2024 DnD’s bastion rules are fun, but extremely abusable.
#dnd #2024dnd #dmadvice
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
D and D's bastion rules are really cool,
0:02
but they're just not well written. The
0:04
Bastion system aimed to fix two
0:06
problems. First, it gives players a
0:08
home, so they're no longer murder
0:10
tourists. And second, it gives players a
0:13
gold sync. Gold has been a huge problem
0:15
in 5e in that there's there's really
0:17
just nothing to spend it on. There's
0:19
full plate and spell components, and
0:21
really that's it. So, this gives every
0:24
party an interesting thing to pour their
0:26
gold into. But but the things that you
0:30
spend gold on for your bastion are
0:32
functionally cosmetic. Like they they
0:35
really don't do anything. Beyond that,
0:39
there's a bunch of mechanical issues
0:41
just within the bastion rules. Even
0:42
ignoring the gold cost issues. Like if
0:45
you want defensive walls for your
0:46
bastion, the optimal design for your
0:49
bastion is an inverted pyramid with a
0:52
very very tiny base with a little tiny
0:54
wall around it and one door. And that is
0:57
the easiest way to defend your bastion
0:59
because apparently ladders don't exist.
1:01
I don't know. A lot of the facilities
1:03
for bastions just really aren't very
1:05
good. But the biggest the biggest
1:08
problem with bastions is the second you
1:11
hit level 9, they become a factory for
1:13
uncommon magic items. You can have NPCs
1:17
produce uncommon magic items for you. It
1:19
takes them about a week, which means
1:21
every week you're getting a batch of
1:23
free uncommon magic items. This
1:26
obviously doesn't solve the attunement
1:27
issue. Like you you're still limited to
1:29
attuning to three items, but there are a
1:31
ton of really powerful magic items,
1:34
common and uncommon, that don't require
1:36
attunement. Like imagine that you just
1:39
churned out a bunch of jugs of alchemy
1:41
and then just had them pouring out
1:44
poison on mass and you could just poison
1:46
all of your weapons all the time. Sure,
1:48
basic poison isn't especially useful,
1:50
but go sell it for hundreds of gold a
1:52
vile. You can get rods of the packed
1:54
keeper. You can get immovable rods. You
1:56
can get bags of holding which you can
1:58
then turn into bombs. So like just the
2:01
ability to churn out free magic items.
2:04
Like you don't even have to pay a cost
2:06
to produce them. The the bastion just
2:08
does it for you. And magically the
2:11
bastion is self- sustaining. So it pays
2:13
for all of its own costs. There is no
2:16
way to balance the game when players can
2:20
have a a functionally infinite quantity
2:23
of even uncommon rarity magic items. The
2:27
number of things that you can do that
2:28
just knock the game over almost
2:30
immediately means that using the Bastion
2:32
system as written is pretty prohibitive.
Games
Games
Roleplaying Games
Roleplaying Games
Table Games

