Tool proficiencies in DnD have so much potential to be something interesting, but they just aren’t
Oct 8, 2025
Tool proficiencies in DnD have so much potential to be something interesting, but they just aren’t. WotC hasn’t done anything interesting with them, and they’ve given us very little reason as players to engage with that part of the system.
#dnd #dnd5e #2024dnd #ttrpg #dmadvice
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
What do I think about tool proficiencies
0:02
in D&D 5e and how they work? Uh,
0:04
frankly, I think they're pretty
0:05
disappointing. The 2014 rules made tools
0:09
this weird afterthought that worked
0:11
basically the same way as skill
0:13
proficiencies, but they're always
0:14
terribly explained and very difficult to
0:16
use with the exception of thieves tools.
0:18
Anithar's Guide to Everything gave us
0:20
expanded tool rules which gave us more
0:23
benefits to having proficiency in a
0:25
tool. So, like if you're proficient in
0:26
cooks utensils, when you take a short
0:28
rest, people would get additional
0:30
healing if they spent a hit die. But
0:32
people had already adjusted to the idea
0:33
that tools were functionally useless and
0:35
were to be ignored. So, nobody knows
0:37
those rules exist. We're 10 plus years
0:41
into fifth edition, and most people
0:42
still don't know that those rules in
0:44
Xanithar's guide exist. Now, in the 2024
0:47
rules, the proficiency thing really
0:49
hasn't changed, but now we have an
0:51
explicit list of things that you can
0:52
craft with any given set of tools. It's
0:54
like four or five mundane items per
0:57
tool. So, it's it it is the most
0:59
pointless crafting system, but it does
1:02
technically exist. But in terms of
1:04
actually contributing to the game,
1:06
contributing to the game experience,
1:08
other than thieves tools, I really don't
1:09
think tools matter. Now, you as players
1:13
and as dungeon masters could lean
1:15
heavily into making those tools matter,
1:18
offering ways to make tools important.
1:20
like uh your players are dungeon
1:23
crawling a a noble manner that's been
1:26
taken over by ghosts or something. They
1:28
go into the kitchen and the guy with
1:29
proficiency in cooks utensils can do
1:31
something special in the kitchen. Like
1:34
you can offer those opportunities in
1:36
your games if your players are, you
1:39
know, aware enough to take advantage of
1:42
them. At the same time, you as players
1:44
could ask your DM for those
1:46
opportunities like, "Hey, um I'm in a
1:48
kitchen. I'm proficient with cooks
1:50
utensils. Can I look around and know
1:52
that something is a miss here? And your
1:54
DM might be like, I don't know how to
1:56
cook. I don't even know what to put in
1:58
this room. Or your DM might be like,
2:00
yes, you notice this, this, this, and
2:01
this are missing. And I've had that h
2:04
that specific thing happen to me in a
2:06
game because uh my long-term dungeon
2:08
master at the moment uh really really
2:10
likes to cook. So, he knows his way
2:12
around a kitchen. And like he's made
2:14
jokes about like, oh yeah, you go into a
2:15
kitchen and all of the ingredients are
2:17
missing. And he later explained to us,
2:20
oh yeah, the ghost was making barbecue
2:22
sauce or whatever. So it it's going to
2:24
vary by dungeon master. And
2:26
unfortunately, that really depends a lot
2:27
on their realworld capability. So it's
2:30
really hard to make tools useful and
2:33
interesting in 5e. And the system really
2:36
just is not doing a lot to help
Online Media
Games
Roleplaying Games
Roleplaying Games
Hobbies & Leisure

