Pacing DnD is super hard. The 5-minute adventuring day is a natural player response to bad pacing caused by the utter lack of good guidance on how to adequately pace DnD games.
#dnd #dnd5e #2024dnd #ttrpg #characteroptimization #dungeonsanddragons #dmadvice
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
Pacing in D and D is and has always been
0:04
really stupidly annoyingly hard. Like
0:07
just borderline impossible. I'm a native
0:10
of third edition where the concept of
0:12
the 5-minute adventuring day was
0:14
basically ubiquitous. The idea was your
0:16
party spellcasters would burn all of
0:18
their base spells in the very first
0:20
encounter of any given adventuring day
0:22
and then everyone would just go home so
0:24
the wizard could take a nap. And then
0:26
you would continue adventuring the next
0:28
day and do the same thing over and over
0:30
again. And because a lot of D and D is
0:32
still around dungeons and a lot of
0:34
dungeons are designed where the monsters
0:36
sit in a room and wait for you, that
0:38
works perfectly fine. So it it was very
0:41
video gamey. It was very silly. The
0:43
pacing was terrible and it was never
0:44
very much fun. But from an optimization
0:48
and tactics perspective, the safest,
0:50
most effective thing you could do was
0:52
always one encounter days, burn
0:54
absolutely all of your resources in one
0:57
go, and then go home because stretching
0:59
your resources out over the course of
1:01
the day meant that you had to stretch
1:03
yourselves thinner, which increased
1:04
risk, so nobody did it. Fifth Edition
1:07
still very much has that exact same
1:09
problem. I've talked about this
1:11
previously, but the 2014 Dungeon Masters
1:14
Guide had a section called the
1:15
adventuring day, which was in the
1:17
section around combat encounters. The DM
1:19
was given an XP budget to stretch
1:21
between long rests. The expectation was
1:24
you're going to have six to eight combat
1:26
encounters in a given day so that you
1:28
would adequately challenge your players
1:30
and stretch their resources to a point
1:32
that they actually felt threatened and
1:34
strained in some fashion. But fitting 6
1:37
to8 encounters in a single adventuring
1:39
day is a nightmare. Like the considering
1:42
how long combat can take in Dn D. Um
1:46
those six to eight combat encounters
1:48
that might be a month's worth of play,
1:50
which means your players might not get
1:52
to take a long rest for an entire month,
1:54
which is deeply dissatisfying. So pacing
1:57
D and D is really, really hard. And the
1:59
2024 rules have only made that worse
2:01
because now like we had bad guidance in
2:05
the 2014 rules. Now we have no guidance.
2:08
We're basically left to guess how much
2:10
our party should be able to handle in a
2:12
given adventuring day. My personal
2:14
opinion is the expectation should be
2:17
three deadly in the 2014 rules, hard in
2:21
the 2024 rules, three combat encounters
2:24
between long rests, one short rest in
2:26
between. If you're using the gritty
2:28
realism variant from the 2014 Dungeon
2:31
Masters Guide, like that can make things
2:33
a lot better. The pacing feels a lot
2:35
more natural. It feels more internally
2:37
consistent to your world. So, that's
2:39
personally what I like to do. Um, and
2:42
then yeah, like you might have fights
2:43
every couple of days, unless you're
2:45
doing a dungeon crawl. And that honestly
2:47
that just works so much better than the
2:49
default pacing.
Games
Games
Roleplaying Games
Roleplaying Games
Table Games

