0:00
This comment asked kind of an
0:01
interesting design question. Underneath
0:03
the actual text of the question, the
0:05
user is asking, "How do we balance the
0:08
players need to mitigate risks with the
0:12
fun of encountering those risks live?"
0:15
Specifically, they call out using
0:17
familiars to scout dungeons, which yeah,
0:19
using your familiar to scout a dungeon
0:21
is great because your familiar is
0:23
functionally expendable. You can reummon
0:25
them for 10 gold pieces with a ritual.
0:27
So, if you lose them, it's a super brief
0:30
inconvenience. Sorry, Cora. Am I
0:32
familiar? But it's considerably safer
0:36
than having one of the players stumble
0:38
into a trap and die, cuz bringing a
0:40
player back costs considerably more gold
0:42
and probably has much more emotional
0:44
impacts than losing your magically
0:46
summoned cat. So, the question is, how
0:49
do we balance the need for players to
0:52
mitigate dangers in a dangerous
0:53
situation while also making those
0:55
dangers fun? Honestly, I don't think you
0:57
need to. 10-ft poles have been a thing
1:00
since like OD and D before it was even
1:02
advanced Dungeons and Dragons. Players
1:04
would use 10-ft poles and tap anything
1:06
that could potentially be dangerous and
1:09
being cautious in a dangerous dangerous
1:11
situation was part of the expected play
1:14
style. Like that's gone away in the days
1:16
of passive perception and things like
1:18
that. But still, if a sensible person
1:21
going into a situation that they knew
1:24
was dangerous, like you would expect
1:26
them to take steps to protect
1:29
themselves, to be cautious, to uh scout
1:32
things safely, like throw things down a
1:34
hall, send a familiar to scout the area
1:37
because again, the familiar is easily
1:39
replaced, resummoned. In an internally
1:41
consistent world, you shouldn't expect
1:43
all of your players characters to be
1:45
idiots and stumble into every single
1:47
trap. You need to challenge them in
1:48
different ways. If they're scouting an
1:51
area with their familiar, reward them
1:53
for that, but every once in a while,
1:55
kill the familiar so that they they feel
1:57
like, yes, I did the right thing sending
2:00
my reummonable creature into the
2:03
dangerous spot instead of myself. Now,
2:05
they have that reinforcement like, yes,
2:07
I did a thing to mitigate risk to
2:08
myself. They feel good about that. And
2:11
you know, you can change the surprises
2:13
after that because maybe now all of the
2:15
enemies are on alert that somebody is
2:17
scouting around their dungeon looking