0:00
I've been diving into the reviews
0:01
reviewing all the many comments and
0:04
messages I receive every day and
0:06
comparing that with my own recent
0:07
cruising experiences and from all of
0:09
that I have come across five Cruise
0:12
Lines the passengers seem to agree are
0:14
rising with the tide and floating above
0:17
all others at the moment so perhaps ones
0:19
that you should consider more than ever
0:21
before here's what I found it's the
0:25
newest of all the mainstream Cruise
0:26
Lines selling for the first time in 2021
0:29
and it's proving to be a hit with almost
0:32
all Cruise passengers who try them even
0:34
Cruise Riders and sites rate them so
0:38
sites like cruisecritic.com gave them
0:41
the editor Choice Awards for Best Food
0:43
and nightlife and the overall passenger
0:46
rating there is an incredible 4.1 out of
0:49
five now I personally was much more torn
0:52
on them as I'll explain but first here's
0:54
what people like most about them while
0:57
they're on the pricier side because they
0:59
operate with the so-called premium
1:01
category so that's lines like celebrity
1:04
Honda America Disney and Princess people
1:07
like me really like that unlike those
1:11
virgin is adult only with passengers or
1:14
Sailors as they like to call them having
1:16
to be 18 or over so that's a big plus I
1:19
also agree with people that the more
1:21
all-inclusive fares so the 20 dining
1:24
venues tips Wi-Fi Fitness classes some
1:27
soft drinks like water juices coffees
1:29
and sodas being included is a big Plus
1:31
in fact the only food I had to pay for
1:33
when I was on Virgin was the afternoon
1:35
tea which was pretty good as most
1:37
reviews say I also found the food and
1:40
the food options some of the best at Sea
1:42
certainly for the fair they have Mexican
1:44
Korean Steakhouse vegetarian and I like
1:48
the food Hall concept instead of a
1:49
regular Buffet service I also agree with
1:52
reviews is mostly good and as a very
1:55
young and diverse crew and that's also a
1:58
very different nationality mix that
2:00
you'll find there versus most lines the
2:03
entertainment and daily program are very
2:05
different to other lines with more
2:07
experimental shows sort of big acrobatic
2:09
shows high energy immersion dance shows
2:13
very risque comedians but for fans of
2:16
things like trivia traditional Cruise
2:18
activities they're much less of those
2:20
it's much less appealing from that front
2:24
entertainment wise to be a little bit
2:25
too wacky but based on the reviews I do
2:28
seem to be a little bit in the minority
2:30
now it's actually turned out not to be a
2:32
young person line and the average age
2:34
they've revealed on Virgin is around
2:37
about 50 years old but it is for those
2:39
with a youthful mindset that people who
2:42
like are busy kind of lots of you know
2:44
drinking Fitness activities parties and
2:46
kind of late night activities on cruises
2:48
I'm not really into that camp so
2:50
probably why it was less spot on for me
2:53
Royal Caribbean is also getting very
2:56
strong reviews at the moment with
2:58
overall ratings similar to that of
3:00
Virgin voyages so really high looking at
3:03
why I think that's larger driven because
3:05
this family-friendly line has brought
3:07
out these new Mega ships over recent
3:10
years that are packed with features that
3:12
are exciting and popular with families
3:15
multi-generational groups younger Cruise
3:18
couples and groups of friends their kind
3:20
of action-packed resorts at Sea are a
3:23
bigger draw in many cases than the
3:25
destinations they sell to this certainly
3:27
seems to be the case when I look at the
3:29
reviews cruises seem to love how they
3:32
have lent into the many attractions and
3:35
the choices packed on these ever larger
3:37
ships you know flow Riders water slides
3:39
aqua and ice skating shows and all the
3:42
choices of bars and restaurants plus the
3:45
big Production shows which include
3:47
Broadway shows in some cases so for
3:50
example hairspray on Symphony Of The
3:52
Seas that I was on also which I agree
3:55
with they seem to be able to please all
3:58
budgets and all Cruise types with
4:00
everything from really good value cabins
4:02
like insides and ocean views right up to
4:05
massive luxury suites including what are
4:09
some of the biggest and most costly
4:11
Cabin Suites at Sea you know sixty
4:14
thousand dollars and plus a week now
4:16
it's interesting I find that luxury
4:18
Travelers rate the sweets the food and
4:20
the service as much as value Travelers
4:23
do they their choices and the cabin so
4:25
they seemed to be able to cater for many
4:27
many types of Cruisers now the main
4:29
negative reviews seems to be actually
4:31
about the older ships of which there are
4:33
still many in the fleet they're more
4:35
dated they're like the scale they lack
4:36
the facilities and of course on the big
4:39
ships one of the criticisms is you need
4:41
to accept there's going to be crowds and
4:43
busy venues now I'm not a fan of big
4:46
ships but I do find Royal Caribbean
4:48
really good at what they do with a wide
4:51
range of options for different Cruiser
4:53
types so unlike some large ship lines
4:55
that have been on like MSC cruises I
4:57
feel they offer kind of much more
4:59
variety and they do offer more quiet
5:01
spaces in that busy kind of crowded ship
5:04
experience a line that gets an even
5:06
higher rating and better reviews of both
5:09
of those lines is Disney and I think
5:11
that's because they appeal to a very
5:14
specific crowd now for me personally it
5:16
was definitely not one of my highly
5:18
rated lines but that is because I'm not
5:22
families and adults who love Disney
5:25
films shows characters including the new
5:28
ones they now include like Marvel Star
5:30
Wars they love the Disney Cruise Line
5:34
experience it's a total immersion into
5:37
the Disney World with character meets
5:40
character show based dinners in the
5:43
restaurants every night very slick
5:45
Disney production shows big merchandise
5:48
shops and it is very full-on with Disney
5:51
which wasn't for me now many positive
5:54
reviews by the way also come from adults
5:56
cruising without kids who still love
5:59
Disney and the adult only areas on the
6:02
ship is a big plus for many people now I
6:05
did not share many reviewers enthusiasm
6:07
because I'm not a Disney person and so
6:10
many of the characters and the shows
6:12
kind of went right over my head because
6:14
I wasn't familiar with the stories I
6:16
also found the show pretty crowded
6:18
because of course there are lots of kids
6:20
and families sharing cabins so
6:22
particularly at those kind of school
6:24
holiday times it's really busy but
6:26
Disney is not designed for me but if
6:28
Disney is a love and you have the budget
6:31
because they are rather costly then
6:33
reviews suggest they are very much a hot
6:35
Cruise Line and very hot right now
6:38
another cruise line that is consistently
6:41
getting good reviews and on Cruise
6:43
Critic gets the highest passenger rating
6:46
of any line an incredible 4.6 out of 5
6:49
is the one that I'm also actually on the
6:51
fence about again as I'll explain and
6:54
this one is Viking Cruises like virgin
6:56
voyages it is also an adult only line 18
7:00
plus which is something that reviewers
7:02
rate there are so few adult only options
7:05
and with more lines at all levels really
7:08
attracting families this has become even
7:11
more positive in the reviews for people
7:13
seeking kind of a sophisticated adult
7:15
experience the downsides which some
7:17
critics point out is that it is rather
7:19
costy line even considering fares
7:22
include an excursionary report
7:24
especially dining Wi-Fi beer one and
7:26
soft drinks at lunch and dinner access
7:28
to the spa and often gratuities
7:31
depending on where you're booking but it
7:32
has a pretty onerous early payment of
7:35
full Cruise Fair term versus other lines
7:37
in some regions when you books that's a
7:39
negative but the opposite argument given
7:41
is you're selling that on a ship
7:43
carrying just just over 900 passengers
7:46
the ships are very modern they're very
7:48
stylish there's a really good enrichment
7:50
program the food is good they include
7:52
afternoon tea that I do agree is
7:54
probably one of the best at Sea I think
7:57
though because it's a smaller audience
7:59
due to the cost this does help boost the
8:02
positive reviews and ratings because
8:04
Viking has a really loyal
8:06
fan base lots of repeaters and they
8:09
review the line often and they're very
8:11
fast by the way to defend the line
8:12
however I agree that they are a slick
8:16
and stylish line and the reason I rate
8:18
them less highly than the ratings
8:20
suggest overall is although I've cruised
8:23
them twice I do feel the fares are still
8:25
a little bit higher for what they
8:26
provide and I feel though that the line
8:28
works really well for travelers that
8:30
like a much more curated experience more
8:33
like their River Line and it suits
8:35
independent-minded Travelers perhaps
8:38
but I may be overthinking it and it has
8:41
of course not stopped me booking another
8:42
one I'm booked and let's cruise with
8:44
them next year so we will see it's
8:45
definitely one that's really hot and
8:47
rated really highly right now I want to
8:50
talk about a line that gets overall
8:51
stronger views among some of the higher
8:55
ratings by the way of the line so again
8:56
that 4.1 out of five so that virgin does
8:59
but this hides a very mixed review based
9:03
on which class of ship and which grade
9:06
you're cruising in and I think this is a
9:07
really interesting example of a line
9:09
that's hot in Parts but not in others so
9:12
choosing which shift and which grade you
9:14
you Cruise in it is really important
9:16
Celebrity cruise reviews but you know
9:19
differ really widely based on which ship
9:21
people go on and what grade so they have
9:23
three classes of ships with the one
9:25
they're focusing on being The Edge class
9:27
so Edge Apex Beyond an Ascent now these
9:30
are really contemporary modern ships
9:32
that very different to the existing
9:34
Solstice and millennium-class ships
9:36
which are much more traditional in
9:38
design and layout and and you know
9:41
overall look now The Edge class have the
9:44
infinite balcony Caverns where they've
9:46
enclosed the balcony in the cabin and
9:49
has a sliding glass window instead it
9:51
makes the cabin bigger but Cruisers
9:54
certainly like me kind of miss the more
9:55
open air balcony so that is very
9:57
divisive in the reviews they have
10:00
features like the Magic Carpet which
10:02
alternates uh you know between being a
10:04
bar restaurant and a tender boat
10:05
platform which people like it also has
10:08
funky venues like Eden and much more
10:11
kind of modern entertainment than their
10:13
competitors now reviews for these new
10:15
ships are generally way more positive
10:18
than for the older Solstice and
10:20
millennium-class ships with people
10:22
including me based on my experiences
10:25
other different classes feeling that the
10:27
new ships are getting kind of the a team
10:29
as it were and the older ships are
10:31
getting much less care and attention
10:33
certainly that's what it feels to me now
10:35
on top of that I can also see reviews
10:38
for those in in the retreat which is
10:40
their Suites so they people in The
10:42
Retreat have access to a lounge a large
10:45
Deck with pool hot tubs a bar the
10:48
dedicated luminai restaurant and those
10:50
reviews are way more positive than those
10:52
people who are not in the retreat now
10:55
not only because it's a really good
10:57
experience which I agree with but also
10:58
because regular Cruisers are really
11:00
frustrated that a large area of the ship
11:02
is then closed off to them and
11:05
critically The Retreat area means
11:07
there's no venue on edge class ships for
11:10
regular Fair guests to look at over the
11:12
front of the ship so in scenic areas
11:14
there is no bar or no deck to look at
11:17
the view up front it's only available to
11:19
retreat guests now I must admit that my
11:22
experience and views of celebrity has
11:24
also been very different when going in
11:26
the retreat versus not with the retreat
11:29
being much more elevated much more
11:32
positive without a shadow of a doubt if
11:34
those are the five lines getting great
11:35
reviews from passengers right now what
11:37
are the ones that are getting the thumbs
11:39
down the worst join me in this video
11:42
where I look at those starting with the
11:44
lowest rated line dramatically lower
11:48
right now see you over there