DnD 5e’s mounted combat rules still drive me insane. The 5.5 rules didn’t change them even one word, which is baffling.
#dnd #dnd5e #onthisday
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
Do I want to talk about D&D 5E's mounted
0:02
combat rules and how messy and annoying
0:04
they are and how much I dislike them?
0:06
Why yes, how much time do you have? Uh
0:08
I started a podcast because I hate these
0:10
rules so much.
0:13
Uh the mounted combat rules in D&D 5E
0:16
are an absolute trainwreck. The best
0:18
thing you can do is be a small character
0:20
riding a medium mount because that is
0:22
the only thing that makes sense within
0:24
the text of the rules. Anything beyond
0:26
that and you get into really really
0:28
messy conversations around where you are
0:31
in space, what you can reach, what you
0:33
can attack, all of those things. It's a
0:35
huge pain. Don't use the mounted combat
0:37
rules unless you're a small character on
0:39
a medium mount. This commenter is asking
0:41
specifically around riding a pet like
0:44
the Beast Master Ranger's companions as
0:47
a small character potentially using the
0:49
enlarge/reduce spell to change your
0:51
size. First, if you're relying on
0:53
enlarge/reduce to be small enough to
0:55
ride your mount, you are not equipped to
0:58
ride your mount. It lasts a minute and
1:00
it takes concentration. The first thing
1:02
that hits you, you're going to be too
1:03
big to ride your animal and then you're
1:05
going to be in trouble. Also, the rules
1:08
for the Beast Master Ranger do not
1:09
discuss in the slightest if there's any
1:12
special rules around riding your
1:14
companion. If you ride them, they have
1:16
to act as an independent creature or
1:18
they can't attack. So, that just gets
1:20
you in all kinds of trouble. So, just
1:22
don't do it. Your best bet is if you
1:24
want to have a pet that you can ride,
1:26
either cast find steed and just assume
1:28
that it's not going to do any attacking
1:30
or play a Drake Warden Ranger. Both of
1:32
those are intended for riding and have
1:35
slightly better rules to support it.
1:38
They're still not amazing because again,
1:39
5E's mounted combat rules are an
1:42
absolute trainwreck, but they're at
1:43
least marginally better. And those of
1:45
you thinking, "But what about the 2024
1:47
rules? They must have fixed all of these
1:50
long-standing problems that Tyler has
1:52
been complaining about on the internet
1:53
for so long." Uh no. No, straight copy
1:57
pasted, not one word different. Did not
2:00
get better, did not fix any of the gaps.
2:03
Uh, I am salty. I am an entire salt
2:06
mine. I am like like concentrated
2:10
seawater. I am so salty.
2:13
Uh, [snorts]
2:15
on the bright side, when you talk about
2:16
people writing homebrew content for uh,
2:19
5e, anyone who's actually tried to work
2:21
with the mounted combat rules, it's a
2:22
great way to make friends. Be like,
2:24
"Hey, those mounted combat rules suck,
2:25
right?" A surprising number of people
2:28
designing third-party content will be
2:30
like, "Yes, let's have an intelligent
2:32
conversation, cuz you know what you're
2:34
talking about."
Games

