Expertise in thieves’ tools isn’t a thing in DnD 5.5, but they basically just shifted the rules to more closely resemble what a lot of people already thought they were in 5e.
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
D&D players, did you know that the rules
0:01
for picking locks changed pretty
0:03
significantly in the D&D 5.5 rules? This
0:06
is something that I've seen a ton of
0:08
people miss, and a lot of people had the
0:09
rules for picking locks super wrong in
0:12
the 5E time frame. So, under the 5E
0:14
rules, picking a lock was a dexterity
0:17
check using your proficiency in thieves'
0:19
tools. Slight of hand did not factor in
0:22
in any way, but I saw a lot of people
0:24
using slight of hand as the skill for
0:26
picking locks, and basically just
0:28
ignoring that thieves' tools proficiency
0:30
existed in the slightest. Also in the 5E
0:32
rules, you could add expertise to
0:34
proficiency in a tool. So, rogues with
0:36
expertise in thieves' tools were really,
0:39
really good at picking locks and
0:41
disarming traps, and that was great. In
0:43
the 5.5 rules, things have changed a
0:45
bit. You have to look at the item
0:46
description for locks in the player's
0:49
handbook to actually find the rules for
0:50
how to pick a lock because the skill
0:53
descriptions don't say anything useful
0:55
on the subject. The description for the
0:57
lock in the player's handbook states
0:59
that a creature can pick the lock using
1:02
thieves' tools with a DC 15 dexterity
1:05
slight of hand check, which means that
1:07
you're now using your proficiency in
1:09
slight of hand instead of proficiency in
1:11
thieves' tools. You can still get
1:13
proficiency in thieves' tools, of
1:14
course, and the standard rules now are
1:17
that if you have two proficiencies that
1:19
apply, you use the higher and you get
1:21
advantage on the check. So, by default,
1:24
a rogue at level one with proficiency in
1:26
slight of hand and thieves' tools has
1:28
advantage on all of their checks to pick
1:31
locks, which is pretty nice. But
1:33
notably, you can no longer apply
1:35
expertise to tools. Expertise now only
1:39
applies to skills. So, instead of
1:42
putting expertise on your proficiency in
1:44
thieves' tools, you now put it on slight
1:45
of hand. Slight of hand's role in the
1:47
game has expanded significantly, and
1:50
other than that, basically, you're doing
1:52
the same things that you were doing in
1:53
5E, but you're going to have almost
1:55
perpetual advantage. So, the rules are
1:57
slightly different, the outcome is a
2:00
functionally the same, and the rules
2:02
have basically adapted to what a lot of
2:04
people were already doing because they
2:06
misunderstood the rules. Honestly, I
2:08
think it's perfectly fine. In fourth
2:10
edition, Sleight of Hand was called
2:12
Thievery, and it was very intentionally
2:14
for picking pockets, picking locks,
2:16
disarming traps, those things. It was
2:18
kind of an like all-in-one rogue stuff
2:21
skill, and honestly, I think that's
2:23
fine. Like, it's not enough part of the
2:26
game that it needs to be a bunch of
2:27
different skills like it was in second
2:29
and third edition.
Games

