What are DnD 5e’s greatest strengths? The game has a lot going for it beyond just name recognition, but I have a couple favorite things. I play a lot of TTRPGs, they all have good parts and bad parts, and familiarity with other games really helps highlight what makes each system special.
#dnd #dnd5e
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
What are D&D 5e's greatest strengths as
0:02
a tabletop role playinging system?
0:04
Beyond just its popularity, beyond just
0:07
how well-known it is and how easy it is
0:09
to find a game compared to other RPGs,
0:11
D&D 5e does actually have a lot going
0:13
for it. My favorite aspect of 5e is the
0:16
concept of optin complexity. They
0:19
designed the game to appeal to a broad
0:21
range of tastes. They wanted to
0:22
consolidate the hobby, bring in the
0:24
entire audience on one edition. So they
0:26
had to cater to the tastes of people who
0:28
are still playing second edition, third
0:30
edition, and fourth edition, which are
0:31
all very different games. Third edition
0:33
and fourth edition have much more
0:35
complex characters. The combat is much
0:37
more like tactical highstakes chess on a
0:40
grid compared to second edition. Second
0:42
edition is comparatively rules light and
0:44
characters are relatively simple without
0:47
a ton of buttons to mess with. 5 does a
0:50
reasonably good job of allowing players
0:52
to choose how much complexity they want
0:54
in their characters. If you want to
0:56
build a champion fighter and just take
0:59
ability score increases on your
1:01
character, that is a perfectly fine way
1:02
to play a character. Conversely, if you
1:05
want to build some like crazy multiclass
1:07
monstrosity with lots of feats and lots
1:10
of buttons to push and lots of decision
1:12
points and tons of customization, you
1:14
can do that, too. And those two
1:16
characters work within the same system
1:18
without the system falling over. Of
1:20
course, optimization can push things to
1:23
the point where that basic champion
1:24
fighter won't be able to keep up, but
1:26
you can still play within the same
1:28
rules, and both of those characters are
1:30
perfectly valid. Fe also does a good job
1:33
of sticking to its one resolution system
1:36
whenever there is a role to be done.
1:38
Like, they consolidated around the name
1:40
D20 tests in 5.5 for a reason, because
1:43
ability checks, saving throws, and
1:45
attack rolls all work essentially the
1:47
same way with the exception of natural
1:48
ones and 20s. It's always just roll a
1:51
d20, add your modifier, roll high, meets
1:54
it, beats it. There are no exceptions.
1:56
Opposed rolls are an exceptional rarity,
1:58
and really, you don't need to learn much
2:00
more beyond that. Previous editions had
2:02
all kinds of specialized systems where
2:04
you had weird obscure modifiers like, oh
2:07
god, 35, any kind of special attack,
2:10
tripping, grappling, whatever.
2:11
Incredibly complicated. Took a whole
2:13
bunch of things. and second edition and
2:15
before like thief skills were a
2:18
percentage that you had to roll under to
2:20
succeed which feels super weird because
2:22
they also had facko and yeah so one
2:25
resolution system it just works it
2:28
doesn't need to be complicated it's on a
2:30
flat mathematical distribution which
2:32
people understand reasonably well
2:34
without thinking a lot about the math so
2:36
that all works for people and it's
2:37
perfectly fine
Games

