The pugilist is really powerful, but it only needs a couple changes to bring it more in line with the rest of the game.
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
The D and D pugilist on D and D beyond
0:02
is broken. It is incredibly overpowered
0:05
and absolutely just runs away with the
0:08
max expectations for D and D 5e. But can
0:11
we balance it without doing like some
0:14
massive redesign? Probably. Yeah. Um the
0:18
biggest problem with the class is
0:19
Haymaker. Without Haymaker, it is a
0:22
solid class. It does good damage. It's
0:24
got good utility, interesting buttons to
0:27
push, and it's a ton of fun to play.
0:29
delivers very well on the fantasy of a
0:32
like non-mmystic bare knuckle fighter,
0:35
but Haymaker allows you to maximize the
0:37
damage dice on your unharmed strikes and
0:40
with your pugilist weapon. So, simple
0:42
weapons, improvised weapons, but it
0:44
isn't limited to the weapon damage dice.
0:46
It's any dice on the attack. Pugilist
0:48
has built-in options that add additional
0:51
damage dice, and then you can stack on
0:53
things like
0:55
Strike of the Giants. Uh, the Goliath
0:58
has several racial traits that let you
1:00
add additional damage. Hex, hunter's
1:03
mark, divine favor, like conjure miner
1:07
elementals could go on there. Like
1:08
literally anything that adds damage dice
1:10
to the attack can be maximized with
1:12
haymaker. And there's functionally no
1:15
cost to using Haymaker. [snorts]
1:17
And that lack of a cost is the
1:19
fundamental problem. If it costs
1:21
something, it wouldn't be such an issue.
1:23
But you only pay the cost if you miss.
1:26
So, you're only going to use it when
1:27
you're likely to hit. So, the cost is
1:29
functionally negligible. You're going to
1:31
get advantage easily from knocking
1:33
enemies prone or from anything else in
1:35
the class. There's a bunch of options
1:37
just built into the subasses for getting
1:39
easy advantage. And if you're still
1:40
worried, you can add things like bless
1:42
or the uh that one elixir from the
1:45
alchemist artificer that gives you 1d4
1:47
on all of your attacks. Like you can you
1:49
can get magic items. There's so many
1:51
ways to boost your attack so you will
1:53
functionally never miss, which means you
1:55
are functionally always doing maximum
1:58
damage. So the easiest fix is just
2:01
either remove haymaker or impose
2:03
disadvantage when you use it. Previous
2:05
versions of the pugilist impose
2:07
disadvantage on the feature. Like
2:11
previous versions of the pugilist impose
2:12
disadvantage on your attacks when you
2:14
tried to use it, which offset the huge
2:17
benefit of maximizing your damage.
2:19
Honestly, I don't know why that
2:20
diversion didn't make it on into D and D
2:22
Beyond. And a lot of people in comments
2:25
on my videos are operating for from the
2:27
assumption that that's still a thing.
2:29
It's not. Beyond that, reducing the
2:32
Fisticuff's damage die to be the exact
2:35
same progression as the monk's damage
2:36
dice is probably also a good choice. The
2:39
fact that they're one step ahead seems
2:41
completely unnecessary, especially in
2:43
the 2024 rules where the monk's damage
2:45
is already really
Entertainment Industry
Online Media
Games
Roleplaying Games

