It can be hard to challenge DnD characters who can’t reasonably fail at specific tasks, but the ability to pass a check isn’t the only way to make that check challenging.
#dnd #dmadvice
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
How do we meaningfully challenge D&D
0:02
characters who can basically guarantee
0:04
success on things that they're good at?
0:07
This commenter points to Eloquence Bards
0:08
who have a really, really high floor on
0:11
their charisma checks. So, like, they're
0:13
saying 23 minimum on a persuasion check,
0:15
which is really, really good. The
0:18
expected DCs described in the Dungeon
0:20
Master's Guide generally don't go much
0:22
above 20. So, being able to hit 23 means
0:25
that they're expected to succeed on
0:27
basically every charisma check in the
0:29
game. So, how do we meaningfully
0:30
challenge those players? Sometimes you
0:32
just have to let them have it. Like, if
0:34
they've built their character to be
0:36
really good at this one thing, then just
0:39
let them be good at that thing. Let them
0:41
succeed on the charisma checks. Like,
0:43
let them get their way a lot of the
0:45
time. But, remember that charisma checks
0:47
aren't mind control. They won't always
0:50
get exactly what they want. They might
0:51
get the best thing that the NPC can give
0:54
them reasonably, but they're not just
0:56
going to like walk up to the king and
0:58
say, "Hey, put me in charge." And the
0:59
king says, "Great, you're king now."
1:01
That's That's not how it works because
1:03
that character, short of exceptionally
1:05
strange circumstances, is not just going
1:07
to give you a kingdom. Like, that's
1:09
That's not how people work, no matter
1:11
how charming you are. So, then, in some
1:13
ways, you are removing the challenge of
1:16
charisma checks, but that is, again,
1:17
fine because they built themselves to be
1:19
really good at that. So, you have to
1:21
find other ways to challenge them. Like,
1:23
the NPCs might give the players
1:26
everything that they're willing to give,
1:28
and that might not be enough for the
1:30
players. Like, they might go to the king
1:32
and say, "Hey, we have this huge
1:33
problem. Uh we need a bunch of money to
1:36
deal with this problem." And the king
1:37
can be like, "I'll give you all that I
1:39
can spare, but the kingdom's in massive
1:40
debt right now. So, here's my pocket
1:42
change. Good luck." And then, look for
1:45
ways to challenge them outside of their
1:47
skill set. Playing to characters'
1:49
weaknesses or focusing on the strengths
1:51
of other characters in the party always
1:53
presents novel challenges. No matter how
1:55
good a player is at one given specific
1:57
thing, generally the entire game does
1:59
not revolve around just that one
2:01
specific capability, even though it does
2:03
feel really good when it comes up and
2:05
they get to shine.
Games

