0:00
Is it valid to cast D and D spells like
0:02
toll the dead on chests and other
0:04
objects and stuff to see if they are
0:06
creatures or if they are in fact
0:08
objects? This is a good question. So, a
0:10
lot of spells in Dn D specify that they
0:12
target creatures rather than just
0:14
targets or objects or something like
0:16
that. So, you could in theory use those
0:18
to target an object to find out if it
0:21
was a mimic. Is this valid? Rules is
0:24
written. Yes. uh if you attempt to cast
0:26
a spell in an invalid way, the spell
0:28
simply fails. So like you could cast
0:30
toll the dead and it would just fail if
0:33
you tried to cast it on a chest because
0:35
toll the dead only targets creatures.
0:37
And this highlights kind of a weird
0:39
oddity in the 5De rules. Like they very
0:41
much assume that you're going to use
0:42
combat abilities specifically in combat
0:45
against enemy combatants. And a lot of
0:47
times those abilities kind of break down
0:49
when you try and use them outside of
0:51
combat. It's not quite as bad as it was
0:53
in 4E, but it can still be pretty bad.
0:56
So, rules is written. This strategy
0:58
absolutely works, but whether or not
1:00
your DM is going to allow it really
1:01
comes down to your table. Um, so these
1:03
are good questions to have with your DM.
1:06
Like, it I would like to try this. Is
1:09
this something that you're comfortable
1:10
with? Cuz yeah, rules is written, it
1:13
works, but it feels very against the
1:14
spirit of the game. Um, and to all of
1:17
the people who are going to say like,
1:18
ah, this is this is unfair. I would
1:20
never allow this at my table. Well, it's
1:21
like casting Toll the Dead to find out
1:23
if a chest is a mimic isn't any stronger
1:26
than throwing a rock at it and seeing if
1:28
it sticks to the mimic because mimics
1:30
are sticky. So, this doesn't get you
1:32
anything that you couldn't do by
1:34
completely mundane means, but it is a
1:37
weird rules interaction.