NPCs will interact with Invoke Duplicity similar to how they would interact with any other visual illusion, but the specific will vary wildly. #dnd #dnd5e #2024dnd #ttrpg #characteroptimization #dungeonsanddragons #cleric
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
This question asks how I would have NPCs
0:02
interact with the trickery domain
0:04
cleric's invoke duplicity feature.
0:07
Invoke duplicity creates a perfect
0:10
visual illusion of your character. So it
0:13
looks like you. It mimics your motions.
0:15
It mimics your gestures, your
0:17
expressions. It looks and acts exactly
0:20
like you perfectly. However, it is only
0:24
a visual illusion. There's no sound,
0:26
there's no smell, and it's intangible,
0:28
so it can't be touched. So, as soon as a
0:31
creature touches it or interacts with it
0:33
physically in any way, they're going to
0:34
realize that something is up. If you're
0:36
trying to use invoke duplicity in a
0:39
social situation, it's it's going to be
0:41
immediately weird because anytime you're
0:44
talking, it's coming from your own
0:46
space, not from the creature. Unless you
0:48
do some shenanigans with spells, maybe
0:50
more likely you're going to use it
0:52
either as a distraction in some specific
0:54
situation or you're going to use it in
0:56
combat, in which case creatures might
0:58
not have time to notice that your
1:00
illusion isn't making sound or speaking
1:03
or anything like that. You could treat
1:05
it like any other illusion and have
1:07
creatures make an intelligence
1:08
investigation check to look at the
1:10
illusion and determine that it is
1:12
elucery, but that's not explicitly
1:15
written into the rules. So, it's kind of
1:17
up to DM interpretation at that point.
1:19
Personally, I would have NPCs, monsters,
1:22
etc. interact with the illusion based on
1:24
their intelligence and maybe if they're
1:26
proficient in investigation or if they
1:28
knew how to cast illusion spells
1:29
themselves. A creature that's really
1:32
familiar with illusions, if they
1:33
interact with it physically, their first
1:35
thought is probably going to be like,
1:36
"Oh, yeah, this is an illusion. I know
1:38
that this is elucery, so I'm not going
1:40
to try to physically interact with it."
1:43
that won't save them from the explicit
1:45
effects of the ability, but at least
1:48
tactically they will handle it
1:49
differently. Then for creatures that
1:52
don't know how illusions work, they
1:53
might find the entire thing super
1:55
confusing. Like, is this some kind of
1:57
defensive effect like blur or blink or
2:00
mirror image, and they probably don't
2:02
know what any of those are either. So,
2:04
they just know something is up here.
2:07
This is not normal. and then default to
2:10
how a reasonable creature of their
2:13
intelligence would probably respond.
2:15
Anyway, that's how I would rule it.
2:17
We're already a little bit beyond what
2:19
the text of the rules say to do because
2:20
we're interpreting creatures thoughts
2:22
and actions and decision trees
2:25
essentially. So, uh, a lot of this is
2:28
just going to come down to what makes
2:29
sense to the DM at the time. So, uh,
2:32
yeah, whoever you're playing with, if
2:34
you are playing a trickery cleric, talk
2:36
to your DM about this beforehand. get a
2:38
general sense of how they want to handle
2:39
things so that neither of you are
2:41
surprised when it comes up during the
2:43
game. And I think everybody will be
2:44
happier there. If anybody has more rules
2:46
questions, let me know in the comments.
2:48
I'm always happy to help.
Games
Roleplaying Games

