DnD 5e’s mounted combat rules are terrible. Easily my favorite dead horse to beat
Sep 11, 2025
DnD 5e’s rules are terrible. Easily my favorite dead horse to beat when discussing problems in 5e. The fact that they got those rules so wrong and have proceeded to largely ignore them for a decade is infuriating.
#dnd #dnd5e #2024dnd #ttrpg #characteroptimization
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
Do I want to talk about D and D 5e's
0:02
mounted combat rules and how messy and
0:03
annoying they are and how much I dislike
0:05
them? Why yes, how much time do you
0:07
have? Uh, I started a podcast because I
0:10
hate these rules so much. Uh, the
0:14
mounted combat rules in DD5e are an
0:17
absolute train wreck. The best thing you
0:19
can do is be a small character writing a
0:21
medium mount because that is the only
0:23
thing that makes sense within the text
0:25
of the rules. anything beyond that and
0:27
you get into really really messy
0:28
conversations around where you are in
0:32
space, what you can reach, what you can
0:34
attack, all of those things. It's a huge
0:36
pain. Don't use the mounted combat rules
0:38
unless you're small character on a
0:39
medium mount. This commenter is asking
0:41
specifically around riding a pet like
0:44
the beast master rangers companions as a
0:47
small character potentially using the
0:49
enlarge reduce spell to change your
0:51
size. First, if you're lying on enlarge
0:54
reduce to be small enough to ride your
0:56
mount, you are not equipped to ride your
0:59
mount. It lasts a minute and it takes
1:01
concentration. The first thing that hits
1:03
you, you're going to be too big to ride
1:04
your animal and then you're going to be
1:06
in trouble. Also, the rules for the
1:08
Beast Master Ranger do not discuss in
1:11
the slightest if there's any special
1:13
rules around riding your companion. If
1:15
you ride them, they have to act as an
1:17
independent creature or they can't
1:19
attack. So, that just gets you in all
1:21
kinds of trouble. So, just don't do it.
1:23
Your best bet is if you want to have a
1:25
pet that you can ride, either cast find
1:27
steed and just assume that it's not
1:28
going to do any attacking or play a
1:31
drake warden ranger. Both of those are
1:33
intended for riding and have slightly
1:36
better rules to support it. They're
1:38
still not amazing because again, 5e
1:40
mounted combat rules are an absolute
1:42
train wreck, but they're at least
1:44
marginally better. And those of you
1:46
thinking, "But what about the 2024
1:48
rules? They must have fixed all of these
1:50
long-standing problems that Tyler has
1:52
been complaining about on the internet
1:54
for so long. Uh, no. No. Straight copy
1:57
pasted. Not one word different. Did not
2:00
get better. Did not fix any of the gaps.
2:02
Uh, I am salty. I am an entire salt
2:07
mine. I am like like concentrated
2:10
seawater. I am so salty.
2:13
Uh on the bright side, when you talk
2:16
about people writing homebrew content
2:18
for uh 5e, anyone who's actually tried
2:21
to work with the mounted combat rules,
2:22
it's a great way to make friends. Just
2:24
be like, "Hey, those mounted combat
2:25
rules suck, right?"
2:26
A surprising number of people designing
2:29
third party content will be like, "Yes,
2:31
let's have an intelligent conversation
2:33
because you know what you're talking
Games
Roleplaying Games
Roleplaying Games
Table Games

