Everyone should absolutely feel empowered to change the rules to suit their needs, but we still need the published rules to work so that we can actually play the same game. #dnd #dnd5e #2024dnd #ttrpg #dungeonsanddragons
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
this is a pretty common response I see
0:02
on basically any video discussing the
0:04
rules for D&D Pathfinder any tabletop
0:07
RPG really uh the idea that yeah you
0:10
just change the rules if you don't like
0:12
them for whatever reason and and that
0:14
makes sense rule zero in any RPG is the
0:16
rules are what you decide they are the
0:19
rules are how you interpret them and
0:20
you're free to change them as you see
0:22
fit but when we discuss these games
0:25
online I'm not at your table i don't
0:28
know how you have changed the rules and
0:30
probably nobody else does either so we
0:33
can't engage in meaningful discussion
0:35
about game rules if you come into the
0:38
discussion with a wildly different
0:39
interpretation or if your attitude is
0:41
just I'm just going to ignore that rule
0:43
i'm just going to change that rule um we
0:46
want the rules to be good as a baseline
0:50
we want the rules to work for as many
0:53
people as possible and sure there's
0:54
always folks who are going to change
0:56
things because of personal preference
0:58
but we want the rules to be understood
1:00
and playable from that baseline without
1:03
modification because if the game doesn't
1:06
work at its baseline the game doesn't
1:09
work at all and sure you can change the
1:12
rules a ton you can take a really awful
1:15
rule set and tweak it until it works for
1:17
you but it creates this kind of ship of
1:19
Thesius situation where like eventually
1:21
you have replaced so many parts in the
1:24
game it's not really the same game it
1:26
has the same shape it does the same
1:28
thing it has the same trappings but it's
1:31
no longer Thesius's original ship how
1:34
far can you change Dn D before it stops
1:37
being DND and it's basically some system
1:39
that you created with Dn D trappings
1:42
there's absolutely nothing wrong with
1:43
that but it does make it very difficult
1:45
to have rules discussions
Games
Games
Computer & Video Games
Sandbox Games
Roleplaying Games
Roleplaying Games
Table Games
Hobbies & Leisure
Virtual Worlds
Gaming Reference & Reviews

