Removing concentration from Hunter’s Mark would definitely make the DnD Ranger more powerful, but would introduce some other issues. Solvable issues, but still issues.
#dnd #dnd5e #2024dnd #ranger #ttrpg #dungeonsanddragons
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
what happens to D and D's ranger if we
0:02
make Hunter's Mark not require
0:04
concentration that's an awesome question
0:07
so there's a ton of precedent in the
0:09
mechanics and we can even look at the
0:10
one D and D play test for you know
0:13
results of how this would play out they
0:15
briefly experimented with rangers being
0:18
able to cast Hunter Mark as it is
0:20
without requiring concentration and they
0:22
tried a different ways for that to work
0:24
so if we just take the spell as is and
0:26
remove concentration it immediately
0:28
becomes too powerful because the ranger
0:30
can outdamage any other character in the
0:33
game up until about level five and even
0:35
then after that they're pretty good
0:37
basically on cruise control so that was
0:40
deemed a little too powerful so they
0:42
tried a couple of different things uh
0:43
they tried making Hunter's Mark once per
0:46
turn so like you only get the damage
0:48
bonus once per turn but it doesn't
0:49
require concentration and uh folks
0:52
decided that wasn't strong enough
0:54
because it didn't encourage things that
0:56
have worked for the ranger historically
0:58
in 5e crossbow X or two weapon fighting
1:01
just getting more attacks to apply that
1:03
stacking damage bonus i do still think
1:05
that could work as an option if the
1:08
damage scaling was better than what we
1:10
got in that play test and you can look
1:12
at the monster slayer ranger who has a
1:15
very similar ability um hunter's prey I
1:17
believe it is that or slayer's prey i I
1:20
honestly I can never remember so it it's
1:22
effectively hunter mark without
1:24
concentration you apply it as a bonus
1:26
action and then once per turn you can
1:28
deal 1d6 bonus damage when you hit them
1:30
with an attack and conveniently that
1:33
does stack with hunter's mark so it's
1:35
pretty reliable damage but it does tax
1:37
your bonus actions pretty heavily so
1:38
like that could just be a thing the
1:40
hunter's mark could just be 1d6
1:43
once per turn no concentration and maybe
1:47
the damage scales as the spell gains
1:50
level and that would work perfectly fine
1:52
um alternatively we can look at what a
1:54
lot of other subasses have done
1:56
especially for the wizard where um like
1:58
a summon spell that normally lasts for
2:00
an hour you can cast it without
2:02
concentration but it only lasts for a
2:04
minute so we could do the same thing
2:05
with hunter's mark there so you're not
2:07
stretching that same spell slot across
2:10
multiple encounters but you don't have
2:12
to worry about concentration um there
2:15
there's arguably an issue with being
2:18
able to cast Hunter's Mark multiple
2:19
times in the same encounter but remember
2:21
that spells on a single creature don't
2:23
stack with themselves so like you sure
2:26
you could spread it around between
2:27
multiple creatures but there's a huge
2:29
resource cost to doing that and
2:30
personally I think that's fine my ideal
2:33
fix would be Hunter's Mark once per turn
2:38
scales better or scales damage as the
2:41
spell gains levels doesn't require
2:43
concentration i think that's the best
2:45
solution but everyone's going to arrive
2:47
at a slightly different conclusion
Games
Games
Roleplaying Games
Roleplaying Games
Table Games

