6-8 encounters in dnd almost certainly does mean combat encounters because non-combat encounters don’t reliably consume expendable resources.
#dnd #dmd5e #2024dnd #ttrpg #dungeonsanddragons #dmadvice
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
This is a comment on my recent video
0:01
about pacing in Dn D and it it's a good
0:04
point and we should have this
0:05
discussion. So the 6 to8 encounter day
0:09
from the 2014 Dungeon Masters Guide is
0:12
from a section called the adventuring
0:14
day which is under the section on combat
0:17
encounters. So just by organization it's
0:20
reasonable to assume that those 6 to8
0:22
encounters are intended to be combat
0:24
encounters. It is also reasonable to say
0:27
that it doesn't have to be combat
0:28
encounters. It can just be encounters
0:31
that consume resources of some kind. Eat
0:34
hit dice, eat spell slots, things like
0:36
that. But it is really difficult to make
0:39
those non-combat encounters consume
0:42
expendable resources. When players walk
0:44
into a social situation, they don't
0:47
typically go in thinking like, "Oh yeah,
0:49
I'm going to have to ask the wizard to
0:50
burn a bunch of spell slots and the
0:52
cleric's going to have to heal me."
0:53
Like, no, that's not how that works.
0:55
you're probably going to use like
0:56
guidance and maybe enhance. So lowlevel
1:00
resources in small quantities. So those
1:03
aren't serious resource expending
1:05
encounters. The particular comment that
1:07
I'm starting this video from calls out
1:09
doors and traps. Handling doors. You
1:11
might cast find traps to see if there
1:13
are traps in the area, but it's
1:14
incredibly imprecise, so you still need
1:16
to fall back on skills. You might handle
1:18
locks by casting knock, but knock like
1:21
it's an expensive resource for what can
1:24
be handled with a slight of hand check
1:26
in the 2024 rules or thieves tools check
1:29
in the 2014 rules. And it's so easy to
1:32
be good at that. Why would you bother
1:34
taking knock? Traps have that same
1:37
problem. Like you you can't reasonably
1:39
expect players to go through significant
1:41
limited resources when they're handling
1:43
a trap. They might take some damage, so
1:45
they might need to take a short rest and
1:47
spend some hit dice or they might go
1:48
through some inexpensive healing
1:50
resources. Like I if they have time,
1:53
they could use prayer of healing or
1:55
something like that to heal themselves a
1:58
whole lot at a very very low resource
2:00
cost. So, we can't reasonably expect
2:04
social situations, doors, traps,
2:07
exploration scenarios, we can't expect
2:09
those to be a real resource pressure,
2:12
especially since so many of those
2:14
problems can even be handled by
2:16
completely mundane means. Like, all of
2:18
those situations can be handled
2:21
perfectly by a well-built rogue with no
2:24
spells of any kind. And it doesn't
2:26
require a single resource. It just
2:28
requires time and checks and maybe
2:31
rolling well. So, we can't reasonably
2:33
expect non-combat situations to deplete
2:37
resources in the same way that a combat
2:39
encounter would. So, when we account for
2:42
balancing an adventuring day, when we
2:44
account for pacing challenges for
2:46
players, like those things are all fun
2:48
parts of the game, but they don't make
2:51
combat harder. And that's the issue with
2:53
D and D's pacing is how do we make
2:56
combat adequately challenging for a
Games
Roleplaying Games

