Why does asparagus make your pee smell? - Big Questions - (Ep. 22)
3K views
Apr 3, 2025
A weekly show where we endeavor to answer one of your big questions. This week, "doxysrox" asks, "Why does Asparagus make your pee smell?"
View Video Transcript
0:00
Hi, I'm Craig, and if you wanted to watch Mental Floss on YouTube today, you're in luck
0:04
Today I'm going to answer Doxies Rocks' big question. Why does Asparagus make your pee smell
0:08
Why does Aspergas make your pee smell? Thank you for your question, Doxies Rocks. I'm not sure why you capitalize the word Asparagus
0:13
but I'm going to assume that you're referring to the vegetable, not because you have a friend named Asparagus who makes your pea smell
0:17
because that sounds like a personal problem. Regardless, this is one of those hard-hitting questions that made me want to be a host in the first place. Let's get started
0:30
First of all, Doxies Rocks, you're in good company. In 1781, Benjamin Franklin wrote a letter to the Royal Academy of Brussels, basically telling
0:39
them to invent a drug that would make bodily functions smell better. In the letter, he wrote, A few stems of asparagus eaten, shilkerun, a disagreeable odor
0:48
That guy really had a wide range of interest. Anyway, asparagus has a chemical in it that scientists believe is only found in that vegetable
0:54
hence the name, asparagusic acid. During digestion, the acid gets broken down, just like when you eat protein, your body breaks
0:59
it down into amino acids, just like how I break it down on the dance flow, and you'll feel
1:04
like you dropped acid. Asparagus acid gets broken down by our bodies into different compounds which contains sulfur Methanethyel and dimethyl sulfide create a pungent smell And dimethyl sulfoxide and dimethyl sulfone create a sweeter smell The combination of these in addition to other sulfur compounds
1:19
produce the pungent urine smell. They're known as volatile organic compounds because they can evaporate thanks to their
1:25
low boiling point, which means that we can smell it. Amazingly, the digestion process happens so fast that some people notice that their urine
1:30
starts to smell a mere 15 minutes after eating asparagus. But there's actually a way to lessen the odor
1:35
Drink water. Also, just never go to the bathroom. Hold it. Now some of you are like, what are you talking about, Craig
1:40
My pee doesn't smell after ate asparagus, I'm got, I'm got, I got, L-O-L. Well, it turns out that only some people experience the asparagus pee smell phenomenon
1:47
That's not actually what it's called, but that's what I'm going to call it, because I'm an innovator. And it has been studied quite a bit over the past few decades
1:53
There are probably two things happening here. First, around one quarter of people actually possess the ability to smell compounds in urine
1:59
That's right. Some of you can't even smell your own urine. Secondly, some people seem to digest asparagus differently altogether
2:05
For them, less sulfur-containing compounds are produced, so their urine doesn't. Doesn't smell at all
2:09
Well, aren't they special? Thanks for watching Mental Philosophy on YouTube, made with the help of these lovely people
2:14
one quarter of whom know that I smell like urine. If you have a big question, leave it in the comments below
2:19
Thanks for watching. See you next week
#education
#Nutrition