0:00
Let's talk about how mounting and
0:01
dismounting a creature works in D and D
0:04
5e. Not like that. Not like that.
0:08
Still not like that. Uh, riding a horse.
0:12
Let's talk about riding a horse in Dn D.
0:14
Reading straight from the text here.
0:16
During your move, you can mount a
0:18
creature that is within 5T of you or
0:20
dismount. Doing so costs an amount of
0:22
movement equal to half your speed. Round
0:24
down. For example, if your speed is 30
0:25
feet, you spend 15 feet of movement to
0:27
mount a horse. That all seems very
0:31
simple. Now, Dn D is typically played on
0:34
a grid, unless you're doing completely
0:36
theater of the mind, in which case none
0:37
of this stuff matters anyway. Uh, if you
0:40
are playing on a grid, there are some
0:42
massive questions that that single
0:44
paragraph of text leaves us. Where do
0:47
you go when you mount another creature?
0:51
If you are a small or medium creature,
0:53
you fill a 5-ft square. If your mount is
0:57
a medium creature, they fill a five-
0:59
foot square. So presumably when you
1:01
mount the creature, you occupy that same
1:03
five- foot square. But what if you're
1:05
riding a large creature such as a horse,
1:08
the thing that you're most likely to
1:11
ride in Dn D? You still have to obey the
1:15
rules of spacing and positioning in 5e.
1:19
You must still occupy space rules as
1:22
written. You can't end your turn in the
1:25
same space as another creature unless
1:27
that creature is like significantly
1:29
different size or prone. Which means
1:31
rules as written, you can't end your
1:34
turn on a horse because you have to be
1:37
in the same space. Alternatively, maybe
1:40
you just place your character in a 5-ft
1:43
space above your horse's uh 10-ft cube.
1:48
Why? Uh, okay. Let's assume that we're
1:51
just ignoring that and we're considering
1:53
this an exception to the sharing a space
1:55
rule. What space are you in? Cuz you're
1:57
still a 5-ft creature that snaps to the
2:00
space. So, of the eight 5-ft cubes that
2:04
make up a large creatures cubic space,
2:07
which one are you in? Are you in the
2:09
high ones? Are you in the low ones? Are
2:11
you in the back? Are you in the front?
2:12
What happens when your horse turns? uh
2:16
rules as written like okay let's assume
2:19
you're on your horse's right hunch off
2:22
the ground so like you're in the rear
2:24
right space your horse moves forward
2:26
turns 90 degrees to the right you don't
2:29
move so your horse goes forward turns
2:34
you are now on its right front shoulder
2:37
right shoulder I guess there's no back
2:39
shoulder but you're now on its right
2:41
shoulder your horse could spin like a
2:44
pop in place and you go nowhere.
2:50
What are these rules? It's been 10 years
2:54
and they haven't fixed them. What is