The martial/caster divide in DnD is very real, and I have some thoughts on how to address it.
#dnd #dnd5e #2024dnd
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
Of course I have thoughts on the
0:01
Marshall caster divide in D and D. Of
0:03
course I do. I'm a wizard man. Keep the
0:07
Marshall caster divide. Keep it.
0:10
Marshalls don't deserve to have fun. How
0:11
dare they? No, I'm I'm kidding. I'm
0:13
kidding. Obviously. Uh I'm RPGbot. I
0:16
write about character optimization. And
0:18
something that you learn very quickly
0:20
when you write about character
0:21
optimization is most optimized things
0:24
are spellcasters in some fashion. I
0:27
challenge any marshall character that
0:29
can't cast spells to suddenly make their
0:31
familiar appear. Anyway, marshall cer
0:34
divide. So, the biggest issue in D and D
0:35
is that spellcasters grow in capability
0:38
exponentially. What they can do grows so
0:42
much faster than what fighters can do.
0:44
Marshall characters become tougher. They
0:46
can deal more damage. They have more
0:48
ways to stab things. Wizards can change
0:52
reality. Wizards can one-shot
0:54
encounters. and martial characters just
0:57
can't keep up with that. That now that's
0:59
not to say that marshall characters
1:00
aren't fun and satisfying to play. And
1:02
wizards are obviously glass cannons, so
1:04
they do have limitations, but with the
1:06
way that most people play Dn D, the
1:09
limitations on spellcasters aren't
1:12
significant enough that Marshall
1:14
characters feel like they can keep up.
1:15
Part of that is people are just really
1:17
bad at pacing D and D, cuz 5e does
1:19
sincerely make that a nightmare to do
1:21
well. But also just a a wizard can solve
1:25
most problems with one spell, whereas
1:28
marshall characters typically need
1:30
skills and tools and time and maybe
1:32
magic items, whereas a wizard can just
1:34
be like, uh, locks knock. Um, enemies
1:38
uh, banish or fireball or whatever, and
1:41
like all of your problems are solved.
1:43
This user suggests adding battlem just
1:46
as a default thing for marshall
1:48
characters, and that's certainly an
1:49
option, and I encourage you to try that.
1:51
Let me know how it goes. Personally, I
1:53
don't think you need to use the battlem
1:55
system specifically. Go into the 2014
1:58
dungeon masters guide and there's a
2:00
bunch of variant rules in there which
2:01
introduce special attacks that marshall
2:03
characters can take. Climbing a
2:05
creature, disarming a creature, a few
2:07
other things that I'm forgetting right
2:09
now, but look at those in detail in
2:11
general. Just let those things be in the
2:14
game. They offer other things that
2:16
marshall characters can do beyond what
2:19
is listed in their class features and
2:21
beyond just stabbing things. Offering
2:24
those options for Marshall characters to
2:26
use gives them more buttons that they
2:28
can push in combat, which makes them
2:30
dramatically more interesting to play
2:32
and significantly more effective.
Games
Games
Roleplaying Games
Roleplaying Games
Table Games

