0:00
This comment is about grappling in D and
0:02
D and it asks if I prefer the 2014
0:04
ability check method or the 2024 method
0:07
where it's a saving throw after making
0:09
an unarmed strike. Personally, I'm
0:11
really invested in this the ability
0:13
check method like that. I always found
0:15
that very satisfying. Players could
0:17
build themselves around it. They could
0:18
make themselves good at grappling
0:21
intentionally by, you know, taking
0:23
proficiency and potentially expertise in
0:25
athletics. But at the same time, it was
0:28
also really, really easy to abuse. Cuz
0:30
what monster is going to be proficient
0:32
in athletic? Almost none of them. So you
0:35
could use athletics to grapple really
0:37
effectively. Like a barbarian with
0:39
expertise in athletics was functionally
0:41
unstoppable, especially if you were Path
0:43
of the Giant, so you could get big
0:44
enough to grapple anything in the game.
0:46
Like nothing was going to beat you on
0:48
that skill check. So you could grapple
0:50
anything. You could shove anything prone
0:52
and then just hold them there. and every
0:55
encounter gets way easier. I've done
0:57
that. It works super well. The 2024
1:00
version is a lot more balanced, I think.
1:02
But at the same time, there's no way to
1:05
be intentionally good at grappling.
1:07
Sure, there's the grappler feet, but it
1:09
doesn't make you better at starting a
1:11
grapple. It doesn't make you better at
1:12
initiating grapple. You're very slightly
1:15
faster because you can do it as a bonus
1:16
action, but you're no more reliable than
1:19
just the next dude next to you who's
1:21
just as strong. So, I I do think the
1:25
2024 version introduces less problems to
1:28
the game. Um, but I thought the 2014
1:32
version was more fun simply because you