The Tragic Real-Life Story Of John Mellencamp
21K views
Apr 2, 2025
Everybody can enjoy or even relate to the people and themes in John Mellencamp's music. That's because Mellencamp is a real guy who's lived a few lifetimes' worth of drama and struggle. Here's a look into the tragic real-life story that shaped and influenced the life and work of John Mellencamp.
View Video Transcript
0:00
Everybody can relate to the people and themes in John Mellencamp's music
0:04
That's because he's a real guy who's lived a few lifetimes' worth of drama and struggle
0:08
Here's a look into the tragic, real-life story that shaped the life and work of John Mellencamp
0:14
Mellencamp is lucky he made it out of his childhood alive. Shortly after his birth in 1951
0:20
he underwent surgery for spina bifida, a birth defect that leaves an opening in the spinal column
0:25
that can make the spinal cord extend outside the body and leave a growth. That was usually
0:29
Usually a fatal condition back in the early 50s, but a new surgical technique saved young
0:34
Mellencamp's life. More than 60 years later, in 2014, he met the surgeon who performed the operation, Dr
0:41
Robert Heimberger. They remembered it because I was the first one they'd ever done
0:45
According to Mellencamp, Heimberger and associates performed operations on three infant spina
0:50
bifida patients at Riley Children's Hospital in Indianapolis. died on the table. Another girl lived, I think, till she was 14, and then she died, and then me
1:03
Mellencamp's songs are often from the point of view of the underdog. They're about hardworking
1:08
individuals from small towns trying to get a leg up to be able to afford a little pink house
1:13
That's a struggle Mellencamp witnessed in his hometown of Seymour, Indiana, and within his own family. His father, Richard, met his mother when he literally ran into her
1:22
on the street one day. As Mellencamp told the New York Times in 1987, Richard and his older brother
1:28
Joe were running from cops after roughing up four guys in retaliation for a beating Richard had
1:33
gotten earlier. Those Mellencamps were playing the detestable part in which the community had cast
1:38
them. As Mellencamp explained, for as far back as anyone can care to remember, there has been a rigid
1:45
petty, small-town class system in Seymour. The top of that system was occupied by people who became
1:50
rich during the Industrial Revolution, while the rest were farmers. The singer's great-great
1:55
grandfather moved from Germany to Indiana in 1851 and started the family farm, which had to be sold
2:01
a generation later. That left John's grandfather Harry to drop out of school in the third grade to
2:07
work as a carpenter. When Harry went to register to vote, the clerk laughed at him and made fun of
2:12
his name. As John put it, we were always hearing talk that, you low-class Mellencamps will never
2:17
amount to anything. At the age of 18, Mellencamp was dating a woman three years older than him
2:22
named Priscilla Esterlein. When she became pregnant in 1970, the couple tried to do the
2:27
traditional thing and get married, but under Indiana law at the time, 18-year-old Mellencamp
2:32
wasn't old enough to do so without parental permission. But that's when the couple hit
2:37
upon a solution. They eloped to Kentucky, the next state over. That marriage lasted a little
2:42
over a decade through Mellencamp's early career hurdles, stumbles, and dead ends
2:47
But it couldn survive when he fell for another woman After seeing a photo of professional TV extra Vicky Granucci at a friend house Mellencamp became infatuated When they finally met it turned out they actually had fantastic
3:00
chemistry. He and Esterlein quickly split up so that Mellencamp could marry Granucci
3:05
who notably stars as Diane in Mellencamp's Jack and Diane video. Two months after they made it official, they welcomed their first daughter
3:12
Teddy Jo, who would later go on to become a cast member on The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills
3:18
After he married Granucci, Mellencamp's history of tumultuous love affairs still wasn't over
3:23
as he would once again fall for a new woman, leave his current wife
3:27
marry the new gal, and put her in a music video. This time, it was Elaine Irwin, whom he met when she was the cover model for his 1991 album
3:36
Whenever We Wanted. Ten weeks after their first face-to-face, they were engaged
3:40
and in 1992, they married. She's also the star of his video for Get a Leg Up
3:45
This third marriage lasted a long time, almost 18 years. But it nonetheless fell apart as surely
3:51
as the first two. Apparently, women just don't like me very much. That's all I can say about that
3:57
In 2011, not long after his divorce was finalized, Mellencamp struck up an on-again
4:03
off-again relationship with movie star Meg Ryan, a coupling that apparently left the rocker a
4:08
little wounded. When he appeared on Howard Stern's radio show after splitting with the actress in
4:13
2014, he revealed, Oh, women hate me. I loved Meg Ryan. She hates me to death
4:19
But all was not lost forever. After a year-long relationship with model Christy Brinkley
4:24
Mellencamp and Ryan reunited, and in November 2018, they got engaged. How would you figure out at 67 now, let's do this thing for real
4:33
I don't know what you mean. While John Mellencamp suffered from a potentially fatal birth defect as a baby
4:39
his third child similarly faced an uncertain future. In 1985, Mellencamp and his wife at the
4:46
time, Vicki Granucci, awaited the arrival of their second child together. While she was pregnant
4:52
Granucci fell ill with chickenpox, and doctors informed the expectant parents that the illness
4:57
might result in fetal deformity. Mellencamp told the New York Times, "...we were so terrified. Maybe the way my parents were with my spinal problems at birth.
5:06
Mellencamp also noted that he and Granucci were so afraid of losing their child that they
5:10
didn't decide on a name until the day Granucci gave birth. He told the Times
5:15
As the doctor began the delivery, we decided that if there was any justice in the world
5:20
the baby would be healthy. Mellencamp has left alcohol and marijuana behind, but he's not a man totally devoid
5:35
of vice, as he's an enthusiastic, lifelong smoker. As he revealed in a 2018 interview with CBS News he started puffing on cigarettes at the tender age of 10 and he doesn think more than five decades of the habit have been all that bad for him and he got a bit of a theory about that I believe that it the combination of cigarettes and alcohol that get people
5:58
the two of them combined. That theory may not carry too much weight, though, considering that Mellencamp suffered
6:04
a heart attack in 1994 at the relatively young age of 42. He was on tour, and he didn't feel well
6:10
So he went back to his hometown of Bloomington, Indiana to consult with doctors there
6:15
He later spoke about the health scare during an appearance on The Late Show with David Letterman
6:19
mentioning that when the doctor told him he was having a heart attack, he went nuts and called him, quote, everything in the book
6:25
He said, John, you can say whatever you want to me or act any way you want, but a first-year medical student could tell you you've had a heart attack. And I went, oh
6:34
Nevertheless, Mellencamp didn't entirely quit smoking after that. He just cut down from four
6:40
packs a day to one. I'm just gonna, this is the number for the Surgeon General
6:48
Mellencamp's road to fame and fortune as an authentic rock and roll star wasn't traditional
6:52
or short. By the time he scored his first top 30 hit in the United States with I Need a Lover in
6:58
1979, he was almost 30 years old, which is fairly long in the tooth for the youth-oriented
7:04
music industry. And that came after he'd already recorded two misbegotten albums that each failed in
7:09
their own unique way. In 1975, Mellencamp, tired of playing in go-nowhere bar bands
7:15
moved to New York City to make it as a rock star. He found a champion in David Bowie's
7:20
former manager, Tony DeFries. Bowie had just unamicably parted ways with DeFries
7:25
and so the manager tried to position Mellencamp as the next Bowie by way of Bruce Springsteen
7:31
Saddled with the silly stage name of Johnny Cougar, Mellencamp released his first album
7:35
the DeVries-produced Chestnut Street Incident in 1976. It consisted primarily of covers of
7:42
familiar tunes like Jailhouse Rock and Hit the Road Jack. It sold only a paltry 12,000 copies
7:48
Afterwards, Mellencamp's label, MCA, refused to release his next album, The Kid Inside
7:54
and then dropped him entirely. Mellencamp experienced some hard-rocking success with the release of his albums American Fool and Uh-Huh in 1982 and 1983, respectively
8:05
Then he doubled down on the social commentary and soul-searching with 1985's Scarecrow and 1987's
8:11
The Lonesome Jubilee. Among the biggest sellers of his career, they went on to be certified five
8:16
times platinum and three times platinum, respectively. But the success of those albums
8:21
bears a painful origin, as Mellencamp created Scarecrow and The Lonesome Jubilee to cope with
8:26
the deaths of loved ones and how his family shaped him. As he told the New York Times in 1987
8:32
Let face it you are your parents whether any of us like it or not The lonesome jubilee like Scarecrow and the rest of my best stuff is about me and my family tree grappling against both the world and our own inner goddamned whirlwind His grandfather with whom he was
8:47
incredibly close, died of lung cancer in 1983. Mellencamp shared with The Times
8:53
just before his death, he called everybody into his bedroom, and although he wasn't a religious
8:57
person, he said, you know, I'm having a real bad beating of a time with the devil
9:02
It stopped me cold to see my grandpa so scared. Six hours later, he was gone
9:07
After that death, John Mellencamp's uncle Joe became, quote, the kindest soul you could imagine
9:13
But then he died, too. Mellencamp has revealed that the song Paper and Fire from The Lonesome Jubilee is about
9:19
Joe and his family's ingrained anger. It's widely known that Mellencamp was born in a small town, specifically the south-central
9:26
Indiana burg of Seymour. He's easily the town's most famous son, but the second most famous might be George Green
9:34
Me and Mellencamp have known each other since they were in the same Sunday school class
9:37
and they would later go on to write some songs together. In fact, Greene helped Mellencamp pin some of his best-known tunes, including Hurt So
9:44
Good, Crumbling Down, Rain on the Scarecrow, and Human Wheels. The last song they wrote together was Yours Forever for the soundtrack to the 2000 film
9:53
The Perfect Storm. Soon after, they had a falling out. Mellencamp wrote about their split in the liner notes to his 2010 box set On the Rural
10:01
Route 7609. Like when you're married, when you're friends with somebody for a long time, the more things
10:07
build up, the more things can go wrong. There were personal problems cross-pollinated with professional issues
10:14
George has written some great lyrics and we've written some great songs together, but I just
10:18
couldn't do it anymore." After that fallout, they never collaborated again, as Green died in 2011 at age 59 after
10:25
a short battle with an aggressive form of lung cancer. Mellencamp has projected an image as somebody who likes to get rowdy and mix it up
10:33
After all, he's the guy who fights authority, even though authority always wins
10:38
It turns out that his sons, Hud and Speck, have lived out the central battle described
10:42
in Authority song, Out in the Real World. In the early morning of July 16, 2017, Hud and Speck got into a fight in the parking
10:50
lot of a Jimmy John's sandwich shop in Bloomington, Indiana. According to the police report, a small group of men started mouthing off to the Mellencamp
10:58
boys, and then things escalated. HUD said that somebody hit him while Speck had blood on his face by the time police showed up
11:05
Speck was sentenced to community service and probation after pleading guilty to account of
11:09
public intoxication. This isn't the first time Speck and HUD have run afoul of the law. In 2015
11:16
Speck served four days of jail time for a misdemeanor battery charge over an incident in 2013
11:21
in which the brothers kicked a teenager they thought had hit Speck. At this rate
11:26
It looks like the troubles in the Mellencamp family will continue for generations to come
#Marriage