Becoming Death: J. Robert Oppenheimer's Regret | 1945 | Time Travels
290 views
Apr 6, 2025
Becoming Death: J. Robert Oppenheimer's Regret | 1945 | Time Travels
View Video Transcript
0:00
New Mexico, 1945
0:02
There's a flurry of activity as military officials and scientists get themselves into order to witness something extraordinary
0:09
A few put on special welding goggles, even though it's only just after five in the morning
0:15
The minutes tick down until all has fallen quiet. Then, 5.29am, there's a blinding flash of light and a thunderous roar
0:26
In a patch of sand a few miles downrange, an enormous ball of flame and energy gives birth to a towering mushroom cloud
0:39
425 people look on in awe as the first ever nuclear bomb is detonated
0:45
and among them is the man whose scientific work had made it happen. He had named the nuclear test Trinity after a line from a 17th century poem
0:53
but as the flash subsided and goggles were removed, the man was reminded of another, more ancient poem from the Hindu holy book
1:01
As the staff around him laughed, cried, or stood in silent awe
1:05
he recited the line in his head, I am mighty time, the great destroyer of worlds
1:12
and I have come here to destroy all people. The man's name was J. Robert Oppenheimer
1:20
and he and his team had just changed the world forever. Hello, time travellers. I'm your friend Mike Brady, and this is the remarkable story of J. Robert Oppenheimer, the father of the atomic bomb
1:47
It's hard to imagine where somebody so influential as Oppenheimer could come from
1:52
History's full of movers and dreamers, doers and daredevils, and often they have surprising backgrounds or unusual childhoods that drove them into action
2:01
But in J.R. Oppenheimer's case, even though his work would eventually go on to change the face of the world and society forever
2:08
his background story is surprisingly straightforward. Julius Robert Oppenheimer was born on the 22nd of April 1904
2:16
to a family of Jewish German immigrants living in New York City
2:20
His family were wealthy, thanks to his father's clothing business, and the young Robert grew up in luxury
2:27
However, it was a lonely childhood. Robert's mother was protective of the boy
2:32
after his younger brother had died as an infant, and he spent most of his time at home with her
2:38
Here, he developed a passion for the sciences, becoming an amateur geologist and writing to local collectors
2:44
He was occasionally bullied by other children for not pursuing the same sports and games as the others that were his age
2:51
but it was clear to his parents that they had an exceptionally bright son, and they encouraged his interests
2:59
He managed to skip several grades at school, and even convinced the curator of the Museum of Natural History to tutor him
3:06
In high school, he was top of his class in all of his subjects, from Latin and German to physics
3:12
And one friend recalled that he took on more classes than everybody else because he was just trying to keep himself occupied
3:19
The young Oppenheimer developed a deep love for the desert environment of New Mexico
3:23
when he visited a friend's ranch there, and years later he'd purchased the ranch himself
3:28
renaming it Pero Caliente, or Hot Dog. In 1922, Oppenheimer attended Harvard
3:35
and eventually settled on chemistry as a major after having tried basically everything the university had to offer
3:42
There could be no question of his academic brilliance, and after three years he graduated Summa Cum Laude
3:47
making the Dean's List and was offered a graduate fellowship. But instead, Oppenheimer chose to travel to England and then Germany
3:54
studying advanced physics and earning his doctorate. But at 1927 at just 23 years of age Oppenheimer was back in the US teaching between the California Institute of Technology and Harvard University
4:20
Oppenheimer was a tall, thin young man who chain-smoked like a chimney
4:24
and, through periods of intense concentration, often forgot to eat for days
4:29
His hyperfocus wasn't just born of interest. The young man was often depressed and he was prone to bouts of rage
4:35
He once told his brother that he needed physics more than friends. Despite his youth, he was already well known in his field thanks to his European experience
4:43
He was also well acquainted with the new theories that were coming from the continent
4:48
Among these theories was the idea that a chain reaction could be caused in uranium
4:52
that would lead to a massive release of energy, which, if harnessed, would produce the most powerful weapon ever created by humankind
5:04
With the outbreak of the Second World War in 1939, Allied scientists had deep fears
5:10
See, Germany had been at the heart of nuclear physics studies before the war. And if Nazi Germany's scientific community was able to turn the theoretical atom bomb
5:18
into the real thing, then the war in Europe would be over and the swastika might fly across the globe
5:25
A group of atomic scientists contacted Albert Einstein and expressed their concerns
5:31
Einstein, in turn, wrote a letter to American President Roosevelt with the concerns of the scientists
5:36
and asking that the United States begin research of its own nuclear weapon
5:40
But the response was not impressive. At first, the U.S. government was reluctant to take it seriously
5:46
But then, in 1940, something was discovered that changed everything. Now, the theory behind the atom bomb had existed since the early 1930s among nuclear physicists
5:56
But it wasn't until 1940 that the atom bomb became not just theoretical, but an actual possibility
6:06
See, only uranium-235 was capable of producing the chemical reaction needed for actually producing the atom bomb
6:13
But that was a particularly rare form of the element. Then in 1940, two German physicists studying in Britain
6:20
discovered a process for producing uranium-235 quickly and in quantities large enough to make building a bomb a viable option
6:28
The danger was immediately apparent If the Nazis were able to discover this process as well
6:35
they might be able to make a bomb big enough to destroy London or any other European city
6:40
Word of the new discovery made its way to America and the United States government was at last spurred into action
6:48
They established groups to study the possibility of the atomic bomb in 1940 and two years later, Dr. J. Robert Oppenheimer was brought on board
6:58
Now, the young physicist was quickly given control of the new secret weapons development program
7:03
codenamed the Manhattan Project. He was given a single objective, build a bomb before the Germans did
7:09
and his appetite for scientific advancement was voracious. He took to the task with absolute enthusiasm
7:21
Oppenheimer selected Los Alamos, a region of his beloved New Mexico, as the location for the secret laboratory and its support city
7:32
The site at Los Alamos quickly bloomed to house over 6,000 people
7:37
and Oppenheimer, without ever having held an army rank or managed more than a small team of people
7:42
was in charge of all of it. For years, he and the other scientists at Los Alamos
7:46
worked around the clock to find a way to build an atom bomb. By the 16th of July 1945, they'd finally succeeded
7:56
The Trinity test was conducted in the New Mexico desert and ushered in the nuclear age
8:07
Oppenheimer had gazed coolly at the massive explosion and whatever internal conflict he might have been feeling he did his best to hide From the reports of witnesses the only thing he said when he saw the explosion was
8:25
I guess it worked. Fears of a Nazi nuclear bomb had been largely unfounded
8:32
Hitler had never invested enough resources to get the Nazi nuclear program off the ground in the first place
8:37
and his bloodthirsty regime had chased hundreds of highly influential scientists, physicists, and chemists away
8:44
purely because of their Jewish heritage. In fact, the two German scientists
8:48
who discovered the method for easy production of uranium-235 back in 1940 had actually fled Germany
8:55
and even went to work for Oppenheimer and the Manhattan Project in America
8:59
Now, the scientists at Los Alamos had been eager to beat the Germans to the bomb. But then when the time came to actually use it
9:04
on their other enemy, Japan, there was a sudden reluctance. The United States now possess
9:09
the most terrifying destructive weapon ever produced. and Oppenheimer and his team had willed it and worked it into existence
9:18
Now the blood of tens of thousands or even millions could be on their hands
9:23
So the mood was grim. One of Oppenheimer's colleagues remembered in the weeks after the Trinity test
9:28
finding him pacing the camp with his pipe, muttering, Those poor, poor people
9:35
In August 1945, the atom bomb was deployed operationally, first over Hiroshima and then Nagasaki
9:42
killing a combined total of roughly 200,000 people. Oppenheimer was justifiably upset about the second atomic bombing at Nagasaki in particular
10:03
He felt that the use of a single bomb would be enough to convince the Japanese to surrender
10:07
had they simply been given more time. He travelled to Washington to speak to President Truman and requested the bomb be banned
10:14
telling the President that, I feel I have blood on my hands. President Truman was, to put it simply, unimpressed by this display of remorse
10:26
He kicked Oppenheimer out and told his secretary, I don't want to see that son of a b**** in this office ever again
10:30
And later called him a crybaby scientist. The atom bomb project was now well out of Oppenheimer's care
10:37
and his creation had a life of its own. Terrifyingly, it was now in the hands of the greatest military-industrial complex on Earth
10:45
Oppenheimer's intense desire to complete the project, followed by an equally intense regret at having done so
10:51
reflects the two sides of the man. Before the project was completed, he was the obsessive scientist
10:56
who was given the chance to break barriers and invent something never before conceived of
11:00
But when it was finished, he was filled with deep regret and the horror that his scientific breakthroughs and achievements had led to the incineration of nearly a quarter of a million people
11:15
Immediately after the war, he began advocating for arms control, going so far as to suggest that the Soviets be allowed to collaborate with the Americans on nuclear weapons
11:23
that the bombs be banned like poison gas had been after the First World War. He deeply feared the nuclear arms race between the Soviet Union and the United States
11:32
because he more than anybody understood the full destructive potential of the atomic bomb
11:37
But when his efforts to share control of nuclear power failed, he became despondent
11:42
He also knew that America's sole control of nuclear power wasn't going to last
11:46
telling Times Magazine in 1948 that our atomic monopoly is like a cake of ice melting in the sun
11:53
and his vision was prophetic. In 1949, the Soviet Union tested a nuclear bomb of their own
11:59
and the dynamic of power in the world was forever changed. With the loss of their nuclear monopoly
12:09
the US military was no longer satisfied with the state of their nuclear arsenal
12:12
They needed bigger and better bombs right away and set about the creation of the hydrogen bomb
12:23
Oppenheimer opposed the development of this new bomb as he was already horrified by the destructive potential of regular atomic weapons
12:36
A hydrogen bomb was hundreds of times more powerful, and he refused to take part in the development
12:40
and encouraged other scientists to boycott the program as well. When he heard that the US Air Force's plan for nuclear war
12:47
involved the carpet bombing of Eastern Europe, he called the plan genocidal
12:51
He was particularly concerned about the threat of nuclear terrorism once saying that in the modern world a single man
12:59
was capable of destroying New York with a briefcase Around the same time Oppenheimer was labelled as a security risk
13:07
by the Eisenhower government as a result of his opposition to nuclear war
13:11
and with some previous left-wing activism during the Great Depression This was an era of great mistrust and scapegoating
13:18
Oppenheimer had his security clearance revoked and he was removed from his authoritative positions
13:24
This only further cemented his opposition to nuclear weapons. He was particularly critical of the American war planners for their willingness to kill billions of people as part of a standard plan of attack
13:35
He asked, What are we to make of a civilization which has always regarded ethics as an essential part of human life
13:42
but which has not been able to talk about the prospect of killing almost everybody except in prudential and game-theoretical terms
13:49
Seeing the persecution Oppenheimer was facing, Albert Einstein suggested that he simply move to another country
13:56
A scientist as accomplished as Oppenheimer would have no trouble getting a job anywhere in the world
14:01
and he would not have to face the anti-communist witch hunts that had taken over the United States
14:06
But Oppenheimer refused for a simple reason. He was an American patriot
14:11
Damn it, he said. I happen to love this country. He was eventually politically rehabilitated in the 1960s
14:18
and was invited to the White House by President Kennedy, but he never stopped advocating for the destruction of nuclear weapons
14:24
and arguing against the insanity of nuclear war. If there is another world war
14:32
this civilization may go under. We need to ask ourselves whether we're doing all we can to avert that
14:43
We need, I think, to learn to understand the realities of life abroad
14:50
not so much in terms of slogans as in terms of the lives of men
14:58
In our response to these realities, there is hope for peace. He was nominated three times for the Nobel Prize, but never won for classic Oppenheimer reasons
15:13
He simply had too many interests to take any single field to the point that he would actually win a Nobel Prize in it
15:20
On the 18th of February 1967, Oppenheimer died after having fallen into a coma several days before
15:26
His funeral was attended by hundreds of scientists and public figures, including American President Lyndon B. Johnson and dozens of his former colleagues and staff
15:35
And even today, Oppenheimer's legacy continues to be felt. The threat of nuclear war might have fallen out of the public consciousness
15:42
but it's not vanished. Russia and the United States maintain nuclear arsenals of thousands of weapons each
15:48
while smaller stockpiles are held by India, Pakistan, the United Kingdom, France, China, and North Korea
15:58
Luckily, there hasn't been a nuclear attack since the bombings of Japan in 1945
16:04
But so long as the weapon exists, there will always be the temptation to use them
16:10
We can only hope that Oppenheimer's prophecies are never realised
16:34
Thank you
#education
#History
#Physics