DnD 5e is a great game, but it certainly has some flaws. Some bug, some small. Some were in 5e and got fixed in 5.5, but some were ignored, and others were added to systems that were fine how they were in 5e.
#dnd #dnd5e #2024dnd
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
I really love fifth edition. Like,
0:02
sincerely, I do think it's a really fun
0:03
game. I enjoy it quite a bit. But, no
0:07
game is without its flaws. And the
0:08
question is, what do I think D&D 5e's
0:11
biggest weaknesses are? My favorite dead
0:14
horse to beat about fifth edition is the
0:16
mounted combat rules. A game that
0:19
evolved out of chainmail, which was, you
0:22
know, fantasy wargaming where mounted
0:24
cavalry charges were a thing. Like, the
0:27
first Player's Handbook had a knight on
0:30
horseback on the cover. And we've
0:32
strayed so far from anything that
0:35
resembles functional mounted combat
0:37
rules. And like, that that makes me so
0:39
angry that I started a podcast. But,
0:42
there are bigger weaknesses, of course.
0:44
Um 5e's reliance on the plain English
0:48
definitions of words has repeatedly
0:50
bitten us in a lot of ways. The
0:52
differences in the ways that people
0:54
understand what a word means, or a
0:56
sentence means, or even just comma
0:58
usage, have led to massive rules
1:01
ambiguity where like, to the designers,
1:04
it made sense because they were all in a
1:05
room talking about it. But, to laypeople
1:08
who don't have access to the designers
1:10
to ask them questions, a lot of the
1:12
time, the text rules feels like absolute
1:15
gibberish. 5e also, for very long time,
1:18
has not done a great job giving Dungeon
1:20
Masters tools to run a balanced game. I
1:23
talk a lot about the adventuring day
1:25
mechanics and how like, D&D 5e is very
1:28
much built for six to eight combat
1:30
encounters per day, and they give you
1:32
the tools to build and run games within
1:34
that framework. But, if you don't hit
1:36
that attrition expectation, the game
1:38
feels horrifically unbalanced. And we
1:40
got an updated edition in 5.5, and I
1:44
don't know that they really solved that
1:46
problem. Like, they upped the expected
1:48
difficulty of encounters, and that's
1:49
probably great, but we still don't know
1:51
how to balance a full adventuring day,
1:54
cuz they just took that section out of
1:56
the book. I also think 5e's skill and
1:58
tool system is fairly weak. Like it's
2:01
intentionally loosely defined and you
2:03
are explicitly within the text of the
2:05
rules encouraged to mix and match
2:08
ability scores and proficiencies in
2:10
skills or tools to suit a given
2:13
situation. So, instead of it always
2:15
being like intelligence investigation,
2:17
you might do like charisma investigation
2:19
gather information or something like
2:21
that. But that's really terribly
2:23
explained and basically every ability
2:26
check listed in the text of the rules is
2:29
the default. Like and even on the
2:32
character sheets, it lists every skill
2:34
proficiency with the associated ability
2:37
score. So, while it's allowed within the
2:39
text of the rules, there's absolutely
2:41
nothing encouraging you to actually do
2:43
that. So, the skill system feels
2:45
incredibly rigid and limited. And also,
2:48
there is absolutely no reason for
2:50
athletics and acrobatics to be separate
2:51
skills. It should just be athletics and
2:54
then the difference should be is it a
2:55
strength check or a dexterity athletics
2:58
check?
Games

