DnD’s gritty realism rebalances the game in a way that works much better for how most groups play DnD in today’s world. It has some issues with dungeon crawls, but you want still do them without much additional stress.
#dmd #dnd5e #2024dnd #ttrpg #dungeonsanddragons #dmadvice
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
This comment comes from a discussion
0:01
around the gritty realism variant for Dn
0:04
D. So, just to recap on what that is, it
0:06
changes the way resting works. So, a
0:08
long rest takes an entire week. A short
0:10
rest takes 8 hours. So, basically what a
0:13
long rest was previously. So, you're
0:15
essentially stretching an adventuring
0:17
day from a single day into multiple
0:20
days. And you might go like one week of
0:22
adventure, one week not adventuring. Um,
0:24
and I personally advocate for that
0:27
because I think that pacing works a lot
0:29
better for how people tell stories in Dn
0:31
D today. This user's complaint with the
0:33
system is that postponing long rests so
0:36
that they take an entire week makes
0:38
things really, really hard for
0:40
spellcasters, non-warlocks specifically,
0:43
because you're depending on spell slots
0:45
that take you an entire week to get
0:47
back. And yes, that is a problem, but at
0:49
the same time, that is the point. It's
0:51
been a longtime criticism of Dn D that
0:54
spellcasters are disproportionately more
0:56
powerful than marshall characters,
0:58
especially the fullcasters, clerics,
1:00
druids, wizards. Like you h you are so
1:03
much more powerful and so much more
1:05
bursty that you dominate combat
1:07
encounters. You dominate most situations
1:10
because you can throw a resource at it.
1:12
And plausibly the DM can only fit like
1:15
two or three encounters between long
1:17
rests unless you're crawling a dungeon.
1:19
So, you're going to go nova in every
1:21
single encounter that you're in, and
1:23
then it it's not a challenge, and
1:25
basically the marshals are just there to
1:27
stand in the way and keep enemies from
1:28
getting to you. Gritty realism flips
1:31
that logic to some degree. The
1:33
spellcasters need to manage their
1:35
resources much more carefully because
1:37
they don't know how long it's going to
1:38
be until their next rest. At the same
1:40
time, classes that depend on short rests
1:42
become much more effective because like,
1:44
yes, you still have to manage your
1:45
resources. you might only have one or
1:47
two combat encounters per day, which
1:49
means you're only going to have one or
1:50
two combat encounters between short
1:52
rests. So, unless you're crawling a
1:55
dungeon where it's fight after fight
1:57
after fight after fight, it works really
1:59
well. And this is how most people tell
2:01
stories in D and D anyway because like
2:04
if you're traveling over land, you might
2:06
have one random encounter per day. It's
2:07
like, oh great, the wizards are going to
2:09
nuke it turn one. Why did we even bother
2:11
rolling initiative? Gritty realism
2:13
variant isn't about being gritty or
2:15
realistic. It's about changing the
2:17
pacing of the game so that you can tell
2:20
stories that aren't dungeon crawls and
2:22
still challenge your party adequately.
2:25
It does require you to shift your
2:27
expectations, but that's fine. The
2:29
expectations are more in line with how
2:30
people play the game today anyway. And
2:33
if you want to do a dungeon crawl, you
2:34
still can. Just the party needs to know
2:37
this is going to be an unusual challenge
2:39
for how we've been running the game.
2:40
Maybe you turn off gritty realism just
2:42
for that dungeon. Or maybe just lower
2:44
the difficulty of the dungeon.
2:46
Effectively, you're going to have two or
2:47
three encounters in this dungeon and
2:49
then you're going to have a short rest.
2:50
And like maybe that's just how you do
2:52
your dungeons. You do a five room
2:53
dungeon with three combat encounters.
2:55
And that works perfectly fine. I've run
2:58
games like that. It works great.
Games
Games
Roleplaying Games
Roleplaying Games
Table Games

