Healing in DnD combat turns combat into an attrition fight rhat payers almost always lose
May 5, 2026
Healing in DnD combat turns combat into an attrition fight where your enemies don’t care about long-term costs of attrition, but players do. Removing enemies from the fight is more efficient.
#dnd #dnd5e #2024dnd
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
Healing in combat is still a bad idea,
0:02
even in the D&D 5.5 rules. Character
0:05
optimizers and experienced players have
0:07
been discouraging healing in combat in
0:09
D&D since at least as far back as third
0:11
edition. And to this day, it remains a
0:14
poor choice in combat because it is
0:17
fundamentally an attrition fight in a
0:19
game where players always lose attrition
0:23
fights. Players are limited by spell
0:25
slots, by daily abilities, by how many
0:27
potions are in their pockets, and they
0:30
have finite resources to heal themselves
0:32
at any given time. The enemies may also
0:35
have technically limited resources like
0:37
spell slots, but those creatures
0:38
generally only need to live about three
0:41
rounds to be successful. Players need to
0:43
live the entire campaign. So, any
0:46
situation where you turn combat into an
0:48
attrition fight, even if you win that
0:50
fight, you have lost that fight because
0:53
you have spent significantly more
0:55
resources than the game expects you to
0:57
spend in any given combat. Healing is an
0:59
especially useful example because it is
1:01
such a clear treadmill. You are spending
1:04
a spell slot or something equivalent to
1:06
heal yourself or another player
1:08
character for an amount of damage that
1:10
the monsters are probably able to do in
1:12
a single action without spending a
1:15
limited resource. So, you are at best
1:18
spending a spell slot to stall for time.
1:22
Enemy damage will also scale as you gain
1:24
levels and as enemy CR increases, and to
1:27
keep up with the amount of healing that
1:29
you need to do just to keep pace on that
1:31
treadmill, you need to cast higher and
1:33
higher level spells. So, you are
1:35
spending your most powerful resource to
1:38
just buy yourself not even a round, a
1:41
turn. You're buying yourself a turn by
1:44
healing in combat. Now, there are some
1:46
notable exceptions here. Healing Word is
1:49
arguably the most important healing
1:51
spell in the game because you can rescue
1:53
an unconscious ally, and the most
1:55
important hit point is the last hit
1:58
point. So, as long as they have 1 HP,
2:00
they're still in the fight, they're
2:01
fine. Spells that also heal like enough
2:04
hit points to get someone from zero to
2:07
above half, those are generally worth
2:09
it. So, spells like heal or lay on hands
2:12
or power word heal, like those are good
2:15
options for in combat healing. But, it's
2:18
a one-and-done that does a ton of
2:21
healing compared to something like
2:23
healing word or healing spirit or cure
2:26
wounds even. So, with rare exception,
2:28
save healing, especially if it uses your
2:31
action, save that for outside of combat.
2:33
You should be using your action to
2:35
defeat your enemies because damage that
2:37
your party never takes never needs to be
2:40
healed.
Games

