The current lack of background options is more of an issue than the way that backgrounds work
Nov 6, 2025
The current lack of background options is more of an issue than the way that backgrounds work. As we get more options, the restriction will stop being frustrating and it will become more interesting.
#dmd #dnd5e #2024dnd #characteroptimization
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
This comment brings up kind of a
0:01
fundamental restriction in the 2024 D
0:04
and D rules because we have such a
0:06
limited number of backgrounds currently.
0:08
Like we just got a bunch of new ones,
0:10
but we still don't have a huge roster.
0:12
But because we have so few, there are
0:15
objectively correct choices when you're
0:17
matching a background to a class. Like
0:20
farmer is a very obvious choice for
0:22
fighter because you can get strength and
0:24
constitution gives you the tough feat.
0:26
Like for each individual class, there
0:29
are maybe two or three backgrounds in
0:30
the player's handbook that give you the
0:32
ability scores that you need and a feat
0:34
that actually works for you. That's
0:36
incredibly restrictive. Since the 2024
0:39
rules are an update to fifth edition, a
0:41
lot of us are very accustomed to the
0:43
post Tasha's world that we've been in
0:46
for five plus years where ability scores
0:48
are more flexible, where we've got 30
0:50
plus species options to choose from. But
0:53
remember back to the early days of 2014
0:56
5e, we had the exact same problem except
0:58
the ability scores were coming from our
1:00
race. So like if you wanted to play a
1:03
monk, you wanted dexterity and wisdom
1:05
increases and the only way to get that
1:07
in the player's handbook was wood elf.
1:09
So wood elf monk was the answer. So,
1:12
we're basically in that same space that
1:14
we were in the early 2014 5D rules where
1:18
we just don't have enough options yet to
1:21
allow a lot of flexibility. So, if
1:23
that's a problem for your game, if
1:24
you're really chafing at those
1:26
restrictions, consider the custom
1:27
background rules, consider third-party
1:29
content, consider just making stuff up
1:32
at home. Um, there's a lot of things
1:34
that you can do. I understand the
1:36
restrictions are very frustrating for a
1:38
lot of people and that's perfectly fine.
1:40
like the the restrictions will become
1:42
less of a problem as we get more
1:44
character options. We just got Heroes of
1:46
Forgotten Realms which gave us a bunch
1:48
of new options and Forge of the
1:49
Artificer is coming in I think early
1:51
December or like at the end of November.
1:54
So hopefully we'll get some more options
1:56
there. Um, but as we get more and more
1:59
background options, especially ones that
2:01
use existing feats, especially from the
2:03
player's handbook, I think we're going
2:05
to see those restrictions loosen as we
2:07
have more choices and backgrounds become
2:09
less of a restriction on the
Games
Roleplaying Games

