DnD 5e’s initial design process was a chaotic mess, and we’re very lucky that the final result was as good as it is. If a few more things had gone wrong, the game could have flopped and DnD could have gone away.
#dnd #dnd5e
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
D&D 5e arguably was a poorly designed
0:03
game. Like that there is plenty of room
0:05
to look at the system and say like yes,
0:06
none of these things work, none of these
0:08
things make sense, all of these things
0:09
feel obsolete 10 years later. Yeah, like
0:12
yeah, that that is fine to say. But
0:14
also, I just want people to understand
0:16
what a series of coincidences and happy
0:19
accidents we got that led to D&D 5e
0:23
actually being what it is. Because a lot
0:25
of the things in D&D 5e's design were
0:28
kind accidental. Mike Mearls has talked
0:30
about a lot of this stuff on Twitter
0:32
over the years, so like I'm half
0:33
recalling a lot of knowledge, so bear
0:35
with me. Um but one of my favorite
0:37
examples is proficiency bonus and armor
0:40
class. When they figured out how armor
0:43
class was going to work in 5e, they
0:45
weren't sure if there was going to be
0:46
any kind of scaling proficiency. They
0:48
hadn't landed on proficiency bonus yet.
0:51
It was just your ability modifier on
0:53
things. And that explains why a lot of
0:55
the scaling works so weirdly, is like
0:56
especially armor class. If you get full
0:58
plate as a fighter at level one, your AC
1:01
probably never improves from there
1:02
unless you get magic items. But attack
1:04
bonuses continue to improve, so you're
1:07
going to hit hit more and more often as
1:09
you gain levels. Because again, they
1:12
figured out armor and decided they were
1:14
happy with it before they settled on
1:15
proficiency bonus as a thing that they
1:18
were going to keep. Like they
1:19
experimented with a plus one proficiency
1:21
bonus at low levels. They experimented
1:23
with proficiency being a die that you
1:25
rolled and added to the D20. Like they
1:28
they were doing a ton of things. There
1:29
were very few sacred cows except the
1:32
class roster. And then there were just a
1:34
ton of issues with people working on the
1:36
design not communicating with each
1:38
other. So like people were designing the
1:40
same things by accident, or people were
1:42
designing things based on previous
1:44
versions, and things didn't line up. The
1:47
first adventure we got, Wrath of the
1:49
Dragon Queen, was written by Kobold
1:50
Press, who, you know, outside company,
1:53
very well known to everybody, very well
1:55
known to all of the designers, but they
1:56
didn't even have the final rules when
1:58
they were writing the adventure because
2:00
they hadn't been written yet. So, like,
2:02
just a ton of stuff in early 5e design
2:06
was just an absolute mess. And we got
2:10
really lucky that the game out and came
2:12
out as good as it is and as playable as
2:15
it is cuz it could have just been an
2:17
absolute trainwreck, and it's entirely
2:19
possible that like D&D would have just
2:21
been gone after that.
Games

