DnD 5.5’s DC 15 to hide was a totally unnecessary nerf to Rogues. Sure, they have other ways to deliver Sneak Attack, but hiding was the most consistent option that didn’t rely on your allies. Nerfing that option makes the Rogue much harder to play at low levels.
#dnd #2024dnd #rogue
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
The D&D 5.5 rules introduced a base DC
0:03
of 15 for a few different mechanics,
0:05
most notably stealth checks. A DC of 15
0:08
really isn't all that hard, but it does
0:10
create a really terrible experience for
0:13
low-level player characters. A level one
0:15
character will typically have a plus
0:17
five on anything that they're good at.
0:19
So, that's plus three from your ability
0:20
modifier and then plus two from your
0:22
proficiency bonus. And short of
0:24
expertise, there's really not a lot that
0:26
can get you above that plus five. So,
0:28
the minimum DC of 15 to hide means that
0:32
it's really difficult for any low-level
0:34
character to successfully hide. Until
0:37
your proficiency bonus and your
0:39
dexterity have scaled a little bit,
0:40
you're going to hit that DC 15 a little
0:43
more than half the time. So, on a 10,
0:45
which is 55% of the time. The D&D 5e
0:48
rules were written with a 65%
0:51
success rate as the target for something
0:54
that your character is good at. Armor
0:56
class scales based on that. DCs scale
0:58
based on that. It's always eight plus
1:01
proficiency plus ability modifier. And
1:03
that's that hasn't changed since the
1:06
2014 rules were published. And the vast
1:08
majority of things in the D&D 5.5 rules
1:11
still use that mathematical expectation.
1:14
So, it's really odd that they gave us
1:16
this DC of 15. It's especially bad for
1:18
rogues who are planning to rely on
1:20
cunning action to hide in combat. If you
1:23
can only succeed at hiding 55% of the
1:25
time and you need that to successfully
1:27
use sneak attack, then you're going to
1:30
really struggle. So, the expectation may
1:33
just be every rogue needs to take
1:35
expertise in stealth so that they can
1:37
hide successfully, but that's still only
1:40
a 65% chance to succeed at doing
1:43
something that should be functionally
1:44
automatic, especially against enemies
1:46
who have perceptions of like plus zero,
1:48
plus one, plus two. So, making rogues
1:53
run this incredible risk of failure as a
1:55
bonus action means that playing a
1:57
low-level rogue is deeply frustrating
2:00
and deeply unsatisfying. I still don't
2:02
understand why they added the arbitrary
2:04
DC of 15 on these things. Like it it's
2:07
not a good addition to the game. If
2:09
they'd set it at 10, sure. If they'd set
2:11
it at five,
2:13
why bother? So like maybe 10, but 15
2:17
just feels like they looked at rogues
2:19
and thought, "We don't want you to have
2:21
fun until you're like level five or six
2:23
or something."
Games

