Up next in 10
My Wife Cheated with My Sister's Husband — So We Made Them Pay! | True Story
Aug 5, 2025
#redditrelationship #aita #redditstories My Wife Cheated with My Sister's Husband — So We Made Them Pay! | True Story When I discovered my wife was cheating, I was heartbroken. But when I found out it was with my sister’s husband, the pain turned into cold, calculated rage. With the help of my sister, a brutal prenup, and an anonymous tipster named “Pissed-Off 9999,” we exposed everything — the lies, the hidden cash, and the betrayal. This story isn’t just about infidelity — it’s about justice, family, and taking back control when life falls apart. And our kids? They became the unexpected heroes of it all. 👉 Watch until the end to see how we turned their lies into our victory. 📌 Don’t forget to Like, Comment, and Subscribe for more powerful real-life stories.
View Video Transcript
0:00
In emergencies, you act fast. Cardiac
0:02
arrest, chest compressions, bleeding.
0:05
You stop it before worrying about a
0:07
broken bone. But what do you do when the
0:10
emergency is your life and the patient
0:12
is your marriage? I sat on my patio, a
0:15
cold beer in my hand, feeling
0:17
blindsided. As a critical care nurse, I
0:20
prided myself on spotting subtle signs
0:22
of decline, but I had missed all the
0:24
warning signs of my 18-year marriage's
0:26
demise. The email was anonymous. the
0:29
sender pissed-off 99. It contained a
0:33
video, proof that my wife Bonnie was
0:35
cheating.
0:36
I had no intention of saving the
0:38
marriage. I wanted to end it painfully
0:40
for her and her lover. But after
0:42
reconsidering, I didn't want innocent
0:44
parties hurt, especially my kids.
0:48
My sister Susan lived next door in a
0:50
house identical to mine, a gift from our
0:52
family. I called her over. Isn't it
0:56
early for a drink, Rob? It's only 2
0:58
p.m., she said, noticing my beer. I'm
1:00
off for the weekend. In the mood, I
1:02
replied, knowing she'd understand my
1:04
flexible work schedule. I handed her a
1:07
beer. I found out Bonnie is cheating on
1:10
me. My voice trembled. Susan's face
1:12
pald. Are you sure? I nodded. There was
1:16
a video attached. No doubt.
1:19
That cheating cow? Susan fumed. How does
1:23
she even have time for an affair? She's
1:25
home every night except bachelorette
1:27
parties and I'm always with her. Then
1:30
her eyes widened in horror. She works
1:33
with Rich and they usually drive
1:35
together. No way. She's cheating with my
1:38
husband Rich. I hugged my sister as she
1:40
burst into tears. I'm so sorry. I've had
1:44
a couple of hours to calm down enough
1:46
not to grab a weapon.
1:48
Susan composed herself. Okay, what do we
1:52
do? wait for them and confront them.
1:55
"No, we need a plan. We'll act normal
1:58
tonight, just like yesterday. We'll
2:00
greet them with a kiss." "Are you
2:03
serious?" she asked, a look of disbelief
2:06
on her face. "We need to be smart.
2:08
Well get legal advice tomorrow. At
2:11
least we know we haven't contracted any
2:13
STDs," I added with a smirk, trying to
2:16
lighten the mood. Susan pointed at me.
2:20
Hell no. Rich isn't getting anything
2:23
from me. Bonnie can have him, and we
2:26
mustn't let the kids know yet. I agreed,
2:30
remembering our four teenagers, who were
2:31
more like siblings than cousins, away at
2:33
our parents for the weekend.
2:36
Family was everything to me, and the
2:38
thought of destroying their unity was
2:40
heartbreaking.
2:42
I can't forgive or forget infidelity, I
2:44
told Susan.
2:46
Neither can I, she said. I need to
2:49
figure out how to get rid of her without
2:50
losing everything. I won't risk jail or
2:53
let her take the kids. I can't hurt Rich
2:56
either. I have to be there for my kids.
2:58
I get it. We need to break them
3:00
financially, I said. I'm going to take
3:03
every penny I can get. Susan's eyes
3:05
gleamed with a new fire. Our houses are
3:08
safe. Dad gave them to us before we
3:10
married. And didn't you and Bonnie sign
3:12
a prenup? Dad insisted on a legal
3:15
opinion for all of us. If either party
3:17
cheated, they'd only get 20% of joint
3:20
assets and no alimony.
3:22
I remembered the prenup. Bonnie's
3:25
wealthy father had insisted on it,
3:27
fearing I'd take his fortune. My father
3:29
had done the same for Susan and Rich.
3:32
Our prenups were ironclad.
3:34
The next morning, we met with Jake, a
3:36
divorce attorney and Susan's boss. We
3:39
explained the situation and the prenup.
3:42
As long as you have evidence of
3:43
infidelity, you're good, Jake said. The
3:46
cheater only gets 20% of joint assets.
3:49
The prenup is strict. We'll serve them
3:51
divorce papers at work on Thursday at
3:53
noon. After the meeting, we went to the
3:55
bank to transfer money into new separate
3:58
accounts.
3:59
I checked my email and found three more
4:01
videos of Bonnie and Rich. I thanked the
4:04
sender, pissed off 999, who then replied
4:08
with an address, 9203 Victoria Street,
4:11
apartment 2011. I investigated and found
4:15
the apartment was rented by their
4:16
insurance company with Rich's signature
4:18
on the contract. On Thursday, Bonnie
4:21
called me, furious about the divorce
4:23
papers. "I know you found someone else,
4:26
and I'm setting you free," I calmly told
4:28
her, our rehearsed response.
4:31
She angrily denied the affair and
4:33
threatened to take everything, including
4:35
the kids. "I barely kept my voice
4:38
steady.
4:39
By the way, the girls are packing your
4:41
things. Everything will be in front of
4:43
the house for you to pick up. We have a
4:46
restraining order and change the locks
4:48
this morning. I hung up on her shouting.
4:52
10 minutes later, Susan texted me.
4:54
Backyard, bring your cooler. Make sure
4:57
it's full. Rich had also tried to deny
4:59
the affair to Susan, blaming it on a
5:01
secretar's gossip.
5:03
We had been prepared, and Jake arrived
5:05
with two sheriff's deputies to keep
5:07
things from getting out of hand.
5:10
Rich and Bonnie arrived with a lawyer,
5:11
Budro Landry, a bully from my elementary
5:14
school days.
5:16
"Hey, Robert," Budro smirked. "I hear
5:19
you're having trouble with your wife." I
5:22
ignored him, my focus on the legal
5:24
process. Bonnie and Rich were furious,
5:26
accusing us of taking all the money from
5:28
our joint accounts. We had statements
5:31
proving the original amounts, but Bonnie
5:33
was so angry, she didn't realize her
5:36
credit cards were now cancelled.
5:38
After a tense exchange, Bonnie and Rich
5:40
left their things in tow.
5:44
The next day, another email from
5:45
pissed-off 9999 arrived, an audio file.
5:49
It was Bonnie, Rich, and Budro
5:51
discussing how to hide money and fake an
5:53
alibi to get around an investigator.
5:55
They even mentioned flying to the Cayman
5:57
Islands. Do they have secret bank
5:59
accounts? Susan wondered. I see the bank
6:02
statements. He couldn't have hidden
6:03
much. The following Wednesday, we met
6:06
with a court-appointed financial
6:08
arbitrator. He was reviewing our
6:10
paperwork when he noticed a discrepancy.
6:13
Mr. Fontano, there's a big difference
6:15
between Mrs. Fontano's salary estimate
6:17
and her tax returns for the last 2
6:19
years. She reported an income of
6:21
$140,000 annually, not $600.
6:26
"What the hell?" I exclaimed.
6:29
Bonnie and Rich had been hiding $80,000
6:31
a year in bonuses.
6:33
So, where's the money, Bonnie? I
6:35
demanded. Is that why you went to the
6:37
Cayman Islands last Friday? Bonnie,
6:40
looking terrified, asked. How did you
6:42
find out? You did it yourself, I said.
6:46
Both you and Susan insisted the kids
6:48
install phone locator apps. They tracked
6:51
you when you didn't answer them on
6:52
Friday and saw you reappear near the
6:54
coast, suggesting you were in the
6:56
Cayman. The arbitrator took control of
6:59
the situation. Further investigation
7:01
revealed the money was split evenly
7:03
among five accounts belonging to their
7:05
children. Jason and Diara Fontano and
7:08
Robert Dave and Cynthia Jenkins. The
7:11
parents showed responsibility if not
7:13
remorse by giving the money to their
7:16
children. My jaw dropped. So that's what
7:19
had happened. My kids were the ones who
7:22
had outsmarted their parents. The
7:24
hearing was expedited. All five kids
7:26
insisted on attending. As Judge Goody
7:29
started the proceedings, my daughter
7:31
Diara raised her hand. "Your honor, I
7:34
read that children 15 and older can
7:36
choose which parent to live with." "In
7:39
some states, yes," the judge replied.
7:42
"In Louisiana, I consider the children's
7:44
opinions after speaking to them
7:45
privately."
7:47
Diara stood up. "I don't need to talk
7:50
privately. My mother cheated on my
7:52
father and our entire family. I want to
7:55
live with my dad. Jason, Robert, Dave,
7:58
and Cindy all stood in agreement. The
8:00
court officer was taken aback, but the
8:02
judge just smiled, looking at our
8:04
children with pride. The battle was far
8:06
from over, but in that moment, I knew we
8:09
had won. Our family though changed was
8:12
not broken.