Sure, a president can sue the press. But can he win?
0 views
Jul 24, 2025
In a slew of defamation lawsuits against the press, Trump filed his most recent $10 billion case against The Wall Street Journal.
View Video Transcript
0:00
Can a president sue a media outlet for libel and win
0:03
President Trump is trying to find out. President Trump is no stranger to filing lawsuits
0:12
against media outlets, but he's never won, only settled before a verdict
0:17
if not seeing his case dismissed. The last president to successfully sue a media outlet
0:23
was Teddy Roosevelt in 1913. President Trump most recently sued the Wall Street Journal, Rupert Murdoch and several others for $10 billion for defamation
0:34
He's also recently settled lawsuits with ABC News and CBS News, which the president considers a
0:41
victory in its own right. We spoke with attorney Jeffrey Robbins, who has tried defamation cases
0:47
both on behalf of public figures and the media. You do have what seems to me a strategy
0:56
a purposeful strategy of trying to intimidate media organizations into diluting their coverage
1:03
hedging their coverage, altering their coverage, softening their coverage, pick your adjective
1:09
And, you know, he feels as though he's gotten results and he has
1:15
The president has said he wants to make it easier to successfully sue press organizations
1:20
That would likely mean overturning the famous 1964 Supreme Court case, the New York Times
1:27
versus Sullivan. That granted journalists some of the world's strongest legal protections and puts the burden
1:34
of proof on the plaintiff. Prior to that decision, all that a public figure had to do was to show that the defendant
1:43
let say a media defendant was negligent in publishing a false statement In the advent of New York Times versus Sullivan however the standard has changed And now a public figure has to show not only the ordinary elements of a
1:59
defamation case, that there was a false statement of fact that defamed him or her and did him or her
2:06
damage. But now that public figure has to show that the publication, the publisher, published
2:13
with actual malice. The president is no stranger to suing the media. He or his businesses have
2:20
filed 20 media or defamation cases since announcing his first presidential campaign
2:26
He's estimated to have filed 4,000 lawsuits throughout his lifetime. He may also have some
2:32
well-positioned allies if he does try to overturn Sullivan. Supreme Court Justices Clarence Thomas
2:38
and Neil Gorsuch have shown support for overturning the ruling. Robbins also pointed to another
2:45
argument to overturn Sullivan, the drastic change in the media landscape since the 1960s
2:52
even since the signing of the Constitution. The First Amendment was enacted at a time when we
2:57
were talking about small mom and pop printers. We no longer have that. We have massive multi-billion
3:06
dollar conglomerates with a huge amount of power and the power easily to destroy someone's
3:11
reputation. Robin says that journalists these days have a lot to worry about, reducing content
3:17
in a 24-7 news cycle, worrying about clicks and shares, and that can lead to mistakes
3:24
which could become big legal problems if Sullivan is overturned. You can read legal reporter Ava
3:31
Federally's full report by downloading the Straight Arrow News mobile app today or going to san.com
#Media Critics & Watchdogs
#news
#Politics