage in
13:37
two weapon fighting, full attack was how
13:39
you did it. So, like you had to be
13:41
basically in melee already cuz you could
13:43
only step 5 ft and still make a full
13:46
round action. But once you were there,
13:47
like yeah, slice and dice. Good times
13:49
are being had. Now, I'm going to jump
13:51
back into that paragraph. So, if you
13:52
wield a second weapon in your off hand,
13:54
you get you can get one extra attack per
13:57
round with that weapon. You suffer a
13:59
minus 6 penalty with your regular attack
14:02
or attacks with your primary hand and a
14:04
minus 10 penalty to the attack with the
14:07
off hand when you fight. This way you
14:10
can reduce these penalties in two ways,
14:13
which we'll get to in a moment. So the
14:15
number scale is obviously a lot bigger
14:17
in 3x than it is in 5e. But
14:20
surprisingly, like Randall, if someone
14:22
came to you in 5e and said, "Randall, I
14:25
will let you do two weapon fighting, but
14:27
you're going to take minus5 to your
14:30
off-hand attack and minus three to your
14:33
main attack. Would you do that?" Okay,
14:35
so I'm taking a 15% less likely to hit
14:38
with my primary. I'm 25% less likely to
14:41
hit with my secondary. Uh I'm doing
14:44
quick math.
14:47
I I don't think so. That that sounds
14:50
bad.
14:50
>> It is. It is bad.
14:51
>> Yeah, it it sounds like the most likely
14:54
outcome is that I now miss with both
14:56
both weapons unless I absolutely know
14:58
that whatever whatever I'm fighting I'm
15:00
I'm going like their AC is four.
15:03
>> Yeah. Like I'm gonna get two weapon
15:04
fighting to fight this door. Absolutely.
15:06
I'm in. [laughter]
15:08
>> Anything that can move, no.
15:09
>> Yeah, that's pretty much exactly the
15:11
answer. Like the math is just so
15:13
atrocious that you would never do it. So
15:16
then you start looking at the ways that
15:17
you can reduce the penalties. So if your
15:19
off-hand weapon is light, so like if you
15:22
have a long sword in one hand and a
15:24
short sword in the other, which was like
15:25
the go-to combo for a lot of people, if
15:28
your off-hand weapon is light, the
15:29
penalties are reduced by two each. So
15:31
it's now minus 8 for the off hand,
15:33
minus4 for the primary hand. Then the
15:36
two weapon fighting feat lessens the
15:38
primary hand penalty by two. And this
15:41
change between 30 and 36. So or see 30
15:44
and 35. So in third edition, the two
15:46
weapon fighting feat reduced both
15:48
penalties by two. Using an light
15:50
off-hand weapon reduced both penalties
15:52
by two. And then there was another feat
15:54
called ambidextrous that reduced the
15:57
off-hand penalty by four. So, if you had
15:59
two feats and a light weapon in your off
16:02
hand, you could get the penalties down
16:03
to minus two for each attack, which
16:06
let's just call that equivalent to minus
16:08
one to both of your attacks in 5. So,
16:10
like Randall, if you got
16:11
>> that feels great. Yeah,
16:12
>> I'm in. I'm% less likely to hit on
16:14
either. I'm probably going to hit on one
16:16
and I might hit on both.
16:18
>> Yeah. So, yeah, the math is much more
16:20
appealing, but it came at the cost of
16:22
two feats and there were exactly three
16:24
ways in third edition to get there at
16:27
level one. Rangers got two weapon
16:29
fighting as a bonus feat. Fighters got a
16:31
bonus feat at level one. And humans got
16:33
an extra feat at level one. And
16:35
everybody got one feat by default. But
16:37
it like if you wanted to do two weapon
16:39
fighting, you had to be a ranger, a
16:41
fighter, or a human in some combination.
16:44
So it was this massive annoying annoying
16:48
feat tax to make two weapon fighting
16:50
just barely functional. It did get a
16:53
little better in 35. They just got rid
16:54
of the ambidexterity fee cuz they're
16:56
like this is two weapon fighting is not
16:58
so good that we need this extra guard
17:00
rail.
17:00
>> Mer they merged ambidextrous and two
17:02
weapon fighting into two weapon fighting
17:04
and now it's just -2 - 2.
17:06
>> Yes, exactly. Now there were there was
17:09
like a million other things that added
17:11
on to two weapon fighting. Uh there was
17:13
improved two weapon fighting. There was
17:15
greater two weapon fighting. There was
17:17
two weapon rend. Like stacks and stacks
17:20
and stacks of feats cuz it was third
17:22
edition. That's what we had. We had
17:24
feats and we had prestige classes and
17:26
darn it, we were happy.
17:28
>> Me is appropriate.
17:30
>> Closet closet's asking in the chat to
17:32
did two weapon fighting rangers lead to
17:35
drifts or did drift lead to two weapon
17:37
fighting rangers?
17:38
>> That one I don't know. I'm fairly
17:41
certain. I'm fairly certain that drift
17:44
long predates third edition.
17:47
>> All right, I'm going to the internet.
17:48
I'm getting a live answer. Carry on.
17:50
>> Let's ask our Salvatore. I don't know.
17:52
Do you think he'll pick up right now?
17:53
It's late. [laughter]
17:55
>> I don't know what time zone he's he's
17:56
in. He might be on the west coast.
17:58
>> What's up,
17:58
>> Ash? You live on the West Coast. Do you
18:00
know Ra Salvatore?
18:01
>> R Salvatore? Yeah.
18:02
>> Do you know him personally?
18:04
>> Yes.
18:04
>> Yeah, that was the question.
18:06
>> Can you call him right now? We have a
18:07
Dris question.
18:09
>> Cuz everybody in LA knows everybody.
18:11
That's how that works, right?
18:12
>> Yeah. LA's a small town, right?
18:14
>> Yeah, totally. It's not the second
18:15
largest town in America. [laughter]
18:18
>> Okay. Uh,
18:20
>> 1988.
18:22
>> Exactly. So, this predates third
18:24
edition. That's right. Yeah.
18:26
>> Predates second edition. Jeez, Trist and
18:29
I are the same age. Look at us go.
18:31
>> Oh god, that must make you feel really
18:33
old.
18:34
>> My My hairs keep turning white, man.
18:38
Yeah. Honestly, that's like the eighth
18:39
thing today that Tyler's
18:41
>> Yeah, [laughter]
18:43
that in the immortal words of Zuko,
18:45
that's rough, buddy.
18:47
>> Yeah. Oh god, I I saw like I watch a lot
18:50
of D and D creators on various video
18:52
platforms and I saw some creator say
18:54
like I've been playing D and D a really
18:57
long time, like 8 years. I'm like, oh
19:00
god, really? They're going to make me
19:01
feel that old? And then she goes on to
19:03
say, I started when I was a teenager and
19:06
just like like dust. I am dust. I'm
19:09
elderly. I am falling apart. It's It's
19:12
the scene from the end of Saving Private
19:14
Ryan where uh Matt Damon becomes old
19:17
Matt Damon.
19:18
>> Yeah. Odd. All right. So, back to my my
19:21
old man shouts at cloud about third
19:23
edition. So, two weapon fighting was
19:27
really fun in third edition for a lot of
19:30
reasons. And it it really was just I'm
19:32
going to throw just so many attacks at
19:35
my problems. Like, I don't know how I'm
19:37
going to get in Melee first. There were
19:39
ways, but you're going to get into melee
19:41
and you're just going to throw like 10
19:42
attacks at things. It was really popular
19:45
for rogues because you could sneak
19:46
attack on every attack and rogue sneak
19:50
attack damage progressed at the same
19:52
rate it does in 5e. So like if if folks
19:55
looking at 5e are like, "Oh yeah, like
19:57
level 10 rogue 5d6 damage." Like, okay,
20:00
that's fine. It's not amazing on its
20:01
own. Now imagine that, but you're doing
20:03
it like six times in a turn and just
20:07
just throwing mountains of dice at
20:09
people and it felt so good. It really
20:12
did.
20:12
>> Melting things.
20:13
>> Yeah. And then we get to Pathfinder,
20:16
which builds on what 35 had. Like it
20:19
very much kept the 352 up and fighting
20:21
rules perfectly unchanged and then kept
20:24
piling in more feats. There were a bunch
20:26
of feats that let you add dexterity to
20:28
damage instead of strength. So suddenly
20:30
dexterity based two weapon fighting
20:31
builds became very very powerful. There
20:34
were really good throne two weapon
20:36
fighting feats. And then the the fulcata
20:40
the falcata came in I don't remember
20:42
which book but everyone immediately
20:44
realized this thing is a monster. So in
20:48
in third edition you scored a critical
20:51
hit. Like the range at which you scored
20:53
a critical hit varied depending on what
20:55
weapon you were using. like they could
20:56
go as low as like 18 to 20. I think
20:59
there were a couple of oddball weapons
21:01
that could go like 17 to 20 that nobody
21:03
really used. Alternatively, weapons
21:05
could always crit on 20, which was still
21:07
the baseline, but would multiply more.
21:10
So, like a great axe would do triple
21:12
damage. A scythe would do quadruple
21:14
damage.
21:15
>> Yes, sides are awesome. Okay, so I want
21:17
to make sure I understand this. So, you
21:19
have a set of weapons that are a little
21:20
bit like uh what is it? fighter the
21:22
fighter champion ability of like, oh,
21:24
now you crit on 19 to 20 and at a high
21:25
enough level you crit on 18, 19, 20. You
21:27
had weapons that just gave you that.
21:29
>> Well, [clears throat] also crit threat
21:31
manipulation was one of the biggest
21:33
metas Pathfinder one. Like if you were
21:36
any sort of marshall that focused on
21:37
melee weapons or ranged weapons either,
21:40
you wanted to you wanted to take a few
21:42
crit Yeah.
21:43
>> crit specialties that get increased your
21:46
crit threshold, increased like your crit
21:48
damage, had writer effects on crits.
21:51
Yeah,
21:51
>> I think one of one of my friends built a
21:54
character that could crit on like a 12
21:56
or higher. So, yeah, it's insane.
21:59
>> Okay. And so, that's like one class of
22:01
things. Then the other class of weapons
22:02
are like, "Oh, but when you do crit, you
22:04
get to deal two times the damage, three
22:05
times the damage, four times the
22:06
damage." Okay, that sounds really cool.
22:08
And never shall the two meet
22:10
>> until the Falca
22:11
>> until Falcata. Yeah.
22:13
>> Yeah. So, 19 to 20 crit range, triple
22:16
damage on crit. If I remember right,
22:19
like there's something that improves the
22:21
crit range by one. So you could get it
22:23
to like 18 to 20 and then take improved
22:25
critical which doubles it. So then
22:27
you're critting on 15 16 17 18 19 20 and
22:32
then doing triple damage.
22:33
>> So I have a 30% chance of dealing triple
22:35
damage and I'm making multiple attacks
22:37
per turn.
22:38
>> Yeah, cuz you're two weapon fighting
22:39
with these things.
22:40
>> Who cares if I'm taking a penalty? Like
22:42
it's the actual dive roll that matters.
22:44
>> Exactly. I mean, I will just say
22:46
critting with a scythe on my mess, not a
22:49
Marshall character, super dope cuz I
22:53
didn't crit all that often cuz I wasn't
22:55
built for it, but man, when I did
22:57
[laughter]
22:59
>> Okay. Was a crit an automatic hit?
23:01
>> Yes.
23:02
>> No.
23:02
>> Or no? No, it wasn't. Uh, you had to
23:04
roll to confirm. That was the thing. So
23:06
basically what it was is when you when
23:08
you rolled an at 20, you rolled again
23:11
and you saw if you if you hit with a
23:14
normal like a normal modified attack. If
23:16
that attack confirmed, then it was a
23:18
crit.
23:19
>> Yeah. And of course you could get a
23:20
bunch of things that would improve that
23:22
secondary roll. So like plus four from
23:26
power critical I think it was. And then
23:27
you could get like a bunch of other
23:29
bonuses from items. So it basically made
23:31
that trivial as long as you invested in
23:33
it enough. But then you could get like
23:35
highle crit feeds that were like dazing
23:38
critical like oh I have crit you you
23:40
don't get a turn.
23:41
>> Yep.
23:41
>> Okay. I want to I want to make sure that
23:43
I understand this. So let's say the AC
23:45
was 21.
23:47
>> Very low AC.
23:48
>> That's fine. I have no modifier somehow
23:50
magically. And I roll a 20.
23:52
>> You roll at 20.
23:53
>> Yeah. I rolled an at 20. Okay. So I've
23:55
I've crit. Now I need to roll again. But
23:58
if I roll again I can only get a 20. I
23:59
can never get 21. So I I miss.
24:01
>> No.
24:02
>> No no no. It still hits. It's still an
24:04
automatic hit on a natural 20. It is
24:06
still an automatic hit.
24:07
>> It's not a crit then. So if you can't
24:10
confirm, then it does then it's just a
24:12
normal hit.
24:13
>> I think you would still confirm on
24:14
another natural 20.
24:16
>> You would. Yeah, you would still confirm
24:18
on another natural 20. 20 is always
24:20
consider was always considered an
24:22
automatic success.
24:23
>> Yes.
24:23
>> Okay. And then if I had like the fakata,
24:25
so I had like 18 19 20 were considered
24:27
crits. Same rules. I've automatically
24:30
hit with an 18, a 19 or a 20. And now I
24:32
have to roll again. It
24:33
>> It wasn't an automatic hit. You still
24:35
needed to hit if you hit that number
24:38
unless it was a natural 20.
24:40
>> I gota Okay, that's exactly what I'm
24:41
asking. That's okay. I I know it would
24:43
have felt simple at the time and I would
24:45
have learned it. It's like anything else
24:47
that I'm thinking two things. That's a
24:49
little complicated and I feel like it'd
24:50
be really intimidating to a new player
24:52
and a shameful trick. Oh, you've
24:54
succeeded. You got the good number and
24:55
we're all excited about it, but now I
24:57
need you to roll again to see if it
24:58
really was good. Well, the thing is,
25:00
>> oh, dear God. Like, how long would it
25:02
take to resolve the 10 attacks?
25:05
>> So long.
25:06
>> Welcome to Welcome to Pathfinder 1, and
25:10
combat takes for godamn ever.
25:13
>> Yeah.
25:13
>> In Pathfinder 1, like it's it's it's
25:16
abysmal. But what I will say is I was a
25:19
person who really didn't like the
25:20
confirmation of crits when I first
25:22
started playing. I was like, this feels
25:24
overly complicated and stupid. But, you
25:26
know, I think it kind of balances out
25:27
because when you do crit in Pathfinder 1
25:30
and 3X, it's way more devastating and
25:34
more more because you don't just double
25:37
the dice like you do in 5e. You double
25:40
everything.
25:41
>> Yeah.
25:42
>> And if you're and if you're if you have
25:44
like a scythe or something, you're
25:46
quadrupling everything. Any modifiers
25:48
you have, the only thing that doesn't
25:50
get modified is precision damage. That's
25:52
it.
25:53
>> Yeah. So, uh, yeah, two up weapon
25:54
fighting, fishing for critical hits,
25:56
incredibly effective.
25:58
>> So, ironically, rogues had less
26:00
devastating crits in Pathfinder one
26:02
because you can't double sneak attack
26:05
damage cuz it's precision damage,
26:07
>> but you know, you throw enough sneak
26:08
attack dice at things, you don't really
26:10
care.
26:11
>> No. No.
26:13
>> All right, so that gets us out of third
26:15
edition. Let's skip over fourth edition
26:18
cuz I don't remember the rules well
26:20
enough. If I remember right, two weapon
26:22
fighting was basically just you picked
26:23
the two weapon fighting powers. Like
26:26
that is what I remember it being and
26:27
that's fine. Fifth edition. Did I write
26:30
There we go. Yeah, I too far down in the
26:32
card. 2014 D and D 5e. Chances are if
26:36
you're listening to this podcast, you
26:37
know these rules pretty well. Gentlemen,
26:39
would either of you like to dramatically
26:42
read this quote of of rules text that I
26:44
copy pasted into the card? Got you good.
26:48
Uh, okay. When you take the attack
26:50
action. Sorry, I'm gonna try that again.
26:53
>> You use Zach Pranagan in that one. I
26:54
liked it.
26:56
>> Okay, I'll do Zach Branigan or just for
26:58
you, buddy. When you take the attack
27:00
action and attack with a light melee
27:02
weapon that you're holding with one
27:04
hand, you can use a bonus action to
27:06
attack with a different light melee
27:08
weapon that you're holding in the other
27:10
hand. You don't add your ability
27:12
modifier to the damage of the bonus
27:14
attack unless that modifier is negative.
27:19
Inform the men. This
27:20
>> policeman's telling us about his weapon
27:23
holding.
27:24
>> Kip, show them the medal. I won.
27:27
[laughter]
27:28
>> All right. There is also Oh, like
27:30
another little extra sentence. If either
27:32
weapon has the throne property, you can
27:34
throw the weapon instead of making a
27:35
melee attack with it. So, this is what
27:37
let you do two weapon fighting at range.
27:39
You could throw daggers, you could throw
27:40
hand axes. That's it. So, this is what
27:43
everyone is used to from the 2014 5D
27:45
rules where you spend a bonus action to
27:47
make that extra attack. Now, from what
27:49
we know from like what Mike Merles has
27:53
said online, from what Jeremy Crawford
27:55
has said in videos and stuff, when the
27:58
2014 players handbook was written, they
28:01
didn't expect bonus actions to be as
28:04
important as they were. Like Mike Merles
28:07
has said very recently on Twitter like
28:09
the bonus action was his idea and he
28:12
regrets it because like they they needed
28:14
it to limit a few things especially
28:17
multiclassing and they wanted players to
28:19
not think that they had to use the bonus
28:22
action to get everything they could out
28:24
of their character. That is very much
28:26
not what happened.
28:26
>> Wait, he's saying the bonus action in
28:29
general was his idea or the idea to do
28:31
the extra attack with the was his idea?
28:34
The bonus action was his idea if I if I
28:36
remember right from what he said.
28:37
>> I call BS Mike Merles because you know
28:40
why? Because in 35 there was a thing
28:42
called a swift action which is
28:44
essentially the same thing.
28:45
>> I I think he means like the bonus
28:48
bringing the bonus action into 5, not
28:50
like the idea of that specific kind of
28:53
action.
28:53
>> Okay. Gotcha. Gotcha.
28:55
>> Yeah. Should that mechanic exist in 5D?
28:57
I I see where he's coming from because
29:00
in Pathfinder 1 and I think in three 3X
29:03
swift a there was very little things
29:05
that you could do with your swift
29:07
actions. Not a lot of things use swift
29:09
actions. It was mostly like just like a
29:11
temporary buff or something or like a
29:14
setup maneuver or sometimes.
29:16
>> Yeah. or sometimes saying up for like a
29:19
movement like I believe faint you faint
29:22
you could make a swift action if you
29:23
took the right feats but other than that
29:26
it swift actions were really rare
29:28
certainly not the same prevalence that
29:30
bonus actions were
29:32
>> okay and so the the idea of a swift
29:34
action carried over from 3x and and it
29:36
sounds like yeah like let's call it a
29:38
bonus action not everybody needs to use
29:40
it all the time except for now if you're
29:43
if you're optimizing a character and
29:44
you're not finding a way to take
29:46
advantage of your bonus action every
29:47
single turn. You're wasting your time
29:49
and you're doing a bad job of optimizing
29:50
that character.
29:51
>> Yeah. Like I'm trying to think, were
29:53
were there any spells in 3x that used
29:56
swift action? You're muted. You're
29:59
muted.
30:00
>> Probably stuff published in later books,
30:02
but I can't think of anything off the
30:04
top, man.
30:05
>> Was True Strike a swift action?
30:07
>> No. True Strike was a full action and it
30:10
sucked.
30:11
>> So full action True Strike and then next
30:13
round you could use it. Yeah, I remember
30:14
true strike being really good in
30:16
Pathfinder one.
30:17
>> It in 35 at least you cast as an action.
30:21
It only targeted yourself. It lasted one
30:23
round. You got plus 20 to hit, which was
30:25
really nice, but it's like combat might
30:26
be over by then, man. Like just save her
30:30
suck something.
30:30
>> Yeah, I'm going to look it up. We'll
30:32
see.
30:33
>> Curious closet in the chat. So, what
30:34
you're saying is Mike Merl's regret is
30:36
Tyler's fault. You know, if if any of
30:39
the Wizards of the Coast designers want
30:42
to blame me for any of the changes that
30:44
needed to be made in the 2024 rules, my
30:46
email address is [email protected].
30:50
I will [snorts] happily take that
30:51
criticism.
30:52
>> No, you're right. Yeah, it was a
30:53
standard action. Weird. Everybody told
30:55
me that true strike is so good in
30:57
Pathfinder 1.
30:58
>> If you quicken it and then do like
31:00
disintegrate or something, although
31:02
everything spells are always a touch
31:04
attack, so it's like you're never going
31:05
to miss anyway. You know what the
31:07
average touch AC is?
31:10
>> That's not true. Okay, fair enough. But
31:11
that I I've run into many many a
31:15
creature that has a really high touch
31:17
AC. Usually it's it's like something
31:19
like a monk or like uh a ninja or
31:22
something that has really high
31:23
dexterity.
31:24
>> That's true.
31:24
>> What What are What are you talking
31:26
about? A touch. I have different ACs
31:29
depending on what you're doing.
31:31
>> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Welcome.
31:33
>> You also have combat maneuver defense.
31:36
uh called your CMD and a combat maneuver
31:39
bonus which is your CMP.
31:40
>> Mhm.
31:41
>> Oh man, it was wild. Uh welcome to the
31:44
the dark side of Pathfinder one and uh
31:47
3.5. Let me just briefly explain.
31:49
>> Okay, wait wait wait no wait no no no.
31:50
Okay, we have so much podcast to get
31:52
through. Like I just in in 20 seconds
31:54
I'm going to ask one question then let's
31:55
plow through. Does this basically
31:57
resolve to being the same thing as like
31:59
your your reflex DC or your fortitude
32:02
DC? No, actually. Okay. The best way
32:05
that I can I can describe it, so you
32:07
have your regular AC, which takes into
32:09
account your armor, right? So, if you're
32:11
wearing armor, this works exactly like
32:13
5e. Your touch AC discounts any armor
32:16
bonus that you have. So, it's just
32:18
purely your decks based AC.
32:21
>> Yeah.
32:21
>> And then you also you have a third one,
32:23
which is your flatfooted AC, which is
32:25
the opposite. It only takes into account
32:27
your armor, not your deck bonus
32:30
>> cuz you're flatfooted.
32:31
>> Yeah. Exactly. So, which did kind of
32:34
that's the only one that did kind of
32:35
carry over to Pathfinder 2 with the
32:36
offguard, but it's so much simpler. And
32:38
that's just a minus two, which so much
32:41
simpler.
32:42
>> Diamond inheritance a problem in
32:44
JavaScript.
32:44
>> What?
32:45
>> Cuz like one counts my armor, one counts
32:47
my decks, and then I've got the final
32:49
that actually brings both in.
32:50
>> Buddy, this is JavaScript. If you want
32:52
inheritance, you're going to have to
32:53
bring it from home.
32:54
>> Oh my god. This is such a nerdy
32:57
conversation.
32:58
>> But back back to what we were just
33:00
talking about. Yes,
33:02
>> all of them. All of them. But wait, wait
33:04
one second. I was in the middle of
33:05
something.
33:06
>> Yeah.
33:06
>> Okay. Before you came with your
33:08
JavaScript joke, you nerd. [laughter]
33:11
>> So, the reason why we're talking about
33:12
touch AC is all spells with very few
33:16
exceptions targeted people's touch AC.
33:18
So, if you if you had like a spell that
33:20
did a to hit modifier, which it seems
33:23
weird to most people because in 5v
33:25
there's not a lot of those. There were a
33:27
lot in Pathfinder 1. So, you would use
33:30
touch AC for that?
33:31
>> I I know I said we should go, but let's
33:32
stay here for a second longer. Okay. So,
33:35
I there's range spells. It's just the
33:37
range spell uses your touch AC to see
33:39
whether or not uses the enemy's touch
33:42
AC. Yes.
33:42
>> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. [clears throat]
33:44
Fine. Fine.
33:46
>> Yeah, that was my reaction, too. I was
33:48
like, h fine. It it did make me feel
33:50
really good as a witch when my party was
33:53
struggling to hit this heavily armored
33:54
dude and I was just hitting him every
33:56
single time because he is slow as hell.
33:59
He [laughter] has no reflexes to speak
34:01
of. But the there were a few times where
34:04
a guy's AC, his normal AC and his touch
34:08
AC were the same because he didn't wear
34:09
armor and he had unarmored defense and
34:11
it was a nightmare and I hated those
34:12
fights. [laughter]
34:14
>> Okay, actually I'm I'm fully converted
34:16
at this point. I love the idea of like
34:18
yes, I'm a big strong British fighter,
34:21
but the softest magic will like bring me
34:23
to my knees.
34:25
>> Yeah, it did make it did make magic cast
34:28
the disparity between magic casters and
34:30
marshals even more wide.
34:32
>> Yeah.
34:33
>> Magic Well, you think magic caster like
34:35
casters and 5year are powerful? Oh,
34:37
buddy. [laughter]
34:39
>> Pathfinder one magic casters are on
34:41
another level. You can do so much,
34:43
especially since nothing requires
34:45
concentration. Let me repeat.
34:47
>> Nothing requires concentration.
34:50
You can have like Okay, like one or two
34:54
things. I never cast a spell that has
34:56
ever required concentration
34:58
>> because the ones that do suck.
35:00
>> Yeah, they're terrible.
35:01
>> But like I can summon a huge sphere of
35:05
water that can cover a giant so that
35:07
he's basically drowning. I can put down
35:10
a pit with that giant and I can put some
35:13
tentacles over the giant in case he ever
35:15
escapes all at the same time. No
35:18
concentration required. That is insane.
35:21
So if you want to feel like a god, don't
35:24
play 5ev. Play play original D. Play 3.5
35:28
or Pathfinder 1. It is insane and I get
35:31
why people swear by it as a caster. It's
35:34
it's incredible.
35:35
>> I like that Jules Vern special. That
35:36
that sounds pretty good.
35:38
>> All right. Anyway, let's jump back to
35:41
2014 D and D 5e and two weapon fighting,
35:44
which is about as far away from
35:45
spellcasters in third editions as you
35:47
can get. Really?
35:48
>> Yeah.
35:49
>> All right. So, a a question I frequently
35:51
see people get wrong or have
35:54
historically less these days,
35:55
fortunately. But when you're doing two
35:57
weapon fighting, what happens with extra
36:00
attack? Honestly, very little. You do
36:03
not get an additional attack with your
36:05
off-hand weapon. It is literally like so
36:07
you attack with your primary weapon that
36:09
lets you qualify for two weapon
36:10
fighting. At some point later in your
36:12
turn, you can attack with your off-hand
36:14
weapon as a bonus action. And because
36:16
you have an extra attack, you can attack
36:18
with any weapon that you have in your
36:20
hand. So it can be either one of those
36:22
weapons that you're holding. And like
36:23
it'll apply your ability modifiers, all
36:25
of that. It is just a normal attack, but
36:27
it is just one additional attack. So
36:30
because of this two weapon fighting
36:32
builds, when you go from level four to
36:35
five, your damage increases by 50%.
36:39
Every other marshall character that gets
36:41
extra attack, your damage increases by
36:44
100%. So two weapon fighting is very
36:47
very briefly good in the 2014 rules from
36:50
levels 1 through 4 and then as soon as
36:53
everyone gets and gets extra attack, you
36:55
have fallen behind. Like granted, there
36:57
are things that change that. Hunter
36:59
Mark, hex, etc. But at least with the
37:02
player's handbook, just the player's
37:04
hand, like it was rough.
37:05
>> Is that true, though? Because what if
37:07
you also have extra attack? Doesn't that
37:09
just mean that you're in damage
37:10
increases by 150%.
37:13
>> No, because you're making Okay, I think
37:16
percentage is confusing, right? The
37:18
argument you're making is if you don't
37:20
have two weapon fighting, you're going
37:22
from one attack to two attacks per turn
37:24
when you get extra attack. If you do
37:25
have two weapon fighting, you're going
37:27
from two attacks to three attacks. And
37:28
then the question becomes, would you
37:30
rather be making two attacks with a
37:33
different weapon over the three attacks
37:35
with a weapon suitable for two weapon
37:36
fighting?
37:37
>> I see what you're saying. I see what
37:38
you're saying. Got it.
37:39
>> Yeah. And at least early days, the
37:41
answer was two weapon fighting till you
37:43
hit level four and got extra attack and
37:45
then
37:46
>> Yeah. Stop.
37:47
>> Pretty much.
37:48
>> Yeah. Okay. So, I want to very briefly
37:51
look at the dual wielder feat in the
37:54
2014 players handbook. We're going to
37:56
look at it. We're all going to think
37:58
about it. We're all going to look at it
38:00
accu like accusingly. Think about what
38:02
you have done. Come back better. And
38:04
then we're moving on cuz the feat sucks.
38:07
All right. So, so what do we think of
38:09
the two weapon fighting rules? Like
38:10
we've both we've all played 5e for years
38:14
and years and years. We know the system
38:16
pretty well. Guys, what are your
38:18
experiences with two up in fighting?
38:20
>> Underwhelming, I would say. I think I
38:22
used it once and then I never dual wield
38:25
it again. I think the only the only time
38:27
I felt dual wielding was worth it was
38:29
when I was a rogue, especially like a
38:32
swashbuckling rogue cuz I'm not really
38:34
using my bonus action for really
38:36
anything at that point. So, and it's
38:38
just another opportunity to sneak attack
38:40
if your first attack missed. So, I can
38:42
see the benefit there. But if I'm a
38:44
fighter, no, it's not worth it.
38:47
>> Yeah. [laughter]
38:48
>> Yeah, I'm with you there completely. I
38:50
have built many two up and fighting
38:52
characters and have never taken one to
38:55
the table for any extended period,
38:57
unfortunately. Especially later in the
38:59
addition as we kept getting more and
39:00
more useful things to do with the bonus
39:02
action. It just got so hard to leave
39:05
your bonus action free for two weapon
39:08
fighting. Like you could spend two
39:10
rounds in combat setting stuff up with
39:12
your bonus action and then if you got
39:14
your third turn, boy, you would feel so
39:16
special with that one off hand attack,
39:18
but like so many times combat would be
39:20
over before you got to do it. It's like
39:22
why did I bring this extra weapon? I
39:24
could have had a shield. I could have
39:25
been stabbed 10% less.
39:27
>> Yeah. Especially since like fighters and
39:30
pretty much every other marshall has a
39:32
thing to use their bonus action on.
39:34
Yeah. Um, like even rogues, if you're
39:36
not a swashbuckler, you and you're not
39:38
using your bonus action for things,
39:40
you're bad, broke. [laughter]
39:42
>> The whole point is you come in, stab,
39:44
and disengage. But as a swashbuckler,
39:46
like I said, I and it I actually think
39:48
it kind of makes sense for the character
39:50
because swashbuckler classically wields
39:52
a rapier in one hand and a dagger in the
39:54
other. And so it makes sense that you
39:56
can just stab stab and immediately leave
39:59
without having to use your bonus action
40:01
for anything. Because let's be honest,
40:02
who what what melee rogue hides every
40:05
turn? That's just is too much work.
40:06
>> No, that's hard. [laughter]
40:08
>> Like, who are you gonna have cover right
40:10
there and get away with hiding? Doesn't
40:12
make sense.
40:13
>> No, it it doesn't work. Yeah.
40:15
>> Yeah. Okay. So, the the one good thing I
40:18
will say about the 2014 weapon fighting
40:20
rules is like they kind of make sense.
40:22
Like you're doing an extra thing with
40:24
your other hand as a bonus action that
40:27
is separate from most of the rest of
40:28
what you're doing. So, like there's some
40:30
kind of logical sense there. Fine. The
40:33
rest of it's just bad. Like, it's not
40:35
worth your bonus action. Putting the
40:37
fighting style into it to get a few
40:39
extra points of damage on that off-hand
40:41
attack, not worth it when you could have
40:43
any other fighting style. Basically, the
40:45
dual wielder feet is just absolute
40:47
garbage. And doing two weapon fighting
40:50
at range is really, really hard because
40:53
you don't have enough action economy to
40:55
draw enough weapons to keep throwing
40:58
them.
40:58
>> [laughter]
40:59
>> Yeah. And I think a lot of people have
41:00
been using crossbow expert wrong.
41:03
>> Yeah. Absolutely.
41:04
>> Yeah. I see a lot of dual wielding
41:06
crossbow experts. I'm like, I don't
41:08
think it works that way. [laughter]
41:10
>> Explicitly does not.
41:12
>> Yeah.
41:13
>> All right. So, let's get into 2024 D and
41:16
D where hey, it explicitly does work
41:18
that way. Now,
41:19
>> shall I read this in Zangan's voice
41:22
again?
41:22
>> Do it.
41:23
>> Absolutely.
41:24
>> Okay.
41:24
>> Light property. When you take the attack
41:27
action on your turn and attack with a
41:29
light weapon, you may make one extra
41:31
attack as a bonus action later on the
41:33
same turn, that extra attack must be
41:35
made with a different light weapon, and
41:37
you don't add your ability modifier to
41:39
the extra attack's damage, unless that
41:42
modifier is negative. For example, you
41:44
can attack with a shortsord in one hand
41:46
and a dagger in the other using the
41:48
attack action and a bonus action, but
41:51
you don't add your strength or
41:53
dexterity.
41:55
I can't see what I'm looking at, Tyler,
41:57
because you're typing dexterity
41:59
[laughter] or Randall. That's who it
42:01
was. Where was I? I lost my place. Damn
42:04
it, Ke. But [laughter] you don't add
42:06
your strength or dexterity modifier to
42:09
the damage roll of a bonus action unless
42:12
that modifier is negative. K, bring my
42:15
light weapon. [laughter]
42:16
>> Beautiful.
42:18
All right. So, this is very similar to
42:22
the 2014 rules with a couple important
42:24
distinctions. So, very importantly, the
42:27
two weapon fighting rules were their own
42:29
rule in 2014. In the 2024 rules, it's
42:32
just the light weapon property. Like,
42:35
there is no dedicated two weapon
42:37
fighting rule. It is this is just a
42:40
thing you do with light weapons
42:43
specifically. Now, all of the other
42:46
things are basically the same. You're
42:47
doing the bonus action, make the extra
42:49
attack. You don't get to add your
42:50
ability modifier unless it's negative.
42:53
But they did remove the restriction
42:55
limiting you to light weapons or sorry,
42:59
not light weapons. You It has to be
43:00
light weapons. They removed the
43:02
restriction limiting you to melee
43:04
weapons. So now you can do this with
43:06
light ranged weapons which notably
43:09
include pistols, probably laser pistols
43:12
if I remember right, and hand crossbows.
43:14
So now people actually can use two hand
43:19
crossbows. And very importantly, the
43:20
loading property no longer requires a
43:23
free hand, which means now yes, you can
43:26
use two hand crossbows and you don't
43:28
have to worry about reloading.
43:30
>> That would apply to laser pistol,
43:32
wouldn't it?
43:33
>> Yeah. M double fisting laser pistols
43:36
like double fisting a nice champagne
43:40
[laughter]
43:40
velvet velour.
43:44
>> Fine, I'll let it happen. You convinced
43:45
me. [laughter]
43:47
>> Yes.
43:50
>> All right. Okay. So, now we need to take
43:52
a look at the Nick weapon mastery
43:54
because this is the next important piece
43:55
of two weapon fighting in 2024. Randall,
43:58
you put Ash on the spot. So, now I'm
44:00
going to put you on the spot. Read the
44:02
Nick mastery as Kif.
44:05
>> Can you do that voice? I don't [snorts]
44:06
know if I can.
44:08
>> Oh, I don't I don't know if I can. Okay,
44:11
I'll try. When you make the extra attack
44:13
of the light property, you can make it
44:16
as a You can make it as part of the
44:19
attack action instead of as a bonus
44:21
action. You can make this extra attack
44:23
only once per turn.
44:25
>> Kif, you're depressing the crew with
44:27
your modeling attitude. [laughter]
44:30
>> Yes. Nobody cares, Captain. And spare me
44:33
the weary sigh for once. [laughter]
44:37
>> Okay, sir.
44:38
>> So, very important. The Nick weapon
44:41
mastery, if you have that mastery and
44:43
you're using a Nick weapon, lets you
44:44
make this extra attack as part of the
44:47
attack action. So, you no longer need to
44:49
spend your bonus action to do it. Now,
44:52
it does clarify you can only make this
44:54
attack this extra attack once per turn.
44:56
So, you can't then turn around and also
44:59
do it as a bonus action. So, like you're
45:01
a level 20 fighter, you have extra extra
45:03
extra attack, you make four attacks with
45:05
your primary weapon, you still only get
45:08
one with the off-hand weapon, but it
45:10
doesn't eat your bonus action anymore.
45:11
So, like, that's nice.
45:13
>> That's fine.
45:14
>> Yeah. I do love that the example in the
45:15
light property calls out the shortsord
45:17
and dagger combo, which is pretty much
45:20
the go-to. Very frequently when you're
45:22
doing two weapon fighting, your primary
45:23
weapon will have the Vex property and
45:26
your secondary weapon will have the Nick
45:28
property. And for whatever reason, just
45:29
the good two weapon fighting rules just
45:32
do that.
45:33
>> Quaset asked us if if me and Randall are
45:35
going to make those our two characters
45:37
when runs Star Wars. [laughter]
45:40
>> Oh my god.
45:41
>> I I think we I think we kind of have to
45:43
now.
45:43
>> Kind of.
45:44
>> Assuming Assuming Billy West doesn't sue
45:46
us. [laughter]
45:48
>> Look, if they care [clears throat]
45:49
enough about us to sue us, we'll roll
45:52
over and apologize and we're going to
45:55
use that for marketing purposes. I don't
45:57
know. It'll be great.
45:57
>> I know. I'd be I'd be down. Yeah.
45:59
>> Yeah. We If If he wants to come do Zap
46:02
Brandan on the podcast, he can come do
46:04
Zap Brick on the podcast.
46:05
>> Otherwise,
46:06
>> if you think if you think we're doing a
46:07
bad Yeah. If we think we're doing a bad
46:09
impression, please come on and show us
46:11
how how much fools we are.
46:14
>> Yes. All right. So, I now want to look
46:15
at the dual wielder feet. So, I am
46:18
There's a joke in here about me looking
46:20
like Fry with a beard. I'm sure
46:23
>> I can see it.
46:24
>> We're just going to let it go. Just
46:25
here. will push my hair up in the front
46:26
and call me executive delivery boy or
46:29
something. All right, the dual wielder
46:31
feet when you take the attack action on
46:33
your turn.
46:34
>> Boo boo. Do a fry voice. You made us do
46:37
a voice.
46:38
>> I am not good at impression.
46:40
>> Randall didn't know how to do a KIF
46:42
voice and he tried anyway cuz he's a
46:44
trooper. You don't get to weasel out of
46:46
this. [laughter]
46:48
>> I think I'm going to have to like right
46:51
this second. I can't think of words.
46:54
voices. [laughter]
46:56
>> Look, he's he's not sure how to sound
46:58
like himself right now.
46:59
>> I I will admit Fry is a tough one to to
47:02
do an impression of. I don't think I
47:04
even I sound super high pitched like
47:07
isn't that
47:08
>> Look, you just have to sound very
47:10
excitable and nasal and I already sound
47:13
like that.
47:14
>> Fine. Cop out. Attack him on Twitter.
47:18
>> Tyler, why not Zenberg? because the
47:21
people wouldn't be able to understand
47:23
what I'm saying.
47:24
>> That's fair. That's That is a totally
47:26
valid.
47:26
>> When you take the attack action on your
47:28
turn and attack with a weapon that has
47:30
the light property, you can make one
47:32
extra attack as a bonus action later on
47:34
the same turn with a different weapon,
47:36
which must be a melee weapon that lacks
47:39
the two-handed property. You don't add
47:41
your ability modifier to the extra
47:43
attacks damage unless that modifier is
47:45
negative. Now, if you read that text,
47:47
you stare at that text, you listen to me
47:50
say it, there's exactly one obvious
47:53
question, and I'm going to wait for
47:54
either of you guys to arrive at that
47:56
question and ask it.
47:57
>> Yeah, I think you're overestimating our
47:59
smart capabilities.
48:00
>> All right, folks in the chat, feel free
48:02
to chime in here and see if you can beat
48:03
Randall to the punch.
48:04
>> It's a bit complicated,
48:07
first off.
48:07
>> Yeah.
48:08
>> Yeah.
48:09
>> So, if you stare at it long enough, you
48:10
will eventually land on the words.
48:12
>> Oh, no.
48:13
>> Okay. Wait. Is it that if I'm using
48:15
Nick, which didn't make me use the bonus
48:18
action? Yeah. I don't get to take
48:20
advantage of You can make one extra
48:22
attack as a bonus action later on the
48:23
same turn. Oh, if I'm using Nick, I can
48:25
make three attacks, right?
48:26
>> There you go.
48:27
>> Okay. Yeah. Cuz Nick would let me
48:30
without using my bonus action make the
48:32
extra attack. And then with the dual
48:33
wielder, I can burn my bonus action to
48:35
make a third attack.
48:36
>> Yes.
48:37
>> Got it. Now, where where people get
48:40
caught up on this, the Nick mastery, the
48:42
last sentence is you can make this extra
48:44
attack only once per turn. And then
48:46
people look at dual wielder and they're
48:48
like, "Wait, but it's just changing the
48:50
bonus action." No, this is a completely
48:53
separate bonus action from the one
48:54
granted by the light weapon property.
48:56
You can explicitly make an additional
49:00
attack with a different weapon as a
49:02
bonus action. Which means if you take
49:04
this at level four, you can go attack
49:06
with a light weapon. Attack with a light
49:08
weapon, my offh hand that has the nick
49:10
property, and then as a bonus action,
49:12
attack with that weapon again. Now,
49:14
another weird thing in here, the weapon
49:16
must be a melee weapon that lacks the
49:18
two-handed property. So, technically,
49:20
you could like shortsword, dagger with
49:24
the nick property, pull out a completely
49:26
different weapon, and then attack with
49:28
that. [laughter]
49:29
I don't know why you would actually. No,
49:31
I do know why you would. weapon
49:33
masteries. Like if you're a fighter and
49:34
you've got like eight weapon masteries,
49:36
you can swap weapons every time you make
49:38
an attack as part of the attack action.
49:40
So just like attack, she weapon, attack,
49:43
sheath the weapon. Like just like in
49:44
out, in out, get all of those weapon
49:46
masteries, debuffs, shove, topple,
49:49
cudigra, nick, nicholas, like all those
49:53
masteries in there. Could Could my Nick
49:55
Could I use my Nick extra attack, which
49:57
is not the bonus action, to throw a
49:58
weapon? Like I'm imagining like bite the
50:00
melee person next to me, throw, you
50:03
know, the a dagger at the person
50:05
attacking my wizard and then pull out
50:07
the second shortsword and strike the
50:08
person in front of me again.
50:10
>> Yeah, you absolutely could.
50:11
>> Awesome. Yeah,
50:12
>> I do that then. Where do I roll?
50:14
>> Where do you roll? At the table? I don't
50:16
know.
50:16
>> My brain hurt.
50:17
>> Yes. Yes.
50:19
>> No. Likey.
50:20
>> Okay, now I'm I'm going to make this
50:22
very like the slightest bit more
50:23
annoying.
50:24
>> No, make it better.
50:26
>> Do it. Do it. So when the players
50:28
handbook like first got out to content
50:31
creators and stuff like people
50:33
immediately noticed this and were like
50:35
this seems too good to be true. Are we
50:38
misinterpreting this Jeremy Crawford in
50:41
the stupidest place possible? The
50:43
stupidest place in a YouTube comment
50:46
under a dungeon dudes video like why in
50:49
a YouTube comment responded yes.
50:53
Yeah, right.
50:54
>> Okay. Was it really him or was he just
50:55
somebody who has like the Jeremy
50:56
Crawford handle?
50:57
>> It was his account.
50:59
>> Okay.
50:59
>> All right.
51:00
>> But yeah, he said yes, this is exactly
51:02
how it is intended to work. So like it
51:05
feels a little counterintuitive. It
51:07
feels too good to be true for two weapon
51:09
fighting builds, but this is exactly how
51:12
they wanted two weapon fighting to work
51:13
in the 2024 rules.
51:15
>> So it went from being useless to being
51:19
ridiculously incredible
51:21
>> kind. Yeah. But there's an opportunity
51:24
cost to it, right? Like the what weapons
51:26
have nick mastery?
51:27
>> Daggers, scimitars,
51:29
light hammers, hand axes.
51:32
>> Okay. So reasonable, but none of them
51:34
are like world changers and having take
51:36
the dual wielder feed as opposed to
51:38
anything else.
51:39
>> Yeah. And it does still eat your bonus
51:40
action to get the extra attack there.
51:43
And even with the the two weapon
51:45
fighting fighting style, dual wielder,
51:47
that extra attack still doesn't apply
51:49
your ability modifier. So, it's still
51:51
just like a d6 from a scimitar or
51:53
whatever.
51:53
>> Okay, that's not too bad.
51:54
>> Yeah, but where you're getting the extra
51:56
damage then becomes like hex, hunter
51:59
mark, conjure minor elementals, magic
52:02
weapons, all kinds of stuff like that.
52:05
[laughter]
52:06
>> Delat light hammer and sickle combo does
52:08
have style points though. Really does.
52:10
>> Yes, comrade.
52:12
All right. So, gentlemen, having now
52:15
roughly mastered two weapon fighting in
52:18
the 2024 rules, how do you think it
52:19
compares to the 2014 rules?
52:21
>> Definitely better.
52:23
>> Yeah, better. And and also, I think is a
52:25
good showcase of the weapon properties
52:28
in 2024. Like, here's mechanics that
52:30
people didn't love in 2014. They really
52:32
weren't getting play, especially at
52:33
higher levels. Okay, great. Let's fold
52:36
them into weapon mastery and let's
52:37
expand it. Al although now again, let's
52:40
we're all gonna spend all of our time
52:41
pushing in people across the B
52:42
battlefield rather than messing around
52:44
with any of this
52:45
>> kind of. Yeah, [laughter]
52:47
>> because the opportunity cost of using
52:49
these weapons is that I'm not shoving
52:51
people off cliffs.
52:52
>> This is true.
52:53
>> Well, since we referenced the hammer and
52:54
sickle, I'M GOING TO THE ONE place that
52:57
hasn't been corrupted by capitalism.
53:00
PATHFINDER 2. [laughter]
53:04
>> SURE. OKAY.
53:07
uh [laughter]
53:08
our action economy, comrade,
53:13
>> someone in the chat mentioned red alert,
53:16
so I felt it was necessary. [laughter]
53:19
>> Uh all right. Yeah, let's jump to PF2.
53:22
So for a quick refresher on the action
53:24
economy and Pathfinder second edition,
53:26
you get three actions and a reaction.
53:28
That's your turn. Sometimes actions can
53:31
be combined into activities, quote
53:33
unquote, which take two or three
53:35
actions, but most of the things you're
53:38
going to, well, I can't really say most.
53:40
A lot of the things you're going to do
53:41
in combat, like stabbing a dude, is one
53:44
action. Very important. Stabbing a dude,
53:46
very important in Pathfinder.
53:47
>> Love stabbing a dude.
53:49
>> Yeah,
53:51
>> it's one of my favorite pastimes, too.
53:53
[laughter]
53:53
>> Technically, that is not a lie.
53:57
>> Yeah. [clears throat]
53:58
Uh, all right. So I I should also touch
54:00
and touch on the multiple attack
54:02
penalty. So since you can attack as a
54:04
single action and you get three actions,
54:06
the way that they balance that in
54:08
Pathfinder second edition is your second
54:10
attack and then any further attacks take
54:12
a stacking penalty. So it is minus five
54:15
for your second attack, minus 10 for
54:17
every attack after that. So this the the
54:20
multiple attack penalty or map
54:23
>> un unless you use an agile weapon.
54:26
>> That's right. which reduces it to minus4
54:28
and minus8 and then you're a ranger and
54:30
you take the flurry style and then it's
54:32
minus2 and minus 6 I think and like
54:35
there there are ways to reduce it but
54:36
for for the baseline it's -5 - 10 now
54:40
you're probably looking at this and
54:41
thinking like but wait where does two up
54:43
weapon fighting it and come in it's very
54:45
simple you make one of your attacks with
54:47
your first weapon and then you make your
54:48
second attack with your other weapon
54:50
which has that and then you have that uh
54:52
multiple attack penalty on that second
54:54
attack with the off-hand weapon now This
54:56
is where agile weapons come in. And it's
54:58
very common for people to use a
55:00
non-aggile weapon in your primary hand,
55:02
an agile weapon in your off hand, like a
55:04
dagger, a a main gou. Like there's
55:07
there's a million of them. There are so
55:09
many weapons in Pathfinder. Like
55:11
hundreds [clears throat] of weapons.
55:12
>> Yeah, there's a lot.
55:14
>> Yeah. Yeah. The the main gouge is really
55:17
like one of my favorites personally for
55:19
two weapon fighting. It is very much a
55:21
parrying dagger. The damage on it kind
55:23
of sucks, but you can use it to parry
55:25
and boost your AC, which feels like very
55:28
swashbucklery.
55:29
>> It's almost like there's a class that's
55:31
called that.
55:32
>> Yes. So, weapon properties get to be a
55:35
lot of fun. Pathfinder, and you can
55:37
really find weapons that cater to very
55:40
specifically how you want to play your
55:41
character, and that's really awesome,
55:42
and I love that a lot. But two weapon
55:45
fighting does get better from there. So,
55:47
it's not just like, oh, my off-hand
55:49
weapon has a slightly better attack
55:52
bonus on my second attack, and it might
55:53
have different properties. No, it's
55:55
better than that. Most marshall classes
55:57
will have, I guess I can't say most at
55:59
this point. Several marshall classes at
56:01
this point have feats that support two
56:03
fighting. So, rogue, ranger, fighter, I
56:07
think barbarian,
56:08
>> gunslinger as well. Gunslinger, they
56:10
have an entire subclass dedicated to two
56:13
pistol fighting. I think it's called the
56:14
pistol,
56:15
>> I think. No, I can't. Yeah, I think
56:18
Pistol, one of your options is dual
56:20
wielding pistols. Yeah, just get those
56:21
pepper boxes and get to it.
56:23
>> Yep. Yep.
56:24
>> So, just reading off the names, Rogue
56:26
gets twin faint, which lets you attack
56:28
with one hand and then sneak attack with
56:30
the other. Ranger gets twin takedown. If
56:33
I remember right, you attack with both
56:34
weapons at the same time, and then like
56:36
resistances only apply once. Fighter
56:39
gets a double slice and also twin parry,
56:41
which lets you use parry weapons better
56:43
and boost your AC more. or so like that
56:46
that main gouch suddenly becomes as
56:48
effective as using an actual shield
56:50
which is cool. So all of these feats
56:52
will offer ways to mitigate the
56:54
drawbacks from two up and fighting
56:56
provide additional benefits to using two
56:58
up and fighting. So like you'll pick
56:59
these up over the course of your
57:01
character's career and get gradually
57:03
better. And it's more than just oh I get
57:06
another attack. It's like you get to do
57:08
something unique that other characters
57:10
don't get to do specifically because
57:11
you're using two weapons. It feels
57:13
really cool. Yeah, it seems like there's
57:15
a lot of options to build interesting
57:17
and unique twin fighting character.
57:20
>> Yeah. And again, and again, so right
57:22
there is an opportunity cost. You're
57:23
taking these feats as opposed to other
57:25
things that you might take, but in
57:26
[clears throat] exchange, the penalty of
57:28
two weapon fighting is is further
57:29
diminished, making it more fun and more
57:31
rewarding to engage in it.
57:33
>> Curious Quazet has corrected me in the
57:34
chat. Apparently, it's pronounced Main
57:36
Gosh, not not Gaus, like G- A C H E.
57:40
>> Gorch. Main Gorch. You know what? That's
57:43
That's my head cannon now. Garsh,
57:46
>> every time you use it, you just get
57:48
possessed by the spirit of Goofy.
57:50
>> Yeah, we we we have a swashbuckler in
57:52
our party. Tyler, please don't.
57:54
>> That's fine. [laughter]
57:56
>> Delta, it took me a lot of time to
57:58
realize Tyler was attempting to
58:00
pronounce French. Attempting [laughter]
58:04
>> to be fair to Tyler, I probably would
58:05
have pronounced it gouch, too.
58:07
>> Yeah. Look, I never tried like goucha,
58:10
like a hard ch
58:12
>> ga. Yeah, like ga chameleon. I don't
58:14
know.
58:15
>> I mean, it's it's the same for me when I
58:17
hear people butcher Spanish. Like, you
58:20
know, chipotle.
58:21
>> I'll have the chipotle with the
58:22
jalapenos.
58:23
>> Oh, jeez.
58:24
>> And the green child.
58:26
>> Does Does anybody say that seriously,
58:28
though? Like, isn't that always sarcasm?
58:30
>> No. Oh,
58:32
>> no.
58:32
>> Yeah.
58:33
>> You haven't been anywhere near Texas, my
58:35
friend. [laughter]
58:36
>> Oh, god. In Texas, that's not There's no
58:38
excuse.
58:39
>> I I would think, but I I spent almost
58:43
half my life like 45 minutes from the
58:45
Texas border. [laughter]
58:48
>> You lived Yeah. You lived in Louisiana.
58:50
Yeah. No, I mean the thing was is like I
58:52
worked in customer service in New Mexico
58:55
and we would get and and no shame on
58:57
Texans. Okay. If you're a Texas person
58:59
who says it who says it well, I'm so
59:01
happy for you and thank you for doing
59:03
that. Well, I'm just saying people who
59:06
did mispronounce it were mostly Texans.
59:08
And you know how I could tell they were
59:10
Texans? Because they had a stereotypical
59:13
Texan accent or they told me
59:15
>> they [laughter]
59:16
Well, okay. It is actually funny you say
59:18
that. So, there's like a long list of
59:20
French names in Louisiana that the like
59:22
the very real phenomenon of like you
59:24
drive into Texas and everybody who has
59:26
that family name pronounces it a very
59:28
Americanized like a Bear becomes Heert.
59:31
Okay. The name of the novela Melasal
59:34
Melanch like all of these names just get
59:36
butchered and it's like oh you must be
59:37
from Texas. How do you know? Because you
59:39
mispronounce your own last name.
59:41
>> [laughter]
59:42
>> I was I was watching this etiquette
59:44
video and this guy was reading a very
59:46
entitled and uh angry tweet that he was
59:48
trying to answer and he says, "Oh,
59:50
they're from Austin, Texas." That makes
59:52
so much sense. That explains so much.
59:54
[laughter]
59:55
>> Just like the shade, sir. Jesus.
59:58
>> All right. Austin is awesome.
1:00:00
>> Austin is great. I do like [laughter]
1:00:02
Austin. Yeah.
1:00:03
>> All right. Back on topic.
1:00:05
>> Texas
1:00:07
weapon fighting, sir. We should just we
1:00:09
should just do
1:00:10
these Sam.
1:00:12
>> We should do Tyler, Randall, and Ash.
1:00:14
Just talk about their thoughts on the 50
1:00:17
states of America. [laughter]
1:00:20
>> All right, Pathfinder, if you're going
1:00:22
to do two weapon fighting, you need to
1:00:24
have doubling rings. You need to have
1:00:27
doubling rings. You need to have
1:00:28
doubling rings. I cannot say this
1:00:30
enough, Tyler. What's a doubling ring?
1:00:32
>> Yeah, what's a doubling ring?
1:00:33
>> A doubling ring. So, there's the lesser
1:00:35
rings and the greater rings. the lesser
1:00:37
rings when you're when you're wearing
1:00:39
doubling rings and wielding two weapons,
1:00:41
the the fundamental runes of one weapon
1:00:45
are duplicated on the other. So like
1:00:47
let's say I have a plus one striking
1:00:49
dagger in one hand and just a regular
1:00:51
bog standard dagger in the other. I
1:00:53
don't want to spend the money to make
1:00:56
both of my weapons good. So I get
1:00:57
doubling rings instead. And now both of
1:00:59
my daggers are plus one striking daggers
1:01:02
and I am happy. Now, a few levels later,
1:01:05
I've got some cool property runes. My
1:01:07
plus one striking dagger is a plus one
1:01:09
striking flaming glowing dagger. Name
1:01:13
any other rune. I don't know. But it's
1:01:15
real cool. But the problem with the
1:01:16
lesser ring is it only copies the
1:01:18
fundamental rune. So, my other dagger is
1:01:20
still just plus one striking. And it's
1:01:21
sad. So, I get the greater doubling
1:01:24
rings and they copy all of the runes.
1:01:27
And now both of my daggers get to be
1:01:29
plus one striking, flaming, and glowing.
1:01:32
And that makes me happy.
1:01:34
>> Got it.
1:01:34
>> Yeah, that makes a lot of sense.
1:01:35
>> Don't Don't you don't use two weapon
1:01:38
fighting without doubling rings unless
1:01:40
you want to make Tyler sad.
1:01:41
>> Yes.
1:01:42
>> What's the cost of a doubling
1:01:43
[clears throat] ring?
1:01:44
>> The if I remember right, the basic
1:01:46
doubling rings are like a level two or
1:01:48
three magic item. Like they're very very
1:01:51
inexpensive.
1:01:52
>> Okay.
1:01:52
>> I think the the greater ones are like
1:01:54
level eight or something. Check archives
1:01:56
of nethas. But like the the reason you
1:01:58
know that they expect you to have these
1:02:00
is the pregen two weapon fighting
1:02:03
characters always have them.
1:02:05
>> Okay, that makes sense.
1:02:06
>> Yeah. Okay, so we don't have a ton of
1:02:08
time left, so I'm just going to very
1:02:09
quickly touch on some other systems. So,
1:02:12
a lot of other RPGs will have a
1:02:14
twoaction system in combat where you
1:02:16
have like a major action and a minor
1:02:18
action of some kind. Like in in Star
1:02:21
Wars, it's called your action and your
1:02:24
move. In Imperial Maladictum, it's your
1:02:26
action and your maneuver. I think alien
1:02:28
>> you got those switched,
1:02:29
>> did I?
1:02:30
>> According to your script, at least.
1:02:32
>> Yeah. Yes. Like action and maneuver.
1:02:35
Action and move. Whatever. Anyway, so
1:02:37
very frequently when you engage in two
1:02:39
weapon fighting in these systems, if you
1:02:41
attack with two weapons, attacking is
1:02:43
still just your action. So, you do still
1:02:45
have your maneuver to go and do other
1:02:47
things. But that gets us into the
1:02:48
situation of like, okay, if I'm just
1:02:50
going to get double damage, why would I
1:02:52
not always do this? And every system
1:02:54
I've looked at has a slightly different
1:02:56
approach for how to make this work. In
1:02:58
Imperium Maladictum, like you take
1:03:00
penalties to your attack, so it's harder
1:03:03
to hit, but if you hit, you do get
1:03:04
damage from both weapons. In Star Wars,
1:03:07
if you hit, you automatically hit with
1:03:09
your primary weapon, but you have to
1:03:11
spend the the like bonus symbols, like
1:03:14
something small, but good symbols. You
1:03:16
spend those two of them to hit with your
1:03:18
offhand weapon, and then anything after
1:03:20
that you can do fun stuff with. So like
1:03:22
there is a cost. Star Wars also makes
1:03:24
you use like the worst stats between
1:03:27
those two weapons. So like if you're
1:03:29
using two different things and you're
1:03:30
really bad with one of them and really
1:03:32
good with the other, you're going to
1:03:33
suffer. So don't do that. But every
1:03:36
system has a rule for this. There is
1:03:38
almost always a cost to two weapon
1:03:40
fighting compared to just using one
1:03:42
weapon. And it's always like I am paying
1:03:44
the opportunity cost of whatever that is
1:03:47
to maybe get more damage.
1:03:49
>> All right. This week we have a question
1:03:50
of the week. Uh this week our question
1:03:52
of the week comes to us from Mythic
1:03:54
Bluehill.
1:03:56
>> What an awesome name.
1:03:57
>> Yeah,
1:03:57
>> that's pretty. Yeah. In your opinion,
1:03:59
what are the elements of a great
1:04:01
convention game? Any particular
1:04:03
favorites and insights on con games?
1:04:05
>> I don't have any insights to offer cuz
1:04:07
I've been to one D and D convention and
1:04:09
I don't feel I'm qualified to answer it.
1:04:11
So, I'll leave the question to you
1:04:13
fellas.
1:04:15
>> Okay. [clears throat] I I've got a
1:04:16
couple things here. If it is like the
1:04:18
game describing who it is meant for, I
1:04:21
think is tremendous. A lot of
1:04:22
conventions will do the thing of saying
1:04:24
like, "Hey, this is beginner welcome or
1:04:26
this is or basically usually they'll
1:04:28
just leave that line out if it isn't
1:04:30
beginner welcome." They're not like, you
1:04:31
know, Frog Hearts only, but that's huge.
1:04:32
So like sitting down for the first time
1:04:34
and playing a game you've never played
1:04:35
before, then having the adventure be
1:04:38
made to walk you through the skills
1:04:39
without there having to be a tutorial.
1:04:41
Because ideally, I want to sit down, I
1:04:43
want you to tell me the most very basic
1:04:44
thing. hand me a pregen character sheet
1:04:47
and then we're going to go and let the
1:04:48
game teach me versus if you're sitting
1:04:50
down to something like Adventures League
1:04:52
or Pathfinder Society. Having the
1:04:54
adventures set up to basically touch
1:04:57
everything and give everybody time to
1:04:58
shine, right? So, are we playing 2
1:05:00
hours? Are we playing 4 hours? What do I
1:05:02
want? I want an amount of combat that
1:05:05
matches that pace. I want degrees of
1:05:07
success where at the end of it, you
1:05:09
could say like you nailed it or maybe we
1:05:11
missed a little bit of something. I love
1:05:12
a good puzzle because I'm a sucker for a
1:05:14
puzzle and I want there to be a
1:05:17
reasonable opportunity for one or more
1:05:20
of us to die.
1:05:21
>> Okay, that's all I want.
1:05:23
>> Okay. All right. In my opinion,
1:05:25
communicating what the game is ahead of
1:05:28
time is absolutely critical. Like
1:05:29
Randall, you hit on this a bit, like is
1:05:31
it beginner friendly or not? So, yeah,
1:05:34
communicating what is the expected level
1:05:35
of experience from your players? What is
1:05:38
the premise of the game that you're
1:05:40
going to be running? Are there any
1:05:42
things that charact that players might
1:05:43
need to be concerned about like horror
1:05:45
elements, sensitive topics, anything
1:05:48
that might make people uncomfortable?
1:05:50
All of those things, general tone,
1:05:52
themes, like people shouldn't go in and
1:05:55
be surprised by what they're playing.
1:05:57
That's always bad when you get to the
1:05:58
table. I agree with Randall. Like it if
1:06:00
you have to teach the mechanics, it
1:06:02
should be quick. You've got to have
1:06:03
pre-gens unless building a character is
1:06:06
specifically part of the session cuz
1:06:07
like in some games that's a thing. like
1:06:09
Murkborg, you build a character in like
1:06:11
30 seconds and you're you're going to
1:06:12
have to do it a few times. So, you kind
1:06:14
of have to know how it works. So,
1:06:15
pregens a well formatted character sheet
1:06:19
makes such a difference. Like, you can
1:06:22
kind of expect everybody to know how to
1:06:24
play D and D unless it's explicitly a
1:06:26
beginner's D and D game, but like any
1:06:28
other system, have a character sheet
1:06:30
that pe people can look at and like
1:06:32
parse in like 60 seconds. And then once
1:06:35
you're in the game, just on rails, like
1:06:37
99% of the time, you're need your game
1:06:40
needs to be on rails. There needs to be
1:06:42
a very very clear plot direction. Like
1:06:44
no one should have to wonder like did we
1:06:47
miss the plot hook for this entire
1:06:48
session that we're have that we're now
1:06:50
playing. Like that's miserable for
1:06:52
everybody. You get the end of 4 hours,
1:06:53
no one's accomplished anything, everyone
1:06:55
walks away sad. Like don't do that. Just
1:06:58
give me a nice linear dungeon or like a
1:07:00
very obvious mystery that I'm supposed
1:07:02
to investigate and solve. Like we're not
1:07:05
here to to impress anybody usually. Just
1:07:08
like it. It's fine. It's a convention
1:07:10
game. We're here to have a good time and
1:07:12
walk away with a good story to tell.
1:07:14
>> Oldh Hill Leisure Illuminati. Hey,
1:07:17
>> I'm Reynold James. You'll find me at
1:07:18
amateurjack.com and on Twitter and
1:07:20
Instagram, Jackamate. Also, be sure to
1:07:22
check out my new nolla grimmoire tale.
1:07:25
There's a link in the description. And
1:07:26
if you have already if you have already
1:07:28
read it, yeah, if you wouldn't mind
1:07:29
reading and reviewing it, that'd be
1:07:31
tremendous for me to help other people
1:07:32
find it. I'm Tyler Cam. You'll find me
1:07:34
on RPGbot.net.
1:07:36
Dual wielding D&D and also Pathfinder
1:07:39
and trying to find some way to fit Tales
1:07:41
of the Valiant in there somewhere. Maybe
1:07:43
in my teeth, who knows? Facebook and
1:07:45
Twitter, RPG, B, DOT, NE, most other
1:07:49
socials as RPGbot.
1:07:51
>> Hey, you could just be like Zoro from
1:07:52
One Piece. He does he does use his third
1:07:55
sword in his
1:07:55
>> teeth. There you go. All right.
1:07:56
[laughter]
1:07:57
>> And I'm Ash Eli. You can find me on
1:07:59
Twitter, a dual wielding both consumate
1:08:02
professional and a guy who has no idea
1:08:04
what he's doing [laughter]
1:08:05
on Twitter at Graven Ashes. If you want
1:08:08
to hire me to run a game for you, you
1:08:10
can find me on startling.games,
1:08:12
link in the description. I'm going to be
1:08:14
starting some new games this year, so
1:08:16
keep an eye out for that.
1:08:18
>> All right, folks. The year is 2025.
1:08:20
Things could be better. O,
1:08:23
>> that's that's too real.
1:08:25
>> Yeah, we are depressed now. Okay, sorry.
1:08:27
I'll pick it up. I'll pick it up. Uh,
1:08:29
we're glad you're here. We think it's
1:08:30
awesome. We want to grow the show. We
1:08:32
want to have more folks listening
1:08:33
because ultimately that's what helps us
1:08:35
do this podcast every week. And so, if
1:08:37
you could do us a favor if you rate us
1:08:38
and reviewed us wherever you get your
1:08:39
fine podcast, that would help other
1:08:41
folks discover us and it would be
1:08:42
tremendous. We There are links to I
1:08:45
don't know. I can't talk
1:08:46
>> things
1:08:47
>> there. There are links to things. Here's
1:08:49
the deal. We talk about a lot of books
1:08:51
on this show. We talk a lot of game
1:08:52
systems. We love your friendly local
1:08:54
game store. Go support them. But if they
1:08:56
don't have something you're looking for
1:08:57
or if you're not going to be able to
1:08:58
make it there, we do have affiliate
1:08:59
links for a lot of the materials that we
1:09:00
talk about in the show notes. If you
1:09:02
were to go click those and follow those,
1:09:03
that's another way that you can support
1:09:04
this podcast and we appreciate it.
1:09:06
Finally, please consider supporting us
1:09:07
on Patreon where you can find all kinds
1:09:09
of great rewards. Heading into tier,
1:09:11
you'll get early access to rpgbot
1:09:12
content and polls for future content. At
1:09:14
our $3 tiers, you'll enjoy your choice
1:09:16
of adree access to rpgbot.net or ad free
1:09:18
podcast episodes and access to live
1:09:20
stream podcast recordings. At our $5
1:09:22
tiers and above, you'll get all of that,
1:09:23
plus access to the RPGbot. You'll find
1:09:26
us at patreon.com/rpgbot.
1:09:28
Do you have a question? Is it a nagging
1:09:30
question? You can nag us with that
1:09:32
question through the question of the
1:09:33
week system. To do that, email us at
1:09:35
podcastrpgbot.net or message us on
1:09:38
Twitter at rpgb doot ne. Are you wearing
1:09:41
a shirt? Do you wish you were? Do you
1:09:43
need to find a way to buy a shirt? Can I
1:09:45
recommend to you the rpgbot store, my
1:09:48
friend? [laughter]
1:09:50
Yeah. Like, do you have internet access
1:09:52
and a credit card, but no shirt?
1:09:54
>> Well, you know what they say. No, no sho
1:09:57
no shirt, no shoes, no service. Get a
1:09:59
shirt.
1:09:59
>> Or I heard a song isn't working.
1:10:03
>> I heard a song once that was uh no
1:10:05
shoes, no shirt, no problem. So, you
1:10:07
know,
1:10:08
>> that's [laughter] that's a different
1:10:09
kind of business.
1:10:10
>> Yeah.
1:10:10
>> Yeah. Uh do you need more RPGbot in your
1:10:14
life? Is there a a venue of
1:10:16
communication that lacks RPGbot? Is it
1:10:18
your email? Cuz if so, I have a
1:10:20
solution. [music] You could sign up for
1:10:22
the rpgbot.newsletter
1:10:23
right now and have the newsletter show
1:10:26
up in your inbox virtually through
1:10:29
email.
1:10:31
>> It's the best spam you'll ever receive.
1:10:33
>> Sixish days a week if I remember.
1:10:37
>> Spam. [laughter]
1:10:39
>> All right, folks. We're done here.
1:10:41
>> So, I'm thinking of making running an
1:10:44
adventure for DM's Guild. We'll see if
1:10:46
that goes to anything. Yeah, we all
1:10:48
shoot. Do it.
1:10:49
>> Yeah, cuz I don't know if I'll ever
1:10:52
finish this Ravenloft campaign
1:10:54
>> because it's been going very slowly. So,
1:10:57
I just I'm just like it's such a cool
1:10:59
idea that I just want to write it down.
1:11:00
I'm not promising anything,
1:11:03
>> but I am going to work at that.
1:11:05
>> But if you're hearing for this for the
1:11:07
first time, just tweet at Craven Ashes.
1:11:09
>> No, don't do that. [laughter]
1:11:13
>> All right, fine. You can do it. It'll
1:11:15
it'll motivate me to work on it. Yeah,
1:11:18
it could be fun. It's going to be a
1:11:19
challenging endeavor, though, because
1:11:20
the plan is for it to go from level
1:11:22
three to level 20.
1:11:23
>> Oh, that's maybe ambitious for your
1:11:26
first thing to publish.
1:11:27
>> Yeah. Mhm. Tyler Tyler, I might what I
1:11:31
might just do is release like standalone
1:11:33
adventures that take place in the Raven
1:11:35
Law system and then combine them.
1:11:37
>> Oh, that would be fun. Yeah.
1:11:38
>> I mean, that's actually like if you if
1:11:40
you read Kingmaker, that's how Kingmaker
1:11:42
was originally published in Pathfinder
1:11:43
one. It was actually just some
1:11:44
sequential modules that they I mean,
1:11:46
that's how that's how a lot of uh
1:11:48
adventure paths in Pathfinder 2 work now
1:11:50
as well is like they just have
1:11:52
self-contained adventures like Yeah.
1:11:55
>> Yeah. [laughter]
1:11:56
>> But
1:11:58
Quasa in the chat, he never said it went
1:12:00
through any intervening levels. Just
1:12:01
levels three and level 20.
1:12:03
>> Yeah.
1:12:04
>> No, it goes through intervening levels.
1:12:06
Quasa, don't be a smart you know what.
1:12:08
[laughter]
1:12:10
>> Odd levels only, though. Uh I thought
1:12:11
you say Delta in the chat.
1:12:12
Alternatively, join the Discord and yell
1:12:14
at him more personally. Good value for
1:12:16
the money.
1:12:16
>> God, [laughter]
1:12:20
>> somebody showing up in Discord just to
1:12:21
go, "Ash, Ash, I want my content. I want
1:12:24
my content."
1:12:26
>> If I if I do do it, this is to tease it.
1:12:30
So, it's it's a Ravenloft game that
1:12:32
deals heavily with Van Richton, his
1:12:33
past, the true nature of the dark
1:12:35
powers, going through different a lot of
1:12:39
different domains of dread. It's not
1:12:40
just one, like you're going to a bunch
1:12:42
of them. And it may or may not uh
1:12:44
involve Pale Knight, which is not an
1:12:47
oftalked about person in Dn D lore. If
1:12:50
you know, you know.
1:12:52
>> I don't. Okay.
1:12:53
>> She's a very interesting character.
1:12:55
[laughter]
Games

