DnD 5.5’s new Hell Knight Fighter. Cool flavor, some good ideas, but the mechanics don’t deliver on the what the subclass is trying to do.
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
Let's talk about D&D's new Hell Knight
0:01
fighter. It is very, very cool and it's
0:04
got some really fun ideas, but the
0:06
mechanics are absolutely lacking.
0:08
Subclass is built around inflicting
0:10
infernal wounds on your enemies and you
0:12
have a pool of points that you can use
0:13
to do this. It's your Constitution
0:15
modifier times per short rest. So, for a
0:18
lot of fighters that's going to be plus
0:19
three, so three uses per short rest. In
0:23
a packed adventuring day, that means
0:24
that you're going to get to use this
0:26
probably once, maybe twice per combat
0:29
encounter, which really is not a lot,
0:31
especially considering how minor these
0:33
effects are. The initial effect is just
0:35
1D6 fire damage and then 1D6 fire damage
0:38
at the start of each of your target's
0:40
turns. So, it like in a lengthy combat,
0:43
that's 2D6, maybe 3D6 damage from your
0:47
subclass and that's basically all you
0:49
get. A lot of the subclass's
0:50
functionality is gated behind rolling a
0:53
six on those damage dice. If you roll a
0:55
six, you get some extra stuff and the
0:57
extra stuff is admittedly very, very
1:00
cool, but it's one in six times. So,
1:04
let's say we've got three uses per short
1:06
rest. A full adventuring day, we get to
1:08
use all nine of our uses and one in six
1:12
turns we roll a six. Like, let's assume
1:15
perfect averages. Now, let's assume that
1:17
we apply this on turn one, combat goes
1:20
for three turns and our target doesn't
1:22
die until the end of their turn. So, we
1:25
get three rolls. So, it's a total of 27
1:29
rolls, one in six, that's a little less
1:32
than five times. So, our fun part of our
1:35
subclass comes up maybe five times on
1:38
average on a very packed adventuring day
1:41
where everything goes exactly to plan.
1:45
And that's assuming roughly eight
1:46
encounters. So, our subclass does
1:47
something cool just slightly more than
1:50
half of the time. Uh that's that's
1:54
awful. That isn't fun and the fact that
1:57
it's again, 1D6
2:00
fire damage and sure, we get to ignore
2:02
fire resistance and that's great, but
2:04
it's 1D6 damage most of the time. So, in
2:08
a typical encounter, the experience of
2:10
our class is we're going to do two,
2:13
maybe three D6 fire damage over the
2:15
course of the encounter and be really,
2:18
really mad that we haven't rolled sixes
2:21
and that is the experience of the
2:22
subclass.
Games

