Up next in 10
Will listening to Mozart make your baby smarter? How about playing them some educational DVDs? Turns out, there might be a bit more to helping your baby become the next Einstein.
Join Justin in an endless pursuit of the truth in this all-new episode of Misconceptions. Today we break down some myths and misconceptions about our favorite tiny humans, babies.
-------
Mental Floss is the home for all things curious. Subscribe here for new Mental Floss videos every Wednesday at 3pm (and don't forget the bell!): https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCpZ5...
Don't miss a video! Subscribe NOW: https://www.youtube.com/@MentalFloss?sub_confirmation=1
About Mental Floss:
Mental Floss is where curious people come for trivia-tastic information. Mental Floss produces lists of fun facts, debunks common misconceptions, and tells untold stories from history, science, culture and more.
Website: http://www.mentalfloss.com
Twitter: http://www.twitter.com/mental_floss
Facebook: https://facebook.com/mentalflossmagazine
Copyright Notice: This video and YouTube channel contain dialog, music, and images that are property of Mental Floss. You are authorized to share the video link and channel, and embed this video in your website or others as long as a link back to this YouTube Channel is provided.
2025 Mental Floss
Misconceptions About Babies | Mental Floss
https://www.youtube.com/@MentalFloss
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
All newborns do is eat, poop, and cry oceans of tears
0:05
That sentiment isn't quite true for a number of reasons. We'll get into the surprisingly rich interior lives of babies in a little bit, but maybe
0:11
the most unexpected reason it's false is that newborns don't actually cry tears at all
0:17
Most babies don't shed tears in the first few weeks of their young lives
0:20
The lacrimal glands generally start ramping up tear production around two weeks into a
0:24
baby's life, and it's typical for visible tears not to be noticeable until weeks or
0:28
even months after that. By the way, if you've never heard the term lacrimal glands before
0:33
you might be surprised to learn that the tear ducts are not responsible for tear production
0:38
Misconception within a misconception? Dare I say a mis-inception? Nah, that sounded cooler in my head. Let's just run the intro
0:47
Welcome to Misconceptions. I am your host, Justin Dodd, and I am a baby. That's a little bonus
1:01
misconception for you. I'm actually a grown man, but all of the adorable home video footage you're
1:06
about to see of a baby is, in fact, me. There's a lot of misinformation out there about babies
1:14
and yzing some of these misconceptions can shed light on humans of all ages
1:19
From anatomy to psychology to commerce, we can learn a lot about ourselves by identifying
1:24
what we might have wrong on the subject of infants. Babies are blank slates A number of influential thinkers, from John
1:32
Locke to David Hume, have put forth some version of the tabula rasa, or blank slate theory
1:37
of knowledge. Locke asked readers to think of the mind's starting place as resembling white paper
1:42
void of all characters. And while that was more a point of departure for an ysis of how we acquire knowledge
1:48
than an actual proposal for how a baby's mind functions, I think it's fair to say that
1:52
many of us do look at babies as essentially blank slates. I mean, to what extent do babies know anything
1:58
And how would we even know if they did? A few developments in the last half-century or so have helped scientists start to explore
2:04
what babies may know. First, scientists like Robert Fance realized they could use the time a baby spends looking
2:10
at something has a rough indicator of interest or surprise. While that might seem like a pretty crude method, the results gleaned from measuring
2:18
the duration of an infant's gaze in various situations have often proven repeatable in
2:23
different labs at different times. Four-day-old infants, for example, were shown to have a preference for the language their
2:29
mother speaks. That's not proof a baby knows the language, of course, but it does seem to suggest some
2:33
sort of knowledge or awareness of what they've been exposed to, perhaps even in the womb
2:39
Newer technologies, like functional near-infrared spectroscopy, allow scientists to yze babies' brains
2:45
It works by shining near-infrared light at a baby's skull, which lets researchers measure
2:49
levels of blood oxygen in the brain and, by extension, which areas are experiencing more
2:54
activity at different times. This technology has shown, for example, that 4-6 month old babies at risk for autism exhibit
3:02
less brain response to social cues than a low-risk group of peers
3:06
Insights like that could one day lead to earlier detection of a range of neurological differences
3:11
The same technology was used on newborns less than a week old, with results suggesting that
3:15
even babies that young experience more brain activity in specific regions of the brain
3:20
when looking at dynamic social stimuli, such as a person's face playing peekaboo, compared
3:25
to non biological motion like a moving arm The increased brain activity occurs in the same region of the brain observed in adults engaged in social interaction suggesting that the ability to engage with social
3:37
stimuli is, if not innate, something that begins developing incredibly early in a person's life
3:43
Scientists are now trying to use functional MRIs to get even more insights into the brains of
3:48
babies, but even with the technology we have available, you can read about a dizzying number
3:53
of ways babies could be said to know things we might not expect
3:56
A study published in PLOS Biology in 2008 showed that even 3-month-old infants may have
4:02
a sense of numerosity. When shown a sequence of images of four dots in all different configurations, for example
4:08
the babies showed evidence of boredom, but their apparent interest perked up when shown
4:12
a different image containing 8 dots. Other studies have even suggested that babies can do a kind of rudimentary math
4:20
Five-month-old babies were shown two individual objects added together one at a time behind
4:24
a screen. When the screen was pulled away, babies tended to look longer if one or three objects were
4:30
present instead of the expected two. This might indicate surprise at the wrong number of objects being revealed
4:36
One more study on the topic of what babies have going on in those soft little heads of theirs
4:41
A team of researchers tried to look into whether babies can make moral judgments of any sort
4:45
Here's how they set up the experiment. Eight-month-old babies were shown a little skit, basically where one character, let's
4:51
call him Justin, acted in a nice way, helping another character complete a task
4:57
Then two new characters were brought in, one who rewarded friendly Justin and one who punished him
5:03
The babies preferred the rewarding character, which was expected as babies generally show
5:07
a preference for nice behavior. Here's where it gets interesting, though. In a different setup, instead of a helper, the researchers brought in a hindering character
5:15
in place of friendly Justin. Let's call him, I don't know, Christopher Giampallo, the bully from my fourth grade social
5:21
studies class. After Christopher hindered a different character, two new characters were brought in, one who
5:26
punished Christopher and one who rewarded him. This time, the babies preferred the Punisher
5:32
It's impossible to read their minds, but it sure seems like they had some sort of instinctive
5:37
sense that bad behavior should be punished and good behavior should be rewarded
5:41
Now, I'm not saying we should start installing baby judges in our nation's courtrooms
5:46
But I am saying that I do in fact have a copyright application into the WGA East for a sitcom
5:52
called Baby Judge. A pregnant woman's belly reveals the baby's sex Have you ever heard that a pregnant woman's belly can reveal her child's sex
6:01
Supposedly a high baby bulge indicates a girl, while a low belly is proof of a boy
6:07
Some say this line of thinking can be traced back to English folklore. The reasoning rested on a belief that boys are more independent and could therefore stay
6:14
low in the abdomen while girls needed more protection. Obviously, that reasoning doesn't stand up to much scrutiny
6:21
Whatever the sex, unborn babies are not renowned for their independence, and the idea that
6:26
sitting lower in the abdomen is the fetal equivalent of getting an entry-level job in
6:30
your own apartment doesn't really make sense, no matter how fun it is to think about a baby
6:35
eating pizza on a couch made of milk crates. Note to self, baby judge has pizza-loving roommate named Booger
6:43
Even if the rationale is off, though, could there be something to this folk wisdom
6:48
After all, boys do tend to be larger than girls. Maybe that affects how they sit in the womb
6:53
Not so. Researchers from John Hopkins University published a study in Birth showing no relationship between abdomen shape and gender First pregnancies generally sit higher up but that because the mother abdominal wall tends to get stretched out with each pregnancy regardless of the sex of the baby Other supposed indicators of the baby sex like their in heart
7:12
rate, also lack empirical support. For most people who want to know their baby's sex
7:16
an ultrasound is going to be your best bet. While we're in the womb, let's put on some
7:20
Mozart. Will the refined compositions make your baby smarter? The Mozart effect makes
7:26
baby smart. In 1998, the governor of Georgia started the program to give new mothers classical music CDs
7:34
In Florida, daycare centers were required to play classical music for their charges
7:39
These interventions can probably be traced to the so-called Mozart Effect, which developed
7:43
from a 1993 paper published by Francis Rocher in the journal Nature
7:47
Strangely, that study was done on college kids, not babies, and it specifically examined whether
7:52
listening to classical music before several reasoning tasks and prove performance on those tasks
7:58
There was an improvement, but the idea that those findings can be translated to babies
8:02
or general educational achievement throughout life were far outside the scope of that one paper
8:08
When psychologist Christopher Chabrie yzed 16 studies related to the Mozart effect, he
8:12
found only a minor positive impact from music and only on that same specific type of reasoning task
8:18
Different meta-ysis was done by a team of scientists in Germany and found the effect
8:22
to be non-existent. Even Roche was clear, saying, "...there is no compelling evidence that children who listen to classical music are going to
8:31
have any improvement in cognitive abilities." That doesn't mean there's any harm in playing classical music for your baby before or after birth
8:39
A study from the Institut Marques in Barcelona suggested that babies in the womb are stimulated
8:44
by classical music. created a special intravaginal speaker and then played music through the speaker for fetuses
8:51
They used ultrasound scans to look for movement and concluded that a statistically significant
8:56
percentage of fetuses responded to the music, compared to non-musical vibrations or music
9:01
played through headphones placed on their mother's abdomens. Fair warning though, I checked with Best Buy and they are all sold out of intravaginal speakers
9:10
Black Friday. Capitalism. An intriguing study from Israeli researchers indicated that babies might find Mozart's
9:17
music calming, leading to lower energy expenditure and a desirable increase in rate of weight
9:22
gain for premature babies. Though the study didn't pit Mozart's music up against anything else for comparison
9:29
If you like The Marriage of Figaro, by all means listen to it with your baby
9:33
You can even put a little earbud on your belly button if that makes you happy
9:38
don't think you're creating a Baby Genius or a Super Baby's Baby Geniuses 2, which is the actual
9:44
terrible name of the sequel to 1999's seminal talking baby film Baby Geniuses
9:49
Educational Videos Make Babies Smarter Speaking of baby geniuses, do educational DVDs make babies smart? With names like Baby Einstein
9:58
and Your Baby Can Read, surely all that stands between your child and precocious brilliance is
10:03
actually being able to find a DVD player in 2020, right? Not so much. The Baby Einstein videos were
10:10
wildly successful, as long as the goal was to sell lots of DVDs. A 2003 study estimated that
10:15
a third of all American babies between 6 and 24 months old had one of the videos. In terms of
10:21
making babies smarter, though, the evidence is severely lacking. A study published in the Archives
10:26
of Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine showed that babies exposed to the Baby Wordsworth DVDs which purported to help babies learn up to 30 words demonstrated no enhanced language acquisition compared to a control group left unexposed to the supposedly
10:41
educational content. In fact, infants who watched the content at a young age actually had
10:47
lower language scores than those not exposed to the DVD at all, though they didn't suggest
10:52
a cause-and-effect relationship per se. A study at New York University's Steinhardt School of Education demonstrated that the
10:59
Your Baby Can Read DVDs were quite successful in convincing parents of their efficacy
11:04
They generally reported a belief that their children were, in fact, learning vocabulary
11:08
that outpaced the control group. But in all other measures the study examined, the DVD watchers and the control group showed
11:15
no meaningful differences. After the Campaign for a Commercial-Free Childhood made a complaint to the Federal Trade Commission
11:21
in 2006, Baby Einstein dropped the word educational from its marketing, an apparent admission
11:27
that they could not substantiate the claim. Not long after, under threat of a class action lawsuit
11:32
Disney, who at this point owned the Baby Einstein brand, announced it would offer refunds for up to
11:37
four DVDs per household. While the promise of a DVD that can make your baby smarter has
11:42
pretty obvious appeal, the truth is that most experts in the field would prescribe a much
11:47
lower tech regimen to help your baby learn—reading, playing, and talking with your child
11:53
Although I will fully admit that every important lesson I learned early in life
11:56
came from a VHS tape that was orange. Baby walkers help babies walk
12:02
Selling parents dubious ways of giving their baby a leg up is big business. Another example is walkers
12:08
those little devices on wheels that can support baby mobility before they can stand and walk on
12:13
their own. The idea is that you can put the baby in the devices, and while it holds them up
12:18
they can develop stronger legs, allowing them to walk faster and therefore avoid the embarrassment of
12:23
being the only baby at daycare without defined calf muscles. Okay, that last part is not true, but neither is the rest in reality
12:32
Walkers can actually delay independent walking. It takes the job of balancing out of a baby's hands, which is a necessary skill to develop
12:39
in order to walk on your own, and it can mean less time spent crawling, which is an essential
12:44
step on the road to walking. Beyond those drawbacks, walkers can actually be quite dangerous
12:49
From 1990 to 2014, over 200,000 babies in the US went to the emergency room for walker-related injuries
12:57
Children can fall down, get their fingers caught, and, perhaps because they can't see the ground
13:01
below them, accidentally fall down stairs and other high-risk areas. While safety improvements have been made in the devices, 2,000 toddlers still went to
13:09
the ER for injuries related to walkers in 2014. Canada has actually banned their sales, and the American Academy of Pediatrics pushes
13:17
for the same ban here in the United States. There is one big caveat to this misconception, though
13:22
For babies with developmental issues of physical debilities, support tools with wheels can
13:27
absolutely be a useful tool. Those devices are generally called gait trainers, and they don't look much like the walkers
13:33
we're discussing. For typically developing infants, though, you're better off plopping your baby on the
13:37
floor next to something like a couch or a table that they can use to pull themselves
13:41
up until they get the hang of walking on their own. And to all the babies out there watching, hey, you got this
13:48
is like riding a bike, which you don't know how to do either. Or speak language, probably
13:54
so uh, never mind. If you have an idea for a future episode of Misconceptions, leave it in the comments below
14:01
And to stay up to date with all things mental floss, hit that subscribe button. Goo goo gaga
education