Expensive material components can be an important limitation on spells in dnd 5e, but the no-cost components for most spells are basically just flavor.
#dnd #dnd5e #2024dnd #dmashice
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
How should dungeon masters handle
0:01
granting expensive material components
0:04
for spells in their campaigns? This is a
0:07
hard question without a really clear
0:09
answer. Fifth Edition doesn't have an
0:11
official wealth by level curve, so
0:13
there's no explicit expectation of how
0:16
much money your character should have at
0:17
any given time. I reverse engineered one
0:20
up on rpgbot.net. So, if you Google 5
0:23
wealth by level, I should come up and
0:25
you can use that as a general guideline.
0:27
But if you're relying on the random
0:28
treasure tables, your players should
0:31
gradually get enough treasure that they
0:34
will be able to afford to buy those
0:36
expensive material components. And
0:37
honestly, I'd say just just give them
0:40
the means to convert the gold into
0:42
whatever diamond powder or whatever they
0:44
might need, and that will give them
0:45
enough to cast their spells. The
0:47
expensive material components on spells
0:49
are there to prevent a lot of spells
0:52
from becoming an abuse case, from
0:54
becoming a huge problem in the game.
0:55
like Revivify. It doesn't cost a ton of
0:58
money, but it works very quickly. You
0:59
can use it in combat, and that's
1:01
frequently enough. But if players could
1:03
cast Revivify for free all of the time,
1:06
then death has no threat to the party
1:09
because all it costs to fix as a spell
1:11
slot. Of course, we're seeing a ton of
1:13
new ways to make Raised Dead free to
1:15
cast, but just ignore that. There are
1:18
other spells like heroes feast costs a
1:20
thousand gold pieces to cast and that is
1:23
expensive enough that it's not realistic
1:25
for parties to cast that every single
1:27
day. They might do that on a day where
1:29
they're facing a significant enemy to
1:31
get condition immunities, resistance to
1:33
poison, expand their hit point maximum,
1:35
all of those things, but you can't
1:37
expect them to have that every day
1:38
because a thousand gold pieces is a lot
1:41
of money. fifth edition really doesn't
1:43
have a lot that you can do with gold,
1:45
which is super frustrating. They tried
1:47
to turn the bastion system into a gold
1:49
sync and it didn't really work. Um, so
1:52
really beyond low levels, once everyone
1:54
can comfortably afford full plate, the
1:56
only thing you're going to use gold for
1:58
is those expensive material components.
2:01
And most of the time that's not an
2:03
issue, but there are a few standouts
2:05
where it becomes a problem. So just try
2:08
to stick to that wealth by level curve
2:09
as much as you can. Use random treasure
2:12
generators if that's helpful for you and
2:14
just keep a general idea of how much
2:17
gold the party has and make them
2:18
actually spend gold on expensive
2:20
material components. For the inexpensive
2:23
stuff like the copper coin for detect
2:25
thoughts, like you you don't need to
2:27
keep track of those. Just they have a
2:28
spell component pouch. They have a
2:29
spellcasting focus. You do not need to
2:31
think about it any further. It's more
2:33
important that they use their hands than
2:35
that they track whatever bits of garbage
2:38
on a spreadsheet.
Games
Roleplaying Games
Roleplaying Games
Table Games

