The Afghanistan War Commission's mission: Weapons and Warfare
1 views
Sep 2, 2025
This week on Weapons and Warfare, host Ryan Robertson takes a look at the work of the Afghanistan War Commission.
View Video Transcript
0:00
Two years into a four-year term, the Air Force's top four star unexpectedly calls it a career
0:06
What's behind the decision? Plus, Spain scraps plans to buy the F-35
0:12
What that means for Lockheed Martin and NATO. And buckle up, we're going for a ride with the Hurricane Hunters as they fly into the eye of Hurricane Aaron
0:22
Hello and welcome to Weapons and Warfare, a show made for people who want to know more
0:32
about our national defense. Our goal is to help you have an informed conversation about what's
0:38
happening with America's military. For Straight Arrow News, I'm your host, Ryan Robertson
0:42
and we start this week with a look back at America's war in Afghanistan. In 2021
0:48
Congress tasked a bipartisan commission with documenting the stories of warriors who served in America's longest-running war
0:58
While the commission's full report will not be released until next year
1:02
we are hearing from some of those entrusted to do the job. And that's the subject of this week's debrief
1:09
38 days. That's all the time that stood between the horrific events of September 11, 2001
1:19
and the first Americans setting foot in Afghanistan on October 19. 7,255 days later
1:29
the last American military contingent would leave. It is America's longest war, and now
1:36
Veterans from the United States' 20-year involvement in Afghanistan are telling the commission reviewing the decisions that shaped the war it was indeed hell, but also confounding, demoralizing, even humiliating for them
1:52
One thing that's particularly important to us is to tell a human story of the war
1:58
We know that the media has covered the issues and conflicts of Afghanistan extensively
2:05
but oftentimes the stories of the individuals who served on the ground get lost
2:10
The report will yze key strategic, diplomatic, military and operational decisions made between June 2001 and the chaotic withdrawal from Afghanistan in August 2021
2:24
I think Afghanistan, like any war, is full of coming-of-age stories when you get down to the very individual level
2:29
And those are, as Bob said, those are gut-wrenching. Those are very personal things
2:33
According to numbers from the AMARC Foundation, more than 832,000 Americans served in Afghanistan
2:40
throughout Operations Enduring Freedom and Freedom's Sentinel. Nearly 21,000 were wounded, while 2,456 made the ultimate sacrifice
2:53
One of the main goals of the commission is to take a close look at the strategic
2:58
diplomatic and operational choices made by the U.S. during the war, as well as gather lessons learned and offer recommendations for the future
3:07
Our work is not just about what the U.S. did in Afghanistan
3:11
but what the U.S. should be doing in any country where it deems it has a national security interest
3:19
To date, the commission conducted more than 160 interviews with cabinet-level officials
3:24
military commanders, diplomats, Afghan and Pakistani leaders, and others. This isn't just us talking to Americans
3:33
We're talking to allies, partners. We're talking to Afghans about their experience and try to understand how they saw the decisions and our actions over the course of the war
3:44
The commission is also hosting forums for veterans, including a recent one at a National Veterans of Foreign Wars convention
3:51
The reason we are in Columbus today is to talk with those coming to this VFW convention
3:56
One is to educate them on the purpose of the commission, but it also allows them to have a voice and express their concerns, tell their stories about their experience in Afghanistan
4:10
The group released its second interim report in August. It draws no conclusions yet, but identifies themes emerging from documents, interviews, and veteran forums
4:20
The commission's final report is due to be made public by August 22, 2026
4:26
I'm joined now by senior producer and Air Force veteran Brett Baker
4:32
Brett caught you on the road this week, but honestly, I'm really glad we did this story on the commission's findings from the war in Afghanistan so far
4:40
because whatever criticisms Americans have of their government and the handling of the global war on terror
4:47
the service members doing the actual work on the ground and in the skies you know they all performed admirably for the most part Absolutely Absolutely So it really critical that their voices are part of the official record and it helps inform leadership
5:04
You know, what's next going forward whenever this kind of thing happens again
5:10
All right. Well, let's go ahead and get to some headlines you may have missed. Just two years into a four year assignment, the Air Force's chief of staff is calling it a career
5:21
In a surprising move, General David Alvin announced his retirement. He will remain as chief of staff until a replacement is confirmed and expects to leave around November 1st
5:32
two years into his four-year term. Of his decision to end his 39-year career, General Alvin said
5:41
more than anything, I'm proud to have been part of the team of airmen who live out our core values
5:47
of integrity, service, and excellence every day as we prepare to defend this great nation
5:54
Alvin is an Air Force Academy graduate and command pilot with more than 4,600 flying hours
6:01
Brett, General Alvin's departure is, you know, surprising to say the least, and marks another
6:08
in kind of a series of top commanders to either quit or be fired since President Donald Trump
6:14
named Pete Hegseth as the Secretary of Defense. Yeah, and you know, this guy, we've seen him speak
6:21
a few times at different symposiums we've been into. He is a compelling figure. Like he can
6:28
command a room. You listen when he's talking. So whatever his reasons are, whatever the motivations
6:36
were. We don't know exactly, but I do think that it is, it's, I think it's a blow to Air Force
6:44
leadership that he's stepping out this early. You know, it's supposed to be a four-year commitment
6:49
and, you know, halfway through he's pulling the ejection handle. I don't think it's good for the
6:56
Air Force. I don't think it's good for the DOD, but it is what it is. Well, his legacy will always
7:03
be tied to the F-47 as well. So even though it was a shortened time in office there as Chief of
7:11
Staff of the Air Force, he definitely made a mark on the service for sure. Thanks, but no thanks
7:18
That's the word from Spanish military officials as they put a stop to a deal with Lockheed Martin
7:23
for a fleet of F-35 fighter jets. Instead, Spain is turning its focus to European-made options like
7:30
the Eurofighter and the future combat air system. Spain had set aside more than 6 billion euros to
7:38
upgrade its aging Navy and Air Force fleets, but with rising tensions over defensive ending targets
7:43
and political friction between Madrid and Washington, the U.S. jets are now off the table
7:49
Canada was looking at doing a similar deal, Brett, but ultimately it looks like they will stick with
7:55
thereby of 88 F-35s. What do you make of all this? It's interesting for sure
8:02
I think it's more of a sign of the time we're in right now
8:05
than it is anything that has to do with the performance of the vehicle itself
8:12
Because right now their fleet is mostly Harriers and F-18s. So you're talking 50 to 30-year-old technology
8:20
And now they're going to wait for something that is still in development. So who knows when those 6th Gen fighters are going to become available, whereas you have a 5th Gen fighter if they're still fully realizing its capabilities available now
8:35
So I do think it's a bit of the moment. You know, with the America First policy, European units or countries are looking out for themselves and saying, OK, well, maybe we're just going to have to operate within this
8:49
And so I think that's probably like the biggest part of this piece is let's keep it within Europe and that'll help whatever happens down the road
8:59
You bet. Yeah, there is some fears that whether they're founded or unfounded, they exist
9:06
That if the Europeans buy a lot of American technology, that the Americans might be able to, you know, turn off a function of that vehicle or a piece of equipment or something like that
9:18
Um, so Europeans want to provide for themselves and, and ensure that doesn't happen
9:24
Uh, we saw this in Ukraine when Starlink was kind of shut down for a little bit, uh, when
9:28
Ukraine was trying to launch a counter-offensive into Russia, uh, that counter-offensive was
9:34
ultimately called off because they didn't have, uh, the satellite communications to make
9:40
it possible. Talk about a turbulent day at work. This is video of the 53rd Weather Reconnaissance Squadron aka the Hurricane Hunters tracking Hurricane Aaron flying a WC Super Hercules out of Keesler Air Force Base is that right I mispronounced Puget Sound a couple of weeks ago
10:04
and I feel awful about it, so I want to make sure I get Keesler Air Force Base correct
10:08
Keesler Air Force Base in Mississippi. The crew deployed ocean buoys to collect real-time
10:13
measurements of waves, currents, and atmospheric turbulence. And, oh yeah, they flew into the eye
10:20
of the hurricane, yielding some amazing video. Brett, I will not ever do this. What say you
10:28
I, you know, I'm game. Let's go. I mean, they're not going to go fly it if they don't plan on
10:33
coming home. So. That's true. That's true. Turbulence has never brought down an airplane
10:38
but well, they say it hasn't brought down an airplane. Yeah, it's amazing work they're doing really
10:46
You know, the technology is catching up to where now they can put things into these storms
10:52
I couldn't even begin to comprehend what it all is, but I do think it's fascinating that they're like
10:57
opening the back of that plane and just chucking stuff out. Yeah
11:00
All right, go to work. Yeah. Yeah. Definitely some amazing technology. Hopefully they learn a whole bunch of stuff
11:06
you know I don't know if humanity will ever be able to stop a hurricane but if we can predict
11:12
paths and that sort of thing then hopefully we can you know get people out of harm's way
11:17
Brett want to thank you for joining us and being a trooper this week obviously you got some seasonal
11:22
allergies going on hope you feel better next week get some honey get some tea in your system
11:27
and we'll see you later see you next night it's time to break up with mainstream media
11:33
and try something new. At Straight Arrow News, we're bringing back trustworthy journalism
11:40
Bringing you news, not noise. Bringing you facts, not fluff. Bringing you clarity, not chaos
11:49
We are. We are. We are Straight Arrow News, the news you've been looking for
11:56
For unbiased, straight facts, visit san.com. Innovation is at the heart of the defense industry, people with a vision for what's possible, pushing things forward
12:09
And as American leadership turns its attention toward the Indo-Pacific, they are asking their defense industry partners to bring new ideas to the table at a pace not seen in decades
12:21
While that's always been the business model, recently there's been a significant change
12:26
Where they once wanted bigger, stronger, faster, they're now asking for smaller, smarter, and more cost-efficient
12:35
That's why the Cummings Aerospace Hellhound is our Weapon of the Week
12:41
As the video evidence shows, the Hellhound S3 is a bit of a head-turner
12:47
this man-portable 3D-printed turbojet-powered drone is capable of delivering on a wide range
12:55
of loitering munition missions. Through flight tests, we've demonstrated a top speed of 384 miles per hour to date
13:03
In addition to that, it gives you rapid time to target. The operator can use that speed to really execute a target quickly
13:11
Sheila Cummings is the founder, president, and CEO of Cummings Aerospace. She tells us the S3 was designed with portability in mind
13:20
Well, the vehicle itself is approximately 12 pounds. It's 3D printed, so it makes it a very light and effective solution
13:28
Overall, the launch canister, the vehicle, ground control system, you're looking at a total system weight of about 40 pounds
13:35
And so it's integrated onto a rucksack to demonstrate that main portability
13:40
Cummings says once trained, an operator can have the system up and ready to go
13:44
in as few as two minutes. But it's really in the skies over the battle space that she says this
13:50
variant of the Hellhound really offers the user a lot of bang for the buck. The Hellhound S3 variant
13:57
can not only hold a munition solution, but it can carry an EW payload or RF payload or other payloads
14:04
we haven't even identified yet. And so the open systems architecture design really supports
14:10
technology evolution and gives you the flexibility for changes in the mission needs
14:15
The S3 was designed to compete for the U.S. Army's Low Altitude Stalking and Strike Ordnance Program
14:21
also known as LASSO, and while it wasn't picked up in the first increment of weapons purchased
14:27
that opportunity went to Aeroviron's Switchblade 600, the Army says LASSO will not be a single
14:34
manufacturer program, suggesting a future opportunity for outfits like Cummings Aerospace. Despite that initial disappointment, though, Cummings says her company
14:44
has its sights set on a much bigger picture The reality is Hellhound is a family of UAS products so the S3 variant is just one We have others that we want to bring online to support the broader UAS market
14:59
and counter-UAS market. To that point, just a few weeks ago at the Space and Missile Defense
15:04
Symposium, Cummings Aerospace rolled out the Hellhound S4, which is a Group 2 UAS that could
15:11
fit within the scope of President Trump's Golden Dome project. If you like a bargain, good news
15:20
This is a BOGO edition of Coms Check, two for the price of one, so let's get straight to it
15:27
First up, after decades of failed attempts, including the recent cancellation of a second
15:34
robotic combat vehicles competition, the U.S. Army is attempting to develop RCVs with a unit cost cap
15:41
of $650,000 while also asking for prototypes of unmanned ground commercial robotic vehicles
15:49
that can carry more than 2,200 pounds and navigate alongside soldiers in armored brigade
15:57
combat teams. The RCVs should support basic remote capabilities and include autonomous
16:03
features for navigation and various operational modes. They need to reach at least 34 miles per
16:11
hour on roads and 25 miles per hour off-road with a range of 140 miles, advanced sensing capabilities
16:20
and potential features for countering unmanned aerial vehicles and conducting electronic warfare
16:27
A lot of kit in a little box. About a month ago, we featured the Lockheed Martin Jagam in our
16:33
Weapon of the Week. Well, now the U.S. Army has awarded Lockheed Martin a $720 million contract
16:40
for the joint air-to-ground missiles and Hellfire missiles. It's a deal that will not only take care of the Army and Navy
16:48
but international customers as well, including 160 Jagams for the UK and Hellfire missiles
16:55
for NATO allies like Poland, Spain, the Czech Republic, Italy, and Canada
17:04
All opinions expressed in this segment are solely the opinions of the contributors
17:08
Alright folks, that's going to just about do it for us this week here at Weapons and Warfare
17:13
If you liked what you saw and or heard in the episode, and you want to share it with your friends, we encourage that
17:19
So go ahead, like and subscribe to our social media feeds, and download the Straight Arrow News app today
17:25
Our mission here at the show is to try and make the world of defensive technologies
17:30
and national defense more accessible for you. So for my wrap this week, I thought it was important to add some context
17:36
to a story I saw Reuters put out recently. It got picked up by a bunch of different outlets
17:42
The headline reads, the U.S. Navy is building a drone fleet to take on China
17:47
It's not going well, which is somewhat true, but doesn't give enough context
17:53
The Reuters report details two Navy tests where different types of unmanned surface vessels
17:58
were being controlled by AI agents. Things did not go exactly as planned
18:04
The mishaps from one of those tests was caught on video, and the Navy ultimately put a hold on a $20 million contract with L3Harris
18:14
one of the companies providing AI software for the autonomous tests. The story only talks about two tests, though
18:21
which included just a few surface vessel and software providers. But the Navy is performing dozens of these types of tests
18:30
with many different vendors trying to find the right combination of craft, software, and armaments
18:37
For instance, I spoke with the CEO of Havoc AI earlier this year
18:42
about his software successfully controlling dozens of surface vessels in two different parts of the globe simultaneously from a land-based testing facility
18:54
That test went very well. Doing live field tests will inherently include failures
19:01
as many tests are designed to push a system to the point of failure so you can find its limits
19:08
When it comes to fielding naval drones, it's true there may be too many cooks in the kitchen
19:13
There were several naval offices all working on drones. Now they're getting rolled into one, the Naval Rapid Capabilities Office
19:20
So in my mind, it's not necessarily that the Navy is failing to field a drone fleet
19:26
It's just easier to get people to click on an article about failures
19:31
I don't know if that says more about the outlet or the audience. For senior producer Brett Baker, video editor Brian Spencer, and motion designer Dakota Patio
19:40
I'm Ryan Robertson with Straight Arrow News, signing off
#news
#Politics
#Veterans