Yan Xishan: China's Reformist Warlord | Unveiling a Controversial Legacy | Time Travels
3K views
Apr 4, 2025
Step into the extraordinary world of Yan Xishan, the enigmatic Chinese warlord whose audacious vision and relentless pursuit of reform reshaped the course of a nation, leaving an indelible mark on China's complex history.
View Video Transcript
0:00
In the heady years of the 20th century, few countries underwent as much political turmoil and upset as China
0:07
For years, it was divided between warring factions. The communists, who fought to build the workers' paradise and overcome the stagnant legacy of traditional Chinese leadership
0:16
And then the nationalists, who wanted to build a modern republic in the place of the old empire
0:21
But squabbling amongst these governments were the warlords. men who had gained personal armies of considerable size
0:27
and were able to rule provinces as largely independent countries, each with their own quirks and beliefs
0:33
Some of these rulers were little more than bandits seeking just to enrich themselves
0:38
Others were opportunists who fought for whatever side seemed more likely to win in that moment
0:43
One was named Yan Zishan. He is one of the few that can be truly said to have fought for a vision
0:50
As ruler of Shangzi, he sought to modernise the province and turn it into a beacon for the rest of China to follow
0:56
while maintaining what he felt was China's essential cultural bedrock. Now, how did he try to modernize China
1:03
And how did it all come crashing down? Well, hello time travelers, I'm your friend Mike Brady
1:07
and this is the story of Yan Zishan, the forward-looking warlord of Shang-Zhi
1:22
Yan Zishan was born in 1883 into a family of minor bankers and merchants and began his
1:31
education in a local village school. When his father's bank went broke, however, he was left with few options
1:37
Not wanting to be restricted to his village, he instead enrolled in the tuition-free Taiwan
1:42
Military Academy. The Manchu government had hoped that this academy would train a new generation of modern
1:47
officers capable of reversing China's decline. At the academy, he studied Western subjects not usually taught in China
1:55
It obviously had an impact on the young man and it broadened his mind to the wider world
2:00
In 1904, he travelled to Japan to study and graduated from the Japanese Imperial Military Academy
2:06
While in Japan, though, he quickly realised that without major reform, China was doomed
2:10
to fall further and further behind the Western world. Japan's development in particular was upsetting to him
2:16
It was only a few decades before China had been the more powerful of the two
2:21
But now Japan was an industrial powerhouse capable of competing with the West
2:26
This experience in Japan impressed on Zishan the importance of modernization. Abandoning the old ways of superstition and lumbering old government
2:36
Zishan was committed. He would never abandon his attempts to lead China into the modern world
2:41
He also saw what Japan had done to the Korean people underneath their rule, and feared that
2:47
the same might happen to China if nothing changed. He took his life's newfound purpose very seriously
2:53
Zishan joined the revolutionary societies that opposed the Qing imperial government, and when the revolution came in 1911, he organised an army revolt in Shang-Chi that would remove
3:02
all imperial power from the province. For this, the new government awarded him the position of military governor of Shang-Chi
3:09
making the official ruler of the province. It was a meteoric rise to power for the 28-year-old former student
3:16
and he had big plans. Following the revolution, there was a brief period
3:21
when China stood unified under the rule of Yuan Shikai who went so far as to declare himself emperor of a new dynasty
3:29
However, when he died in 1916, all unity collapsed. The regional governors owed no loyalty to the central government
3:37
and began fighting amongst themselves. Yan Zishan kept Shang-Zi largely neutral in the conflict, occasionally committing token forces to whatever side was willing to make a deal
3:47
but mostly just focusing on modernizing his own small corner of China
3:52
While this was happening the rest of the country collapsed All the military governors kept their own regions under their control and China was reduced to a constantly shifting web of alliances with colonial empires nipping at the peripheries
4:06
Japan had been in a very similar position once upon a time, with shogun and samurai warring for power
4:11
but that had been over 40 years earlier. China was divided, and their potential future enemy
4:17
was only gaining in resolve, unity, and organisation. Zishan's worst fears were coming true
4:25
By 1911, Shang-Zhi had a population of about 11 million people, all of which lived under the rule of Yan Zishan
4:31
For almost the next 30 years, Shang-Zhi would be an island of relative stability in war-torn China
4:38
and Yan Zishan would attempt to reform it into the perfect Chinese society that would save the country from its decline
4:44
In many ways, Yan saw himself as a sort of modernising emperor
4:48
He ruled Shang-Zi as though it was his own kingdom. But in the province, he saw the potential to save the whole of China
4:55
He was to be the bridge between the modern and traditional worlds. His innovations were designed to preserve the existing order and adapt it to the New Age
5:04
rather than overturn it completely like many political movements at the time
5:09
One of the first reforms he attempted was to turn Confucianism from a philosophy into a religion
5:15
comparable to Christianity. He saw that in the West, a common cultural rallying point
5:19
that encouraged clean living and diligence provided a good foundation to build society on
5:24
In an attempt to give China something similar to rally around, Confucian services were held in villages
5:29
in which people were encouraged to confess their sins and the services would end in a hymn to Confucius
5:35
These so-called heart-washing societies provided a public forum for people to confess their faults
5:41
and provided social pressure to correct them. Yan also saw the importance of education in reforming China away from its feudal past
5:49
and bringing it into the future. While in power, Yan made massive investments in schools
5:55
far outpacing anything his contemporaries were building. In 1911, a staggering 99% of Shangzi was illiterate
6:04
To deal with this massive problem over the next decades, Yan built more than 26,000 schools in villages across the province
6:11
So by 1923, there were 800,000 children enrolled in school where they could learn to read and write
6:18
In one of his speeches, Yan declared that the three great duties of the people are to serve in the army, to pay taxes and to receive an education
6:28
See, education wasn't just important for bringing economic prosperity to the province
6:32
but was also essential for building up the sort of nationalism that Yan saw was necessary to save China from foreign domination
6:39
If you could get the people educated and solidified behind the country, then they could present a united front to the enemy
6:46
Students in these schools were continually reminded of the concessions that had been forced upon China by foreign powers
6:52
and they were taught that they must work to undo them. They weren't just educational institutions
6:57
but machines to help mould students into citizens capable of serving the country
7:02
Zishan also attempted to establish new universities, but these were severely hampered by unqualified professors
7:09
The mathematics faculty in one of these universities was so allegedly incompetent that they spent an entire semester
7:15
trying to work out the dimensions of a small lake on the ground. In the name of a useful and strong population
7:22
he also objected to the poor treatment of women. Yan was deeply hostile to the practice of foot binding
7:29
an ancient and traditional Chinese practice because it mutilated women for no reason
7:33
rendering huge sections of the population useless and encouraging a social divide
7:38
He banned foot binding almost immediately after taking power. Yan also wanted women to be able to sustain themselves, so he established women's schools
7:48
in every province where peasant girls were taught to read and learn a trade For the first time in Shangzi Yan also codified a system of laws that were taught to the peasants Previously the power of officials to interpret the law and the inability of peasants
8:03
to dispute it led to huge issues with corruption. And Yan hoped that by teaching the peasants their
8:09
rights and responsibilities, he would bring about a new era of prosperity by eliminating corrupt
8:14
officials. Villagers were also allowed to pass their own minor laws and elect their own local
8:20
officials. In the time of warlords, though, social reform was not enough. Every province required a
8:27
strong army to keep themselves from being invaded by an ambitious warlord and taken over. Yan took a
8:32
different approach than the majority of his fellow warlords. The Shangzi army was made up of a civilian
8:37
militia who came together for periodic training rather than a professional force loyal only to
8:43
the warlord. They were not the best trained or well-equipped army in China, but due to this policy
8:48
Yan was capable of calling up over 100,000 troops to defend the province
8:54
He also used the militia to build and repair roads and to assist with harvests when they weren't training or fighting
9:01
In the early years of his rule, Zishan's army was one of the few in China to have genuine popular support
9:08
Yan himself was well known for visiting villages and respected among peasants for not coming from aristocracy
9:14
He was known in and outside Shangzi as the model governor for his reforms
9:18
Zishan built his own weapons factory rather than relying on imported weapons from foreign nations
9:24
and his province did not engage in wars often with the other warlords, preferring instead to turn the Shangzi into a mountain fortress in the midst of the conflict
9:33
Banditry in the provinces had also been a major issue when he took power
9:37
The lack of opportunities for soldiers often meant that after their services
9:41
they would take to the wilderness and steal. Not only did Yan Zishan eliminate banditry through deploying the army and watching the roads
9:49
he also ensured that the soldiers were taught a trade while in the military to ensure that they would be able to find a job after their time in the army
9:57
By the end of his rule, banditry in Shangzi had been virtually eliminated
10:01
The mountainous terrain of Shangzi, the large militia and the arms factories in the province
10:06
managed to keep the region safe from invading powers. And with all this in mind, it might sound like Yan Zishan was basically the perfect governor
10:16
But unfortunately, he was still a warlord in the middle of war-torn China
10:21
And what he implemented wasn't all good. In addition to damaging cultural practices, he outlawed, quote
10:29
idleness, sloppiness, brawling, excessive merrymaking and the use of the old calendar
10:35
He formed early rising societies to make sure that people were out of bed by 6am
10:39
and reported the people who were not as idlers. In some cases, these people were made to perform labour for the state
10:46
I would have been in trouble. Yan also instinctively feared democracy. He was more than willing to use it as a propaganda tool, of course
10:53
but he refused to give the people an actual role in government. He set up village councils
10:58
but wouldn't give them authority to actually do anything except give advice. He had his portrait hung in every village in Shangzi
11:04
and ruled through martial law. People were taught that loyalty to Yan Zishan was the highest virtue
11:11
In this way, along with his natural conservatism, he saw himself as a new Chinese ruler
11:16
He wasn't attempting to radically reform China. He was just more trying to do enough to make China powerful
11:22
while retaining the hierarchical social structure. Now, due to Yan's reforms and attempts at modernization
11:28
things in Shang-Chi remained stable for the majority of the interwar years
11:32
But then his worst fears came true, and everything changed. Japan invaded China in earnest in 1937, and Shang-Zhi found itself on the firing line
11:44
Japanese troops flooded into the province, and despite the huge militia, the mountainous
11:49
terrain and the new policies the structural weaknesses of the warlord state made themselves apparent Corruption within the Zishan army had secretly grown to be too much
11:59
Commanders refused to work with one another and troops were so badly led and supplied
12:03
that important positions in Shangzi were simply abandoned without a fight. Shangzi troops themselves
12:09
were forced to rob for supplies and were by that point so badly disciplined
12:13
that many of the peasants of Shangzi were more hostile to their own men than the Japanese
12:18
Now, the Japanese paid labourers better than Yarn did, and many peasants willingly built fortifications for the Imperial Army
12:26
Indeed, the reports of peasant behaviour indicates that most didn't fully understand the context of the war in the first place
12:32
and saw Japanese troops simply as the soldiers of another warlord's province
12:36
The wealthy class in particular was hostile to Yarn due to his high taxation of the rich
12:41
and they largely became collaborators with the Japanese, helping to organise labour and the payments of taxes
12:47
In order to defend the province, the communist army came to fight alongside the Shangzi troops
12:52
and quickly became the far more popular of the two. The communist troops were well disciplined and fought effectively
12:59
They implemented rent reductions and badly needed land reform, and they opposed the rich that had hoarded much of the wealth of the province
13:06
The communists swept control of Shangzi out from under Yan through popular support
13:12
Seeing that he was losing control of his people, Yan went so far as to attempt an alliance with the Japanese independently of the rest of China's
13:19
forces. A ceasefire was signed in 1944. There's even a suggestion that Japan saw Yan as a successor
13:26
to Chinese Republican leader Chiang Kai-shek should Japan win the war. When the war ended in 1945
13:34
Yan even made a deal with the Japanese to have all occupied territory handed over to his men
13:39
Then, instead of repatriating the Japanese troops, he incorporated them into his own army to fight the communists
13:46
As late as 1947, the streets of Taiwan still were crowded with Japanese soldiers
13:51
dressed in Yan's uniforms but fighting under their own commanders. This only undermined his popularity further
13:59
By 1949, the communist forces were too strong to resist any longer
14:04
Shang-Zhi fell. for the first time since 1911, some 37 years prior
14:10
Shangzi wasn't under the rule of Yan Zishan. Yan fled to Nanjing, where he was briefly made Premier of the Republic of China
14:17
It was an inglorious end to what had been a bold and daring plan. Once the Chinese communists gained control of China, Zishan fled again to Taiwan
14:28
Now here, he was deserted by most of his followers and lived out a humble life, writing books on philosophy and history
14:35
He'd been a divisive figure. On the one hand, his reformist policies had been implemented for the greater good
14:41
with a view to bring the whole of China into the modern era. But poor decision-making and reason had resulted in the same old issues emerging
14:49
Corruption, megalomania overshadowed what could have been a legendary legacy and a different direction for China
14:56
He'd been a warlord turned statesman, but in the end, he was just a fugitive
15:01
Zishan lived out the rest of his life in Taiwan and died in 1960
15:06
But some die-hard followers still bestowed a final, lasting honour in Zishan
15:11
For decades, a small group of former aides tended to his grave and maintained it
15:15
until 2011, when the last of those men turned 81 and was too old to keep up the tradition
15:21
Today, the city of Taipei government maintains the site instead, the final resting place of the warlord who tried to modernise China
15:30
Hello time travellers, thank you so much for watching this video. If you enjoyed it leave a comment below and don't forget to subscribe to the channel
15:39
Until next time remember, history doesn't repeat but it certainly echoes
#Anthropology
#education
#History
#Political Science
#Social Sciences