Old Forester Single Barrel (Barrel Strength) - Tasting & Review
2K views
Apr 14, 2025
Trying a store pick from Hi-Time Wine Cellars of the new Old Forester Single Barrel Barrel Strength. This cask strength release comes in at 128.6 proof. #RyeWhiskey
View Video Transcript
0:00
Hey guys, welcome to Bourbon Bites. My name is Clifton and today we're reviewing Old Forrester
0:04
Single Barrel Barrel Proof. So those of you that have been watching me for a while may know that
0:13
Old Forrester typically isn't my favorite whiskey. I usually am not the biggest fan of the flavor
0:20
profile of a lot of Brown Forman products, but I know that a lot of people really are. I know
0:26
Old Forrester 1920 is a ton of people's favorite whiskey. So this is actually a pretty new release
0:31
from Old Forrester. It's actually my first time ever seeing it on the shelves. This is a pick from
0:36
a store called High Time Wine Cellars out here in Southern California. I know a few other stores
0:40
around the area are getting picks. Not sure about your area? Check with your local stores. I know
0:45
this was kind of announced about four or five months ago, so I'm just now starting to see it
0:49
in Southern California. So let me know if you're seeing it in your area. There's not an age
0:53
statement on it, but we do know that this is 64.3% ABV, so 128.6 proof. So that's pretty hot
1:00
Now, I do have a little bit of a disclaimer here. The store that I picked this up just put it on the
1:05
shelves, and they put it up for $39.99. Now, based on my research of this single barrel barrel proof
1:13
the MSRP is supposed to be around like $70 to $80. So I wouldn't think, this is a pretty
1:19
reputable store, so I wouldn't think it'd be a pricing error. So I'm wondering if maybe they
1:23
came down on price since announcing it. Because like I said, it's been a few months since this was announced
1:27
Maybe they realized that price point was a little too high. I'm not fully sure. But in the end when I give this a score I going to give it two scores One at the price point and one at the more likely to price point So with that I going to go ahead and as you can tell I tasted this a few times It really growing on me So I going to go back and give it another taste just
1:47
for you guys. Got my old Forrester glass here for the occasion. So at first on the nose, the biggest
1:54
thing that I'm getting is like a strong wood note. Like it's very oak forward. And that's not something
2:00
that I typically would say about an Old Forrester product. But behind that, there's like a spiciness
2:05
but it's not like a baking spice. It's more of like a black, or not even a black pepper. It's
2:10
like a, yeah, it's more like a cayenne pepper. It's really spicy. It's almost like eating a
2:15
savory dish, that cayenne pepper note. But it mingles really well with the oak. Not too much
2:20
sweetness at first, but I'm curious to see how the nose evolves once we get a taste and maybe we can
2:25
revisit it and find something else. Before I give it a taste, I just want to give a shout out to my
2:28
amazing patrons. Right yesterday before filming this, we did our monthly Patreon hangout. Tons of
2:33
fun over at Patreon. So if you're curious, go check that out. Or you can follow me on Instagram or Facebook. I'm really trying to build those out a little bit more. But I just want to say thanks
2:40
to everyone that's kind of helped me build this up. I've noticed a lot of new likes on Facebook
2:44
lately. So just want to say I really appreciate you guys. So cheers. Oh, that's hot. First instinct
2:50
on the palate, hot. It's really like bold and spicy, like at the tip of the tongue. This is
2:55
128 proof so you can feel that at the beginning but I think once it kind of
2:59
once you've had the first initial shock at the tip of your tongue it really does open up a bit on the finish so the nose is definitely opened up it's way sweeter
3:07
and it like a baking spice sweetness almost like a like a pie crust or dare I say pecan pie or pecan pie wherever you from I from South Carolina We call it pecan pie Still a little bit of the banana but it not the banana runts note which I very thankful for
3:22
It reminds me a lot of Jack Daniel's single barrel barrel proof. Maybe one day I'll do a live stream comparing those two
3:28
If y'all want to see that, let me know in the comments below. Yeah, it's like a banana nut right on the nose, but the nut instead of like a peanut, it's like a pecan
3:34
So let's go back for a second taste. a little less hot but um i think it's now it's like some of the oat characteristic that i originally
3:41
got on the nose is more on the palate definitely has a bit of a kentucky hug going down um but it's
3:47
still got that pecan no that's like a nice like caramelized pecan or another way to think about
3:52
it is almost like a caramel drizzle on top of like a banana nut bread um but with pecans so it's it's
3:58
very very sweet but it's like a dark dark rich caramel in the palate so i will say i mean like
4:04
I said, not the biggest Old Forrester fan, even though I do have some of their merch. I think this is a fantastic whiskey. Like I said, this is a pick from High Time Wine Cellar, so
4:14
your mileage may vary depending on your store and their barrel select program, but I think they
4:19
knocked it out of the park with this one, especially at the $40 price point. So I guess it's time for
4:24
me to start giving this a score. My new score system, I'm going to start doing this a little
4:28
bit more on streams and the reviews like this. I think I'm going to do it out of eight because
4:32
with like 8-bit, it kind of goes with the theme. I don't know if it was supposed to be $40
4:36
I don't know if somebody messed up when they put this on the floor. So I'll give it two scores. One at that $40 price point and one at that $80 price point, which is literally
4:44
double So at I would have to say I would give this whiskey a 7 out of 8 Now I say that because I not the biggest Ulf Worrester flavor profile fan If you love that if you love 1920 you would give this an 8 out of 8 at hands down You
4:59
would not complain. You would love every minute of this. So, if you love Old Forrester 1920 and
5:03
you see this for $40 at your store, grab it. Just don't think twice. Grab two. I wish I would have
5:07
grabbed two, honestly. Now, let's say this bottle is actually $80. Then things get a little bit
5:14
different. There are other barrel proofs at a lower price point that I would probably pick up
5:19
instead of this. At $80, I would probably put this at about a 5 out of 8. But like I said
5:25
if you're an Old Forrester fan, you'd probably put that at a 6 or a 7 at the $80 price. Either way
5:31
$40, $80, Old Forrester fan, not Old Forrester fan. I do recommend picking this up. I mean
5:36
I think it may change your mind like it's changed mine about Old Forrester a bit. Because like I
5:40
said, I just really wasn't a fan, but I'm really liking what I'm getting out of this glass here
5:44
So please let me know in the comments below what you've seen this priced at in your area
5:49
and especially if you've tried it, let me know what you think, if you think it's worth that price. But yeah, totally recommend this one, and if you're new here, welcome. I do live streams every
5:57
Thursday and Saturday, and if you're not yet subscribed on YouTube, I would love you to get
6:01
the subscribe button. It really helps me out, and of course, that like button on Facebook and YouTube
6:06
means a lot. Of course, if you're watching on Facebook, hey, hit the like button on the page too
6:10
So thank you all so much for watching. This has been Bourbon Bites, whiskey reviews
6:14
with a retro twist. I'm Clifton and I'll see you guys next time
6:18
Cheers
#Alcoholic Beverages
#Beverages
#food
#Food & Drink