Up next in 10
The Goodfellas Scene They Couldn’t Show — The Real Tommy DeSimone | Full Documentary
0 views
Aug 27, 2025
He didn’t shout. He didn’t brag. He just made rooms go quiet. This is the story Hollywood couldn’t show you—the real Tommy DeSimone: taller, younger, deadlier than the legend in Goodfellas. From Queens street corners to the Lufthansa heist, from Billy Batts to Spider and Jerothe, to a 1979 disappearance that still haunts New York—we break down the facts, the myths, the witness accounts, and the three most credible theories about who signed Tommy’s goodbye. What you’ll learn: The Queens roots and family ties that built a quiet enforcer How Paul Vario, Jimmy Burke, and Henry Hill shaped “Two-Gun Tommy” What really happened with Billy Batts—and why that line was fatal The casual brutality of Spider and Jerothe Inside the Lufthansa heist: plan, payout, and body count Why the FBI heat flipped the crew—and who had motive to erase Tommy The three leading theories: Gambino retaliation, Lucchese clean-up, or Burke’s paranoia Chapters 0:00 Meet the Monster 1:40 Title & Disclaimer 2:00 Queens Roots 5:10 Apprentice to the Luccheses 8:50 The First Switch Flip 11:30 Billy Batts: An Invisible Line
View Video Transcript
0:00
Imagine a world where power is absolute
0:03
and betrayal is a daily occurrence. A
0:06
world where a man can stroll into a bar
0:08
with a brown paper bag and inside it
0:12
isn't lunch. It's the end of somebody's
0:14
story. You know the movie lines. You've
0:17
laughed at them, quoted them, replayed
0:20
the scenes. But behind the legend was a
0:24
man who didn't raise his voice, didn't
0:26
ask questions, and didn't blink. He
0:30
didn't have to because when Tommy
0:32
Desimone walked into a room, he was the
0:34
fuse and the bomb. This video is for
0:36
documentary and educational purposes.
0:39
Some events are disputed based on
0:41
testimony, rumors, and law enforcement
0:43
files. We're not here to glorify crime.
0:46
We're here to understand a life that
0:47
burned fast, burned hot, and left a
0:49
shadow that Queens still steps around.
0:52
So, who was the real Tommy D? Was he
0:54
built by the streets or born with a
0:56
switch most people don't have? Let's go
0:59
back to the beginning and see what the
1:01
neighborhood made and what it unleashed.
1:04
Queens, New York, June 6th, 1946.
1:09
The Ravenswood Houses. The youngest of
1:12
eight in a family where crime wasn't the
1:14
family secret. It was the family
1:17
business. A grandfather with rackets out
1:20
west. An uncle in the Gambino family.
1:23
Not just connected, but respected.
1:26
Sunday dinner came with red sauce,
1:28
laughter, and lessons you didn't find in
1:31
school books. By 12, the kid is booking
1:34
numbers around the block. By 14, he's
1:37
steering stolen cargo through Brooklyn
1:40
back streets, sneakers just grazing the
1:43
pedals, heartbeat steady like a
1:45
metronome. Teachers remembered a polite
1:48
kid chewing gum like it owed him rent.
1:52
Neighbors remembered a different
1:54
soundtrack. The sound of his mother's
1:56
voice breaking when the cops knocked and
1:59
asked, "Ma'am, where's your son?" After
2:02
some poor driver got laid out for pocket
2:04
change and a pack of cigarettes, was
2:07
that nurture or nature? Did the
2:09
neighborhood write the script or did
2:11
Tommy bring his own pen? Maybe both.
2:14
Maybe that's how monsters get made. One
2:17
lesson at the dinner table, one shortcut
2:20
on the street, one rule learned because
2:23
you watched someone else break it and
2:25
wished you had the nerve. By 19, he's on
2:29
the radar of Paul Vario, a Lucasi Karpo
2:32
who could take one look at a kid and see
2:35
the work he could do. Tommy's 220, 6'2,
2:39
quiet as a closed door. Vario brings him
2:42
in, not with ceremony, just with trust
2:45
and a nod to the men who can teach him
2:48
how this world really turns. Jimmy
2:51
Burke, Henry Hill. Two names, two roads,
2:55
one education. They teach him how to
2:58
look like he belongs anywhere. How to
3:00
move through the cracks and come out
3:02
clean. Tommy learns fast. He learns how
3:05
to make a car, do what he wants without
3:08
a key. He learns how to carry heat
3:11
without anyone noticing. He learns that
3:14
if you keep your mouth shut and your
3:16
hands steady, people invite you to
3:19
bigger tables. They start calling him
3:22
Two Gun Tommy, a joke that isn't a
3:26
warning dressed up as a nickname. And
3:29
still the question, how do you teach a
3:31
teenager to live with a weapon the way
3:34
most people live with a wallet and never
3:36
blink? Is it training? Is it talent? Or
3:40
is it something colder? Most guys in
3:43
that life wait years for a license, a
3:46
whisper that tells them they can do what
3:49
everyone knows is coming. But with
3:51
Tommy, the first body doesn't ride in on
3:54
ceremony. According to stories told
3:57
later, some by Henry Hill, some by men
4:00
who were there, some by men who pretend
4:02
they were, Tommy is 17, walking past a
4:06
chainlink fence by an Ozone Park
4:09
playground. A stranger leans on the
4:11
metal. Tommy's got a borrowed pistol. He
4:14
lifts it. One shot. No provocation, no
4:18
name in the paper, no headline the next
4:21
morning. just silence and a switch that
4:25
flips behind his eyes. Is that the
4:28
moment a person becomes a weapon? Or is
4:30
that the moment he realizes he always
4:33
was? From there, the laugh comes out at
4:36
odd times. He cracks up when no one else
4:39
does. And when he goes quiet, people
4:42
start checking the exits without moving
4:43
their feet. He's loyal to the crew,
4:46
devoted to the work, but there's a
4:49
feeling around him, like standing near a
4:51
live wire. Most men flinch at that
4:54
feeling. Some men find it useful. Then
4:57
June 1970 rolls in, and with it, a man
5:01
named William Billy Bats Bener, a maid
5:05
man from the Gambino family. He's fresh
5:08
out of prison, dressed sharp, soaking up
5:10
the kind of attention you get when you
5:12
come home alive. And he's got a memory.
5:16
At Robert's lounge, surrounded by
5:18
handshakes and toasts, Bats leans into a
5:21
story, ribbing Tommy about shining shoes
5:24
back in the day. It's banter. It's a
5:27
needle. And it crosses a line that isn't
5:30
on any wall. In that world, the lines
5:33
are invisible until you trip them. Bats
5:36
trips one. 10 days later, the
5:38
celebration continues in a queen's
5:41
basement. There's drink. There's music.
5:44
There's the slow electric hum of tension
5:47
that men like Jimmy Burke can smell in a
5:50
breath. It's not a party anymore. It's
5:52
punishment. It's a beating that turns a
5:55
room into a red memory no one can scrub
5:58
clean. Bats ends up in a car trunk. They
6:02
drive, they worry, they move him, and
6:05
for a while they get away with it. Years
6:08
later, when the authorities open the
6:10
ground, the story hardens into bone and
6:12
holes. One made man dead. One unspoken
6:16
truth written in fear. You don't do that
6:19
without a bill coming due. If you could
6:21
rewind that night, if you could hit
6:23
pause right when the joke becomes an
6:24
insult, would anything change? Or was it
6:27
always going to end in a trunk, a
6:28
shovel, and a phone that won't stop
6:30
ringing? The legend of Tommy isn't just
6:33
about the high-profile hits. It's about
6:36
the ordinary horrors, the casual cruelty
6:39
that makes a crew hold its breath.
6:42
There's a basement club called the
6:44
suite. The air thick with smoke and
6:46
excuses. A young waiter everyone calls
6:50
spider. A few words, a few drinks, a
6:54
shot fired like a punchline. The kid
6:57
limps. He tries to stand his ground.
6:59
Maybe for pride, maybe for fear. And
7:03
then there's another shot. Different
7:05
accounts put different men nearer or
7:06
farther from the trigger, but the
7:08
message is the same. A life taken in a
7:12
room where the only rule is that there
7:15
are no rules anyone will admit to later.
7:19
And then there's Ronald Jera, a
7:21
hot-headed Gambino hopeful who roughed
7:23
up the wrong man's relative on the wrong
7:25
day. He disappears. What emerges is a
7:29
body where precision and rage shake
7:33
hands. In the morg, the details are
7:36
clinical. In the street, the verdict is
7:39
quicker. He shouldn't have touched
7:41
family. If Tuesday had a face, it wore a
7:45
scowl. At any point in this story, you
7:49
could step back and ask, "What drove
7:52
Tommy? Was it power, fear, loyalty, or
7:56
the thrill of standing at the edge and
7:59
never looking down?" That's the question
8:01
Lorman asked. And the question
8:03
old-timers still won't answer directly.
8:06
Maybe because they don't know. Maybe
8:09
because knowing doesn't help you sleep
8:11
any better. Then comes the night that
8:14
turned this crew from local operators
8:17
into headline thieves. December 11th,
8:21
1978.
8:22
Middle of the night. The cargo bays at
8:25
JFK are a maze of shadows and schedules.
8:30
The plan is tight. The timing is
8:32
tighter. What happens in those minutes
8:35
becomes the biggest cash score America
8:37
had seen up to that point. Millions in
8:40
currency, a mountain of jewels, and a
8:43
spotlight so bright it bleaches out
8:46
alibis. The city wakes up to rumors. The
8:49
cops wake up angry. The papers wake up
8:52
hungry. And the crew starts to celebrate
8:55
in a way that makes survivalists shake
8:58
their heads. Because after a score like
9:00
that, quiet is your friend. But quiet is
9:04
not what follows. People connected to
9:06
the job begin to vanish. Drivers,
9:10
gobetweens, the guy who knew a guy. One
9:13
by one, strings get cut. Was it
9:16
paranoia? Was it strategy? Or did it not
9:19
matter? Because when you're holding a
9:21
bag of cash that heavy, everyone looks
9:24
like a risk. Tommy gets his cut. He's
9:28
seen burning money for laughs. The kind
9:30
of stunt that makes people grin in the
9:33
moment and worry later. Maybe it was
9:36
bravado. Maybe it was boredom. Maybe it
9:39
was a message. I can do this because I
9:42
want to. Either way, the lights got
9:45
bright. The feds were already staring.
9:48
Now, they started writing things down.
9:51
By 1979, the heat isn't heat anymore.
9:55
It's fire. The FBI is everywhere and
9:59
nowhere. On phones, in cars across the
10:02
street, in file cabinets that grow
10:04
thicker by the day. And Henry Hill, the
10:07
ultimate adapter. The guy who could
10:10
always find a way, runs out of ways. The
10:13
drugs don't fix it. The money doesn't
10:16
solve it. The future looks like a
10:18
concrete bench and a calendar that won't
10:21
move. Henry flips. He talks. He writes a
10:25
map of nights and deals and disasters.
10:29
Billy Bats, Spider, side hustles,
10:32
Lufansa, the moments that stitched the
10:35
crew together and began pulling it
10:37
apart. What happens when a man you drank
10:40
with tells the world your secrets? Does
10:43
loyalty break all at once or does it
10:46
crumble? In a life without mercy, who
10:49
pulls the trigger first? Your friend,
10:52
your boss, or your enemy? If there's a
10:55
single day people point to, it's a day
10:58
that should have been forgettable.
11:00
January 14th, 1979,
11:03
a winter Sunday. Tommy kisses his wife.
11:07
He says he's picking up a suit for his
11:08
daughter's birthday. He gets in his red
11:11
Toronado and drives toward a quiet
11:14
sitdown about a smalltime hustle.
11:17
Witnesses see him walk into a social
11:19
club in Queens. No witness sees him come
11:23
out. From that moment on, the story
11:26
split like a river hitting rock. One
11:28
story says the Gambinos handled it. A
11:30
maid man had been killed. Another of
11:32
their upandcomers had been murdered.
11:34
There are debts you can pay with cash
11:36
and debts you pay another way. Some say
11:38
John Goti was in the room. Some say he
11:40
wasn't. All agree. If it was Gambino
11:44
business, the point wasn't just to end
11:46
Tommy. It was to send a message that
11:48
outlived everybody present. Another
11:51
story says the Lucesy family took care
11:54
of its own problem. Tommy was a
11:56
liability. With the feds sniffing around
11:59
and Henry Hill singing, Tommy's
12:02
volatility became a risk the crew
12:04
couldn't afford. In this version, it's
12:07
not vengeance, it's housekeeping.
12:10
A third story pins it on Jimmy Burke's
12:13
paranoia. After Lufanza, after the
12:16
bodies, after the bravado, Jimmy may
12:19
have decided that anyone who drew
12:20
attention to himself had drawn a target
12:23
on his back, especially someone as
12:26
fearless and unpredictable as Tommy.
12:29
There are variations. There are
12:31
embellishments. There are invented
12:33
details told with straight faces. None
12:36
of them bring him back. There is no
12:39
grave for mourners. No funeral for old
12:42
friends to skip because it's safer that
12:44
way. Just an empty chair at a birthday
12:47
table and a family that learned how to
12:50
grieve without closure. Which version do
12:53
you believe? In a world where truth is
12:56
the first thing to get buried, which
12:58
rumor sounds like the facts you can't
13:00
prove? When people think of Tommy
13:02
Desimone today, they see a movie. They
13:06
hear a line, "What do you mean I'm
13:08
funny?"
13:09
They picture a short, middle-aged
13:10
hothead who turns jokes into threats and
13:14
rooms into battlefields.
13:16
But that's the movie. The real Tommy was
13:19
28 years old. He was tall, built like a
13:23
bouncer, and carried himself like a man
13:25
who knew he wouldn't be challenged
13:27
twice. The film keeps the humor, the
13:31
sudden rage, the unpredictability.
13:33
It leaves out the quiet. It leaves out
13:36
the everyday cruelty. It leaves out how
13:39
young he was when the worst things
13:41
started and how fast it all ended.
13:44
Still, when that line plays, when the
13:47
character leans in and needles the man
13:50
across the table, something true shines
13:53
through. The feeling of being trapped in
13:56
a moment that could go either way and
13:59
probably won't go your way. Men who
14:02
lived that life flinch during that
14:05
scene, not because of the accuracy of
14:07
the height or the age, because the
14:10
energy is right. The danger is right.
14:13
And the reminder is right there.
14:15
Sometimes the scariest man in the room
14:17
doesn't need to be loud to be lethal. So
14:20
what is Tommy's legacy? Is it a
14:23
cautionary tale told to kids who think
14:26
fast money means easy money? Is it the
14:29
rumor that still crawls through queens
14:32
on summer nights? The one about laughter
14:35
that sounds less like joy and more like
14:38
a blade? Is it an unfinished story with
14:41
three endings, each one believable, each
14:44
one told by men who never learned to use
14:47
the word maybe? Before we decide, let's
14:51
look again at the beginning, at the
14:52
table where everything started. Imagine
14:56
being a kid and learning that respect is
14:59
something you can't buy, only take.
15:02
Imagine the first time someone hands you
15:04
an envelope and it's as heavy as a
15:07
choice. Imagine the first time you hurt
15:10
someone and the world doesn't stop and
15:12
your heart beats the same as it did an
15:15
hour before. Does that make you feel
15:17
invincible or does it make you feel
15:19
nothing at all? People ask whether Tommy
15:22
was loyal to what? to whom he stood next
15:26
to men who taught him the trade. He did
15:29
what he was asked and he did what he
15:31
wanted. Maybe in the end loyalty wasn't
15:34
a word that fit his life. Maybe the only
15:37
promise he kept was to himself. To never
15:40
be the man who backs down. Never be the
15:43
man who apologizes.
15:46
Never be the man who looks away first.
15:49
Here's another question. If you remove
15:52
the movie, remove the glamour and the
15:54
soundtrack, what's left? A family that
15:56
missed him in ways they couldn't say out
15:58
loud. Victims whose names faded into
16:01
case files and whispered memories.
16:03
Neighbors who learned to lock up earlier
16:05
and walk faster. A neighborhood that
16:07
produced legends at the cost of
16:09
funerals. And here's where I turn it
16:11
over to you. If you were sitting at that
16:13
last table, watching Tommy walk in to a
16:16
quiet sitdown, which ending would you
16:19
expect? Gambino retaliation for a maid
16:22
man. Luces clean up to satisfy law and
16:25
survival. Burke cutting one more loose
16:28
end because paranoia is the only
16:31
insurance policy that works when the
16:32
feds are listening. Drop your theory.
16:36
Tell me not just who did it, but why
16:38
that version makes the most sense to
16:40
you. Was it a message? Was it math? Was
16:44
it both? If you've made it this far,
16:46
you're the kind of person who doesn't
16:48
blink at hard histories. You want the
16:52
real story, not the glossy version. So,
16:55
while we've got you, think about this.
16:58
In every true crime legend, there's a
17:01
moment where a life could have turned
17:03
another way. What was that moment here?
17:06
The chainlink fence at 17. The night at
17:10
Robert's Lounge. The first time an
17:12
envelope with more cash than a month's
17:14
rent slid across a table and into a
17:17
young man's hand. We can't change what
17:20
happened. But we can decide how we
17:23
remember it. Not as comedy, not as
17:26
romance, as a series of choices made by
17:29
people who thought they understood the
17:31
price and found out they didn't. Tommy
17:34
Desimone lived 28 years. He left behind
17:39
50 different legends. depending on who's
17:41
telling it. He was an apprentice, an
17:44
earner, a liability, a friend, a
17:47
monster, a ghost. All those stories
17:51
can't be true. But they can all be
17:53
useful. They can warn, they can teach,
17:56
they can remind us that the line between
17:59
swagger and a grave is thinner than it
18:03
looks from the outside. So the next time
18:06
someone quotes a movie line and the
18:08
whole room laughs, remember the men who
18:11
tensed up instead. Remember the places
18:14
where the laughter didn't sound like
18:15
joy. Remember that somewhere in Queens,
18:18
there are still people who cross the
18:20
street when a bar door opens the wrong
18:23
way. And remember that legends don't
18:26
live forever. They fade. They get
18:29
retold. They get revised. They get
18:32
replaced. But every once in a while,
18:35
late at night, when the streets are
18:37
empty and the city hums, someone swears,
18:41
they heard a laugh that didn't belong to
18:44
the present. A laugh that carried a
18:46
warning. A laugh that said, "Don't
18:49
forget what happens when you cross a
18:51
line you can't see." What do you think
18:54
happened that last night? Which hand
18:57
signed Tommy's goodbye? Tell me in the
19:00
comments. And if you want more stories
19:02
like this, stories that refuse to blink,
19:05
stick around. We've got more ghosts to
19:07
meet, more myths to unmask, more legends
19:10
to unravel until the truth is the only
19:13
thing left standing. Until then, walk
19:17
past Robert's Lounge in your mind.
19:20
Picture the sign gone, the windows
19:22
boarded, the block a little too quiet,
19:26
and listen. If you catch it, the faint
19:29
echo of a joke turning into a threat,
19:32
don't panic. Just remember what you've
19:34
learned here. In a world where power is
19:36
absolute and betrayal is a daily
19:39
occurrence, survival isn't about being
19:42
the loudest. It's about knowing when to
19:44
speak, when to stay silent, and when to
19:47
walk away. Tommy Desimone chose his
19:51
moments. In the end, someone else chose
19:54
his. Your move.
#Documentary Films