Aaron Judge and Shohei Ohtani are possibly the two best players of their generation. Which superstar would you pick for your team?
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
They are two of the best players of their generation, the LA Dodgers' Shohei Otani and the New York Yankees' Aaron Judge
0:06
both on pace to be first ballot Hall of Famers. But if you were starting a team, which one would you pick
0:12
I can't choose, so I'm just going to lay out the facts and let the debate begin
0:19
Let's start with Judge, who's played the first 42 games like he comes from another planet
0:24
He leads the majors in nearly every hitting category. And with all the injuries the Yankees have suffered, he has single-handedly carried his team to a first-place start in the American League East
0:35
He told reporters Sunday he models his game after the greats Albert Pujols and Miguel Cabrera
0:41
They're the two best, I feel like, right-handed hitters I've ever seen. So, yeah, just trying to follow their lead
0:47
And, you know, just wherever I'm at in the lineup, I've got to do my job. I'm hitting 30, I've got to drive guys in, I'm second, get on base and do what I need to do for the team
0:54
Shohei is not having quite the same start to his season, but the Dodgers are
0:59
also in first place due in large part to his presence. Like the three-run homer
1:04
he hit Friday in the ninth inning to complete a comeback against the
1:07
Diamondbacks In 2024 Shohei became the first player to hit 50 homers and steal 50 bases in a single season He constantly got manager Dave Roberts shaking his head Between him and Barry Bonds they the two best plays I ever seen
1:24
I play with Barry, but what Shohei does in the clutch, I've never seen anything like what he does in the clutch
1:32
All right, here are the 2025 numbers so far. Judge does have the edge not only over Otani, but the entire league
1:38
14 home runs and 40 RBIs plus an astronomical OPS lead the majors
1:46
Otani is no slouch and don't forget he's also an all-star pitcher working his way back from Tommy John surgery on his right elbow
1:54
And one more thing in Otani's favor he has a World Series ring
1:57
which he won in October beating the Yankees and Aaron Judge. The reigning MVPs in their respective leagues will once again be all-stars
2:06
Otani for the fifth time, Judge for the seventh? Are they on another World Series collision course
2:13
It's too early in the season to say that, but if they remain healthy, the debate will continue to rage on
2:19
Who would you start your team with? Which players more valuable? Is anyone else in the conversation
2:25
I still can't decide. We're going to check back in a few months' time to see where we're at
2:30
For Straight Arrow News, I'm Chris Francis
news
Sports
Team Sports
Baseball


