Did World of Warcraft DnD consider a mana mechanic instead of spell slots? We asked James Wyatt, and he had a really thoughtful answer!
#dnd #2024dnd #wow
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
Did you guys consider doing some sort of
0:02
mana mechanic? Like I've seen the spell
0:05
slots variant from the 2014 dungeon
0:07
masters guide. I've seen that suggested
0:09
as closer to mana from a video game. So
0:13
that might be an interesting option in
0:15
place of spell slots, especially when
0:17
adapting video.
0:18
>> So here's another funny story. Um, when
0:21
I was working on the plain shift
0:23
articles, I did some tinkering around
0:25
with what if we take the spell points
0:27
rules and add color mechanics to it and
0:30
basically translate a magic mechanic
0:32
into a D and D mechanic in that way. Um,
0:35
but none of that is in the the magic
0:38
crossover books. And the reason for that
0:41
is that the fundamental purpose of those
0:42
books is to let you play D and D in
0:44
these worlds that that happen to have
0:46
been created for a different game. And
0:47
so that that philosophy carried through
0:49
into this book as well, that this is not
0:52
about translating World of Warcraft as a
0:55
as a game to the tabletop. It's about
0:58
playing the game of Dn D in the World of
1:00
Warcraft. Um, so the the particularly
1:03
amusing part of it is that Joey Hake is
1:05
running a campaign that I'm playing in
1:07
right now, and he is using the spelloint
1:09
mechanic from the 2014 Dungeon Master's
1:11
Guide as an optional is a variant rule
1:12
in the setting. I don't I don't care for
1:14
it. It's not my thing. I wanted to play
1:16
[laughter] D and D. So, I'm not playing
1:19
as Bowcaster and that's fine. But that
1:20
that fundamental principle of we're
1:22
sitting down here to play D and D, not
1:24
to play World of Warcraft, not to play
1:25
some other game.
1:26
>> And you know, that's that's important
1:28
for D and D players who might be picking
1:30
up this book to to loot it for classes
1:32
and monsters and dungeons and whatever,
1:34
but it's also important for World of
1:36
Warcraft players who we want to migrate
1:38
into Dungeons and Dragons and learn how
1:39
to play the game. So, um yeah, it was it
1:42
was that was never on the table. We do
1:44
have potions of mana in the book that
1:46
are are basically like a pearl of power
1:50
fundamentally. You get your spell slots
1:52
back. But but
1:53
>> yeah,
1:53
>> I guess there there's a bigger issue
1:55
there about um the rhythm of play and
1:58
how how resources re recharge over time.
2:03
[clears throat] In WoW, they recharge
2:04
very quickly. In D and D, there's a rest
2:07
mechanic where you're resting for an
2:08
hour or overnight to get everything
2:10
back. And and that just changes the way
2:12
you interact with a world in some pretty
2:14
fundamental ways.
Games
Roleplaying Games

