Thrown weapons have gotten a lot better in the 2024 DnD rules. They still can’t compete with a bow in many ways, but they’re at least usable now, and weapon masteries add some fun options
#dnd #dnd5e #2024dnd #ttrpg #characteroptimization #dungeonsanddragons
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
I got a question on Instagram from
0:01
someone asking me to look at throne
0:03
weapons in Dn D. They've changed a lot
0:06
between the 2014 and 2024 rules in some
0:09
really important ways if you want to
0:11
explore that fantasy. So, let's take a
0:12
look. In the 2014 rules, thrown weapons
0:15
were really, really hard because you
0:16
only got one free item interaction per
0:19
round in which you could draw a weapon.
0:20
So, if you started with a weapon in
0:22
hand, you could throw it, draw one,
0:23
throw it. So, if you had extra attack,
0:25
you're immediately out of ammunition.
0:28
There were a couple of ways to address
0:30
this and make it slightly better. The
0:31
first option we got was the dual wielder
0:33
feat which let would let you draw two
0:35
weapons anytime you could draw one. So
0:37
if you had extra attack, you could throw
0:39
throw draw two weapons and that would be
0:42
it. Um so you would really wouldn't
0:44
benefit from two weapon fighting in any
0:45
meaningful way a lot of the times. Or if
0:48
you were throwing like daggers or
0:49
something, you go throw throw draw throw
0:52
and then you kind of have to juggle on
0:55
your next turn and you could make it
0:56
work. But it was really painful and
0:58
there would always be turns where you
1:00
ended without ammunition or started
1:02
without ammunition. We eventually got
1:04
the throne weapon fighting style which
1:05
would let you draw a weapon as part of
1:07
the attack to throw it. So finally,
1:10
finally there was a way to actually make
1:12
this work. It also came with a plus two
1:14
damage bonus, but it was still just
1:17
strictly worse than using fighting style
1:19
archery because you were less accurate.
1:22
the weapons you were using dealt less
1:24
damage and the plus two bonus made up
1:26
the gap, but you're taking a fighting
1:28
style to be at best as good as
1:31
unmodified archery. So, it's like why
1:34
would you even bother? If you're going
1:35
to take a fighting style, just take
1:36
fighting style archery, use a bow or a
1:38
musket or whatever. It wasn't worth the
1:40
resource cost. And there really just
1:43
wasn't a way to build it to keep up with
1:47
archery. The only reason to do it was
1:49
because you could do it with strength
1:51
instead of dexterity, and that wasn't a
1:53
reason. In the 2024 rules, the changes
1:55
to how we draw and stow weapons made
1:57
things a lot easier. Now, you can equip
1:59
or unequip a weapon before or after any
2:02
attack made as part of the attack
2:04
action. So, you can draw, throw, draw,
2:07
throw, draw, throw to your heart's
2:09
content, and that works fantastic.
2:11
Weapon masteries also made things a lot
2:13
better since you can still apply the
2:15
weapon masteries when you throw weapons.
2:17
One of my favorites is throwing trident
2:19
because they have the topple mastery,
2:20
which means you can throw them at flying
2:22
enemies, knock them prone, and cause
2:23
them to fall out of the sky. Hilarious.
2:26
Very effective. Gives strength-based
2:27
marshals a really, really good option.
2:30
The throne weapon fighting style, still
2:32
bad. A fighter built around thrown
2:34
weapons could be really, really
2:36
effective by leaning into those weapon
2:38
masteries and the fact that fighters get
2:40
so many more weapon masteries than
2:42
everybody else. But really, that's the
2:44
only benefit you're getting over just
2:45
using a bow or a musket or something.
2:48
So, it's a lot more viable in 2024. It's
2:51
still not super amazing,
Games
Roleplaying Games

