Republicans continue push to end nationwide injunctions by district courts
3K views
Apr 3, 2025
Conservatives contend individual judges have been overstepping their authority by blocking President Trump’s agenda nationwide.
View Video Transcript
0:00
Republicans are continuing their push to stop nationwide injunctions with a new bill that would limit court orders, including injunctions and temporary restraining orders to parties that are directly before the court
0:12
Republicans contend that individual judges are overstepping their authority by blocking President Trump's agenda nationwide
0:20
Senator Ashley Moody stated this clear overreach was never envisioned by the framers of the Constitution
0:26
This important legislation will be a tool to help stop the unreasonable restraints on executive authority
0:32
There are more than 90 district courts in the U.S. with 677 judges
0:37
Geographically, each district covers at most a single state, oftentimes just a region within a state
0:43
One judge in one district has the authority to implement what's called a universal injunction
0:50
which halts executive action across the country while the case works its way through the court system
0:56
Senator Chuck Grassley stated, The Constitution limits judges to exercising power over cases or controversies
1:04
Judges are not policymakers and allowing them to assume this role is very dangerous
1:08
The Congressional Research Service identified 17 nationwide injunctions issued in the first two months of the Trump administration
1:15
To put that into perspective the Department of Justice identified 12 nationwide injunctions during George W Bush presidency and 19 during Barack Obama Democrats and Republicans politicians and judges have all spoken out against nationwide injunctions
1:31
Supreme Court Justice Elena Kagan, a liberal member of the court, once stated
1:35
it just can't be right that one district judge can stop a nationwide policy in its tracks
1:40
and leave it stopped for the years that it takes to go through the normal process
1:44
There's an argument that we should look at how injunctions from a single district court have applied nationwide, but it ought to be above politics
1:56
It should not be motivated by particular rulings. And so far, the system seems to have worked pretty well
2:04
This bill has a greater chance of being approved than other measures introduced by Republicans that are considered more extreme
2:11
like impeaching judges who rule against the president or lowering the funding levels for certain courts
2:17
I'm not going to support reducing the federal judiciary's budget because someone doesn't agree with their opinions
2:27
That's not the right way. That's not the way we do it in America
2:31
The sponsors of the nationwide injunction bill say the Supreme Court has the authority to tell lower courts to stop nationwide injunctions
2:38
They also say Article 3 of the Constitution gives Congress the power to set limits on judicial authority
2:44
I'm Ray Bogan for Straight Arrow News. For more reporting, download the SAN app
#Law & Government
#Legal
#news
#Politics