0:00
Yes, D&D spell casters are expected to
0:02
cast a lot of cantrips. I spoke
0:04
previously about how D&D 5e expects six
0:07
to eight common encounters per day, and
0:09
Mike Mearls discussed the game being
0:11
balanced around 23 rounds of combat per
0:14
day. At low levels, and honestly until
0:16
reasonably high level, full spell
0:18
casters don't have that many spell
0:20
slots, so they won't be able to cast a
0:22
leveled spell every single turn. This is
0:26
intentional. This is on purpose. Spell
0:28
casters are by nature bursty. They have
0:31
big spikes of effectiveness, do a huge
0:33
amount of damage, or have some huge
0:35
effect on the battlefield, but they can
0:38
only do that a few times per day. That
0:40
is the cost of playing a spell caster.
0:42
By comparison, martial characters are
0:44
much more sustainable because they don't
0:46
have a limited pool of spell slots.
0:48
Like, you never run out of sword. A
0:50
fighter can be just as effective all day
0:53
long, provided that their hit points
0:54
hold out. Now, they'll have certain
0:56
features that recharge on short rests,
0:58
and they might have long rests subclass
1:00
features, but the core of the class
1:02
keeps fighting all day long. People have
1:05
talked about spell casters being
1:07
unbalanced, being overpowered since 5e
1:09
launched. Like, this has been an issue
1:11
since at least third edition, and it's
1:13
always been the same problem. Spell
1:15
casters are bursty. They have very
1:17
limited resources that are very
1:19
powerful, so they can take over an
1:21
encounter in a turn, two turns, three
1:24
turns, whatever, and run away with
1:25
things if there's no limitation on their
1:28
resources, which is why D&D needs that
1:31
attrition fight. D&D needs those 23
1:34
rounds of combat. You have to put
1:36
resource pressure on your spell casters,
1:39
or they're disproportionately powerful
1:41
compared to martial characters. At-will
1:44
cantrips became a thing in fourth
1:45
edition and stuck around into fifth
1:47
edition specifically to give spell
1:49
casters something to do once they're
1:52
short on their big spells. It gives you
1:54
a way to remain reasonably effective and
1:57
impactful even when you're not throwing
1:59
fireballs. So, yes, spellcasters are
2:02
expected to cast cantrips. They're
2:04
expected to cast a lot of cantrips,
2:06
honestly. And that is part of the
2:08
balance of the game. Now, that may not
2:10
be how you prefer to play the game, and
2:12
that's perfectly fine. You can change
2:14
things, but understanding the intent of
2:18
the design behind the game empowers you
2:21
to make intelligent changes.